Tactics: The Importance of Adaptation and Pattern Recognition (Patreon)
Content
We have repeatedly criticized instructors who teach over-engineered Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) for every conceivable scenario.
The cognitive workload required to learn a dedicated, highly specific procedure for every possible environmental variable creates a dangerous imbalance between training variety and actual repetitions. In short, learning a new technique takes time and mental bandwidth to memorize. If you are trying to learn 30 different micro-SOPs for the exact same primary task, you will end up trapped in a cycle of learning and maintaining niche skills, leaving you with zero time to get sufficient, high-quality repetitions on the fundamentals.
While there is absolutely a time and place to introduce environmental variety, it’s not in the lecture room or during initial dry runs. Let's first explore the main issue at hand.
Solutions for Non-Existent Problems
Especially in the CQB (Close Quarters Battle) realm, instructors who make their living selling over-optimized procedures often base their entire curriculum on the "What If?" argument.
For example, there is a widely circulated idea that if there is heavy furniture in a room, the basic principles of Strong-Walling or Points of Domination (PoD) will fail. This premise, however, assumes that the assault team behaves like unthinking robots who simply crash into couches and get stuck.
In reality, when you train a team in PoD CQB from basic tape drills and eventually start throwing in pieces of furniture, the team naturally adapts. They will subconsciously handle the heavy furniture like physical walls, stopping their movement along the perimeter only when forward progress is simply no longer possible.
This requires fast processing speed and strong pattern recognition skills. In this context, pattern recognition means nothing more than projecting the foundational movement pattern of PoD into a room full of clutter. As long as the basic principle and intent of PoD are fulfilled, the baseline procedure still works. You don't need a new SOP for a sofa.
The CQB vs. SUT Double Standard
In Small Unit Tactics (SUT), no instructor will ever teach you 30 different techniques for conducting a flanking attack based on slightly different vegetation, tree density, or cover. You are expected to understand the core principle and rapidly adapt to the terrain.
Why should it be any different in CQB? The direction of your flanking attack, the exact angle of your threshold evaluation, the distance of your bounds—these are all dynamically dictated by the live situation, not by regurgitating 30 isolated, hyper-specific drills.
There is "Tactics" in TTPs
People love to talk about TTPs (Tactics, Techniques, and Procedures). Whether you are relying on a rigid procedure or a fluid technique, the "thinking" part of tactics—adapting to a situation on the fly—will never fade away completely.
Whether operating in SUT or CQB, combat is a game of seconds or even sub-seconds. Improving your pattern recognition skills is critical to winning that time. Your brain memorizes every scenario you run. At first, pattern recognition starts as a conscious thought: "I've been in this situation before, I did X to solve it, let's try it again." Eventually, through sheer volume of reps, it evolves into a subconscious decision pulled instantly from the depths of your memory. You will react and adapt organically, and the only way to build that skill is by getting enough core repetitions.
Building the Scenario and the "Flow"
Once you have mastered your isolated dry runs in a plain, open area or a taped-out room, it is time to add variety.
Change the position and number of enemy targets. Add single pieces of furniture or complex terrain, and slowly increase that clutter. Later on, you can introduce variables like friendly casualties, weapons malfunctions, or simulated radio comms failure. This is how you and your subordinates learn to be actual tacticians.
Do not aim for an instructor to hold your hand and spoon-feed you the "perfect" solution mid-exercise. A high-level instructor will silently memorize every step you took, only interrupting the exercise if there is a severe safety violation or a complete failure of the tactical intent. Everything else is saved for a detailed AAR (After Action Review) discussing why you made the choices you did. Constantly pausing an exercise to correct a shooter's foot placement is lazy, didactically incorrect training.
Ultimately, building a "flow" is what every tactician strives for, whether in the shoot-house or the woods. You want a fluid, violent procedure that naturally adapts to the chaos. This is absolutely not achieved by trying to pick the right procedure out of a mental rolodex of 15 options. It is achieved by mastering a highly limited amount of core procedures, and adapting them to the circumstances based on hard-earned experience.
As always, thanks for your attention.