Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

Content

CSNY's return was one of the most hotly awaited reunions in rock, only for the band to be utterly wrecked by the '80s.

As always, check for my errors! 

Files

TRAINWRECKORDS: Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young's "American Dream"

This is "TRAINWRECKORDS: Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young's "American Dream"" by Todd Nathanson on Vimeo, the home for high quality videos...

Comments

waywardlaser

Holy shit I timed that well for once

Stokes

Yay a new Trainwreckords while I'm working! Thank you Todd! I'm still holding out that you do The Beginning by The Black Eyed Peas

MJS

10:22: audio not in sync with picture when it comes back to you

Chris Black

David Crosby is fucking crazy (haha)! I'm sure it sucked for some folks close to him, but from afar it's sort of aspirational...

Amelia Maciorowska

the title song sounds like it's doing the exact same thing This is America did - no real commentary, just gestures at the idea of one

Angela

10:25 the audio doesn't match the clip of you sitting at your piano - you're mouth isn't moving.

David Gutierrez

Albums that would make great future episodes of Trainwreckords: - In Blue by the Corrs - The Corrs changed their sound to finally break the music market in the United States, but at what a cost. The album sold millions of copies, but their die hard fans abandoned them. The Corrs never recovered from this. - Shadows and Light by Wilson Phillips - Bionic by Christina Aguilera - Love Beach by Emerson Lake and Palmer - Masterpiece Theatre by En Vogue - Anything is Possible by Debbie Gibson - how did the teen pop princess' reign come to an end so quickly?

Pietro Gagliardi

The thing with the harmonies on that soft country song about evictions is that it sounds like they layered all the vocals multiple times, so it sounds like there's three copies of them singing all at once. I ... wouldn't have done that, at least not for that song.

Chris Black

@10:22 is that the clip you meant to use? It's you in shadowed profile, but not actually speaking the voice over.

Laura Bianca-Pruett

This was a really great episode! I love when you go back into 1960s-1980s classic rock territory!!!

Bailey Vogt

10:23 audio doesn't match up with video. Looks like your head is filled with Ronald Reagan's thoughts.

Justin V

Between this, the "No Talking Just Head" album, and Van Halen the late 90s was a dark time for classic rock bands trying to make a go of it without their famed lead singer.

Kristopher Bluth

These are four guys who are undoubtedly talented and illustrious, yet I listen to them together and feel nothing. I saw Bob Dylan a couple weeks ago and he could probably blow all of them off the stage (Yes, including Neil.)

Kristopher Bluth

The Heads album would be another excellent episode. Jerry, Tina, and Chris: I love ya, but what the hell were you thinking?

maruhkati

I've seen Neil Young in concert more than once. I am not at all familiar with this record. This is gonna be good.

Duke86fan

when that vietnam song came in as soon as i heard that synth i was just.... dying of laughter

Jesse Shade

I can easily imagine Neil Young having to wash his mouth out with vodka and turpentine immediately after recording the vocals for any of these songs he didn't write himself. Not even Genesis at their most synthy sounded this hollow.

John Wick

I was also thinking about ELP's "Love Beach!" :)

Graf von Tirol

Ah yes, that's one of my wants here. It's sad that such a feel-good story wound up a massive disappointment. With that out of the way, the five I'd like to see down the line: * Yes - Union (Pop Yes and Prog Yes (Anderson Bruford Wakeman Howe) unite, but didn't synergize that well and some of their parts were replaced with session musicians. The tour was a success, but they kinda meandered the 90s onward) * The (Byrneless) Heads - No Talking, Just Head (they could just be the Tom Tom Club with guest stars, but no) * Black Sabbath - Born Again (the point where post-Ozzy, post-Dio Sabbath wrecked) * Emerson, Lake and Palmer - Love Beach (yet another infamous supergroup flop) * Happy Mondays - Yes Please (I've seen a case made for it; the fustercluck that was the Barbados trip and the fact that it bankrupted Factory Records sounds like material for this show)

Justin V

I hear "Genius of Love" is being sampled in a recent pop song, so I think back to their better side-projects.

Tom Carter

So that title track is one that goes after scandalous politicians leading America, hence destroying the "American Dream". And yet it sounds like what'd happen if a System of a Down song were sung like I'm Yours by Jason Mraz. Okay then!

Hiatt Werling

"No Talking, Just Head" is also a dream Trainwreckords episode of mine.

Joe G

I'd love that Heads episode as the backdoor pilot for a Concrete Blonde One Hit Wonderland via Johnette Napolitano.

Joe G

Those electric piano/marimba samples on those late-80s synths are just so corny. In the right song they work but they so often do not.

Kristopher Bluth

The production on this whole thing is just astonishing. This isn't the worst sounding Trainwreckord (that honor will hopefully always go to Cut the Crap), but it's up there.

Gene Younkin

I clearly remember Steve Winwood, Roy Orbison, and Mick Jagger singing a Mamas And The Papas song with David Bowie from the ‘80s but I don’t think I’ve ever heard of this album before today.

James

I swear every rock/metal band that was active in the late 80s-early 90s was contractually obligated to write a song about Jimmy Swaggart or televangelists in general.

Graf von Tirol

On the note of Winwood, before Young was considered we almost had Crosby, Stills, Nash & Winwood. Traffic had just split up, but he was too busy with Blind Faith.

Kristopher Bluth

Hell, they inspired Shatner's story for Star Trek V.

Laura Elizabeth

Ah, No Talking, Just Head. Proof positive that "fuck you, we'll make our OWN band!" doesn't work when the person you're fighting with is also the most talented member.

Justin V

They were everywhere, easy targets, and dressed really silly. It was hard not to comment on them.

James Yates

I loved the 3 part series that the "Rivals" podcast did on CSNY, the second I saw you did a Trainwreckords on this album, I know we were in for some wild shit.

Damian Penny

Good episode as usual, but I’m disappointed that after showing Stephen Still talking about how much he loves drinking you didn’t splice in Mike Love saying “life in prison for being a ladies man.”

Damian Penny

Are you the guy I argued with in the Todd in the Shadows subreddit about Debbie Gibson? I thought Electric Youth was a big hit and it was her album *after* that which was the Trainwreckord. I do agree that Shadows and Light would be a good one. But my Trainwreckords Holy Grail is the Sgt. Pepper’s movie soundtrack with the Bee Gees and Peter Frampton (and, um, George Burns).

Damian Penny

I’ve never listened to the whole thing, but from this episode I think some of these songs (even the ones not written by Neil) could have been salvaged with better production.

Matt Croc

Neil Young being photoshopped into an album cover isn't anything new because the last Buffalo Springfield album also added Neil in after the fact when he wasn't around for the photoshoot.

Damian Penny

The thing is, I actually remember hearing the title song a lot when it was released. Maybe it got Can-Con play because Young wrote it? I agree with Todd that “You Got It Made” is actually good.

Damian Penny

Bad cover art is a Trainwreckords cliche at this point (Witness, Cyberpunk, Kilroy was Here, Crash…)

Dakota Naas

For a brief moment, knowing Don Henley's litigious tendencies, I thought you were actually serious about him being the dark specter looming over the 80's.

The Hand Of The People

7:42 Ironically, I've always seen this as an exclusively, almost pretentiously, American trend. Other countries rarely indulge in the trope of solemnly putting their nomenclature before a piece of art. Stuff like French Exit and A Very British Scandal are the first that come to mind, but pale before how many titles "American" is slapped onto. To quote Mr. Wednesday in American Gods, "America is the only country in the world that wonders what it is. The others know what they are."

Alina

This may not be an error, but the footage of the band playing on the stage looks slowed down and when it's with the actual song playing over it, there's a dissonance because of the speed of playing/singing isn't matching up to the speed of the song playing. Is that just the only quality the footage is available in? Other than that, always love a Trainwreckords episode!

JasSpy

"Old Man" by Neil Young is a funny song to me nowadays, cuz I can never resist imagining that Young is singing to Phelous's Old Man character. Neil: "Old man, take a look at my life, I'm a lot like you!" Old Man: "Do you have a daughter named Beauty, and are you bothered by a Beast? No? Didn't think so. I guess you're just being a typical pretentious musician. HEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!"

Mr. Jones

90's music >>> 80's music

Jasper Phua

Mardi Gras II: Electric Boogaloo

Jasper Phua

Eh, that's not really fair, at least Glover got a striking video to go with that song.

David Gutierrez

I don't think its me... I just did a google search out of curiosity and found a subreddit argument between redditors Fckyrrspctbltypltcs and JournalofFailure. Neither of those are me, but they argued back and forth about Debbie Gibson. I've posted on that subreddit, but not under those names. Anyway, I only became a fan of Todd and Trainwreckords over the past year or so. A while back, I discovered the TV Tropes page where people try to predict future episodes of Trainwreckords (https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/WMG/ToddInTheShadowsTrainwreckords) Somebody posted Debbie Gibson's "Anything is Possible" as a future episode of Trainwreckords and it got me thinking, what did happen to Debbie Gibson? When I was a kid, there was a brief moment where she was huge, all over the radio and MTV, etc. I think a Trainwreckords episode about Debbie Gibson would be a good one. I just checked Wikipedia. "Electric Youth" sold over 4 million worldwide and went to number 1 in the US. "Anything is Possible" sold under a million worldwide and only went to number 41 in the US, though she continued to be popular in Japan.

Gator McKinley

Not a correction for the video, but could you post on Twitter the source about Billboard data from the 80s being manipulated? I'm a huge but newer chart geek and I am very interested to hear about this possibility

Jason Schneiderman

Basically, up until 1991, record sale numbers were tabulated by calling up stores and just asking people what was bought — which means that there were all kinds of ways to make fraud happen. In 1991, Soundscan was implemented, which tracked actual sales from the register. https://ultimateclassicrock.com/billboard-soundscan/

George E. Schneider

That's an editing trick that Todd uses when he doesn't have footage of a song being played. It also gets a lot of use in the CCR Mardi Gras episode of Trainwreckords.

Charles Kieser

No real factual errors here, although I have seen some more love for Neil Young's "Trans" recently. The rest of his 80s albums barring "Freedom" are supposed to be pretty bad, though. Bob Dylan and Joni Mitchell also had pretty rough 80s output overall. Seems like the decade was not kind to 60s folkies. Leonard Cohen might be the only exception.

Gator McKinley

Thanks for providing that, that's super interesting! Do you know if this impacted the Hot 100 or just the Billboard 200 Albums chart?

Tim Briody

huh, I immediately recognized “Got It Made” when the chorus hit. Had no idea it was CSNY.

Dan H

I was waiting for a "Traveling Wilburys did the 'elder musicians coming together in the late '80s' better" comment throughout the episode, and got it at the very end.

Adam Violet

I hate to say it, but I think you flubbed the last line. "(R)ecords made entirely out of emotional obligation with guys you can't stand anymore doesn't work"

Kristopher Bluth

What’s interesting is multiple ‘60s artists who struggled through the ‘80s released albums in 1989 that were widely considered to be returns to form. Not only Young (“Freedom”), but Paul McCartney (“Flowers in the Dirt”), Bob Dylan (“Oh Mercy"), and even Lou Reed ("New York") all put out their most critically acclaimed stuff in years. It's as if they knew that better days were ahead...

Kevin Goldsmith

At 10:22-10:26 the clip of Todd at the piano doesn't match the spoken line. I can't tell if that's intentional or a mistake on which insert to include there.

s bel

In an alternate universe, 80s Crosby played Obelix in a live action Asterix movie

Noah Veik

I know this might be a correction that might seem pointless, but I think it might be helpful to add a comment that mentions the bands each member comes from. I am personally unfamiliar with all of these guys and didn’t know that one was from the Byrds, one was from the Hollies, ect. until I went and looked it up

Jasper Phua

Yeah this is a huge reason he doesn't usually do OHWs from before the 80's.

Justin V

My parents had that "Yacht Rock" album of CS&N. Since it was the 80s and tape players in a car were a new thing I heard it quite often. I had no idea at the time THIS was the same band that did Ohio/Judy Blue Eyes/etc. They sounded so 80s, like anything else on the Light Rock/EZ Listening stations my parents usually ignored. It's not bad, just not exactly the cathartic cry about troops murdering college students like a decade earlier. The parents got me into Queen, Dylan, CSN, good Chicago, Jefferson Airplane, Joni Mitchell, etc at a young age. I'm still pretty sure I'm the only kid who asked to sing Bob Dylan in Sunday School at 4.

RedBedroomRecords

i'll defend VHIII on my deathbed. One band i'd love to see a OHW on is the short-lived R&B group "Before Dark", the only reason I even know who they are is because they were on an episode of "City Guys".

RedBedroomRecords

to me a song should stand out on its own, it shouldn't require a video to make it good, I felt like that song was boring and listless, it had no impact on me whatsoever even with the video.

RedBedroomRecords

I nominate KISS-Music from the Elder as while they definitely had success after that, that was the end of them innovating as a band as their most succesful tours after that were all about playing to nostalgia and ignoring the bands "Unmasked" era pretty much entirely. Also Scorpions- Eye II Eye.

RedBedroomRecords

Debbie Gibson did some acting since, I saw her in one of those Asylum monster movies along with fellow 80s pop sensation Tiffany.

RedBedroomRecords

I thought Born Again was critically acclaimed and loved by fans though? I think Seventh Star would be a better fit since that wasn't even originally supposed to be a Sabbath album, it was supposed to be a Tommy Iommi solo album but the record company forced it to be put out under the Sabbath name.

RedBedroomRecords

I think there were other good ones too, Genesis "Jesus He Knows Me" comes to mind.

RedBedroomRecords

yeah and it makes me wonder if there were any bands that actually sold better then the charts reflected.

Kristopher Bluth

If memory serves, Daylight Again was intended to be just Stills and Nash until the label pressured them to bring on Crosby. Might as well start off the Eighties with some corporate greed, amirite?

RedBedroomRecords

I still say the 80s is pretty damn good and I for one liked Shadowlands, Soldiers of Love, Don't Say Goodbye and Shadowlands.

RedBedroomRecords

Yeah that sort of thing works for Def Leppard, but not for this band.

RedBedroomRecords

I like that sound but it was jarring as hell to hear it on a song like that.

HankInYourPlace

This is a tiny factual error, but Neil Young is an American citizen as of 2020. “What did you know about that Neil, you WERE Canadian.”

Angela

he has dual citizenship I believe. Canada lets you keep your Canadian citizenship when you get citizenship from another country.

Vanessa Merzuis

At around the 10:22 mark, your voice is heard but your lips are not moving. I don’t know if this was intentional, but I just wanted to make sure you knew. Great video nevertheless!

Monotone

It’s a shame there’s not a way to view these early releases on Nebula. I can easily watch that on my TV through their app, but here I have to cast it to my TV. Just not as convenient and plus, I assume you’d get some more revenue if I watched it there.

Keith Badje

I actually kind of love "Yes, Please." It was a wreck to make, and kind of a mess to listen to, but there's some great lyrics and some kinda awesome grooves.

Jess Morgan

I'm nominating Todd's Neil Young impression for "best two seconds of Todd" for 2022.

Mouser

The Abilene Paradox in album form.

Kristopher Bluth

The Wilburys were also smart enough to treat the whole thing as a goof. They weren’t singing Very Serious Songs about Vietnam vets and farm foreclosures.

Taylor Abrahamse

weird abrupt flash of willie nelson when you talk about farmers and farmaid

James Thomas

I became a patron just so i could watch this. Also I'd love to see a OHW on The Rasmus now that they've resurfaced in Eurovision

Jacoby Good (@BASEDSouljah)

It got taken down "due to a copyright claim by Music Vault" on YouTube just for ya'll that don't know yet. I re-play Trainwreckords all the time to catch certain stuff I missed, and just noticed it!

Chris Orsten

Todd a while ago asked about "Calling All Stations" on his Twitter. IIRC The fact that it wasn't expected to be a massive seller (It was not even expected to go Gold), since even Phil Collins' previous 2 solo albums flopped, to him puts it in a "failed experiment" instead of a Trainwreckord. If anything, Todd should do Phil Collins' "Both Sides" as a Trainwreckord. that was expected to be huge, and it bombed huge, and completely derailed his career.

Deanna Banana

I love this episode! My parents played the hell out of the Deja Vu album when I was a kid and it has a very special place in my heart. I went with them in the 90’s to see CSN in concert and they mostly played songs off that album. I don’t think I’ve ever listened to this one, and I learned a bunch of stuff from this vid about the group I didn’t know.

user no. g_{64}

Did I just miss the Trainwreckords title card with the colliding trains, or is it really not there? If it's not there, is that deliberate?

Jason A

Fabulous episode, terrible album! More importantly, how is David Crosby still alive?

user no. g_{64}

Oh yes, blind old bat me. Thank you, Stephen!

Peter Melling

Well, it looks like the Don Henley footage got the original upload striked. That’s inevitable, given his tech boomer attitudes. This is why Todd will never do The Long Run on trainwreckords. EDIT: Apparently, it was waterpark commercial footage that did it. That’s strange.

Russet Burbank

I'm pretty sure that the "pan flute" on American Dream is a fife, in keeping with the American Revolution motif.

MarioDaBean

Wow, this album sounds like shit