Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

As always, please check my errors.

And as always, please vote in the Song vs. Song poll. We're doing "Dancing on My Own" by Robyn vs. "Run Away with Me" by Carly Rae Jepsen. You may have heard of them. https://www.patreon.com/posts/new-poll-dancing-143540782

Files

ONE HIT WONDERLAND: "Piano in the Dark" by Brenda Russell

You know that she's caught up in the middle, she cries just a little, when she thinks of letting go, but what else do you know about the long varied career of Brenda Russell? Check out "The Dinner Plan" trailer here: https://youtu.be/_aCQ5iJIuxg?si=1jgWa5j3hQtJnxWL Support Todd on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/toddintheshadows

Comments

JasSpy

Haven't watched the video yet, but I don't need to do that to ask this: Is this your final video Todd? We all know what this song is and what it means in relation to Todd. And he's covering it now? I very much so hope this doesn't mean you're retiring Todd, and making ths as a farewell video.

J Singh

Weird pause at 13:51-52 Otherwise another Todd Classic

Matt

Few things make me smile like Todd throwing shade at the Oak Ridge Boys lol

surasshu

yes yes yes yes yes

Andrew Davey

Whoa, we're going there (again)! I remember hearing this song on "smooth jazz" radio stations as a kid... But then, I just didn't hear it "out in the wild" any more. You definitely got my attention here, so I'm on my way to watch it NOW.

Andrew Davey

OK, I just watched... And I love it! I don't want to spoil the ending for anyone who hasn't watched yet. But if you've ever been curious about the late 1980s R&B-soft rock-adult contemporary crossover scene, go watch this ASAP!

Bailey Vogt

13:51-13:56 has dead air

Paul Anderson

Though I wasn't listening to the radio in 1988 (because gloop) I saw Brenda sing this on Robert Townsend's HBO show and it thoroughly stuck in my head. If I heard a bit I could sing the chorus. 37 years later you've closed the loop and it turns out she really was singing "when he plays piano in the dark." Her HBO performance is on YouTube and a lot of people remember it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RjpV5T_uWHM

JasSpy

Okay so, Todd doesn't even acknowledge in the video that this song is what directly inspired his gimmick. A lot of newer viewers might not know that. I don't know why he wouldn't bring it up. Closest he gets is saying "she wrote my theme song" at the end.

Rei The Gei

Great, informative, and funny episode, just the way a One-Hit Wonderland should be. Quick editing note, there seems to be a gap in the video and audio clips at about 13:50 after the chopsticks gag, which was otherwise a highlight of the vid.

Colton Moore

Also, considering the whole "yacht rock" discussion, I was waiting for basically the entire video for a Bruce Hornsby mention because I thought he was on that live version too - turns out I was thinking of "I Can't Make You Love Me". Semi-related: holy shit, "Piano in the Dark" vs. "I Can't Make You Love Me" would be an *amazing* Song vs. Song episode

Juhani Aho

"I Want Your Fuck Hotel California II" XD Also, 11:135-11:40 is too quiet, Todd, I can't hear you

Paul Anderson

Gloop is the word for Chicago and their ex Peter Cetera competing from 1985 onward to produce the most bloodless, mawkish, codependent schmaltz. By the end of the 80's popular music was dire. The gals who once unleashed Barracuda and Magic Man now crooned Nothing At All over the PA at Macy's.

Johanna M

I only know this song because Todd talked about it in an old old video, and that was because he was talking about the Flio Rida song. When I saw it pop up in my notifications I was like "oh of course!" It seems so right to finally cover this one :D. Really excellent singing from Todd in this episode too.

Jennifer Layton

This may wind up being my favorite episode of all time. Not only did you pick a great song, but I also find out she eventually won a Grammy, and I get to hear Laughter in the Rain and yacht rock. You've made this GenXer very happy. By the way, there's a glitch just before the 14-minute mark where everything goes blank. Otherwise, perfect. I'm going to be humming this song all day.

Austin F

hearing there were tumblr people that were into todd is the least surprising thing ever. as someone who was active on there in the 2010s, the girlies there LOVED a man with a mask or obstructed/unseen face. honestly, i can't believe i didn't realize it until now. same reason they love Ghost from COD or the guys from Welcome to Night Vale

Pietro Gagliardi

"You've got mass appeal" Heart full of equity, you're an asset... Here for that "Laughter in the Rain" rep. Truly great song. My headcanon is that Paul McCartney wrote "Silly Love Songs" specifically about Laughter in the Rain.

Tom Carter

Funny story: for a time, I was big into a certain NetFlix anime with an anthropomorphic male wolf as the lead character. This used to be my unofficial theme song for him. Don’t ask me why, it just happened.

Kristopher Bluth

And the sad thing is that "Nothin' at All" was actually one of Heart's better sellout songs.

Kristopher Bluth

My sister had the cassette single of this, so I never really gave this song more thought than that. Thanks for showing me the error of my ways. Also, yes, kids, gloop was very much a thing. Look over my music collection in 1989 and with the exception of the occasional Def Leppard or INXS, you'd think I was a 40-year-old secretary instead of a 15-year-old kid.

Kristopher Bluth

Even Sedaka's '70s stuff is far sturdier than it has any right being. There's a reason reality show kids still sing "Solitaire".

Alina

I think I've been waiting for this ever since you mentioned it in a video 15 years ago

Teddy Haines

Hm. I vaguely remember him describing how he came to his gimmick on the TGWTG forums many years back, and I don't think he mentioned this song back then either. He cited Phantom of the Opera instead, as I recall. Certainly Piano in the Dark would draw some inspiration from that as well, if only subconsciously given how iconic it is.

Ethan Melton

Between 13:51 and 13:56 there are black frames and silence.

ClaMaRo

“As an enthusiast of both pianos and darkness…” Sir!!

Joe G

How have I never heard about her connection to my hometown before? Hamilton, Ontario is very proud about Daniel Lanois opening his first studio here. Even the fact the lead singer of The Cult went to high school here for like 3 years is local music scene lore. But I've never heard about Brenda Russell's roots here.

Connor Rankin

This song was completely blocked out of my memory until I saw this video today

Herbieguy

As someone who owns her first album on vinyl: I'm kinda surprised she only has two hits. Would've figured she'd be bigger. (Also if you're doing more R&B for the series I am strongly looking forward to the inevitable Tom Tom Club OHW).

Herbieguy

Oh by the way since you briefly mentioned Hines: He did have a very, very brief music career. I used to own his S/T on vinyl, too. I got rid of it because it sucked. So you're not missing much.

Quinn

SADE REFERENCED!!! We are one step away from talking bout MF Doom

William Kaye

theres a gap in the video at 13:52

Brian Dermody

“Get Here” was, where I was from anyway, a massive Desert Storm jam. My top 40 station had a version with sound bites from the news and all that too. You could practically hear the program director, “Right? Kuwait stuff? That one line about the Arab man? Riiiiight?”

Angela

Speaking of One Hit Wonders who won their Grammy via musical theatre, are we gonna get a Duncan Sheik episode?

Karl

As Gen x nothing like in-depth analysis of this and learned so much. The funniest was hearing this in a strip club and I’m like “oh no that’s not what this was about” in 1995

Karl

I don’t understand the reference but love the comment

Sarah Schumm

lol feel called out for requesting a OHW with a depressing ending.

Claire

It was such a good episode, It felt all the way through you had fun doing it !

Russet Burbank

Why did those EDM songs have to give Brenda the Chipmunk treatment

margo

Brenda Russell has shown up in two music documentaries I've watched this year - the one Todd mentioned, Yacht Rock, and the Allee Willis doc which I am sure he will inevitably clip from down the line.

Connor Rankin

I honestly don’t think Tom Tom Club counts considering two of their members were members of Talking Heads I mean yeah I see where you’re coming from, but again, they still had Talking Heads to fall back on

Herbieguy

I'm mostly just coping at the microscopic chance Todd could cover Talking Heads in some way one day.

Connor Rankin

He literally talked about Burning Down the House on song vs song 💀 and they had a Stop Making Sense bonus episode. You’re well covered

Herbieguy

I was more referring to making a video. I dont listen to any podcasts, Todd or otherwise. Though since you mentioned it i may make an exception to listen to the Stop Making Sense one.

Connor Rankin

I getcha. I was begging them to do something They Might Be Giants related for so long, I know Todd and Lina were sick of me 💀

Herbieguy

I think after the best / worst of lists for this year there's a chance we'll get a juicy one. I remember when Todd asked for Trainwreckord suggestions a while back people had TONS of juicy ideas so maybe if I'm lucky he'll do one of mine.

Anthony Skatz

I always like episodes like this where musicians who are clearly very talented but maybe don’t have the “star“ mass appeal, or perhaps don’t have that “A+ charisma“, or aren’t a very “big“ personality, still figure out ways to do some great things in music, even if it’s not them at the forefront. something where the people who really know, really know.

Sarah Schumm

I feel like Gloop led directly to Grunge. I was 15 in 1990 and remember pop radio being basically unlistenable between 1986 and 1991.

Sarah Schumm

I agree Tom Tom Club doesn’t qualify as a OHW, they were too big in clubs.

Steve Harper

Rewatching this, and something occurred to me: could the 'mass appeal' line be in reference to the song being called Gravity? Since gravity is literally an attraction between two objects with mass? I might be reaching with that one. And frankly it still wouldn't be a good lyric. But I'm a science nerd at heart.

Steve Harper

Also, I had no idea that there was a The Colour Purple musical.