Why Warfare Is Not "Safe" (Patreon)
Content
“Your tactics aren’t safe.”
This is one of the most recurring phrases we hear when people discuss particularly daring or dynamic tactics. The constant struggle between proponents of limited penetration CQB and more dynamic approaches, in particular, is often fueled by arguments regarding “safety.” Let's have an honest conversation about what safety actually means.
To do that, we need to understand that safety is just one component of a broader doctrinal concept that the military calls “Protection.” Let's look at the overarching term first.
Protection is generally defined as:
"Preservation of the effectiveness and survivability of mission-related military and nonmilitary personnel, equipment, facilities, information, and infrastructure deployed or located within or outside the boundaries of a given operational area." (Joint Publication 3-0, Joint Operations)
This is a very broad term. Generally, military assets are “protected” in order to fulfill their mission and retain warfighting capabilities. Sounds great, so the safest place there is should be war, right? Keep in mind that protection largely refers to preserving the warfighting capability of a whole force, not necessarily your own life.
Because it is such a broad term, Protection is split into three sub-sectors: Security, Survivability, and last but not least, Safety.
Security
Let's go over security and its definition first:
"Measures taken by a military unit, activity, or installation to protect itself against all acts designed to, or which may, impair its effectiveness." (MCTP 3-30G)
Security refers to organizational measures that protect a unit or installation. This can be anything from “pulling security” to COMSEC, OPSEC, or PERSEC. Taking the example of pulling security at a patrol base, however, means that at least two individuals need to man an observation post (OP) in front of the perimeter. Now I'll ask you two questions: Is manning an OP a task that you would consider “safe”? Is manning a guard tower while everyone else is in a contained base a safe activity?
Both activities are, by comparison, absolutely unsafe. You are in an exposed or isolated position, putting your own life at risk in order to provide a lesser risk to others so that they can conduct their warfighting activities.
Survivability
Next, we have survivability, which is the quality of a unit or piece of equipment to:
"Avoid or withstand hostile actions or environmental conditions while retaining the ability to fulfill their primary mission." (ATP 3-37.34)
If you read that correctly, you may notice that this is largely not about avoiding hostile actions, but withstanding them. Furthermore, it is hardware-focused. A vehicle's survivability will, for example, be defined by its armor, speed, concealment, or active protection systems. For an infantryman, this generally means body armor and physical concealment.
Predictable environmental factors like cold weather or heat also need to be addressed with garments, shelter systems, and comparable technical solutions. Still, are you “safe” in a warzone because you are wearing plates? Are you safe in cold weather because you have fitting garments? Risk is reduced, but you are not safe. Indeed, warfighting capabilities always take priority over maximum protection if those interests collide. For example, maximum protection against bullets and shrapnel would require the warfighter to wear every single piece of their body armor system. Instead, body armor is often reduced to a minimum in order to maintain the ability to fulfill core warfighting functions by enhancing speed and endurance.
Safety
Security and Survivability are the core pillars of the Protection Triangle when it comes to actual warfighting capabilities and hostile environments. Now let's talk about safety, which is defined as:
"Freedom from those conditions that can cause death, injury, occupational illness, damage to or loss of equipment or property, or damage to the environment." (DoD Systems Safety / MIL-STD-882)
What we see is that—contrary to Protection and Security—safety is not talking about tactical actions. Safety is talking largely about conditions. Safety is literally buckling your seatbelt, getting your medical check-up for a certain activity, or, as a more graspable example: weapons safety. The military does not define safety as being shielded from the enemy; in a military context, safety is being protected against dangers which are not a result of hostile actions.
Conclusion
As stated at the beginning, the military does not prioritize your individual survival in the context of an operation. Fulfilling your task is what matters, and if fulfilling your task requires you to accept risks—which you already do by entering a warzone—you have to take that risk.
So, when the debate inevitably circles back to limited penetration versus dynamic CQB, we have to stop framing it around colloquial "safety." In CQB, neither tactic is safe. You are utilizing Security (your team's sectors of fire) and Survivability (your armor, speed, and violence of action) to accomplish a mission. War is a dangerous craft, and true safety is left at the door the moment you make entry.
As always, thanks for your attention.