Tactics – The Penetration (Patreon)
Content
According to US Field Manual (FM) 3-90, a penetration is a form of offensive maneuver where an attacking force seeks to rupture enemy defenses on a narrow front to disrupt the entire defensive system. While modern US and NATO doctrines generally prefer envelopment or turning movements to avoid the attrition of frontal assaults, the penetration remains a vital and highly effective maneuver when enemy flanks are anchored or unassailable. It is a brute-force breaching attack that aims to shatter the enemy front line using the concentrated application of overwhelming force.
The Maneuver
A penetration is typically conducted in the following phases:
Frontal attack on a broad scale in order to fix the enemy.
(Executed concurrently with Phase 1) Assembly of a breaching force.
Identification of a gap.
Opening the gap.
Securing the gap.
Rolling over enemy defenses (as in a flanking attack) or continuing to penetrate into the enemy's rear area.
The execution of a penetration attack requires a comprehensive understanding of surface and gap warfare, meaning the fixing force will actively try to locate gaps in the enemy defense. A gap isn't necessarily—as the name implies—a physical opening without any defenses, but rather a soft or vulnerable spot in the Forward Line of Enemy Troops (FLET). At a larger scale, the use of reconnaissance elements, such as cavalry scouts, allows commanders to conduct a fast "recon pull," with the recon element actively setting the stage for the breaching force.
The breaching force needs to act with absolute violence of action. An overwhelming application of speed, firepower, and high-quality forces is required in order to create the breach and to further stretch and secure it. Once the initial breach is created, it needs to be expanded for follow-up elements exploiting the gap. It is very common that parts of the fixing force will then transition roles to help exploit the breach.
Why a Penetration Attack Works
NATO and other Western forces excel in their dueling capability, meaning that a concentrated force is able to punch well above its weight due to its speed, tactical initiative, and precision. A successful penetration attack requires versatile forces that can seamlessly transition between fixing, breaching, and exploiting roles.
While Soviet and modern Russian forces also heavily rely on penetration attacks to conduct deep operations, for them, it is a highly orchestrated event in which every element has a rigidly pre-planned role. This is where the Eastern European concept of "Assault Units" stems from. However, if something goes wrong, these complex breaching operations can fall apart like a house of cards. A flexible, Western-style penetration attack, on the other hand, relies on initiative, speed, surprise, and violence of action at the lowest tactical levels.
The Limitations Penetration attacks excel in rupturing and rolling up narrow, surface-type front lines. Deep frontlines (defense in depth), on the other hand, will require multiple breaching efforts and will result in follow-up forces facing a complex net of mutually supporting positions. However, if a FLET is very deep and dense, it will most likely either have an open flank or can at least be enveloped, as defensive resources are always limited by the trade-off between surface area and depth. For example, a commander with 12 squads available can either deploy those squads in a long line (a large surface) or in a 4x3 rectangle (deep but narrow).
The most obvious limitation, however, is the sheer concentration of high-quality forces required to conduct a breaching attack. Even with overwhelming numbers of troops, attackers are limited by the physical space available, as there is only so much mass you can concentrate at the point of the breach. Elements conducting a breaching attack therefore need to be highly capable in direct, close-quarters combat. Finally, the exploitation force risks falling victim to the defender pinching the breach closed, thereby cutting the attackers off completely from their logistics.
Conclusion: Highly Effective – But Only for Elite Warfighting Organizations
As simple and brute-force as a penetration attack sounds, it remains one of the most decisive forms of maneuver. The rapid decision-making and overwhelming force required to execute it successfully should never be underestimated. This is why notoriously rigid or poorly trained armies often suffer horrific defeats during breaching operations, while elite, highly adaptable forces succeed.