Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Extended Play Lounge - Episode 19 POLL

  • Jon Anderson - Olias of Sunhillow 41
  • David Gilmour - There's No Way Out of Here 69
  • George Harrison - All Things Must Pass Away 66
  • Chris Squire - Fish Out of Water 54
  • Rick Wakeman - Six Wives of Henry VIII 133
  • 2022-04-27
  • —2022-05-01
  • 363 votes
{'title': 'Extended Play Lounge - Episode 19 POLL', 'choices': [{'text': 'Jon Anderson - Olias of Sunhillow', 'votes': 41}, {'text': "David Gilmour - There's No Way Out of Here", 'votes': 69}, {'text': 'George Harrison - All Things Must Pass Away', 'votes': 66}, {'text': 'Chris Squire - Fish Out of Water', 'votes': 54}, {'text': 'Rick Wakeman - Six Wives of Henry VIII', 'votes': 133}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2022, 5, 1, 3, 0, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2022, 4, 27, 22, 49, 46, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 363}

Content

It is once again time to vote for the next album to be featured in the Extended Play Lounge. This episode will be coming up in the first week of May.

In our last full poll, Dark Side of the Moon won and The Similitude of a Dream came in 2nd. Both of those albums were then featured this past month.Since the voting for Rumours, All Things Must Pass Away, and A Night At The Opera was relatively close, I'm taking this opportunity to start fresh. This is a new poll, where we're selecting from solo albums from artists who were also in big prog/rock bands. Some of these albums have been highly upvoted in our recommendations channel, and I wanted to have a level playing for these albums in the poll. 

Of note...I have not heard any of the Wakeman, Anderson, and Gilmour albums. I have heard some of Squire's (but only one listen). And, I'm familiar with but no expert on Harrison's album.

Happy voting! The poll will run through Saturday, April 30.

Comments

Jeff Waltzer

Really tough choice here. Wish I had multiple votes.

Pat Cecil

the eagle eared may spot Kate Bush singing backing vocals on "There's no way out of here" it that comes out

Barbara Hughes

Doug, it’s All Things Must Pass, not All Things Must Pass Away. 😁❤️

Mark J Moerman

David Gilmour's first solo album is entitled "David Gilmour". "There's No Way Out Of Here" is one of the tracks, but it is not the album title.

Illume Eltanin

All I'll say is Dr. Doug has a vinyl copy of Olias of Sunhillow in his possession to refer to both album artwork and the included story. Apparently a book of the music score for Olias is on its way to him as well, which would make for a very interesting analysis...

Jim Reeves

Much prefer David Gilmore's second, "About Face" to his first album. I voted instead for Olias.

Gary Thobaben

So, it’s in last place here but that Chris Squire record is amazing. Better than Olias IMO. If not the whole record id love a Silently Falling react!

R. Douglas Helvering

Sorry for not double-checking the proper album titles. Now that the poll is active, I can't edit the choices.

MrWondrous David Beckwith

Jon and Rick created entire worlds with their albums. Not sure I can say the same of the others. Not as familiar.

Juan Ignacio Quesada

VERY tough choice! Can I vote for all? Rick Wakeman was my vote, but I love almost equally Olias

Richard Moore

Much as I like Harrison, I'm more interested in hearing Doug's take on prog albums. I picked Olias, because it's the one I'm least familiar with, having heard it only a few times and not for a while.

Steve MacArthur

It's time for the Wake! Though perhaps Journey might have made a better opening gambit...

Allen

One thing about Wakeman's solo albums: they move too fast through some interesting motifs/themes/melodies. I have a feeling (if Wakeman wins), Doug will be disappointed. Especially since the subject matter (16th century England) is so intriguing to use as a concept album. I think Steve Hackett's "Voyage of the Acolyte" is more interesting than all five of these selections.

John Clark

Perhaps a mash up of the Prog albums? Say, 1,2&4 from Squire,tracks 1,3 and 4 of Wakeman, 1,2,7,8&9 from Gilmour and all of side one from the Anderson?

Eduardo Alejandro del Corral Lira

Will admit, Six Wives while fantastic, is overshadowed by its great neighbor "Journey to the Center of Earth" ... Hopefully that will one day get its turn

Nick

I hope Chris Squire gets some more love. It's a wonderful album.

Garance A Drosehn

For a Rick Wakeman album I'd recommend "Journey to the Center of Earth" or the more recent "The Red Planet" over "Six Wives of Henry VIII". I voted for Gilmour's self-titled solo album, which includes several excellent songs (IMO!). I was working at a college, and that album was played frequently in the dorms for several years after it was released.

Garance A Drosehn

In the category of solo albums by members of notable prog-rock bands, another album that I'd expect Doug would really enjoy would be the recent album "Five" from Tony Banks (one of the members of Genesis). Tony worked with The Czech National Symphony Orchestra and Choir for that release.

Nicholas Karter

I cannot get into Journey. It is over orchestrated for simple themes, The synth sound is thin and annoying and the singing is awful. I much prefer Six wives and I think Criminal Record contains the best Wakeman composition, Judas Iscariot, with powerful church organ and synth sounds.

Eusebio R-Z

No-brainer for me. In my totally unscientific opinion, 6 Wives is one of the greatest albums of the XX Century. It is also one of those uncommon cases where a member's solo work makes it into a live album for the band. I respectfully agree to disagree with people who prefer other Wakeman's albums :P

Douglas W Gann

Wakeman is the obvious choice here. High school hijinks. Wakeman on the walkman after sneaking into the backyard to get stoned before bed.... But sometime soon, I still believe either of Gilmore's solo albums demonstrate genius and either is worth a spin.

Jason Stockwell

Olias has what I assume are very interesting keys and structures... the chord progressions are so out there.

Müseyib Ələkbər

You would check out Phideaux's album "Doomsday Afternoon". I've been waiting for this 😥

Göran Wallby

Easy choise. Chris Squire. Great album

Paul Hoyle

All great albums that I'm sure will be reviewed eventually....I feel Jon Anderson's album is the most creative and exciting of all of these though....please spin this eventully

Dave Cohen

Six Wives is an amazing album. I can't wait for you to do it in the EPL. It's a natural.

Richard H

Wakeman is a great keyboard player, but his solo albums always sound dreadfully under-produced, with awful vocalists.

Mike D

The two selections that really benefit from a cover-to-cover listen are the Anderson and Wakeman. Olias gets my vote, since it's a truly singular achievement.

Aarf

All interesting choices, I voted Wakeman (a sort of nostalgic choice for me). The good thing is that in time, I feel all will be featured here, just because they are good interesting music.

bobj

I find it interesting that three of these choices are former members of Yes.

James Hyzy

All good choices, I think Squire's is the most musically diverse. If not this time, I hope Doug reviews it eventually. Doug has been a fan of Squire throughout his Yes reviews.

Adam Miles

It seems I'm outvoted by the Yes-adjacent contingent (which is okay!), but I'd really dig seeing George Harrison get some love on the YouTube channel, if not a full EPL. The tracks from ATMP that I'd love to see Doug review are "Beware of Darkness" (probably the most interesting musically) or "Awaiting On You All" (best use of Spector's production style and great lyrics).

Frits van Voorst

I agree with Richard Hessler. Solo albums of Rick Wakeman never have impressed me. Sometimes a single track did, like Judas Iscariot, which has a ‘borrowed’ classical theme. He’s a great keyboard player within a group like Yes: there lies his real talent, as a team player.

Paul Hoyle

I am amazed that the best album on the list is currently last!! I can only think many have not heard it yet?

Neale Brassell

This would have been an interesting poll with just the solo albums from the members of Yes after Relayer... the two listed above, plus Alan White's Ramshackled, Steve Howe's Beginnings, and Patrick Moraz's The Story of i. Personally I don't really care for White's or Howe's, but the other three would be a close call. Moraz's, specifically, is really... out there. He beat Gabriel to the punch incorporating world music into prog by many years!

Russell Clemons

Hey, I've seen numerous songs/bands I've wanted to see reactions to. There are a couple bands though that in searching I've noticed haven't shown up that I think would be interesting to see reactions/analysis to First is a band called "Thank you Scientist" I'd suggest "FXMLDR" specifically with the Bluecoats marching band. The are Jazz/prog rock. Second is Between the Buried and Me. I'd start with something like "fix the error" or if you want to go with a huge epic "White walls". They are more Grind Core meets Progmetal

Itsfun2listen

If you want to see how yes performed at the hall of fame without Chris, then Geddy stepped up to the plate and does a mega job, fantastic version of Roundabout