Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

POLL: Fan Favorites - Our Favorite TV Performances

  • Easy Money - King Crimson - Midnight Special 1973 112
  • Comfortably Numb - Pink Floyd - Live 8 2005 131
  • The Musical Box - Genesis - Belgium TV 1972 154
  • Voodoo Chile/Hey Joe/Sunshine - Jimi Hendrix - Happening for Lulu 1969 58
  • Knife Edge - Emerson Lake and Palmer - Beat-Club 1970 92
  • My Generation - The Who - Smothers Brothers 1967 66
  • I Want to Hold Your Hand - The Beatles - Ed Sullivan 1964 39
  • Radio, Radio - Elvis Costello - SNL 1978 32
  • Here Comes the Sun/Homeward Bound - George Harrison & Paul Simon - SNL 1976 62
  • Take a Pebble - Emerson Lake and Palmer - Beat-Club 1970 78
  • Old Man - Neil Young - BBC4 1971 56
  • Live and Let Die - Paul McCartney - Super Bowl 2005 60
  • Enjoy the Silence - Depeche Mode - David Letterman 2013 36
  • Light My Fire - The Doors - Ed Sullivan 1967 65
  • Why - Annie Lennox - Jools Holland 2008 37
  • 2024-09-23
  • —2024-09-30
  • 1078 votes
{'title': 'POLL: Fan Favorites - Our Favorite TV Performances', 'choices': [{'text': 'Easy Money - King Crimson - Midnight Special 1973', 'votes': 112}, {'text': 'Comfortably Numb - Pink Floyd - Live 8 2005', 'votes': 131}, {'text': 'The Musical Box - Genesis - Belgium TV 1972', 'votes': 154}, {'text': 'Voodoo Chile/Hey Joe/Sunshine - Jimi Hendrix - Happening for Lulu 1969', 'votes': 58}, {'text': 'Knife Edge - Emerson Lake and Palmer - Beat-Club 1970', 'votes': 92}, {'text': 'My Generation - The Who - Smothers Brothers 1967', 'votes': 66}, {'text': 'I Want to Hold Your Hand - The Beatles - Ed Sullivan 1964', 'votes': 39}, {'text': 'Radio, Radio - Elvis Costello - SNL 1978', 'votes': 32}, {'text': 'Here Comes the Sun/Homeward Bound - George Harrison & Paul Simon - SNL 1976', 'votes': 62}, {'text': 'Take a Pebble - Emerson Lake and Palmer - Beat-Club 1970', 'votes': 78}, {'text': 'Old Man - Neil Young - BBC4 1971', 'votes': 56}, {'text': 'Live and Let Die - Paul McCartney - Super Bowl 2005', 'votes': 60}, {'text': 'Enjoy the Silence - Depeche Mode - David Letterman 2013', 'votes': 36}, {'text': 'Light My Fire - The Doors - Ed Sullivan 1967', 'votes': 65}, {'text': 'Why - Annie Lennox - Jools Holland 2008', 'votes': 37}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2024, 9, 30, 3, 45, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2024, 9, 23, 17, 53, 31, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 1078}

Content

In this month's edition of the Fan Favorites, we're focusing on our favorite live performances for Television. And, our community has come through with some great selections! Here are the 15 finalists. Select Up To Five of your preferred choices!

This poll will be active through this coming Sunday, September 29!

For your convenience, here's a YouTube Playlist of these selections: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLO0n3LrUjxKrnzr6w1cMWAgznKIUmHK4J&si=bz8VbSxkXE1j9jyy

🚨 NOTE: This month, it is particularly important that you watch the videos in the above YouTube playlist, since this month’s Fan Favorites is not just about the music itself, but particularly these televised live performances. So please do check out the YouTube playlist!

Comments

Mark J Moerman

Regarding the Neil Young clip -- there was no such thing as BBC4 in 1971. BBC4 has existed since around 2002 and often has repeats of archival programming. I'm pretty sure the Neil Young clip originated on BBC2.

Fran B

I’d be curious to know how many genesis fans there are in relation to the total fan base. Let me clarify please. This was NOT a criticism of Genesis or their fan base. I too am a fan. It was simply an observation that - out of the population that voted - 1 in 8 total votes was for Genesis.

joey burgio

Easy Money is the easy choice for me! This is probably the best footage we’ll ever get of KC before their first breakup. Not to mention, this is one of their only live performances of Easy Money that DIDN’T include the quite raunchy & rapey second verse lyrics… “Well, I argued with the judge But the bastard wouldn't budge 'Cause they caught me licking fudge And they never told me once you were a minor” Yet another example of why 70’s prog music will never be replicated in this day & age, sorry not sorry😂

Ruth James

Yay, at last my selection has reached this stage🙂

Karl Stubsjoen

Jeezz. Too many of my favourites on this list. I’ve preferred to vote for Sir Paul, but I realise The Musical Box has a much bigger change to win this. So Genesis it is 👍🏻😉

Matthew Hackbert

Vote for Knife Edge since Doug has not heard it! It also outperformed Take a Pebble in the discord voting. Take a Pebble was already in a BTS episode...

KellieE69

Prince didn’t even make the cut 😭😭😭

Margaret Barnes

Please consider throwing some more love toward Elvis Costello - that “F U” moment on LIVE TV (with Lorne Michaels just off camera, flipping him off the whole time!) was such an iconic moment! It took guts, that early in his career. It got him banned from SNL for the next 12 years, too.😁 So Rock & Roll!! 🤘🤘

rogerb

A bit of background to the Jimi Hendrix performance : - this was a live broadcast - Cream had announced they were splitting up earlier the same day - Hey Joe was the closing number for the show - the next BBC program was their flagship 6pm News that always had to start on time - the Cream tribute meant the show ran over leading to: outrage (at the BBC) that the News should be delayed by a bunch of hippies & Jimi was banned from the BBC At the time live programs on the BBC were taped to allow a single repeat showing and then the tape reused; this recording survived at the end of such a tape long enough for a BBC librarian to recognise the contents and archive it separately.

Ron Swirson

I HOPE Knife Edge edges out Take a Pebble, not because I like one song over another but because the video to Take a Pebble is ruined by annoying 70's video effects and you can't see Keith playing piano. Knife Edge video is clean with no video effects.

Bob Lessard

What! No bands that performed on Don Kirshner's "Rock Concert"!?! Possibly the best live rock concert show of that time. Kirshner was the first to put Kansas on the map with that show.

Salvador Montoro Goethe

A chance to see very early Genesis live...no doubt! Comfortably Numb is also one of my favorites

Guitar Channel

Good to see some Beat Club videos on the list, a show with excellent sound (not lip sync). Old Grey Whistle Test would be another show to explore for future videos.