Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

The most uncomfortable part of the story of John Newton is that, after surviving the deadly storm that inspired “Amazing Grace” and giving his soul to Jesus, he kept working on slave ships for another six years. I assume we’ve all heard the basic story, the slave trader who turned over a new leaf with his second chance, being reborn through God’s grace (“becoming a New Guy,” in Elephant Graveyard terms). But whoever first told me the story of “Amazing Grace,” back when I was a kid, left that part out. Indeed, Newton didn’t get promoted up to captain until after his supposed conversion. That’s six long years of the Triangular Trade, among the greatest of all atrocities ever committed by mankind, by a supposedly Christian man, before the stroke that ended his career as a sailor. Redemption isn’t easy; it comes slowly for some people (indeed, I would bet, for most people). On Wikipedia there’s a quote from Newton to the effect that he thought he had given himself to God after that storm but clearly he hadn’t, not really, not yet. The song claims that he “was blind, but now I see,” and that part isn’t quite true either; Newton didn’t like his job but not to the extent where he would later view his actions as immoral and criminal. During this time, he says he believed that his job enslaving and transporting his fellow man must be God’s design for him, and obeying God simply meant treating the slaves in his cargo hold as well as he could – a compromise he saw more clearly as a moral failure later in life, but an unfortunately common self-justification that should be familiar to all of us, and which Newton could very well have gone his whole life telling himself. If we believe in divine intervention, that stroke was also a deliverance from God, just as much as his survival six years earlier.  

By the time he retired from seafaring, he already knew what he really wanted to do with his life, which was preach the Gospel. He took a desk job on land and got involved in his local parish and began studying all the subjects he needed to learn to get his preacher’s license. Eventually, he got his official ordainment, got a job running a small church, got promoted to a much bigger church in London, wrote a bunch of big hit songs including “Amazing Grace,” and by all accounts was as popular and successful as someone in his profession could expect to be. By the time he started pushing to end the slave trade, he’d been out of the game for decades without saying word one about it, and likely could have gone the rest of his life silent on the matter. Newton was apparently serious about this God stuff; one must assume that his conscience ate at him in ways that even half a lifetime serving the Lord could not extinguish (or perhaps, in ways that serving the Lord could only amplify). He begins his treatise, Thoughts Upon the African Slave Trade, by saying that the abolitionist cause doesn’t really need his thoughts, there are plenty of people who have exposed the ugly details of slavery already; it was simply to unburden his own conscience. That might be false humility; he sent his thoughts to every legislator in Parliament, hardly the act of a man whose only goals are personal. Certainly, history has recorded him as one of the most important men in the movement, although that may be as much about the enduring legacy of “Amazing Grace” as anything else.

I think a lot about “Amazing Grace” – by some distance the most overplayed song I have ever attempted to write about – despite my indifference to spirituality. I have some upbringing in the Church and while it didn’t really take, my experiences there were mostly positive. (I saw a lot of my own perspective in Rian Johnson’s “Wake Up Dead Man,” which is not necessarily a movie for true believers but wants to see the best in those who are.) I especially have thought a lot about “Amazing Grace” lately, considering the full-on Jesus thing happening in music right now, a lot of which is selling the same kind of redemption story that “Amazing Grace” does. Forrest Frank tells his fans that he was treating his depression with drugs and alcohol before he found Jesus. Jelly Roll, the tatted face of this new trend, uses the wreckage of his former life as a junkie and criminal as a storytelling device in his personal narrative.

I see why it works. It’s powerful. These are the same things that make “Amazing Grace” the pinnacle of its form, even to those like me who don’t really care about God – a lot of people turn to Jesus simply because they like His story so much, and the story of John Newton works like that for me. But it’s not only that; meta-text didn’t make this the most popular hymn of all time. “Amazing Grace” is above all else Christianity’s greatest pop song, an era-defining banger, an all-time bop. It’s catchy; if God really was working through Newton, that melody is the finest evidence for it, still powerful whether delivered in the most soaring gospel tradition or the most whitebread CCM, adaptable to country or pop or r&b or cacophonous bagpipes or any genre that allows sincerity. The first few dozen versions that show up when I search for it on streaming include Elvis, Aretha, Johnny Cash, Alan Jackson, Pentatonix, Judy Collins, Sufjan Stevens, various choirs and tabernacles and marching bands, The Dropkick Murphys, Andrea Bocelli, Destiny’s Child, J-pop singer Mika Nakashima. Time hasn’t dulled it. It’s the perfect song for any occasion, the perfect filler to put in your movie when you don’t have a licensing budget (so much so that it has its own TVTropes page). A classmate in college used “Amazing Grace” for a key emotional beat in the stage musical he wrote, almost certainly because he ran out of time to write a new song. You can do that with “Amazing Grace,” the same way classic rock stations can play “Don’t Stop Believin’” five times a day; it doesn’t get old.

I hear its influence in the Christian songs that hit the charts last year. My favorite of the them was “Hard Fought Hallelujah” by Brandon Lake, a grizzled guitar slinger with a lot of tattoos who kind of looks like Andrew W.K. and has a voice like Chris Stapleton. “Hard Fought Hallelujah” is also a song of redemption, and he sings about keeping the faith through the tough times; Jelly Roll featured on a remix of it, the two of them selling what I’ve seen called “barstool conversions.” These aren’t pampered suburbanites with untested, empty pieties; they’ve been there, man, they’ve seen some shit, just like John Newton (Newton’s stories of his life before Jesus are rough; he doesn’t call himself a “wretch” for no reason). Lake attests that he’ll sing his “storm-tossed, torn-sail” hallelujah, words I took as an explicit reference to “Amazing Grace.”

Brandon Lake isn’t John Newton, though. Lake performed at Charlie Kirk’s funeral last year, which forever put me off the song. The second version of “Amazing Grace” that comes up for me on Spotify is by Carrie Underwood, who performed at Trump’s inauguration a year ago and has also used her influence to have worship-song-themed weeks on American Idol where she’s a judge. I first became interested in “Amazing Grace” the song through Amazing Grace the movie, a 2006 film about John Newton’s protégé William Wilberforce and his crusade to end the slave trade. Amazing Grace is a good film, but it’s also clearly an act of propaganda, from the time when evangelicals first realized that making good movies would be helpful to the cause. (This effort has continued only intermittently, since making good movies is hard.) The version of “Amazing Grace” that appears in the film was performed by Chris Tomlin; Chris Tomlin also sang at Charlie Kirk’s funeral. To emphasize: Chris Tomlin, who performed the title song in a movie about fighting slavery, also sang at a memorial to a hatemonger who supported segregation and despised Black people – a memorial that ended, naturally, with a crew of bagpipers performing “Amazing Grace.” These people are all frauds and liars, as deserving of the label “wretch” as Newton the slave trader. Perhaps they, like Newton, will find their worship of Christ just the first step in a long evolution of the soul (and if they’re right about the existence of eternal damnation, they’d better fucking hurry up with that), but I’m not holding my breath. I realize now that “Hard Fought Hallelujah” and the like, Jelly Roll and Forrest Frank, their redemption is from their personal vices and lack of worship. Maybe I have no right to speak on this as someone who has not heard the sweet sound of salvation, but that definition of redemption means very little to me.

All of that should make me sickened to hear “Amazing Grace,” or at the very least bored. “Amazing Grace” is less a song and more a fact of life at this point, and I’m sure that for many people, the only opinion they have about it as a work of art is that it’s a tedious cliche. It still hits for me. “Amazing Grace” is about the transcendent power of Christ, but it transcended Christ. Christianity is many things, but it’s also a culture, made up of people, able to be stained and ruined by the people that call themselves Christians and how they act. “Amazing Grace” might belong to the Church and all its followers, but it also belongs to the world, because it’s tied to the story of John Newton, and Newton is, to put it in modern terms, uncancellable.  Newton walked the walk. He lived the life. For me, “Amazing Grace” isn’t a story about God, it’s a story about a man – a man who, in real life, realized that worship alone was not righteousness. I should not be shocked by the way that so many Christian artists miss the point – Christians have been perverting the message of the Bible for millennia, why would “Amazing Grace” be any different – but it honestly offends me more.

Files

Celtic Woman - Amazing Grace

Music video by Celtic Woman performing Amazing Grace.

Comments

sconce

The ending part about how the song’s use in Christian nationalist spaces represents how shallow redemption is in the name of Christianity reminds me of that picture from some crazy megachurch of a pastor carrying a Cross to Bear with wheels on it. All of the self-congratulations for finding salvation but none of the actual finding salvation

Jack Darnell

I currently have a job where I go into nursing homes and sing for the elders there door to door. Many of them request gospel, and the only gospel song I really know well enough to perform is Amazing Grace (though I should really work on that). No one ever turns it down. It hits every single time, for every single person. I just sang it at least 3 times this morning. But I never knew much about the story of its writer. This was a deeply interesting read for me, and something I’ll continue thinking about as I continue singing the song for those who wish to hear it. Especially as I find myself in Ubers playing CCM stations (like this morning), which frequently annoy me. Yet this song I still find meaningful. I don’t have all my thoughts put together, but this was a really good read. Thanks Todd.

Austin F

as a gay who grew up while gay marriage was the prominent culture war (i turned 18 in 2014, when it was legalized nationwide), i've been thinking a lot about the fact that evangelicals support trump despite how cartoonishly immoral he is, and it's made me much more hostile towards christianity. that's not something i feel good about; i don't like judging people for things that they care about so much. but if christianity is supposed to help its adherents find their moral compass (like evangelicals love to claim), it clearly failed, so why do we keep having to give it more chances? when has it ever earned it? why do i have to reserve my judgment towards people who judged me so much, for moral standards that are obviously a sham? i obviously know that not all individual christians are like that, but the insane evangelicals of the world aren't the only ones who claim that their religion helps their moral compass, and it's clear that it can't actually do that. why do gays always have to be The Bigger Person and try not to make other people feel bad? even though i've never been religious myself, i don't like how disillusioned with religion (not even just christianity) i've become. but as i've gotten older, i've realized that my edgy 15 year old New Atheist self was wrong about a lot of things, but he was also right about some others.

Anthony Hansen

Elephant Graveyard AND Mika Nakashima mentioned, nice

Lanth

"realized that worship alone was not righteousness." Yeah that's. Pretty much my main problem with modern Christianity. Go volunteer in more prisons and picket fewer clinics, fuckers. My favorite version of Amazing Grace is appropriately enough, by an atheist, Ani Difranco. I don't think grace needs religion, thankfully.

Lanth

Wow he just made the subtext text with that move, huh

Dimetre Alexiou

A great and thoughtful post. It echoes with a lot of the conflicts I feel about institutionalized Christianity.

River Gowan Stone

I was raised Christian Fundamentalist in the 80s and 90s, and the rest of my family is still In It, to a greater or lesser degree (mostly greater tbh). The narrative of evangelical fundamentalist Christianity requires a "true" conversion, but it also requires that the "road to Damascus" moment be inherently conservative. Not simply politically conservative (though, also that) but to conserve the system more and more restrictively. I hate it on so many levels, but the one that still makes me angriest is that the "personal relationship with 'Jesus Christ'" has 0 connection to the actual words and actions and ethos of "Jesus Christ." I understand that the project of Christian fundamentalism was always disingenuous. It's just so hard to let go of the hope that the sincere people I grew up with might one day have a conversion -- the kind that upends one's life and that results in actual change in real time -- and get to experience God's grace for real

Kelley Runyon

Jesus, Todd. This thoughtful ramble smacked me in the face with thoughts and feels and...stuff. My religious upbringing (which also didn't take) left me with a lot of random Christian songs rooted into my brain including, of course, Amazing Grace. I hadn't considered how offensive perverting Amazing Grace truly is. "Worship alone [is] not righteousness" is such a key point, maybe an obvious one, but not one I've always articulated well. I have struggled with how to understand how my deeply religious mother can support Trump and the right wing in general (That's not really true, I know that she does it by never actually considering anything he does or that the right believe other than abortion which she opposes obvs). Anyway, thanks for rambling.

Stephen

I don’t think this current trend of famous people becoming more actively Christian is about personal growth or spiritual journeys. I think it’s politically driven, and not just about rationalizing their own political choices (to everyone else or just to themselves). They’re trying to make Christian Nationalism happen.

Matt Cramp

I appreciate this seems like a wild swing, but bear with me: As a young man I remember reading Robert Lifton's "Thought Reform and the Psychology of Totalism", which was written based on a number of interviews of Chinese in Hong Kong who'd escaped, or been released from, Chinese concentration camps. It's one of the first books to really attempt to understand, psychologically, what brainwashing is. Part of his findings was that Chinese brainwashing (a literal translation of the CCP's term for what the re-education camps were doing, washing the brain) wasn't much different to how coercive cults operate. The science has marched on since then, but there's one insight that struck me. Lifton describes a coercive approach that's a key method of control: a culture where transgressions against the group were expected to be confessed to, and a lack of confession was seen as evidence of guilt. This led to people confessing to offences that didn't exist, were easily disproved, which served the purposes of those in charge just as well. In mid-20th century China, confessions were evidence, and those who did not submit could be charged with real crimes based on their fake confessions. But it doesn't have to be so straightforward; the act of false confession *itself* binds people to an abusive institution. (Lifton explicitly contrasts this with Catholic confession: in Catholicism, they are private and secret, a first step to redemption rather than a way to tear people down in front of their group.) In 1972, evangelical Mike Warnke wrote a book where he claimed he'd been recruited by, and then come to lead, a group of Satanists operating in secret, and that he had now found God and was confessing his sins. To a skeptical eye, his claims are ludicrous, but he spent years, decades, celebrated by the evangelical community for his bravery in exposing the wickedness of the secular world, until an evangelical magazine noticed that his timelines had shifted enough that he was claiming he was still practicing in the cult when evidence showed he was preaching elsewhere. The way evangelism uses conversion stories fits the pattern Lifton describes: very public stories of redeemed sinners, where the community doesn't care if it's true. They need to believe, desperately, that the secular world is depraved, because then it excuses how inadequately they live up to the example of their own holy book. They need to wrap themselves in songs like Amazing Grace and not think about its message, because if they thought of themselves as wretches they would never, ever stop.

Quinn

Honestly it goes to my pretty succinct view on organized religion. I love Christianity, I hate Christians. I love the ideas and the beliefs, I hate the people who take it, warp it to suite their own wants, and then shit it out to the masses. I doubt if organized religion can be a force for good anymore due to the actions of the supposed "faithful" and I struggle with feelings of burning rage towards people who supposedly follow a moral code delivered from god. I am a frustrated wretch in that way.

Quinn

I agree, it's insincere and built upon a desire for power above all. Denying them that power is where we need to be better.