Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Thank you for the support! You guys and grrls are awesome!

What Daphne said in the bottom middle panel is essentially correct, although simplified for space. And by "simplified," I mean the details are important. It's not "maybe one particle is moving and another isn't," it's that there's no difference. One of them is moving, or the other one is, or they both are. At lightspeed, it doesn't matter, because due to relativity, two particles moving toward each other at lightspeed are still only going C relative to each other, not 2 C. 

That's for massless particle. I'm actually not sure how that works with massful particles, but if a massless particle is going C, then from its perspective, the massful particles are going C and Mr. Massless is holding still. Except massful particles can't go C. So I guess it's one of those "One of two twins gets into a ship that accellerates toward C for 5 hours and when he gets back 50 years have passed" things. Time dilation, fine. But what I mean is that while the one twin is approaching C, and spends only 5 hours doing it, but to the twin on the ground watching, this "high speed flight" took 50 years. The distance traveled is the same, but from the ground twin's perspective, space twin didn't get anywhere near lightspeed. So I guess massful particles are just trundling along, but also going C from the perspective of the massless particle that's actually going C, except everything is going C? 

I don't know relativity well enough to understand most of the details, but whoever invented Superpowers definitely did. 

Here's a time Harem conserved momentum. 

Files

Comments

3of4

That was Sydneys Boot Up Sequence

C.G. William

Nothing quite like hypothetical or in this case practical physics while half asleep. Although Sydney is right. The testing of this was insanely reckless. A few ounces of matter at light speed hitting a planet is catastrophic. Let alone the whole mass of a human.

codesurfer

Space is sorta like time in that it is both more and less flexible than you think. The previous comic's example shows this due to her ignoring the rotation of the earth and the various other universal spins that would flipped and thus catastrophic. It is all relative in BS hand wavy ways because we all want to know why she is asking Sydney of all people in the middle of the night something and maybe we'll get back to figuring out all the ways her powers break physics afterwards.

Thisguy

I mean, considering how fast the earth is moving, I guess there was always something going on.

Orlet Soir

Well, let's start with a small silly fact, that the surface of the Earth moves at up to 1670 km/h (depending on how close to the equator are you), then the Earth is careening through space at 107000 km/h around the Sun, and the Sun itself is whizzing at 828000 km/h around the galaxy... So yeah I would say it is safe to say that Harem's teleportation preserves her momentum relative to the point she is teleporting to (as in, whatever momentum she had relative to the origin is preserved relative to the destination; i.e. her entire frame of reverence gets translated over). Which, honestly, would absolutely make sense, otherwise the teleporter would just splatter against the nearest wall if they even slightly misjudged the relative difference in speeds from their origin to the destination. Which would make teleporting outside of direct line-of-sight extremely dangerous, if not impossible. Now, what would be if she tried teleporting to a point relative to something else moving, like a stone, or a bullet? That would be a fun way to create some crazy momentum out of nowhere.

Nathan Wilson

Daphne looks very tired. What kind of woman emergency would have her going to Sydney instead of Dabbler?

Michael Obert

Don't know I've ever seen Harem with such a serious look on her face before; kind of worrying about whatever the Womergency is. Hope the rest of her is okay.

Czarzhan

About teleporting to be standing still beside a moving bullet, that would be theoretically possible if the bullet was in a vacuum, but in an atmosphere her sense she uses to keep from materializing in a solid would sense the air moving by that fast as practically a solid.

Greg Morrow

To be honest, Harem is -not- conserving momentum, because she can teleport around on the surface of Earth without getting flung off if she makes an east-west jump. That is, her velocity in New York includes a substantial component that is parallel to the equator and tangent to the surface of the Earth at New York's longitude, because the Earth is rotating and she's moving along with it. If she teleports to LA and preserves momentum, that same vector is no longer tangent to the surface of the Earth, and she flies off the surface of the Earth. She has to be constantly re-orienting to the local non-inertial reference frame on arrival. But for her falling trick to work, the conserved momentum must be in her frame of reference, which means that east-west jumps won't work like I said above, because her frame of reference rotates by exactly the same amount that her rotational velocity needs to rotate. But now north-south jumps are a problem, because the velocity due to rotation at the equator is bigger than the velocity at New York (sine of the latitude), so that if she jumps north, she's going to stagger east. And if she ports so that she's facing the other direction, now her local frame has her rotational velocity facing the other direction, too. So the conclusion is that she unconsciously adjusts to a frame defined by a local object at rest (again, inherently non-inertial), and retains only the velocity she's got relative to the local object at rest at her departure point. Depending on how her power defines "local object at rest", she might be able to port onto a plane (the interior is locally at rest). But if she can adjust velocity at all, she might be able to do it consciously, and not have to do her falling trick at all. Cf. Steven Gould's Jumper series, which gets into velocity adjustment in detail in books 2 or 3.

Town Crier

Frix is not spooning. He's Cast Iron Panning.

Killianti

Massless particles moving at C don't experience time, so the speed of everything else is kind of irrelevant. Speed and frames of reference work the same wheather something is massive or massless. The difference is that it's not possible for something massive to reach C because it gets more massive the faster it goes and requires more energy to accelerate.

Town Crier

It's all spacey-wacey, timey-wimey technology.

Ampws

You could have gone old school and said 'jaunt' - cripes I just dated myself.

Mark Magagna

I was just thinking that with experience she might be able to buy the powerup that allows her to pick the object she's "at rest" relative to. Right now it looks like she's limited to "one of my other bodies" for that particular manifestation.

Mark Magagna

Hm. Guessing this one has to do with Earth humans as opposed to space people. And Dabbler might laugh.

Mark Magagna

Assuming she can lift it of course. Second best would be plans. Much lighter, but plans often assume capabilities that Earth might not have. Having a copy or preferably more than one to tear apart and reverse engineer might be better overall.

Mark Magagna

She likely has to be able to sense the object she's picking. Another body is easy, since it's all just her. A small object moving fast? Especially if it's moving fast relative to other large nearby objects? Probably not. A large object moving fast that she's already been on, but she doesn't already have a body there? Maybe? Which might limit her interstellar teleportation after all, since pretty much every other star (and thus anything orbiting it) is moving relative to our Sun at km/s speeds.

Mark Magagna

Daphne already knows her momentum isn't conserved. Or rather, it's kind of optional.

DonnieRamesJio

I just woke up and read this... I'll read it again after some coffee

Anton Schleef

I'm guessing an unplanned pregnancy, but who's is still up for debate. I really can't see her trying to talk to someone in the middle of the night who's a couple thousand light-years away for anything less.

Anton Schleef

My best guess is an unplanned pregnancy. Sydney isn't the best at being serious, but as someone who's been with the strip for several years (maybe a full decade now) she's the only one who'd take it seriously (or as seriously as she's able to), not give her any grief over it, commiserate with her if the guy isn't worth anything without offering to 'educate' him, and overall be the best support for something like that at oh-dark-30.

Anton Schleef

Sydney, you're forgetting something very important. Harem doesn't make copies as a 'side effect' of her teleportation, her teleportation is a 'side effect' of her making copies without de-materializing the original as well. Thus, she's always doing both energy-to-matter conversions as well as matter-to-energy conversions without needing to draw massive amounts of extra energy from somewhere or having a place to 'deposit' said energy. And you don't want to think about how much energy e=mc^2 says is needed to create the mass for an adult human from pure energy, or how much energy the mass of an adult human would create when undergoing a 100% conversion to energy. Simply put, accelerating herself to light-speed or faster is the lesser oddity here. Well, that's assuming that the ship is physically traveling fully within our reality at FTL speeds. Remember, an FTL drive system that creates a warp bubble type of effect has the ship _inside_ the bubble at relative rest to wherever it departed from, while the bubble _itself_ is what's actually traveling at FTL speeds, thus she wouldn't need to accelerate herself to light-speed or faster because inside the bubble nothing is actually traveling that fast. It can be a confusing area of theoretical physics.

Raymond Dannelly

Frix is awake, aware, amused, and doing that on purpose.

JasonAW3

I suspect that what is actually happening is that the 'substrate' of the version of Harem is, well, not overwritten, in cases like this, but more rearranged. Essentially, the particles of her body swap momentum between the two different versions, when it is needed. Or, and here's the fun idea; the space the craft is actually in isn't 'moving' relative to the space where the stored Harem bodies are, thus a stored version of Harem wouldn't need to worry about conservation of momentum. (Quantum Physics is weird that way...) Then, there's always the possibility that Harem is actually a Quantum creature born into a human physique. Adjustments would be made by instinct.

Steve Brinich

"Harem doesn't make copies as a 'side effect' of her teleportation, her teleportation is a 'side effect' of her making copies without de-materializing the original as well." It's natural to see it the former way since 99% of the time she teleports she doesn't spawn another instance (since she's usually maxed out).

Anton Schleef

So, did you have a point beyond just quoting me?

Autoskip

Sydney is going to kick herself when/if she remembers that she can teleport out using her Comm Ball.

Cha0sniper

It sounds like Harem's brain handles a lot of the finer details for her, which leads her teleportation to work how she expects it to at any given time. Which also implies that if she can get control of the mechanism, she can choose whether or not to preserve momentum on any given teleport.

eddi_TBH

Carol is a smuggler among her other talents. Sneaking illegal tech past any monitors watch Earth is easy. Consider that she smuggled Max and co. out.

Sir Butcher

I dunno, Syd is about the worst person to ask for help for such a thing?

Sir Butcher

I can imagine Deus already betting for Maxima...

Martin Drkoš

FTL travel probably requires some physics shenanigans that mean that the ship isn't actually moving or whatever anyway.