RAMBLE ON: "American Skin (41 Shots)" by Bruce Springsteen (Patreon)
Downloads
Content
I believe in America. I believe in Bruce Springsteen, so I must believe in America, since Bruce Springsteen is our American-est American. If patriotism is a virtue, Springsteen is the ideal patriot, a man who loves his country while never ignoring or excusing its flaws. Springsteen could easily have just been a really great rock singer, but circumstances made him a figurehead for loving the United States from the left; his biggest album was called “Born in the U.S.A” and it had a big American flag on it, right when America was high on patriotic imagery. Reagan tried to coopt his image, Bruce was forced to distance himself and make his politics explicit, and from then on, he’s been the blue-state Captain America. I’m grateful for it; I’m no right-winger, but I don’t like people insulting America. It gets on the fightin’ side of me, to quote a right-wing song. America has been very good to me and my family. Springsteen’s patriotism is one you can get behind, one you can emulate; you can be proud to be an American listening to Springsteen without being mistaken for a racist or an asshole.
I have doubts about America these days, so I have doubts about Springsteen too. I got tickets to see him in The Forum a couple weeks ago (if you have a chance to see Bruce in your lifetime you have to take it); I don’t know if I was prepared for the tone of the show, which I can only describe as “libbing out.” Springsteen takes his responsibility as the face of progressive America seriously; I got my tickets on a whim at the last second, and Bruce admitted the tour was also kind of a whim. When ICE murdered two people in Minnesota (jesus-christ-that-only-happened-this-year), Springsteen immediately responded with a protest song, “Streets of Minneapolis,” and slapped together this tour. He began with a short speech about America, launched into Edwin Starr’s “War” as an opener, and ended it by denouncing Donald Trump, but Bruce obviously isn’t (and probably could never be) anti-American. The tour was called “The Land of Hope and Dreams Tour,” a name that signals that for all its faults, The Boss still finds hope in this country, and feels pain when it lets him down. Bruce Springsteen believes in America.
That’s all well and good, but I couldn’t help but be hyper-aware that I was watching a big rock concert in an arena amongst a crowd of people who could afford Bruce Springsteen tickets. The closest thing to radicalism was the presence of former Rage Against the Machine guitarist Tom Morello, a guest performer with the E Street Band off and on for the last decade, and even he’s a guy I wonder about; Morello was the member of Rage who went to their Rock Hall of Fame induction in a tux while Zack de la Rocha was in the streets marching for Palestine. During the Boss’s latest protest anthem “Streets of Minneapolis” (a song I must tragically admit I don’t think is very good – spiritually Bluesky in the most derogatory sense), Bruce tried to lead the crowd in a chant of “ICE Out Now” and maybe I’m projecting in but he seemed disappointed in how tepid the response was. I wondered how many people here were conservatives who just wanted to hear “Dancing in the Dark,” and also wondered if maybe L.A has too many influencers and rich assholes to make for good concert crowds (I saw Charli XCX in the same venue and she was vocally angry at how quiet we were). I wondered if we weren’t all just jerking off pretending any of this mattered. I have friends with more radical politics, who believe that the American project only serves to disenfranchise disfavored minorities, extract their worth and hand it to elites. I don’t agree but I also don’t really have the inclination to argue against them right now. Is Trump dismantling the American ideals, or is he simply revealing what they always were? During the first few songs he asked us to pray that the troops overseas got home safe and praised the “peaceful protesters.” If you forced me to answer, I’d say that yes, I want the troops to come home safe, and that I don’t really think violence is the answer, but that wasn’t the message I wanted to hear.
Maybe he should have saved the “ICE Out Now” chants for later, because I understood better through the night about what The Boss was going for, that the political stuff wasn’t him getting the new material out of the way before playing the hits. Bruce Springsteen was emphatically not here to sing “Glory Days” or whatever for a crowd of rich Boomers. Bruce Springsteen was here to play every goddamn political song in his catalog, most of which came out after his peak years of fame, so tough luck for any casuals in the audience. He didn’t play “I’m on Fire” and he didn’t play “Thunder Road”; he was here to sing “The Ghost of Tom Joad,” “Death to My Hometown,” “Land of Hope and Dreams,” “Wrecking Ball,” “My City of Ruins,” and so on; I think he would have even skipped “Dancing in the Dark” if he could get away with it. I literally said “Oh wow” aloud when he pulled out “41 Shots.”
In 1999, a 22-year-old named Amadou Diallo was gunned down by four NYPD officers while reaching for his wallet. According to even the most exonerative version of the story, one officer mistook the wallet for a gun, made the decision to shoot first, and stumbled backwards from the recoil of his own gun; the other three officers thought that guy was falling backwards because he’d been shot, then unloaded their clips into the innocent, unarmed man – including after he had already gone down, according to witnesses. (This is too obvious to need saying, but Diallo was Black.) The NYPD cleared the officers of wrongdoing, but the outcry overtook their ability to sweep it under the rug, with one detail in particular screaming out for answers: 41, the number of times the cops fired. (Pathetically, they only hit him with 19, from close range.) This would have been the first big actual news story about systemic racism I ever heard; I was too young for the L.A. Riots, I didn’t really understand the implications of O.J., but there wasn’t much that could be misunderstood about this one. Diallo had done nothing wrong, the cops questioned him because they were on the lookout for a random criminal (Black, naturally) who had nothing to do with him, and then they killed him. They were charged with second-hand murder and found not guilty. The family sued for $61 million and settled for $3 million.
“American Skin (41 Shots)” was Springsteen’s response to the shooting. Bruce wasn’t the only person to write about Diallo; Public Enemy, Erykah Badu and Wyclef Jean all wrote songs, but I wasn’t nearly plugged in enough to know about any of them, I was barely plugged in enough to know Bruce. It was definitely the first new Springsteen song I ever heard, and I’m not sure how many of the old ones I would have known at that point, it might have been literally just “Born to Run.” I don’t remember how I felt about it, I knew people on the message boards thought it was important, but I was still trying to learn about music at that point, I was so far behind that I didn’t have time to waste on some protest song from a legacy artist who peaked 15 years ago. I’ve heard it a few times since, but I don’t think it ever really connected with me; it was about an event that happened when I was a kid, and I’ve grown to find the slapping of the word “American” on everything to be corny and even insulting. Why all this focus on Americans, what makes them special? The narrator of “Born in the U.S.A.” emphasizing that he’s native-born, doesn’t that imply that his disenfranchisement would be okay if he weren’t? Why is he even now praying for American troops and not the school they bombed?
It’s an important thing to note here though that Diallo was not American, in the legal sense. He was not born in the U.S.A. He was trying to become a citizen, but he hadn’t yet and it’s possible that he would have failed (he lied about his country of origin on his application for asylum). None of this matters to Springsteen. Diallo was living in America when it happened, so he was an American. More importantly, being born in the U.S.A. would not have saved him. The second verse is a mom telling her child (named “Charles,” a very American name) to be polite to cops, because they could do to you what they did to Amadou Diallo. Springsteen became the embodiment of America long ago, but the image he projected was overwhelmingly white; downtrodden, working class, economically depressed, but white. For the first time, Bruce was attempting to grapple with someone else’s struggle.
Springsteen started performing this song in concert in 2000, after his reunion with the E Street Band, and the first recorded version of it was from that tour, off his Live in New York City album. Bob Lucente, president of the Fraternal of Police, said Bruce was a “floating fag” and called for a boycott. Mayor Giuliani condemned it and warned Bruce not to sing it in New York. He sang it every night for ten days in Madison Square Garden. Some people booed. A year later, the Twin Towers fell, and it was not cool to talk shit about cops. (The Strokes had to remove “New York City Cops,” a song about what idiots the NYPD were, from their debut album.) But Bruce did not stop performing “American Skin.” Setlists.com tells me he performed it 13 times in 2002, including again at MSG; I remember the post-9/11 world and I cannot imagine the balls it took. Bruce kept performing it and finally released a studio version in 2014; I guess police brutality hadn’t been solved in the thirteen years between. Six months after he re-released it, Mike Brown was killed in Ferguson and a new protest movement called Black Lives Matter sprang up in every American city. If Bruce came to protesting racism late in his career, he was still more than a decade ahead of the culture.
I should not have said “Oh wow” when he started playing it at that concert in 2026, clearly, this was where the show had been heading all night. But as someone who hadn’t been super-keeping up with latter-day Bruce, “American Skin” was a distant memory, a protest about some long-ago thing that didn’t matter anymore; why, protesting the panicky fuckups of the normal police seemed quaint, after the cold-blooded intentional murders by the dictator secret police we’ve got going on now. But the second it started, a song I don’t really remember ever connecting with suddenly became the most vital song on the planet. “Getting killed just for living in your American skin” has taken on new terrifying dimensions on top of its already awful meaning. “It ain’t no secret,” sings Bruce, meaning that it’s not a secret that police are stupid racist assholes who can kill you and get away with it. But it was a secret to me, back in 1999, as a dumb sheltered kid raised around conservatives. It’s obviously not a secret to me now; maybe I just needed to get older, or maybe things just had to get so fucking bad that I could really hear it.
The original, live version of “American Skin” has a guitar solo from Bruce – a surprisingly ragged and violent one – and ends with a plaintive sax wail from the E Street Band’s legendary sax man Clarence Clemons. Clemons died in 2011; the studio version replaces him with another guitar solo, this one from Tom Morello, then a new collaborator of the Boss’s (Morello has apparently had a lot of influence on Bruce’s latter-day output). I don’t know why Bruce chose to re-record the song but if I had to guess, it’s because he had a chance to get the guitarist who played “Killing in the Name” to shred on it. Morello might honestly have never been better than he is on “American Skin,” and he was even better than that the night I saw him. I felt pain; I felt awe. I dropped any doubt that Tom Morello was some kind of phony, or at least I didn’t care.
I was on board for the rest of the night. The night stayed mostly with deeper cuts from his more recent albums, and I felt badly deprived that I don’t know more about them. Bruce played a couple of the big songs, “Born to Run,” “Dancing in the Dark.” But he ended with one final protest song, Bob Dylan’s “Chimes of Freedom.” I listened to “American Skin” all the way home. I believed in Bruce Springsteen for a night, maybe I still believe in America too.