RAMBLE ON: "Fortunate Son" by Creedence Clearwater Revival (Patreon)
Downloads
Content
My dad, a dyed-in-the-wool conservative, loves “Fortunate Son.” This isn’t a “Born in the U.S.A.” thing where he doesn’t understand what the song is about; he knows damn well what it’s about. I think pretty much everyone knows what it’s about, despite various idiot music supervisors putting it in inappropriate rally-around-the-flag ads and movies. The meaning of “Fortunate Son” is too blatant to be ignored, including by my father. Partly he loves it because, you know, it’s fucking “Fortunate Son,” who the hell doesn’t like “Fortunate Son.” Also it’s partly generational – I don’t think there’s a hippie classic he doesn’t love unreservedly, even though he hated hippies. My dad loves Five Man Electrical Band’s “Signs,” maybe the smuggest, judgiest hippie song ever written. If he can like that, he’s definitely going to be fine with “Fortunate Son.”
But it’s more than my dad overlooking politics because he recognizes a good song. I think he agrees with the song. I think most people do. Between the two Fogerty episodes I’ve done, I’ve read and learned about CCR and their enduring appeal. They were connected to the ‘60s counterculture, they came up alongside the Grateful Dead and Jefferson Airplane. They played Woodstock. Woodstock! And yet, they were only ever adjacent to the counterculture. They liked country music. They were defiantly unpretentious. Truckers and rednecks could listen to them just as easily as Hank Williams. They were spared the anti-hippie backlash because they were spiritually a backwards-looking band, loving roots music and jug bands and the bayou (in his memoir, Fogerty displays some disdain for his fellow Bay Area bands, with their over-the-top drug habits and boring, self-indulgent jam session concerts). Creedence in fact were kind of considered lightweights in their scene, with their unthreatening retro aesthetics and focus on hit singles over full album statements.
Those criticisms weren’t true, of course, and they beat the allegations easily; within ten years of their breakup, they had already ascended into the upper pantheon of ‘60s bands. I do wonder how they would be seen now though, if they’d be considered something along Skynyrd or even The Eagles, a signpost along the way to Boomers’ slide to conservatism, if not for “Fortunate Son.”
Fogerty had been drafted. He got extremely lucky that a sympathetic authority figure in the army sent him to the Reserves rather than the front lines. He’s grateful for that, obviously, but two years shining boots far from home is still not anything to be happy about.
And boy, Fogerty is not a happy man. This probably was already clear in the two episodes I’ve done, but John Fogerty is the angriest man who ever lived. The writer block that stemmed from his unceasing rage reminds me of David Lynch’s Angriest Dog in the World; He cannot eat, he cannot sleep, bound so tightly with tension and anger he approaches a state of rigor mortis. It’s remarkable that CCR didn’t have more angry songs, but perhaps the one was enough. “Fortunate Son” is Creedence’s only political song, only protest song, and it’s so toweringly massive that it put CCR forever in the counter-culture pantheon. Part of that is Fogerty’s wail of rage, and part of it is the band matches it with every bar. (One of Fogerty’s least likable traits is his need to shit on the contributions of the rest of the band. In every live version I’ve found of “Fortunate Son” every member of Creedence fucking cooks.) But part of that is that the points it makes are pretty undeniable. Poor kids were dying. The loudest war hawks demand your sacrifice but not their own. Who could argue? Fogerty says his time in the army made him more attuned to the common man, and a little resistant to the hippies, but common men can tell that their lives are on their line while rich fat Republicans eat gourmet food and sleep in satin sheets. “Fortunate Son” is that rarity, a political anthem that expresses a sentiment that basically everyone agrees with but feels like a Molotov cocktail tossed into a cop car.
So how does “Fortunate Son” get so easily reappropriated? How does it end up in a Wrangler jeans ad? Is that the fate of all great art, that once they become too big they stop representing their intentions and just represent great American music in general? There’s a false collective memory that every Vietnam War movie features “Fortunate Son” in there somewhere; in fact, it’s only been in one, “Forrest Gump.” (People might be thinking of “Time Has Come Today” by the Chambers Brothers, a similar-sounding ‘Nam era hit that must be cheaper to license because it’s been in dozens of films.) To me, the intent of “Fortunate Son” is much harder to miss than “Born in the U.S.A." but I guess if you only listen up to the first bar (which is where the Wrangler ad cut it off) then maybe its twangy guitars, its country leanings, its undeniable whiteness, just read like classic Americana. (Shockingly, “Fortunate Son” appears on CCR’s most backwards-looking album, Willy & the Poor Boys, where they cover old blues standards and appear on the cover in character as the titular jug band.) Maybe its reputation as one of the best songs in the greatest era of music has fossilized it somewhat. And certainly, the fact that the “common man” likes it hasn’t helped its sentiment from being co-opted. In 1992, the now-voting-age conservative Boomers blasted Bill Clinton as a draft dodger for getting completely legal educational deferments even though Clinton, the child of a widowed single mom in small-town Arkansas, was no one’s definition of a fortunate son. No one disagrees that wealth brings privilege but people elected a racist billionaire because he claimed to be against the elites. Everyone loves “Fortunate Son” but fortunate sons still run the world.
I can’t hear it like that though. No amount of time, overpraise or overuse has dulled even a second of “Fortunate Son.” When Reagan tried to use “Born in the U.S.A.” as a campaign theme, he obviously had misunderstood it, but to me that seems like a funny but reasonable mistake someone could make if they’re not listening closely. But I simply cannot imagine the person too lazy or careless to notice the rage against the machine in “Fortunate Son.” They’d have to both have emerged from a cave and not speak English, and even then they should be able to tell the anger. “Fortunate Son” appears in the end credits of the hilari-bad Michael Bay knockoff “Battleship,” a rah-rah patriotic movie that jerks off the Navy and veterans but might be a stealth satire, the appearance of “Fortunate Son” being Exhibit A. Who didn’t recognize that song and laugh as they left the theater? It’s so incongruous the movie might as well have ended with “Fuck the Police.” I don’t care if everyone likes it. I like it. I ain’t no fortunate son.