Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

Content

End of the month, man, exhausting. Let me know if you saw anything wrong with this video! Or if it sucks!

And as always, please vote in the Song vs. Song poll where we are doing "1985" vs" Stacy's Mom": https://www.patreon.com/posts/new-poll-stacys-64218831

Files

POP SONG REVIEW: "Sweetest Pie" by Megan thee Stallion and Dua Lipa

This is "POP SONG REVIEW: "Sweetest Pie" by Megan thee Stallion and Dua Lipa" by Todd Nathanson on Vimeo, the home for high quality videos and...

Comments

Jared Stone

I don't know why, but the video link still isn't working

Ultranatic Productions

When you said “Get me to 5K subs” did you mean 500K, because you’re well past 5K?

Summer Woods

The link worked fine for me! I appreciate you talking about this song since it just seemed so empty to me…and you fully explained why. Also, funny as always. Killing it, Todd.

Colton Moore

There's also the unmentioned problem that this is just exactly Bad Habits again musically. Like, it isn't even subtle - Dua's on the same rhythm to start the hook, it's the exact same key, everything. That said, that video is... jesus christ, how did anything top Numb Little Bug for worst music video of the year thus far

Joshua C

Sweetest Pie is just vagina, so "I'll drive and you just lay back" is pretty simple, right? Like, amazon position or something like with the chick on top. Not sure what is confusing Todd there.

I, II, II, IL

I think when you first mentioned the song, it was charting below Something in the Way in Australia. I checked the charts again, and while its doing better than Something in the Way, it has gone down a few places, and is now doing worse than Mr Brightside!

Marina Vollin

This is only tangentially related, but my theory for why we got that abysmal Bruno mashup at the Oscars is that that was supposed to be the opening number (hence all the academy navel gazing) but it got shoved into the middle when Beyonce signed on. IDK why else disney should get to two songs from Encanto, one of which wasn't even nominated. Interesting take about Megan and Doja. As someone who doesn't listen to top 40 radio and only interacts with pop music through this channel and twitter I never considered Doja a bigger star than Megan but that might just be my bubble.

Loeko

fantastic timing, ending this video with "save us harry styles, you're our only hope" and releasing it on the same day harry styles releases his new single 😩

Nir revel

Todd was always very literal and especially dislikes mixed metaphors but I'm fully with you here. Pie as a metaphor for vagina is so obvious now it's just a synonym

Reena Setälä

It's still stupid mixed metaphor. The thing about food metaphors is that they are about eating. Driving isn't eating. Being driven is definitely not eating. If you ain't eating, the sweetness is irrelevant. Warmest, nicest, moistest, most succulent could all work in the the context if you wanted to take the emphasis away from eating.

Octo

"Step on my balls madam" is begging to be adding to an out of context video

Nir revel

Something about Todd's take here just doesn't translate to me here.... IDK what exactly because I do usually tend to have similar tastes to him in terms of when crass songs are fun and when they are cringe. Maybe I just vibe with Dua Lipa more which makes the difference? IDK I just don't share his sentiments here. To me this is WAP but through Dua's style then Cardi's

walterxbenjamin

For some reason the video is only playing in Firefox, not in Chrome. The problem seems to be on Vimeo's side. Strange.

James Eldred

Ever since people started talking about Megan Thee Stallion being so damn great, I felt like I fell into bizarro world. She's a generic rapper with no real personality besides "I like fucking" and most of her biggest hits have no hooks, no melody, no good samples, just bland beats. I'm happy to see that someone else finally dislikes one of her songs as much as I do.

gerald oxford

Can you do a one hit wonderland on Flava in Ya Ear by Craig Mack?

Jacqueline Sailer

While we're on the subject of Megan Thee Stallion's latest single flopping, she had a song on the most recent Addams Family movie soundtrack. Is the curse about to strike again?

Jacqueline Sailer

For what it's worth, Lion King did produce two pop hits, although they were just the Elton John versions of "Can You Feel the Love Tonight" and "Circle of Life", with no "Hakuna Matada" in sight.

Franco del Rosario

Extremely minor correction (if you even want to take any action): At the 13:08-13:10 mark, it has a bit of an awkward cut from a shot of you to another shot of you, if that makes sense. At 14:13, similar thing happens too. If this were any other YouTuber, I wouldn’t even have noticed, but your editing is always so tight & good that it stuck out. Great video. Amazing that you were able to have so much commentary on a song that is so aggressively meh / mediocre.

MJS

I don't really get it either. I'm not the biggest Cardi fan either but she's clearly better at this whole "strip club rap" thing and has more range.

Arag0ns

I was just thinking about this song the other day and came to the conclusion that the reason this song didn’t “work” for me personally was it’s inclusion of dua lipa. She just… seems apathetic musically somehow, and she brought it with her.

Alejandro Vasquez

Hey y'all, recent patron here, very excited for my first early access. I like to watch Todd's vids on my TV, but does anyone know if there's any way to stream Vimeo from my phone to my screen? I don't see any AirPlay-type options here

Michael Schrag

I feel like showing this music video calls for some kind of body horror tag, lol. Not really serious about that, just... yeesh, that face-pie and the eye-hands.

Robert

Watching an unlisted vimeo video on a TV is a horrible experience. I tried and most of the time I didn't get it to work. Way easier on YouTube.

Robert

There are some horrible images in that video. I was close to only listen to the rest without watching it. That cheek pie and the middle finger out of the eyes. Vomit inducing...

Joe G

Disney owns ABC, the network that airs the broadcast, so they have to do something to make up for the fact that non-animated Disney films don't get nominated. (The other thing was producing the most anti-film Oscar broadcast in recent memory. Sheesh.)

Brian Anderson

No mention that they lifted the melody from Shawn Mendes’ “Nothing Holding Me Back”?

Joe G

Yeah, I've seen early David Cronenberg films that didn't squick me out as much as that video.

Shiny Skunk

This Meyers commentary part of this video makes me think Todd would be great if he started reviewing the full work of video directors.

ranavain

TBH I kind of agree, I think her style works well for a LOT of the music she does, but she sticks out here. I also think she just looks ridiculous in the video; she's obviously super hot, but she just looks like she's trying too hard to Be Sexy, and being juxtaposed with Megan Thee Stallion it makes it worse

Christian Samples

Todd: “Doja Cat makes songs about kissing” Doja Cat, in that exact same song: “I FEEL LIKE FUCKING SOMETHINGGGG!”

ranavain

oh yeah no I totally agree. The spider crawling under Dua's face skin? I have no idea why they thought the move here was Sexy Body Horror but it is emphatically not the right decision

Nicholas

At 0:46, shouldn’t that say “Get Todd to 500k subscribers”?

ranavain

I use the Vimeo TV app! I have an Nvidia Shield TV Pro, and use Plex within that to manage media, but I suspect that any TV box that can download apps has a Vimeo app. I add it to my Watch Later to make it easy to find on the TV

ranavain

Yes, one of the things that bothers me most about this song is that the whole thing is a ostensibly about one metaphor, and they spend so much lyrical space on a completely different metaphor. It's just lazy songwriting

ranavain

I think Megan is extraordinarily talented but I think she's also shaping up to be a Lil Wayne - very prolific, and thus very hit-and-miss. Wayne has put down some of the best verses known to rap, but he's also done some of the worst. I'll take it, tbh, at least we get SOME good stuff that way

STTICE

Good shit as usual

Shiny Skunk

yeah, i thought that song was about eating pussy? i guess it has plausible deniability, esp for the censored radio version.

Todd in the Shadows

Thanks, this is the kind of stupid error I need you guys's eagle eyes for

Allison Driskill

Todd, I am so sorry to inform you that "THEE" is not pronounced with a long "e." It's just "the." I don't know why.

Meluieth Box

God, I'm actually going to have to just listen to this in another tab, this music video is hitting me in all kinds of wrong ways, I feel like I'm gonna throw up.

RedBedroomRecords

i've literally never heard this song before now.

RedBedroomRecords

i've seen worse but yeah I get people being put off by this.

TheCHR83

This is the first time I ever saw the music video and...you're not wrong. Woof.

Ben French

It's days like this...I'm glad I don't pay attention to the charts.

Jonathan P

"Save us, Harry Styles, you're our only hope." Holy shit did Toddstradamus finally nail it?

Tedd-Z

Personally, I kept hearing 'Movin' Too Fast' by Artful Dodger