Training: Why Slow Is Smooth, But Smooth Is Not Fast (Patreon)
Content
"Slow is smooth, and smooth is fast." It is probably the most common training fallacy in the tactical community.
On the surface, it seems logical. Learning a skill slowly and smoothly allows you to absorb all the details and nuances, supposedly providing you with the ability to speed that skill up on demand. Furthermore, our brains assume that a skill executed "smoothly" will naturally outpace a skill that looks jerky or explosive. But science and biomechanics tell a very different story.
Basics vs. Fundamentals We have covered the difference between basics and fundamentals before, but for those who missed it, here is the concept in a nutshell:
Basic: Learning the mechanics of a skill (e.g., how to change a magazine).
Fundamental: Applying and speeding up that skill under realistic conditions.
This distinction is where the idea of "slow is smooth" begins to fall apart, and it is exactly where the myth is rooted.
When you learn a basic skill, you need to understand the mechanics. An instructor will walk you through the necessary steps, you will slowly conduct them under supervision, and finally, you will prove that you can execute the task independently. Congratulations, you are now able to swap a magazine. This is the foundation of proven learning models like the World War II-era Training Within Industry (TWI) program. It is a fantastic system for delivering basic mechanics.
Slow is Just Slow! You have learned to slowly swap a magazine. To change it fast, you actually have to train fast. Sports methodology gives us clear parameters on how intensely we need to push ourselves. The first step in speeding up a process is to push to 50% perceived effort. Later, you need to push to 85%—this is the sweet spot where you learn to balance speed with security. But ultimately, you must get reps in at 100% perceived effort from time to time. Yes, to be fast, you must physically train fast.
The reason for this is that our brains and muscles work entirely differently at high speeds. At a low perceived effort, your body primarily recruits slow-twitch muscle fibers. Furthermore, your brain processes the information differently. This is easily proven when you try to teach someone a task you are used to doing at lightning speed. For example, tying an overhand knot that you casually whip together in a fraction of a second becomes surprisingly difficult to describe and execute in slow motion. This is because your brain relies on subconscious cadence and rhythm when executing high-speed motor tasks, not conscious step-by-step thinking.
Smooth is Not Always Fast Skills that are executed slowly can be conducted with incredible smoothness. The reality of fast execution, however, is very different. Fast-twitch muscle fibers rely on explosive momentum—momentum that you must abruptly interrupt and reverse in order to change directions. If you were to watch a high-speed skill executed utilizing maximum acceleration and deceleration in slow motion, the result would look violent and snappy, not "smooth."
The bottom line is simple but critical: Changing a mag fast is not the same skill as changing a mag slowly. The learning process, the involved muscle fibers, and the neural pathways are inherently different. If "slow is smooth and smooth is fast" were physiologically true, an elite endurance marathoner would automatically be an Olympic sprinter. Both types of motion are running, but they are entirely different disciplines.