Layering: Hacks & Fallacies (Patreon)
Content
We have covered the science and application of layering several times on this page, so you should be fully set up to layer your garments the right way. With that being said, we still get a lot of questions. Questions never hurt—unless they are dumb—so I want to use this article to cover some hacks and fallacies regarding insulation and waterproof layering.
Let's start with everything associated with Gore-Tex (GTX) layers.
Gore-Tex (GTX) Hacks & Fallacies
1. Should I wear my BDU under my GTX layer? Generally speaking, wearing your BDU (Battle Dress Uniform) under a GTX layer is a liability that will result in either overheating or freezing. If you are wearing a standard field shirt, you should not wear it under your GTX jacket. The reason is simple: NYCO (Nylon/Cotton) is not a technical fabric.
When it's hot, you will trap heat and collect moisture under your GTX jacket. When it's cold, that moisture will get trapped inside your NYCO uniform, making it clammy and rapidly leading to hypothermia. Whenever you can, take the time to ditch your field top, or just wear a breathable combat shirt. Obviously, if it suddenly downpours on a patrol, you won't have time to strip down, but whenever you dictate the pace, dress properly.
2. GTX jacket: Under or over my Plate Carrier? If you are absolutely certain that you will be wearing GTX the entire time, you can wear it under your Plate Carrier (PC), but it will not breathe as well. It is usually much more practical to wear your GTX jacket over your PC—just buy a jacket one or two sizes larger to accommodate the gear. While GTX breathes best when worn tight to the body, it’s vastly more practical to just throw it over your kit. You can compensate for the trapped heat by leaving the main zipper open to ventilate.
3. Field clothing over GTX? While you lose some breathability, this is an absolutely valid idea for a niche tactical application: noise discipline. GTX makes a very loud, characteristic "swishing" sound when the fabric rubs against itself. Therefore, wearing your NYCO or softshell garments over your GTX jacket and pants can make a lot of sense during a stealthy night approach. There are actually lightweight GTX options specifically designed to be worn under a uniform for this exact reason.
4. Can I put my GTX garments in the washing machine? You not only can do this, but you absolutely should! It is an eternal barracks myth that you shouldn't wash GTX. GTX can and should be washed at 40°C (104°F) on a gentle cycle. Pollution from dirt, carbon, and especially salt from your sweat will clog the pores and drastically ruin the garment's breathability.
Furthermore, you don't need to constantly reapply DWR (Durable Water Repellent) spray after each wash. In fact, you should do another thing the barracks lawyers tell you not to do: put it in the dryer! A low-heat tumble dry will actually reactivate the garment's existing DWR coating.
Insulation Hacks & Fallacies
Now let's go over insulation garments. You will notice some similar themes here.
1. Should I wear my insulation garment over my BDU? Again, putting a non-technical layer (NYCO) between two technical layers serves little purpose. You either wear your insulation layer as an outer top layer (especially large high-loft jackets) or you wear it between your base layer and your BDU.
This is dictated by the circumstances. If your insulation layer is just for short, static stops (like a short halt on patrol), it's best to just throw a massive puffy jacket over all your kit. If you know you will need the insulation all the time (especially low-loft jackets or fleeces), keep it well protected under your BDU. Just keep in mind that wearing a Plate Carrier will compress the jacket, reducing its ability to trap warm air.
2. Is it important to have loft pants? Absolutely! If you are operating in an environment with harsh winters, you will need loft pants for prolonged static work (like manning an Observation Post). In many environments, it is also highly advantageous to sleep in your loft jacket and loft pants instead of using a sleeping bag. The tactical ability to immediately stand up, grab your rifle, and move during a nighttime alert is well worth trying this setup.
3. Should I use the compression stuff-sack for my loft clothing? The rule of thumb here is: As long as you don't need to, don't use it. Every time you tightly compress a piece of loft gear, it loses some of its future insulation capabilities due to micro-damage done to the loft fibers. Of course, if your ruck is already bursting with water and ammo, it's better to compress the jacket than to freeze without it. But generally speaking, avoid it. If you are storing your puffy gear at the base or at home, leave it uncompressed on a hanger!
4. Low loft or high loft? Most people make the mistake of buying a massive, super-insulating high-loft jacket first. Don't do this. You should always build your layers from the bottom up.
First, get proper thermal base layers.
Next, get a heavier mid-layer (like a 200g fleece or Merino wool pullover). This alone is sufficient for most temperate weather.
Next, get a low-loft jacket for static work.
If you still freeze wearing all of this, then it is time to consider a high-loft jacket. Building from the bottom up provides you with a modular system for all seasons, rather than just one massive coat you can only wear in a blizzard.
5. What is a "thermal base layer"? This is a colloquial term for next-to-skin layers that have built-in thermal properties. This is achieved by either making the fabric thicker or adding an internal grid texture (like a waffle top) to trap dead air against the skin. Generally, thermal base layers are built on the idea that in harsh environments (like Northern Europe), you will always need some baseline insulation, even when conducting highly demanding physical activities.
Conclusion
Generally, layering is a simple concept. Don’t overthink it; the simplest explanation is usually the correct one. Layer up properly, care for your technical fabrics, and collect your own field experience based on your subjective comfort.
As always, thanks for your attention.