Kit Theory: Summer Base Layer Fabrics (Patreon)
Content
Sweating in the field equals freezing later on. While sweat cools us down, it will drop our body temperature to undesired levels if it stays close to our skin for too long. Of course, we can't avoid sweating, but we can select layers that make us sweat less and, at the same time, dry faster.
Today, I want to discuss choosing the right fabric for the job. But first off, let's go over why we actually may need a hot weather base layer under a field shirt or even a combat shirt.
Generally, we need to understand that no base layer is actually "cooling," as many manufacturers advertise. Every layer of fabric you add—no matter how thin—adds insulation. So, don’t make the mistake of wearing a long-sleeve base layer when we only want to move sweat away from the center of our body.
But if it's that way, why even wear a t-shirt under a BDU shirt?
The primary reason is simple: BDUs are made out of NYCO. While NYCO is a rugged and protective fabric, it's not a performance fabric. NYCO will retain sweat and will feel clammy after a while. Pair this with NYCO not drying super well, and you've got a recipe for nightly discomfort or even hypothermia. Furthermore, it will start to chafe against your body; this effect accumulates once your BDU is wet.
Last but not least, even the best performance layers need to be changed after heavy physical activity. As you usually only carry one set of BDUs, you won't have a spare option to change into if you go this route. This is also the reason why wearing a base layer even under a combat shirt (which has a performance fabric body) can make sense in certain scenarios. As already stated, less fabric is more. So if you are in a staging area or in another relatively safe environment, taking off that combat top can make sense.
Now that we've cleared that up, let's go over the fabric choices that are available.
Synthetics (Polyester and Polypropylene)
Pros: Synthetics have an undeservedly bad reputation. Due to synthetics being very rugged, synthetic fabrics can be made into exceptionally lightweight materials that don’t fall apart in the field. Being that rugged also allows for punctured fabrics or mesh weaves, which significantly increase breathability and dry times. Finally, synthetics are incredibly cheap as they can be made from recycled resources. Synthetics have the best dry times of all performance fabrics.
Cons: The only two cons of synthetics can be considered a thing of the past when looking at modern fabric blends and manufacturing techniques. First off, synthetics retain almost zero water. While this is something that you actually want from a base layer, it also means that the fabric provides a lot of surface area for bacteria. This results in synthetics smelling fast, so make sure your synthetics have an anti-bacterial treatment like Odorex if you are worried about smell and hygiene. As synthetics are essentially oil, they burn super fast and will melt and drip. So, for real-life field use, synthetics need to be blended with FR (Fire Retardant) fabrics or at least need a factory FR chemical treatment.
Merino Wool
Pros: Merino is a great fabric that, when used in lighter-weight versions (180g or below), makes a decent summer base layer. Merino is anti-microbial, inherently FR, and no-melt/no-drip. It furthermore has a natural UPF rating and doesn’t cool you down until it is soaked with water by about 30%. Furthermore, it is breathable and has good capillary action (wicking). But is it the “perfect fabric” manufacturers like to advertise? Not really. It has many cons which become obvious in the summer.
Cons: Merino does not dry very fast when compared to synthetic fabrics. Furthermore, it has a distinct clammy feel to it once it reaches the 30% moisture threshold. This isn’t an issue when hiking or hunting, but it becomes one once you conduct high-level physical activity. There is a reason why you don’t see runners, soccer players, or other athletes running in merino wool. While Merino is not a cold-weather-only fabric, it definitely provides more insulation gram-for-gram compared to synthetic fabrics. Last but not least, it's not very rugged, meaning it wears down fast in a military environment—especially when we look at the thin fabrics used in hot weather layers.
Merino Blends
Merino blends address the weaknesses of Merino by adding what the Merino industry has always called inferior: synthetics. Usually, high-strength fibers like nylon are added in order to increase durability. Keep in mind that the more nylon is added, the more rugged the shirt becomes, but the more of the unique properties of Merino you lose.
Semi-Synthetics
Semi-synthetics are fabrics that are based on natural fibers like bamboo but are heavily processed. They fill a niche but come with very interesting properties:
Lyocell / Tencel: A fiber derived from the wood pulp of eucalyptus, oak, or birch trees. It’s a very comfortable, breathable, and soft fabric. It is, however, not truly wicking, as it soaks water into the core of the fabric instead of pushing it out. While this creates initial comfort, it eventually hits a threshold where the fabric just can't wick moisture anymore.
Viscose / Rayon: Created by extracting cellulose from bamboo grass and spinning it into fibers. This fabric is even more comfy than Tencel but has almost zero wicking capabilities; it quickly starts to feel damp and clammy.
Modal: This fiber is made from beech tree pulp. It creates softness and comfort and has the best wicking capacities of all semi-synthetics. Sadly, it is very fragile.
All semi-synthetics are nothing you want as the primary fiber of a military base layer. But if you add small amounts to a synthetic fabric, you can increase comfort significantly. This especially comes in handy when it comes to inherently FR synthetics which add Nomex. Nomex is not very skin-friendly and feels uncomfortable. By adding a small amount of Modal or Tencel, you suddenly get a very comfortable FR base layer solution.
Conclusion
I would usually add a “Tier List” as people call it nowadays, but as I expect our readers to be grown-up adults, I think you can connect the dots between the different pros and cons of your fabric options yourself. None of those options are perfect.
I personally prefer “Tri-Blend” type synthetic fabrics that rely on synthetics, semi-synthetics, and FR fabrics. But this is my personal choice.
As always, thanks for your attention.