Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Combat is often depicted as two sides simply trying to annihilate each other, with the victor being the one who eliminates all resistance through kinetic means. This is far from the truth. In reality, most engagements are won long before the last defender falls. Battles typically conclude when the enemy routs as their combat power collapses, or when they surrender due to having no viable options left.

Law, common sense, and intelligence requirements dictate that prisoners must be captured. Prisoners provide valuable information, strategic media footage, and general operational prestige. Furthermore, an enemy force fighting honorably to the last man is far less desirable—and more costly to deal with—than an enemy surrendering en masse. Recent footage from Ukraine involving surrendering Russians, or the famous mass surrenders of the Iraqi Army during the Gulf War, highlight a crucial battlefield reality: the collapse of enemy fighting spirit.

But how do you actually take prisoners safely and efficiently?

The Point of Capture (POC): Balancing Tempo and Security

First, we must recognize that dealing with surrendering enemies requires us to balance two competing priorities: maintaining the tempo of the assault and ensuring security.

When an enemy capitulates, they must clearly demonstrate their intent. This means dropping their weapon and assuming an unambiguous posture of surrender—halting all movement and raising their hands. If your unit is still conducting the assault, maintaining momentum remains the ultimate priority, but potential prisoners must be treated as an immediate security risk. A surrendering enemy (or group of enemies) must be immediately guarded by at least a buddy team-sized element.

Standard military doctrine often relies on the mnemonic of the "5S and a T" (Search, Silence, Segregate, Safeguard, Speed, Tag). However, this primarily addresses larger, post-engagement Detainee Collection Point (DCP) operations. During an active assault, we must add a crucial sixth "S" for Secure.

At the Point of Capture, execute the following immediately:

Secure: Force the enemy to drop their weapon while you keep your muzzle trained on them. Have your buddy immediately apply flex cuffs or other restraints.

Search: Search the prisoner for weapons, explosives, radios, and intelligence. Remove and seize any found items immediately.

Silence: Arrange the enemies so they cannot communicate with each other (e.g., facing a wall or placed in stress positions). While doctrine often dictates having them face different directions, keep in mind this can create a chaotic hazard when operating inside a confined room, as it may prevent you from providing safe cover for the teammate conducting the search.

Consolidation and Evacuation

Once the POC actions are complete, the tactical situation usually branches into one of two scenarios:

Immediate Advance: The assault team immediately (or simultaneously) pushes forward, leaving a fireteam-sized element behind to secure the prisoners.

Follow-on Forces: Follow-on elements arrive to either take over the assault or take custody of the prisoners.

Regardless of the scenario, the prisoners must eventually be moved to a Detainee Collection Point (DCP), which is either pre-established in the OPORD or hastily established on the ground. Depending on combat intensity, you may need to first set up a Temporary Holding Area (THA). A THA is simply a secure location for your subordinates and the prisoners, which could be an adjacent, cleared room or a nearby covered position.

Once moved to a THA or DCP, the remaining steps are conducted:

Segregate: Divide the prisoners into combatants and civilians. If possible, further subdivide them by rank, gender, and function. Captured equipment and weapons must be segregated on a safe side of the DCP, completely inaccessible to the detainees.

Safeguard: While the location of the DCP or THA should inherently provide cover from direct gunfire and artillery, this step serves as a reminder to protect prisoners from acts of retaliation by your own forces or non-combatants.

Speed: Move the prisoners to the next echelon's holding area (DCP, DHA, or TDF) as quickly as the tactical situation allows.

Tag: Tag the prisoners using the most practical method available. This ranges from color-coded cuffs, labeled tape, and chem-lights to specific capture tags like DD Form 2745. Ensure all confiscated items are identically tagged and linked to the correct prisoner.

Final Thoughts

Keep in mind that handling prisoners is a multi-layered, highly fluid process. If you have the time, manpower, and security to conduct all of these steps at the Point of Capture, do so. Treat the "6S and a T" as a checklist of intent rather than a rigid chronological order.

Remember: individual and operational security dictate the battlefield. Secure is the most crucial step, closely followed by Search and Silence. Prioritize those three at the Point of Capture to maintain the initiative and keep your team alive.

As always, thanks for your attention.

Files

Comments

Opfor8r

Excellent post as always, definitely not spoken about enough and I am always glad when you explain maneuver warfare as inherently having prisoner situations as a result of successes on the battlefield. Of note with the Secure portion, we always drilled proper coverage so as to reduce fratricide risk from the covering soldier whilst the securing soldier can do his actions. We also always rehearsed the grenade drill thats inherent to "dead checks" for the assault line because as we know some prisoners have no intention of being captured.