Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

Content

Time to bitch about "Bitch"! 

As always, please vote in the Song vs. Song poll, this week we are doing "Runaway" by Kanye West vs. "Marvins Room" by Drake! https://www.patreon.com/posts/new-poll-runaway-51827171

And as always,  if there's errors please inform me!

Files

ONE HIT WONDERLAND: "Bitch" by Meredith Brooks

This is "ONE HIT WONDERLAND: "Bitch" by Meredith Brooks" by Todd Nathanson on Vimeo, the home for high quality videos and the people who love them.

Comments

Angela

Excited for the inevitable Alanis Morrissette comparisons XD

CJ

Error spotted: Instead of "Did she do anything else?", you put "The Failed follow-up" twice Great vid, though :) I love any of the OHW vids you do from the Nineties. Such a rich and fascinating decade for music

CJ

Also, the next one from this scene you gotta do is "Mother Mother" by Tracy Bonham!

AnalogSkullerosis

When I used to be stuck with the same radio station day-after-day at my job, my dumb ass always thought this was an Alanis Morrissette song. When you played it during the intro my eyes went wide at this realization. Anyway, great video as always. :)

Vanessa Picard

I watched Muchmusic religiously at the time "Bitch" came out and they played it in heavy rotation. I don't remember ever hearing/ seeing the video for the follow-up. It sounds so of its time in the worst way possible, yikes.

Anthony Hansen

"I'M A (*abrupt cut*)" you were proud of that one, weren't you

Wyatt

Wow, her body of work AND her politics went to some very awkward and uncomfortable places.

Josh Sunarso

Fond memories of listening to this song while playing Mortal Kombat 2 on my SNES.

Kyle Olson

"It was challenging for the time" Yeah, just wait until the YouTube algorithm see this.

James

The message that people are multi-dimensional and complicated may seem basic and obvious when you say it out loud, but I still think it is message that is worth repeating on occasion. Pop cultural discourse tends to want to categorize people into overly simplistic stereotypes, and then inevitably fights back against those stereotypes by replacing them with other overly simplistic stereotypes, so I think that a piece of pop culture with the message "I'm complicated" is worthwhile to have around.

Harrison Bieth

Well, that was interesting and now I like the song less. Also, the double 'The Failed Follow Up" transition.

Shiny Skunk

Has there ever been a time in history when Jennifer Love Hewitt has not come off like a desperate C-lister

Keith Badje

I remember Spin magazine writing something in the late 90's saying the charm of the song was allowing repressed office workers to freely say the word Bitch for 3 weeks. That seems about right.

Christopher Hill

As an Australian, it’s literally impossible to listen to Bitch without thinking about Bloke. Happy to see it wasn’t forgotten in this review.

andimalloutofbubblegum

And with her support of Trump, she downgraded from Bitch to the C word. I said what I said.

Paul McA

I will not lie, the whole way through the review that was what was playing in my head, and I felt _kinda_ bad about that and yet. . . .

Brittney With An E

Ngl i thought this song was by Alanis Morrisette (who I hate) until now.... then again I also thought Lilith Fair was a person so maybe I’m just dumb

Ryan Storey

To be fair, she's said repeatedly that she's not a Trump supporter. But she does seem quick to defend him more than anything, so who knows.

Liam Omega

Me before watching this video: "Oh! I love this song!"

Liam Omega

Me after watching this video: "Well...shit."

Kristopher Bluth

Because I'm also contradictory, I did peek at her Twitter feed, and while it wasn't quite as horrible as I feared...yeah. Don't worry, Meredith, Portland will get along just fine without you.

Josh Liller

The problem is that it assumes that all of a complicated person's dimensions are, and should be, acceptable. If you're okay with the "I'm a bitch sometimes; deal with it" philosophy then you should be okay with similiar attitudes that substitute "bitch" for "bastard", "asshole", or "immature jackass", and regardless of whether those attitudes are expressed by a woman or a man. I would argue there are some things that nobody should ever be any of the time.

Kristopher Bluth

Say what you will about Alanis, but at least she seemed to be coming from a place that was genuine (That and she had some killer production backing her up.) "Bitch" is the equivalent of Phyllis Diller putting on love beads.

Jacqueline Sailer

Oh, no, no, no, not another Rick Derringer. Really hate when artists I like turn out to have unacceptable politics.

Kristopher Bluth

Here's how I know my cell phone sucks: every time I type "Love" into a text, it immediately wants to add "Hewitt" (No, that's not a joke.)

Jasper Phua

A quick look through her Twitter feed and admittedly no tweets mentioning the Orange One but A LOT talking about Antifa... yeah, I think we can safely say which side of the political bread she butters on.

Jasper Phua

Surprised you didn't mention this being sampled in Bebe Rexha's platinum hits (what else?) "I'm a Mess"

Jasper Phua

@Josh: no one likes the person who Always Gets Little Rush Out Of Telling People John Lennon Beat Wife, jsyk

Kristopher Bluth

I know multiple people who claim not to be Trump supporters but still make excuses for him every chance they get. Sadly, my "unfriend" button has gotten a little bit of a workout in the past twelve months...

Liz Jackson

Damn. I liked that song. But then again, I also still listen to Rock'n'Roll hoochie koo, and Rick Derringer is WAY worse than just a couple of dumb tweets.

TheCrazyEven

okay we're up to two artists featured on this show who've ended up pushing right leaning values in recent years, unless i'm forgetting someone else besides rick derringer

Gene Younkin

“I Need” was giving me Fun Style flashbacks for some reason.

JasSpy

This is probably the only remote chance I'm going to get to ask you to cover "Combine Harvester" by The Wurzels, one of the greatest meme songs ever recorded. Better yet, make it an OHW triple feature with "Brand New Key" and the other Irish parody "Brand New Key" coincidentally received some how. And get Linkara to cameo definitely too!

Jasper Phua

doofenshmirtz_two_nickels_meme.jpg

The Other Greg

I fell as a 'geriatric millennial' that I'm coming to terms with it. Johnny Rotton wasn't a surprise, but Morrisy stung a little.

Don McHoull

I guess she tried to pass herself off as being part of Gen-X back in the 90s, but now that she's ranting about Hillary Clinton on Twitter her true Boomer self is shining through

Angela

After reading Kevin Sorbo's feed, I doubt I'll ever be shocked by 90's washout celebs touting right wing politics again.

Jon Heiman

I think I saw "All I Need" like once.

superdogcoin

The unfortunate right wing plot twist strikes again.

Sean Riley

By contrast, I was _horrified_ when I heard Chris Franklin's voice again. Good god, I'd hoped to never remember.

Andrew

She’s clearly a “centrist”! As in she defends the right and attacks the left

Cassandra Gelvin

I looked into the lyrics of this song a while back, and it came off more like someone describing untreated bipolar disorder. "I'm a bitch, I'm a lover, I'm a child, I'm a mother" and the additional lyric "I'm nothing in between" make the song's narrator sound like they have wild mood swings. If she was "everything" in between, it would make more sense as describing everyone.

Tim Mackie

As an Aussie, words can not express how happy I am you put the Chris Franklin song as the stinger

Amanda Shore

I looked at her Twitter and boy I did not like that

Beau Dure

I'm depressed, I'm a ... no, I'm just depressed

James Lefkowitz

I would guess that though she influenced the corporate/Hot Topic/facebook algorithm softening of the word "bitch", the wave that brought "bad bitch"/Missy Elliott/"100% that bitch" came from mostly rap and african-american trends and wasn't as related as you put it here.

Ford Diem

This episode was great, but I'm surprised after her hit it wasnt mentioned the only thing that I was aware of that Meredith did. She wrote the song "I'm Alive" by Becca which is notable for being the ending song to the anime Black Butler. I'd recommend listening to it because it 100% made sense to me that she wrote it.

Emily Kohls

I love this song too and I did not need to know about *that*. 😩😔 Thanks Todd.

Lanth

....so it turns out this whole time I've been conflating Meredith Brooks and Natalie Merchant. Oops.

Stephen

That outro gave me one of the most severe cases of cultural cringe I've had in years

Matt Cramp

also excited to see the return of the song that Google thinks is more notable than the man behind Errant Signal, to that man's eternal chagrin

Rei The Gei

Lemme guess, a lot of TERF stuff?

Taylor Abrahamse

Lily Allen did the same thing 16 years later with 'Hard Out Here', same talk about 'retaking the word bitch'. And I had totally forgotten about this so I was like 'good for you Lily!'

RedBedroomRecords

yet another 90s OHW i've never heard before in my life(at least not that I can remember) and after learning her becoming a total wackjob i'm extremely grateful for that. i'll gladly take Nickelback and Hewitt over Brooks, at least they didn't turn out to be right-wing nutjobs like her. Also cannot stand the song "Creep", i'm not one bit surprised Tom Yorke hates that song with a passion and refuses to play it at concerts anymore.

RedBedroomRecords

that seems awfully mean-spirited and unnecessary, she's a pretty good actress.

RedBedroomRecords

I was shocked when I randomly came across Kristy Swanson attacking Nancy Pelosi on Twitter, that was a nasty surprise.

Heather Simpson

I still think of it every time I hear this song (never actively sought it out, it just got a lot of airplay at the time), but I was *not* expecting it to come up.

RedBedroomRecords

Morrisey always came off to me as a pretentious asshat before I learned he was a bigot, so that was no great shock to me at all.

Laura Tate

I had the same thought! In fact, I think I made a face when "I Need" came on that I haven't made since "Bollywood"

Laura Tate

Girl Boss Smash Mouth is potent and haunting. Absolutely love it lol

Matt Ryan

Also as an Australian I have to note that this version was a #1 hit over here

RedBedroomRecords

No mostly her whining about "antifa" and other right wing nonsense, TERF stuff is more for famous people in the UK.

Stephen Gillie

The problem with women is they're only human. This song really helped me understand and empathize with the women in my life, in the midst of 90s Tom Leykis masculine toxicity. Looking at where she went after, and the other replies about where she is today, maybe it's a good thing that she had just the one hit?

Miranda Whittaker

Why is being a Bitch the opposite of being a Lover? Wasn't this the era of "Why men Love Bitches"? Odd dichotomy.

Jason Schneiderman

Got a list from my mother, loaf of bread, a stick of butter, quart of milk—it's for my mom. Wasn't Sesame Street the bomb?

BMJ614

Please do a One Hit Wonderland on Kreayshawn's Gucci Gucci

matt

nice man, another solid one hit wonderland ep. this is totally another song that just kind of came and went and I never thought about it much - it's so much fun having you walk us through these little check-ins on where they were then and where we are now.

Angela

Eh they didn't endorse anything, they just didn't voice their support in a timely matter.

Raymond

Apparently Chris Franklin Bloke

Laura Bianca-Pruett

My husband could have written this comment verbatim! He was shocked when he realized at the beginning of the video that it wasn’t an Alanis song.

Mariangela Osiecki

Thank you so much for ending on "I'm a bloke", being Aussie I remember this version more than the original.