RAMBLE ON: "God Bless the U.S.A." by Lee Greenwood (Patreon)
Content
This year July 4th fell on a weekend. For Billboard purposes, this meant we got a full tracking week of holiday playlist music, and for a major anniversary to boot; the 250th was a muted affair for me but apparently a big one for the rest of the country, because it sent nine America-themed songs back onto the Hot 100. Here they are, in order: “Courtesy of the Red, White and Blue” by Toby Keith. “Party in the U.S.A.” “Sweet Home Alabama.” “Chicken Fried” by Zac Brown. “Don’t Stop Believin’.” “Born in the U.S.A.” “Take Me Home, Country Roads” by John Denver (this one might have more to do with the World Cup). “Fortunate Son.” Kenny Chesney’s “American Kids.”
We can analyze what all these songs have to say about America (both “Fortunate Son” and “Sweet Home Alabama,” what a country) but the song that caught my attention was the one that didn’t re-chart, Lee Greenwood’s “God Bless the U.S.A,” a song I remember from my childhood as the definitive Independence Day song. I really loved that song growing up – I remain a patriot and will not apologize for it, my family fought so hard to come here for a reason – and I was heartbroken after I transitioned into adulthood and started developing taste of my own and discovered that the song wasn’t very good. I guess that would have been right after its post-9/11 resurgence, but I don’t think I’ve listened to it since – and certainly, considering Lee Greenwood’s latter-day career as a MAGA grifter, I haven’t been encouraged to, and the rest of the country seems disinterested also. In a world obsessed with the pop culture of the ‘80s, “God Bless the U.S.A.” has managed to find a pocket of nostalgia that America does not want.
“God Bless the U.S.A.” makes an appearance in one of my favorite books about music, Michaelangelo Matos’s Can’t Slow Down, a cross-section of every part of the music industry in the blockbuster year of 1984. Most of the book is about various genres raking in more cash than they’d ever seen, but the tone of the country music chapter is one of mild panic. Nashville had enjoyed unprecedented crossover success in the early ‘80s, making superstars of Willie Nelson, Kenny Rogers and Dolly Parton, but all that was evaporating now that audiences had actual pop music to listen to again. This is why the Nashville of ’84 is now clinging to Lee Greenwood; except for Willie’s duet with Julio Iglesias, “God Bless the U.S.A.” is the only song that’s attracting any attention outside the country audience.
This is somewhat embarrassing for the powers that be in Nashville, since Lee Greenwood’s music, and I can’t stress this enough, sucks. Greenwood honed his craft in Las Vegas, pursuing music in between dealing blackjack as a day job, and he has more in common with Wayne Newton than Waylon Jennings; he makes schmaltzy adult contemporary that, but for the twang in his voice, would barely be considered country music at all. Greenwood takes the starring role at Fan Fair, country music’s premiere promotional event (now called CMA Fest), and organizers seem defensive about keeping future stars like George Strait and Reba McEntire on the bench while headlining this AM cheeseball who makes Barry Manilow-ass housewife music. Greenwood would have twenty Top 10 country hits between 1983 and 1990, including seven number ones, and they are all completely forgotten today; the New Traditionalists would soon erase shlock like Lee Greenwood’s “I.O.U.” and “Going, Going, Gone” from history, forgotten artifacts of a soggy, string-laden era when country tried too hard to copy Lionel Richie.
“God Bless the U.S.A.” is the one exception, catching fire at a time when America could not be higher on itself – an age of Red Dawn, G.I. Joe and Hulk Hogan – and persisting still todayyyyyy. But curiously, even in 1984, it did not hit #1 on the country charts, stalling out at #7. Despite its long shelf life, I can easily see why it’s had its spot usurped by Toby Keith; it’s just so mawkish and dated, in both production and sentiment, broad enough to connect to an America-loving audience but not deep enough to want to listen to it enough to send it to number one. On this latest July 4th, “God Bless the U.S.A.” reached Spotify’s top ten, but that wasn’t enough for it to re-chart, held back by the little problem that barely anyone was playing it on July 3rd. “Fortunate Son” gets played all day every day regardless of the time of year; it only needs a little bit of seasonal boost to reach the Hot 100. But there's only one date on the calendar where anyone plays “God Bless the U.S.A.”, and at this point only out of obligation. It’s the America song, it has to go on the playlist, but we mostly just wait until it’s over so we can listen to Springsteen or “Chicken Fried” again. It’s far easier to imagine the guy who listens to Toby Keith, not even for political reasons but just because he thinks the music slaps, than the guy who casually listens to Lee Greenwood. (Depressingly, “Courtesy of the Red, White and Blue” was still in the Spotify 100 ten days after July 4.)
But honestly, even for all its banality, the fact that “God Bless the U.S.A.” is fading from prominence makes me sad. You can say a lot about the ugly side of Reagan-era patriotism but there’s an innocence to it too. The reason that Lee Greenwood loves America is that if he lost everything and he and his family had to start over with nothing, they could do it, because this is the land of freedom and opportunity; I grew up pretty comfortably despite both my parents coming from abject poverty, so this sentiment still speaks to me. It’s a sharp contrast to Toby Keith, who only likes America because we kill people. (Side note: How fucking pathetic is it to play this song AFTER getting your ass kicked in the Middle East.) Greenwood’s patriotism is at least one that believes in The American Dream, it has a reason to exist, or it did at one time; with the Soviet Union no longer a counterpoint, no one really talks about America as the leader of the free world anymore. Even post-9/11, people would talk about how the Taliban “hated us for our freedoms,” and now conservatives don’t even say that much. Freedom and opportunity aren’t even buzzwords anymore. “The flag still stands for freedom and they can’t take that away,” well apparently they can. Incredibly grim times.
There is a better world where Lee Greenwood tried to keep “God Bless the U.S.A.” alive as a less problematic counterpoint to the ugliness of Toby Keith, but of course he’s not the kind of guy to do that, and even if he did he’d be crushed; his music just isn’t good enough. (The entire Toby Keith catalog gets a big bump every July.) For someone like me who does kind of want to celebrate the country even in the face of what it’s become (and/or always was, but we don’t need to discuss this), there’s always Springsteen or Creedence or Mellencamp, but surprisingly I think I might actually go with “Don’t Stop Believin’” as my replacement “God Bless the U.S.A.” That’s a weird one to get a July 4th bump, but after thinking about it I can see it actually, and it’s the first thing that makes me like the song again after getting sick of it eons ago – if the positive case for “God Bless the U.S.A.” is that it believes in promise of a better tomorrow in the great U.S. of A., well, “Don’t Stop Believin’” is about that exact thing and also doesn’t suck.