Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

Content

I'm excited to finally dive into this piece, which I found to be already one of my favorites from this band. Join me as I peel back the layers of this beautiful and poignant classic song!

Unlisted Vimeo Link: https://vimeo.com/738042007/72e2d51a4c

Files

Take a Pebble (ELP) - Behind the Score (Episode 25)

Comments

Colin Heath

Thanks so much for diving into this piece as you so eloquently put it. It truly is a wonderous piece of both composition and performance. I myself have zero understanding of the complexities that went into the writing as I've never been a party to any musical theory at all. I just know that music is the greatest and only true language in the world and I love hearing you enthuse over the many, many masterpieces out there.

Stop Propaganda

Having had a long term correspondence relationship with Greg Lake, I can say he was a very talented and upbeat person. I miss our emails and hand written letters. Doug, thanks for looking into some of his work along with his seriously talented band mates and I hope that calligraphy I sent you found a home somewhere on the wall of you home, its where it belongs!

Don Mal 1

wow....very cool.....dk

Peter Tutak

The Chambers Brothers, King Crimson, and the Nice. I would have paid the $5 or $5.50 for what the best seats in the house cost at the time to hear that show. (God bless Bill Graham for putting together such eclectic bills at the FE, FW, and Winterland.) The fast section here (past the ostinato), along with Fairport Convention's "Dirty Linen" (Dave Pegg) and Glenn Cornick's Bourree solo were the first really hard pieces I attempted on the bass back around 1971, and were my first inkling that the bass could serve more purpose than just establishing root functions and got me using the pinky finger on my fret hand. That was all she wrote. Nice work on teasing apart the magic of this piece and illuminating what makes it so special. Thanks, Doug - great work !

MrWondrous David Beckwith

I got yer plagal cadence right here in my britches! I'll prolong yer tonic! Kidding. I'd get caught. With that out of the way, let me congratulize you for this most tasteful classic, which more than most songs, showcases Greg's angelic voice. Using only piano was a good editorial choice too. Some of the percussion seemed supererogatory and added little...at least until the end, where the tympanic tonitruations were a source of horripilation and resolve.

Frank D

I love the Behind The Score episodes! You always look so happy following and explaining and critiquing the piece. I've loved this piece since it was released, lord knows how many times I've played it. Also, it was uncanny how well they reproduced this in concert. Keith really was such a great talent, as were Greg and Carl. The first supergroup indeed! Great episode Doug!

Tony Wawryk

A beautiful piece, which I never tire of hearing over 50 years since the first time. As our dictionary-swallowing friend David Beckwith says (I learned three new words today, though I'm not sure when I'll get the chance to use them - horripilation though, got to get that one in somewhere! :) ), it showcases Greg's superb voice, but also his guitar and bass playing, the latter particularly tasteful. I happen to think Palmer's work, especially with brushes, fits in well and adds tonal and rhythmic variety over the top of Keith's left-hand ostinato. They really stretched out when they played it live - sometimes a little too far - but that they took on and successfully played this incredible music live showed what talents they were (are, in Palmer's case, still a superb drummer). Thanks for walking us through this one, Doug! Pirates live from Montreal Olympic Stadium next, please!

Randy Hammill

I think I’ve always loved Keith’s piano pieces the most. Live this would become an extended improvised piano solo where he would throw in quotes from various classical, jazz, and other pieces. Greg would then have an acoustic solo section, not this solo but several of his pieces (like Lucky Man and Still…You Turn Me On). Keith tended to speed up the solo sections, though, which I think impacted their musicality. Although it did highlight how good his left hand was.

Allen

I'm wondering if Doug considers this "progressive rock": some jazz improvs, but mainly a classically-folk arranged piece?

R. Douglas Helvering

It’s definitely a hybrid style…but its backbone is folk/singer-songwriter…which, given this expert treatment, becomes something really special.

Allen

Just to further the conversation about the archetypal progressive rock piece (or album), it seems like the Moody Blues's "Days of Future Passed" relies on soulful, blues-derived wailing to deliver a "mood" across their melodic/rhythmic compositions (I don't have the background you do to assess what their song structure is based around, such as meter, chord progressions, etc.). If that style of vocal delivery were to change, would it assume a more "pop"-oriented sound? Maybe that's the key to defining "progressive rock": its hybridity? Regardless, I'm looking forward to "The Inner Mounting Flame," a truly unique and standout album!

Allen

Thanks Doug! I'm interested in vocalization because my gut sense is Led Zeppelin, for example, would have a different audience if someone like Buddy Holly were singing to the music of Bonham, Page, and Jones? I'm assuming, however, that Holly would be motivated to sing in a different manner based on Zeppelin's hard-driving rhythm section and Page's mode of composition. It's an interesting question as to how vocalists contribute to the songwriting process. I guess it depends on the seed of the song (if the vocalist presents a piece of music, a demo on tape, and the bluesy quality is already there, vs. the guitar/bass player initiating the first fragments of what would become the finished song).

Gerard Dion

Thank you Doug for your analysis of this beautiful song! I really enjoyed it! It really presages what ELP will later become and is a fine showcase for the brilliance of Keith Emerson IMO. It's terribly sad that he's no longer with us. I would have loved to hear you both discuss this song together. Now, when are you getting to Pirates, please?