Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

Content

/edit Reuploading a bunch of things people caught, if it's not working at the moment just give it 15 minutes and it'll be back up

God, finally managed to finish a video. I have been suffering from the most crippling writer's block. I wanted to have this done two weeks ago. Well, at least it's finished. Check my errors, y'all!

And also, hey, please vote in the Song vs. Song Poll, where we are doing "Stupid Girl" vs. "Just a Girl" https://www.patreon.com/posts/new-poll-just-vs-69090224

Files

POP SONG REVIEW: "Break My Soul" vs. "Falling Back"

This is "POP SONG REVIEW: "Break My Soul" vs. "Falling Back"" by Todd Nathanson on Vimeo, the home for high quality videos and the...

Comments

Damian Penny

I saw “Break My” in the notification and thought it was a OHW episode about Matthew Wilder.

Will K.

FYI for the final draft: I think "dance, monkey" (at 4:18) has a racial connotation you probably didn't intend

Wren Jayasekara

The "dance monkey" comment may go over people's heads, and become interpreted as a racial slur

Will K.

Audio glitch at 10:32

GregD

Excited to hear your thoughts on some new music. Not that I dont love all your stuff, but I dont keep up with current trends or songs much.

ts_babyjane

yay ! i actually knew about these before you talked about it. lol, i'm the lone person in the "idk, the drake album is kind of interesting" lol, to me it's sounds like he was trying to make a drain gang album.. of course he's not and it's a bad Drain Gang album, but its still fascinating

Will K.

at 15:40 the cut from one mad tv clip to the other is awkward, has a quick flash of another shot

gooberdude

there is a brief stutter on the word "Drake" at 10:33

Ben Mackenzie

I get what you were going for comparing Drake to a performing monkey but going from what's happened to other people making similar gags about other Black/mixed people before innocently, it could go very badly

Franco del Rosario

Around 7:13, it cuts from a shot of you to another shot of you.

Pietro Gagliardi

I got the sense that musically Drake desperately wants to be The Weeknd from this episode. I very much could be wrong, but that's the first thing to come to mind when I heard that falsetto.

MJS

7:14, awkward edit

Vanessa Merzuis

That Dance Monkey reference can very much be perceived as racist, even if you didn’t mean it that way.

Tirgo

At first I assumed the "line of brides" in the video was sort of a Drakey way to convey that he'll keep finding failed relationships and getting remarried time after time, sort of a commentary on his inner Drake brooding or whatever. Five seconds later, the video informs me that this isn't a metaphor or symbolism, he's literally marrying all of them at the same time. For that I have no idea.

Duke86fan

why drake decided to make a dance album because artists like pinkpanthress on tiktok were getting popular and so he will chase every trend

Franco del Rosario

In the context of Beyonce making a song for the queer community, I’m surprised you didn’t specifically mention Big Freedia who adds so much to Break My Soul. (And, incidentally, was also a guest on Drake’s last truly great hit, Nice for What). Still an interesting and entertaining video as ever.

Stefan Ristic

i feel like falling back could work better as a childish gambino song honestly, his voice is much more suited to it than drake's thin falsetto. great video as always todd!

ToadMan101

In terms of quality and deserving to expand, I think Drake’s hit a low with CLB last year. It’s clear that all he is, is an AI machine that makes songs so that people can mindlessly stream his music because… he’s Drake. Also, the public has been turning against him more than you think. Not only are the negative reviews coming through more frequently, but I’ve seen (at least in my social media experience) more and more people call out the creepy stuff he’s done with underage women dating all the way back to 2010 and the most recent case being in 2019. Personally, that’s probably gonna be kept an open secret because he’s such a big name, and even if a huge news company made an article about that, it won’t affect his streams anyway unfortunately. Asides from that, there have been numerous rap tweets where people categorize who’s the GOAT, favorite, least favorite, etc., and Drake for the most part has been listed in overrated. The overexposure has probably hit a high this year, and I think people would be okay if he didn’t do anything for 2023.

Emanuel Alfredsson / Lemanic

As an occasional Deep House producer, I think Drake’s Sade-drenched Sophisto-Rap wanted some of that old Larry Heard revival money that the UK EDM scene seem to produce right now at the heels of Disclosure but also the 2010s Outsider House scene. Drake is a known UK-phile, so trying to get on that is beyond plausible.

Shiny Skunk

Is the audio for the Drake song fucked up, or is the song just mixed that badly? It sounds like it's being played through radio static.

Sarah, the Creator

While this Drake album was just as boring as his other recent output, Jimmy Cooks is actually his best song in a long time (damning with faint praise maybe lol). Unlike Knife Talk, I actually don't find myself wishing it was just a 21 Savage song!

AlabasterLaserblaster

Would definitely reconsider the dance monkey joke. You meant it innocently of course, but it could be misinterpreted easily. Maybe nix it or lampshade it?

Joel Eblin

I think it's interesting that last December, Grimes released her song Player of Games, which is inspired by 2000s house music. She had her follow-up single Shinigami Eyes that continued the 2000s house inspiration, but I wonder if the Drake and Beyonce house music will have her shelf the rest of the EP. Do I think Beyonce or Drake were inspired by Grimes? I highly doubt it, but I think the idea of a house/dance throwback-era has been in the works for a little while.

Gemini Man

To add to your point, I just listened to Falling Back before watching this, I watched this video, I already can't tell you what Falling Back sounds like.

Kristopher Bluth

Here’s how you know I’m old: Drake has been a massive star for years and the first thing I still think of when I hear his name is Jerry and Elaine wavering on whether they like or hate “the Drake”…

Zoey

It should also be noted that Lady Gaga also sort of fell off the mainstream and kinda with her fans after her Joanne album in 2016 (success of "Shallow" in 2018 notwithstanding) and the release of the Chromatica brought people back, which also was largely inspired by 90s house.

Joshua C

Yeah, you will absolutely want to ditch the "dance monkey" bit at around 4:17. I get the non-racist point you are making, but I cannot for the life of me think of a proper synonymic replacement phrase to not accidentally call Drake THAT.

Christian Reiswig

I don’t see any significant issue with the dance monkey joke, it’s a very common expression. Anybody would understand what it means without jumping straight to bad connotations.

Nolan Roberts

There was kinda a ska come back with "She's Kerosene" by The Interuppters

MarioDaBean

I’m impressed on how half-assed Drake’s music is

Jacqueline Sailer

There have been plenty of popular house revival singles over the past several years, so these songs are nowhere near as much of a shake-up as the pop-punk revival tracks were last year. If anyone is the biggest female pop star right now, it would likely actually be Dua Lipa, who, true to the early '90s house divas, isn't as known for her personal life.

Jacqueline Sailer

What you're describing in this video occurred 12 years ago on a much more radical scale. Once electropop blew up, suddenly every active R&B star was releasing housey dance music, a genre which America had so thoroughly rejected throughout the 2000s. Everyone, from Usher, to Chris Brown, to Akon, to Sean Kingston, was now putting out singles that you could play alongside Cascada.

Mad Duck

Falling Back is not a single

Christian Samples

Funnily enough, Beyoncé was one of the *few* R&B acts who didn’t hop on that bandwagon, instead that album was much more traditional R&B and it’s aged WAY better than most of those acts

Christian Samples

Good video, but I must ask that you please remove that “dance monkey” joke. I know it wasn’t meant in that way but it can definitely be taken the wrong way

Tedd-Z

Yeah, with the poor mixing and Drake's loose flow not fitting with the beat, it sounds like a really lazy mash-up

Johnny Riches

That ouija board bit was one of my favorite todd bits in a while, I loved it

Sadie S

Was Chromatica really that successful for her? The people I talked to and the reviews I saw all considered it kind of a half-assed, rehashed version of what she used to be good at, and I myself was pretty disappointed by it. I'd be interested to see a different perspective on it, though.

Alice Allan

Singing the Gettysburg Address! Gold. So happy to see this in my inbox.

Lanth

I'm hearing a stutter/skip/repeat of "Drake" at 10:33

Benjamin W

I know you didn't mean anything malicious by it, but the "dance monkey" bit still made feel uncomfortable. If it's not too late, I would edit that out

Anthony Hansen

I would like to think that, but this is the internet.

superdogcoin

Monkey might be a bad choice of words. I know you didn't mean it that way, but in reference to black man that might be a little yeesh.

Zack

I'd rephrase the "dropping right that minute" line for Beyonce. The album still hasn't come out yet. Also there's a sudden change in framing at around 7:14.

Michaela Tussey

Might be due to my being chronically online, but public opinion of Drake has been going downhill for a long time. House music has always felt like a divisive genre in the sense that it's either great or completely heinous. Also... the true star of "Break My Soul" is Big Freedia! It wouldn't have been as successful without her sample imo.

James Thomas

I think the problem is that like with Mchine Gun Kelly's gentrification of pop punk, there's so much fantastic actual house music out there that's more worth listening to. Why listen to out of touch superstars trendchasing when acts like HAII, Hannah Peel, Kelly Lee Owens, Daniel Avery have been putting out fantastic music lately.

RedBedroomRecords

Ah yes Cascada, a friend of mine played me a burned CDR with "Everytime We Touch" on it months before that song was everywhere on the radio, it's a cool feeling knowing something before it becomes popular.

RedBedroomRecords

Exactly Drake's attempt at House music is like what some music critics I follow said about MGK's "Tickets to my Downfall"-if some unknown up and coming artist pulled this crap they would've been laughed out of the room and not been given a free pass but because it's Drake it's somehow OK for him to phone it in.