Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Movie Poll: No particular theme.

  • Rocky Horror Picture Show (1975) 989
  • Crimson Tide (1995) 631
  • Furiosa (2024) 533
  • King Kong (2005) 693
  • Barbarian (2022) 524
  • A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood (2019) 270
  • Kingdom of Heaven (2005) - New only to Simone 421
  • 2025-09-08
  • —2025-09-18
  • 4061 votes
{'title': 'Movie Poll: No particular theme. ', 'choices': [{'text': 'Rocky Horror Picture Show (1975)', 'votes': 989}, {'text': 'Crimson Tide (1995)', 'votes': 631}, {'text': 'Furiosa (2024)', 'votes': 533}, {'text': 'King Kong (2005)', 'votes': 693}, {'text': 'Barbarian (2022)', 'votes': 524}, {'text': 'A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood (2019)', 'votes': 270}, {'text': 'Kingdom of Heaven (2005) - New only to Simone', 'votes': 421}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 9, 18, 17, 57, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 9, 8, 17, 50, 15, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 4061}

Content

The last weekly polls winner will be available this Saturday. Reminder: movies that don't win does not mean they will never be watched, it just means they will be watched later. Please be respectful to each others opinions, we're all just here to have fun and watch movies. :)

Comments

JakeyShakeyBakeyBoy

Haha gotta go with Rocky Horror as a top pick for the great catchy songs and the incredible Tim Curry. Will be a fun week of antici…………..pation to see what ends up being the pick ☺️

Zack Gallardo

Kingdom of heaven is VERY good. Be mindful of which edit to watch. Wars have been started over less.

Hanno

Kingdom of Heavennnnnn

TheLeftPecOfTheLord

Wow another incredible line up of choices! I think these are all winners tbh happy with any of them

Ashton Lewis

It's my birthday this year so can we all vote King Kong please :)

Jordy's_Here!

As much as I like the Monsterverse films….Peter Jackson’s King Kong (2005) will always hold a soft spot in my heart!!

JakeyShakeyBakeyBoy

Directors Cut was first shown to this guy back in the day. Haven’t actually seen theatrical but it might be a fun experiment at some point haha

Sean Brown

Kingdom of Heaven MUST be the directors cut.

Mike W

Rocky horror should make for an "interesting" reaction 😃

Zack Gallardo

We had the theatrical cut on dvd as a kid. When I saw the directors cut I was thrown!

Ian Hunt

As I’m sure a lot of people will say, if you do Kingdom of Heaven, do the director’s cut

Jean-Dominic Lapointe

When it said “no particular theme”, I didn’t expect to actually be “wildly all over the place” 🤣😂🤣. Very interesting choices, it’s gonna be great no matter what

Inkpendude

King Kong is great, and surprisingly the game on ps2 was also super fun

JakeyShakeyBakeyBoy

That’s the consensus I’ve long been aware of. Must be drastically different viewing then but the DC is fantastic nonetheless

Philipp Roensch

It is time for Furiosa, let's gooo! The RHPS will be... interesting.

Luke D

I was surprised Barbarian wasn't far in front, would make for a great reaction, but I guess not enough people are familiar with it.

Zhivko Yakimov

It is mostly cut scenes, no noticeable changes otherwise. In essence, they cut most of the scenes involving characters other than the protagonist. Unfortunately, it takes away too much, as you can easily fail to understand the motivations of certain characters in the theatrical version. It was clearly under producer pressure, and it is one of the examples when a director's cut is vastly superior to what was originally shown.

Maniacalmouse

Rocky Horror all the way! Since this one is a random type poll, I also have a few random movie suggestions: Brick (2005), Drop Dead Fred, Pump up the Volume, and Titan: A.E.

The Gunslinger

Crimson Tide is an excellent film. The late Gene Hackman and Denzel Washington are both outstanding. BTW, you should give Atlantis: The Lost Empire a watch.

JakeyShakeyBakeyBoy

Ah nice to know! Cheers dude! Yeah some of those scenes focusing on the periphery really add to the weight of that film for sure

Actuarial Lurker

KIng Kong had great special effects- BUT it pales story wise against LOTR of course since any film truly rides on its underlying script quality. Beautiful Day celebrates the life of a truly decent man- a pastor who envisioned a world safe for kids. RHPS is a cult classic that one must watch drunk in college and not a surprise that its winning- George and Simone should play a drinking game to it- but that would involve looking up spoilers

Matrim

I’m shivering with antici…

Christian Valdersnes

RHPS. Tim Curry all the way, it's a decent movie but Tim's performance is a delight. Crimson Tide is the best movie on this list, Denzel and Gene in the same movie. Perfect

Jeromy M

Really enjoyed it on xbox360. Hired it from video ez to finish it and hand it back haha.

JoeE

Say it

JoeE

Would also recommend sing street, one cut of the dead, state of grace, ed wood, living in oblivion

Theo Bracco

I will surely be a beautiful day in the 'Binge if that movie is chosen. It's okay to feel those feelings, and you are beautiful people.

Hercule Pyro

Rocky horror would have them so confused.

Jaaahn

the amount of times ive seen in their YT comments of people being angry at their gender bending thumbnails, i think the confusion (and likely anger) will come from certain demographic of viewers lol

Lee Fernee

Dead man's shoes please.

Jacob King

Rocky Horror is essential viewing but Chris Hemsworth in Furiosa is nearly as camp.

Rhiannon

Ahhhh! RHPS!!!! A full on camp to the max classic. So weird and wonderful.

Basil Hazzard

I just don't understad why people are always asking reactors to watch RHPS. It's just NOT a good movie to watch. The magic of RHPS is the experience of going to see it with an interactive audience. 90% of the fun is the audience yelling at the screen.

DemNikoArt

Okay, then I will also do some no particular theme suggestions ;) - Go! - Starsky & Hutch - I love you man - Palm Springs - Beerfest - Lucky number Slevin - oblivion - The machinist - Prisoners - Cloudy with a chance of meatballs - Mitchells Vs the machine - 11:14 - Chronicle - looper

Fritz

2 very good movies from recent years you have missed so far are Challengers and Conclave.

Jaaahn

its only that IF its not your first time seeing it.. when you know what to expect, so people shouting makes it fun because youre not missing anything. who the hell wants to watch a movie for the first time in a auditorium where you cant hear the movie.

Jacob King

Simone is Frank-N-Furter (obviously) but I’d like to see George as Rocky.

Christian Valdersnes

you are so right, it's way better as a play then a movie. but still it's fun to see Tim's brilliance in this movie.

John

It's a great list, though I am certainly pulling for Crimson Tide, Denzel Washington, Gene Hackman, Viggo Morgenson, John Gandolfini. A thoughtful and engaging movie

Matthew Johnson

If you watch Kingdom of Heaven make sure you watch the directors cut - it’s a superior film.

Random Nevermind

Two random movies for the next random poll People vs Larry Flynt Lincoln Lawyer Also they would go well after Devil’s Advocate

Logan Kerlee

I LOVE that Rocky Horror Picture Show is winning so far! It's a long time fave of mine and it's a show that I feel more people should see/know about. :)

Matrim

…pation.

Rhett Samios

Rocky Horror is a must watch

Lyle Morgan

RHPC is one of the worst movies ever when watching it for the first time in your home. It’s the greatest piece of art in history when watching at the theater. 😂

Mike FromOz

I see you shiver in antici...

Cosmic Slice

Man....wish Beautiful Day was winning because I have yet to see any reactors do that movie....and it's really good.

Mike FromOz

Absolutely. I saw it at the cinema when it first came out and was like "uhmmm... that was... eh...", but the director's cut makes it so much better.

Kevin M. Pitts

Some good options here. Crimson Tide has two great performances, I did enjoy Peter Jackson’s King Kong remake, and I thought Tom Hanks really nailed Fred Rogers in A Beautiful Day. However, I voted for Rocky Horror as I just think that Simone & George will have fun with the campiness of it all. And Tim Curry is just terrific.

Onikaze

as Tim Curry is in this list I will once again ask/recommend Legend(1985) by Ridley Scott. Tom Cruise , Mia Sara, Tim Curry. just a beautiful film where nearly every shot has atmospheric motion. with a very different soundtrack by Tangerine Dream.

Mike FromOz

Let's do the Time Warp again!!!!

inspectordh

Crimson Tide is a great movie

Amelie W

Funny story, on my 12th year school trip we visited London and saw the Rocky Horror Show on stage. I was definitely the only person there who had never heard of this famous play/movie and had no idea what was happening at any time. There's apparently a lot of rituals you're supposed to study beforehand, but if you know those I don't expect it matters where you're watching from.

Kevin M. Pitts

Agreed. I’ve seen the film dozens of times but I would still feel overwhelmed seeing it in the theater with the super fans. Not that I wouldn’t want to at some point. I’m sure it’s a hell of a time. But seeing the film for the very first time and having that be in the theater with so many others that know when to shout what and when to utilize which prop would be crazy.

Brandon

I'd love to see a dark horse victory from Crimson Tide. More Gene Hackman is never a bad thing.

Florian

I thought we watched the Rocky Horror Picture Show, but I‘m allways in for some spicey Tim Curry 🤤 Damn it Trivia, I love you ❤️

XeonAlpha

Since this year is the 50th anniversary of Rock Horror this only feels appropriate.

Xavier Casanova

Barbarian would be such a fun reaction. And they MUST watch Weapons.

Kaushik Sethunath

Here's requesting 2015 Best Picture winner and black comedy, Birdman! For the filmmaking, performances and general vibe, I think it'll be right up George and Simone's alley, and would make for a great reaction. Would love to atleast see it in a poll soon!

Godrick

If you had asked me to arrange these movies based on most votes to least votes- I wouldve gotten it 100% correct.

Warmachine1228

Still hoping for A Long Kiss Goodnight sometime soon.

Jimmy Olofsson

Don't really have a strong personal favorite in here but voted Barbarian as I think it's the kind of movie that lends itself well to the reaction format and I enjoyed it!

John

Its a fun movie and worth a watch

FWPJR.

I love seeing that Rocky Horror Picture Show is winning right now, it’s a really fun and entertaining movie. So I know it’ll definitely be great watching you two react to it.

Marko T.

Peter Jackson's King Kong is amazing

FWPJR.

You don’t have to keep requesting movies over and over again, they keep a list of movies every time we suggest one.

DonkyDave

Crimson Tide is actually a 90s banger, can someone please tell Simone that it has Viggo Mortensen in it so she can rig the poll

Matthew Mosley

watched last night ... sooo different.

FWPJR.

I’ve watched it at home many times and I love it, and one of those times was my very first times watching it. But I’m sure it was a blast watching it in theaters when it first came out. I missed that happening by a few years ( I was born in 1983 )

Cinebinge

hi Matthew, all movies are made from films recommended by patrons. all recommendations are placed in a backlog with each movie accompanied by a numeric score, the score is based on how many different patrons suggests the same movie (spamming does not count). each poll then takes some from the top of the score, some from the middle and some from the bottom. if theres a theme like a genre, then its exclusively from films of that genre (base on what imdb says the genre is), and other times there is no theme such as this week, then its entirely a random grab.

Zack Gallardo

It bugs me now because I know I SHOULD like the DC more, but since I saw it second and saw the other version dozens of times first, the extra scenes throw me off of pacing. Either way, one of my favorite films. The cast, scenery, fights, dialogue, characters, ugh so great!

jmundt33a

And Denzel, and Hackman.

Fox

Please add Tyranasaur 2011, Olivia Coleman. Session 9 2001.

Nabikon

Still hoping for Freaked (1993) to be add over any of these

Xavier Casanova

Which did you watch, Barbarian or Weapons?

Fox

Dragon the Bruce lee story please

Paul Mix

+1 on the '76 version of King Kong… that's "my" version, so to speak. Plus Jeff Bridges is always awesome.

ChiefKC

Let's do the Time Warp AGAIN!

Tom P

Please consider "Breaking Away" (1979). Winner of best screenplay Oscar. A funny story of four local kids living in the shadow of the University of Indiana.

Paul Mix

A random comedy recommendation I don't think I've suggested yet: - Four Weddings and a Funeral (1994)

FWPJR.

You should enjoy watching it, like I said it’s fun and entertaining movie. But if you don’t like it I’d understand.

Onikaze

ah thanks, I was unaware. however I try not to do it incessantly, I think the last time I did so was sometime last year

jmundt33a

She may say chefs do that, but only insane navy cooks do that. But Under Siege is an entirely different class of movie.

jmundt33a

Runaway Jury is also fabulous, with Hackman on the other side of an unwinnable suit Also, Dustin Hoffman, Rachel Weiss, John Cusack, Jeremy Piven, Leland Orser, Bruce McGill (before he went crazy), Bruce Davison, and Dylan McDermott.

Maarten Martens

I'm hoping for Big Fish (2003) to come up again in a poll. It will probably not win, but one day it will. That day will be a good day.

Shibby

Two more british crime comedy's you may enjoy are: RocknRolla Layer Cake

Logan Nelson

Really, rocky horror? This should be experienced in a theater live... Its the only way to watch it appropriately... But alas, here we are... Lol..

FWPJR.

Oh ok, I just said that because sometimes people will recommend the same movie ( or movies ) on every poll.

Warmachine1228

Ummm... you stopped the Kevin Smith film series at Chasing Amy. You did Dogma 1st which was the next film. After that is Jay and Silent, Bob Strike Back which might be the most fun film Kevin Smith has ever done.

Logan Nelson

It's not that great on screen as a home viewing experience... Its one of the few films that really works when watched with a large group of fans... Half of the fun of the film comes from the audiences interaction... Just a wierd movie for a channel like this where they can't even see each other while reacting... All good tho...

JayF

Rocky Horror is the best film on the list IMO. Instead of "A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood" I'd suggest going with the documentary from 2018 "Won't You Be My Neighbor?".

Smooticus

yeah, it's definitely an audience participation movie. If you don't get tehat part of it, it's kind of a letdown.

jmundt33a

No. Just…no. Two films which definitely aren’t comedies. An early Matthew Vaughn…thing, and an inferior Guy Ritchie effort. Of course I’m even reevaluating The Gentlemen after finding out the whole thing is a product placement bonanza for his non-cinematic hobbies including the grill and the beer/ale brand.

jmundt33a

About Time. Have they done Notting Hill yet? And they did Love Actually. About Time is about as invisible as Robbie and Kirby can be, but it’s great fun.

Eric Taylor

Rocky horror is definitely fine to watch for your first time as just a regular movie in your own home. If you've never seen it and go to a live event with audience participation and all that it's just going to be crazy and confusing. See if you enjoy the movie as it is first and then consider seeing it live later on. I've done both and personally while I enjoy the props and the shouting and the singing along, and the dressing up, I don't care for the shadow cast that people do in front of the screen and I can't imagine someone who's never seen the film going and having all that chaos at once while trying to enjoy the movie for what it is. If you can't sit at home and watch the movie by itself then you don't really even like the movie, you just like the gathering.

Eric Taylor

I'd really like to see a continuation of the conjuring series. Part two is my favorite

Jaaahn

if they watch rocky horror for the FIRST TIME in a theater with fans, the only thought they would have after the movie would be "i sure wish i've could heard the movie instead of people screaming and shouting".

Relic

I like The Drop (2014) some time down the road. Tom Hardy, James Gandolfini's last film.

Jaaahn

its only that experience after the first time viewing.. if they watch rocky horror for the FIRST TIME in a theater with fans, the only thought they would have after the movie would be "i sure wish i've could heard the movie instead of people screaming and shouting".

Mintea

Here's some more recommendations that I don't see too often: - Tank Girl (1995) - Annie Hall (1977) - Luca (2021)

Charles Gaba

Please consider the following films: --The Russia House (1990) (espionage/romance) --Ladyhawke (1985) (medieval fantasy/action)

Brina Blue

Thanks for your post! I confused the 2 movies so now I'm going to change my vote!

MaikeruNeko

I love RHPS, but as an introvert seeing it live sounds overwhelming and just not fun. I have and will continue to enjoy it on my own terms, and there's nothing wrong or inappropriate about that.

Logan Nelson

They had subtitles when I watched it, for this very reason lol... (Small screening, ~150" screen, ~20 people, 3 loaves of bread used 🤣🤣)

Alex Wong

Continue with Rocky please, I've been waiting for you guys to get to Creed. Thank You!

Jaaahn

yeah again thats only a great experience for you because its not your first time seeing it or hearing the songs. what you really think subtitles and drunken screaming crowd singing is better than the actual performances in the movie, the performances that made those people fans in the first place??

Thomas Cunningham

Still waiting on an "Into the Wild" (2007) reaction someday, hopefully.

Dane Winton

Lots of good ones for me in this one, really like Rocky Horror and Furiosa, Barbarian is wild and even though I haven’t seen it in years I remember being quite fond of Peter Jackson’s King Kong. Not familiar with the other three.

Polecat21

at some point King Kong - 1933 version

Jaaahn

yeah i mean that may be the experience for you it doenst mean it will be so for them. all those people in the theater screaming and singing had to at some point, watch it for the first time in a theater. at some point when the movie first came out, everyone only saw it as a new film without the screaming audience. it only became that experience years and years later.

Jeff I.

Highly recommend Barbarian and Weapons for horror in October! Both written and directed by the same guy and both are really good.

Corabal

Kung Pow has disappeared as an option, that can only mean we're getting it soon 👀

@Foodmancing

The directors cut of kingdom of Heaven is one of my top 10 favorite movies

Tim Hibbard

As a proud Yinzer (someone from Pittsburgh PA), I would love to see you guys watch A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood. Mr Rogers is quite possibly the greatest export this town has ever produced. Greater even than ALL of the steel, ketchup, and pickles we ever made combined. lol

Tim Hibbard

Rocky Horror will make for a great non-horror spooky season movie.

FWPJR.

I’ve only watched it at home, I wasn’t born when it came out in theaters ( I was born in 1983 ) and judging by the comments I guess I’m weird from enjoying it from home lol

Major Peril

So, come up to the lab and see what's on the slab...

Daniel Smith

Never Let Me Go. Will keep suggesting each week regardless of the poll type as you need to know as little as possible about this great film. I don’t even want you to know the genre.

Jeb Manning

Peter Jackson's King Kong is great, but I really hope you would react to the 1933 original. It's one of the best movies ever made, and it's one of my top 10 favorites.

R. Chang

I don't know if I can say that Rocky Horror is a good movie - it kind of falls apart towards the end for me. But it's a wild ride everybody should experience and I have deep nostalgia for it from my college days and some of the songs I genuinely love. I have no idea how you guys are going to feel about it.

Lars G

I feel like the whole point of Rocky Picture Horror Show is to see it at midnight at a show. Not quite sure how it will translate

R. Chang

Yeah. So much of my feeling about this movie is tied to the experience of seeing it at a midnight showing in a packed theater with a live cast, all the props and shouting at the screen. It will be very interesting to see how it plays to them without that.

QuoteO

I would love to see „All Quiet on the Western Front“ (2022), a classic beautifully remade, won a couple of Oscars.

Clipped

Rocky Horror Picture Show, but I mean you gotta get some newspapers, toilet paper, squirt guns, toast, etc.

m

arse cock?

m

All of those, mostly Palm Springs is a standout personally, as is Slevin, and with Palm Springs I have to recommend my favorite Samberg movie out there: Popstar: Never Stop Never Stopping. Kinda would guarantee this being up their respective alleys, shit's really funny.

Seth's Coffee Cup Ambush

Great choices here! I don't think you could go wrong with any of them, though Rocky Horror might be the most fun reaction. Some suggestions of no particular theme: Fantastic Mr. Fox (2009) - Wes Anderson's foray into animation is very charming. Isle of Dogs is good too, but I rank this higher. Notorious (1946) - A romantic thriller from Hitchcock, IMO one of his best. The 36th Chamber of Shaolin (1978) - Excellent kung fu classic. I would love to see more reactions to these generally. The Big Sleep (1946) - My favorite Humphrey Bogart role. There's a reason he's basically the archetype for hard boiled detectives. Surprisingly funny for a noir, though I guess it's to be expected from Howard Hawks. The Pink Panther (1963) - Lots of fun. Cozy, charming, ridiculous. It's got that 60's thing going.

m

wdym It's not like they're going to get on the RHPS train without ever watching it to begin with. And fair enough to put a disclaimer out there that it "might not be all it is hyped up to be" - but I mean there really is no substitute to just freaking jumping over your shadow and diving into the material. Which isn't that dense or inaccessible just because you don't get a matched viewing or anything, either. Imagine watching a movie like that in a theater and understanding just about nothing about what the fuck is happening around you, sounds like a bad trip if you ask me.

m

+1 Brick, great stylization and a movie I would visualize as being super difficult to pull off. No idea why that cage was suddenly rattled, but I highly recommend "The Man from Earth" on top. Not at all a similar movie or anything, just bounced around in my mind.

m

Fair enough I suppose, but the theatrical cut is definitely widely considered dogwater for a good reason. The movie was basically stripped of the political connective tissue making it all "make sense", as it were. Pacing sucks donkey feathers, studio interaction ruined it because they were trying so hard to go for another Gladiator. Theatrical vs. DC, imho, is an IMDB 6 epic drama "decent attempts" vs. easily one of the best historical epics on film, subject to personal preference, obviously. Much less so than, say, Blade Runner and the "noir narration drama" - where I can perfectly see either side making a great case for why it does or doesn't help the final product. Sadly not going to be it for now, but it is a fantastic movie and discusses lots of interesting cultural and historical aspects just about anyone could do with, just for the sake of education.

m

also the goshdarn (no blaspheming!) Gregson-Williams OST leaning into the Zimmer vibes... weird that I entirely forgot to mention it. It's great.

TheNeonRabbit

Antici............................pation

Maniacalmouse

No need for a connection. It is a random list, after all lol. I will have to check it out.

sarCC

While it looks like watching Barbarian might be a ramp up to Weapons(which, in my opinion should be viewed BEFORE Barbarian...just to keep your expectations lower), I do worry that mean this year's hot, popular thriller will be seen before last year big, popular thriller everyone was buzzing about: LONGLEGS. So, I just want to see if I can drum up some support for that surprisingly great thriller featuring Nic Cage and current Scream Queen Maika Monroe.

sarCC

Such an excellent movie.

Logan Kerlee

Pretty sure a couple of the songs will miss while others will land very well. It's a classic for a reason. :)

sarCC

And dialogue punched up by Quentin Tarantino (it's pretty easy to clock his most obvious contributions).

Logan Kerlee

Absolutely true but it's a sad fact that most haven't had the opportunity to watch this show live. I feel that this is the easiest/best way to introduce folks who are either scared or opposed to watching something live/in the theater.

Logan Kerlee

I'd be down for a reaction with that. :)

Zack Gallardo

This is such a good flick. Definitely punches above its weight.

UnlicensedOkie

I wish they’d do a special theatrical release here in the US, since it went straight to SYFY channel here. That’s where I watched it when it premiered back in 2002

D.A.V.E.

I know the Time Warp Song because it was on Top of the Pops in the 80s but I've never seen Rocky Horror, I guess I'll watch it for the first time next week.

Zack Gallardo

I graduated in '07 and this was definitely a formative film for me as a young warthog.

rictus grin

a list with a lot of what i think are good movies , but rocky horror FTW ;)

Michael Buhl

My wish list: Network After Hours Sunset Boulevard Duck Soup How to Get Ahead in Advertising The In-Laws (1979 version) Dog Day Afternoon Withnail & I Fitzcarraldo The Wicker Man (1973 version) Paper Moon Barry Lyndon The Pink Panther (1963 version) The Conversation Beyond the Valley of the Dolls Lost in America It's a Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad World Death at a Funeral (2007 version) Sullivan's Travels Bedazzled (1967 version)

Cavatica

This is a great list!

QuiGon

Great recommendation!

QuiGon

Two more recommendations: - Darkest Hour (UK, 2017): This would be a great complement to Dunkirk, which you have already watched. - Inside Man (USA, 2006): Another great Denzel Washington movie.

Jonathan thomas

Watch Bright (2017) action - comedy. Please thanks

Jose Robles

Kingdom of Heaven, love that movie, hope more votes for it!

Jethro Divine

It would be really funny to see an entire poll of parody-type films someday. Sure, most of them are feces, but a few of them do have some odd sort of entertainment value. I'm not holding my breath for this one. It could look something like: Superhero Movie Stan Helsing Epic Movie Dracula, dead and loving it (Leslie Nielsen doing Leslie Nielsen things alongside Mel Brooks) Not Another Teen Movie Meet the Spartans Have a nice day!

Jonathan Eaton

I just wish they could watch Rocky Horror with the audience participation soundtrack. The audience participation is what made the movie a cult classic.

Jaaahn

you want them to not be able to hear the movies original audio/music lol?

Vengeance

Have G&S seen Thank You For Smoking? Dark comedy, satire starring Aaron Eckhart.

Layan

Horror movies recommendations - bring her back - Talk to me - Weapons - Death becomes her - Longlegs - The lighthouse - Pearl

Adam

Task is only 2 episodes in so far, but I'm ready to nominate it for the short show poll. It's already great.

dansoddity

man Furiosa is so good

zak

Please do Barbarian this spooky season! Also Strange Darling is an excellent horror film you should check out.

Kinokind

I've seen it both ways, upon original release and at one of the most famous audience participation theaters back in the day. Although the latter is big fun (an Eddie clone drove an actual motorcycle down the aisle to the stage - exhaust and all), as participation became more codified and enthusiastic, many of the jokes and much of the dialog was drowned out, as was some of the music. I would advise seeing the original version, as God and Richard O'Brien intended, then see (or better, attend) the real-life cult extravaganza it has become. You can't appreciate the call and response if you don't know the original dialog.

Matthew Mosley

Thanks for the reply. So can I just drop recommendations anywhere ?

BellaBlue

I was really hoping for Barbarian...w Furiosa as a solid option...but before voting I predicted RHPS would win so not surprised... I do believe everyone should see RHPS...however...my personal opinion is it isn't best for reactions..and should always be experienced in the theater where the entire audience participation portion is all part of the fun and experience...so it's fine...but more than anything I feel bad for you guys (S&G) that you won't experience the first time in the way it should be experienced

BellaBlue

Yes....finally I see someone else mention Strange Darling...such a great film... and been wanting Barbarian for awhile now as well...and w Cregger hitting another home run w Weapons hopefully they will get on top of that

max

Damn barbarian would've been perfect. Such a unique style of horror and with the recent release of Weapons too. Both such great films. Zach Cregger on a roll cant wait to watch you both react to that... maybe closer to Halloween.

BellaBlue

Requests for your consideration: October is around the corner division: - Talk To Me (2022) - Black Phone (2021) Note: Sequel coming out this year - Longlegs (2024) - Late Night With The Devil (2023) - Heretic (2024) - Presence (2024) - Men (2022) - Abigail (2024) - The Menu (2022) - Infinity Pool (2023) - Fear Street Part 1: 1994 (2021) - Fear Street Part 2: 1978 (2021) - Fear Street Part 3: 1666 (2021) - The VVItch (2015) - Strange Darling (2023)

Mycenaeus

Two random suggestions: Battle of Britain (1969) Sex Kittens Go to College (1960)

BellaBlue

tbh..IMO .the film should really only be watched in the theater w audience participation...certainly as a first time experience..but it is what it is

Trevor S Bright

I really hope they see the original 1933 King Kong before the 2005 one. I kinda hope they see them close together. If the '05 one wasn't so long, I'd almost suggest they do an original/remake double feature like they did with the Nosferatus.

BellaBlue

which is why it should be seen in the theater for a first timer IMO..the entire experience is what makes it so fun and memorable...the film itself is just a solid B flick

BellaBlue

I agree completely. Wo the entire experience of it, its really just an ok B flick... the whole point of it is the fanfare and craziness of being in the theater..the water guns...etc etc

BellaBlue

it is a classic when experienced in the theater w a live audience and all the nonsense that comes w it... otherwise it is a very mid b flick

Jeffrey

RHPS really needs to be a live watchalong.: )

Seth's Coffee Cup Ambush

Great list. Infinity Pool was wild. Unhinged in a good way. What a trip. The VVitch was great, I'd love to see a reaction to that as well.

zak

Glad to see someone else appreciate that film, although i am starting to feel bad for Kyle Gallner, he keeps doing great stuff that doesn't get the attention it deserves, like Dinner in America

R. Chang

I think it's got a bit more going on than that, but I agree it is hard to separate my opinion of the movie from those crazy midnight showings.

AC10

Will we ever see Simone flip a Loonie again?... 😐

Jack Mingle

they need to do the extended cut of (2005)

TheGrimOne

I shiver in antici...

Anders Sandum

Movie recommendations: The Man Who Would Be King(1975) The Mission(1986) The Last of the Mohicans(1992) Quiz Show(1994) Cold Comfort Farm(1995) Hackers(1995) Rob Roy(1995) Swingers(1996) Beautiful Girls(1996) Kingpin(1996) Event Horizon(1997) Dangerous Beauty(1998) Stigmata(1999) Deuce Bigalow: Male Gigolo(1999) Almost Famous(2000) Gosford Park(2001) Bandits(2001) The Royal Tenenbaums(2001) Spy Game(2001) Joe Dirt(2001) Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back(2001) A Mighty Wind (2003) The Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou(2004) I Love You, Man(2009) Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy(2011)

McShades

If you ever get a chance, you should give Real Steel (2011) a viewing, it's a very underrated movie. If you liked Rocky, odds are you will like Real Steel.

Matthew Johnson

What a good list. Definitely co-sign a bunch of these, especially Gosford Park

John

The 13th warrior is great

John

I definitely would co-sign network

Seahag

I know King Kong isn’t coming in second by a huge amount, but if it still does…can we pretty please get it later?

Seahag

Also could do a double feature on it like Nosferatu

Charles

Came here to just comment and recommend Role Models! 😝

James W.

Kingdom of Heaven director's cut only. That theatrical cut was dogshit, beautiful but poopy nonetheless.

Perry Campbell

I hope u can add (King Kong 1976) it’s still my Favorite Kong movie. Loved the soundtrack too😍😍😍

sarCC

All great recommendations, especially 13 Assassins!!! [Unrolls scroll]

sarCC

Yeah, Strange Darling was one of my top 3 favorite films of last year and Willa Fitzgerald was my favorite performance.

sarCC

Yes, the documentary is WAAAAAAAAY better. I can understand watching the bio pic version later, but not before. Same goes for Man On Wire and The Walk.

Jonathan Eaton

And make sure to sit in the back row.

Merlin's Merkin

Please, please, *please* at least put Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (1990) on a poll. I've subscribed for *years* at this point and while I keep doing it because I love you guys (as a fan, nothing weird) I've really just been waiting and hoping for that movie and I'm absolutely shocked it hasn't come up yet.

Shawn B

Hey, there must be a glitch or something, I don't see, "Willow (1988)", in the poll at all!

Shawn B

You have my vote for TMNT

Shibby

RocknRolla is most definitely a comedy even if you don't personally find it funny. Layer Cake is funny to me, in a dark way. If you don't want to watch them you don't have to, I recommended these because I believe Simone and George will enjoy them.

Emily G

Practical Magic please 🙏

warcrimes

05 King Kong is so bad. also cant believe thats 20 years ago

elias rinis

Ypu should really do both the original and 2005 King Kong, same as Nosferatu, that reaction was so unique i really liked it.

Bruce Liddle

Just been to see the 50th anniversary released of Rocky Horror. Superb. Forgotten how many times i've seen it now. Have it on VHS, laserdisc, dvd and bluray. Soundtrack on vinyl, cassette and cd. Phew.

Joe

Barbarian and Weapons double feature!1

Mike W

Seeing people's thoughts on what your first experience of rocky horror should be, reminds me how wonderfully different people are. For me, watching it for the first time in a room with people who have seen it multiple times and react before something happens and are loudly taking over it would be awful. I would feel so lost and out of place.

Brandon Meng

Sadly, I don't feel strongly about any of these movies, but The Rocky Horror Picture Show would be a great precursor to The Perks of Being a Wallflower for reasons you'd understand as you watch the movie. Recommending the following for future consideration: Perks of Being a Wallflower Sideways Nebraska Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri Manchester by the Sea The Royal Tenenbaums Midnight in Paris The Secret Life of Walter Mitty (2013) Moonrise Kingdom Eyes Wide Shut The Descendants The Holdovers Finding Forrester The Way Way Back The Edge (1997) I Love You, Man Silver Linings Playbook 500 Days of Summer Blue Valentine Big list but I love all of these movies. Here's to hoping one or two might stick. Cheers!

Clipped

You’re 100% correct. I saw it at midnight showings at a theater in Chicago every single week for an entire summer around. It is impossible to overstate how fun that was. Theater nerds acted out the movie in real time to an eager, packed house, which added a whole ‘nother dimension. My favorite crowd participation line will always be “Appearing tonight and one night only…ALFAFA’S SHADOW!”

Jacob King

I didn’t care for Big Fish when it came out. I loved the book and was disappointed with some of the choices. Then I rewatched it recently with Popcorn in Bed’s reaction and (with 20+ years of life experience) it just shattered me. It’s such a great experience.

Jacob King

Perfect October movie!

Jacob King

Absolutely. The best way to see it is as a 14 year old who’s not ever thought much about sex or sexuality and has the volume low because they don’t want to alert the rest of the house to what they’re watching in case they get told to stop.

BH

Man I hope King Kong wins. It’s so good. Please consider adding Flight and American Gangster in a future poll 🙏🏼

BH

We must have watched different movies. 05 KK is incredible

Jacob King

Longlegs was fun but a bit of a letdown compared to The Blackcoat’s Daughter. Still hoping for a Mandy reaction.

jmundt33a

With the passing of Robert Redford, I’d push for a couple of his movies to move up the reaction queue. My choices would be Sneakers for acting and Quiz Show for directing. But I’m curious about other suggestions.

Mike FromOz

Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, for sure.

Emily G

I agree completely!

jmundt33a

All The President’s Men and The Sting. The Natural is a fun baseball film Even Up Close & Personal is better than it is remembered.

Jeff I.

They usually do the second place poll winner two or three weeks after the poll winner.

jmundt33a

Kingdom of Heaven keeps getting kicked on these. I hope they react to the director’s cut someday. Best Bloom, peak Eva Green and Jeremy Irons and Ed Norton doin’ work. Plus a Liam Neeson guest spot.

jmundt33a

American Gangster is awesome. It even prompted a quality TV show as a response and alternate narrative.

Daniel M

I have watched Cinebinge a long time on youtube but I am a new Patreon supporter. Would love to see them react to Super Troopers 2 and Strange Brew. Have those ever come up in a poll?

jmundt33a

Both of those. Also his directorial work Quiz Show.

CT

I'd like to throw out a recommendation for an HBO miniseries called Angels in America (2003). Based on a play of the same name, 6 episodes, Al Pacino, Meryl Streep, Jeffrey Wright. Prestige TV from back in the day. The genre would be Drama/Fantasy(?).

JC

Please watch Into the Blue (2005) it's very underrated!

Xavier Casanova

After news of Robert Redford passing, you guys need to do some reactions to his films. I think you both would love: - All the President's Men - The Sting - Sneakers

Relic

Three Days of the Condor

Levi

Due to Robert Redford passing you should try watching some of his films, they're fantastic! I'd recommend either All the President's Men, a film about the journalists investigating Watergate, you all have said in the past you love competent people doing things competently and this is just that. You don't need to know much about Watergate to get enthralled. And or, Butch Cassidy & The Sundance Kid, a western which has great chemistry between the main two protagonists and gets you empathizing with some morally gray people.

Ian Hunt

Also, recommend the Sting in honour of Robert Redford

warcrimes

Nope but hey, opinions.

jmundt33a

Sneakers has the smallest profile, but it’s great.

Matt

Recommend, Short Circuit 1986

Liquor & Swords

Remember, when you eventually watch Kingdom of Heaven, you'll want the director's cut, it's almost a different film and far superior!

sarCC

I highly doubt it will get many votes as it's very un-widely-seen, but The Hot Rock is one of my very favorite Robert Redford flicks, and one of my fave heist movies.

Michael

Plus a little bit of Kevin McKidd, from HBO's Rome=) Brendan Gleeson in a fun heel role, too.

jmundt33a

I have absolutely never heard of that.

jmundt33a

Fun? In that he seems absolutely cartoonishly evil? I only know McKidd from Journeyman and the first Percy Jackson film.

CappyZed

What are the chances we get RHPS and Diamonds are Forever the same week?

John

I think you could have a Robert Redford Poll: The Natural The Sting Three Days of the Condor Jeremiah Johnson Downhill Racer All the President's Men Indecent Proposal Spygame

John

These are great, but I would add The Natural, one of my top 5 baseball movies of all time

John

I'll support TMNT 1990

jmundt33a

Sneakers, Butch Cassidy, and The Last Castle all missing.

jmundt33a

Sideways and Finding Forrester are the best of these, but Silver Linings Playbook is excellent.

jmundt33a

Perfect fun Halloween movie. There’s something so endearingly weird about seeing Mags Bennett say “Ladies, let’s clean HOUSE!”

jmundt33a

Premonition is a surprisingly good flick. Just to throw out a Julian McMahon title.

Miro Salom

watch weapons (2025) now that it’s out!

Ashton Lewis

100% agree. Would love to see that reaction

Ashton Lewis

It would be interesting to hear George's take on the mythology of that film for sure. Plus, Jackie Chan and Jet Li in the same film = awesome

Marko T.

Peter Jackson had amazing 4 years in the early 2000s: LOTR trilogy and King Kong.

Fox

The father, Anthony Hopkins

Daniel Smith

I think they will love it. So glad I watched it blind, had no idea where the film was headed.

Florian

Just remembered a movie while watching Stranger Things and the CIA comments, "the good shepherd" highly recommend

CappyZed

Ah I was just thinking "Charles Gray Week"

Jeff I.

Seconded! The Father won Anthony Hopkins an Oscar for Best Actor, and it's arguably one of the best performances of his career. Great storytelling and Olivia Colman is excellent as well.

beefjerkywizard

Perfect for spooky season. Also Weapons is my favourite film of the year, so far

E-You

Given the recent passing of Robert Redford how about we watch one of his movies, that you 2 have not seen? There is a lot to select from new and old (even Twilight Zone episode from the 60's). My pick would be a hidden gem of a movie, "Lions for Lambs". 2007 film that stars RR, Tom Cruise, Meryl Streep and Michael Peña.

E-You

My pick would be "Lions for Lambs," a 2007 film that stars RR, Tom Cruise, Meryl Streep, and Michael Peña.

Jonathan Eaton

I just found out the Audience Partici… pation soundtrack for The Rocky Horror Picture Show is on Spotify so I will be syncing that with the reaction for a little added fun.

max

Yeah I heard a lot of mixed things about it but after actually watching it... god damn I wanna see them react to it bad, it was so so good.

Rupert Purcat

RIP Julian. Great actor for a PM's son. Shame he did not get more movie roles.

Geoff Murphy

Hi! If you are looking for October movies I would like to suggest “Abraham Lincoln, Vampire Hunter” and “Bubba Ho-Tep”

Kyle B

If you guys have a Halloween poll brewing, I suggest Pumpkinhead. So, few have reacted to it, and it's a fun creature flick with a good mythology, and top-notch creature effects.

ChiefKC

You guys should really consider doing this as a live reaction.

Civil Hooligan

Throwing a random recommendation in to check out American Me. It's a gangster movie that covers the origins of The Mexican Mafia and used real gang members as extras. The film is fantastic and the behind the scenes stories of what occurred during filming to the extras adds to the weight of the film and it's overall message.

Maeve1667

Have you guys seen Birdcage (1996) with Robin Williams and Nathan Lane? It is such a funny movie!

Logan Kerlee

Just want to mention how much I appreciate all of you. :) Ya'll choose awesome movies and I'm always having a great time watching these reactions. I've been a sub for quite some time now - I just felt that this was a good time to declare how thankful I am. :) Be well, everybody!

Marko T.

Peter Jackson was actually making King Kong movie in 1997-8. It was in early production but got cancelled. Then he made Lord of the Rings. When they were big successes Universal got back to him and asked if he wanted to make King Kong and he said yes. Pre-production started when Return of the King was in post-production.

Mk

Yeah! Exactly what he said **fingers crossed**

Logan Kerlee

I LOVE how well the Rocky Horror Picture Show reaction turned out! :)