Why The IAR Is an Evolutionary Dead End (Patreon)
Content
The Infantry Automatic Rifle (IAR) is a buzzword that is currently all over Instagram. Honestly, I am somewhat split here. Usually, all the "modern IARs" we see on social media are enthusiast and hobbyist topics, and I don’t want to chime in and ruin someone’s day just because they tinker around with gear they like in their off-time.
But because we are in the tactical community—perhaps the only "hobbyist" community where every project needs to be justified with a real-world "need"—we have to actually chime in and talk about the nonsense that IARs are. As usual, we find most of our answers by looking at history and military application.
The Automatic Rifle
The most prominent historical example of an automatic rifle was the BAR. This weapon system was largely deployed in WWI and WWII by a position called the "Automatic Rifleman," and we can actually see where this journey goes when we just take a look at the context and nomenclature. The automatic rifle was essentially nothing more than a rifle that could fire a common cartridge on full-auto, usually utilizing a heavy barrel and a bipod.
In WWI and WWII, a rifle that could fire on full-auto was something special, as most issued rifles could only fire semi-auto at best, or were standard bolt-action rifles. Furthermore, the only nation that had developed a dedicated General Purpose Machine Gun (GPMG) at this point was Germany. Other than that, militaries relied on light and heavy machine guns. Light machine guns were very close to what an "Automatic Rifle" was, but they almost exclusively featured quick-change barrels. Concepts like the Squad Automatic Weapon (SAW) were not even in development yet.
So, let's look at the defining traits of a historical automatic rifle:
Fully Automatic
Man-Portable
No Quick-Change Barrel
Magazine Fed
Fires a Common Cartridge
Equipped with a Bipod
When Germany developed its first Sturmgewehr (assault rifle), there was suddenly a weapon that was better in almost every aspect than the BAR or the IAR concept. It is not surprising that—except for a few outliers like the RPK—IAR development was completely halted and proved to be an evolutionary dead end due to the invention of the assault rifle. The fact that most nations later adopted the concept of the GPMG, and that the modern squad automatic weapon followed a few decades later, is a further testament to the IAR being completely obsolete. It became nothing more than another annoyance in the already bloated armory systems of most militaries.
The USMC and the IAR
The "return" of the IAR was essentially heralded when the USMC adopted the HK416 as the M27 IAR, replacing the M249 SAW. We have to keep in mind, however, that the USMC argued this based heavily on the realities of the Global War on Terror (GWOT), where accuracy was deemed more important than sheer volume of fire.
Ultimately, the M249 was kept in armories anyway. Even more tellingly, in 2017 the M27 IAR became the standard-issue rifle of the USMC. This made it essentially just another assault rifle that "could suppress if necessary"—an idea that WWII Germany explicitly cited as the main reason for developing assault rifles in the first place. So, the IAR wasn’t actually a game changer here. Some people in procurement circles still bring up the point that the entire IAR project was essentially a Trojan horse set up from the beginning to justify the procurement of a new assault rifle for the chronically budget-strapped USMC.
Don’t Make Stuff Up
This brings us back to the current Instagram trend. While it can be fun to clone military rifles or build heavy-barreled setups for the flat range, the IAR concept remains an evolutionary dead end and is not something necessary for civilian applications.
Modern mil-spec assault rifles (and their semi-automatic civilian counterparts) are highly capable of providing short bursts of suppressive fire on their own. It is better to be proficient in understanding what a standard rifle is actually supposed to be. Doctrinally, an assault rifle is intended to fill the gap and provide fire when a GPMG or SAW is jammed or needs to be reloaded. Civilians already have a powerful tool at hand, even at semi-auto. There is absolutely no need to artificially bloat civilian "doctrine" by inventing a need for another weapon system that does nothing better than a well-set-up standard rifle.
As always, thanks for your attention.