Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

EDIT EDIT EDIT: The embed doesn't seem to be working (WOW PATREON, THIS VIMEO PARTNERSHIP IS GOING SO WELL), so here's the direct link. Does this work?: https://vimeo.com/user89788165/thething

EDIT: Okay, I just uploaded it to YouTube, hopefully that link works

This episode kicked my ass. I clearly need a break -- I was planning to take this month off, but then I missed deadline so technically I'm posting this during my vacation; I'm taking a badly needed break after this. I may be back next month or I might extend it, either way you don't need to adjust your patronage since I get paid by the video anyway

But as always check for my mistakes!

And as always, please vote in the Song vs. Song poll! We're doing Sia's "Chandelier" vs. Miley Cyrus's "Wrecking Ball": https://www.patreon.com/songvssong/posts

Files

TRAINWRECKORDS: Mötley Crüe's "Generation Swine"

Can Mötley Crüe, the defining hair metal band, remake themselves for the '90s? The answer will not shock you! Support Todd on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/toddintheshadows

Comments

Syl W

Enjoy your break, Todd!

TheOwlGuy

Yes! I was hoping you make a Trainwreckords video for this

Thomas Carmody

Based on that album artwork, this should have been a Primus album.

Serendipity

Thanks for all your hard work! Enjoy your break Todd!

Jason Lee

We appreciate your efforts Todd! Get some rest, try not to think about music too much!

Eagle

The video link appears to be broken.

Yannic Schäfer

Is it me or does the video not work for anyone else? Anyways, enjoy your break Todd! EDIT: direct link works, I'm on Firefox windows 10

Alina

It's possible to get the vimeo link from the source code, but the embed is broken, like the comments above say. ETA: didn't notice any issues with the video. Always love a Trainwreckords! Enjoy your time off.

Teddy Haines

Now it takes me to Vimeo where it says Sorry, we couldn't find that page

Craig Nelson

Does not work for me on mobile haven't tested PC

CDN

May I ask how you get the link from the source code?

Kael

It’s asking me to log into Vimeo to view the video

Anthony Raye

the direct link works thank you!

ts_babyjane

the direct link you posted in the edit works.

Elisa

I clicked through to the Vimeo page and it plays fine now, thanks.

Charles Kieser

Please do Everything Now at some point

Alina

The link in the edited post works for me. On firefox, in case it matters.

Henry Kiley

I saw them on their most recent tour. Vince looked...unwell.

Isaac

If you like failed attempts to save a slipping career that only cemented its death, there's a very good episode to be made on The All-American Rejects' Kids in the Street, which tries to catch the indie rock boom of 2012 and also get a little Fall Out Boy/Panic at the Disco style personality, and fails at both horribly.

meffeww

there is a dip in the audio quality of your voiceover between 6:30 - 6:50 (reminds me of your old videos, kinda nostalgic, but definitely not intentional). besides that, this was such a fun episode - and hearing the lyrics to Brandon is the hardest I've laughed in a while. enjoy your break and thank you for the great content as always!

Kylie McInnes

Sounds about right. This album was hot fucking garbage. Metallica managed to make great heavy modern rock albums (Load and ReLoad are both excellent albums), Aerosmith just made dirtier and sleazier hard rock, but Crüe...just...no.

meffeww

also it might be my Twitter brain, but I can't help but imagine Pamela Anderson giving birth to a baby Joe Biden when I hear that Brandon song.

MarioDaBean

I genuinely thought “Brandon” was a joke

Peter Melling

I facepalmed several times at the promotion for the album and the “Brandon” song. Seriously, it sounds like something out of a Mr. Show sketch or an IASIP episode. Corabi’s interview was very telling as to the absolute lack of direction the album had.

Buddog18

wow just... nailed it.

KatastrophicImp (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-15 03:00 Oh boy. This is probably the first video you've done that I got a bit worried at before clicking because I have a lot of nostalgia attachment to Motley Crue... But yeah no, everything here was pretty much spot on. I really wish they had gone the "velvet revolver" route with the '94 album, and thinking Vince could just be slapped in for the songs meant for Corabi was stupid as hell. Nikki seemed to learn an important lesson which was "keep it to the solo albums", these kinds of songs go to Sixx AM to make now which is probably for the best. "Motley Crue" really is an accurate band name. For better or worse, the whole group is kinda mismatched and Vince by himself is basically holding up the entire "hair metal" aspect, so without him they lose all of it, and with him they can't do anything else. Realizing that is probably why they don't put out albums anymore. They could probably get away with occasional singles, but trying to make a whole bunch of songs that hit that sweet spot where things match up right probably isn't doable out of their original era without sounding utterly dated and only of interest to their old diehard fans.
2022-09-05 00:58

Josh Liller

It seems like Motley Crue would have been better off if the band went on hiatus for a few years in the mid-1990s so all the members could do their own side projects with their visions of what Crue should be. After that bit of experimenting and getting out of their system they could come back together and actually hash out a coherent vision. Seems to work for Dave Grohl.

nursermk

I was able to view on Vimeo. Enjoyed it, learned a little.. Hey take some time, relax, and come back when you feel revived and rejuvinated. I know that overclocked feeling and it just takes time to get back to baseline.

Laura Elizabeth

Me, squinting at that Pam and Tommy clip before you said what it was from: Wow, Tommy Lee looks EXACTLY like Sebastian Stan.

David Gutierrez

Another great video... just a note, at the 22:45 mark, more or less, there is a very odd cut/edit/jump. Just something to check.

take5™

i was gonna first ask "dont u think its a bit too early to call that a trainwreckord?" and then i remembered that its been 5 years now, and they just released a new album, and it was desperately trying to get back to the sound of the glory days, and most critics thought it was just mid, and then The Rest happened, and i think now, yeah, its time

take5™

great episode todd, what a wild ride. tho now im more wanting the final piece of the Glam Metal Flop Era Trilogy, even tho i know it will probs be an hour long and a bitch to make. but it doesnt really matter ... gotta find out for yourself ...

David Gutierrez

Enjoy your break Todd. When you get back to making videos, here are some interesting "Trainwreckords" to consider: "Bionic" by Christina Aguilera "Hootie Mack" by Bel Biv Devoe "Testify" by Phil Collins "Love Beach" by Emerson Lake and Palmer "Masterpiece Theatre" by En Vogue "Bleed Like Me" by Garbage "Chinese Democracy" by Guns N' Roses "Victory" by the Jacksons (The Victory tour featured no songs from the Victory album) "Supposed Former Infatuation Junkie" by Alanis Morisette "Face the Music" by NKOTB "The Yellow Album" by the Simpsons "Now & Forever" by Kim Wilde "Shadows and Light" by Wilson Phillips "In Blue", "Live in Dublin", or "Borrowed Heaven" by the Corrs

Johnny Riches

Thank god Todd isn't sick of Nirvana Killed My Career episodes, because I literally never will be

GEWolf

I remember being a like 12-13 year old edgelord metalhead kid (in like the early 2000's after that was really a thing) and hearing Dr. Feelgood for the first time and getting swept away. Then hearing Generation Swine and quietly going back to Feelgood and Kickstart My Heart like nothing ever happened lol

CJ

Interesting that they mentioned Cheap Trick as an influence to the album, as Rick Nielsen and Robin Zander are credited on backing vocals on "Glitter". But glad to have this one covered, I always wondered what exactly happened in the 90s to Crue

Kristopher Bluth

I remember going to B. Dalton and thumbing through magazines like Kerrang and Hit Parader that were all about the hair metal and completely baffled as to what to do with stuff like Pearl Jam and Alice In Chains. When Motley Crue’s self titled from 1994 was coming out, they tried SO HARD to hype it as some grand event that a whole generation was foaming at the mouth for (“There’s a group of kids who have never heard Crue and are desperate to experience real rock at last! Really they are!”). Heh heh, have fun going on Where Are They Now? shows to whine about how mean Kurt Cobain was to you. Say what you like about where bands like the Pixies, Jane’s Addiction, or even Bush wound up, but they aged far more gracefully than most of hair metal did…

Kristopher Bluth

Watching shriveled up metal guys cry about how much they didn’t understand grunge never gets old.

Katy Hart

Vince Neil's voice is really more suited for the old Crue stuff. He has an edge of sarcasm that fits the 80s stuff more .

Kristopher Bluth

And I’m sure I’m not the first to suggest this, but the story behind “Waiting for A Star to Fall” by Boy Meets Girl is actually a lot more interesting than you may think. Nirvana Killed My Career and Screwed By The Label all in one episode!

Christie Brewster

I loved hearing the intro to Glitter and imagining them covering Open Up by Leftfield. And when you said Tommy Lee was going to sing, I had Eddie Van Halen flashbacks. Also 'You're All I Need' is my favourite of theirs, so they can do ballads. Fun revüe :)

RedBedroomRecords

I would've put their self-titled album here as a Trainwreckord personally as that was the true beginning of their decline in popularity, their autobiography The Dirt certainly looks at it that way, one notable passage from the book had the band members asking some fans if they wanted to meet them for autographs in the parking lot after the show, and once they got to the parking lot they were distraught to see only a handful of people asking for their autographs compared to previous tours where they'd had dozens of fans waiting for them after the show waiting for autographs, it really showed how unpopular Corabi was with the fans and how much Grunge had taken over.

Jacqueline Sailer

If Imagine Dragons were around in 1997, this is exactly the type of music they'd be making.

RedBedroomRecords

I think Motley Crue has decent ballads, I think Without You is pretty good, Home Sweet Home isn't that great though and is admittedly amongst the weakest of the hair metal ballads, it's no "Heaven" or "Every Rose Has It's Thorn" for sure.

RedBedroomRecords

i'll gladly listen to Swine over anything those hacks ever put out.

Aaron Larson

Take a deserved break, we'll be here when you come back. Love the episode, was in college during this era and I remember just thinking the whole Crue thing was just sad and depressing. Now that I've heard more than the only video, I realize it was so much worse.

RedBedroomRecords

Eh I don't get Grunge either, to me it just seems like a bunch of whiny self-entitled brats from the suburbs whining about how much life sucks, you could only get away with that kind of whiny nonsense in the 90s, once the economy crashed most of Grunge aged liked spoiled milk, nobody wanted to hear a bunch of straight white dudes complaining about life when people were getting laid off left and right. Frankly i'll gladly take Hair metal over Grunge any day, frankly I never got what the big deal about Nirvana was(and that album cover to Nevermind always creeped me the fuck out, I don't blame that kid for suing over it one bit).

RedBedroomRecords

don't forget Genesis-Calling All Stations, Run DMC-Down with the King and Vanilla Ice-Mind Blowin Don't really think Yellow Album qualifies as novelty albums about TV shows are kind of a stretch. I don't remember Bleed Like Me flopping really.

RedBedroomRecords

Probably yeah, Saints of Los Angeles was a good album, but there's never going to be another Dr Feelgood.

RedBedroomRecords

they sort of did do that though with the Quarternary EP where each band member did a song in their own style, Tommy Lee was the one who was really into the industrial stuff(and the song he did on that EP "Planet Boom" got remade for the Pamela Anderson film Barb Wire as "Welcome to Planet Boom") so it was no surprise when he went into that direction with Methods of Mayhem after his exile from the band in the early 2000s.

Kristopher Bluth

Down With The King was actually a decently-sized hit. Their real Trainwreckord would probably be Crown Royal, Clive Davis’ attempt to do with them what he did with Santana (i.e. team them up with a bunch of guest stars who were hip with the kids). Instead, it was delayed by a year and a half, quickly fizzled upon release, and they never released another album.

RedBedroomRecords

I don't think they're all awful people, at least not Nikki, that guy had a genuinely fucked up childhood with no real chance of a normal life, so it's a miracle he's even still alive. Also felt pretty bad for Mick with his ankylosis condition that had been causing him constant pain since he was 19 (which is what drove him to drink so much)Vince and Tommy seemed to choose to be bad seemingly just for the hell of it whereas Nikki and Mick just seemingly got dealt a bad hand in life and tried to numb the pain with drugs and alcohol.

Robin Rohwoldt

Enjoy your break, dude - wouldn't like to see you burn out (I've almost been there a few times). See you when you feel refreshed!

Reena Setälä

I never really got grunge either. It was too directionless. Complaining about being bored, and numb, and depressed. They weren't generally even angry towards anything specific. At a time when every single schoolmate had at least one parent unemployed, that felt pointless. Either give actual commentary or help us forget it for a while. Plenty of acts all across genres capable of that. Grunge just wanted to wallow.

Graf von Tirol

More possible suggestions, in two categories American * The (Byrne-less) Heads - No Talking, Just Head (just be the Tom Tom Club with guest stars ffs) * Metallica and Lou Reed - Lulu (Todd alluded to it during St Anger, so it's just a matter of time) * The Cars - Door to Door (the greatest hits album brought renewed interest to their backlog after the highly successful Heartbeat City, so surely they can recapture that...) * Jefferson Airplane - Self-titled (yes, the one where they tried the proper reunion after the infamous Starship phase) * The Black Eyed Peas - The Beginning (oh god) British * Yes - Union (the tour was phenomenal, but the album was a mess) * Black Sabbath - Born Again (Spinal Tap reference) * Happy Mondays - Yes Please! (what a story the recording process was) * Supertramp - ...Famous Last Words... (the two frontmen won't record with each other) * The Moody Blues - Keys of the Kingdom (only five years removed from the MTV colossus, but diminishing returns and a televised lawsuit from the keyboardist did not help)

meffeww

I just checked it again - yes, it's from "the band was poised" until the Pam clip. Oddly, I went through that part several times now, and sometimes it sounds just fine, but if I play it from the very beginning, the audio quality changes. I don't know if it's the video's problem or a technical issue on my end.

Damian Penny

The similarities between this and "Van Halen III" - save for the original vocalist returning - are incredible. Songs written for someone else's vocal range, a weird mishmash of styles, a completely overmatched producer, the most famous non-singing member actually getting to sing an epically cringey ballad - it's all here. I really do like "Afraid," though, so that's one more good song than "VH3" had on it.

Damian Penny

I really want a Wilson Phillips Trainwreckords episode, just so Todd can examine what the heck happened between an absolute blockbuster debut and a follow-up that sank without a trace just two years apart. (And before anyone answers "Nirvana," their rise didn't affect female-led pop acts nearly as much as it cratered the eighties rock bands. Whitney, Mariah and Celine freaking *owned* the nineties.) There's a great episode to be made about Paula Abdul's "Head Over Heels," too. Literally everything that could possibly go wrong for that poor woman between 1992 and 1995 went horribly wrong.

Damian Penny

The less a hair metal band changed its sound, the better they were able to hang on a bit longer in the nineties. Firehouse, who showed up just as the party was ending, had top 40 singles as late as *1995* because they sounded exactly like their 1991 debut album. Def Leppard's "Adrenalize" was basically Hysteria 2.0 and was a much bigger album than people remember.

Calum O'Halloran

Fantastic episode, though I do heartily disagree with your dislike of the “Terry Gilliam-directed Saw” style of video. More of that forever, if you ask me.

Kristopher Bluth

So what's worse, "How Many Say I" or "Brandon"? That's a tough one...

Kristopher Bluth

Vince Neil could sing with the Residents and instantly turn them into dated cheese.

Peter Melling

Mentioning Peter Criss towards the end made me think - his solo album from ‘78 was very much a trainwreckord for him. Since Kiss arguably doesn’t have a trainwreckord, this’d be the best way to talk about the solo album project as a whole and how Peter’s album basically was his end as a contributor in the band. Also, Peter’s book is legitimately one of the most awful musician autobiographies I’ve ever read. The man has almost zero self-awareness and refuses to take any responsibility for his bullshit (even when it looks like he’s gonna do it). 10/10 would hateread again.

David Gutierrez

To anyone wondering why Wilson Phillips' "Shadows and Light" might make a good episode of Trainwreckords, check out the following articles, one from 1992 from Entertainment Weekly, not long before WP broke up, and the other from 2020 from Rolling Stone. https://ew.com/article/1992/11/27/decline-wilson-phillips/ https://www.meremart.com/Entertainment-Weekly--November-27-1992 https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-features/wilson-phillips-hold-on-bridesmaids-interview-957375/

Oisín Harrell

I watched a lot of Headbanger’s Ball as a kid – I’m probably one of the few millennials who remembers Riki Rachtman, unless he got a shit-ton of new followers from Monday Nitro – and Mötley Crüe was one of my earliest favorite bands (the other two being Skid Row and Aerosmith). My mom bought me Decade of Decadence on cassette and a VHS compilation of their music videos. The subject matter went way over my head as a four year-old, but I thought they were fucking awesome. I even went as a hair metal rocker – complete with a jean jacket vest and oversized black curly wig – to my preschool Halloween party (not entirely unlike a shrunk down John Corabi). Part of me feels an odd sense of nostalgia towards The Crüe for that reason. For a lot of people, Nevermind instantly vaporized everything that came before it. But as someone who watched MTV during that weird fucking stretch between 1989 and 1991, I think it might have given me the broad appreciation for music that’s carried into my adult years. At the same time though…this scene really needed to die. I tried watching The Decline of Western Civilization Part II a few years ago, which follows a couple of struggling L.A. bands in the oversaturated hair metal scene and contains interviews with bonafide rock stars from that time – and except for Alice Cooper and Lemmy, everyone comes off like a massive asshole in that documentary. Rock had become too comfortably Spinal Tap and something had to change. I kind of respect The Crüe for following bands like Manic Street Preachers and Pantera…but Nikki Sixx isn’t Richey Edwards and Vince Neil sure as shit isn’t Phil Anselmo. Japanese bands like Buck-Tick and Malice Mizer actually did a great job of balancing stadium glam rock with nineties darkwave, but…yeah, this sounds like ass. I hope Charlie Clouser at least got paid decently if he really did work on this. Patreon rant/reminiscence/thing over. Great work as always. Enjoy your vacation.

Octo

Only mistake I could see is using an image of "Creep" when discussing STP. "Creep" actually has the word "creep" in the lyrics

Anthony Pierre Coco

Between the glam acts going grunge and the flashy hip hop acts having to act hardcore the early 90s really are a Trainwreckords gold mine (I know this in 97 but still)

Sunny

Machina- The Smashing Pumpkins Ye- Kanye West

darkjaden825698

Take all the time you need, Todd! You deserve a break!

CB

This is fun timing because I've been listening to a lot of them recently (and I also think their ballads suck). They really struck me as the kind of band that could only exist in the exact time period they started in, outside of it they just seem like an oddity. Some awesome songs though. Have a good long break Todd and thanks for another great episode!

RedBedroomRecords

The Beginning was actually a major hit though, I think that crappy Reggaeton album they did(whose name i've totally forgotten) is far more fitting as nobody liked that one and you can feel how lifeless and soulless the band is without Fergie.

RedBedroomRecords

Born Again wasn't really a flop, I think Seventh Star is more fitting as that wasn't even meant to be a Sabbath album, it was supposed to be a Tommy Iommi solo album but the record company didn't have confidence that anyone would buy it without the Sabbath name, also maybe Dehumanizer.

RedBedroomRecords

Peter's book had some fascinating stories but it was a lot of whiny nonsense, still not as bad as Bobby Blotzer's book. I think Out of Control is a bigger Trainwreckord, Peter blamed lack of label promotion for it's failure but I think the real truth was fans just weren't interested in him as a solo artist(at least not as much as Ace). i think Music from the Elder was a Trainwreckord as that was the end of KISS leading the trends and it forced them to ditch their makeup for a while and they had to rely on their 70s songs for their 90s comeback.

RedBedroomRecords

I thought most of the bands came off as fine in that documentary and even some Hair Bands have argued that Nirvana didn't really kill off hair metal and it was already on the decline as Warrant frontman Jani Lane recounted seeing their posters in the record label building being taken down and replaced with posters of Alice in Chains so the groundwork was already being laid. Nirvana actually never wanted to be famous, they were perfectly happy being obscure and unknown and i'd argue fame is what led to Cobain's death as he never really seemed happy with his success and looked deeply uncomfortable.

RedBedroomRecords

I think they have some good ballads, especially in their much better follow-up album New Tattoo.

RedBedroomRecords

VHIII at least sounded like the original band somewhat.

CB

I'll check that out! It's not like I've listened to their entire discography, just the ones I've heard so far I wasn't impressed with so I was inclined to agree with Todd. I'm not much of a ballad guy to begin with to be fair.

Peter Melling

Ringo the 4th would make for a funny trainwreckord. Todd has been looking for an “established act does disco” video, for which this mess would be perfect. I’d probably prefer Elliot Roberts talking about it in his eventual “Ringo solo album ranking” video though. Elliot does good stuff, go check him out.

Oisín Harrell

I actually had a similar vibe with a different Trainwreckord. When Todd did his episode on Witness, I kept thinking of Get to Heaven by Everything Everything, which came out the year before and made big summery pop songs out of the geopolitical anxieties that later gave way to Brexit and Trump. It’s very doubtful that Katy Perry used Everything Everything as an inspiration for “purposeful pop” – I don’t think anyone in the States listens to them except for weird indie kids and Radiohead fans – but it’s also not impossible either.

Duke86fan

very good luck on your break.. i hope you honestly feel a lot better after this break as i love all your content and have been watching since 2012

user no. g_{64}

What gets me is the random woodworking footage spliced into the video for Afraid... I mean, I get it, what with the guy polishing the doll woman's wooden leg, but... working on a lathe is actually really relaxing, so it doesn't fit the tone, at all.

Kristopher Bluth

After giving it some thought, “Brandon” is worse than “How Many Say I”. As awful as Eddie’s song is, at least he doesn’t come off as a moron when he sings it. Tommy sounds like he just learned that the baby comes out of the mommy.

James Thomas

Its funny as a few iconic metal bands of the 80's went through low points in the 90's without their most famous lead singer. Yet unlike Iron Maiden, Judas Priest, and Black Sabbath Crue seem to be the only one who got worse once their singer returned.

RedBedroomRecords

I think Crue did get better after this album though as New Tattoo was a fine return to form and Saints of Los Angeles was their best album since Dr Feelgood.

RedBedroomRecords

Eh I think this is more listenable then "Load"(which was a "Load" alright, a Load of shit for the most part) which was WAY too fucking long for it's own good with way too much filler and too many overlong, boring and mediocre songs.

RedBedroomRecords

Very true, Hair metal bands that radically changed their sound like Dokken failed(and their reunion album Shadowlife was even worse then Generation Swine, bringing back George Lynch unfortunately did not translate into success and unlike Tommmy Lee once Lynch left he never came back, though Dokken proved they could make good music without him on albums like Erase the Slate and Lightning Strikes Again) to gain a new audience and only alienated their old fans. Christian Metal acts were the absolute worst offenders as their sellout albums sucked the most and they were put between a rock and a hard place as due to their sound being more niche they were completely at the mercy of Christian record labels, so you had once good bands like Guardian and Holy Soldier completely neutering their sound with some of the worst attempts at Grunge/Alternative on the planet, one Christian metal band Bride even tried to go Nu Metal with Fistful of Bees, which is the most hilariously awful sellout album ever, seriously if you ever want a good laugh go listen to that trainwreck on Youtube. Then there are bands that changed their sound a bit but not too much like Winger and Poison which resulted in them mostly retaining their audience. Of course sometimes hair metal bands retaining their sound does not always translate into success as Great White found out with 1992's Psycho City which had some of their best songs but only hit 107 on the top 200(though they did later have a top 40 hit with Rollin Stoned in 1999 which was pretty impressive).

RedBedroomRecords

i was like that in high school when I first heard Appetite for Destruction in the 2000s, my mind was blown.

RedBedroomRecords

Alice in Chains funnily enough started out as a Hair Metal band called Sleze, and then Alice N Chainz, their box set has some demos of their hair metal phase and you can still hear some elements on Facelift.

plusmin

Did Todd move to once a month permanently?

plusmin

We still love you! I'm just jonesin for some more TITS!

Sean Stellar

Thanks for all of your hard work, Todd. I feel unfortunate that I haven't seen your videos until just about a week ago but I've watched every one since then. Really enjoy your musical perspective and fair criticisms. I wasn't sure where to drop this suggestion but I'm sure it has probably been referenced before for Trainwreckords. I'd have to say Angelic 2 The Core by Corey Feldman. As far as derailing a music career, I'm not sure one was ever really established but it has to rank somewhere up there with one of the worst albums of all time. Lol thanks again for all of the great content.