Tactics – How To Fight (Patreon)
Content
After having gone over the six forms of maneuver in our previous articles, we have explained the tools. But knowing the tools tells you almost nothing about application. Just because you know the task and purpose of a wrench, you are not necessarily able to fix a house. All forms of maneuver don’t exist in a vacuum; they are part of a doctrinal framework. Understanding this framework allows you to apply the right tools.
Hierarchy of Efforts
In the military, there is a hierarchy of efforts. This categorization is very simple and divides efforts into two categories: Main Effort and Supporting Effort.
The main effort is what wins the battle and makes you take and hold ground. At a small unit level, your main effort during a flanking attack would be your assault element. The assault element is what determines a win or loss. On the other hand, there is the supporting effort. Supporting efforts—as their name implies—support the main effort and enable victory.
To provide you with a more concrete example using what we have discussed so far: Your main effort could be a flanking attack, while your supporting effort is a frontal attack fixing the enemy in place. While there is no limitation on how many supporting efforts there can be, there can be only one main effort during an operation. However, keep in mind that multiple operations can happen simultaneously and that the hierarchy of an effort is also subject to scale. While a flanking attack conducted by Bravo and Alpha companies of an infantry battalion may be the battalion's main effort, this same flanking attack could merely be a supporting effort at the division or brigade level.
Generally, the hierarchy of efforts sets the stage for the importance of an action and will determine how much support and logistics will be made available to an effort. The main effort will always have the highest priority when it comes to resource allocation.
While the main and supporting effort concept scales down to the smallest tactical level, it also applies when planning large-scale combat operations. Larger-scale assets will clearly be tasked to conduct either main or supporting efforts.
Types of Operations
Now that we have run over the hierarchy of importance, we need to discuss task and purpose. Generally, all actions conducted on the battlefield fall into one of the following types of operations:
Decisive
Shaping
Sustaining
The Decisive Operation is what forces a decision. It will always aim for the enemy's center of gravity—be it destroying a powerful combat asset, taking an important city, or destroying an industrial hub. At the highest strategic levels, decisive efforts aim to win the war. However, at the tactical level, a decisive operation simply achieves the commander's immediate objective. Just like with the main effort, there is only one decisive operation at each level for subordinate units, though higher echelon elements can conduct their own decisive operations.
Shaping Operations are what enable decisive operations. Fixing the enemy, reconnoitering positions, providing flank security, or disrupting enemy formations are all actions that set the conditions for a successful decisive operation. Usually, a multitude of shaping operations are running at the same time or are executed in rapid succession.
Sustaining Operations are defined by all operations that do not immediately affect combat but enable the force to continue fighting. This includes medical support, logistics, quartering, and base security.
Understanding the Scale!
As previously mentioned, it is important to understand the scale of things. The operational framework is not a linear system, but a complex ecosystem influenced by scale and situation.
Imagine invading a country from two regional borders. Your main force is in the south; another, smaller force is in the east. Your strategic, decisive goal is to take the capital of that country. Your forces in the south will be the main effort, while your forces in the east are the supporting effort. This is the strategic scale, and a lot of things need to happen before reaching your ultimate goal of taking the capital.
Your main effort is now conducting several shaping operations in order to fix the enemy, while your supporting effort is conducting shaping operations in order to disrupt the enemy. You designate one of your strongest elements in the south to conduct a decisive flanking attack, while other elements will shape the battlefield by fixing, reconnoitering, and infiltrating.
All subordinate commanders will then assign main and supporting efforts, as well as decisive, shaping, and sustaining operations, in order to fulfill the higher commander's intent.
Historical Example: Operation Desert Storm (1991)
The U.S. and Coalition ground offensive against Iraqi forces in Kuwait and Iraq (Operation Desert Saber) is a classic example of this doctrinal framework in action.
Decisive Operation: The famed "Left Hook" executed by VII Corps and XVIII Airborne Corps. Their mission was to sweep deep into Iraq, bypass the main defenses in Kuwait, and destroy the elite Iraqi Republican Guard. This directly accomplished the mission of liberating Kuwait by destroying the enemy's center of gravity.
Shaping Operation: The U.S. Marine Corps conducted a massive amphibious feint in the Persian Gulf, while other Coalition forces launched direct frontal attacks into Kuwait. These actions "shaped" the battlefield by deceiving the Iraqi command into believing the main attack was coming from the sea and the south, effectively pinning down multiple Iraqi divisions so they could not maneuver against the decisive "Left Hook."
Sustaining Operation: The establishment of massive logistical hubs (such as Logistics Bases Echo and Romeo) deep in the desert. These operations pushed millions of gallons of fuel, ammunition, and water forward to keep the armored columns of VII Corps moving at an unprecedented pace. Without this, the decisive operation would have stalled out in the desert.
Main / Supporting Efforts: Within XVIII Airborne Corps, the Main Effort was the 24th Infantry Division's rapid armored drive to the Euphrates River to block the Iraqi retreat. The Supporting Effort was the 101st Airborne Division, which conducted a massive helicopter assault to establish Forward Operating Base Cobra. The 101st (the supporting effort) protected the flank of the 24th ID (the main effort) and severed enemy supply lines.
Now that you know the framework and the tools, you can actually start to plan! However, keep in mind that you shouldn’t confuse knowledge with capability; this means that knowing all of this will not replace your ability to come up with a clever plan.
As always, thanks for your attention.