Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

Content

We've only just begun. 

Anyway, please vote on Patreon for our poll on "Song vs. Song" where we're doing "Band on the Run" vs. "Mr. Blue Sky," you love it: https://www.patreon.com/posts/new-poll-band-on-54899711

And please catch any errors

Files

TRAINWRECKORDS: "Passage" by Carpenters

This is "TRAINWRECKORDS: "Passage" by Carpenters" by Todd Nathanson on Vimeo, the home for high quality videos and the people who love them.

Comments

Duke86fan

Tbh I had no idea about the respect or hate the carpenters got.. they always just existed

Timur Hahn

Now I kind of want to hear "2112" as sung by Karen Carpenter.

Lewis Lovhaug

Holy crap, back in February I somehow ended up looking at a few Carpenters TV specials and discovered Space Encounters. I just kind of wrote it off as "Star Wars is popular, so get some goofy 70s cheese out of it." Didn't realize there was all this backstory and explanation for it.

Aaron Anaya

This is interesting video I honestly don’t really know anything about the Carpenters.

S. R.

This made me tear up a little. Great ending.

WikiPera

The opening ad has killed me

Franco del Rosario

Oof. I haven’t even watched the video yet, but The Carpenters were my mom’s favorite band growing up, so, of course, they will always mean a lot to me. Plus, they’re still extremely highly regarded in a lot of Asian countries (Japan, Philippines, etc.) and still get a metric ton of radio play on soft rock stations around here. I just know that this video will hurt me. I can’t wait.

Sam Frederich

The audio and video are out of sync at 8:18. Great video as always, what a frickin' ride

Georgina Storey

Very cool! There's a glitch around 8:18 where your voice doesn't match the footage of you speaking.

Tom Williamson

Absolutely loved it. I literally punched the air when Todd revealed his love for Calling… Happy World Contact Day everybody.

Alan Kase

There's something I find particularly funny about hearing the "you put the drummer in charge" line in relation to The Carpenters since Karen was the drummer. That's a solid joke, Todd.

Kevin W.

Holy cow that was a wild one.

Gwen Stearns

In the introduction to the video, you might've meant 'hippies never liked them,' rather than 'hipsters never liked them.'

Gaby G

Excited for this one - the Carpenters are one of my three favorite groups of all time, so I’m ready to fiercely defend them lol. They haven’t gotten the critical attention they deserve until recent years.

Jennifer Layton

As a GenXer who loved the Carpenters growing up, I loved this episode. I agree with you about their country songs. Karen was suburban Connecticut, not Nashville.

C Puffer

“Really putting the Karen in Karen Carpenter” lol good one.

Teddy Haines

I guess my takeaway is that had Karen lived longer, we really needed to hear her on an Ayreon album.

Juan Nunez

My main take away is that they do a very good David Bowie.

Angela

The thing about Don't Cry For Me Argentina is, I think it's SUPPOSED to be condescending and glurgy. Like, it's not a sincere song, especially if you apply to an Evita like Patti Lupone, who wear's her social climbing and bitchiness on her sleeve. She's acting to her voter base. Granted not all actresses play Evita that strongly, but does lend me to to think that Karen Carpenter was not the one to cover this.

Jordan Schmidt

this is what i get for wanting you to talk about klaatu someday..

Justin V

Watching the Star Wars Holiday Special commercials (preferably by Rifftrax, they're all on YouTube) makes awful 70s TV Specials make a lot more sense.

RedBedroomRecords

Yeah when I saw the Simpsons "Family Smile Time Variety Hour" segment in Spin-Off Showcase I thought it was a huge exaggeration, but then I saw some clips from variety shows like Pink Lady and Jeff and I realized those variety shows really were that corny and lame.

Shiny Skunk

Oh man, I fucking l o v e The Carpenters so I am PUMPED for this.

Wyatt

I love the Carpenters, always have, but hearing Karen Carpenter singing a racist tirade at her maid is like seeing Bob Ross running a dogfighting ring. That just feels WRONG.

Anthony Hansen

I was shrieking with laughter throughout the "awkward" reveal.

Justin V

Karen had a wonderful voice, and it even had a touch of tragic melancholy to it which was downright haunting after her death. I'm just old enough to remember stories of her battle with anorexia in health classes. Like all Light Rock in the 70s, this was going to be derided by critics and ultimately pushed off to EZ Listening radio while the bands made cash. Attempting to appease the critics is almost always going to fail when you're the disliked subgenere. That said, "Calling Occupants" is so perfectly weird that they deserve all the credit for going for it.

Nicole Crawford

Carpenters go Prog rock? OK Sure why not? Couldn't be any worse than that time Billy Joel thought he was Keith Emerson.... This Klaatu cover actually sound pretty damn good, I agree with you. Probably a bit late in the decade to go in that particular direction seeing as how badly more established groups in the genre would flop just a year following this album. Perhaps that was part of the reason why the album didn't do as well as it could have.

Justin V

It's the Paul Lynde Halloween one that does it for me. Such a Word Salad of guests and events.

Jennifer Layton

Agreed. My mom was a huge Carpenters fan, and I have to ask her if she knew about that song.

Erik Danielson

Me: yay, new Todd video! This’ll be entertaining. *sees who the videos is about* Me: oh, wow. This is gonna be a wild one

Nicole Crawford

"Attempting to appease the critics is almost always going to fail when you're the disliked subgenere." Tell that to Genesis lol. They got hugely successful almost immediately when they started writing more accessible songs. But I see what you mean generally.

Richard D'Orazi

The “Calling Occupants” cover is basically what you get if a similar down the middle and uncool artist today like Ed Sheeran and Adam Levine tried their hand at covering some weird and obscure song and somehow managed to make it sound good against all expectations to the contrary.

Jasper Phua

So is this easily the best album done in this series?

Shiny Skunk

Yeah, the fact that Karen died so tragically, and wanted so badly to be loved in a way that never really happened for her, adds a lot of pathos to that song.

K

In any conversation about TV specials influenced by the Star Wars mania of the 70s, I have to recommend people look up the Donnie & Marie Star Wars special on Youtube. For my money it's more baffling than the Holiday Special.

Kristopher Bluth

Stuff like this is why I’m a patron. Bra-fucking-vo.

Justin V

Probably just my opinion, but yeah it's a misfire but with just enough good in it to recommend. Looking over the others it's probably the most respectable one -- they tried and it didn't quite work. It's not cynical like Metallica or Jewel or unlistenable like The Beach Boys.

Kristopher Bluth

And on a related topic, Karen’s solo album should certainly qualify as a Trainwreckord. It was recorded in the late ‘70s, scrubbed at great expense, went unreleased until the ‘90s…and yeah, there’s a reason. Want to hear Karen Carpenter singing horny mid tempo disco ("My Body Keeps Changing My Mind")? How about a duet with Peter Cetera called “Making Love in the Afternoon”? Yep, it happened. I understand her feeling stifled by her image and wanting to branch out, but talk about not playing to your strengths…

John Wick

"When you put the drummer in charge, you get drum solos." Karen was the drummer. That line made me LOL. :)

Henry Kiley

I never thought I’d see a Trainwreckord that’s even more banana-sandwiches insane than Funstyle, but here we are.

Kristopher Bluth

Kudos to Todd for helping put that in context. Karen may have been a phenomenal talent, but irony and wry sarcasm just weren’t weapons she had in her arsenal.

Tom Carter

Okay, I heard that Calling Occupants song and was INSTANTLY reminded of Princess Leia’s song about Life Day from the Star Wars Holiday Special. Is it just me?

JasSpy

No Star Trek references Todd? Cuz Calling Occupants sounds like the result of The Carpenters binge watching too much of TOS and TAS, (but not TNG, that hadn't been made yet).

Nick Ostrem

The most shocking part of this video was learning that their choice of that sci-fi song actually predated Star Wars, I would have bet the farm on them seeing that Star Wars was a hit and scrambling to find their piece of the pie instead of it just being a fortunate decision. That TV special though, woof, that might be the second most obvious Star Wars cash grab to hit network TV after, you know, the obvious one.

Richard D'Orazi

Apparently, Michael Jackson’s “Rock With You” was originally written in consideration for Karen’s solo album which just feels weird to think about

Garrett Hicks

Aw man, I love Klaatu and the original “Calling Occupants”! Then again, I did nod appreciatively and knowingly at Todd’s line “This is some real nerd shit,” so… Guilty as charged.

AstarothLuLz

I don't know why, but I find Todd's sponsor ads to be fucking hilarious. They're the perfect example of being technically correct while drowning in irony.

Library of Context

I never realized that The Carpenters pretty much only did covers. I looked back at their discography, 95% of their stuff, they don't have a writing credit on. To me it was always elevator and department store music. Being 1977, I was alive when this album came out, although very young - even then I mostly knew The Carpenters as a punchline.

Kristopher Bluth

After thinking about this more, the moral to the Carpenters’ story in the latter half of the ‘70s is a simple one: you can get critical acclaim or you can cohost variety specials with John Davidson. Pick one, because you can’t have both.

Jared Walske

I cannot express to you how happy I was to hear you talk about Calling Occupants of Interplanetary Crafts, a completely bewildering song that I have a deep, sincere love for. Week made

maruhkati

It's quite likely that the best song on this album wouldn't even have been on it if it weren't for a rumor that would have been squashed in like thirty minutes if the Internet had existed.

Josh Liller

The Carpenters were my mother's favorite band. If you had known my mother that would not be at all surprising.

Adrian Fernando

I'mma be honest, I thought this was gonna be about the Cranberries.

Taylor Abrahamse

As a Canadian musician, I've met people who've met people from Klaatu - but man are they reclusive! I'm glad you love Occupants, it deserves so much love, and I really admire them for going for it and taking a risk.

Russet Burbank

Also, We're gonna groove tonight, we'll make you feel alright Carpenters Christmas Boogie!

Joe G

She'd have been awesome on the "Discovery" and "Oracle" sections for sure but I'm damn curious how she would have tackled "The Temples of Syrinx".

Joe G

A lot of 70s music really feels like a throwback to 40s and 50s music. Smooth-voiced crooners backed by a large ensemble playing light jazz arrangements? Even disco is more like an amped-up branch of that musical family tree than a descendant of hard rock music.

Laura Bianca-Pruett

“This is some real nerd shit” and I love it! I am putting Calling Occupants next to Michael Sembello’s Automatic Man on my “top songs” playlist.

Laura Bianca-Pruett

Oh, and depending on how you classify Christmas albums, you may have made a mistake around the 28 minute mark - they actually put out two studio albums after Passage - Christmas Portrait and Made in America. Normally I’d say that Christmas albums don’t count, but considering that it ultimately went platinum, that’s a pretty big deal. Plus “Merry Christmas Darling” and “Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas” have cemented themselves into regular Christmas radio airplay.

James

I'm now imaging what would happen if Imagine Dragons tried covering Ayreon (extremely nerdy Sci-Fi prog rock/metal band) and it somehow came out good. Ayreon for reference: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fUSoR4EdyIo