Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Go to this site: Cinebingers.ca for the unedited versions of all our content.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/c4pFnU8Yt4 👈 for the full reaction where you do not need your own copy.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/fSzdLiFcr2 👈for the full reaction where you need your own copy.

If you are on a phone/tablet, hold down the link above and press "open in browser", or go straight to Cinebingers.ca on your browser app.

Episodes: Up the Long Ladder, Manhunt, The Emissary

Files

Comments

StonyD

It's always darkest before the dawn lol

Michael M.

Also worth mentioning, release date wise, Star Trek V: The Final Frontier would fall roughly where we are now

Joel

Just as a point of reference, George, the normal quoted figure for the crew + families on board the Enterprise is 1012

Mastervodo

While "Up the Long Ladder" may have been a bit wonky.... that actress that Riker canoodles with is quite fetching. Quite.

TomGas2025

Slowly you are reaching season 3...there it starts to really take off.

Bruce Woodcock

To answer the questions: 1. 15 generations may seem like a long time, but the point is that no one expects a solution to the replicative fading problem they describe even in 300 years. Sure, it's possible, but it's a non-viable solution anyway do to point 3. 2. Why not just open up migration to the new planet? Because the Mariposans are repulsed by sex and wouldn't inbreed with them. So yes, at the end of the episode, they convince the Mariposans to have sex with the Bringloidi, so in theory, yes, the Mariposans could have sex with any human that migrates. But the Bringloidi are an instant solution to two problems. There's no need to find the Bringloidi another planet to live on, and there's no need to wait the months or years it would take for other colonists to migrate to Mariposa. 3. The biggest part you seem to be missing is that Humans (Earthlings, anyway, which is the majority of Enterprise personnel and a huge part of the Federation) HATE CLONING. Due to Eugenic Wars that happened on Earth previously, any sort of cloning, genetic modification, genetic selection, etc. is completely abhorrent to Humans. There aren't any humans on the Enterprise who are going to agree to it, and it might even be illegal in the Federation at the time. 4. As you said, the repulsion to sexual intercourse is mental, not physical. Plenty of time for that to develop in a society. No one is suggesting there is a physical barrier to sexual reproduction for the Mariposans. 5. The disgust of sexual reproduction probably extends to pregnancy as well, so in-vitro fertilization is still not an "out". It still requires Mariposan attitudes to change, although perhaps that would be slightly more palatable. 6. You also seemed put off by Riker and Brenna having sex when they only just met. This is the 24th Century, people. Humans are sophisticated enough to not have hang-ups about casual sex between consenting adults, and they have the technology to ensure perfectly safe sex. No diseases and no Riker babies.

Scott CineRam

In the last episode of your previous reaction (#217, Samaritan's Snare), what's the reason for the Enterprise dropping off Wesley and Picard in a shuttle when they would have to make a SIX-HOUR trip to their destination??? Why would they not simply fly to the planet where Wesley is due to take his exams?

Eric Wilson

They dont divert the enterprise just for a couple people. It is a matter of wasted time for all the crew.

Spacedone

Take that tongue out of your cheek before you do yourself an injury.

Spacedone

Oh God, my least favourite episode of S2. Save us from Star Trek series and their Hollywood 'Oirish' episodes (looking at you, Voyager...)

Forsythe

Up the Long Ladder felt like someone’s polyamorous fantasy written as a TNG script.

SuPaTiLt

Did anyone else notice Diedrech Bader in the third episode? I wasn't really paying attention but as soon as I heard his voice I was like 'I know who that is!' I tell you what I'd do... Two chicks at the same time

Mike FromOz

"So, we're thinking about making an episode about Space Irish. Any thoughts about how they should be portrayed?" -- "Drunk!" -- "Bumbling farmers!" -- "Sharp-tongued women!" "All great ideas, let's do this."

Bonbon

And to think Up the Long Ladder was written by the same person who wrote The Measure of a Man (Melissa Snodgrass). Yikes!

Hugh Jass

It's amazing that "Up the Long Ladder" was written by the same person who wrote "The Measure of a Man" which was one of the best episode yet.

Data Cable

K'Ehleyr was played by Suzie Plackson, whom you previously saw as the Vulcan doctor Selar in "The Schizoid Man." (Now that I think about it, that ep also featured a modification of the torpedo tube prop, in the transporter room, no less.) *Apparently* there were plans to make that character a love interest for Worf (which might explain why that character was introduced at all, when Pulaski could have filled the same story purpose in that ep), but it seems the plans changed, keeping the actress and replacing the character.

Downside dn

George, i think youre getting stuck on the term "generations." in normal context, that 50-80 years. if you remember from the clone Rhyker and Pulaski, they were cloned at their age of 40/60. they have maybe 30 years each. 15 Generations of adults is not 1000 years, its most likely at best another 300. The entire problem is the genetic degradation of cloning. For 5 people they only have 350 years before complete genetic collapse "in 50 years... its terminal" as said by Doctor Pulaski. Cloning degradation has no solution, giving them another 1000 years wont solve the issue. also the option of sending out a signal to the Federation is not a positive either. They dont want integration, they want cells. they dont want people that arent them living on their planet, "its repugnant" is often stated. Opening their borders to federation colonists isnt what they want. i agree this episode isnt particularly my favorite, but any idea the cloning world had just pushes the problem off. The solution when it was 5 of them should never have been a permanent solution to base their society off of.

Wormtongue

Gotta love when George goes into full prof. mode. And if they think have seen the worst Star Trek episode... just wait until the last episode of the season.

MrCAL

I think Worf is a character that has some of the most interesting dynamics to him. Back in the episode "A Matter of Honor" (where Riker becomes first officer of a Klingon ship), Riker states that he was surprised how much the Klingons laughed and had humour. This was a way of stating that Worf is not actually like a typical Klingon. We know at this point that Worf was raised from childhood by humans, so Worf's knowledge of Klingon culture is built on academic pursuits, rather than practical experience. Due to this, Worf's Klingon identity is based on a idealistic veneer of the race without any realistic nuance. This is why whenever other Klingons come in contact with him, they find him rather stuffy and socially odd. He is the Klingon in their books, not in their reality.

Jomero

The first couple of seasons of TNG absolutely took unused scripts for TOS and retrofitted them to "work" in the current series. It would not surprise me at all that Up the Long Ladder was one of them. I think Season 3 is when all the TOS-ness is pretty much purged from the show. Not that there aren't silly or groan-inducing episodes from that point forward, but it feels like there's a lot less of them. It's why I prefer rewatches starting at Season 3, which Simone also mentions she does as well. As for the fish people, their whole purpose: To give Mick Fleetwood of Fleetwood Mac a guest starring role on Star Trek. Also, in the Holodeck, the man with "the eyes?" Remember those eyes. He will be back in the future as another character. And it will be...... Glorious. To your house.

John Rose

I'm always commenting on "Up the Long Ladder" with other reactors because both my sister and stepmother are extras in the episode as well as my stepmother was an animal trainer that did several episodes of the show including this one. My main reason for getting into TNG was watching this episode with my family. Later on I got to go on the set of one of the movies but that is a story for another day.

John Rose

"Up the Long Ladder" is definitely an episode that hits differently thru todays filter but I must say I didn't think anything negative about it when I watched as a child.

Mastervodo

She really did nail that character. And it is kinda funny that we have seen her before already!

ExoPrime 270

Y’all gotta just sit back and enjoy the ride sometimes. Not everything has to be a serious commentary. Remember this is from the 80’s/90’s. We still aren’t above stereotyping as a society in the 2020’s.

Thall

Edit: Sorry guys, just saying it here again in case you don't read threads. Didn't mean to lash out, wasn't about you either. You're lovely, that's why I am here for your content. Jesus, sometimes I think you just hate Star Trek. Episodes like 218 are just goofy fun. Enjoy it. Not everything has to be dead serious. And if you really hate it so much, just get an episode guide and skip, get to DS9 and move on from there.

Andrew R

Most population genetic papers use 25 years as a generation. Some assume as high as 29 years old. At most that's 435 years. Generations is not the number of avg lifespans of a human but the avg interval between birth of parent to offspring and so on

TomGas2025

The Actress in the Emissary playing Kh'eleyr had already appeared in Season 1 as a Vulcanic Doctor...she will have several apperances on Star Trek...in TNG, in Voyager and Enterprise. Not sure if she appeared in DS 9 as well. And she played Marshalls Mum in How I met your Mother.

TomGas2025

Oh what a lovely Teaparty...😉😂

Niklas Ekman

I normally enjoy goofy Star Trek, but I agree with Simone and George about "Up the Long Ladder". Both the humor and the scifi elements just fall flat for me. To each their own.

Cinebinge

Hi Thall, sorry to hear that you feel that way but nope. As we've stated many times in a lot of Star Trek viewings we both are absolutely enjoying the show and loving it. But to us, loving something does not mean we have to like every aspect and every episode or must find it flawless, and finding flaws and having criticism does not automatically mean we dont enjoy something. To us, when we like something, we become engaged and notices flaws more because we so wish it to be great all the time. It is when we are disengaged and bored that we have nothing to say and simply move on after something is over. Add to that, we are all different people and have different preferences, and that includes preferences in types of stories/tone. Even a great story arc isn't going to hit everyone exactly the same way, and we believe it is important to be able to understand and accept that different people with different minds and different perceptions will like and dislike different things.

Cinebinge

Oh yeah no we understand, we arent expecting it to have the standards of decades later; but to us understanding it does not mean we have to just accept it or enjoy it. And not enjoying one episode or aspect of an episode, does not mean we are not enjoying the ride overall, nor does it mean we require everything to be serious. Remember, everything we discuss is what came to our minds organically as things happen, we are not going to pre-filter everything with a "oh its just the times" censor, otherwise there would be nothing to discuss, everything would just end with "oh its the 80s".

Robert Gendron

Gene Roddenberry had very specific ideas about romantic relationships. You could see it in the Motion Picture with Ilia and Decker, then in TNG with Riker and Troi. Very open relationships where sex was de-stigmatized to be not much more than a handshake like on the utopia planet. So while this episode seems very regressive, it is very much in line with Roddenberry's views of progressive relationships. It's one of the reasons why everyone is rapidly ok with three partners and the sexless society are the villains of the story.

Thall

Look guys, I'm sorry. Wasn't about you, really, just personal stuff coming up, and I was disappointed you didn't enjoy one of my favorite goofy episodes. Didn't mean to lash out at you like that. I am here for how you are and engage with stuff, because you're great people even if I personally have different thoughts sometimes!

GAB

Advance warning that the season finale 222 is yet another stinker. The series then gets much better.

p0sthum4n

George, would you like me to...wash your feet?

gfixler

I've heard both pronunciations of hegemony, those the soft G seems much more prevalent.

p0sthum4n

UTLL: Melinda Snodgrass remarked, "It was intended to be a commentary about immigration, because I hate the current American policy. I wanted it to be something that says sometimes those outsiders you think are so smelly and wrong-colored, can bring enormous benefits to your society because they bring life and energy. That's what I was going for. Now my boss, at the time, was Maury Hurley, who is a major Irishman and leads the Saint Patrick's Day parade. When I was describing to him what I wanted to do, I was trying to come up with an analogy, and I said it was like a little village of Irish tinkerers, and he loved it so much he made me make them Irish tinkerers. I said okay, and that's how it came about." Snodgrass admitted that rewrites and budget restrictions resulted in the intended commentary being lost.

Phil Jacke

Season 1 also has some terrible episodes (code of honor and skin of evil come to mind) but nothing that's as good as the great episodes in season 2. So season two has high highs and low lows but season 1 just has low lows and some okay episodes. Every season has a few stinkers but starting in season 3 the average episode is a bit better (and there's still a few great episodes in every season) which is why most fans think season 3 is when it really gets good

gfixler

The next question is: hə-JEM-ə-nee, or HEJ-ə-mō-nee? English... I give it up.

R. Chang

Up the Long Ladder is widely regarded as one of the worst episodes of TNG. Personally, my pick goes to a certain season 7 episode.

gfixler

"Mariposa, the Spanish word for butterfly." And "Melissa" is the Greek word.

David N

That big purple dress that Lwaxana Troi was wearing looks like something Moira Rose would wear in schitts creek.

DasBigUn

Gorge and Simon should TOTALLY actually watch the bloopers when they get a chance. The bloopers for TNG are hilarious

dc

Dr. Selar! The one Data’s creepy “grandfather” found attractive.

DasBigUn

I forgot how VIOLINTLY IRISH this episode was

PIG

I look forward to Cinegbinge with TNG everyweek and the god damn first episode up just had to ruin 1/3 of it. I was watching this wondering why I didn't remember it, only to realize I always avoided it.

StonyD

It's always near the end of the second season where I cautiously wait to see if the reactor is going to rage-quit the show because of how much it suuuuuuuucks lol

GAB

By the way, you already saw Susie Plaxton (K'Ehleyr) playing the Vulcan, Doctor Selar, in 206 "The Schizoid Man". She makes three more experiences in Star Trek shows - that's as much as I'm saying.

StonyD

George, +100pts for the "Pan-Galactic Gargle Blaster" reference. Don't forget your towel, you hoopy frood! #42

TalynOne

Worf having measles was just character development, not everything has to be about life threatening danger. Up the Long Ladder is just a dumb fun episode. Not a favorite, but far from the worst. If anything our society, especially American society, has regressed when it comes to sexuality. And because of that our prudish puritans attitudes scoff at how easily everyone is willing to go for it. I think Riker's portrayal as a man whore is overblown, if anything Kirk dwarfs Riker's encounters by many magnitudes.

Paul Peavler

Hoo boy, we’re in the season 2 trenches this week. Everybody settle in, it’s a rough one.

Kae

They should probably just skip the finale entirely. It's just entirely a clip show with barely any plot.

Jpsynergy

I'm finding a lot to enjoy even in the 'bad' early season episodes, the ones episode guides usually tell you to skip. I just love these characters so much. Thanks guys. Can't wait for season three.

JD Nevesytrof

I'm positive Picard has never and will never have a sexual thought about Lwaxana and it is nothing but Mrs. Troi's out of control libido and gigantic ego causing extreme wishful thinking.

Gryff

Up the long ladder is one of the more panned episodes out of all of TNG by modern audiences. I dont think anyone has ever said this is their favorite episode. A couple of points of clarification about it where a question was asked. They stated in a quick throw away line that there are roughly 200 Bringlodi. Picard stated most of the crew wouldnt want to be cloned. Picard essentially did George's plan but with the colonist looking for a new planet that he had on hand. It was most convenient because neither were in the Federation so he could avoid most of the paper work. I imagine colonist were invited to move in afterward even if they never joined the Federation.

Angzarr

There's a certain Riker line in "Up the Long Ladder" which... well, IYKYK. I hope I remember to revisit this topic in a few months. It really does feel like a recycled unused TOS script, but as far as I can tell it was not.

Angzarr

Yeah, she really nailed both Klingon and Vulcan. She's great!

Angzarr

Suzie Plakson AND Robert C O’Reilly in a pair of episodes! Two faves. Also, unrecognizeable under the makeup of the Klingon captain is Lance LeGault, an otherwise very familiar face in 80's TV. Best known as the antagonist on The A-Team, Colonel Decker. And the bridge officer in in charge of the phasers in that last episode? You know what he'd do in the holodeck? Two chicks at the same time, man. And I bet if he had enough credits he could hook that up. Chicks dig guys with credits. EDIT: and of course, how could I forget Mick Fleetwood’s Emmy-worthy performance as Hungry Hungry Fish Face!

Angzarr

Eh, Up The Long Ladder is rough, but I like the other two. I like a good silly episode, and holodeck episodes. UTLL though... oof. I think it wouldn't have been quite so bad if it wasn't for "Danilo Odell" (leader of the Space Irish) being so gratingly over the top.

Angzarr

The "oh shit, we ran out of money, now what?" episode.

Emptysea93

I love that you can totally tell Simone remembers something but doesn't want to give it away to George, she becomes so quiet and has this look of abject terror that she might somehow give away a spoiler.

Angzarr

This. I've always felt that he was insecure about not being a "real" Klingon due to being raised by humans, so he's overcompensating by trying to be what he thinks a "perfect" Klingon should be.

Drew Acheson

The actress that plays Worf's love interest you've actually seen already. She was in a previous episode as a Vulcan officer, I think it was the episode where Picard beamed down to the planet to talk to the other captains about the conspiracy in Starfleet. She is also in other Star Trek series as other characters.

James W.

While i certainly understand the nostalgia for long seasons, ep 218 and 219 are exactly why I don't miss them. Self-indulgent filler can be really frustrating. TNG has a lot of filler, a lot of skippables but at least 219 is funny. Edit: 220 is one of my favorite episodes of the whole series. It also made me like Worf more because If found him 1 dimensional and tiresome for the most part. He has ended up being one of my favorite characters across all TNG and related shows.

James W.

GLORY...TO YOU...AND YOUR HOUUUUSE!

gfixler

A few thoughts: 1) I think Lwaxana should marry Harcourt Fenton Mudd. They're perfect for each other. And Q should officiate. And the cat lady from the animated series should be the bridesmaid. And it's a 2-parter. And somehow it's George's favorite episode ever. I know. It makes no sense. 2) I think when Lwaxana, Troy's mother, said she and Riker were getting married, part of his surprised smile was him secretly thinking "Wow, I landed both of 'em!" 3) I think George was trying to disguise his thoughts by saying nice things, but I just get the feeling he didn't like the space Irish one. Call me crazy. 4) there are some real stinkers in trek, but (especially as a kid), it wasn't always about the story. It was just feeling like I was living on the ship. I actually feel like I'm not really there in a lot of polished shows and movies, because they're so sleek, and completely unlike life. Life has goofiness. It has things that go nowhere. That's not an excuse, because I don't usually love things that stink, but at least as a kid, Star Trek could stink, and I'd still love pretty much every episode, because I was on the ship. I was in space. I was living the dream. I actually liked when it would be a little random, because it felt real. It didn't feel like a show. It felt like "Wow, maybe this would really be like what it would be like." It wouldn't be all neat story arcs. It would be messy, like life, just life in space. 5) I realized many, many years later (25 years?) that I'd hate life on the Enterprise. It's basically being in the military. It's a cool version, and I'd be fascinated for a bit, but then I'd just want to be left alone in my room, to do my own stuff. I wouldn't want to fall in line and follow orders. I wouldn't want to wear a scratchy uniform. I'd want to sleep late. I've crafted my life around my laziness. Life on that ship would not fit me very well. If I hung out with anyone, if would probably mostly be Wesley and/or Guinan.

Ron

* Up the Long Ladder: Utterly embarrassing for all concerned. o Actual dialog: "Clones." "Clones?" "Clones." o The title is a reference to an old Irish saying "up the long ladder, down the short rope" as well as to the molecular structure of DNA (cloning). o The phrase itself is a traditional one and relates to the desire of Irish nationalists to punish King William III and his descendants for what they consider to be his crimes against Ireland and the Church. Specifically, they wanted him to walk up the gallows steps (the "long ladder") and then be hung on a short rope until dead. (scifi.stackexchange.com) From the "Journal of American Folk Lore", p. 122 (sec 410) > Up the long ladder, > Down the short rope. > To hell with King Billy! > Three cheers for the Pope! * Manhunt: Another clunker, but, for me anyway, I think Lwaxana is eventually redeemed. * The Emissary: Finally, a good one.

Ben Schwartz

I love when he does. And then Simone will just reply with "Yeah. Mhmm." -- Intellectually, they're on two different levels.

Jimazoid

One thing that irks me is "Real World Logic" vs "TV/Film Logic". IRL, we would most likely make choice that, in the moment, makes sense to us. In TV/Films, they write stuff for the Drama or Plot or such and sometimes we are left wondering WHY?!?! Yes as George pointed out, there were several other things that could of happened During the Up The Long Ladder episode, but the plot of getting the Bringloidi together with the Mariposans, at the end of the episode, makes it an interesting twist. You sometimes have to turn your Real World Logic Brain off when watching stuff and just watch it for the fun sake. Manhunt is a little all over the place, but any Lwaxana episodes are hilarious and like Simone said, She's taking to herself, since Majel is the ship's computer voice! No need to mention Mick Fleetwood since its been mentioned... FOOD! The Emissary: This is a Shared Episode Title, as the Series Premiere of Deep Space Nine is called Emissary. Worf focused episodes are my fave!

MacGuffinStuff

I think I mentioned before why Worf is one of my favorite characters, and The Emissary is specifically one of the reasons, lot of relatable themes about being multicultural by default lol. But it's also just a great episode and a lot of fun, great new character with the Buck Rogers style Lycra bodysuit (Erin Gray, am I right? 😆), and when George said, her poor mother, a human woman with a Klingon man, I've known a few women who would probably put him in his place lol, and they're all like 5 foot 2.

Watchout4J.Who

Might have been noted before, or maybe it's spoilery, but season 2 had the misfortune of overlapping with a Writers Guild strike so there are definitely TOS scripts that had to be rehashed and kitbashed but also lead to some great outside contributors coming onboard for some of the better episodes and of course going forward into Season 3.

Robert Mendoza

I have been looking forward to seeing your reactions to Up the Long Ladder since it's such a bad episode I think it has only two redeeming scenes; Worf and Pulaski sharing tea and the scene in the lab when Riker and Pulaski have their cells stolen. Otherwise it is just so bad.

Spacedone

They said a while back they're intending to do them by chronological release date so Star Trek 5 should be coming up between TNG S2 and S3

WastedPo

I think maybe you're remembering this wrong (or I am). K'Ehleyr, played by Suzie Plakson, appeared earlier in this very season. She was the Vulcan doctor that beamed down in "The Schizoid Man" that the old guy kept hitting on. And to address George's post-show comments, she is still pretty distinct looking and identifiable, even in the Vulcan ears.

WastedPo

I agree with George about "manhunt." there were actually a lot of genuinely funny things in this episode, and it could've been good (if a bit lightweight) if they just stuck with the main plotline of Deanna's mother. But the foray into the holodeck took up so much screen time, and felt like it was a script from another episode, that it bordered on incompetence. George came up with a great idea that Picard should've told Lwaxana that he was seeing someone else. (And then there'd be a scene where they have to pretend to be dating.) Then they could've stretched the whole plot to encompass the entire episode. Of course, then we'd essentially get "Three's Company" style hijnks involving the TNG crew, but I frankly would be fine with that.

Drew Acheson

You are absolutely correct, I had that wrong. Good call!

emmanuel override

Sorry if you know this and I am stating something that is already obvious…. You commented about the openings…. they were often designed to be able to be cut. The show was both designed for broadcast and syndication. Some places where it was shown had shorter air times, so shows usually had a scene that could be cut to meet the time requirement without disrupting the overall story. The opening was often used for that purpose. I appreciate the art of it.

punterjoe

Up the long ladder still makes me cringe. It's not the first (or last) time Trek has turned Irish culture into a 24th century lucky charms commercial. From drunken Riley taking over the ship and serenading the crew with "I'll take you home again Kathleen" in TOS to all the stuff you haven't gotten to yet. No spoilers, but just WAIT til Voyager! 🙄 Trek has been almost as brutal on the Irish as Family Guy (both shows created by folks of Irish heritage 🤔). I'm not fussed by it, I have a skin as thick as a russet potato... but I do find it ... curious.

Greg Johanson

I think George is going to love Ds9 based on some thoughts on the third episode.

Imthecatman

Fun fact: Under the fish alien makeup of those 2 aliens (in the manhunt episode) is Fleetwood Mac.

MacGuffinStuff

Hey did anyone else notice Diedrich Bader on the Enterprise crew? I most remember him as the funniest character on the Drew Carey Show; and he was also Rex, the proud husband of Starla and creator of Rex Kwon Do, in Napoleon Dynamite; and he was the neighbor in Office Space, "Fuckin A".

James W.

I feel you and yeah with people steering away from ad driven television, its harder to fund programming big seasons. Well, to be fair, they can't afford to do that AND make sure all their rich execs/investors can afford that second or third super-yacht. :D I really dug the old HBO episode structure of doing 10-13, 1 hr eps, a season. Felt that was a great middle ground, especially for shows that trying for a more structured narrative. Enough time to become legitimately attached to characters so the events of the show have more impact. When I watch a show like Paradise or SIlo, I am happy for the shorter season so they don't milk it too hard. A recent winner for me, on almost every level but especially sizing, was Andor. I would have watched more but I am glad Tony decided to wrap it up. To be clear I think the 20+ sized seasons work fine for stuff like sitcoms, the filler is part of the fun, if you even want to call it filler. There are plenty of "filler" episodes from shows like Fringe, Star Trek, B5, etc that I would be very sad to lose but some are brutally inane on rewatch and you can almost tell they just need to fill their quota or the budget was thin so they have recapisode.

Vinnero

I watched TNG as it was released and many times since, I have never noticed all Berazoid have black eyes.

Maerandir Eldar

Yep. Came here to say precisely this. Most of Season 2 was either: - Unfilmed/unfinished TOS scripts (hence why you're seeing a lot of names in the writing credits that you did in TOS) - Scripts that were written to be used in the Star Trek: The Next Phase series which ended up morphing into Star Trek: TMP - Spec scripts from folks whom the production staff were confident would never join the Writer's Guild and look for additional compensation It's seriously a miracle TNG made it past S2, considering the insane number of difficulties and personal turmoil behind the scenes. If Paramount had not made a deal for three seasons right out of the gate, I doubt there would have been a third season at all. No way it would have happened today.

James W.

I also think there is a lot of waste and inefficiency in their production pipelines that hamper their ability to maintain velocity on higher production value shows.

FromDarknessComesLight

regarding the hegemony pronunciation in 218: there was a standing rule on set that whenever a new species, colony, or character name came up in the script; the first person to say it in the script would decide how to say it, then the rest of the cast would have to stick to that pronunciation. The most notable instance of this happening is in Encounter at Farpoint with Data's name - Patrick Steward was the first to say it and went with the pronunciation DAY-ta instead of DAH-ta (the latter being more common at the time for the word 'data').

Robert Cooper

"Whatever happened to that Klingon fatalism of yours?" No, that was Belarusian fatalism.

Jay Perry

Do you really think, firswt hand knowledge of the ancient world is not in demand?

John

I JUST now saw it... OMG!!!

John

Watching your faces was the best part of "Up the Long Ladder."

John

I find it hard to believe that of all the people on the Enterprise, they couldn't find 3 or 4 that would be willing to be cloned (and probably more) to help that culture.

Brandon

I'm late to this batch of episodes. When Simone messed up the timing on "space" in the intro of 'Up the Long Ladder', it was ironically in perfect sync for me. The episodes I'm watching have a slightly longer break before the opening theme and in between each commercial break. I didn't see anyone else mention that Star Trek V: The Final Frontier was released in between 'Up the Long Ladder' and 'Manhunt'. So basically, the "intended order" would have been to sandwich one of the lesser TOS Trek movies in between two of the worst episodes of season 2 of TNG. A full buffet of weird story choices. 🤣

Patrick

Lwaxana is great. I don't care what anyone says. I also love Picard expertly cockblocking himself.

Robert Cooper

"Galaxy" as a word is from the Germanization of the Latin "Via lacti", or "Milky Way". Because until the 1930s we didn't realize there was more than the one. It's really all about boobs.

Basilisk

So, fun fact - the actress that played K'Ehleyr (Suzie Plakson), you've already seen in a previous episode, but she was playing a Vulcan - the episode where that odd scientist died, but put his mind into Data.

Andi Herr

What blows my mind is that "Up The Long Ladder" was written by the same person as "The Measure of a Man".

Jobbe Smit

Still less cringe than the ghost sex episode.

Maxi

How much do ya wanna bet that Picard is just constantly thinking, "Fuck her" when Deanna's mother speaks and she is misinterpreting that as the other kind of fuck.

Maxi

Now I need to see Patrick Stewart as a sad clown quoting Shakespeare while making balloon animals or pulling out an endless hanky lmao

Maxi

I swear I recognized her, we're seeing just about as much of her real forehead now as we did then lmao

Paul

This is why reaction content is great, it can flair up in emotional outbursts but, it's in the act of reliving and in a sense sharing what we love with others. Sometimes, they don't like it too, or like it in different ways. That's okay. It's all part of the journey, Thall! And I hope your personal stuff is better now.

Mark

kahn

This Justin

In the Star Trek: The Next Generation episode “The Emissary,” K’Ehleyr was played by Suzie Plakson. Earlier in the same season, Plakson also played the Vulcan doctor Selar in “The Schizoid Man,” the episode in which Dr. Ira Graves transfers his consciousness into Data’s body. Another bit of trivia: Diana Muldaur, who played Dr. Katherine Pulaski during season 2 of The Next Generation, had previously appeared on Star Trek: The Original Series. She played Dr. Ann Mulhall in “Return to Tomorrow” and Dr. Miranda Jones in “Is There in Truth No Beauty?”

Elisa H.

*what a handsome race". Love that line from Worf

Elisa H.

So right now what IP would you insert yourself into on the holodeck? I think right now I'm feeling hanging out with the doctor and Donna on the tardis