Tactics – The Frontal Attack (Patreon)
Content
A frontal attack is such a simple maneuver that it is often dismissed as dangerous, useless, and unsophisticated. Why should we even discuss it in depth? In reality, the frontal attack is not only the most basic form of offensive maneuver, but it is also one of the most common and essential tactics to master.
Generally, military doctrine pushes us to flank enemy positions whenever possible. "There is always a way to flank," you may say, and while shaping operations and maneuver may eventually enable a flanking route, time is frequently a critical constraint. The greatest benefit of a frontal attack is its simplicity: it is straightforward to set up and execute, and therefore requires very little time to plan.
US Doctrine and the Art of Fixing
U.S. military doctrine describes the frontal attack as "a maneuver in which an attacking force seeks to destroy a weaker enemy force or fix a larger enemy force in place over a broad front, directing its elements along the most direct approaches."
This definition highlights a vital fact, especially for small unit leaders: the frontal attack is the gold standard for fixing an enemy. While your assault element will most likely flank the objective, I am absolutely certain that almost all attacks by fire conducted by your support element have been nothing more than frontal attacks. Keep in mind that a frontal attack does not necessarily involve a full-scale infantry assault; it can simply be a blunt attack by fire. So much for the maneuver being useless and rare.
Maintaining Momentum Against Delaying Forces Even when it comes to the assault phase, the frontal attack is heavily underrated. The enemy will almost always deploy smaller, weaker forces to delay your advance. This delay isn't caused by the brute defensive potential of these skirmishing forces; it relies on the assumption that you will lose momentum by stopping to distribute your forces into complex maneuvers.
A blunt frontal assault, conducted swiftly and violently, can shatter the enemy's intent. Small unit doctrine reflects this principle: enemy observation posts (OPs) and smaller security perimeters are meant to be "rolled over" by the main effort. Not losing momentum and denying the enemy the time they hoped to buy by deploying skirmishers is key here.
The Question of Surprise
It is often assumed that a frontal attack robs the attacker of any element of surprise, as you are essentially running directly into the enemy's guns. Let’s dissect this assumption. Because the enemy understands the popularity of flanking and knows their flanks are a vulnerability, they will frequently reinforce those flanks or overstretch their defenses to avoid exposing them. Because they anticipate a complex maneuver, the sheer application of speed and violence of action directly up the middle can create a paralyzing, unexpected surprise of its own.
Differentiation from Penetration The primary difference between a frontal attack and a penetration attack is that during a frontal attack, the commander disperses forces evenly across a broad front. With that being said, a frontal attack can serve as an excellent shaping operation for a subsequent penetration. In practice, the lines can be so blurred that a frontal attack seamlessly transitions into a penetration attack when applying the principles of surface and gap warfare.
"Outdated and Rarely Successful" - A Historical Myth
History is full of highly successful frontal attacks. The invasion of Omaha Beach is a classic example of a scenario where nothing but a frontal attack was possible. Conversely, the Battle of 73 Easting is a prime example of why, even in the modern age, frontal attacks remain of utter importance—especially for Western forces. By bringing overwhelming training and technology to bear, coalition forces achieved an unmatched dueling capacity that rendered Iraqi attempts at resistance completely ineffective in a direct, head-on engagement.
The Broad Push
Attacking on a broad front provides another often-overlooked advantage: the enemy has far fewer opportunities to slip through the lines. This is especially advantageous during urban operations, where securing a linear front prevents bypass and infiltration.
Understanding the Whole Picture
The success of an operation is not decided by the complexity of a single maneuver. The reality of tactics exists in a microcosm. Inside a macro-level frontal attack, numerous smaller flanking attacks and envelopments happen concurrently. We must discard the antiquated idea of a stiff, 19th-century force advancing slowly in a straight line. When the higher command's operational attempt is frontal, a broad spectrum of dynamic, small-unit tactics can—and should—be utilized to fulfill the commander's intent.
Conclusion
When you need shock, confusion, and want to swing the tactical clock back in your favor, a frontal attack may be a much wiser choice than you think. There is only one strict prerequisite: superiority. This must be established either by physical mass or by overwhelming quality. Furthermore, the frontal attack remains the crucial mechanism for fixing the enemy in place.