Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

You are patrolling along a crest. Suddenly, you take fire from a small machine gun position. Your reaction is textbook: Alpha and Bravo return fire to fix the enemy, you assemble a support and assault element, and you select an avenue of approach. It should be an easy task to take out a small MG nest.

Alpha assaults through, executing a right-hook flanking attack because the right side provides the best micro-terrain for a covered approach. Suddenly, you hear a bang. Your lead man just got taken out by a booby trap or a UXO (Unexploded Ordnance). You suddenly lost 50% of your assault element. At this point, taking out the MG position becomes extremely difficult, and you decide to withdraw.

You lost this engagement. Were your tactics bad?

No! You applied gold-standard tactics. You fixed the enemy, selected the best avenue of approach, and split your teams correctly. What you couldn’t know was that a piece of unexploded ordnance was sitting on your perfectly selected route.

Could you have sent a scout team to recon the route first? Sure. But that would have resulted in so much lost momentum and surprise that the suppressed enemy would have likely found a way to reposition and prepare for your flanking attack. We are only talking about probabilities and "what ifs" here. Even if the ordnance was a deliberately placed mine, hitting it was more bad luck than a failure of skill.

The Illusion of Control

Bad luck has lost battles throughout human history. Whether it was unpredictable storms wiping out entire naval invasion fleets or modern radios inexplicably failing at the worst possible moment, warfare is governed by chance. The famous military theorist Carl von Clausewitz called this "Friction"—the countless unforeseeable variables that make simple tasks incredibly difficult.

The fact that luck is such a massive factor in warfare is something that tactical enthusiasts and preppers hate to admit. A lot of people in this space have a deep-rooted control disorder; recognizing that luck matters means their most important psychological safety blanket—absolute control—is suddenly ripped away.

Micro Scale: "All Skill, No Luck"?

The smaller we go regarding scale, the more the lines between skill and luck blur. In a hypothetical 1-on-1 CQB situation where no deliberate planning is possible (like an Immediate Active Shooter Response), the skills of shooting and cognitive processing become paramount, but luck is still in the room.

At some point, you have to make a dynamic entry where you simply won't be able to check every deep corner simultaneously. You can only hope to "out-speed" your bad luck. Luck and skill are absolutely connected at this micro-level, and overdeveloped hard skills (marksmanship) are what you use to aggressively mitigate bad luck.

Macro Scale: Mitigating Fate

Of course, you are not a mere slave to fate. Two factors can mitigate the impact of bad luck on a larger scale:

1. Deliberate Planning: The longer we think about a plan, the more contingencies we can build. By framing the situation, we can restrict the variables that rely on luck. However, due to the nature of time, the operational picture will eventually change. If you take too long to make a decision or conduct a movement, the enemy will adapt, and you will face a very different situation than the one you initially planned for.

2. Unrelenting Speed: Contrary to deliberate thinking, speed has no cap that stacks the odds against you. The returns are not diminishing. If you have incredibly fast processing speed—in terms of spatial awareness, psychomotor skills, and pattern recognition—you can override what appears to be bad luck. In fact, you can create your own luck. Is that "lucky" snapshot in a hallway really luck, or is it the result of thousands of hours of processing and shooting reps?

Conclusion

At the end of the day, luck will always play a role, and carefully trying to prepare against every single odd simply won't work out.

That is exactly why professional militaries formulate an EMLCOA (Enemy's Most Likely Course of Action) and an EMDCOA (Enemy's Most Dangerous Course of Action) and build basic contingency plans off of those. Your best bet against bad luck at the deliberate level is good intelligence, while fast reaction times and pattern recognition skills will stack the odds in your favor on the ground.

As always, thanks for your attention.

Files

Comments

Keith wong

Yeah weather elements can also change pretty quickly

Thomas Blau

One of the best examples of how much luck can matter is the 507th Maintenance Company ambush during the Battle of Nasiriyah (part of 2003 Iraq invasion). Radios weren't working, M2 .50 cal machine guns on the vehicles malfunctioned during the ambush, and the ambush was mainly caused due to a navigational error largely stemming from extreme fatigue and stress leading to poor communication and coordination. The extreme fatigue and stress was due to the unit conducting a multi day push without rest (which is why training under hard conditions is important) since the overall invasion needed to move fast. I am sure every one of us has made a wrong turn while driving during a long trip. Human error is not something you can every completely eliminate and there are definitely factors that can increase the risk of incidents stemming from human error.