Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Why not watch the video again?! Seeing as I'm WASTING YOUR TIME with a STUPID NOTIFICATION because I FORGOT TO CHARGE FOR THE DAMN VIDEO.

Just so we're not wasting everyone's time completely, gimme your suggestions for Trainwreckords

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gPoiv0sZ4s4

Comments

Kevin Lopez

Green day’s trilogy would be a GREAT episode for trainwreckords

Matrim

Maybe you should switch to monthly…might make it simpler

Hector Gonzalez

Push and Shove by No Doubt or AKA by Jennifer Lopez

Tank1319

Uno Dos Tres by Green Day. Do a triple Train Wreckords

setalp

Queen - Hot Space. I know they continued to be popular in Europe, but their albums in the US after this one did not do well. Their legacy was cemented, but people forget how big of a drop they had in popularity until Wayne's World brought them back in America.

Mali-Cat

Idk if this is a "Trainwreckord" per se, but "Portals" by Melanie Martinez. Edit: I also submit "Viva Las Vengeance" by Brendon Urie (of Panic at the Disco!) That was a real stinker of an album.

David Yurch

Adore by Smashing Pumpkins

Gwen Stearns

Fall Out Boy - Mania Eminem - Revival Canibus - C! True Hollywood Stories Metallica and Lou Reed - Lulu

A.J. Caimi

The Beginning by Black eyed peas

Ben Mackenzie

McCartney’s Press to Play - tried to go full tilt into the 80s working with Hugh Padgham, featured his first single in or out of the Beatles that completely failed to chart, was basically his last attempt at being a contemporary artist

Sid Iyer

The Naked Truth by Lil Kim from 2005

Oscar Bernard

I guess it's more of a career killing *film* than album but I feel like Sia never recovered from Music

Justin Thompson

I know this is basic, but Garth Brooks - in the life of Chris Gaines

Atticus George

Shout by Devo, lost their deal with warner records after they released it

Rob Wilson

I've always wanted to tell you this. there is so much potential in having the 2010 Michael Jackson "Michael" album be the first posthumous train record, mainly for so much drama surrounding three of the songs having had an impersonator song them, the case was taken all the way to the California supreme Court as an example of possible consumer fraud. Plus you wouldn't have to worry about blowback from the MJ community, because none of us actually like the album.

Kate Margaret

always hoping for that Encore by Eminem episode 🥰

MealGin

Schizophrenic by JC Chasez

Anne Ginzburg

So Much for Stardust was a good comeback though, and while they certainly have less mainstream success than Am/Ab, it's not like Uma Thurman was more respected than Last of the Real Ones in alt circles lol

sconce

I have no idea if you would be willing to do a movie soundtrack as a trainwreckord, but it might fit - Sia’s Music Soundtrack. It might not count cause during the years where there wasn’t much good music coming out there was a bunch of her older songs becoming hits because of TikTok and commercials, but since then she’s never been able to regain the momentum she had even as a songwriting collaborator and her reputation has never been fully restored. Plus that soundtrack has quite a bit to discuss on it on its own - it’s the perfect example of her sellout period after her indie darling days and mainstream breakthrough

Steph

Has Duran Duran had a trainwrecord? Seems like they had one every few years in the late 80s/early 90s? Maybe Liberty or Thank You? Obviously they’re still going and have had good records since. I’d maybe count Red Carpet Massacre as one as well. I love them, but they’ve wrecked themselves many many times.

Zach Gozłan

Big day by chance? Too soon?

SecretGull

The Beginning - Black Eyed Peas. To go from defining the sound of the late 2000s to DIRTY BIT was unprecedented.

aquabreeze

"Some Nights" by fun. It's an amazing album imo but the band broke up after it blew up. Some real good behind the scenes drama there. Nate Ruess's solo record "Grand Romantic" for similar reasons

Mr.Myoozik

Emerson Lake & Palmer's "Love Beach", Genesis' "...Calling All Stations...", The Black Eyed Peas' "Elevation", Camila Cabello's "C.OXO" Queen's "Hot Space" Christina Aguilera's "Bionic"

Liza Boudreau

Todd please I literally just got “New York London Paris Munich!” out of my head

Evan Morgan

The Big Day is an easy choice. I'd be also very interested in Pretty Odd by panic. It caused multiple band members to leave and was commercially extremely underwhelming. It caused the band to basically turn into the Brendan Urie show and reshape the band as it was known. They made the album to sound nothing like I Write Sins not Tradegies and it was a huge flop as a result

gaia

Devo - Shout, though getting video footage from that time period is tough

CJ

Nah, they recovered critically from that in a couple years. Commercial failure? I dunno

Anne Ginzburg

I feel like at least half of that was the real-life controversy. It definitely didn't help that she totally switched her style and sounded way worse (imo), but I don't think she could have made Bohemian Rhapsody work with the uphill battle of the pandemic and rape allegations.

CJ

If you're going to lean into being a country music historian in middle age, then you're going to have to address the elephant in the room - In the Life of Chris Gaines

Colton Rice

Thank You is a trainwreckord

Natalie Sturhann

You'll never do it but Lines Vines and Trying Times by the Jonas Brothers (obviously they had their comeback but that firmly destroyed their first era)

Juhani Aho

Christina Aguilera's Bionic/Lotus cannot be evaded forever, Todd...

CJ

That was nothing compared to MACHINA though, in terms of failure

Scott C

Did you ever mention Neil Young’s “Fork in the Road” (2009) anywhere? The entire thing is a concept album dedicated to his “LincVolt” electrified vehicle. Not really a “Trainwreckord” per say but definitely a curio

Steph

God I love that album but it definitely wrecked them

Isaac

My request is The All-American Rejects - Kids in the Street, an album I actually like a lot but is a very strange and objectively unsuccessful attempt to fit in with the early 2010s indie boom that flopped so badly they haven't released an album since (they finally have one coming out in January though)

Colton Rice

I don’t think they did ever actually recover They had one fluke hit with a cover song and 2 critical hits that were still commercial failures

Kompy

Dont really see how that's a trainwreckord tbh, they had plenty of hits and relevance afterwards

MwdaShadow

Pink Floyd- The Final Cut

Angela

Evanescence's second album, The Open Door, but maybe that's just me. I guess I can't say if the genre popularity just passed them by, or if it was the album that tanked them, but they certainly haven't been the megastars they were with their first album. And it also marked them losing their guitarist and as a result any remaining vestiges of whatever Christian Rock scene they may or may not have been a part of (that was a whole interband conflict in their early days) and it ended up kinda changing their sound over the years.

Colton Rice

So much for stardust was still a big commercial failure Mania still counts

Erika

Scarecrow was relatively successful after that point though, released two years later. 5x platinum, no 1 on the billboard charts, had some hits. Not as big as albums like No Fences, but neither were Fresh Horses or Sevens even before Chris Gaines. It's kind of tough to fully judge the effect of Chris Gaines because he semi-retired for a while after Scarecrow to raise his kids and stopped releasing new music and touring for several years.

Ian Wildman

The Village People - Renaissance. True, Can’t Stop the Music and the general backlash against disco would have doomed any band. But the desperation of their attempt to pivot to New Wave was the final nail in their coffin (even though some of the actual songs still slap). I think you’ve previously dismissed doing Neither Fish nor Foul by Terrence Trent D’Arby; but that would still be an interesting story to dive into, given just how sudden his crash was. Just not sure how to best handle the deadname issue.

CJ

You can't have a Trainwreckord be the band's most commercially successful by far

Graf von Tirol

* Yes - Union * Various Artists - Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band * Happy Mondays - Yes Please * The (Byrne-less) Heads - No Talking, Just Head * Black Sabbath - Forbidden

SpaceAceNate

I know these are technically 3 albums, but maybe ¡Uno! ¡Dos! ¡Tres! by Greenday?

TectonicImprov

Pinkerton. Pinkerton. Pinkerton. I think it should qualify since its reception led to later albums being written off by critics and fans alike. Weezer's career didn't totally die after, but it irrevocably changed.

CJ

Nine in the Afternoon is the only Panic song I can listen to though. Thanks Rock Band 2

MrTyeDye

Duran Duran - Thank You Christina Aguilera - Bionic Trapt - Shadow Work

David L.

Full Circle by The Doors. The Doors really, really, really thought people would care about them after Jim Morrison died, and, no.

Evan Morgan

And it's the only song I like off the album

Zack F

Guns n Roses "Chinese Democracy"

Jack Anderson

Going a different direction, but I think Year of the Snitch by Death Grips led to a series of events that killed the group. Not to mention that it was a serious downgrade in quality even from Bottomless Pit. They went from an act that influenced David fucking Bowie to a punchline.

Rebecca Richards

Just chiming in with Chinese Democracy, seems MADE for this show. I remember the hype around the insanely long production time and the wet fart when it came out. Also maybe Forever by the Spice Girls because the crashing and burning of the Brit Pop bubble was astounding

sconce

I said this in my comment, but there was a soundtrack that went along with it that gives a lot more to talk about in regards to the general falling out with Sia. But then again, he’s done CineMadonna before - the episode could be done in a similar way to that

CJ

That's a complicated one but one I'd still love to hear Todd talk about, if only to hear his opinions on Pink Floyd

Ultranatic Productions

“Head Over Heels” by Paula Abdul Her 3rd album, came off the heels (no pun intended) of one of the biggest smashes of the 90s “Spellbound”, an album which contained Rush Rush, one of the biggest songs in Billboard history by an artist with tons of momentum from the late 80s up to that point…and yet this album halted everything. And granted some personal issues may have gotten in the way too, but she has literally never made another album since this. Which wouldn’t be a problem if it had any hits and it doesn’t. My mom is the biggest Paula Abdul fan in the world, and even she didn’t recognize this album. That’s a problem. I listened to its singles, and while I’m not sure they’re the worst thing in the world, they’re all over the place. So this album kinda checks all the boxes for Trainwreckords. Not just career killing album, but the artist herself? I mean I like Paula Abdul, but even I acknowledge there’s a reason she didn’t stick around longer. I can’t help but compare her to Janet Jackson except less domineering. Which there’s a place for on the charts, but not for the long term really. So give her a very lukewarm, not well received album which shaky singles, some IRL baggage, and you may have a compelling story on your hands.

BigE13

Good Singin' Good Playin' by Grand Funk Railroad. The Band only two years before this was arguably the biggest in America then had a bomb of an Album released in Born to Die in Early 1976 everything is going terrible in the band and they are about to fall apart and then they bring in Frank Zappa to make there next album Good Singin' Good Playin'. They try to change there sound a bit but it doesn’t get them anything and the band collapses after the album is finished. It’s an interesting story and Out to Get You which is the song that Frank had the most involved with is just something.

Alex London

Nelly Furtado’s The Spirit Indestructible. There’s probably a lot of interesting stuff about the critical response to 2006’s Loose, and the impact it had on her career and her direction

Keith Badje

Everclear - Slow Motion Daydream. A commercial flop with a terrible lead single that lead to every non Art Alexakis member of the band leaving.

Ethan Melton

Tin Machine II. The band that David Bowie started and then got bored with.

CJ

I would actually prefer a "Headstrong" One Hit Wonderland. Make Todd listen to more terrible nu-metal 😆

Keith Badje

I love that album. At least the first half of it.

jacob Garaycochea

How so? Would love to hear more on this perspective.

Ryan Sullivan

"Chinese Democracy" by Guns n Roses I think it's one everyone has been expecting for years even the Todd in the Shadows Reddit page has been hoping that becomes an episode XD

Justin Thompson

I understand, but I feel like it fits similarly to St Anger - it didn’t kill his career, he was so huge that even non-country music people knew so much Garth in the 90s - 18/35 singles prior to Chris Gaines were #1 on the country chart - post Chris Gaines the only number 1 was More Than a Memory and the highest charting song off Scarecrow peaked at 5.

Colton Rice

Panic had to big of comeback though to really count

Steel Stepladder

Sick Boy by The Chainsmokers should be talked about as a bigger flop than it is. I think a lot of people viewed it as inevitable and that their bad press merely caught up with them but it really wasn’t!!! They thought they were breaking new ground in the way album rollouts were handled!! They were coming off of some of the biggest hits of all time! They could have easily had more success

Dmills

Duran Duran “Thank You”, I think I just want a Duran Duran video, but it absolutely qualifies.

Kyle LeClair

Well, to try & name a few potential relative deep cuts for Trainwreckords... Ministry - Filth Pig Squeeze - Sweets from a Stranger Jesus Jones - Perverse Fishbone - Give a Monkey a Brain and He'll Swear He's the Center of the Universe Electric Light Orchestra - Time (well, it's more their US career killer, but still) Meat Loaf - Bat Out of Hell III The Fat Boys - On and On Journey - Eclipse The Prodigy - Always Outnumbered, Never Outgunned Queen Latifah - Persona INXS - Full Moon, Dirty Hearts ...And a few more obvious ones: Janet Jackson - 20 Y.O. (well, I say it's more obvious compared to Damita Jo) David Bowie - Never Let Me Down Again Terence Trent D'Arby - Neither Fish Nor Flesh As for the charges, I'll gladly pay double for the next video, or just pay you again somehow if need be. Whatever I can do to help right now, I understand what you're going through. We'll all help you through these issues.

CJ

Oh I forgot about No Talking Just Head. That's a really fascinating weird flop

Evan Morgan

And that's fair. But post this album the band was not the same at all. Again multiple band members left permanently after this came out and was a massive flop. They came back strong, but imo it was a different band at that point

Clementine Danger

I don't think it's a Trainwreckord if it goes double platinum but I still think The Life of Chris Gaines counts.

Patrick Young

Dark Horse by George Harrison. ATMP was a classic, Material World was good, then he went on an abomination of a tour, recorded an entire album with laryngitis, put out a sad cover song featuring Eric Clapton who was boinking his then SO, and George never really got that momentum back that ATMP gave him after. He became the worst thing yet, a nostalgia act 🤮

Kompy

The Cars- Door to Door

Oscar Bernard

Oh absolutely. Honestly I think the combo of the soundtrack being every point you made combined with just how baffling and tasteless the film it was attached to was is why she's struggled to have that comeback.

CJ

Like St Anger, too, it also revealed that this incredible superstar was also capable of very poor taste and confusing judgment

Isaac

I know it's daunting but he's GOTTA cover that shit some day. I know the common fan consensus is that there's a good album's worth of songs in the trilogy but I'm not sure I'd even give them an EP's worth.

Atropine

Jennifer Lopez’ This Is Me…Now multimedia project has all the hallmarks of a Trainwreckord – it might’ve helped kill Bennifer for good, and the project itself feels like the real-life version of Welcome to Me (in point of fact, Jennifer is basically the real-life version of protagonist Alice Klieg). What gives me pause is that 1) you’ve talked about it on the podcast and 2) reviews for Kiss of the Spider Woman are good enough that JLo will probably fully recover within the next two months, limiting the ultimate damage from This Is Me…Now. Her previous album AKA might be a good back-up option; it flopped hard & basically formalized the end of “JLo as pop star.”

Kyle LeClair

Agreed. I mean, their first album debuted at #1, & then their follow-up just one year later MISSED THE BILLBOARD 200 ENTIRELY. How are we not still talking about how legendarily bad that is??

Angie Seibold

May be easier to get footage now that the Netflix doc is out. I second Shout!

Erika

New Kids on the Block - Face the Music

Sam A Lander

Chris Cornell - Scream. After the Big Country video you may not want to do another act who died by suicide, but when the guy from Soundgarden hires Timbaland, we should all pay attention.

CJ

Weird fact: in high school band, we actually played a song from Fishbone's Give A Monkey... called "Servitude," so even if it's not great, I'll always have a soft spot for that song

Sean Wrona

I think the only reason he hasn't done that album yet is because he's been so litigious at preventing his music from being posted anywhere online.

Jamie Sansom

Muse- 2nd law, while not a bad album persay, it did in many ways streamline the band into playing it safe on later albums. The album doesn’t feel coherent enough, feeling more like a complimation collection of songs that wouldn’t fit anywhere else. While drones may be worse, Muse never reached the same maystay that they once had. Survive may have been the theme for the olympics in 2012, but they managed that in spite of this album, not because of it. For me, it was the first time where there where songs which felt phoned in. Usually Muse will have one or two songs on an album that feels like filler, but 2nd law features nearly half the tracklist of filler. You let the bassist sing, of which I like one of the songs he sings, but there’s a reason he hasn’t had vocal duties since. And then you get to the two part title track finale, which feels like an attempt to recreate Exogenesis: Symphony, but whereas that fused rock with classical music, we now get rocked fused with dubstep. A genre which lost fasion within months of the album getting a release. The problem is, there was potentional for a great album, the opener Supremacy is a great unused James Bond theme, Panic Station is a fun dance rock song, Survival is cheesy but fun and animals may be the last truly great Muse song. But the album is fused with the band’s worst impulses, and set the stage for their turn into generic rock throughout the 2010’s.

Joel

Of ones that I've already seen mentioned, Duran Duran - Thank You would be interesting. That has to be one of the most truly baffling decisions in music history considering they'd just defied the odds by making it into the 90s. One that I've not seen, but maybe too niche to get a lot of views: The Stone Roses - Second Coming

Graf von Tirol

Harrison did bounce back with Cloud Nine.

The 4'000th Yamaha DX7 Trent Reznor Broke With His Mic Stand or Foot

As much as I adore Filth Pig... (I genuinely believe that it's their best record, but then again I'm a big sludge metal fan, so of course I like Filth Pig) yeah, that album can't be called anything else tbh. It effectively killed Ministry's commercial peak by itself.

Josh Hammonds

Seconding Filth Pig by Ministry!

CJ

Love Spreads is a jam. The rest though I don't remember

Marie Dacy

Graffiti U - Keith Urban Everything Now - Arcade Fire Chinese Democracy - Guns n Roses The Division Bell - Pink Floyd Bionic - Christina Aguilera I Am Not A Human Being II - Lil Wayne

CJ

Lol yeah that was the point at which I was like "Maybe these guys aren't the generational talents we thought they were." But honestly the assault allegations against Win Butler killed the band more than that album

J Singh

Tbh wouldn't mind if it switched to a monthly model considering how consistent you are. Uh let it be by the the beetles? (I don't know music)

FunFawn21

Mumford and Sons won AOTY in 2013 and followed it up with an album that got rid of the banjos and acoustic sounds that were their entire musical identity. And then I think one of them went full MAGA? Even though they're British?

CJ

Interesting to consider - I would normally say that's just a band that's out of gas fading out with the times, but Heartbeat City was a huge hit. That being said I do still really like the title track of Door to Door

The McNamarii

Considering they're having a moment now, I'd suggest the last MCR album (the one with the spider on it). I always wondered why, after the Black Parade was so successful, that the band just kinda disappeared after that.

Hugh T. Yardis

It didn't necessarily tank their career but it's certainly just a... Disaster of an album but MANIA by Fall Out Boy

CJ

St Anger also sold huge amounts because of hype and name recognition but it's still objectively a Trainwreckord. Chris Gaines is on the Mount Rushmore of career damaging albums

silly character

Third Eye Blind - Blue Michael Jackson - Invincible Linkin Park - One More Light (this one is probably a bummer) Bob Dylan - Saved (most people point to Dylan and Self Portrait as his worsts, but the Christian era derailed his career again after a huge comeback until the late 90s)

Stephen

KooKoo by Debbie Harry Released on the eve of MTV’s launch, the perfect time for her to try for a solo career. She could have been Madonna before Madonna. But instead it was a weird experimental mess that tanked. [I discovered it through your Songs That Stop on the Word "STOP" video BTW.]

Dorian Wainwright

The new Rise Against album hasn't been out a month but I could see it appearing on this show some day. They're calling it Rise Against's St Anger because of the production

Jason Darby

Aside from stuff you already covered a decade a good (The Black Eyed Peas' The Beginning), I'd say: Duran Durans Thank You, Guns n Rose's Chinese Democracy and Genesis' Calling All Stations come to mind.

Jack Anderson

It was the height of their fandom when Death Grips memes and demand was peak. The album explicitly made references to the memes (Death Grips Is Online), Made some strange decisions (Putting the tracks deliberately out of order), and just sounds very low quality, and not in a good lofi way. Then there was no activity for a while. Then they did a tour and the fans behaved the absolute worst, cancelling the tour. Nothing from them since

BlackCat1989

Emerson, Lake & Palmer - Love Beach The Stone Roses - Second Coming Lou Reed and Metallica - Lulu Black Sabbath - Forbidden KISS - Music from The Elder The Velvet Underground - Squeeze Guns 'n' Roses - Chinese Democracy

Kyle LeClair

Yeah, I doubt Todd will ever do One More Light. Something like Chris Cornell's "Scream" can be more justified in that Chris didn't take his own life until years after the album came out & he had reunited with Soundgarden, but Chester's tragic end is sadly intertwined with One More Light's failure.

Josh Hammonds

Probably too niche, but I'd suggest mdfmk by mdfmk (technically KMFDM). KMFDM had a couple of huge club hits in the 90s and managed to turn that into a major label record deal, but then couldn't use the name KMFDM for the album due to (I believe) legal reasons. The album tanked and, while they were able to start using the name again, they never came close to mainstream success and have slowly turned into the industrial rock version of KISS over the years.

EmperorTigerstar

INXS - Full Moon Dirty Hearts, the first INXS album that everyone panned.

CJ

Music from the Elder is another one of the all-time flops, I just want to see Todd talk about it even if it didn't kill off Kiss

Thomas Stubbs

Nelly Furtado’s The Spirit Indestructible is probably one of the strangest-sounding albums from a major pop act that I’ve heard.

CJ

Knocked Out Loaded I thought was considered by Dylanologists to be his nadir. That or simply "Wiggle Wiggle"

Hello

The Monkees - Head (1968). A soundtrack album and film that tries to win rock credibility but just alienates their pop audience. Their hits and relevancy are over, they don’t have a show anymore, and bubblegum pop would move on to the even less real The Archies which would get number 1 on Billboard’s Year End Hot 100 Singles chart.

Deegcakes

You hinted at "Lulu" in the St. Anger vid and it makes me curious

CJ

Danger Days has its fans and I heard songs from it on the radio but I'm interested to know the story behind it

Patrice Keville

You're probably not wrong, but the album was such a stinker, I'd love to see Todd tear it apart. The synthesizers sound like they're farting on you.

Sterling

Send Me On My Way - Rusted Root this song has haunted me since I first heard it's gibberish in Ice Age

Kyle LeClair

Hell, going by its history, it actively hindered sales of their previous album just by merely existing.

CJ

OMG that f'ing album. "The Wolf" was played nonstop on the radio around that time and while it's a bad song I grew to find it comforting for that reason. But yeah it was the most generic soulless faceless indie slop you can imagine

Wicked Dreamer

Schizophrenic by JC Chasez. Fascinatingly bad record.

Joseph Bergeron

I think you should really do "Bone Crusher ft. Killer Mike & T.I.- Neva Scared" for One Hit Wonderland. That song was huge in 2003, and the artist was goofy, and then Bone Crusher disappeared off of the face of the earth basically. It's a weird story.

JazzySpF

MUSIC FROM THE ELDER It killed the OG Kiss. It’s also funny. I know people get technical about it didn’t kill the band but it’s funny as hell. It needs an episode.

Atropine

As for other suggestions: • Lil Wayne’s Tha Carter 6 & Chance the Rapper’s The Big Day seem like no-brainers – the former was universally loathed out the gate, and Chance only recovered from the latter a few weeks ago • A Better Tomorrow by Wu-Tang Clan. Maybe not outright trash, but bad enough that it’s the last full-length Wu album helmed/produced by RZA • Nas’ Nastradamus is an edge case – obviously it didn’t kill his career, but it definitely put it on life support; at minimum it made his beef with Jay-Z a life-or-death situation. (The consensus in 2001 is that Nas had one (1) great debut, and everything that followed was mid to trash; rap audiences didn’t warm to It Was Written until after “Ether” dropped). The album itself is very much a rush job, and “Big Girl” is one of the five worst songs Nas has ever recorded. • Vultures 2 is also an odd case – Kanye hasn’t made anything good since 2018, and Vultures 2 did reach #2 on the charts, but it’s the point where all but the very worst dead-enders finally got off the Ye train. Donda 2 might qualify here; Kanye was already well beyond cooked when the Hitler album dropped (and said Hitler album never officially released).

Joseph Bergeron

The Division Bell is actually pretty good. The Trainwreckord is probably The Final Cut, because of its impact on the end of the band.

Colton Rice

I’d like to throw in another answer of No Talking Just Heads by talking heads

CJ

It is interesting that Death Grips were one of the most unique and boundary pushing musical acts to ever get a modicum of attention from the mainstream (The Money Store was on a major label, but the deal was severed after that infamous No Love Deep Web cover) but their fanbase was a bunch of Rick And Morty fans at best and actively dangerous at worst

Marie Dacy

This is also very true

Anne mangione

Courtney Love “America’s Sweetheart”!

CJ

Lucky you. For some reason I have that terrible AI song from that video stuck in my brain

Mali-Cat

Not to disregard the allegations, but I prefer separating the art from the artist. The album itself is an overly convoluted mess that insists upon itself. The songs lack hooks and, like you said, sound way worse than her previous work.

CJ

Honestly I do respect Garth for keeping his music off streaming. He's probably the most famous musician among Normie Americans of a certain age, and yet he does stuff like only selling his latest album at Bass Pro Shops (this is true)

Atropine

My recollection is that it did succeed in getting them critical respect, so that impacts its Trainwreckord status.

ginny

yes that would be great as I donMt know the album but I’ve long wondered why the other lead singer in n*sync didn’t have as big a career as JT did. He had the voice and the looks

Charles Arthur

Doing something with Nelly Furtado isn't a bad idea right now, since she's back in the public eye for the heinous sin of... *checks notes* gaining weight and not being ashamed of it. Also, making Todd have to edit a bunch of Thicc Nelly videos seems like a nice treat :D

StrongBrush

Calling All Stations by Genesis Raditude by Weezer Chinese Democracy by Guns n Roses

Joel

Yeah, honestly the finished product is mostly just fine, but not as good as their breakthrough. The Trainwreckord is really more the band and how long it took them to release a follow up.

Cassie Cook

Squeeze by The Velvet Underground has always been my number one pick for the show.

CJ

LMAO I forgot Stone Roses did attempt a comeback a few years ago

Joseph Bergeron

"Ja Rule- Blood in my Eye" is a HUGE Trainwreckord. He went from 4 multi-platinum records in a row, to being an absolute joke, in about a year. Then his record label folded under crime accusations. It's a really weird story.

Jack Anderson

They also leaked the album after the label wanted to delay it, contradicting their ARG. That probably didn't help lol

Pietro Gagliardi

Wait what? Invincible? Really? Are you sure about that? I know his career was floundering at the time (and I happen to personally like the album) but a straight up Trainwreckord?

Pietro Gagliardi

Not that Patreon isn't going to be forcing that on in a few months anyway...

Andrew Davey

What the hell, I'll try a bit of a hot take: "Artpop," by Lady Gaga. FYI, I'm a longtime Little Monster, and I've always loved this album. However, Gaga got so much backlash during this album cycle, and all that turbulence seemed to push her to try some new directions later that decade. Even though this 2013 album obviously didn't kill Lady Gaga's career, I'd still love to see your take on how that experience changed her role in the music world.

Tom Sica

Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band (the 1978 soundtrack album). Trainwreckord for a bunch of different artists and there are clips for all of the songs available.

Atropine

Canibus’ career was already kneecapped by his debut Can-I-Bus – C! True Hollywood Stories is terrible, but probably didn’t do much damage by itself (and his follow-up Mic Club: The Curriculum is seen as a return to form). Revival is weird. Eminem’s CAREER is probably bulletproof at this point, but Revival kicks off a corncobbing cycle from Eminem that he’s never really able to recover from – his performances themselves tend to be a mix of Yngwie Malmsteen-esque “sacrificing enjoyability for technical proficiency” and…just the worst Dad jokes you’ve ever heard. Honestly, Revival might be a straight Trainwreckord for Rick Rubin’s work as a producer; it’s where disdain for his work in rap starts matching the steadily-mountain disdain for him in rock.

Pietro Gagliardi

Actually that raises a question: Other Voices or Full Circle? Jim always insisted that the band was equally talented, and Other Voices was their attempt to prove it (plus it's got at least one moment of aged-poorly racial-coded cringe on it, and I know how much people here like seeing that on Trainwreckords/OHW =P ). Full Circle was their attempt at proving it while at the same time admitting that they needed Jim's writing. And An American Prayer was them throwing in the towel and just releasing Jim recordings with a bunch of new playing on top.

Jonathan Keeney

Knocked Out Loaded at least has “Brownsville Girl.” Down in the Groove is probably worse but it’s also too boring to make a good episode from.

Adam Nelson

I feel like Uno/Dos/Tre by Green Day has to be on there. Well they have stayed popular since, there time as major players died with that trilogy of albums.

CJ

Funny how Ja Rule was once big enough to beef with 50 Cent but most people under my age know him as the guy behind Fyre Festival

horserenoir

Chance the Rapper - The Big Day Arcade Fire - Everything Now Happy Mondays - Yes Please!

Christopher Martinez

Eminem's Encore...for us dudes of a certain age, a letdown from which we never really recovered

David L.

That's the thing, his cover of I've Got My Mind Set On You was one of his biggest hits

CJ

He should do an April Fools for that Wu-Tang album that they only made one copy of and sold it to that pharma executive everyone hates

David L.

It would also be a good chance to talk about the plane crash Paula claims to have survived that's there's no record of

Pietro Gagliardi

I still would personally hesitate to buy a MJ album that isn't clearly a copy from before 2009 because while I like having bonus tracks in general I also can no longer be sure what's real or not. Very much something they didn't need to do. Also raises all the "new" material into question, not just those three songs.

DarkenedMortal

Fleetwood Mac - Time, when quite a few of their A-list members had left, and their replacements didn't really measure up, plus they made the mistake of longtime drummer Mick Fleetwood do a spoken word interlude for the first time, and ONLY time.

Arie Seardon

I have a book on Mac's music. The chapter on Time is less than 20 pages. The one on Rumours is about 50ish.

Dook

I'll suggest one I never see brought up in Trainwreckords discussions: Party Rock Mansion by Redfoo. LMFAO were already treated as a novelty act in 2011/12, but by 2016, when moody alt-pop was just about to take over, watching a 40 year old man trying to stay relevant by both trying and failing to adapt with the times (Rapping about whipping and nae-naeing and hitting the quan over DJ Mustard-esque beats or songs with tropical house elements) or by pretending that it's still 2011 and the Party Rock sound is still the dominant sound of pop is just kind of sad. Even for the standards of LMFAO music in 2016, it was a humongous bomb - it only sold 133 copies in Australia, and that was Redfoo's best market. It also features Stevie Wonder, has a connection to an Alvin & The Chipmunks movie, and was proceeded by "Literally I Can't", one of the worst songs of the entire decade. It's just an altogether bizarre record.

Pietro Gagliardi

I wonder how wrong I'd be for suggesting either Divide or No. 6 Collaborations Project by Ed Sheeran. I still haven't heard No. 6 yet (but I do have it), but my progression through his discography was Multiply -> Add -> 5 EPs -> Divide, and you can probably guess that that progression is one of clearly diminishing returns. I wonder if Turn Blue by The Black Keys or any album after that would count, not so much in the "massive commercial failure" department but more in the "complete loss of relevance" department. Looking through the albums I have, P!nk's Beautiful Trauma and Foster the People's Supermodel stand out, and I feel like some 2010s album by either Gorillaz or U2 would qualify but I wouldn't know which would do it (and this whole comment is before I even get to albums from before 2010).

Swaggurai

Ok so hear me out: Steve Vai's "Sex and Religion" He kicked off the 80s by performing alongside rock's favorite crazy person Frank Zappa, but Vai would see breakout success as part of David Lee Roth's solo band with performances on Eat em' and Smile and Skyscraper. This momentum would be maintained through the rest of the decade; with Vai being a consistent presence on MTV, appearing alongside the then white-hot Ralph Macchio in the movie "Crossroads" , joining Whitesnake for their successful "Slip of the Tongue" record, and later releasing his own acclaimed album "Passion and Warfare". After all of that the man would attempt to start his own proper band with fellow Zappa bandmate Terry Bozzio on drums, RnB session demon T.M. Stevens on bass, and a then unknown singer songwriter named Devin Townsend on vocals. The album would drop in 1993 to at best mixed critical reception, markedly less commercial success than his work in the past decade and the band he put together would ultimately explode following the recording of the album, with Vai being forced to tour with session musicians (although he did have the young Townsend in tow for this, he was to put it lightly a bit of a handful to tour with).

TenPoundHammer

SHeDAISY's second album, "Knock on the Sky". Loud over the top album full of sound effects and bizarre production. The lead single "Get Over Yourself" got pulled after only three months because radio programmers thought it was a "man hating" song, and the label sent spatulas to record stations to encourage stations to "flip" the single, but the damage was already done and the follow-up didn't do anything either. SHeDAISY spent almost all of 2003 and 2004 off the charts. I know people who love SHeDAISY but hate "Knock on the Sky" for how loud and weird it is. Personally, I love the album and don't think "Get Over Yourself" is man-hating at all. They even took two pot-shots at it in one of their later singles "Don't Worry 'bout a Thing", which includes the lyrics "Ever knock on the sky and have it fall on your head?" and "ever found your last record in the bargain bin?" Albums three and four were a lot more toned down, and SHeDAISY just quietly broke up when their label closed.

CJ

Doesn't fit the vibe of the show, but thank you for letting me know of this thing's existence - it's hilarious

CJ

You get a free Like for reminding me of SHeDAISY. One of the most "turn of the millennium in America" acts of all time. My parents had their first album

Clementine Danger

Sure as shit never heard anything from Chris Gaines again.

Thunderclaw

U2 - Songs of Innocence. You could argue that No Line on the Horizon was their 'true' career-killer, but I'd argue that the one thing U2 was always known for, was coming back from potentially career-killing albums (e.g. Rattle & Hum into Achtung Baby and Pop into ATYCLB). Songs of Innocence, however, was their first album that didn't hit platinum, was mostly forgettable, and the whole Apple stuff at launch did massive damage to Bono's already contentious public image.

Tom Carter

I’m surprised no one’s mentioned Forever by the Spice Girls yet. They were one of the biggest musical acts in the world for a little while. Then Geri Halliwell left the group, and things kinda fell apart. They tried continuing as an R&B-focused quartet with their third album, and… there’s a reason they haven’t released an album since, nor did any of their solo careers go far. I even have a good pre-title line: “Girl Power doesn’t last Forever, this is TrainWreckords!”

CJ

You know just how obsessed they were with making sure everyone heard that mid-ass album? They got one of the album cuts on the soundtrack of Rock Band 4, presumably as a contractual obligation for getting "I Will Follow" on the game as well. No other artist had ever before had two songs on the default playlist of a regular Rock Band game!

Jordan Schmidt

- Supertramp, Famous Last Words. The fact that they could tell this was gonna kill the band while they were making it should tell you everything you need to know. -The Moody Blues, Sur la Mer, and for that matter Yes, Big Generator. Both killed any idea of a long term career for a classic prog-rock band as pop hitmakers. Not everyone can be Genesis [I'm not gonna suggest Calling All Stations cause I don't actually think it's that bad] -Smashing Pumpkins, Adore. Simply because it might just be time.

Thunderclaw

Disagree. Bowie had built up such a cult following by that point that even though the album sucked and sold terribly, his career couldn't be 'killed' by anything.

Shawn Christopher

Smashing Pumpkins’ “Adore” is a rich text for how unchecked egomania can totally derail a career. Billy Corgan first tried to turn in the basic acoustic demos as a full album, then fired their producer to produce the whole album himself, then argued with the directors of the $800k music video for the lead single and alienated radio programmers by telling them they were making a techno record when that was a four letter word while simultaneously burning through half a dozen different drummers. And now the album is considered a cult classic.

Garrett Catalana

Panic! At the Disco - Pretty.Odd./Cricket & Clover

Thunderclaw

I'd honestly say Drones or Simulation Theory is where Muse started to fall off. 2nd Law undersold, but it at least had songs that charted on par with other Muse songs in the past. It wasn't until Drones that they started to disappear from the charts as well.

Beau Dure

Yes, Union. Hyped as a coming-together of the two warring Yes factions but actually a hyper-processed mess in which many songs were finished off by a battalion of studio musicians and there was very little interplay between the two groups. They never had a top-20 album again.

Anthony Hansen

Hear me out: Hotel by Moby. I remember at the time it seemed to instantly kill his spot in the mainstream stone dead, and he's written extensively about that period in either one of his two memoirs so there'd be a lot to draw from

Josh Liller

If Fleetwood Mac was going to be on Trainwreckords sure it's for Tusk??? Pretentious, experimental, and disastrous double album followup to the mega hit that was Rumours. Tusk doesn't even have a good album cover. And apparently Lindsey Buckingham was kind of losing his mind at the time.

Nicole Bryant

Huey Lewis and the News Small World. I was disappointed.

Josh Liller

Are Turbo by Judas Priest and Chinese Democracy by Guns 'n' Roses too much low hanging fruit?

Josh Liller

Lou Reed and Metallica is such a nonsensical pairing it gets my vote.

setalp

That disaster of a movie deserves a feature length documentary about how unbelievably bad it is.

Hiatt Werling

"No Talking, Just Head" by The Heads.

Dan O'Neill

Raditude stands out, Weezer were at the top of the pop game with an album ranting about how they arent going to trend chase with Timbaland and then instantly after decided to work with him on a disaster. And while not a traditional trainwreckord, "Tim" by The Replacements was an album that was poised to break them into superstardom, but amost every single aspect of its release was self sabotaged by the band itself.

Fsyco

"The Beginning" by The Black-Eyed Peas, since that album killed their careers for nearly a decade

Dmills

I think that The Stone Roses have a dedicated enough fanbase to have a video on Second Coming do well.

Fawkins

Amen by Paula Cole felt like it was fucking designed to be on this show. There’s a whole song where she’s writing misery porn in the ghetto with a very stereotypical sounding Black girl name, the title track has lyrics like “amen to Saddam Hussein and Marilyn Manson and Ronald Reagan”, MASSIVE drop off from the album right before it with the Dawsons Creek song commercially and critically, never had a big album after, listening to it was certainly an experience

Kristopher Bluth

If the Chris Gaines album isn’t a possibility, I’d suggest …But The Little Girls Understand by the Knack.

Jess

I would suggest Pray For the Wicked or VLV personally

Andrew Huntley

Neither Fish Nor Flesh by Terence Trent Darby qualifies in the same way that the Spindoctors Turn It Upside Down did for a Trainwreckords feature. Maybe even more so, since it sold considerably less.

Kristopher Bluth

Tusk still sold four million copies and they recovered quite nicely commercially with Mirage and Tango in the Night. Time was such a disaster that they were forced to regroup a mere two years later as a nostalgia act.

K

Everything to Everyone - Barenaked Ladies I like some of the tracks on here, and I enjoy some of the albums that came after, but this album marks the end of their cultural relevance.

CJ

I know The Knack had one or two other charting singles but I don't think anyone remembers them for anything but My Sharona, so I hope Todd dares to make a OHW video of that song specifically

Kristopher Bluth

It’s honestly not bad, but it has no business being credited to the VU. Think of it as a Doug Yule solo album and it’s fine.

Hunter Hadlock

Pretty. Odd. would be an fascinating one for me considering (and this is where our opinions differ) it’s not even a bad album music-wise, its Beatlesque songs that blend a bit of 70s folk/country are well-formed, they achieve their retro throwback in such a way that it doesn’t feel like a pale imitation and instead just younger fellas becoming very suddenly interested in the past, and there’s a lot of detail not in melody but in lyrics/instruments that show this wasn’t a complete troll move. If this was, like, Jellyfish’s third album, I.e. a band that already solidified their retro aesthetics and sound from the get-go (which honestly would be a very good comparison considering both Panic! and Jellyfish’s core creative leads split due to their diverging influences and direction), I don’t think anyone would’ve batted an eye, but BECAUSE it came from a band that was on a cutting-edge for the emo scene and their next move was to completely work backwards away from that forward-thinking fanbase, it couldn’t help but be alienating on premise alone and not on quality. Pretty. Odd. would be an excellent if peculiar Trainwreckord because in collapsing the band in half, they slowly gained more commercial success at the cost of losing every fiber of their core personality that made them appealing in the first place by replacing it with genuine nothingness (Todd’s briefly mentioned the aftermath of this story in his “ME!” review and has always been a fan, even enjoying Death of a Bachelor, but I’d be curious to hear his whole take on this because, as much as I adore A Fever You Can’t Sweat Out, even I’ll admit its identity crisis of having an album be half dance-punk, half cabaret-rock makes for a strange starting point to even conceive trying to follow up. Realistically, what else could they have done?) EDIT: Upon further research you absolutely can make the case this was a trainwreckord for Ryan Ross, AKA Panic!’s creative lead, one album through The Young Veins and a teased solo album that hasn’t materialized in six years, PatD gained commercial success through what was basically a human sacrifice and to me there’s a more compelling problem to analyze in these roots compared to Pray for the Wicked and Viva Las Vengeance being boring and bored (respectively) death knells.

JasSpy

I know this is probably a long shot, but, I've always wanted you to do a Trainwreckords on "Bridge Over Troubled Water" by Simon and Garfunkel. I'm well aware that in terms of music quality it's a great album, but its troubled production (pun intended) is what resulted in S&G splitting up acrimoniously and hating each other to this day. I feel like not enough people have done video essays on S&G, and the story of what happened between them is undertold and underexplored. I've loved their music the majority of my life and still don't really know the specifics. Wikipedia only gives a very vague account.

Harry Harman

It’s time for the Big Day Trainwreckord, Todd

Harry Harman

The better Arcade Fire album for Trainwreckords is Pink Elephant

Nyx Diaz

Viva las vengeance by panic at the disco, an album that is so forgettable that lead to the end of Brendon Urie

Scott Gesser

I've gotta go with Healthy In Paranoid Times by Our Lady Peace. Their previous album, Gravity, took away everything remotely interesting about them but won them chart success. "Healthy" subsequently gave them neither chart success nor a unique sound, they almost broke up recording it, and they've never had a hit again.

Kristopher Bluth

"Good Girls Don't" hit #11, which makes them borderline as far as OHW status goes. "My Sharona" was the biggest single of 1979 and they were set to enter the Eighties as kings until the follow-up killed their momentum dead. It's their Zingalamaduni.

Scott Gesser

I feel like Slow Motion Daydream was grasping at straws. I know Songs From An American Movie Vol. 1 did -okay- with "Wonderful", but it was such a massive drop-off after their previous success that Slow Motion Daydream felt like it didn't deserve to exist.

Kristopher Bluth

Todd could get a terrific episode out of Sananda Maitreya's whole story.

Keith Badje

I Believe In Love is one of my favorite songs of 1999 (and would have been a huge hit if it was released literally any year other than 1999), and the title track is pretty good despite its pretensions...but MAN, does it collapse from there. I could see a really entertaining TW from this one.

Thunderclaw

If St. Anger isn't low enough hanging fruit than Chinese Democracy isn't either.

Astatine210

You posted about it on Bluesky, but I'd definitely like to see a Muse trainwreckord. Still don't know if it's 2nd Law, Drones, or Simulation Theory though.

horserenoir

Pink Elephant was the final nail in the coffin, but Everything Now is the moment the band's momentum and goodwill abruptly disappeared overnight in a way they never recovered from

Kristopher Bluth

On a topic related to a former Trainwreckord, it’s funny that almost all of Oasis’s current set list is 1994-1996. That might make sense in the US, but they had big hits in the UK well into the 2000s. I get nostalgia, but was Be Here Now such a disaster that all their subsequent hits were actually flops?

Herbieguy

The Heads - No Talking Just Head Think about it: Byrne's new album, their press tour last year, re-releases for two of their albums, and just the fact that spicy band drama makes for some of the most entertaining episodes of the series. Not to mention a quirky new wave-funk band going to fucking NIN-style Industrial just makes for a ten-car pileup of a musical direction. And let's face it: having TH covered on your channel in any capacity would be awesome. My man Jerry Harrison needs more appreciation.

Scott Brown

Jane’s Addiction The Great Escape Artist

Ryan Moore

Korn - The Path of Totality screams Trainwreckord. It's the dubstep album.

Ryan Moore

Maroon 5 - Love is Like. Did you know they put out an album this year and the biggest hit off of it peaked at #76?!

Angela

Heard about the album, not the charting. It's interesting though.

Angela

....would you accept OHW ideas? I have a bunch, and I'm probably never gonna afford to buy an episode, so Imma just leave my wishlist here and hopefully you like one of 'em 😋 All the Things She Said - T.a.T.u One of Us - Joan Osbourne Steal My Sunshine - Len Major Tom - Peter Schilling In The Shadows - The Rasmus (they're basically OHWonders the same way Aha were) Boys of Summer - The Ataris Stacy's Mom - Fountains of Wayne a Sex and Candy - Marcy Playground Mmmmm - Crash Test Dummies

Fawkins

Yeah that song bangs, it gave me hope it’d be some hidden gem and then an hour later

MikeVG

Aside from the usual (Bionic, Muse Sick N Hour Message, Calling All Stations, Corporate America, 3D) I have a few that might qualify. One of them would be Exit the Dragon by Urge Overkill, which took them from critically acclaimed band of the year to forgotten hasbeens overnight. I'm also not sure if it counts but what's the general reception on Beautiful Garbage? Seems like it was admittedly a sellout record but I kinda like what I've heard. Sisqo's Return of Dragon (geez, a lot of dragons today) is another case of going from the top straight to the bottom (it being released so close to 9/11 didn't help either). Not sure what Korn's Trainwreckord would be, probably either Take a Look in the Mirror or the Skrillex collab. OutKast's Idlewild soundtrack might also qualify as it's basically a worse version of Speakerboxxx/The Love Below. Out of the Vein by Third Eye Blind, that qualifies too, man there are a lot of these.

Ian Wildman

I think the TV cancellation hurt them, and the 33 1/3 Revolutions per Monkee TV special stopped any momentum they had. After that, it was just a matter of time until Columbia Pictures/Screen Gems pulled the plug on the project (given they owned the band's IP, as they produced the show)

Keith Badje

Counterpoint: Does anyone really want or need to really hear "The Hindu Times" or "The Importance of Being Idle" live in TYOOL 2025?

sconce

It could’ve been the greatest album of all time and it would still have ended his career with a title like “Schizophrenic” from a boyband member

Trappes

Do they still play "Fcuking in the bushes" ? Because that is a banger. Well there is no Liam, so i figures. (Just kidding I have no real opinion on Oasis beyond FITB being a stone cold slammer of a tune)

Trappes

I would argue C D didn't kill the Gunners as a viable band, but the lack of CD for so long did. They could have survived a weak album in their prime, but building up expections for *this*

TheLoser

Pinkerton would only have counted if your idea of Weezer is permanantly stuck in the 90s. It being now critically acclaimed and Weezer getting their biggest pop hits in the 2000s makes it an odd choice overall, especially when compared to Raditude's entire existance. But even Radititude is debatable considering people say they had a full comeback with either EWBAITE or White. Weezer's output is simply too eclectic and varied in quality in the first place to belong on Trainwreckords IMO.

Matt

Probably the one I'd want to see the most would be The Long Run by The Eagles just for the sheer dramatics of it all Though I could see History by Michael Jackson, The Final Cut from Pink Floyd, or The Visitors from ABBA

Nigel G

... I really love Healthy in Paranoid Times. I hated "Gravity" the single so much that I never listened to the album. HiPT sounded like a return to form.

Julian

JC Chasez's Schizophrenic. Trust me. It's fucking insane.

Steph

Strip by Adam Ant - Friend or Foe was so unimpeachably good. He never hit that high again. I enjoy Strip, but I'm pretty sure it's not actually good.

Steph

Paving the way for Smooth Noodle Maps

Connor Rankin

This is a stretch, but I still think it’s an appropriate album to talk about. None other than Pinkerton by Weezer. The quintessential album that was regarded as a complete flop than suddenly became perceived as a work of art. The inverse Be Here Now.

Connor Rankin

I will never stop requesting Marcy Playground and Crash Test Dummies. They are LONG overdue

Angela

I'll throw them onto my list ^^

DarkenedMortal

I agree, both those albums I would love to see in future Trainwreckords episodes for sure, especially Chinese Democracy. My only real experience with that album, when it was new, was when the single Shackler's Revenge appeared on Rock Band 2's setlist that year. I thought the single was actually alright, and from what I've heard now, the general consensus is that it was about the ONLY decent song on the whole album. Also, I am quite curious to hear about what happened to the Spice Girls after they started to go solo, especially after the Spiceworld movie, lol.

Kristopher Bluth

Chinese Democracy might have been a total game changer if it had come in 1998. Too bad it was ten years late.

Alexis C

"If You Wanna Have Some Fun" is a bop, tho

JP

Calling All Stations by Genesis

Michael Russell

“Songs of Faith and Devotion” by Depeche Mode.

Shiny Skunk

Holding out one day for Bulletproof by La Roux!

Duke86fan

this is basically a free patreon that gives you a monthly video :P

Connor Rankin

I thought that was a good album. That failed?

Michael Russell

Album was a success but it split the fan base and led to one of the core members leaving. Band never fully recovered.

Sam Jones

Robbie Williams - Rudebox Might be a bit non-US centric, and it didn’t *kill* his career but it was a ludicrous head scratcher that ended his tenure as the biggest pop star in Britain

Jordan Felo

Pussy cats by Harry Nilsson. John Lennon produced and helped Harry make the album, who was a huge star at the time having won awards and #1 hits. It's terrible and his career never recovered. I know when it comes to your videos you actually need source material to draw content from. There's both a documentary and a novel (really good read btw) about him and his career.

thegreeninkribbon

I would personally love to see Lulu by Metallica get covered and have our first "Sequel" episode of Trainwreckords.

Mimi Kenny

I’d argue they were already on shaky ground with Reflektor. Everything Now was just such a “yup this band’s best days are behind them” album

Dennis Byron Gonzalez

…Yes, especially “Stop Crying Your Heart Out” and “Lyla”.

horserenoir

Reflektor was very hyped and positively received on release. Everything Now was so bad that it made people go back and reevaluate Reflektor

Carolyn Esposito

I have a few Bionic by Christiana Aguilera solely because it has the lyric, "If I was a ruler, I'd set you straight." Dance by Gary Numan. In America he's known as a one hit wonder obvs, but I'd argue that a Trainwreckords episode would be more interesting since a) He was a big deal in the UK b) This is the album where he drops the iconic androgynous android aesthetic and trys for a jazzy lady's man type vibe. It's quite bad Songs of Faith & Devotion by Depeche Mode. They're attempt at ditching synth/industrial and going for more of a grunge/ early 90s rock sound with mixed results This last one might be a bit of a stretch/too niche but I'd say October Rust by Type O Negative The band's attempt at winning over the lady's while also still appealing to their doom metal fans. It's full of a lot of horny ass ballads. Only charted gold while their previous album charted platinum. The next three albums they went back to doom metal but never went platinum/gold again. Some of the band members have also said that they didn't really like OR. I'd find this one more interesting since I'm seeing Type O have a sort of revival with alt Gen Z online and they like this one. Plus it would be a good Halloween episode :)

Khalid Cailean

Viva Las Vengance - Panic at the Disco

SynGirl

If I had a nickel for every uk synth pop pioneer with an album named Crash something something...

Carolyn Esposito

Lolol this made me realize that I was mixing up The Human League’s Crash with Gary Numan’s Dance 😅

Sterling

I realize now that I completely misread the post my bad

Thunderclaw

I think Todd said somewhere that he considers MMLP2 to be a genuine comeback, so he probably won’t cover Encore that quickly. Now Revival on the other hand…

CJ

Ooh yeah I've been curious about what happened with Idlewild before too.

CJ

The Knack are so frustrating (no pun/homage intended) to me because the mix of power pop tunes, early new wave aesthetic, and hard rock chops is basically my ideal rock band, but so many of their lyrics, including their biggest hit, are creepy or sexist

margo

Pat Finnerty did such a great job though, I understand the reluctance to try and follow that!

margo

There's a great episode of the We Regret to Inform You podcast on S&G which may tide you over, I learned a ton on them from it.

Pan Flute Skeleton

Neil Young - Trans. The weird electronic album he made. Wanted to request it/pay for it in dedication to my dad

TimeBombMan

Flick of the Switch by AC/DC. AC/DC tried to go "raw" and made this mess. One song is literally called "Bedlam in Belgium". You might have fun with this one.

Kristopher Bluth

100%. I saw a documentary about them and even other members of the band thought "Baby Talks Dirty" was gross. I've always thought of them as the Beatles if they sang "She was just seventeen/You know what I mean" over and over as they kept nudging you in the ribs harder and harder. By the time Doug Fieger figured out he needed to sing about something else, it was too late.

Chamois Chui

Don't think I've seen it yet, so: Electric Light Orchestra's "Time". Yes it was a UK No. 1 (and is my all-time favourite album from ELO) but it was such a shift away from their normal symphonic rock that it jarred with everyone's expectations (this was the band that had just hit their peak with "Don't Bring Me Down" and "Xanadu"!) and Jeff Lynne just seemed so very *lost* after this album that there was a huge dropoff in sales for the next two albums, which both felt like contractual obligations before a quiet breakup (even if there are tracks from them that are up there with "Shine a Little Love").

Yeet Dab

Everything Now by Arcade Fire, the Witness of indie rock

Johnny 99

Give it a couple years, that’ll be Pink Elephants

Shiny Skunk

That's a OHW suggestion not a Trainwreckord... lmao ignore me!!!

Dennis Byron Gonzalez

Celtic Frost - “Cold Lake” Notorious 180 degree glam turn from a band that broke a lot of ground for thrash, death, and gothic metal in the 80s. Rebounded creatively with their follow-up “Vanity/Nemesis” but didn’t fully recover commercially or critically at the time and broke up for two decades before recording another album. Danzig - “Danzig 5: Blackacidevil” Change in direction to industrial metal from the renowned gothic/doom metal of the first four albums, recorded and released after the classic lineup of Glenn Danzig, Eerie Von, John Christ, and Chuck Biscuits dissolved. Garnered backlash for the style change, plus controversy for Hollywood Records owners Disney for signing Danzig. Personally I think there’s some good tracks on the album, like “Ashes”, “See All You Were”, “Come to Silver”, “Power of Darkness”, and their cover of Black Sabbath’s “Hand of Doom”. Jerry Cantrell appears on three tracks as well (all of which happen to be three of the five I like most, incidentally).

AG

Courtney Love’s America’s Sweetheart. Or Hole in any capacity. The third Hole album, Nobody’s Daughter, might also be a Trainwreckord. I love Hole, so I’m curious to hear your thoughts

AG

I second Risk. I believe they made that album as a compromise to keep the band together, and while it had some good songs, it was a big change in their sound

AG

I was underwhelmed by ATYCLB, and thought it was a watered-down version of the best work when it first released

AG

Second this one. I’d like to hear Todd talk about Hole and Courtney’s work

Anne mangione

Right?! It checks off a lot of Trainwreckords boxes. It was super overhyped and then when it came out it had a super dramatic drop in quality from Celebrity Skin which had been critically acclaimed. Not to mention the insane behind the scenes drama.

Mary Cahoon

U2's Songs of Innocence? Always wanted to know wtf was going on with it being automatically downloaded onto my iTunes...

Connor Rankin

I deadass once thought my Dad put it there 💀

AlexKorobeiniki

Honestly muse had that one album that leaned really heavy into dubstep sounds and a lot of rock folks dropped

Prideful Xela

Someone else already pitched it, but definitely Schizophrenic by JC Chasez. Let’s also not forget the “classic” from the Drumline soundtrack that preceded it in 2002, “Blowin’ Me Up (With Her Love)”, which is also a complete disaster There’s a reason JC never took off like Justin

Prideful Xela

Also special mention to The Hunter by Blondie. They had massive hits right before this album dropped in 1982. Island of Lost Souls, the lead single, has some of the worst horns in music. It was the only charting hit from it (barely at that) and the album bombed and the band called it quits afterwards

Shawn Lyall

DEFFO Mania by Fall Out Boy. American Beauty/American Psycho was such a huge hit for radio I don't even think you can escape Centuries or Irresistible to this day. Then Mania came out and it flopped so hard you've not heard anything from FOB since unless you're in the fandom including their new album (So Much (for) Stardust) which has since flown well under the radar. That or maybe Jordi by Maroon 5

maruhkati

I'm of an age that Mark Prindle's review of Risk was formative to my young music nerddom

maruhkati

I'm In You by Peter Frampton. He sold more albums in 1976 than Fleetwood Mac, Wings, Stevie, or anybody else with Frampton Comes Alive. (Live albums being a good way to jumpstart the career of not-quite-famous artists was an interesting trend at the time).

Anand Basawapatna

"Music From The Elder" by KISS the quintessential Trainwreckord

Dmills

That and Pool It (1987), failed album to capitalize on their revival.

FunFawn21

This would actually be a good way to tie in the "Home is the worst song ever" discourse happening right now. "Home" -> Stomp-clap -> the kings of Stomp Clap, Mumford and his sons.

Rosen Thorne

Kind of shocked nobody’s said Chinese Democracy yet.

Rosen Thorne

Fucking in the Bushes is actually entrance music for AEW’s Nigel McGuinness, who came out of retirement in Wembley Stadium last year, which Liam and Noel later cited as one of the reasons why they reunited!

Caleb

The Center Won't Hold by Sleater-Kinney

gooberdude

So, here's a question. Is it possible for a debut album to be considered a trainwreckord? If there was an artist who was only marginally known, who rode the coattails of an infinitely more iconic pop star to make a name for himself, and whose first attempt at pop stardom was such a disaster that it not only became quite possibly the most critically panned album of my lifetime, but also ended his relationship with the aforementioned A-lister... What I'm saying is, Kevin Federline's Playing With Fire deserves an episode.

Sam Jones

Nah, that’s the 143 of indie rock

Duke86fan

also heres a fun recommendation... arcade fire's everything now or M83's junk

David L.

It's kinda hard to say anything killed Nilsson's career when he willingly walked away from music for other reasons (vocal strain, Lennon's murder)

Jannikk

Eminem's Revival turned him from a questionable presence in rap (talking about quality) into a complete joke. I'd argue it's not only a Trainwreckord as far as sales or reception go, but he really let the negative reactions to the album get to him. It reached a point where everything he did since seems to be pandering to public demand. Revival seriously hurt his commercial success, his relevance within the rap community and his following artistic output all at once.

Dennis Byron Gonzalez

Speaking as an S-K fan, I liked it better than I thought I would. The title track sounded amazing when I saw them in concert last year. But, it cost us Janet leaving the band. She got Newsteded!

Kevin Merrick O'Connor

Some not mentioned yet: Bryan Adams - 18 Till I Die Chicago -- Twenty 1 Phil Collins - Dance Into the Light (possible comparison with Calling All Stations?) Doobie Brothers - One Step Closer Queen - Hot Space ZZ Top - Recycler

AlexKorobeiniki

OH! Almost forgot, this one’s big; Speedin’ Bullet 2 Heaven by Kid Cudi

Jeffrey Leiker

Songs of Innocence- U2 (aka the album that was uploaded onto iPods without anyone's permission) and I say that as a huge U2 fan but the whole ordeal was a messy PR nightmare for an album that I'd argue was weak compared to the rest of their previous releases (including No Line on the Horizon) and was when they finally "lost touch" and not in an ironic commentary way the Zoo-tv/Pop-Mart tours. To me this was my moment the train wrecked and didn't recover.

ridd.pr

Sweet 7 by Sugababes could be a fascinating one with its revolving door of a lineup that led to it

Cole Cox

I was thinking this album as well. I do remember enjoying some of it though. This all happened when I was like 13

Jeffrey Leiker

1) Ow, my hip 😆 2) It's a decent album, Every Breaking Wave is still a goto for me, it just didn't hit me the same way the first time I heard Joshua Tree or Unforgettable Fire or Actung Baby

RedBedroomRecords

Genesis-Calling All Stations: a sad sending to the discography of a great band. This was a case where things might've been different had the bands original choice for a replacement lead singer not tragically passed away. Ray Wilson is a fine vocalist but wasn't the right fit for the group and the album as a whole was mostly just too depressing for it's own good. New Kids on the Block-Face the Music: America's first real boy-band tries to go for a more "mature" New Jack Swing sound and in the process alienates a good chunk of their fanbase. One of their members left before the tour even started and they found themselves playing to half-empty clubs, a far cry from the stadiums they were used to. Scorpions-Eye II Eye:the most succesful foreign band in the world hits a speed bump when they try to do something they've never done before-trend chasing, in this case a weird mixture of pop, adult contemporary, alternative rock and god knows what else(their first German language song features bizarre rapping from James Kotak). They notably never had another charting-hit after this album with Matthias Jabs later expressing regret for it. Also features Todd's nemesis Peter Wolf. Chicago-Twenty-One: The long-running midwestern rock group unceremoniously sacks original member Danny Seraphine and tries to make a go without him and it goes about as well as you'd expect. Def Leppard-X: X most definitely does not mark the spot here as the band follows up their incredible comeback album "Euphoria" with this bizarre alt-rock misfire which features several outside songwriters(including Max Martin) for then-popular artists like "Lonestar"(blech!), "Rascal Flatts", "Westlife", "Britney Spears", "NSYNC", "Backstreet Boys", "Faith Hill", etc. Just a headscratching album all around that the band never really recovered from.

RedBedroomRecords

Revival was a big hit on the charts though and some did like it so I wouldn't say it qualifies.

RedBedroomRecords

Hollywood Records also got controversy for signing Insane Clown Posse and wanted them to remove a few songs like "Under the Moon" and ultimately it got cancelled and they joined a smaller label.

RedBedroomRecords

I dunno about that considering they had hits afterwards like "Thunderstruck".

RedBedroomRecords

I'd argue if anything it was probably Raditude that killed their career, Crash Thompson did an epic video tearing that thing apart.

RedBedroomRecords

to be fair a LOT of bands from that time sang about the same thing, even Paul McCartney wasn't immune to the occasional song about underage girls.

RedBedroomRecords

that was more of a weird side-project as it certainly didn't end Garth Brooks career.

RedBedroomRecords

Turbo didn't really do much to slow down Priest's momentum as Painkiller did pretty well afterwards. If anything slowed them down it was probably their second album with Ripper "Demolition".

RedBedroomRecords

Revival was a hit though and Eminem still has charting hits from his latest album so I don't see him ever being on the show.

RedBedroomRecords

Father of All Motherfuckers is probably a better choice as that really seemed like the band was completely out of ideas on that one, Revolution Radio at least seemed to right the ship after the trilogy, but "Father" showed a burnt-out band that was just utterly miserable.

RedBedroomRecords

True though that album was later recovered from him and given to some crypto group.

Adam Nelson

I think just based on the time and the ambition is far more interesting then a band that just finally burned out on ideas, in the way many bands eventually due. Though yeah, that album is actively awful.

RedBedroomRecords

Brooks seemed to recover fine, Chris Gaines was more of a bizarre side-project then anything else really.

RedBedroomRecords

Father of All Motherfuckers i'd argue qualifies more since the band sounded tired and completely out of ideas on that one, the very definition of an album that only exists because of contractual obligation.

RedBedroomRecords

Open Door was a massive hit, definitely does not qualify for the list.

RedBedroomRecords

Eh that was more of a weird side project so I dunno if it qualifies, it certainly didn't do much to halt Brooks momentum.

RedBedroomRecords

Todd did say he considered MMLP2 to be a genuinely good comeback so does not qualify, plus Encore sold a fuckton regardless of it's quality.

RedBedroomRecords

also because it's arguably more of a weird side-project then a true career killer.

RedBedroomRecords

Pacific Daydream might be more an example, it was a boring wet fart of a record.

RedBedroomRecords

I'd argue Corporate America would be a better fit.

Eric Wolford

The 2nd Law??? YES, PLEASE. To say no would be ma-ma-ma-ma-ma-ma-ma-ma-madness!

Eric Wolford

"Supernatural" by DC Talk. Not only is it relatively timely (we have excuse to crap on Michael Tait some more), but apparently the band mates were so petty that it led to a messy break-up (at least if Kevin Max's song "I Don't Belong" is to be believed), two solo projects that made egos out of TobyMac and Tait, and just an overall waste after how big "Jesus Freak" was at the time. Yeah, they are technically OHW with the "Jesus Freak" song "Just Between You and Me" (which might also have alluded to the inter-band drama at the time), but given how evil of a person Michael Tait would turn out to be, it's funny to see how their massive stardom exploded by the time the new millennia arrived.

Eric Wolford

Are you kidding me? Two albums later they would release "In Rainbows," arguably one of the most lauded albums by the band. "The King of Limbs" would be a good option, though!

Lewis Edwards

Am I late? Out-of-State Plates by Fountains of Wayne. That's mainly because I want to hear Todd talk about Fountains of Wayne and I've resigned myself to never getting the Stacy's Mom OHW, but it is still interesting. They had years of critical acclaim and sudden serious mainstream momentum after Welcome Interstate Managers - only to squander it (or deliberately arrest it?) with a poorly timed (perfectly timed?) album of old B-sides. And I love that album, it's a really good collection of some classic songs (The Girl I Can't Forget is one of my favourites of all their songs), but just looking at it as a career move, it was a classic Trainwreckord.

AlexKorobeiniki

Yep, that’d be it. Such a shame; i actually liked Drones and freaking loved Thought Contagion, but when I tried to show my friends they just weren’t interested

BlackCat1989

I don't know - Songs of Faith & Devotion is considered one of DM's best albums and is easily their most successful stateside I don't really think DM have had a Trainwreckord, to be honest

Kristopher Bluth

Very late, I know, but Wasp by Shawn Cassidy. Joe Hardy tries to go New Wave...produced by Todd Rundgren.

Joel

I would argue that Pop is still the U2 trainwreckord, even though they bounced back huge for a couple of albums. Mainly would still count it because unlike when they bounced back after Rattle and Hum it was with a major reinventing of image and sound... after Pop it was a creative retreat that resulted in just Y2K attempt at Joshua Tree. Also, Pop love it or hate is interesting to talk about, that Songs of Innocence is just a legacy act releasing late career music in a dumb way.

Eric Wolford

I would argue "No Line on the Horizon" would be a better pick. Yeah, Pop flopped, but "All That You Can't Leave Behind" and "How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb" gave them a considerable rebound. I mean, "Beautiful Day" played incessantly right after 9/11, and "Vertigo" is one of the many songs synonymous with those iPod commercials in the 2000s. However, despite a big promotional push, "No Line" flopped hard, and "Songs on Innocence" served to confirm that U2's relevance had ended.

Eric Wolford

Korn + Skrillex? What could possibly go wrong!

Eric Wolford

PO would be the Trainwreckord for the band. Anything after was the zombie husk led by Urie.

Eric Wolford

Well, it doesn't help that the forces that were motivated to make Evanescence a Christian Band had ties to Michael Tait. Speaking of another band where that creep would have to be brought up to some degree...

Eric Wolford

You can if it was the album that led to their demise. Even if they wanted to come back, Jack Antonoff is more known these days as a superstar producer thanks to his work with Taylor Swift

Justin Maceira

BIONIC - xtina… let’s start a new series Gaga killed my career

Sarah Schumm

I agree. It’s the album that changed the way people think about U2, up until then they were still respected enough that even non fans thought of them fondly. But the Apple release was the point where they became past tense for most people.

DarkenedMortal

Risk and Calling All Stations, I'm definitely interested in, plus Music from the Elder might be a good episode too.

Ryan Moore

I'd like to also add: 30 Seconds to Mars-America: Jared Leto fires anyone in the band without the last name Leto and has thoughts on the world (featuring A$AP Rocky) Maroon 5-Love is Like...-The definitive end of Maroon 5. U2-Songs of Innocence. The iPod album. Sia-Music: Watch Maddie Zeigler start a movie off in possible blackface! Incubus-If Not Now, When?: The album that did the impossible: made Incubus boring Slayer-Diabolus in Musica: The infamous nu metal album from Slayer! Megadeth-Risk: What if The Black Album sucked? Trapt-Shadow Music: Because fuck Trapt

Miss Chriss

The last Panic at the Disco album?

Joel

That's a fair contender as well. Especially since usually U2 bounced back with a big new era after would be flops, and that didn't really happen in this case. If Todd did a U2 video, he could maybe mess with the format and sort of touch on the various would-be career killers (Rattle & Hum, Pop, No Line on the Horizon, Songs of Innocence) and why some rebounded to decide if there was a U2 Trainwreckord at all, though I suspect the conclusion would just be after 30 years (about the No Line on the Horizon era) it's very hard for a band to be popular, relevant and interesting at the same time.

janinho

Secret Samadhi by Live.

Christina Lowry

This Unruly Mess I've Made by Macklemore & Ryan Lewis. You had a tweet a while back wondering if this was a Trainwreckord that I think of every time I hear any of Macklemore's post-2016 stuff. It's all dad rap. He really lost his swag/mojo/it factor after apologizing to Kendrick.

Arbor Rainier

obvious pick but i'd still love to see a the big day episode just because of how massive of a hit chance's star took from it, to an extent that he's never really covered

Brigham Cole

Does Queen's "Hot Space" meet the criteria for a Trainwreckord?

Mikey T.W.O.L.

"Music" by Sia. She regards it as an album in the same vein as "1000 Forms of Fear" and "OnlySee" rather than a soundtrack album. Her latest album - released this year - struggled.

Ralf Greymuzzle

Just do the "Brick" video already... We WANT you to gush about Ben Folds; he's doing the Peanuts musical FFS. That's gold, Schroeder.

Ralf Greymuzzle

Or maybe you could do "Glitter" in time for Christmas

Salvy

Wilder Mind - Mumford and Sons … sorry for everyone that liked that album but they should have known better than to trade banjos for electric guitars and amps. They sacrificed what made them unique and haven’t been as popular since.

Salvy

other suggestions include MANIA by Fall Out Boy and if you want to attack the christian genre some more. Time Stands Still by Family Force 5

Spudzel

Velvet Underground's Squeeze, or Fergie's Double Dutchess

Jeremy

Music From the Elders by KISS Turbo Lover by Judas Priest Risk by Megadeth Chinese Democracy by Guns N Roses Tango in the Night by Fleetwood Mac Never Say Die by Black Sabbath Virtual X by Iron Maiden

Amotrician

Mick Jagger's solo albums ?

Eric Wolford

I don't know. Then Todd would have to tackle ANOTHER Chris Brown's issues (the lead singer is Chris T Brown). Except, rather than dealing with assault, it's dealing with White Supremacy and MAGA. Ugh...

Eric Wolford

Boy, I bet Todd has been hankering to make a Trainwreckords episode on Maroon 5 finally.

FunnyMusicMan

I know this post is two months old, but how about a OHW on Bring Me Eldiweiss by Eddieweiss

Annie V

*chanting* Lulu! Lulu! Lulu!

Annie V

jokes aside I second some entries made by other people, i.e. Bionic (Xtina), Music (Sia) and Macklemore's

MightyQuinn

SQUEEZE is actually a good album, as long as you call it a Doug Yule album and not VU.

MightyQuinn

PINKERTON is great. Any Weezer after Matt Sharp left the band is open, though.

MightyQuinn

Head has some GREAT songs! Too good for a trainwreck

MightyQuinn

Produced by Phil Phucking Collins!

MightyQuinn

His singing is Dark Hoarse

Connor Rankin

But here’s the thing, could it be the beginning of the end?