Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

Content

/edit a couple serious errors caught already, the video might be down for a little bit, check back in 30 minutes if it's not working

Well let's see how this goes down! I'm nervous! 

As always, if you see an obvious (or even a non-obvious) screw-up please let me know. 

And on the complete opposite end of the spectrum, please vote in Song vs. Song because this is a special one for me. We have some Boomer-y dad-rock classics, Bob Seger's "Against the Wind" vs. Jackson Browne's "Running on Empty," https://www.patreon.com/posts/new-poll-running-73217707

Files

Unholy.mp4

This is "Unholy.mp4" by Todd Nathanson on Vimeo, the home for high quality videos and the people who love them.

Comments

Arun Rajkumar

It took me a long time to put my finger on it, but the song reminds me of "If I Were a Rich Man" in places.

Alina

I've gotten so used to Todd releasing episodes in the middle of the night that I'm always taken by surprise when it happens during daytime.

Zoe Nissen

Around 16:25 - should be "like *they're just pointing and laughing" !

Liddell

there's a long silent black screen at about 16:40

Lennon Riley

yeah there seems to be an entire chunk missing in the 16th minute

Zoe Nissen

Also odd moment of dead air from 16:40-16:50?

Sammy

There is a 10 second pause 16:41 - 16:51, it doesn't seem intentional. I thought it might be my connection but it doesn't seem to be

BlackJackel12

I noticed you used the wrong pronouns accidentally for Sam smith at 16:23

Zoe Nissen

RIVERDALE-CORE. Wow, this phrase is excellent.

Elizabeth Kidder

I’m really glad you did a review of this song - very rarely do I listen to a song right when it comes out, so it was nice to listen to this and then see your review. I really liked your idea of the priest in the confessional - much better story idea. And it is a shame every time I’m getting into a song, for it to end after just two minutes. That said, I do really enjoy the groove and gravitas, and the idea floated by interviews that this is for your “villain era”, ala’ Billie Eilish. Good jam to add to the Halloween soundtrack this year.

Andrew Hitzhusen

There's a blank space between 16:43-16:52. But otherwise great review

ridd.pr

From 16:41 to 16:51, there's nothing but black

MikeAtThePiano

Screen goes black for about 10 seconds at 16:41. Also at 7:30 it'd be more accurate to say 'five-part symphony'

Nicholas

There’s about 10 seconds of solid black and no audio starting at 16:41.

Haemophilus

"Nonbinaries" should be "nonbinary people" or possibly "enbies" (but some people find that one contentious)

triggthediscovery

This song gives me Take Me To Church vibes. A song with a christian concept which doesn't really have anything to do with religion, and a video which massively oversells how scandalous the actual song is.

Joshua C

16:40-16:51 is just blank space.

Eleanor Buxbaum

Interesting take! For editing purposes - there are a few seconds of blank at 16:50

Jacob Forrester

"LET. SAM. SMITH. FUCK!" Best quote from Todd in a minute

Meghan Weber

I am in the Our Flag Means Death fandom, and I've been seeing people use the lyrics to this is fan art, and had no clue where they were from. Also, sweet gay pirate rom com, somehow the dirtier scenario than that actually in the song?

Aidan Martin

Imagine being a sex worker listening to this song. I suspect it would be highly amusing

Haemophilus

Otherwise great review! I have missed your pop song reviews this year though I understand your passions are elsewhere right now (part of it is me as a Harry Styles fan........perhaps his big Music for a Sushi Restaurant video will lure you in 😅)

Christian Samples

There’s a moment about 16 minutes in where it just cuts to black before it comes back in. But otherwise pretty good video!

Haemophilus

I relistened to Take Me to Church recently. Used to love it but now it feels weirdly glum and dated? Like the pre-date to the super downbeat pop of 2017-18. Todd disliking it in 2014 at the time bummed me out but he might have been dead on with that one.

Alina

When Todd was talking about how music used to have parts, I kept wondering if he'd heard Maneskin's Coraline and what he thinks about it (I suspect he hasn't and so doesn't care). But on the Eurovision note, Todd, what do you think about Snap becoming this big global hit? This is very off-topic, but as I said on Twitter, Unholy is a perfectly competent but otherwise uninspiring pop song about sex.

Kylie

As a queer person I agree with your points. I mean in terms of blasphemous sex songs it pales in comparison to Personal Jesus, which is a song about being so good in bed your partner will worship you, and that came out THIRTY THREE years ago!

Zoe Nissen

But man, yeah, ugh, the idea of Sam as a priest hearing confessional would have made this SO much better. Is there such thing as an AU for songs like in fanfic? 'Cause I'd be so down for that version of this

triggthediscovery

Oh, I've always liked Take Me To Church. I could see it being seen as cringe in retrospect, but it's still my jam. I just thought the similarities between the two songs were interesting.

Nigel G

The thing that throws me off is ... how does the body shop fit into it? If daddy's getting hot at the body shop, is that where he's bringing this girl? Is he hanging out and distracting the mechanics with dirty stories? Is she one of the mechanics? Does the body shop have a bordello?

Alina

I assumed it was metaphor/slang for a sex club or brothel. Is it just something the song made up?

asapaints

let 👏 Sam 👏 Smith 👏 fuck 👏

MG

I think "keep your business clean" just might be a reference to copraphilia...?

ts_babyjane

can someone post the direct link for phone users? my laptop is broken and im dying to watch this.

Juhani Aho

Can't wait to watch your Top 10 Lists in December, Mark! ;)

Gemini Man

That's actually a really good comparison. Though to me the main comparison is that for both they're good examples that no matter how good every element of your song is, that doesn't necessarily mean it will come together to work at the end.

Nigel G

That makes sense. I checked urban dictionary, and this definition of body shop was added a month ago, and references this song. So maybe it's new slang?

Chromeface

With your comments about the pop song structure and how it's missing parts, I'm reminded of an old Residents album, the Commercial Album. The album consisted of 30 one minute "jingles" made to be like radio ads in the 70s; if you wanted a song for radio play, cool, you can just play a single track three times in a row and you're made. I think the claim "songs were more creative before" is similar to "kids these days." It's a gripe that's as old as the medium, and is more indicative of what the commenter is engaging with than it is about the state of things as a whole.

Reena Setälä

Good run down of the problems with this song. Connect the damn Unholy part to something. Make Sam a priest, make "daddy" outwardly religious or that he needs to feel dirty and sacrilegious to get it up. Kim's verse is complete filler and supricingly clinical considering how much Sam emphasised "daddy" being "dirty" and "not keeping clean". She couldn't even reference doing something nasty. They could have hinted at something at Kim's verse and then throw the full reveal on the bridge. There are building blocks to great song here, they just never bothered to finish it. It feels "juosten kustu" (Finnish saying "took a piss while running", established the objective but badly because you wanted to be fast. I don't know an English equivalent)

Forest 🐞

my personal opinion as a non binary trans person very much aligns with yours. it's processed in ways that very much holds it back. but it's a first in many ways and often they're not amazing. it's fine.

Will E.

as a trans fan (one of your numerous apparently lol) i do cosign that it is very disappointingly straight passing to a casual listener. i find that many songs have sorta a queer coating (whether it be the video or the artists’ own identities) but never explicitly queer in text. i do like the sound of it alot, it gives me evanescence vibes with panic subject matter. this does seem like just a worse version of lying is the most fun (etc etc).

CJ

Are there any openly asexual/aromantic pop artists out there? Because I feel sort of alienated just by so many pop songs about sex in general. Not that I hate those songs, but I feel that's a demographic that remains unrepresented.

Alina

I think that's reading too much into a generically "naughty" lyric. Which, frankly, is the problem with this song, it's too afraid to say anything actually naughty, so it leaves it all up to the listener's imagination. What naughty things are they doing at the body shop? It could be anal sex or it could be playing chess, entirely up to you!

Roguish Paladin

I don't think it's that new as much as it was less prominent in parts of society. I missed a lot when I heard this song on the radio, but when I heard "the body shop" I immediately thought of a fetish or sex club.

beneprism

I would be un-shocked if this song was originally called "Body Shop" and they decided to change the name to make it seem more transgressive.

Roguish Paladin

When you refer to Sam Smith being "a" cabaret MC, were you considering "The" MC, as in the character that Joel Grey and Alan Cumming both played and made famous in their own ways. Smith is somewhere in between the two of them in their dress and they serve a similar role here - an observer of the story who both provides and engages in pleasures of the flesh. Interpretations of Cabaret have been made which portray The MC as German society, so Smith might even be trying to represent queer society...though that might be a reach

John Seiler

"Where's the moral transgression?" Nice pun.

Will K.

"a bitch hit My BMW the other day .. im officially A sexual now" - spaceghostpurrp

Graham Smith

I’m just waiting for “ Let Sam Smith Fuck!” To shows up in the next Todd out of context compilation. Also the as far as you know reference is my favorite infrequent callback.

Alina

I'm way more in these comments today than I usually am, but I'm bored and this is something to talk about. A thought: was this song actively harmed by being out at the same time as NIcki's Super Freaky Girl? That song is basically Kim's verse. In fact, has anyone made a mash-up yet?

Justin Maceira

Here’s the problem with these “Im so dark and naughty” songs by generally clean artists: they are immediately out scandalized by even the mildest line from Nicki Minaj or Doja that’s currently on the radio. It just reeks of trying too hard to not get half way as far.

ts_babyjane

idk, the video’s got a sponsorship by Durex so i feel like its hinting at venereal disease

ts_babyjane

lol as someone who almost exclusively listens to transgender musicians these days… this song sucks it feels like the Drag Race (not just cause it has violet chacki in it) type of gayness. which, these days, feels like the top of the iceberg of queerness. maybe im being really fucking mean, but its like a rich gay people type shit. its presentable/respectable i guess is what im saying. maybe its just the illusion of aesthetics, but what i like about trans/gay art is when its saying something NEW. idk, really this song is just not my thing. Though, the “unholy” themeing feels like theyre trying to bait. they wanted to make a “Call Me By Your Name” type scandal to get attention. i dont like they dont even commit to the bit though, like, celebrate the depravity. instead they have that Carrey Underwood wrecked car with “cheater, liar” spraypainted on it condemning the dude. fuck off.

Katastrophe

"I have no idea if saying posh theater kid Sam Smith as an auto mechanic is objectively funny will be taken as saying non-binaries are bad at it". Well great news Todd, in a hilarious twist of "I have a lot of trans and nb fans" I am in fact, a non-binary person who works on cars, so I will critique this for you. Yeah it's funny. It's made funnier by the fact it seems to be a normal auto shop, which is NOT the same thing as a body shop. Auto shops generally repair to mechanical portions of cars, and body shops in cosmetics. It's not a long clip there, but there seems to be a distinct lack of specify body shop stuff in the "body shop", so it's actually an extra level of goofy. Like you DO need to be able to do some mechanical work to ex, remove bumpers, but I cannot think of any body shop use for the giant wrench Kim has even without the bling on it, and you generally wouldn't ever be that far under a car. You don't roll under a lift at all, because they raise the car all the way up to standing height. The one in the video seems to be on the kind of drive on lift you use for alignments, which would probably make it more obnoxious to access the parts of the car that would require it raised for body work. Like I've thrown a car on a lift that has arms that swing out to raise the car from the jack points under it to get a better look at the rocker panels to make sure I didn't miss a spot with the primer, and it was STILL the more obnoxious option over just using a jackstand. So yeah TL;DR, the more you know the more goofy the scene is. IDK how to explain it's like... if a music video had someone boiling water for tea in a frying pan or something. I imagine you are just picking up on the "I have no idea what I'm doing" vibes because there is a lot of that. The priest suggestion would have probably been a lot better.

Castleknackers

I heard the lyrics "she's dropping it. She be popping it" and that killed most of my interest in the song. I don't think Sam could pull off that line.

Jacqueline Sailer

Feels like anything considered asexual/aromantic is just categorized as kid's music. Would be nice for more pop to be about weirder, less obvious things, indeed.

Georgie Rowe

The "not gay enough" clip really hit home for me - that's kinda been my opinion on Sam Smith from the get go, and persists even when he's the emcee of this song (which I like well enough in the abstract).

Shiny Skunk

Eh, I don't think it hurts it. All due respect to Nicki, but that one's not one of her best, and anyway "I'm hot and this guy buys me things" is all over pop music anyway.

terrymbridges

Gotta say, though, I really like this song. I can take or leave Sam Smith, but Kim is 🔥🔥🔥even though Dr. Luke 😬😬

Lanth

I like the sound, I actually like Sam's pained singing, but the lyrics are just dumb and I can't really get past that. I wish it wasn't in English so I could enjoy it.

Duke86fan

i agree with the idea that its "not gay enough". im queer and a pervert enough to find something good in this if it actually could scare the ben shapiros of the world, but besides mentioning some stuff at a body shop there is nothing truly offensive.. i actually find more lewd shit on my public twitter than anything here (at least maybe a bondage reference or something)

Ryan Storey

It's been interesting seeing Sam Smith evolve from boring adult contempory balladeer to queer icon/sex jam dance diva. It's also nice albeit bizarre seeing Kim Petras get a legitimate hit after languishing in the underground for over half a decade. She signed to a major label a couple years ago, and it has not worked out for her so far and it's already led to her label shelving her album and not letting her put out new music. Her career has basically been in limbo for the past year and a half. I'm hoping this fluke hit with Sam Smith will be enough for Republic Records to put some more backing into Kim again and they'll finally let her release new music.

David L.

My dislike comes from an even simpler reason: Sam Smith's best asset is their silky smooth voice, and this song is so overbearingly produced that the only words I can hear are "body shop." It's a waste

Rachel

You know what would have given this song a little more of that dirty sexy vibe? Flip the genders of the married couple. "Daddy don't know Mommy's getting hot at the Body Shop, doing something unholy" plays against the stereotype of uptight suburban mom with a wandering eyed husband. A married woman being into sex clubs and having a girlfriend she blows all her husband's money on would give the song an edge it's lacking. Of course it would also play into the stereotype that bisexuals cheat more then anyone, but it would give the song SOMETHING.

Taylor Abrahamse

Surprised you got through it with no mention of Lil Nas X. Kim Petras is wildly hot to me (im certainly somewhere on the spectrum), shes about as vapid and insincere as Camilla Cabello but doesn't seem ashamed of that, or trying to hide it with overacting like Camilla. And for Kim to go through what she has just to sing about Coconuts... well, shes earned it. But yeah I can see how this is a bit of a missed opportununity, like a lazy Madonna early 90s single thats barely a song but succeeds because the press around it would carry it alone. Wheras a decade ago we could get 'Born This Way', which is an actual song plus helps the LGBT movement for being obviously about it... this is definitely a meek, nebulos cop out. This Unholy song will probably not have a lot of staying power, but it busted down a pretty inevitable door to bust and gets bragging rights of being first. PS. Kudos for the KISS at the end. And PPS. Fuck Tiktok. Please keep hating on it. Sometimes a technological advancement is just bad - tiktok is like the atom bomb of social media, smoothing any brain in its path

Ryan Storey

RE Todd's comment on the staleness of 2022 pop I think it's telling that one of the biggest hits of 2022 and the defining song of the summer was "Running Up That Hill" — a song from 1985.

Kieran

I totally agree, he suggested that and I was instantly down

Nick Ostrem

I would have paid multiple dollars to watch Todd's first listen of Slut Pop

Nick Ostrem

you know, there *was* a 2022 version of Born this Way that actually felt sacrilegious and queer in a way that this song doesn't... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ekauErew4Bs "Damned for eternity But you’re coming with me Into the afterlife"

Alice Allan

You make me laugh every time, Todd. <3

Taylor Abrahamse

Daymn, that tune is 100x better than Unholy! Odd key changes from the verse to chorus... but gotta love a bi asian cowgirl, using the same sampler as 'Bad', and face melting guitar solos

Justin V

It sounds so much like Katy Perry's Dark Horse to me I expected a tepid rap in the middle.

Call Me Kay

I’m mostly subscribed to amateur and cover artists on YouTube, and sometimes it gives me a very different idea of what a song is before I see the original. I would not have guessed this one was a Sam Smith song for sure.

ClaMaRo

I mean I don't know about everyone else but I'm always here for cranky millennial Todd! Good for Kim getting her first hit but when I first heard this song, I had no idea it was Sam Smith.

Martha Boatright

As I started listening to this with it dropping at the start of October I was initially liking the creepy vibe, good Halloween song about a guy cheating on his wife, ooh I wonder if he's going to meet a grisly ironic fate--and then Kim Petras comes in and is like "and I'm the hot chick he's cheating with! he gives me so much money lol!" and I was like, who are you, go away, you are ruining the vibe, and then it just ends on that note and blech. Of course this reaction does have something to do with me not knowing who Kim Petras was or that she was trans at the time. Now that I do it still feels like they let Katy Perry do a verse on a Weeknd song.

Reena Setälä

She already posted a Max Martin collab snippet to TikTok for reactions, so I think it's fair to say she's getting the full label push right now.

RedBedroomRecords

I actually like that song, this song is quite boring though.

Les

super agree about the song length tho. way too short

AstarothLuLz

I agree that they really missed the opportunity to play more with the "unholy" motif. Like. You bring in a choir to sing backup on a song about cheating--chiefly sung by a non-binary person and a trans woman and even call it "Unholy?" I want to see monocles hit the floor! It feels like so much of the production promises big impacts that the song itself just can't back up... Still. I guess I'd rather live in a world where "Unholy" gets noticed than not. I hope it does good things for Kim at least.

RedBedroomRecords

some people theorized this song was originally called "Body Shop" but it got changed at the last minute.

RedBedroomRecords

Really cool how you ended on the KISS song "Unholy", nice choice! Anyways the bass line in this song reminds me a lot of the one in "Thriller" personally. I agree this song is too short and half-baked to leave much of an impact and too confused with it's own narrative, yeah it's nice it's a hit but I can't help but feel like TikTok has done more harm than good music wise and I believe this song could've easily been a hit without needing TikTok. I too hate TikTok and i'm not going to waste time training the algorithm when I already have enough stuff to watch on Youtube(BTW I hate "shorts" which feels like a short-sighted and desperate attempt by Youtube to be more relevant, i'm dreading seeing more pop songs potentially getting popular due to Shorts as well).

beneprism

Unfortunately the first name that comes to mind is, uh... Morrissey.

Justin V

The other good songs also feel like remakes: Beyonce's could be Crystal Waters, Harry Styles's could be a-ha, Lizzo's could be 80s Minneapolis Funk. Nothing wrong with any of this at all, but interesting how much retroness topped the charts this year. But yeah, for anyone not used to Kate Bush's "Hounds of Love" era -- her music is going to sound like a revelation.

Rish Outfield

Is Kim singing in English? Admittedly, my Portuguese is really rusty, but I feel like my grandfather saying, "I can't understand anything The Nirvana is saying."

Keelee

I like Kim Petras but you're right, somebody getting murdered would have been a WAY better place to take this song than like. A rehash of the verses from My Humps

Martha Boatright

I mean, like Todd I like quite a bit of Katy Perry's music, so it's not a bash on Kim Petras who I know very little about, just that there is a massive tonal clash. My Humps is an even better parallel.

Keith Badje

I turned on the "hit radio station for young people" while driving one day. I heard songs riffing on Genius of Love, Super Freak, Never Gonna Give you Up, Tiny Dancer, and the Blue ripoff Todd showed in his video. And Heat Waves, like, 5 times. I might as well have just turned on the oldies station. This is at least... something? I don't think it's good, but it's better than some idiot mumbling over, I don't know, Don't Speak by No Doubt.

Maura

Mostly just a list of expensive brands you can buy her. Yawn.