Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

First off, guys, before I say anything, I need you to do to something for me. I need you to go to the Song vs. Song Patreon and go vote on our Christmas episode, where we’re doing “Santa Tell Me” vs. “Underneath the Tree.” Thank you. https://www.patreon.com/posts/new-poll-santa-93464774

Anyway. So you guys may or may not know by now, but I just released my most successful video ever. I hadn't yet put it up in here, because it’s so out of my wheelhouse. (I am working on the worst list, for the record.) You guys have been pretty understanding in general, and I did a lot of work on that video so I’m going to go ahead and charge for it. I didn’t give you guys 24 hours exclusive access like I do for my normal episodes, so if you guys think that’s out of line or you don’t feel like a video like this is something you want to pay for, I understand – please message me, and I’ll make sure you don’t get charged. To give you guys something worth your buck, though, I thought I’d share some thoughts about where my head has been at these past 12 months. I’m not sure where to start with this one, so I may as well bring it around back to where it all started: Anakin Skywalker.

Anakin Skywalker doesn’t like sand. It’s coarse, and rough, and irritating, and it gets everywhere. Also, he is haunted by the kiss that you should never have given him. His heart is beating, hoping that kiss will not become a scar. You are in his very soul, tormenting him. I have watched these scenes over and over and just laughed and laughed my ass off, but I feel like this is mostly the fault of George Lucas, an infamously bad writer of dialogue and director of actors. I don’t blame Hayden Christensen, who I think is a good actor who got ruined by Lucas and never got his real shot. I know he’s a good actor because he gave one of my favorite performances ever, as the sniveling fraud in 2003’s Shattered Glass.

I don’t think Shattered Glass was what made me want to be a reporter. I got into journalism because I had to major in something, and that was the only real path for someone who could write, but couldn’t write fiction. I can say, though, that Shattered Glass left a huge mark on my psyche. I loved that movie. I’ve watched it many times over the course of my life, including the past couple weeks. In college, and afterwards, I ended up reading all I could about Stephen Glass, the real guy it’s about, and I did my senior thesis about him. It’s one of my favorite movies – favorite stories – ever.

If you don’t know, Stephen Glass was a star reporter in the late ‘90s for venerable political mag The New Republic. (In my journalism classes I learned to write phrases like “venerable political mag.”) Glass wrote wild, offbeat articles, about topics like political novelty conventions that sold Monica Lewinsky condoms, or Wall Street workers who revered Federal Reserve chairman Alan Greenspan like he was Springsteen. It turns out that these stories were all fake; he invented them, completely.  Adam Penenberg, a writer for Forbes's online magazine, pulled the thread on just a single story of his and it all came crashing down.

Anyway, they made a movie about it, and it’s fantastic (if you like dry films about serious people talking seriously in office buildings, at least). For some reason it inspired me more than All the President’s Men or, later, Spotlight, movies where our heroic newspapermen uncover great horrible crimes. I guess you could call Shattered Glass an underdog story – the highly respected institution The New Republic, “the in-flight magazine of Air Force One,” KO’d by an Internet reporter back when online news was a joke – but embarrassing a snobby periodical is hardly toppling governments or changing the world. Penenberg himself largely disappears from the movie around the halfway point. And yet, there was something to it, something primal – not a story of reporter vs. power, but reporter vs. reporter. Mirror match, Link vs. Dark Link. The good journalist vs. the bad journalist. Truth vs. lies. Why, this was a story about the importance of journalism itself. At one point Penenberg exhaustively lists all the sources he researched trying to get to the truth, and it made me proud to be a reporter. This was a real job; this was hard, honest work I was doing.

Eventually I realized that reporting pays dick, and I wound up making jokes about Justin Bieber’s haircut on the Internet for a living instead (for a lot more money than I did when I was serving the public interest). I’m a successful critic but I’ve never considered myself a very good one – it’s never come easy to me, it’s just a job I fell into. As I write this, I’ve been trying to finish this one Nickelback episode for three months and I can’t seem to get it done (addendum: I finally finished it a couple weeks ago and I think it came out well). Focusing on work just seems harder and harder these days, and it doesn’t help that around this time last year, I had less time to focus on work, because I met someone. His name was James.

In December 2022, two of my friends (Princess Weekes and Maggie Mae Fish), got into a minor argument on Twitter with someone over the hiring practices of our sponsor/platform Nebula. That person was James Somerton, a YouTuber who had been trying to join. Both of them were very angry about his baseless accusations; I was talking about it with them, and as I go through my texts now, I see that I wrote “oh is this the plagiarist guy.” So I must have already heard about him, and the fact that there were some free-floating plagiarism accusations against him; I don’t remember when or for what though, I didn’t know anything about him and I instinctively tune out YouTuber drama. Not my business.

Other people do care about YouTuber drama though. I think it was this little flare-up that brought Somerton, and his minor controversies, to the attention of Harry “HBomberguy” Brewis. I also don’t remember when or from who I heard that HBomberguy was planning to make them his next video (I’ve met and spoken to Harry a few times but we’re not close). But I do remember thinking it was a bad look, and not a good idea. My guiding principle is that drama is bad; I’ve seen so many people caught up in an Internet firestorm who were bombarded with harassment and trolls, and the thought made me ill, even when it happened to genuinely awful people. So I didn’t think exposing other YouTubers to that was a good idea, especially when it’s a giant like Harry vs. some loser I’d never heard of. But it wasn’t really my business.

But I’m skipping ahead (maybe). One event I can definitively place in the timeline happened in January, when I heard some murmurings on Twitter about Somerton again. Somerton, who had complained that Nebula had no queer content (extremely not true), had made a video called “Why Bad Gays Are Good” that was making people upset. Curiosity got the better of me, so for the first time I watched one of his videos. It was dogshit – incoherent, thesis-less rambling, just rancid stuff – but towards the end of the video he made a truly shocking argument: all the cool gays had died during the AIDS crisis, and the unfuckable losers who remained had led the gay rights movement towards sellout assimilationist goals like marriage and military service. This was both wildly offensive and completely historically inaccurate, and I was so shocked that I broke my usual no-drama reserve and subtweeted about it. I mean, this was the guy who was arguing that Nebula should hire him so that he could make “exclusively queer content” for them! Imagine the firestorm if Nebula had hyped up their “queer content” and then published this! But I got some pushback. In response to my tweet, some of his fans got on me, and they were clearly twisting what he had very clearly said to make it sound okay. What had he done to deserve this devotion? I got curious again.

I vaguely remembered hearing someone complain about one of his other videos, that it had lacked historical rigor or something like that. I found it and left it on in the background while I websurfed; it was called “The Gay Image Body Crisis.” I didn’t necessarily like it, I was only half-paying attention to it, but it was clearly a lot better written and structured, and it included some heartbreaking personal stuff about growing up a fat kid in a world (especially a gay world) that looked down on fat people. I could see now why he had an audience; he knew how to dress and light a set, he could structure an argument, most importantly he knew how to deliver lines into a mic in an authoritative tone. I did have some issues with it, like a rambling segment about the definition of fascism that seemed unnecessary, plus there was a lot of historical stuff that didn’t have citation or seem backed up by anything, especially a part about how Nazis had invented our current standards of body fitness. By this point, talk amongst my colleagues about Somerton’s plagiarism was starting to come up more frequently, and I was curious if this one had any allegations against it, so I did some Googling about what people had said about this one video. I found a single comment on Reddit that called the entire thing bad history, which backed up my suspicion that Somerton’s conclusions were a little stretched. But it didn’t strike me as outrageously so… not until I read the part about how, counter to the claims in the video, Ernst Rohm’s murder had nothing to do with him being fat. That troubled me. I’m not up on my Nazi history, I had never even heard of Ernst Rohm, but doing just some cursory reading, I realized there was no way that Rohm was killed for being fat. The rest of the video may have had “truthiness” vibes, yeah, some unsourced analysis, sure, but this… this was something else. It was even worse than his dumb claim about who died of AIDS, which was just a wrong conclusion extrapolated from a snarky Fran Lebowitz quote. Here, Somerton had shared a fun factoid that was completely fabricated. I went back and thought harder about what I’d just watched. Did he really say poor people got fat during the Great Depression? Did he say that the Soviets weren’t attractive because they were always wearing heavy coats? What? Come to think of it, his personal stories about his weight problems also seemed wildly exaggerated for sympathy; he claimed he couldn’t even buy XXXL button-up shirts. He didn’t at all look that fat. Who the hell was this guy?

This was all concerning, but it wasn’t half as concerning as the next thing I discovered. I mentioned this story to a friend, and she told me she had spotted a different fact in one of his videos that seemed made up. In his video about the history of gay adult film, Somerton claimed that gay porn studio BelAmi had invented Skype. I thought I was hearing things. Surely, he just meant that pornography in general had influenced streaming technology in general, or maybe that’s what he had meant to say and misremembered it or fudged a detail or something. But no, it wasn’t a misspeak. He was very clear and detailed about this: He had a whole full segment that porn – specifically gay porn – had literally invented dozens of web innovations, climaxing with how this specific porn studio had created this specific branded technology. “What a weird thing to say!” I texted back. “What an incredibly weird thing to say!!!” Who just says something like that??

At that point I was off to the races. Something about the sheer inanity of “Gay porn invented Skype” set something off in my brain. I wanted to watch everything he had ever made. In February, I watched another video, and he claimed that England had had a homophobic propaganda campaign against Italian tourism. What? When?? I clicked another random video and he said China was faking its box office and announcing it only in English to taunt the West. What? What?? (I was saying “What?” a lot at this point.) I wouldn’t have caught either of these shady claims if I wasn’t looking for them (in both cases, my brain didn’t flag them until long after I’d finished watching). Where were these supposed facts coming from??  My brain went into “Gotta catch ‘em all” mode with his weird facts; I had to get 100% completion. This wasn’t me being offended, or crusading for truth or anything; it was me laughing about what a bald-faced liar he was. What insane thing might he say next???

My amusement with the situation didn’t override my objections to attacking another YouTuber, though, and the other YouTubers I talked to about it can attest that I was pretty conflicted about what Harry was planning to do – and for that matter, conflicted about what I was doing, hate-watching all his videos. Sure, I was beyond amused by the buckwild things this guy would say, but I didn’t enjoy how much I enjoyed it, it felt trollish. He was just some YouTuber, a nobody, not a real writer or anything. Even though at this point all I was doing was laughing at him in private, I felt mean-spirited, like I was a bully punching down on him (never mind that he made more than me on Patreon and he had 300,000 subscribers, a lot more than some of my friends). On the other hand, this certainly wasn’t wasted time; I was learning so much, both from the stuff he had stolen and stuff I had researched just to debunk him. I can legitimately say that my understanding of homosexuality and culture was expanded and deepened by watching James Somerton’s videos, even though by this point I was aware that he had plagiarized much more than I’d realized. After a point you began to spot it very easily. You could Google random phrases you liked and they’d come up. If he ever quoted anybody, that was a good sign that that segment was plagiarized -- he was too lazy to find his own quotes, he just stole from people who had found quotes.  As I recall, the initial accusation against him was that he’d plagiarized the documentary The Celluloid Closet, but he’d deleted that one, and then, while I was browsing his back catalog, he released a new version of it that promised to be longer and more detailed. I found a copy of the original book version of The Celluloid Closet online, and boy oh boy, in the twist of the fucking century, he had just read the first forty pages or so into the camera and passed it off as his own. It was garbage.

But I wasn’t really looking for plagiarism, which honestly I didn’t really care about, certainly not to the extent that Harry did. Harry’s personal bugbear was plagiarism; mine was misinformation. I quietly started asking people on Reddit how the Chinese box office worked and if there could be any fraud involved. I kept looking for more bullshit. Not all his videos turned up anything and I wasn’t expecting much when I clicked on a video about the Scarlet Witch’s children, which I assumed would be just a dull comic book recap. I had become able to pick out Somerton Originals very easily by that point, and oh, how I perked the fuck up when I saw him spin a very dubious story about Marvel writer Allan Heinberg doing a PR campaign against his bosses because they wouldn’t let him write gay characters. I eventually amassed a bulletproof case debunking it, a process that took me weeks. By this point, my amusement at his bullshit had started to turn back into genuine offense and anger.  He was actively defaming people at this point, and it thrilled me to find proof that he was lying. I had found my Stephen Glass. And yet, I was still resistant to thinking about this guy as fair game. So then what was I going to do with all this information I was acquiring?

I don’t know why I did this much worrying. In Shattered Glass (which I revisited about two or three more times over the course of last year), Penenberg doesn’t worry about the ugliness of calling out a fellow reporter. He doesn’t fret with guilt over the harm he’ll do Glass’s career; it’s not like Glass is owed his job, especially after ethical lapses this severe. Penenberg isn’t even outraged at Glass’s crimes against The Truth™; he just found a juicy story and he was excited to share it. So why should I be worried about Somerton’s well-being? Besides, I didn’t have any control over Harry, who was going to be doing all the heavy lifting here anyway, not me. By that point, a lot of people knew about Harry’s impending video and behind-the-scenes chatter about Somerton was starting to really simmer. In April, Somerton started crying on a livestream that his Patreon income had suddenly plummeted to about half of his usual and he might have to quit making videos; my colleague Dan Olson publicly accused him of lying (and privately, so did I – I know how Patreon works, there’s no way this could be true). Over the course of the next year, I would find out that many YouTubers, including some I didn’t even know, had beef with him. If nothing else, Somerton was a way into being part of the YouTube community again; I had stopped feeling like a part of it a long time ago.

Around May or June, I decided that I would probably say something when Harry released his video, in a Twitter thread, or something. The Marvel thing was keeping me up at night, and I knew that Harry was probably not going to cover it, and I figured someone had to tell everyone it wasn't true. And honestly, I had to write something about it, for the simple reason that I was burnt out as hell. In 2022 I had made some of my finest work (if I may say so), and I felt like I’d peaked. I found it harder and harder to keep up the pace, and I felt hemmed in by talking about just music for as long as I have. In between episodes, most of my productive energy was spent researching Somerton, not music. I wanted to try something new. I’m making enough money now that I can follow my fancies where they take me, and I needed inspiration; if I had enthusiasm for something, I had to follow it. (This also led me to compile a playlist of songs that “Stop” on the word stop to listen to on a roadtrip later that summer. I got so engrossed in it that I drove for 14 hours one day, and when I got home I spent the next week compiling it into a half-hour long supercut. I had to follow my muse. I swear, I Really Wanted To Make A “Trainwreckord " But This Is Literally The Way The Wind Blew Me This Time.)

Eventually, I just decided to fight past my aversion to drama. I wanted to cover this if Harry wasn't going to. I asked HBomberguy if if he was going to cover Somerton’s… imaginative inventions (and, honestly, to see if he objected to me horning in on his idea – who’s the real plagiarist here, Todd?) He seemed okay with it (though part of me still fears that I ripped him off). I started speed-racing through Somerton’s episodes, trying to watch them all before Harry released his video in July (which is what I had been told was the target date – lol). By the end of July I realized that I had way more information than would fit in a Twitter thread, and I started considering releasing it as a podcast or something. Maybe even a video. In August, I sat down, wrote out everything I had found, recorded it. I spent two and editing it, and then I put it up privately on my YouTube. And then I saw Taylor Swift at Sofi Stadium that night. Then I went on summer vacation the next day. The video would sit there unseen for the next six months. I wasn’t sure I was going to publish it, but I figured that once Harry finished his video (which I believed would probably be within the next couple weeks or so – again, lol), I could see what he had made and decide if I wanted to show mine.

In the final video you see above, I say that I had it 95% done in August, but that’s not really true. As Harry continued to not put out his video for the next five months (look, I get it, the man’s a perfectionist), I continued to make rewrites, tweaks, edits. I asked a historian about pirates and rewrote that section based on what he told me, I consulted with actual lawyers to confirm some things, I made my line deliveries stronger. I still didn’t feel good about releasing it until I thought about it harder and wrote what I thought was a really strong conclusion. In hindsight, I could have made it less dry, or done it on camera, if I’d known I had plenty of time, but in truth, I wanted to be Mr. Just the Facts on this. It made me feel better about doing a callout, which I still had misgivings about – even though by that point, having watched all Somerton’s videos, I had really started to loathe the man.

James Somerton wasn’t just a thief and a liar; he was a fucking idiot. He’d make screamingly insulting arguments, like how the current gay leadership were a bunch of complacent pussies and that’s why homophobia and transphobia were on the rise – never mind that it was actually a backlash to the growing visibility and power of trans people, what an insulting thing to say to anyone brave enough to be trans right now. He was a truly terrible media analyst: He thought the emcee in Cabaret was a Nazi (he’s not), he thought Glass Onion was “camp” (it isn’t – and don’t fucking argue with me on this), he disliked Forrest Gump because of its “seeming refusal to acknowledge how much luck Forrest has for being in the right place in the right time” (what the fuck do you think the movie is about, you dipshit? The central metaphor is a feather floating in the wind. The most famous quote is that life is a box of chocolates because you never what you’re gonna get. You fucking shit-for-brains.)  He had a whole thing (in more than one video) about how Janelle Monae came out of the closet because everyone was too stupid to know that “Pynk” was a queer anthem and Janelle felt compelled to clarify it for the dumb straights. Bullshit, there was tons of coverage about how gay it was, and Janelle had rumors about her sexuality as early as her first album – her coming-out article mentioned those rumors explicitly, and certainly didn’t mention anything about dense heteros not getting it. He argued that Dua Lipa had stolen credit for the disco revival from Janelle, as if the two of them sound anything alike or that disco hadn’t already been an ever-present undercurrent in music long before Janelle. I decided against including these in my video, since misinterpreting media is not a crime (although the Janelle thing was bad enough that I eventually re-added it). But it sure made me despise him.

Worst of all was that while I was fact-checking him, I’d find comments from people just straightforwardly repeating his fictions as facts. That did a lot to get me past my instinctual fear of drama. How dare you. How fucking dare you. You lied to your fans and now they’re repeating you. Look what you did, you little jerk. In October, I had a nagging feeling I’d missed something big in the whole Nazis-invented-abs claim so I did another search, and I found his bullshit claims being repeated on Deray McKesson’s fucking podcast just the previous week. I hit the roof. This dumbass was Inception-ing his stupid terrible ideas into the world, using the credibility he got by stealing the work of honest writers. I rewrote the entire intro of my video to include it. I also continued to hate-watch his videos as he released them and add new bullshit. Literally the day before it went live, my friend and resident vampire expert Elisa got back to me that she finally had time to watch that vampire video he'd just made, and I was just stunned at how much she found that I'd missed; I added one last entry at the last second. Those newer segments, the ones I wrote and recorded after August, sound much more agitated and angry than the ones I wrote before.

Still, I knew the consequences for him would probably be dire. His channel would die. He would effectively lose his job, not an easy thing to do to a person. Plus, there was a strong undercurrent of loneliness and sadness in his videos – sometimes outright text rather than subtext – and I couldn’t help but feel for him. I myself am also a weird loner isolated by this terrible career, so I sympathized. I started to get nervous again. I had mentioned my little side (?) project to everyone I knew on the East Coast while I was on vacation; many of them were surprised that I’d want to wade into drama, which isn’t like me.

D-day approached. Kat (Harry’s producer) told me the video was almost done. In the late morning hours of December 3, 2023, they sent me a link; I was only halfway through it when it went live. I saw why Harry had taken so long. I think that he too was worried about the optics of a beatdown by someone of his stature, so he had covered all his bases proving that Somerton was truly one of the lowest of the low, one of the scummiest and worst YouTubers who had ever existed on the platform. I am probably the second-foremost expert on James Somerton at this point, but there was so much I didn’t know. I didn’t know about James preparing to throw his cowriter under the bus. The plagiarism was genuinely so much worse than I had realized (and I had realized quite a lot). I didn’t know that shit about his beef with the “Love, Simon” writer. I’d been worried about this guy’s well-being? I couldn’t wait for this motherfucker to be destroyed, and from what I could tell watching Harry’s video, he absolutely would be. This was a fucking homicide. Somerton’s career would be laid waste by the end of the day. He also mentioned a Discord server, which I actually had known about but not used as a resource for my video – I was curious about the fallout of Harry's video so I snuck in there to observe; but I also started digging around in the backlogs and I found the part where Nick admitted the fat Nazis claim was based on “raw observation.” I’ve never been angrier. I had read so much trying to be sure that I wasn’t wrong about it, trying to be sure that I wasn’t falsely accusing them, and this motherfucker was just straight up admitting that he had made it up. No, I’m sorry, he had “observed” it as if you can just look at changing beauty standards and decide that the Nazis must have done it. My fucking God, fuck you.

Harry and Kat had asked me to wait a couple days before I published my video; they were concerned it would look like I had set this up with him, or that we were teaming up to bully him. After 24 hours, I asked them again how long it would be before they were comfortable and I wasn’t stepping on his toes; Harry and Kat said you know what, go for it. I dropped the second nuke.

I had promised myself I wouldn’t gloat about this, that I would remain professional so as not to feel scummy. I did not keep that promise. This was the funniest goddamn thing that had ever happened. HBomb’s video had so thoroughly destroyed Somerton’s reputation overnight that there was now a massive market for James Somerton content, and the views for my video skyrocketed. This was the biggest video I had ever made in my life. It’s a shame I don’t do drama content, because it turns out I’m very good at it. My video isn’t as slick or as sharp as Harry’s but I did do more work than it might seem. I deliberately started with “Gay porn invented Skype” to start off with something fucking ridiculous, and I dropped his most offensive lie – that the SS was dominated by gay men – early, around twenty minutes in. It’s like a roller coaster; you start with the biggest drop early so that the momentum carries you through the rest of the ride (with more drops later, like a lie that the Nazis invented abs, to keep the thrills coming). It clearly worked; for the next three hours, my mentions were flooded with the same three jokes: "Todd with the steel chair!!," "A second video essay has hit the James Somerton," and "Stop Stop He's Already Dead!!" The most anit-callout friend I have texted me to tell me that I had done a good and necessary job, which put my mind at ease a lot. Obviously this wouldn't have happened if Harry hadn't opened this lane for me to walk through, but I had been convinced that my basic, barebones video would pale compare to Harry’s. I joked with a friend that it would get maybe ten views. As I write this, it just hit a million.

And that brings me to right now, typing this to you. What happens now? I guess I go back to working on the worst list. I’ve been able to be successful for as long as I have been on YouTube by staying in my lane – not for the audience’s sake, but for my own sake. Structure helps me focus. Will I ever do a video about this again? Almost certainly not. For one thing, I still can’t help but feel guilty; Somerton as a person is too pitiful to feel good about his downfall, and even though I regard Nick as a willful dolt and a pathetic Renfield of a human being, I worry that I was too harsh on him. I do believe James probably did more of the lying than Nick. I’ve gotten a lot of comments from people who were shocked that I did this, since I’m so averse to drama. (I am in fact so averse to drama that it bothers me that people know my business well enough to know that I am averse to drama.)

But also, here’s the thing: Where on Earth are you gonna find another James Somerton? He fell in my lap, Harry found him first, and there is almost no one who is going to either 1) plagiarize that fucking much or 2) present such insane whoppers as facts. Here’s the thing about Somerton; he’s wildly entertaining. What gets me is that there are probably dozens or hundreds more guys like him, who are systematic plagiarists but not so much so that it would be worth the effort of exposing them, or people who spread as much or (most likely) more misinformation but not misinformation so wildly, hilariously afield from reality – in other words, people you wouldn’t watch a four-hour video about.

I asked a movie critic friend to review Shattered Glass some 15 years ago (the review, like so many things, is also gone from the Internet). My friend liked it a lot, but he said that to him the conflict in the movie wasn’t between truth and lies, but between journalism and entertainment. He thought journalism hadn’t done enough philosophically to confront the fact that journalism basically is entertainment, that so many of the things that make good news are the same as the things that make good advertising. If I found another guy like Somerton who wasn’t as funny, would it even be worth it to me to expose him? My critic friend also said that Shattered Glass was good but couldn’t quite be great, because Stephen Glass’s victims were all abstract concepts, not real people. His crimes were against The Truth – Glass made up a fake story about misbehaving Young Republicans, and he didn’t smear anybody because they weren’t real. He didn’t hurt the reputation of any young Republicans, but he did hurt the reputation of Young Republicanism, just like when he made up a fake story about a teenage hacker holding a software company’s data for ransom, no one’s reputation got hurt, except the Internet’s reputation for safety. That’s just hard to turn into a movie that really hits. It’s hard to get people to care about abstract concepts like The Truth being damaged. I did my best. Now I can move on my life. Back to our regularly scheduled programming.

Files

I Fact-Checked The Worst Video Essayist On YouTube

A partial debunking of every false claim in fraudulent YouTuber James Somerton's videos. Timecodes by user @6ViolinRed 0:00 - Introduction 3:45 - 1. Gay porn invented Skype 4:45 - 2. J.K. Rowling once said you could magically gender-transition at Hogwarts 5:50 - 3. The reason Hitler murdered Ernst Rohm is because he was fat 6:56 - 4. England had a homophobic propaganda campaign against Italian tourism because Italy was turning their kids gay 9:44 - 5. Disney stole from gay charities 10:34 - 6. Marvel Comics writer Allan Heinberg did a PR blitz to force his editors to let him write gay characters 13:22 - Bonus Claim: Michael Bendis also wasn't allowed to write gay characters 14:51 - 7. Jeffrey Dahmer inspired violent hate mobs 16:47 - 8. The SS was "teeming with homosexuals" 17:19 - Bonus Claim: The Hitler Youth was also run by homosexuals 18:35 - 9. There was a big outrage about the gay sex scenes in "Red, White & Royal Blue" 25:38 - 10. The life and death of gay porn star Joey Stefano 29:54 - 11. Tolkien was "nearly laughed out of" Oxford because LTOR was "soft" 30:58 - 12. The record box office for a recent Chinese blockbuster was obviously faked 33:46 - 13. Disney cynically exploited Howard Ashman's death 36:46 - 14. "Rocky Horror" saved 20th Century Fox 37:40 - 15. "Legend of Korra" was moved to streaming because it was too gay for television 39:10 - 16. "I Want to Hold Your Hand" was controversial because any kissing or touching was taboo lyrical content 40:11 - 17. Weird Dahmer fangirls are shipping him with his first victim 42:20 - 18. Disney CEO Bob Iger has a strong pro-gay rights record 46:12 - Bonus Claim: Bob Iger wouldn't let Valkyrie be gay in "Thor: Ragnarok" 46:50 - 19. The origin of Neil Gaiman and Terry Pratchett's "Good Omens" 48:20 - 20. "Yuri on Ice" was censored because of its time slot 49:35 - 21. The case against lesbian author Radclyffe Hall was thrown out because men were uncomfortable talking about lesbianism 50:24 - 22. The Nazis invented our current body standards 55:49 - Brief tangent about co-writer Nick 59:31 - 23. NAMBLA appropriated images from Disney's "Aladdin" 1:00:54 - 24. '90s gay rights activists weren't fighting against employment discrimination 1:04:29 - 25. China keeps jacking up their cut of the profits from imported Hollywood movies 1:05:49 - 26. Disney princesses are marketed to funerals 1:06:50 - 27. Dying AIDS patients kept a "Beauty and the Beast" rose by their beds 1:08:04 - 28. Bob Iger was working on the DCEU because he hates Bob Chapek 1:09:39 - 29. Major industries spend most of their budget buying and burying new technology 1:10:54 - 30. Pirates were philanthropists 1:14:24 - 31. The gay panic trial of John Parisie 1:18:55 - 32. Stan lee loves this Scarlet Witch moment 1:20:33 - 33. Janelle Monae came out because you didn't understand "Pynk" 1:25:16 - 34. European peasants were paranoid about their friends and neighbors being vampires 1:29:27 - 35. The Hitchcock Thing 1:32:43 - Bonus Claim A: Katharine Hepburn didn't believe gay people existed 1:33:53 - Bonus Claim B: There was a deleted dickpic subplot in "Birds of Prey" 1:35:08 - Bonus Claim C: J.K. Rowling says Draco is pro-trans 1:35:42 - Conclusion

Comments

Tinni

Speaking just for myself, I think this is one of the most important videos you have ever done! Those fabrications were not harmless and needed someone to address them. The fact it ended up being you is unfortunate. But in the modified words of Gandalf, "No one wishes to use their platform to debunk liars, but that is not them to decide. All we have to decide is what to do with the platform that is given to us." and I think you did a good job!

Akil Guru

I wouldn't have complained about not getting a preview of the Somerton video anyways, but goddamn, this read was more than worth my Patreon money.

Kyle Olson

I've got a few things to say about streaming video, first: I'm happy for your success but I've got to be honest - I couldn't watch more than a few minutes. Not because you were wrong, but because the level of insanity was too high. It's not like his claims would start getting more sane, but they could certainly get more insane. On streaming video: I worked for RealNetworks in the mid-late 2000s. Before I was there, In the 1990s they pioneered video streaming on the internet, but they wouldn't say they invented streaming. Most certainly they didn't do it for Porn. RealNetworks was founded by ex-Microsoft employees as "ProgressiveNetworks". They intended to use it to distribute Progressive political messages. But they quickly realized the whole "making money" thing was better. The company survived the .Com crash of 2000 because they had sold a ton of stock to keep cash in the bank. "Porn spreads video tech" is a myth about every format. A popular story is that Beta failed because it had no porn - this is very false, and some quick research will prove this. The "porn makes video happen" myth that's probably spread by porn producers for publicity because it sounds believable. As for Skype, even if somehow Skype was created for gay porn (a nuts-balls nonsense claim) the idea that it started internet video is absurd. It's like claiming the Fox Network started network TV. If you're too young you might not know that Fox didn't exist until 1987 (roughly, it's complicated) so you might believe it's the first TV network if someone said that. But if you lived through reality at the time you would know it was false. (It would be more accurate to say it's like claiming Fox was created for Gay Porn, but let's not deal with that.) Before working for RealNetworks, I also worked on a minor video conferencing platform that wasn't Skype. I'm pretty sure no one ever asked to use it for Porn of any sexuality.

Matt Bresnahan

Sometimes a story just needs to be told. And I think that this was something worth reporting on. In the end it was something that while entertaining in a morbid kind of way it was something that needed to get out there

Empyre18

I don’t blame you for being uncomfortable with drama content, but man, when you did it, you did a good one. I had never even heard of James Somerton until your video, and now I can’t get out of this rabbit hole, not just for entertainment, but because there are genuine serious implications (also, any sympathy I had for James went in the garbage with the “all the cool gays died of AIDS line; when I heard that, I wanted to punch a hole in my wall). But honestly, I think you’re right that this probably wouldn’t be good to make this a regular thing. Delving into drama and takedowns probably does something not great to your mental health and social life, and probably should be just instances like this where you’re really pushed over a personal threshold. That being said, I really enjoyed and learned a lot from the video. Keep up the good work!

mo

Hey Todd, you don't know me but I've been following your content for a really long time. I started watching you back on The Bad Website when I was 13, and you were one of the people whose videos I continued to follow as I got older and my tastes changed. I've always been glad to see you're still doing well and that your takes are still great. I certainly didn't expect a video like this from you, but now that it exists, I'm so glad it was you who got to do this. It's such an extra little treat for me in all of this. This is such good reporting and it really shows off your chops. Great job. And man, fuck that guy.

Kamu

i was so surprised when you dropped this video mainly because ive been watching your content since 2009 and it seemed so different from your usual business but i thoroughly enjoyed it and could tell you were immensely passionate about every word you said. reading this has really opened my eyes to the way you make content and i just want to say that i loved the stop video you made and i hope you continue to follow your muse and make videos that evoke this kind of passion in you. and also your nickleback video was very good but it made my spouse obsessed with that album so i have been forced to listen to it every car ride. thank you for that :)

Mo and Soi

I said "hoo boy" in the exact same place in the video as you did so you get my gold star. Even if you choose to not do any other kinds of these videos (exposé work is important but can be very draining) it was good that you did this, because it gave a much needed other side of the coin to Hbomb's video. Plagiarism is bad, and should be eradicated, but there could be an argument of "well he's just informing the masses! That's gotta count!" Your work is instrumental here in showing him as a fraud, because he's also just bald-faced lying, not just plagiarizing. You're the left hook in the 1-2 combo. As well, your work in all your videos is great because you walk the razor's edge between emotional investment and cold objectivity, which is not easy to do. You care but you never let it distract you from the truth. And that's what makes your videos worth it. Keep on keepin on, Todd. And thanks for this knockout.

Lanth

I will admit that I don't think I've ever clicked on a nebula notification as fast as I did when I saw your video, having just seen Hbomberguy's the day before. I had no idea what to expect but it delivered. You did a good job, it really did feel like a roller coaster. And I'm hard to offend but James managed it with "only boring gays survived aids." Fuck you, James.

Kelsey Cavanaugh

Now that you’ve put this out into the world (and it’s a good video! I really enjoyed it!) I hope the next year will be a lot more peaceful for you since you do not have this hanging over you.

PlayMp1

Hey Todd. I've been following you for well over a decade, starting in the middle of high school and continuing to this day (I'm married and I have a career and shit now!), and have been a patron for many years now and will be as long as you're still doing this job. First, if you wanted to charge me triple for this video, have the fuck at it, because it's 1) extremely good, 2) important, and 3) clearly a ton of work. I'm guessing you can't do that per se but I think I'll bump up to the $4 tier now permanently, especially since unlike when your Patreon started I'm no longer a broke college student. Second, please don't fret about your release schedule. Honestly, your schedule is downright frenetic compared to a lot of your peers not named Anthony Fantano (and his reviews, while perfectly well written and reasoned, are relatively simpler to make by just listening to an album, writing out his thoughts, and saying them into the camera, versus all the editing and background and the good stuff I've loved from you for over a decade). Hbomb constantly gets light poking for releasing a video like... annually. You're not exactly in the video essay field per se but your work is still of that caliber of quality. Third, there's nothing wrong with jumping outside your niche a little bit. Dan Olson started off talking about movies, now he's spent 2 years turning all the biggest online grifts to scrap and it's great. Lindsay used to be the Nostalgia Chick - much to her displeasure - and then she ended up making great works that have a much broader sweep and analysis than anything she could have done back on CA. I'm guessing you'll want to return to music for a good while after a mammoth like this one (hence the worst list), but you bet your ass I'll be there day and date for the next time you take a little leap into the unknown. Edit: Oh yeah, and the gay Nazis thing and the "Ernst Röhm was killed for being fat" thing made me want to punt my phone. I minored in history and it's probably my #1 subject matter interest (much more than my major in hindsight), and I have done a *LOT* of research on interwar Germany. Read a lot of books (read Richard J. Evans and Ian Kershaw!), listened to podcasts, watched/listened to videos and documentaries, the works. I find studying and describing how the most infamous movement in world history came to seize total control of one of the most powerful countries in the world and then led it on a genocidal rampage across two continents to be extremely important so that we can live up to Never Again. The idea of the SS, who massacred gay people in the thousands in the camps, being chock full of gay people participating in said massacre, is an outright homophobic statement, and any gay man writing that and saying it out loud needs to say it out loud again to themselves and understand that it's total nonsense, and then delete the entire paragraph that led them to that point. And as for Ernst Röhm, that was a bit more just funny than offensive (Röhm was killed in a simple old fashioned power struggle, as you pointed out), but it still betrayed a total failure to actually read even a single paragraph of a single book on the Nazi regime. For fuck's sake Göring was right there doing enough morphine to kill an ox while somehow also still being the biggest man in government in the Western world!

Rick Griffin

Man, I get it. Getting embroiled in drama, on the face of it, is just not fun. You wade in and all of the sudden your brain is like "what if a Somerton fan decides I was the problem and makes me his life mission to take down". And maybe it's not even that overt, but there's just a lot of potential simmering anxiety about Attacking Some Guy, no matter how clearly and obviously he needed it. I even get some anxiety by proxy after indulging in this type of drama because I start thinking "wait, can I be absolutely certain I'm not as bad as Somerton? Better double check my entire career history to be sure" But you are also right that this was the funniest goddamn thing

AstarothLuLz

There was a reason that I clicked to watch that video within minutes of it hitting my sub box, even though I didn't have a clue what it was about or why you were doing it. I hadn't even watched hbomb's video at that time. I figured that if you of all people felt the need to post something not in your wheelhouse, you felt that you had a damn good reason to do so. I heard your conviction to just correct the facts throughout the video and reading this has reinforced that to me as well. It is, in my opinion, a great act of journalism. You deserve every bit of success that comes with it.

mizushimo

I think if you wanted to branch out past music, you could do really well. You've spent a decade perfecting your style and voice through hundreds of videos and it shows. That fact check video was really good despite it being far outside your wheelhouse

Henry Kiley

Sometimes, the softest paw is a claw. Somerton had his chance to own up and get right. He pissed on it. No regrets. It's for his own good and the good of the free market of ideas.

Taylor Abrahamse

Im really glad you made that video and it appeared right after I had watched the primary takedown of him. Shocked it was from you but I really admire you for doing it, and I hope more ppl stick around for your music reviews after it. If you're exasperated by hit music reviews, and given how fragmented and abstract a concept 'hit music' is now I wouldn't blame ya... heck, Brenda Lee just went #1 and did a MV for a song from 1963 for gods sakes... but anyways! I could definitely see you doing more journalistic pieces that are arts and music adjacent and they would fit great on your channel - maybe a video on payola in music, perhaps about how its infiltrated streaming numbers now. You could investigate it deeper than any other youtuber. Maybe even one just debunking music myths people love to believe are true, myths or half-truths that have become synonymous with an artists brand identities.

triggthediscovery

I liked the video a lot, and would have liked it even if it was just "debunking misconceptions" and didn't have anything to do with the drama. It's full of so much good information and research, I think it's okay to include a little drama as a treat. Like gravy on a hearty pile of mashed potatoes.

Pietro Gagliardi

I watched Shattered Glass in a news literacy course in my first year of college (2009-2010) and I remember liking it, if it did seem a end somewhat abruptly. I keep telling myself I'll watch it again one day. I forget if I pirated it when I downloaded a crapton of movies after becoming a film buff later in college... if not I'll need to get a copy. I wanted to write something in the comments section after watching your video but didn't quite feel comfortable with how to phrase it in a way that wouldn't blow up in my face... but it seemed, especially from your video, like a lot of his lies fit a particular narrative that panders to people stuck in that bleak hopeless world-loathing state of mind that's amenable to fascist rhetoric — I repeatedly called the lies "kinda fashy, and not just because of the Nazi talk" to my friends who I did talk about the video to. "In the past, everyone was secretly gay, and gay was everywhere, and it was glorious, but we were also oppressed, and we were the Nazis and we oppressed ourselves somehow??, and we always made all the movies, and we were always making the fashion choices for everyone, and then AIDS happened, and when you caught AIDS your livelihood immediately ended and you turned into a caricature of a terminally ill soap opera character, and that's why things suck now..." I actually started empathizing with his viewers instead of him, and am personally so glad I (someone who is queer but in weird ways and still trying to figure myself out probably way later than anyone else ought to, and someone who definitely gets himself in a rut over similar bleak feelings) never found him on my own or heard of him before now. (And I was also not impressed by the obvious-teleprompter-monotone that shone through the aesthetics in some of his clips either. Probably gonna start making associations about that style of line delivery, if I haven't already...)

Allison

I know it's not your usual thing but it's a fantastic video and I'm proud of you! I can tell the effort you've put in. (the bit about Elisa giving you vampire lore was lolz) Sometimes we find things we just can't keep quiet about, thank you for saying something.

MagentaFormula0

Personally I'm fine with being charged for it. I'm a patron of both you and Hbomberguy, so im happy to support your work. Plus it still was thoroughly enjoying to watch.

Mitchell McIntyre

I'm not the type to watch a two hour video about a guy I don't know and all the dumb stuff he does, but I thought to myself "If Todd has THIS much to say about this guy, it must be a huge deal, he never does stuff like this." Watched the whole thing in one sitting. You have such a great way of conveying information and telling a story in a concise, and entertaining way. Even if it's outside of your usual content, absolutely charge for it. We're here for you, not just the music videos. So if you've got another 2 hour video about the rise and fall of Blockbuster or some shit kicking around in your brain, go for it. It's natural to get burned out on something when you've stayed on the same topic for so long, especially now that pop music is in a nebulous state of being like it is now. You absolutely killed it, my man.

J Singh

This post was really compellingly written too. I really think you could do more with this. Not necessarily more shit about Sommerton but more videos just using that very basic format you used to expose more stuff, critique poor arguments about your area of expertise - music and music history etc.

Stephen Bride

In the wake of some of the unpleasantness we've seen online over the last few months (including some others Harry covered in his video) it's clear that people in general need to be more careful with their sources of information. Not just to stop misinformation but ensure real creators and sources are rewarded for their work; helping to ensure more of it. Thanks for helping people remember that. You couldn't give early access here, it would have blown the video really. But the fact you have stayed away from drama is part of why this worked so well. If you had a reputation for drama the video would have been overlooked as another example. Being so annoyed that you made it without having done this before shows how big you considered it to be. Also thanks for the "Shattered Glass" recommendation. I'll give it a watch.

Scott Haddlesey

I've watched Somerton videos. I actually stopped getting recommended his content recently, so I actually sought out his channel to find out that a lot of his content had seemingly gone missing – at least anything that I'd be interested in watching. So I forgot about him again until I saw your video on my Youtube homepage. I don't generally watch HBomberGuy, but as someone who has followed your work basically since you first posted on a website that will not be named, I'm sorry to say I'm one of those people who knows your business well enough to know that you'd never post something like this video unless shit was making contact with fan. What I'm trying to say is, I probably wouldn't have heard about this if not for your video. I even watched HBomberGuy's entire video because I watched yours. So I appreciate you risking your reputation and potential retaliation from Somerton's followers for this. Thank you for making sure I and the rest of your audience found out about the untrue things Somerton may have planted in our brains. With all that said, I do hope both that you find a way to find this level of fulfillment consistently from your career without moving on entirely from music content. My fiance and I listen to every Song Vs. Song and look forward to watching your top 10 best and worst lists every year, even if we don't agree with most of your opinions.

Khalid Cailean

Im glad you followed your weird muse the way it went. And I think this video is a testament that you write extremely well and you do some absolutey damning research. It was also great hearing you do something you were clearly super passionate about. If you ended up straying from your usual stuff (which I do love), to do more personal journalistic projects, I would still be a patreon, and would still happily be charged. Anyways, don’t be too hard on yourself, and don’t be afraid to feel proud about the work you’ve done ❤️

big bird

you have personally done me a service by allowing me to link directly to an itemised list of Somerton Specials every time I hear one of them making the rounds. it has been sickeningly enraging to hear the Nazi fitness thing (with no idea where the hell it was coming from), knowing just enough to know it's definitely not true, but not being articulate enough to debunk it. as you well know, it is an exhausting process, and unless you deliver it in precisely the right manner, people do not necessarily listen

big bird

unrelated: for what it's worth, I follow your work specifically for your manner of delivery and thorough research! so if you decided to branch out, I wouldn't be put off. I'd bet that's not an uncommon sentiment. you fill a niche similar to Jenny Nicholson in my entertainment diet

De

I think there's probably a lot of work to be done exposing misinformation but I don't know how you make it fun. You video honestly came off as pretty grim to me. Pietro up in the comments above me said it a lot better but there was definitely a narrative behind Somerton's appeal that's very dangerous and I bet there's a lot of that going around. Reading what you wrote about how this fell into your lap reminds me of something you said about when you got the idea for Todd in the Shadows, how you were pacing around your place thinking about it, a kind of sudden inspiration. Seems to me your inspirations are pretty good. I don't think you should go changing your whole career path or anything but you know, keep an eye out.

Castleknackers

I think it comes across pretty well that this isn't just jumping on a beatdown bandwagon. It appropriately feels like a companion piece that fills a niche that Harris' video wasn't focusing on. I also appreciate this post because it sounds like it's coming from a healthy view on youtube drama. Being able to feel bad for the target at least a little is a mature trait and I respect you for being able to push past it as the video became easier to justify.

Johanna M

I've been watching your videos for over a decade now and I admire how you never change your main style and still stay good and popular. But! Often when you branch out you end up with something great. One Hit Wonderland was my favourite of your stuff for a long time until Trainwreckords started. I'm glad the stability of your regular videos keeps you coming back, but I loved this video and it's great to see how well you did it. I was subscribed to Somerton for a while but I found something about him off-putting (which I could never put my finger on) and I unsubbed; I think in part because Matt Baume was right there making queer media analysis and showing me how good it could be. Be kind to yourself - if you have the flex to follow your interests at the moment that's no bad thing! And thank you for this video and the explainer post.

Michael Fitzgerald

I watched the video and enjoyed it mightily, so it's fair to charge for it here I think. I'm a patron of you because I like the videos you make and, regardless of whether that was in the normal wheelhouse, it was still a great video, so I'm cool with being charged for it I'm not against you going outside the wheelhouse if it leads to a video as good as this one. If you ever want to go outside the usual area again, then you reviewing wrestling entrance themes is a video I'd be down for watching ;)

Jasmine S. Thompson

Hey Todd, thank you for making this. I hadn't heard anything about Hbomberguy's video and i have watched a few James Somerton videos and honestly wasn't informed enough to tell that his claims were downright wrong. I appreciate you exposing him so I know not to spout any of his misinformation. That and it's always good to see another video from you! I have been watching your content since you were using Vimeo and have enjoyed every minute of it. If you want to make the video paywalled (I didn't write understand what you meant by charge for it) I'd be happy to pay but might be confused on where to find it. I assume it would be on Nebula?

Aaron Lutes

Just like everyone else said, this was a compelling read (and the video was a great companion to Hbomberguys!). I hope you find more random things to spark your passion, I'm always happy with your videos and you've gotten me into pop music, but it was cool to see your style on something different and a bit longer. I'm sure substack pays less than dick, but I'd love to read more longform thoughts from you.

Lewis Lovhaug

Todd, you did a phenomenal job. I'm proud that I contributed in my own small way to your fact-checking of this asshole and let me tell you - while I agree with you about wading into Youtuber drama and the potential pitfalls of targeting someone unfairly... this was well-deserved. A popular personality spinning lies and stealing from the hard work of vulnerable, underpaid, underappreciated people is an enemy worth taking down, especially when you consider that some of his victims were friends of ours. This wasn't an unfounded attack on some innocent, well-meaning but ill-executed Youtuber - this was bringing down a bully. Well done, looking forward to the End-of-Year lists because you're so good at them.

GregD

Thank you for all of this, Todd. Thank you for stepping outside your wheelhouse. Do what you need to do to keep your wheel turning.

Beau Dure

This hits home for me because (A) I’m a journalist, (B) my wife worked at The New Republic just after Glass was exposed and kicked out, and (C) I’ve done deep, deep dives that make popular people look bad. I have OCD, so I have both the obsessive nature and the unfairness-fueled anger to drive me through it. When you shared that your main motivation was simply a desire to be a bullshit detector — again, that resonated with me. Sadly, my work has made me LESS popular because you simply do not question Megan Rapinoe and the U.S. women’s soccer team, even if you covered women’s soccer when no one else was paying attention and literally have the receipts. But there’s a price to pay for asking whether the women AND men at the highest levels have teamed up to do a reverse Robin Hood and take money away from future generations, and I’ve paid it. I’m still employable, but it’s safe to say my reputation and my access have taken some hits. On a media conference call, I asked what kind of bridges the men’s and women’s players planned to build to the grassroots volunteers who were so angry over national team spending that they nearly reinstated a past president of US Soccer who had resigned after failing on every level, I was met with complete silence. You have to have iron-clad control of the narrative to be able to do that without anyone else in the media questioning it. I could be envious of your success here, but no — I’m genuinely happy. I’m glad it worked out for you. It’s good, thorough work, and you’ve done all you can do to be fair about it. If it works out for you, maybe it’ll work out for journalists who dare to take on others who spread bullshit. Then maybe we’ll avoid our descent into propaganda-fueled authoritarianism next year. And I enjoyed the Nickelback Trainwreckords.

Vanessa Picard

I will always support the fight against misinformation. I'd never heard of this guy before you video but even just from what I saw it's unbelievable to me that people took him seriously. But that just shows how important it is to highlight people like this because if they dress up their lies the right way, people will believe them! I appreciate that you went out of your comfort zone to make this video and I think you did a great job.

Sam Frederich

You're a mensch Todd. I've never been prouder to be a supporter

Bryan R. Powers

Todd, before Patreon had ever even existed, I was supporting you through viewership; I've seen that same line taken by many people who Somerton has betrayed by lying and grifting. From what I've gathered based on HBomb's video, your video, and so I hear that Philosophy Tube may also be releasing a video about Somerton this Friday(?) - this video didn't feel like YT drama, it felt like collective action. It felt like successful workers inside of a system that rarely, if ever, works *for* them banding together to remove someone that benefits nobody save themself and only serves to hurt their workplace further. You can ultimately call it what you want, it is your video after all, but I wouldn't worry too much over whether you did the write thing or not; you unequivocally did. You helped to quiet a man who blatantly stole other peoples' work for years, works all along the LGBT+ spectrum from all manner of marginalized peoples, who straight-up lied about everything from comic books to nazism; and you helped to enlighten other people to this and steer them clear of Somerton, and perhaps others like him in the future. I've been a fan of yours going on well over a decade now, and, I have to say, this is certainly some of your most impactful work. That said, I'm sorry to hear that you've been dealing with burnout. I know it's common in the YT sphere, but I want to say that I also feel you've done some of your best work over the last year, and I feel like it's only getting better. I'll always be a fan and check out anything you make, whether that's always music content or you branching out to other subjects is up to you, but I'm a fan of Todd in the Shadows first and foremost, and pop music second. Without your content, I'd probably still just be listening to classic rock without any idea as to what is happening in modern music. But your sense of humor and sensibilities mirror my own, and so I'd follow you anywhere. That goes doubly-so after you helped to (unofficially) deplatform Somerton. I'm proud of you, dude. Your video is great. Keep up the good work, whatever that may be. Now, if you'll excuse me, I need to go find a copy of Shattered Glass to watch... P.S. I'd be interested to see *YOU* review that film, seeing as how your requested review is no longer online and it meant so much to you. Just a thought.

randomguy

So I've watched the video a couple of times now and I agree it was super compelling, I have no problem paying for it. You note that despite this being outside your normal wheelhouse you're good at it and I agree. If anything I think you may be underselling just how much of your usual work is journalistic rather than just criticism. One of the things you are really good at isn't simply criticism but putting things in context. Even since One Hit Wonderland first started you weren't just looking the Hit, the part everyone knows, but usually looking into the obscure background, the broader trends in pop music that lead to them being hits, you'd look into why they couldn't follow it up. Trainwreckords does the same, usually looking into the arcs of whole careers and contextualizing them against changing music trends. That gift for contextualizing helps here to, you don't just debunk what he says, if that's all that was needed it would be more like the bonus claims at the end where you just point out mistakes. You put in the effort to show the context, the details that show this isn't just mistakes but deliberate fabrications.

Jess Willmott

Heck, charge me twice for all I care. Thank you for breaking with your usual (and admirable) stance to avoid the drama in order to expose such a flagrant case of fabrication and misinformation.

Hunter Putzke

This is a fascinating read - I'll echo the other comments here and say I'm extremely happy to pay for something like this. More broadly, I just want to see more of what you want to make - I love the thought and care that goes into the context and mechanics of the songs and every topic you discuss.

Andy Gattis

Buddy, I think it’s VITAL for people who make stuff to be able to follow their nose outside of their typical lanes every so often… it both keeps you sane and promotes growth in your skills. All you gotta do is bring the heat with it, and be up-front about the experimental nature of it. You’ve done both these things. You’re golden. I’m happy to contribute to the main thoroughfare and the twisting alleyways alike. Well done.

FunFawn21

Unlike most Patreon accounts, Todd charges per video, not month. So he felt bad about charging Patrons for a video that didn't get released exclusively to them first like he usually does

candidgamera

You do as the muse moves you, man. It was a great video, and I share your anger at the spread of misinformation.

C Puffer

Happy to pay for the video, Todd. It is stellar work. I had never watched this dude or heard of him really—I think a video or two might have come up in my recommendations a few times. So your video, which I watched before Harry’s, was my first real exposure to this tool. I’ve watched yours twice now; something so satisfying about watching someone righteously set the record straight. I also want to say, this essay is excellent. I think you should try to find a bigger outlet for it. It’s great backstory and interesting on its own. I would think Salon or Vulture or some other outlet would absolutely publish it. Excellent work.

Molly Shah

Long time viewer but I just subbed to your Patreon to tell you that I thought one of the most compelling parts of your video was your obvious reluctance in doing it. It really made the entire thing not seem petty or about drama but rather from a deep sincere place of wanting to protect others.

William Frost

I was shocked and amazed you did this video. But it is a masterpiece. Thank you.

Jasmine S. Thompson

Ah I see. Yeah I don't mind being charged for it at all.

Keelee

This video was extremely compelling. Excellent work. If you want to make more videos you're passionate about, even if they're a little off brand, my Patreon pledge isn't going anywhere.

Syl W

I'm proud of you, honestly. You've pushed aside the aversion and the wariness to share something very important. Between you and HBomber (who I had not heard of and now need to binge), you've exposed someone - multiple someones - for taking advantage of people and using their reach for truly awful things. I have respect for people who are brave enough to do that. Thank you.

Ricky G.

This video feels like the necessary companion piece to Harry’s video that I think neither of you anticipated. You’ve done great work cataloguing these insane claims he has made in his videos. I understand that this was a conflicting video to produce and truthfully, you were quite literally the last person I would have bet on to drop the second nuke on this topic. That said, I fully support your desire to potentially explore different topics. We all know how compelling your writing is based on your Trainwreckords videos and how effectively you combine pop culture history with a fun narrative. This was an excellent video and I hope this was cathartic for you in some way. Much love and appreciation for your work Todd. Heres to a great 2024.

Keith Badje

As a fat, boring gay dude: Boring gay dudes were more lucky than boring. And they did a ton of the caretaking of those interesting gays. They also were on the front lines doing the protesting that did a lot to motivate the medical community to come up with the medications that turned HIV from a death sentence to something more akin to Type One Diabetes -- serious, chronic, but treatable and not something that stops you from living a normal life. Marriage was important because you didn't want some awful homophobic family member swooping in on your death bed, making decisions you didn't agree with, and taking away the things you wanted to pass on to your spouse. His content reads like a less coherent version of the essay I wrote in college on how XY magazine was a bad influence on my fellow gays. Fortunately, the only other person to see that was a mass media professor (the same woman who introduced me to Shattered Glass!). I also figured out shortly thereafter that I can pick and choose what parts of gay culture I wanted to pay attention to. Also, can confirm: XXXL button up shirts do exist. Thanks for another great video!

Tim Bates

Just wanted to say, the best thing about your involvement in all this, quite beside how great and righteously angry your video is, is that you do feel confident enough to follow your muse, to fuck with the formula sometimes. As a longtime fan, I think your work has been going from strength to strength these last couple of years, both your 'normal' stuff and your stuff that's different. So, while I totally get finding structure helpful from a productivity standpoint. I'm glad to hear that if you're passionate about a thing, or believe in a thing, you're comfortable following it through. Long may it continue!

Shiny Skunk

Can I just say, and this is mostly tangential to the rest of your essay (which is very good and thorough, but you knew that): The gays (of which I am a member) have been discrediting Dua Lipa by saying [insert name of musician someone likes better] to disco first since the millisecond Future Nostalgia dropped. It's this generation's "Actually Lady Gaga completely stole this thing from [insert name of musician someone likes better] and therefore her ENTIRE CAREER IS A SHAM."

Shiny Skunk

It bothers me specifically because god, this dude really did just present his dumb tumblr-drama-level conjecture as Well Researched Video Essayist Truth. Boo, bitch!!!

Ignifer

I haven't seen this one yet (saving it for the weekend), but I like seeing you follow your passion in new directions. Not to be weird/ parasocial, but that "best buses of the 90s" oddball video was the happiest I'd heard you in a while. It still had a structure, but the "this is new and there won't be one exactly like this again" of it all was very fresh and cool. I still love your music stuff, which has only gotten more thoughtful and interesting to me over time-- I'm watching my way through the old best/ worst lists for nostalgia, and it's cool to see those snapshots of your style changing. But if you dropped more curveball videos or wanted to spend more time in a journalism-leaning direction, I wouldn't mind at all.

Saffron C

I hope some new people just found one of their new favorite YouTubers because of the virality of your Somerton video. I don’t think anyone will have my experience from 2010/11–“wow, a music reviewer using video as a medium, no one is doing this!”—maybe more like, folks will see the rigor from this video and become curious how you bring it to your music content. Love to see it.

nursermk

Gosh, I hate hearing you sound almost apologetic for a lengthy, researched piece. We are here to support you, and I think most love how you find a spark of inspiration--whether it is Taylor, a bus, a "Trainwreckord", or some self-important knob, and give us your take on a topic, with personal asides and relative facts included. I came across this video a couple of days ago and was expecting something less serious or focused (perhaps a quick riff on some rando--to me-- internet doofus) but ended up watching the entire presentation and coming away with feeling it was a job well done, and enjoying your more old-school style of journalism. I appreciate your hard work while bringing this information to light while keeping the format methodical and earnest, yet adding your own Todd-ness to the mix. As the song says "If it makes you happy, it can't be that bad".....right?

Ryan Storey

James' claim that "only the boring gays survived the AIDS epidemic because they weren't getting laid" is so wildly offensive, but I'm just gonna retort by quoting one of my friends named Sam Miller who had the perfect response: "It's wild to hear about 'boring gays too uptight to have sex' from a man who looks like his idea of a party is putting on The Decemberists and drinking sparkling water while pretending to read Judith Butler by the fireplace."

AlexKorobeiniki

lol, Todd, my dude, it was unusual circumstances. You are not a drama YouTuber, you’re not in danger of becoming a drama YouTuber, and you made it very clear in the video what drove you to make it. We’re not gonna hate you for poking your head out of your usual niche when something strikes you. I am sorry to hear that you’ve been feeling burnt out with music content or that you feel like you’ve peaked, because from where I’m standing I’m always excited to see your next video. Genuinely, seriously, you haven’t released a trainwreckords or a OHW or a pop song review that I don’t find engaging. As a creative, plateaus are normal. But there’s always a chance for another peak or valley ahead. In short: congrats on a very successful video! Can’t wait for the year end list sometime in February

Jericho Merklein

Joined patreon again mostly to see this behind the scenes, and to catch up on the Ramble Ons. I have to say, "My Life With James" reads like it could easily be the Start of Darkness arc for the music critic turned drama maven. Lines that were especially chilling were "If nothing else, Somerton was a way into being part of the YouTube community again; I had stopped feeling like a part of it a long time ago." and "I joked with a friend that it would get maybe ten views. As I write this, it just hit a million."

Jericho Merklein

I'm glad you clearly have a lot of self-awareness about that - and the conclusion at the end assuages most of my fears. You understand that there's something very addicting about this, it fills the void. I understand being in a box, creative-wise, life-wise, and I hope you can find a way to do what you find compelling and meaningful - without feeding the plant, as it were.

Weoooo

I help out my brother at his liquor store when nobody else can. I don't drink, so there's a lot of times that I look things up. The ipad that the POS system is on is just an ipad, so it's got a web browser. I'm not signed into google, and neither is anyone else, so instead of suggestions google just tells me what other people are searching. Most of the time it's something that I know will get me upset or something that I do not care about. A quarterback for a football team that isn't mine, a storm in germany, some bullshit story about someone doing something, you know how it is. But yesterday night, while trying to figure out who the fuck we could buy a Tokaji from, I saw a search term that made me laugh out loud and abandon my plan immediately. James Somerton. It was so god damn funny dude. Somehow this complete asshole getting annihilated rose to the top of searches that usually include sports stars signing contracts and big weather events. It was, honestly, the funniest thing that has ever happened. I know why you're apologetic, especially since you've got a lot of viewers now who will expect something like this again. Hopefully they stick around for trainwreckords and one hit wonderland, where you show a similar level of honest to god curiosity and rigor for a similarly easily overlooked topic. It's what I've loved about your videos for like a literal decade, a dedication to actually learn about something. There's so much to know about every single thing out there, and there's a joy in that. I'm honestly not surprised that the thing that really put you over the edge was the refusal by these two to engage in the fundamental process of LEARNING anything; it drives you. I'm glad you can see how good your video actually is, though. It's wonderfully structured, and you carry us along on the 'what the fuck did that guy just say' journey incredibly well. I, too, never said "what? what the fuck are you talking about" audibly more than when listening to this thing. That the WWII GIs were jealous of the ripped nazis put me in a total tailspin not just cause, y'know, they stormed beaches and liberated concentration camps, or because they fought the fuckin' Wehrmacht full of teenagers and old men, but because the popular stories about the Europeans theatre are about how the Americans were taller than everyone else because they actually had consistent sources of nutrition growing up. The ubermench wasn't ze germans, it was us. What the absolute fuck was he going on about? What the fuck was he SAYING

Citizen Calmar

Well, at least this gives some context to what's happening. I didn't watch the original video because I just thought, "Huh. Twitter can't seem to shut up about this four-hour video that a YouTuber I've never really watched put out about a YouTuber I've never even heard of. From context clues, I guess this a well-deserved take-down of the guy, but I don't really know either of these people, so I'll just wait the day it'll take for Twitter to fixate on something else and move on." But then I saw that Todd put out what is basically a feature-length companion piece of his own, when this is not by any means the kind of material he usually covers, and I realized that, god damn it, I'm going to have to set aside six hours this weekend to wade through all this. Maybe this is just one of those zeitgeist-y things that we'll still forget about by New Year's, but now it feels like something I should at least make a point of becoming aware of.

Saffron C

Todd has a Patreon tier, $4/video, where you will receive his written column, Ramble On!

Infinitely Absurd's Absurdities

The more I look at James the more he both sounds and looks like the Theranos ceo. I am glad it was the YT community who called him out for fleecing other creators and his audience. I'm also glad I never have to have his videos squatting in my recommends again.

Paul Anderson

I'm so grateful you made this video. Todd the music critic has years of experience doing research, presenting arguments, and working with the online creator community. Why shouldn't he be the one to speak out on something egregious and harmful? You're not the first or last. Ann Reardon's baking channel investigated cooking hacks and uncovered a Russian troll farm. And this is important work. You and Harris aren't just personally going after James Somerton (though he direly needed it), you're going after labor theft and disinformation, two very real and serious problems today. We've seen for years now there's no accountability unless we create it. In a just world you'd be collecting a bounty. If you feel strongly about something go for it. I don't watch your music videos because I know or am invested in all these musicians and songs. Usually I'm not. But your videos are always so well put together, enlightening, and entertaining.

Taekook

You write very engagingly, with humor and insight. Please keep doing so in your lane and wherever your muse takes you. I have a couple of grad degrees and am unabashedly a research nerd. What I like about your video essays (and Lindsay Ellis’s and Dan Olson’s and Harry Brewis’s) is the vibe of listening to a colleague speak about the part of their field that fascinates them. You can tell when someone has immersed themselves in research because of passion. It’s always a delight to hear. You deliver that consistently.

Josh

So glad you made this video and I'm more than happy to pay for it.

Kelley Runyon

I think what you and Harris did--the careful research and compiling of information into informative and entertaining videos--was important. Truth is important. Correcting misinformation is important. I'm glad that you moved passed your initial instinct not to engage in "drama". Drama is not what this was; this was righteous anger at genuine harm being done to truth. I appreciate it very much.

Mack

I've watched your videos for over a decade, and it's not the content that keeps me coming back - it's your perspective and personality. I'll gladly listen to you talk about any topic, whether it's music or politics or some grifter. As long as you're passionate about it, I'm there. Thanks for this well-written essay & the many years of incredible videos, especially including this one. Cheers!

Darcy Summers

tbh, I love when people I initially followed for a specific niche branch out into other subjects, as it gives me a chance to branch out too. Between this and the Stop project, I'm just glad you're in a financial/mental place where you can jump into other types of projects and don't have to be slavishly tied to the whims of the algorithm. I also appreciate that, with both your and hbomb's videos (and other works coming out like verilybitchie's podcast), while James is the name being dragged through the mud, the point is clearly to remind casual viewers like myself to pay a little bit closer attention and being up some red flags to be on the lookout for. It also puts others trying the same scam on notice to clean up their acts. It's only a matter of time before enough people catch on to what they're doing (hopefully).

Llama

Two thoughts: first, thank you so much for this video, and for taking the time to write up your thoughts on making and presenting it. You so effectively demonstrate the value of research and curiosity by doing and presenting this (like you do with all your work!), while simultaneously breaking down what the lack of those two things does to cultivate bad quote-unquote "content". Second, you keyed into something that I've struggled to explain to my students and colleagues for years now about how willful ignorance and NOT doing the work necessary for research/art will spread misinformation like wildfire. It also allows for disrespect, misogyny, lesbophobia, all that, to underscore whatever possible points are being made, good intentions or not (and Somerton almost certainly didn't have those). It feels bad! I don't like it, and I worry for my students who seem to get a lot of their information from folks like Somerton or his analogues on Tiktok.

The Mad Jay Woman

Early this past weekend I was going to tweet something like “Chuckled at the last TRAINWRECKORDS but have had Nickelback stuck in my head all week, the dangers of watching Todd in the Shadows” And then I got distracted watching YouTube… and now all I hear is blood rushing through my ears… Thanks? 😅 Hearing Somerton referred to as a “public intellect” on Pod Save The People of all fucking places turned my anger over this up to a boil, I can only, imagine what it was like with a stack of evidence proving he was a complete charlatan I’m so very glad you got over the hesitation to publish your findings. One of the things that adds to my outrage over this is the shitty culture around YouTube that frames any and all creator conflict as DRAHMAH. Somerton thrived because people (viewers and creators) either didn’t feel able to call him out and those that did were shouted down, harassed and threatened (hell, it happened to me). Anyone who wants things to be better going forward needs to contribute to making for a better environment - one can’t treat YouTube as your only source of information and a cheap entertainment. Whatever way the channel goes in the future I’m on board, creators should do what they’re inspired to make. If that means branching out to reviewing different entertainment or maybe something more investigative or even more miscellaneous stuff like the “Stop!” collection it should be interesting to see

chili sunrise

I genuinely love that you weren’t trying to drop a second nuke, that the stars just aligned until you had information that was too important not to share. I’m glad you made this, and I’m glad it’s not the kind of thing you want to (or feel good about) making. This was the right time to make an exception. (Also you’re right, you were on FIRE in 2022. Just remember that a high water mark isn’t the same as “peaking.” You got plenty of life left.)

Anirien

Just want to say, that while I enjoy your music content, if the fancy ever strikes you to make something else out of the box, go for it. This video was kind of proof that you’re an engaging YouTuber, even when you’re talking about different subjects. (As was the 90s bus video! 😅)

Chuck Winters (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-15 03:00 I already sent a message of support through Bluesky after watching your video but having read this, I'm compelled to send another one. To my shame, I've never seen the movie MANHUNTER—the movie that introduced Hannibal Lector to the world before Anthony Hopkins made him a pop culture icon, but he only appears for like one scene (played by Brian Cox) with the rest of the movie focused on Will Graham's (William Petersen) hunt for a serial killer that slaughters entire families. Again, never saw it (*really* don't want to front here), but years ago I happened to read a quote from it that stuck with me. Graham's talking to Jack Crawford about the apparent sympathy he feels for his target: "My heart bleeds for him, as a child. Someone took a kid and manufactured a monster. At the same time, as an adult, he's irredeemable. He butchers whole families to pursue trivial fantasies... As an adult, someone should blow the sick fuck out of his socks." Somerton's not a serial killer, nor do they deserve death. But if you take them at their word (though at this point, why would anyone), then yeah, it's easy to feel sympathy for the reasons you point out: They're a member of an oppressed class bullied in their youth, never feeling like they fit in anywhere only to find success on YouTube. And now that it's being ripped away from them, they have to start from zero—less than zero, even, because now they have to claw back from a dogshit reputation. Apart from the shit pulled to deserve such a reputation, it's easy for an empathetic person to put themselves in their shoes, decide that there's no way forward, and feel kind of bad for them. Still. Shit was pulled to deserve that reputation. Whatever tragedy brought them to this point and whatever might come after, someone had to blow them out of their metaphorical socks. I love H. Bomb's work. As someone on the spectrum, I will talk up his Measured Response on vaccines and autism to anyone I think will care. When I saw "Plagiarism and You(Tube)" drop in my recs, though, I ignored it; I was/am laid up with COVID and really wasn't in the mood to learn more about how hopelessly fucked my current platform of choice is for its creators. Then YOUR video hit my recs a few hours later with its much more direct title, which is how I learned what H. Bomb's video was actually about (which isn't to drag H. Bomb, the sudden midpoint reveal is what makes it work). And look, as someone who dabbled in drama YouTube around 2017, I won't deny that there's a familiar, visceral satisfaction to watching you claim this fucker's scalp (well, co-claim it with H. Bomb). And having dabbled in drama YouTube, I respect and appreciate your desire to never have to do it again. I've seen it end poorly for target and heckler alike; it's not hard to draw a line between "taking down other people for fun and profit" and "miserable human being in their own right." The problem is, YouTube seems to have no internal recourse for dealing with issues like plagiarism and misinformation on a scale below "Public health crisis." Someone in the community had to step up to combat this, and the fact that it was you likely brought Somerton, and the larger issues their behavior has exposed, to the attention of an audience who would otherwise care less than they should. If this is what my $4/video over I-can't-remember-how-long helped pay for, then I honestly couldn't be prouder to be a patron. Follow your muse wherever it takes you; I'll be here for as long as I can afford to be. (That said, I suspect you're checked out of the discourse by this point, but I've gotta shoot my own shot: You did GLITTER, you did BURLESQUE...I'm just saying, COOL AS ICE is *right* *there.*)
2023-12-07 01:29

Halflingcronch

Subbed just to read this, and don't regret it for the second. thanks for this.

Kat

I think (or at least hope) what both you and Harris did goes beyond James. A lot of us have gotten complacent about how we receive information, and what type of people we tend to regard with skepticism. I know I’ll be referencing both of your videos for a long time - and yours was a completely necessary add-on to Harris’s. It makes sense (if the guy didn’t care enough to not plagiarize other peoples’ ideas and work, then he wouldn’t care enough to track down primary sources and fact check), but it’s not necessarily the first conclusion people would jump to after learning about the plagiarism. Anyway, a little healthy distrust of information is desperately needed, particularly on the internet. And especially information that sounds like what people want to hear.

Celery

Finally sat down to read this and the parts at the beginning about how you got into journalism really resonated with me. It really makes me want to look into Shattered Glass~

Esme

I wish you weren't so hard on yourself, always comparing your work to HBomberguy. The video you made is great, and it is useful and eye opening about misinformation, a problem that has gripped our country like never before. You did a great job. I look forward to your best list, which is my #1 means of getting pop music recommendations to buy for the better part of a decade.

Chris Carline

This "behind the scenes" was amazing. So glad you made the video. I'd never heard of the guy prior to the hbomberguy epic, and when I saw your title pop up I was like, "wait, what? isn't that the guy I just watched a 4-hour vid about?". Anyway -- thanks. (I also liked the one about Nickelback too.)

Spielman

Thank you so much for posting this. And the actual video, of course. I used to teach a class on misinformation, and this experience makes me wish so much that I still was teaching it, because could have spent a whole fucking semester on this one video. It would give fantastic examples of critical thinking, research, why a high baseline for background knowledge is key to avoiding being fooled, a whole host of things worth talking about. You did great work here, is what I'm trying to say.

Lee Jeakins

Todd, I just enjoy your videos and your writing style. Branch out all you want man. I was definitely surprised to see Somerton as your next video topic, but it didn't take long for the video to feel like a natural extension of your catalogue. Videos that come out of left field like this or the Top 10 Busses are welcome surprises!

Hedrigal

Honestly I was just floored when you released your video because the last time I remember you stepping out of music was like, put put let's plays from back when blip was a thing.

RedBedroomRecords

honestly I never got the hate for the dialogue in the Star Wars prequels, the dialogue always sounded fine to me, no worse then the dialogue in the original trilogy which has it's fair share of clunkers as well(especially the first movie, I remember being really annoyed by Luke's whining when i first saw that film on TV as a kid) Anyways I don't think you should feel bad about James at all, I see absolutely nothing "pitiable" about the man considering how much creepy misogyny(not to mention his erasure of trans people)is spread throughout his videos, he's a genuinely awful person who does not deserve any kind of sympathy from anyone. I don't see him as the least bit pitiful, not after the theft from other LGBTQ creators and disgusting and repeated examples of sexism in his videos(not to mention siccing his fans on anyone who dared to rightfully call him out on his plagiarism, the sad part is he could've been found out years ago but he was so ruthless at bullying his victims into silence with his army of fans that he was able to squash all criticism until someone bigger then him like Harry could finally show receipts of his theft and prove what a truly rotten human being he was). I too found Stephen Glass fascinating so I can relate to you on that, are you familiar with Jayson Blair? He first wrote for the New York Times shortly after 9/11 happened and quickly became one of it's rising stars only to get fired in 2003 over spreading lies about the family of an Iraq war veteran, later it was found out almost every single story he'd ever published was a big fat lie. The funniest Glass story I heard was how reps for the anti-drug program D.A.R.E. were all upset because Glass's Rolling Stone story that harshly criticized the program cost them thousands of dollars and a spot at a charity dinner, even if Glass did lie about DARE it ultimately didn't change the fact that the program was largely ineffective(studies showed that it actually had the opposite effect and INCREASED drug use amongst young people due to the ads making drug use look more widespread then it actually was) so I absolutely do not feel sorry for them in the slightest for what happened to them as a result of that story.

RedBedroomRecords

one listen of all the outright misogynistic comments he'd spread all throughout his videos would erase any sympathy you might've had for him, once I knew that he was on my shit list.

RedBedroomRecords

i'm surprised anyone can feel any degree of sympathy for that awful man after learning about his outright misogyny on display in his videos and him stealing words from dead LGBTQ creators.

RedBedroomRecords

the thing with James is i question how much of his supposed sob story is even true, he's lied about so many other things that it wouldn't surprise me if he also lied or at the very least heavily exaggerated how bad things were for him growing up, not saying he was lying about that for sure, but his reputation for lying is so bad he's given me zero reason to give him any kind of benefit of the doubt.

Alice

There are exactly 2 creators on the platform who I will sit down and watch (as opposed to just having it on in the background) a nearly 2 hour video for, and you are one of them. This is because after following you for a decade, I know any video that is over 25 minutes long has a damn good reason to be. Good work, Todd. This must have been grueling to put together. Hope some of the new folk stick around

matt

ehhhhh look to be totally honest I am not a fan of this genre of video. I never heard of this guy before, I don't really care about internet drama about some rando talking bullshit on youtube or twitter - those people are a dime a dozen, and dismiss them out of hand. Maybe this kind of exhaustive callout video (one hour and forty five minutes!!) will be good for some people, "Oh wow he was lying about all that?? This changes everything!" ...but it's not what I'm here for. That said, I did watch the whole thing, and this is a *quality* video, you clearly put a lot of work into it, and it's also clear that it was important for you to make - I'm not trying to devalue your effort or anything like that. I'm just saying, for my money, I don't care about this stuff. I like watching your videos about music. I care about music. I don't care about whatshisface. It really worried me to see this video pop up out of nowhere on your channel - I was like oh shit, is he going to start doing long form video essays about youtuber drama? I'm relieved it's a one time thing, and I appreciate you taking the time to talk through it here. I dunno, if this turns out to be something you're into, maybe consider making a separate channel to segment your audience a bit - because this kind of thing really isn't what I want to see in general, and from you in particular. Hope that doesn't make me sound like too much of an entitled asshole. But I figure you made something new and different, and you probably want to hear what people think, so - that's what I think. I cannot wait for your best / worst of the year roundup videos 😘

hannah

thank you for all the hard work you do, this video included.

jayyy_rayyy

I'm glad you did this. Yeah, it's different from the music stuff, but deviations from a decade+ long pattern don't happen by accident. It had to mean a lot to you - and as someone who's watched since the complaining-about-Pitbull days, when something's drastic enough to change up the established formula, one pays attention. (Edit: Wow, okay. SHIFT-enter for line/paragraph breaks.) The point is... just glance at my username. I'm someone who could well have been taken in by this guy's nonsense if someone I respect a lot more hadn't said something before I discovered him. I appreciate you for doing this different and very uncomfortable thing. If it kept even one member of my community from being harmed (or even exploited!) by that dude, then it did some good for us at a time when we REALLY need it. Thank you!

Kyokyodoka

Ironic, he couldn't even cite his 'smoking gun' right...

surasshu

not that this video needs more views or anything, but i do wonder why this is age-restricted on youtube now

Random-storykeeper

Honestly, I'm not sure I would have watched Hbomberguy's video if I hadn't seen yours pop up in my feed first. But I think the important thing here is that you took time to show and mention your sources, name the people you spoke to and showed the ways in which you tried to look for and debunk his wild claims. That doesn't automatically make everything accurate, necessarily, but you walk us through your thought process and the parts of the video you're addressing so we can look at it ourselves if we want to. I haven't seen any of James' videos, but from the clips you've shown, it doesn't seem like he did any of that. I mean the whole basis for the plagiarism was that he never cited or credited anyone (or if he did, it was done poorly or well after he got called out). That really should be the red flag if he just never cites anyone or any source. We all learn things and we search for things; sharing that process is the least you can do when you're making a video to completely debunk another YouTuber on the basis of false claims. Whether one of James' claims turns out to actually be true or if they are all false, at least we can see the thought process you took to show why the claim was incorrect or misrepresented. I'm definitely someone who is typically way more invested in the pop reviews and top 10s, but after watching your video, I watched Hbomberguy's video shortly after and immediately went back and rewatched your video. Even if there was hate-watching involved, I'm glad to see it turn into a cautionary tale on the dangers of presenting baseless claims as fact without any (or very poorly cited) references.

Jesse Klein

As usual with your videos, the research and presentation was amazing!

Stormy K.

When I saw this video on YouTube, I legitimately thought that the "Todd in the Shadows" channel below it was a glitch! It's a great video. I understand your conflicted feelings on call-out culture and piling on, but he built an empire out of stealing and lying and you know what, it feels good to see that people still care about that.

Janel Brown

Your topics, research and delivery are always great. I hope you never fully leave behind music but I would definitely watch anything else you put out. I always step away having been entertained and having learned something.

August

I used to be a big James Somerton fan, and figured out the plagiarism/misinformation bullshit about two years ago. I'm so incredibly glad you made this video. Harry's was essenial--the plagiarism was inexcusable and ironclad--but it was critical that the misinformation be brought to light as well. I saw a number of reactions that were along the lines of, "well, he may have stolen things, but at least he exposed a large audience to nuanced and well-written queer thought" when part of the big problem with him is that...no, he didn't. Or rather, he did, but the misinformation swirled in means that you can't actually trust anything you learned from a video of his. The misinformation is far more toxic to his audience than the plagiarism. I've been stewing and intermittently hate-watching his channel for the last two years, which was really really weird for me. I hate the whole parasocial internet drama thing, but I couldn't emotionally let go of the Somerton stuff. His channel was so large, and getting bigger by the year. His audience had so many young queer people in it. I think it upset me so much because, as a person with zero online presence, there was literally nothing I could do, no matter how much damage he did to our community. You and Harry's videos were deeply healing for me, as I'm sure they also were for all the people James hurt far more directly. I also think you absolutely did the right thing by criticizing Nick. As someone who's been following this whole thing for the last two years, I think you still let him off easier than he deserved. Anyway. Thank you for making this, I'm really glad you did.

Zachary Makroy

An absolute banger of a video. FWIW, I'm glad you don't do this kind of thing much but oh god was it deserved. And wherever your muse takes you I'm happy to stick around and follow. Peace out Todd and Merry Christmas

Rebecca Richards

... you literally proved his point where YouTubers are punished for not "staying in their lane" because their audience isn't willing to follow them if they try something different.

Rebecca Richards

I have to be honest, I watched Harry's entire video like as soon as it dropped, which was wild for me because it was 3AM in my part of the world and when it was over the sun was coming up XD I was still in the haze of watching the Somerton implosion when I got the notification that you uploaded a new video. And then I realized "Damn, this guy must be a REAL shitweasel if Todd took him down too." You did incredible work and your video is a necessary one because its overall theme of how Somerton's misinformation had legs outside his fanbase speaks to how easy it is for people to learn bad info and never realize it. Having watched your work for over ten years now, I respected that you do exhaustive research on your content but this video highlighted to me how necessary it is and how much we overlook how much false information enters the public consciousness even without a deliberate misinformation goal. Somerton said those stupid takes usually to make his videos seem more outrageous and vital, he didn't do it because he had an underlying agenda beyond "make money".

matt

Some viewers are there for the creator, some are there for the content. If the creator changes but the content is the same, some viewers will not be willing to follow. If the creator stays the same but the content changes, some viewers will not be willing to follow. There is nothing bad or abnormal or unexpected about this. This isn’t some big “point” that needs proving. I wasn’t saying he needs to “stay in his lane” I don’t know why you’re trying to start shit here but please leave me out of it.

Catherine S

The video was a banger, but I just want to put it out there that I'd watch Todd's videos on basically anything. Jenny Nicholson is another creator who follows her muse and does videos on random stuff I don't otherwise have strong interest in, but I'm always there watching a 2+ hour-long vid about Evermore because I think she tells the story in an interesting way. I love Todd's videos on music but I also love the ones about buses or shitty YouTubers. TL:DR, if music writing is wearing you out Todd, I'd happily watch you talk about weird movies or beanie babies or fads of the 70s or what have you, and I know I'm not alone.

Alliterative Alias

I confess: I saw this video drop, I noticed it wasn't about music, I never heard of the guy getting fact checked, and I had no intention of watching it. But then I read Todd's introduction to the video here on Patreon and I was riveted. Not by the video, the video was a slog. 38 bull-shit statements that had to be called out one at a time. I got through it because Todd’s snark is just as entertaining when he’s tearing down a bad-faith queer essayist as it is when he’s tearing down dog whistles in country music hits. I got through it because this hitherto unknown-to-me James Somerton’s smug, smarmy voice grated on me and I had to hate-watch to completion. I got through it because journalism is flatlining when we need it more than ever. There’s a reason cape and tights super heroes always hang out with investigative journalists. Todd’s glee doing The Darkness on One Hit Wonderland was endearing. I want to see him review music he loves, or hates. If he wants to do a deep dive on some other topic that moves him, I’m here for it. How many YouTube channels does Simon Whistler fucking have? I see no reason why Todd can’t spin off a second channel if he doesn’t want to muddy the waters. Go for it, Todd. Get your Jon Stewart on. Or chase after a Pulitzer. Do something that makes you feel like it’s not just a schtick that’s burning you out.

Morrigan

I care about the truth being damaged. I care a lot. I think people don't care unless they are taught to care though. Anyway, this was a great piece of writing, I 'm glad I joined this patreon (after being a fan for ~13 years, whoops!)

Irfan

Ino

Irfan

Cloutchase

Arbor Rainier

does the other creator's name rhyme with "lenny licholson ?"

Sarah Schumm

Was it the Cocaine anthem? Because that’s the one that got stuck in my head. Possibly because of the video…

Sarah Schumm

I couldn’t get through it, but I’m not asking for my dollar back because you also made “The Top 10 90’s Busses” it’s ok to do something different now and then.

R.E. Jasso

So have you gotten around to seeing Manhunter yet?