Why "Shooter's Preference" is Not a Learning Tool (Patreon)
Content
One of the most annoying phrases in the tactical training world is "shooter's preference."
While I understand the idea that sometimes individual, comfort-based decisions can be the right way to go, it is crucial to understand that uniformity and standards are the absolute pillars of military and law enforcement operations.
I remember a certain training evolution when I was young enlisted. I was a horrible shooter, and almost every question I asked regarding how to hold the rifle to improve my accuracy was answered with, "That's shooter's preference." Back in those days, I thought this particular instructor was a seasoned, professional soldier who embraced individual biomechanics. Yet, I still didn't become a better shooter after applying my supposed "preferences." Looking back now, I know the truth: that instructor simply had no clue how to teach the fundamentals.
Standards Exist for a Reason
An armed organization, just like a successful private business, is built on standards. Standards provide us with an out-of-the-box solution that harnesses the hard-earned lessons of the past. As such, standards should be held high.
Still, neglecting standards, uniform regulations, and SOPs (Standard Operating Procedures) is often viewed as a sign of "edginess." It creates the false impression of being a battle-hardened veteran who is too experienced to "act out of the manual."
Even on the tactical layer, standards deconflict tactical decisions. This doesn’t mean we must adhere to the textbook 1:1 in every chaotic scenario, but if we lose comms in a firefight, our attached elements can at least anticipate what we are doing because we share a baseline doctrine. We also need that baseline so we can actually tell a trainee how to hold a rifle.
What "Shooter's Preference" is Really About
Shooter's preference should be about adaptation, not invention.
Our initial blueprint should always be the SOP or the manual. When we are in the field and realize that the manual solution won't work for a specific problem, we adapt. This adaptation is largely based on harvested experience—experience created by actually applying SOPs, seeing them fail under certain conditions, and figuring out the why. But when we start out as beginners with a "made-up" approach or internet wisdom, we lack the baseline required to know if our new SOPs are actually bad.
The Training Industry and the "Signature Move"
In the age of social media and competing private tactical training companies, we see a lot of weird things that you will never find in any manual. Ridiculously high shoulder stock placement is one of those trends. A professional soldier should immediately recognize that this is not how you are supposed to hold a rifle or manage recoil.
Still, influencers often imply that "vast experience" and "lessons learned downrange" made these hardened veterans transition to this new technique. The far more likely explanation, however, is that these individuals have transitioned into the commercial training world and desperately need something to make their product stand out.
Doing something entirely different is Marketing 101. In a very small and highly competitive market, you need a "signature move" to get noticed, even if it degrades your actual combat effectiveness.
Kit Placement and "Preferences"
While I am not a proponent of hyper-strict uniform regulations, I personally believe that a professional look makes a lot of sense, especially during garrison duty. Things can—and will—get more relaxed once you deploy, but there needs to be a baseline of professionalism.
Interestingly, standards become more important when you are outside the wire. When you have a four-man element and all four soldiers have their IFAK (Individual First Aid Kit) placed in four different pouches in four different locations, you are not acting like a battle-hardened veteran. You are literally obscuring life-saving equipment. In a high-stress trauma scenario, nobody has time to search your rig to find your tourniquet.
Minor kit changes based on individual preferences are a good thing, but those modifications need to be earned through time under gear. Imagine setting up your vest with zero real-world experience based purely on your "preferences." At that stage, your preferences are nothing more than suspicions.
Conclusion
Neglecting standards is not a sign of professionalism; it’s a sign of bad training. A true professional is able to explain and physically demonstrate the standard textbook solution at the highest level, and is then able to identify the operational need for deviations to adapt that standard to the environment.
As always, thanks for your attention.