On Winning: The End of Decisive Victory (Patreon)
Content
When a nation goes to war, its citizens generally expect one of two outcomes: decisive victory or absolute defeat. Above all, they expect a definitive end to the hostilities.
This expectation is based on our classic perception of warfare, forged largely by the events of World War I and especially World War II. In WWII, the Allies—a massive multinational coalition—defeated the German military in open combat. Unable to fight further, Germany surrendered unconditionally and was subsequently occupied. This resulted in the rewriting of their constitution, the installation of a new government, and the total dismantling of their war machine. It was not just the end of the war; it was the end of the conflict. Today, there are no lingering military tensions between these nations in Western Europe, and the underlying geopolitical conflict is definitively resolved.
Contrast this with modern theaters like Ukraine or the Middle East. Despite war being waged with mid-to-full industrial capacity, an end to these conflicts is nowhere in sight. Instead, we see grinding stalemates, political decisions to restrict force, and "surgical strikes" that degrade an enemy’s capabilities but fail to force a strategic decision.
The Ukraine Paradox
When Russia invaded Ukraine, it aimed for a rapid, decisive victory through deep operations and overwhelming mechanized maneuver—true to its historical military doctrine. However, the reality of Ukrainian resistance and modern battlefield lethality denied them that quick win, forcing Russia into a grinding war of attrition.
More than four years later, nothing decisive has occurred, and the Russian economy is straining under the weight of the effort. Even if Russian forces eventually managed to occupy Kyiv, the war would almost certainly devolve into a massive insurgency. On the flip side, even if Ukraine manages to push Russian forces completely out of its territory, the underlying conflict will not end; it will only be a matter of time before Russia or its proxy forces initiate new offensives. The conflict has become eternal.
The Middle East Theater
The standoff between Israel, the United States, and Iran is another eternal conflict. Most of us grew up anticipating a violent climax to this tension. Yet, despite repeated tactical military successes and targeted assassinations, we do not see the Iranian regime fall. Conversely, we do not see the U.S. or Israel reducing their military postures.
The reasons for this modern phenomenon of "eternal conflict" are manifold. Let's break down why the era of decisive victory is over:
1. Nuclear Weapons Nuclear weapons remain the ultimate trump card. They are so lethal, and their use so globally stigmatized, that they are stockpiled solely for when a nation’s very existence is at stake. As soon as an invading force breaches the sovereign soil of a nuclear-armed nation and begins to win, the deployment of nuclear weapons becomes a highly probable option. This threat of mutually assured destruction is why full-scale ground invasions against nuclear-equipped foes are essentially obsolete. A decisive military victory is impossible because a losing nuclear power will simply flip the board to survive.
2. Hyperlethality Modern weapon systems have become so precise and lethal that it is now incredibly difficult to take and hold ground. Sensor-to-shooter kill chains are blisteringly fast; as soon as ground is taken, artillery, drones, and air assets are standing by to clear it. Successfully seizing significant territory requires a level of multi-domain synchronization that most nation-states simply cannot achieve. In the modern era, the defense holds a massive structural advantage over the offense.
3. The Global Economy Most states are inextricably tied to the global economy, creating a form of economic mutually assured destruction. A U.S. strike on China, for instance, would rob countless countries (including the U.S. itself) of critical production assets. Conversely, China is heavily dependent on global sales to sustain its economy. International economic pressure creates a powerful downward spiral on large-scale, decisive war efforts.
The Strait of Hormuz is another perfect example of this economic leverage. While the Iranian Navy consists largely of small patrol boats, and it is unclear if they have even deployed mines on a large scale, the mere threat of disruption is enough. Even when trade vessels pass the strait without incident, insurance companies raise premiums so high that the economic cost of the conflict is felt globally without a single shot being fired.
4. The Internet and Urbanization The internet and social media have made it easier than ever to spread data, coordinate logistics, and motivate insurgent forces on a global scale. Furthermore, as human populations increasingly condense into sprawling megacities, occupying foreign territory has become a logistical nightmare. These digital networks ensure that the ideological roots of a conflict are eternally conserved and amplified, allowing insurgencies to outlast conventional occupying armies.
Conclusion
We must recognize that decisive victory is largely a concept of the past. While decisive battles still occur and remain tactically important, there is almost no practical way left to permanently resolve a major geopolitical conflict by military means alone.
As always, thanks for your attention.