Tactics: Why The First Man Is Always Right (Patreon)
Content
Especially in a CQB (Close Quarters Battle) context, you may have heard the saying, “The First Man is always right!” Whether you are clearing rooms or observing Small Unit Tactics (SUT), we cannot overemphasize the value of this concept. In fact, the current trend in some circles of questioning this principle is highly dangerous.
“The First Man Is Always Right” – What does it mean?
This saying refers to the fact that during tactical procedures, the rest of the team must adjust to the decisions made by the first man moving. His immediate decision on the ground outweighs the pre-planned decision of the team leader or even the standard operating procedure (SOP) itself. In a CQB context, this is based on the harsh reality that the first man is the one putting his life on the line; therefore, his split-second decision dictates the flow of the team.
In application, this means no one interrupts or countermands the actions of the point man during combat. To illustrate this, let’s look at a few examples.
The CQB Example: Corner-Fed Rooms
We will start with a CQB example: a corner-fed room taken using Points of Domination.
By the book, the point man should make entry by moving directly into his blind corner, clearing it, and establishing his sector on the far corner. Simultaneously, the second man moves to the corner the point man didn’t check. The third and fourth men then fill the gaps and complete the “L” shape. When executed perfectly, this method opens and clears the room rapidly.
Now, in reality—whether due to a deliberate on-the-fly decision or simply out of stress—it can happen that the first man takes the “wrong” corner.
The worst possible reaction would be to correct him or call him back, essentially robbing the assault of all momentum. Another critical mistake is the second man blindly sticking to the manual and moving to the corner he originally anticipated. If he does this, the blind spot remains uncleared. Even worse, team members might run into each other's arcs of fire. If a threat emerges in that unchecked corner, either the point or the second man will engage it from the doorway, essentially blocking all movement into the room.
The correct response is to stick to the underlying principle rather than blindly following the manual. The first man takes whichever corner he chooses; the second man immediately adapts to cover the remaining blind spot (the opposing side of the room), and the follow-up elements complete the L-shape. It is totally acceptable to ask the point man why he made a different decision during the After Action Review (AAR), but during the actual execution, you must adapt to him. The first man is right because his actions dictate the reality of the maneuver.
The SUT Example: Bounding Maneuvers
The exact same principle applies in Small Unit Tactics. Let's take a squad attack as an example.
Due to having a small support element, two assault teams plan to utilize a bounding movement. The first team is supposed to move halfway from the assault position to the final assault position (FAP) and provide suppressive fire. The second team would then bound past them, establish a presence at the FAP, and provide suppression until the first team catches up. This ensures constant fire and maneuver.
Now, imagine the following happens: the first assault team ignores the planned halfway mark and rushes straight to the FAP without establishing the intermediate base of fire. This could happen because they forgot the scheme of maneuver under pressure, or perhaps because they realized they had no clear arcs of fire from the halfway point.
Again, the worst choice would be to call Assault One back. It would also be a mistake to try and artificially reconstruct the maneuver by having Assault Two stop halfway. Assault One has already established a base of fire at the FAP. The best course of action is to trust Assault One, immediately form up with them at the FAP, and prepare to assault through the objective.
Conclusion
As you can see, procedures often collapse under stress and the friction of the battlefield. It is of utter importance to understand the underlying tactical principles rather than practicing a textbook approach that satisfies the manual but fails in reality.
Whoever moves first is “right.” While he may not have made the optimal choice, it is your responsibility to make the best of it, adapt to the new situation, and fulfill the commander's intent.