Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Who really has the worst drivers in America? In this month's Roman Report, I compare the 2025 Allstate Best Drivers Report with the Consumer Affairs list of America’s worst driving cities to find out just how safe you really are on the road in America. We'll look at car crash statistics, law enforcement data, and your overall collision likelihood in each city, and discuss what the people in charge are doing to make their streets safer. Whether it's Philadelphia, Washington DC, Boston, or Los Angeles, I can promise you're in for a surprise. But do these rankings reflect reality, or are they just another way to make drivers angry at each other? Did ConsumerAffairs name your city among the worst? Did Allstate rank yours as one of the best? If you’ve ever wondered why your insurance premium is sky-high, or why your city gets roasted for bad driving, keep watching. Because I'm naming names.

Files

The Worst Drivers Live Here (The Roman Report)

Who really has the worst drivers in America? In this month's Roman Report, I compare the 2025 Allstate Best Drivers Report with the ConsumerAffairs list of America’s worst driving cities to find out just how safe you really are on the road in America. We'll look at car crash statistics, law enforcement data, and your overall collision likelihood in each city, and discuss what the people in charge are doing to make their streets safer. Whether it's Philadelphia, Washington DC, Boston, or Los Angeles, I can promise you're in for a surprise. But do these rankings reflect reality, or are they just another way to make drivers angry at each other? Did ConsumerAffairs name your city among the worst? Did Allstate rank yours as one of the best? If you’ve ever wondered why your insurance premium is sky-high, or why your city gets roasted for bad driving, keep watching. Because I'm naming names. Chapters: 00:00 Bad Drivers Are Everywhere 01:35 Intro song 01:43 Allstate Bad Driver Rankings Explained 03:04 Tenth Worst Driving City 05:39 Ninth Worst 07:15 Eighth Worst 08:53 Important Criteria 10:17 Seventh Worst 14:39 Sixth Worst 16:34 Fifth Worst 18:17 Fourth Worst 24:00 Third Worst 27:45 Second Worst 32:25 The Worst Drivers Live Here 37:42 Where the BEST Drivers Live 40:25 Sources and Photo Credits For more deep-dives into cars, culture, and the chaos of the road, check out my other long-form reports: The Sedan Market Is Cooked (The Roman Report): https://youtu.be/nOX8QvMNBYY?si=989sqdC8HtYUyoUk These Car Prices Are Ridiculous (The Roman Report): https://youtu.be/o9UxPkM0QsY?si=r18_3B8T8ryyC3qE Automotive YouTube Is Changing (The Roman Report): https://youtu.be/KXO7SyaV8IQ?si=yW1C6b5qORO6XZFN The Death of the Manual Transmission (The Roman Report): https://youtu.be/CkzaUTl_qSA?si=cAZSNPG7j8HB3Tkw The Life and Death of Saab (RCR Stories): https://youtu.be/lwhxH9SB9h8?si=Fx3etNjv5-xEYJKI The Life and Death of AMC (RCR Stories): https://youtu.be/TCmHII0Pp9w?si=KApV8s_7PlchC4Li If you enjoy the show, Patreon is the best way to keep it going: https://www.patreon.com/regularcarreviews Shirts and Mugs: https://regularcars-shop.fourthwall.com/ Key tags and plate frames: https://www.zazzle.com/store/regularcars Find RCR online: BlueSky: @regularcars / @theromannick Instagram: @regularcarreviews / @theromannick Linktree: https://linktr.ee/regularcarreviews Second channel: https://www.youtube.com/@regularandroman Thank you for supporting Regular Car Reviews! For all sponsorship inquiries, please contact RCR@adhesivemedia.com New 2nd channel "Regular and Roman" https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC521lEhTdxoyfjtwzYVXVNA

Comments

Will nolastname

Reported Accidents. so.... it skips all the unreported NYC stuff. Insurance costs so damn high now, people are not reporting if deductibles too much, fear of rates spiking, crappy barely legal insurance policies from the dude that sells insurance,real estate, primerica and Herbalife.

Ryan Erickson

Hi! Born and raised (and learned to drive) in Worcester, current resident of Boston, and I've also lived in Providence, RI and Washington, DC. I'm really disinclined to trust methodology based on one company's (self-reported, presumably otherwise proprietary) data. They say their policies represent 10 percent of all policies nationally, but surely that rate is higher in some places than it is in others where their market presence is higher. Moreover, what if their market strategy varies? What if they made a bet to distinguish themselves in a market by offering higher premium plans to riskier drivers that other insurers shut out? That's not an off-base assumption when you consider that Allstate only re-entered the Massachusetts auto insurance market in about 2009 after leaving it a couple decades; they could have far less market share than longer-established insurers. (How do I know this? The were one of the few who offered me a policy after I didn't have a car for 10 years, putting me into a high risk pool.) Separately, are there factors, like state laws, that encourage more people to report accidents in some places than others -- say, lower deductibles? I think federal data is a better source, and while much of it is broken down by state, not city, meaning it's not an apples-to-apples comparison, it pretty consistently shows that Massachusetts has among the lowest accident death rates, and Rhode Island has among the lowest pedestrian death rates. Sure, a high share of accidents could be happening here, but if they're fender-benders that seems preferable to -- death? I suppose it's possible that these states would just have a way outsized share of their accidents happening in their cities but on balance this doesn't seem to add up. But from my completely objective viewpoint, it's Providence. People do dumb shit all the time and slowly, and with entitlement, wondering why you're getting angry at them when they pull out in front of moving traffic at about half its going speed.

Frank Litto

Mobile, AL. is the absolute worst.