Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

First off, here's the Song vs. Song poll. We're doing Mariah and Boyz II Men's "One Sweet Day" vs. Elton John's "Candle in the Wind '97." https://www.patreon.com/posts/new-poll-one-day-89146508

Secondly, please check my work. I'm back! I guess. 

Files

POP SONG REVIEW: "Rich Men North of Richmond" by Oliver Anthony Music

It's the viral sensation that's tearing apart the nation. Get Nebula using my link for 40% off an annual subscription! https://nebula.tv/todd-in-the-shadows Sign up for a lifetime membership for $300! Offer only valid until September 30, 2023. Watch Everyone Loves Guy Fieri: https://nebula.tv/videos/lindsayellis-everyone-loves-guy-fieri-now?ref=todd-in-the-shadows Support Todd on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/toddintheshadows

Comments

Micah

Not being in the US, this passed me by, and first I heard of this. While I like a broad range of music, this genre does not apply to me, nor do I ever listen to much. But from looking at just your video, you seemed to pitch your take right to me. I don't pay attention to lyrics as much as I did as a youth. Voices are another instrument primarily to me nowadays, but I like to hear your take on various hits. I find myself revisiting music I did not listen to much then and dig it more now; such is the wonder of the internet.

Sarah, the Creator

Pre-watch thoughts: this song really is lightning in a bottle. The right-wing griftosphere picked it to boost, but it was accidentally super on trend so it caught on enough organically to actually stick once the coordinated push was over. Think about it: this is Todd's second review in a row about a twangy ginger dude with a guitar lamenting small-town problems!

Andrew Behm

I haven’t heard this song “in the wild” (thanks woke liberal bubble, or deleting my Twitter!) but I’ve seen a lot of takes on it recently from YouTubers. I think your take is probably the best I’ve seen. Thanks for doing what you do, Mr. In The Shadows!

Tegan Davidson

I’ve just seen memes of this song but never actually heard the song.

CJ

Correct me if I'm wrong, but wasn't this guy an attendee of Burning Man this year? If so that lends credence to the "independent thinker" stereotype and yet also really casts this thing in a whole new light

Becca, lobster no longer!

On the bright side, we can all justifiably start calling this guy pretentious and watch some heads explode

Christina Kelley

Great vid Todd, just wanted to let you know around the 19:33 mark you say “that’s all that guy sounds to me like” when I assume you meant “that’s all that guy sounds like to me”

Keith Badje

Ugh. This song just gives me such mixed/negative feelings. I mean, it sucks. Lyrically, musically, vocally, most of what it stands for, SUCKS. But, at the same time, I don't think it was meant for mass consumption. This is supposed to be a 200 view on YouTube song, not a #1 hit song. The artist knows this and seems REALLY uncomfortable with having what I think he even knows is a homemade Mother's day card sitting in the Hallmark aisle. So, I can't help but feel some sympathy for him. I have a feeling he's going to happily disappear the second his moment is over. If he decides to try to stay in the public eye, then we know he's a grifter. Other observations: If we were to make a Venn diagram of his concerts and a Trump rally, it would be a circle. People who aren't smart but think they are really are the worst.

Quinn

I am gonna go back to my original point which is that this dude is an amateur who was found way too early in his career. The sanctimonious and judge lines in this song are a product of carelessness and a lack of rewriting more than hatred. I think the best thing for his career is to disappear for a couple years, come back after polishing his craft, and then start from there.

Eddie Faro

This is the perfect song for you to cover Todd. I love when you talk about country music because you obviously have a history with it, and its recent convergence with pop music and the political connotations of it make it so interesting to me. Love the arc.

Kim

As a fellow Virginian, when I explained this song to my husband (who attended Longwood University in Farmville) and I mentioned how Oliver Anthony is from Farmville, my husband just said, "Oh, that's sad."

Miss World

Then why is he complaining about fat people on welfare for an entire verse instead of blaming the people whose actual fault it is that his money doesn’t get far? Nobody is “blinded by ideology,” it’s just not a very good song and saying “well, I didn’t mean to say that, I meant this!” After the fact just proves his songwriting skills are lacking at best if he’s being honest. If I wrote a song complaining about how I hate dogs, then came out saying “well, idk why everyone thinks I hate dogs, what I really meant is that I like cats” people wouldn’t be wrong for thinking I hate dogs.

Miss World

He really does strike me as someone who probably does genuinely mean well and didn’t set out to hurt anyone, but the read that he’s someone who thinks he has it all figured out when really he knows very little is spot on. Not to sound like an elitist but he reminds me of everyone I know who slept through high school, dropped out, and now thinks they’re smarter than everyone else in the world.

Tom Carter

The vibe I get is that this guy wants to be this generation’s Bob Dylan. They’re both rootsy artists who made songs that talked about the ills of the day, all while using their impassioned lyrics and stories to hide the fact that they’re not very good singers. Difference is, Bob Dylan put a lot more thought into his songs, and you could at least tell what he stood for and what he was trying to say. This guy seems to have an idea of what he wants, but it comes off clunkier and like it needed a few more rewrites before being released into the world.

Alice Allan

Funny & thought-provoking as always, Todd. I'll never get over how much work is in these videos.

Jake the Accountant

For me it evokes those old Pete Seeger folk songs but with none of the class consciousness, just bitter culture war stuff. And you're totally right, its incredibly preachy and that's a big part of why it doesn't work as music.

Bill Staley

Because thanks to good intentions gone wrong the system allows it. Up until the '90s you were given "Food Stamps" that only allowed necessary items to be purchased. Items like Cereal, Milk, Veggies, Meat, a limited selection of snacks and health-related items. It was based on "needs" not "Price or Wants". However, lobbyists from the food industry didn't like the limitations. Secondly, if you have never been to the store and seen someone buying a buggy full of junk food while holding the latest iPhone then buying beer, cigarettes, or lotto tickets with their own money after you have blinders on. You and Todd also need to put that Lyric into the context of the verse before and after. He says "We got folks in the street, ain’t got nothin’ to eat And the obese milkin’ welfare" he isn't complaining or wanting to end welfare, just about those who abuse it. The following line is "Young men are puttin’ themselves six feet in the ground" meaning while some people are milking welfare others are working themselves to death trying to stay off of it. The welfare system should be a safety net for those who need help to get through a rough time. Not a hammock for people to spend a lifetime and even generations on. Yet, due to Newspeak and Doublespeak, any attempt to fix the broken system is labeled as "Racist" yet far more whites are on welfare than all other groups combined. Condemned as trying to take money from the poor to give tax breaks to the Rich, yet it's the Rich Men who are making extremely high profits on Junk food sales. It's the same with most problems in our nation. We are so divided that even Common-sense solutions are labeled as partisan. The Rich and the politicians in their pockets (99% of politicians) want the nation divided because they can manipulate them more easily. I'm a Libertarian, I dislike both sides because they are the same. As long as people see things as "Us vs. Them" things will only get worse. Follow the money, who will financially benefit from not solving the problem?

Bill Staley

If you listen to any of his interviews he admits he barely knows how to play guitar, isn't a good singer, and knows nothing about songwriting. He was just a man tired of seeing problems never being fixed and with a ton of passion wrote a song about how he was feeling. What Todd ignored was that Passion, this was his "I'm mad as hell and not going to take it anymore" moment. People on both sides who have their eyes open can as that.

Jacob Roth

Passionately confused maybe

Paggy

I think you hit the nail on the head with the last part. This is no genius. I would keep in mind that he had zero audience when he wrote this on his song. This isn’t the new Olivia Rodrigo album that everyone has been anticipating. There isn’t even a chorus! He probably thought his 30 friends that would hear it would know exactly what he meant. Minor Threat complained about the same thing when “Guilty of being White” became a anthem for those guys with more than brains.

Nick Sestanovich

Well, there goes my streak of trying to ignore this song. At least I'm doing pretty good on the "not listening to 'Try That in a Small Town'" streak.

Graham Smith

Not going to lie I kind of missed everything after seeing the picture of Amydog in a casino which was exactly what I needed in my life right now.

Erik Danielson

I love when we get new pieces of Todd lore! I had no idea you used to be a history teacher, Todd. As for the song itself, I do think Anthony is well intentioned, even if people have dug up some pretty questionable videos that he’s shared on his Youtube, I just think he was more or less shoved into the limelight with this song. As somebody else stated, he’s admitted he’s not a very good singer or songwriter, and it does kind of show in Rich Men. I even get what he was trying to say with the now infamous Fudge Rounds line, but I think he just missed the mark. IMO, it’s a textbook definition of “good idea, bad execution”. I *will* say I’d take a million more Oliver Anthony songs than another Try That In A Small Town.

Keith Badje

Libertarians are the definition of dumb people who think they're smart. But, in any case... physical food stamps ended because they were too easy to trade for liquor and drugs. Not that you can't still do it, but it's a lot harder with the current system. And how libertarian is it really to micromanage the shopping carts of those less well off than you? If we were to actually try to what many (on both the left and right) want done in regards to food benefits, and remove anything that could possibly be objectionable to someone from purchase, recipients of TANF would literally not be able to purchase anything but maybe dried beans and rice (except in Kansas, where they tried to restrict THAT about a decade ago). I grew up in a food stamp budget level household, so it's a topic that rubs me raw. Most decisions at that level are made using about three factors, those being "Is it cheap? Is it filling? And (probably most importantly) does it keep?" It's not something that sets you up for a lifetime of healthy choices.

Henry Kiley

All I hear when I hear this song is a musical version of a TJ Kirk video, right down to the fat-shaming and male suicide statistics. It's "enlightened centrist" faux-intellectualism from an obnoxious white guy who thinks he's smarter than everyone else in the room. It's truly one of the most unpleasant things I've had to listen to all year.

Lindsay Ellis

I've been waiting for this since the moment I learned of this song's existence

Rick Griffin

I'd be slightly inclined to be a little more charitable to him, for the last reason you gave--in the environment he grew up in this IS progressive. That doesn't actually mean it's well-articulated, especially since the line about welfare is all-too-easy to read as the fault of the person who is fat. Why else point out the fact that they're fat so hard in that line when it seemed like he was going to lean on the fact they're destitute? Why not suggest they were made this way by those who are supposed to be the subject of the song? I can get why he thought he WAS doing that, but that's like a really, really basic writing mistake--assuming the people who are listening to you already understand exactly where you're coming from with what you're saying without you having to say it. Being able to grasp the cultural zeitgeist enough to assume something without saying it takes a significant amount of cultural awareness. So I wouldn't say that he's dumb so much as he's actually Not Online enough to grasp why this off-the-cuff set of lyrics is going to ring hollow.

Matt Stevens

I'm just happy you're promoting Lindsay Ellis videos, that's good ex-boyfriend behavior we would all like to emulate.

Doctor Starky

"FYI the majority of both the top 1% and the corporate elite support the DNC. " I'm curious where you got this information. It's also important to remember that there is a lot differing levels of wealth and influence even within that top one percent. There also a lot of rich people who don't just donate to one party.

Bill Staley

Pew Research and Open Secret neither of which can be called biased to either party. You also have to remember, many of the top 1% are tech billionaires who compete to see who can be be the biggest mega-donors. Now to be fair, while corporations with over 1000 employees did give in a higher percentage to the DNC, PACs gave more to the RNC. While the average donation is under $100. They don't buy votes. People like Soros who gave 178 million do. In fact, he gave more than the top two RNC donors combined. Money runs policies. Doesn't matter which party. My point is both sides are evil. I honestly believe most politicians get into it to make a difference. But once on the inside the system corrupts them. Especially in the House where they have to start running again the day after they are elected. I just want people to see it doesn't matter which party you vote for, THEY DON'T CARE ABOUT YOU!

Bill Staley

Well, I could counter with people who think Libertarians are stupid are incapable of independent thought. 😁 However, I want to keep this an exchange of ideas not insults so ignore the opening comment. Most Libertarians are ex-DNC or RNC supporters who opened their eyes to the corruption and hypocrisy of the party they supported for years. It's more of a catch-all for us, which is why we debate each other far more than other party members. I left the RNC after the miss-named Patriot Act (which Biden was a major part of) and it's massive destruction of personal freedoms. As for food stamps, the real problem most should agree with is those who never attempt to get off of them. Like most problems, it's the Government that has created the problem. I believe that is what the song is addressing. Finally, being a musician I've known plenty of people who have the EBT card that sell them for drugs or alcohol.

Zachary Makroy

Personally, I love that Amydog is allowed in the casino.

Kristopher Bluth

I love ya, Todd, but I'm not even sure I want to click on this. Isn't it funny how often people who loudly proclaim that they're centrists or that they don't even support Trump then turn around and parrot every right-wing talking point they can find? Anthony came running every time Fox News waved a microphone and I'm sure he had to know who was buying his song. Too late to return your thirty pieces of silver, dude.

RedBedroomRecords

I thought it was hilarious that this guy basically told the GOP to go fuck themselves after they played this song during the debate

RedBedroomRecords

my dad listens to country a lot but i've never heard this song on a single radio stations(or that "small town" song thankfully).

RedBedroomRecords

eh it's not nowhere near as awful as that "small town" song.

RedBedroomRecords

I wouldn't worry, this guy basically told the GOP to fuck off after they used this song in the RNC debates saying that they were exactly the kind of people he was criticizing in that song, so that definitely increased my respect for him. Anthony does not strike me as right-wing so much as one of those enlightened centrist types who think they have it all figured out.

RedBedroomRecords

interesting video, though i'm not so sure the "Six feet in the ground" bit actually is referencing male suicides, I think it might potentially be referring to young men putting themselves in the ground from having to work so hard because of how bad the job situation is where he lives, with how direct he was with the "fudge founds" and "minors on an island" bits I don't think he's being anti-feminist there as he's not that subtle or clever, and i think he's referencing young men specifically because in poverty stricken areas in the south there's a lot of young pregnant women stuck at home taking care of kids and themselves.

plusmin

Any guitarists in here hating the way that guy plays his G chord?

Jonathan P

I made it until a few days ago, no thanks to some random video on twitter that was using it as background music.

notadocmartin

As a person who went to college in Lynchburg (NOT THERE) and now lives in Richmond, I knew you were from around here and was wondering what you were going to think of this one. FWIW, I think it's similarly insufferable, but I wonder how much of the anti-welfare-queen nonsense can be attributed to "dude who has started thinking about the typical views where he grew up but isn't quite at self-actualization yet." I've known a few of those.

Obsidian Sims

this one was a banger but i freaked out a little (in a good way) when i saw the exact roads i have to drive on to get anywhere

Russet Burbank

"Six feet in the ground" is a specific reference to burial though.

Min Summers

That thumbnail pic looks exactly like the country singer cat meme

big bird

none of this crop of "righteously angry" country songs packs anywhere near as much catharsis as even the mildest of folk punk - which I know is not for everyone, but definitely *is* for those who want to listen to people on acoustic guitars scream-singing at the system. to make the world's most deranged comparison: what is the point of this guy when the likes of Pat the Bunny is right there?

MG

We've all got to make a living.

Lanth

Finally mustered up the courage to watch this. Great video and analysis as usual, of course. It really annoys me that this song takes such a blatent left turn in the second verse, because I really like the tune and chorus; it scratches my mornful bluegrass itch quite well. If only it was in a language I couldn't understand.