Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Episodes: The Schizoid Man, Unnatural Selection, A Matter of Honor

Go to this site: Cinebingers.ca for the unedited versions of all our content.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/uGTTA28db6 👈 for the full reaction where you do not need your own copy.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/29KjzPkl59 👈for the full reaction where you need your own copy.

If you are on a phone/tablet, hold down the link above and press "open in browser", or go straight to Cinebingers.ca on your browser app.

Files

Comments

Mikebdrx

It’s not the size of the tattoo it’s how you place it that counts.

Robert Cooper

I do not understand why they didn't just take the Lantree in tow. I mean, it's still a ship. Take it back to Sol and sterilize it. Also, I don't even want to get into this episode and the wider plot line that the Federation doesn't allow genetic engineering on humanoids. :P

Robert Gendron

Watching The Schizoid Man as a kid, I never realized how much of a portrayal of an abusive romantic partner it was. Constantly hurting people while saying he's not violent, classic DARVO in blaming everyone else for his actions. I wish it was a little more clear that Data defeated Graves's consciousness. Because as-is it looks too much like Graves realized the harm he was doing, which is not a great portrayal of an actual abusive partner, especially for their victims who think 'they can change'.

JakeyShakeyBakeyBoy

Just wanna say I have always enjoyed “A Matter of Honor” because Jonathan Frakes is a charismatic dude and really shines throughout that episode. Also keen for next week and for Mr George to first-time watch one of my all-time favourite episodes to see how it “Measures” up for the good sir. Anyways, I hope you also enjoy the watchalongs everybody 😌🤙🏻

GAB

The lines that Picard quotes in "The Schizoid Man": "So long as men can breathe or eyes can see, So long lives this, and this gives life to thee." are the final two lines of Sonnet 18 "Shall I compare thee to a summer’s day?" by William Shakespeare. The sentiments of the poem are very appropriate to the episode's theme of facing mortality . It's somewhat a retread of the TOS episode "What Are Little Girls Made Of?"

Brandon

'A Matter of Honor' has always been a favorite of mine. Watching Riker do well among Klingons is always fun to see. "One... or both?" 😂 That was Susie Plakson playing the Vulcan Dr. Selar in 'Schizoid Man'. She'll appear again as a Klingon soon enough and as various other races over the course of different Trek series.

Joe Stacey (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-05 05:00 I don't know how long in advance you film, so I'm probably too late for this, but Episode 9 has an extended version that's well worth finding. The additional scenes do improve it, in my opinion.
2025-09-17 13:47

Edina Lewis

“When I stroke the beard thusly” might be my favourite line in all of Star Trek!!!

GAB

The premise that genetic experimentation on humans is permitted as depicted in "Unnatural Selection" flies in the face of what is established in a later Star Trek series, which I guess either chose to ignore this episode or forgot that it ever existed. It's certainly seems inconsistent with the distrust of human augmentation that led to the Eugenics Wars mentioned in the episode "Space Seed" from the original Star Trek series.

Fedora The Explorar

I think the production team for the Klingon food in Matter of Honour said they went to a local Asian market to get the food so it tracks

Light Movies

And here is when George realizes issues on the holodeck are not the worst. A malfunctioning Data could be a mess to handle.

SuPaTiLt

I will refrain from talking about transporter nonsense because I don't want to bring up spoilers but... As far as that sub-atomic species being used as a weapon and changing everything, most likely it would become standard procedure on all Starfleet vessels (and probably those of every affiliated society) to scan for it and they now know to use the neutrino beam or whatever to remove it. So it would rarely if ever be an issue going forward.

StonyD

I disagree. I think the "added" scenes disrupt the pacing, and the added moments of the antagonist in Ten Forward kills his character development later imo. I would prefer they stick with the classic aired episode that everyone knows and loves.

Robert Cooper

I just want to know... Worf hands Riker a small cyndrical tracker. The uniforms down have pockets until Season 3. Where did he put the tracker?

StonyD

Hmmmm....let's see....Oh that one, the doctor guy....pass.....next, the one where Pulaski is "older"....ugh, pass.....OH! The one with Riker on a Klingon ship. Play!

R. Chang

As someone who hated Pulaski when this was first airing, i was very disappointed when she didn't die in that episode.

Gryff

Enterprise sketch tramp stamp! Vote today!

SnabbKassa

completely off topic, I'd like to politely suggest Muriel's Wedding 1994 as a non-American choice. tho Shanelle Riccio already did it and had to take down her reaction because of copyright.

The Real Andrew Kim

LOL the look that Simone gave to camera when George mentions the fusions that could happen with the transporter just said IYKYK with her eyes XD

Gryff

Ladies and gentlemen! Chief Miles O'Brien!

Matt O'Keefe

Yes, thankfully Suzie Plakson will be back. Not only as one of the best characters, but also because she is hot as two different species.

Thall

I will always like Pulaski more than Crusher. Crusher has no personality to me. Pulaski is... grating sometimes, but Crusher is just so forgettable to me. Pulaski also develops, she is not attacking Data anymore for example. Crusher is just Crusher, but I couldn't name a single episode where she is lead.

Data Cable

That "Not engineered, created." line might become retroactively significant, as though Dr. Kingsley were trying to draw a legal distinction.

Nabikon

The doctor in the 2nd episode turned 35 a week before, and so did I lol

R. Chang

That's true. But if you think about it, given the number of world-ending technologies that we've seen and the lack of countermeasures, it's surprising that we don't see them deployed more often, if only by terrorists.

dc

This was a pretty strong 3 episode run! I always had a soft spot for Dr. Pulaski. She gets off on the wrong foot with Data and Picard but definitely improves over the course of the season. You can tell she has grown fonder of Data by the end of “Unnatural Selection”. “A Matter of Honor” is one of my favorites from Season 2. Riker adapts really well to the Klingon ship and warrior spirit, and turns in an impressive performance. “Measure of a Man” is one of my other favorites from Season 2—looking forward to next week especially.

Matt O'Keefe

Do not worry George, there are plenty of Worf episodes coming. Deep and complex episodes.

Gryff

I'm just gonna say it. As far as Trek series go. Lower Decks will make all your wildest dreams come true. Vote for Pedro.

DasBigUn

In 207: they created people using the genetic understanding of other species to CREAT those (children) and that type of modification isnt allowed. It was HIGHLY regulated to begin with and LOSING a crew and ship..I think that is what lead to them banning that knowledge entirley. After all, there is an episode of DS9 that goes into it. ALSO, I think you are misunderstanding the problem with those EXTENSIVE modification too the Teleporter is nearly implossible to actually achieve multiple times. HELL, O'Brian mentioned it was a extremem RISK too the crew AND the transporter. ALSO, all the mods too the children where made BEFORE they where "Born" they where not natural in ANY way. FINALLY, the last thing, the Federation would never allow any sorta gene-weapons to be made (they know about them and their defense agianst them, but they would never develope them for use activley....MAYBE A CERTAIN SECTION between 30 and 32)

DasBigUn

lmao.... Simone having a "Enterprise tramp stamp" just make me laugh

Thall

Oh nono, they didn't reverse aging in the second episode. All they did was reverse the specific damage done by the "antibodies". That alone brought back her previous "form", because all the aging happened because of the dna changes. Doesn't make sense? You're absolutely right, but that's the explanation.

Jomero

I've always liked A Matter of Honor. It sets a great tone for Klingons in future episodes of this and even other series. I love me some Space Barbarians.

akaTheBAY-AY-RON

George: "Oh, you're not even going to try this time." Simone: "No, not this time. Nope. False. That's totally made up. I made it up. Pure fiction. It's fiction. I made it up. I made this one up. It's a made up tale. Total fabrication. Have you walked out of a mall into a huge parking area, and realized you forgot where you parked your car? Ever gone mountain biking? Have you called a plumber to your home lately? How much money would it take to make you spend the night in a cemetary? " George: "..............................................."

Gryff

Riker like a hurricane!

Henchmen21

The captain of the Klingon ship is played by Chris Collins aka Chris Latta. For those children of the 80s (like me) we grew up with him as the voice of Starscream in Transformers and Cobra Commander in GI Joe. Sadly he died in 1994.

DonkyDave

Just realised what the first episode is next week...

Alan Pownall

The Federation bans genetic enhancement of people (due to the eugenics wars featuring Khan) so I'm really not sure what was going on here.

David N

Star Trek day always puts me in a good mood and the episodes just get better from here, keep it up.

StonyD

I feel like the Ira Graves episode was written with Crusher in mind (pretty Doctor) and so they had to create Selar in order to fill that gap in the script.

WastedPo

Are you saying that Pulaski doesn't do it for you?

AVATAR-X

FYI, William Sheppard is also the father of Mark Sheppard who genre fiction fans might recognize from shows like Supernatural, Leverage, Warehouse 13, Firefly and Doctor Who.

Andrew

"Lieutenant" O'Brien. SMH. Simone just lost her Star Trek card.

doe555

Thank you, I recognized Klags face and didnt know from what. Now i know it was from X-Files. Was surprised to find out, that he played multiple roles in TNG and DS9.

Jpsynergy

Star Trek day :)

Angela's invisible airfryer (corey)

I got too excited for Star Trek day and ordered too much Taco Bell. Just woke up from a 2 hour food coma after finishing the first 2 episodes.

Korpse

Drastic measures (Michael Keaton) 🙌

Lex Kuzma

Simone, you're thinking of Heart of Glory. That was the last "sounds like a Klingon" episode.

Angzarr

I really have trouble suspending disbelief with this one. The idea that a DNA change would instantly change hair color back from white, repair joint damage, etc etc just makes no sense.

MacGuffinStuff

I'm sure someone beat me to it, I always watch these reactions after work and even on my days off I watch after I'm done for the day, but the actor who played the Vulcan doctor in Schizoid Man will be back, I knew I recognized her from something, when she stood in frame with Worf it clicked.

John

You beat me to it!

Angzarr

And Max Headroom! Speaking of, there's another one for the "series I'd like reactions to" file. A short one too (6 episodes S1, 8 Episodes S2) they could maybe fit in between other things..

Angzarr

At least that would have been a more interesting and memorable ending than Tasha Yar got.

MacGuffinStuff

This is probably obvious but I just think that as much as I actually like Pull Sackee (don't you hate when that happens, like sitting the wrong way and one gets scrunched?), I think she just wasn't a good fit because, to me Bones and Spock were necessary to balance Kirk, he's intelligent and brave and moral, but you know how Kirk kind of sometimes goes into situations with balled fists and chest first, he's almost a hero from Western which makes sense because TV back then was a lot of tough guys with neat haircuts and no facial hair; and Spock and McCoy sort of hold him back sometimes, not in a bad way, but they'd say "But Jim", they were Kirk's But Guys. But Picard doesn't really need anyone, usually, to hold him back in anyway, he's already a calm, steadfast, logical, sagacious commander, and brave. Beverly "Bedside Manner" Crusher is strong and capable and like a calming presence, and if I'm being honest, for me it's her chemistry with Jean Lúc, and Gates McFadden is striking. Speaking of getting your sack pulled lol, I saw this post once, just the question, something like, "as a woman, if you were a man for a day, what would be the worst thing?" And like 99% of the comments were women saying "having balls" because they can often be very inconvenient, especially against people who fight dirty, also lawn tools, and my cousin's toddlers.

Patrick47

She's not wrong; at this point in the show, O'Brien wears a Lieutenant's pips 🖖

Patrick47

Well, for one thing, the Federation's ban on genetic enhancement wasn't established until later in the franchise, so if anything it's the later episode that retconned this. However, I don't think the Darwin Station's research falls within the limits of such a ban anyway, since their experiments are essentially a form of gene therapy for medical purposes (improving the body's immune response), and not selective breeding to produce a `superior` race 🖖

Nabikon

Thank you!

gfixler

George: Omg, new doctor, it's DATA, not Data. also George: What's her name? Dr. Placenta?

GAB

O'Brian is a non-commissioned officer in DS9, so how can he be a lieutenant in TNG?

Andrew

Picard literally calls O'Brien Chief in episode 207 right before they transport the doctor back on the ship.

Jaaahn

ones a co-worker within the universe where they have to interact daily, and have professional courtesy. the other is a real person remembering a fictional character on screen, a person that has seen a total of maybe 3 times.

Patrick47

Because, at this point in the show, `Chief`referred to his position as Transporter Chief, not to any rank (TNG hadn't yet established that even were any such thing as enlisted officers in Starfleet anyway, although the producers eventually changed that).

WastedPo

Unnatural Selection is a good episode, but the whole thing where the genetically altered kids look like 20-something's is just distracting. It's actually not necessary to the plot, and it's kind of awkward to watch these adult guest stars trying to pretend like they're children. They literally could've just cast actual kids and had the exact same plot. And then in the end when they're exiled to a lifetime quarantine, it would've felt more tragic.

s0rd3z

I have been looking forward to George seeing episode 9 for quite some time and it's almost here (well technically he has seen it probably I just haven't seen the reaction yet) And I love how one of these episodes kind of plants seeds for it in a way for it. Episode 9 is one of my, and many others, top episodes of all of TNG.

s0rd3z

I am really excited to see Georges reaction to it. It's one of my all time favorites. And I am certainly not alone.

s0rd3z

What exactly IS a "Space... Fuck"?? 🤔

LazyBoy Stays Up Late Watchin Video Tapes

Simone might do better to just egg George on when he expresses his views . As in ; "Oh , I know right? Dr. Pulsaski is so insufferable!" (*^ ‿ <*)♡ ┗(▀̿ĺ̯▀̿ ̿)┓

James Wilson

I could be mistaken in my reasoning, but I don't think what they did with the transporter means they can just recreate their younger selves. My understanding is that the antibodies from the Children altered a normal human's DNA. So the solution simply removed that alteration. Someone please correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't believe our DNA changes much, if at all, as we age. So I don't think this would allow someone to just remove their age the same way it removed the DNA alteration. Although I think that would mean while Dr. Pulaski should've simply stopped aging at the accelerated rate, she should've remained the age she reached while her DNA was altered. Aaaaannnd now my brain hurts. Time to go outside.

Chase Lonnergan

Another example of people just not understanding how Time Turners work. A Time Turner cannot alter established events. To everyone BUT the time traveler, everything must proceed as normal in the course of events. In Time Turner time travel, the events of the time travel are already a part of the established timeline. That is why the rocks were thrown at Harry in Hagrid's shack in the FIRST experience of the events. That is also why wizards who time travel cannot encounter their past selves. So, the very popular and ridiculous question of "Why don't they just go back in time and stop event X?" is answered by: Because that event already happened. To the time traveler, going back in time and killing Voldemort is impossible because they live in a timeline in which Voldemort exists. If they go back and kill him, then that timeline ceases to exist, and the wizard would have no reason to travel time in the first place, creating a massive paradox. Time Turners are not the massive, world-changing, story-breaking, super technology that they just lampshaded and forgot. They are a moderately useless trinket that is more dangerous to use than not to.

SnabbKassa

yes. I have been waiting for that "pertinent" episode. What a piece of work is a man?

Raven Dark

@s)rd3z, well, see, when two stars love each other veeery much... Clearly, I've been spending too much time listening to George and his terrible jokes. :D

Raven Dark

I've been dying to see that one! 8 hours and counting...

Lord Joe

They didn't stop aging, they just corrected the two molecules in Pulasky's DNA that had been altered by the disease. Quick info for nerds: As far as I know, the aging process occurs due to the increasingly shortened telumeres during cell division/renewal. And the less oxidative stress and inflammation there are in the body, the slower this process takes place.

This Justin

In “Unnatural Selection,” they touch on the topic of genetic enhancement more. It gets explored more deeply in Deep Space Nine and Enterprise. In fact, it becomes very important. I will even say it helps explain why the Klingons look different in The Original Series compared to The Next Generation.

Angela D. Mitchell

This was so fun to revisit, and just as clever as I remembered. I love being surprised by a story and this was so good. I also loved that there was no cheating the outcome -- Riker was able to honor each code and brilliantly averted potential galactic consequences. You could see how proud Picard was there, too. The B plot with the visiting alien cadet and Wesley was very sweet -- the character definitely reads as neurodiverse to me. I get a kick out of how Simone always recognizes Jeff Kober when he shows up across various shows (as here) because he was on "Buffy." (I hated his character and that story arc but he was great regardless). For me, Kober will always be the fantastic Vietnam soldier in the superb 90s show "China Beach."