Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Go to this site: Cinebingers.ca for the unedited versions of all our content.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/bp60VcouB6 👈 for the full reaction where you do not need your own copy.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/UcsF9heq51 👈for the full reaction where you need your own copy.

If you are on a phone/tablet, hold down the link above and press "open in browser", or go straight to Cinebingers.ca on your browser app.

movie runtime: 02:08:24

NOTE YT Edit may get replaced after you leave a comment as we're still battling copyright against warner brothers on this one

Files

Sherlock Holmes | Canadian First Time Watching | Movie Reaction | Movie Review | Movie Commentary

Full length/Unedited: https://www.patreon.com/Cinebinge https://www.instagram.com/cinebingechannel/ Merch: https://www.cinebinge.ca BlueSky: https://bsky.app/profile/cinebinge.bsky.social Simone & George are reacting to Sherlock Holmes for the first time! Canadians React! Subscribe | Like | Share | Comment Early Access & Full Reaction available on Patreon! #moviereaction #moviereview #sherlockholmes Instagram: @cinebingechannel

Comments

Mike FromOz

I've been hanging out for this ever since the poll from Monday of last week. Settling in to watch this and enjoy the hell out of it with you both. This mustn't register on an emotional level...

TomGas2025

Nice Thumbnail...👍

Krash Koi

Hope you guys check out the sequel.

Matthew Richson

I’ve seen people say as far as accurate to the books go, RDJ’s portrayal of Holmes is the closest.

Big Mac

Yessss I can't wait to see Sherlock Holmes fight a dinosaur

Andras Beck

I like these Sherlock movies :) Also wouldn't mind if they would do Sherlock series with Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman. I enjoyed Martin Freeman's performance in that one.

JakeyShakeyBakeyBoy

Having just built the LEGO Sherlock Holmes Book Nook for a work merchandising client campaign yesterday (a long story) this timed itself perfectly haha. Really enjoy the stylised Ritchie approach after not having watched this for a spell. If y’all are keen for the sequel there’s a consummate actor in a certain role that most certainly crushes it 🤭

Brandon

I just started watching, but I absolutely love that every reaction usually has one of the following two things happen: 1. Simone sees someone. "Hey, isn't that *insert name of actor that looks nothing like the person she's looking at* ? George: "....um what?" 2. George sees someone: "Hey! It's that awesome character actor we've seen in 10 different reactions!" Simone: "I have no idea what you're talking about..." Never ever change, guys. ❤

Rob Q

I know they don't do "reality" shows, but given George's love for Stephen Fry, it could be hilarious to watch them react to the Celebrity Traitors

Ashton Lewis

R.D.J's accent is pretty good, but not perfect. He certainly does a good job with it, but to someone who has grown up hearing this specific British accent spoken by native speakers, you can tell that it's not his natural accent. Off the top of my head, the best examples of Americans doing English accents would be Renee Zelwegger (Bridget Jones Diary), Sean Astin (LOTR) and Johnny Depp (Pirates franchise) - Although I'm sure there are even better ones that I am forgetting

Jeff K.

I’ve never thought about the Scooby Doo-ish nature of Sherlock stories but Simone, you’re definitely not wrong. There’s a solid amount of “Hey, there’s no ghost! It’s old man Carruthers, the guy who runs the haunted amusement park!” to the books for sure.

Richie.B.7692

I really do like these RDJ sherlock films... Hope you watch the sequel

Michael Haug

Victorian Era Andre the Giant haha. He actually used to be a wrestler. Krogan in the Oddities during the Attitude Era.

JBK405

To answer your diagnosis question, while it's obviously not official, the common consensus based on Holmes' overall personality and behavior is that he suffers from manic/depressive bipolar disorder. This is based on his alternating periods of depressive melancholy interspersed with fierce activity, his self-medication with drugs (Heroin and cocaine), etc. The constant reference to Holmes killing the dog is a double-reference to the original stories: #1 when Holmes and Watson first meet and negotiate being roommates, Watson mentions having a pet dog, but it is NEVER mentioned again. So people joke that Holmes killed it when they moved in together. #2 They do kill an actual dog at one point to test whether a substance is poison, and they use the dog because it was suffering and the owner had already asked for Watson to put it down. I like this movie, so don't take my remarks as a sign that I don't, but this is not an "accurate" adaptation of Sherlock Holmes. There's plenty of changes to the core elements of the character and his relationships with everybody else, even if they do include plenty of references to real parts of the stories. The part that bothers me the most -- and this isn't unique to this movie since EVERY adaptation changes this -- is that Irene Adler is NOT a love interest. They do not have a flirtation, they do not have a running rivalry; she appears in one story, wins, and then LEAVES. Her entire plotline is her trying to get away from all of the people after her -- of which Holmes is one hired hand -- and she makes good her escape with her husband who she marries during the course of the story (Holmes is actually a witness at their wedding in disguise). She outsmarts him without seducing him or using "feminine wiles", and I honestly find it quite indicative of overall sexism in our society that every single adaptation says "No, Holmes must be smarter than her, so obviously she used sex to overpower his reason". I saw it put perfectly by somebody else: "in Doyle’s version Holmes happens to get in Irene’s way, so she does the functional equivalent of trapping him under a cup, sliding a newspaper under him and dumping him out in the backyard."

Big Mac

Also there actually is a victorian era/sherlock holmes version of batman called "Gotham by Gaslight". The comic and recent animated movie are both pretty great.

Ashton Lewis

"Nutting" someone means headbutting them, in England, by the way haha - No idea why

Ørjan Watne

The sequel is definetly worth a watch!

Hamesque

In death, a member of Project Cinebinge has a name. His name was Mark Strong.

Jeff K.

“I don’t know which one of you I nutted since I don’t see so well at night anymore!” - Roy Kent in season 1, episode 3 of Lasso confirms your definition! Haha

Dmitriy A.

I really hope Sherlock wins in the next short TV series poll, it is such a great show.

Superpotroast

There is actually two different versions of this movie..Since the sequel does have Moriarty actually casted with a different person than who basically just offers a voice and a hand in this movie, there is the original actor's voice (the one you guys watched) and there's a version where the voice of Moriarty is the guy who played him in the sequel..(I find it weird with the sequel guy's voice because I saw this movie loads of times before the sequel came out and they retroactively made the change to this one..) (Not spoiling the actor's name on purpose for when they watch the sequel)

Ashton Lewis

I really like this film, but I think the sequel is even better. The show is actually even better than both so I hope you get round to watching that at some point

Rupert Purcat

Sequel please, then the 2010 TV series - all of them pretty please. George you will love the books, nice short stories. Thanks, cino's. Cheers

Nathan Jasper

The sequel's awesome and has one of my favorite actresses! I hope you check it out, it's worth it!

Mia Mccline

You guys HAVE to watch the next one. Guy kicks it up a notch, especially with the camera work. I think you'll love it.

Shaka, When the Walls Fell

Definitely need to do the next one. Professor Moriarty is a great villain, the acting is perfect, and the cinematography is chef's kiss.

GAB

VR = Victoria Regina, that is, Queen Victoria. I don't think it has any other significance than being a weird patriotic gesture.

Colin Reid

V.R. Victoria Regina. Latin for Queen Victoria.

cincassette

Another great film featuring Jude Law alongside Matt Damon and Gwyneth Paltrow is "The Talented Mr Ripley" (1999)

Baron Imhoof

She also plays Beth on Yellowstone.

Jordan Hume

The Sherlock TV series should DEFINITELY be on your list of series to watch soon! It's so good! Also, completely unrelated, but you guys really need to watch The Interview! A very funny comedy that you both would enjoy so much!

Elvenwitch

I do hope you eventually get to Enola Holmes; there are two movies out currently with a third in production, I believe.

rictus grin

V.R stands for Victoria Regina it's a a Latinate form of address for British Kings and Queens. these days you see a lot more ER II on things but as time goes on it will be replaced by CR III

Buhr

One small correction. Regina is for queen, Rex is for king.

Buhr

It is a cypher to show that an object is owned by the crown, or to show a person is working on their behalf. Bobby helmets, and their clubs would have it, as would weapons produced for the military during her time, and things like police phone boxes as well.

Brien

Recognized Kelly Reilly about 10 seconds before Simone. I win. Sorry Simone. 😁

Lintrinsic

The stereotypical image of Holmes in the deerstalker hat, overcoat and meerschaum pipe was from an illustration in the Hound of the Baskervilles IIRC. He's never actually described that way in the stories. He's also more physical and a man of action in the stories than most movie adaptations. He went bare-knuckle fighting, hung out at the docks and opium dens and dressed appropriately for the setting. Certainly not a deerstalker in town (London) There was a great British series in the 1980s & 1990's that was extremely popular. I highly recommend it. The more recent show Sherlock had a strong start too.

akaTheBAY-AY-RON

I want to say the movie Simone was trying to reference in the intro was The VelociPastor, and it's comedy GOLD!!! I'm also living in a world where I hope that's not the movie she was thinking of, and The VelociPastor exists alongside a completely different movie where the pope fights a dinosaur. I would watch that ASAFP

John

I hope you consider adding Sherlock to your short tv poll, as well as Luther Idris Elba playing a detective and The Good Place because its great. Kelly Reilly is fantastic in Flight with Denzel Washington

GAB

I meant significance to the story in the movie. Obviously, it has significance in the era.

rictus grin

a very enjoyable movie, but for me the best adaptation of Holmes was by Jeremy Brett in the 80's TV series The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes

Smooticus

You beat me to it

Smooticus

The outbuilding Holms falls through the roof of when he's chasing Irene is a coal shed. London at the time being heated and powered almost exclusively by coal, every building practically had one

m

I liked how you referenced the Batman similarities a couple of times but not (at least at that time) when a literal bat ended up rousing him from his fever dream never thought about it that much, but now I see it

m

Ah yes, Conclave (2024) Seriously though, more pope flicks? The Two Popes was another great one, and I guess The New Pope deserves a mention too, with Malkovich starring next to, you guessed it, Jude Law.

m

Not spoiling a thing, but just let it be known that a shorter set of scenes might put that movie into the top three of George's flicks, almost guaranteed what a great sequel

m

Also as for the "retreading past clues left": Doyles novels were, as far as I know, never really considered great mystery. Good adventure is more in the spirit of what it actually was, which obviously is good enough for any sort of franchise and, many would argue, the essence of good fiction, and even non-fiction; take the reader on a fun journey, and he'll forgive just about any sort of perceived literary sacrilege. Which makes this movie extra special, it's still a bunch of fiction tropes and hardly any of it makes sense, but we're shown way more cohesive of a picture as you'd expect from the written stories, which definitely are plenty handwaving and "then a miracle happened" type resolutions. Just the right amount of supernatural mystery in a comedy mystery that thinks of itself as above magic, and it works so well. Also a textbook example of a great movie with an even better sequel - for my money, personally, of course.

Sumner Hayes

For George, some prime Arthur Conan Doyle quotes: So he sat as I dropped off to sleep, and so he sat when a sudden ejaculation caused me to wake up, and I found the summer sun shining into the apartment. ----- “I want to see whether the objections are fatal, or if they may be explained away. But what in the name of the devil!” The ejaculation had been drawn from my companion by the fact that our door had been suddenly dashed open. ----- In the bedroom he made a rapid cast around and ended by throwing open the window, which appeared to give him some fresh cause for excitement, for he leaned out of it with loud ejaculations of interest and delight. ----- He must have fallen upon his back, for we could see the curved outline of his portly figure standing out above the surface as he struggled desperately to regain his feet. At last he managed to get erect, and came spluttering for the bank with such a mixture of godly ejaculations and of profane oaths that, even in our terror, we could not keep from laughter. ----- Our companion’s ejaculation was called forth by a noise as of a slight scuffle outside the door, with a smothered ‘Oh, sir!’ and ‘What will the maids think?’ ----- “Fancy!” ejaculated the young lady with the crochet needle. ----- While she was walking in this way down Swandam Lane, she suddenly heard an ejaculation or cry, and was struck cold to see her husband looking down at her.

China Andronicus

The second one is also a great film, and Moriarty is perfectly cast. Part three is in the works, though there’s still no release date. A lot of people got fed up with how physical Holmes was, but he can fight, and well, in the books. It was wonderfully written. Both RDJ and Jude Law have stated that Holmes and Watson don’t have a bromance, but a romance, and I’m here for it.

Alex Hyrule

A great portrayal of Sherlock Holmes I thought this movie did across the board. Hope we get to see the Benedict Cumberbatch T.V series soon.

Jasbro

Hope the 2nd one is on their radar as well, one of my favorite RDJ movies outside the MCU.

Drew Acheson

The show Elementary answers several of your questions about Sherlock Holmes including how he would be diagnosed today. It's definitely worth watching.

Ari Ramirez

D I S C O M B O B U L A T E

Mike W

I think RDJ is a pretty good Holmes. His english accent isn't bad, a bit like his welsh in Dr Doolittle it's good on short sentences but wavers a bit on longer. Being a brit of a certain age though Jeremy Brett will always be my Holmes.

AC10

Edit: OMG HER DOOR JUST OPENED BEHIND HER!!!!!!! Please let it have been a cat. That is a true horror. I was waiting for George to say Who's behind you in the door? Scarring the hell out of Simone... Ah man.... Opportunity lost I guess. Maybe next time. I freekin love these movies.

Gryff

DISCOMBOBULATE.

DasBigUn

Sherlock holmes series next...lol

Gabe

Others have mentioned it, but BBC's Sherlock would be a great option for a future drama series! The first two seasons are especially great

Matt Blanchette

Sorry the WB copyrighters are still givin' you grief! :-(

Denashi

The second movie is quite excellent as well and the actor playing Moriarty (not saying who it is, but yes, you do know him!) is SO damn good! *edit* Oh no! George got spoiled!

CommanderBrownCoat

When y'all are looking for a new tv show to watch, you might want to check out Elementary, a modern take on Sherlock with Lucy Liu as Jane Watson! And of course, there is the BBC Sherlock with Bilgo Baggins and Smaug! :D

Simone's Coconut Squire

The deerstalker was an invention of early Sherlock movies and doesn’t ever appear in the books. In fact, Sherlock would have NEVER worn that hat around London as that is basically a hunting hat and it would be considered extremely gauche to be seen wearing that in town. It would be like wearing hiking boots with a suit.

Drew

Anyone mention RDJ’s a Wing Chun practitioner (like Ip Man), and that’s the basis for Holmes’ fighting style?

Michael Kemmet

For Simone: Mark Strong is playing Trent Ikithon. You know, the nice guy that taught Caleb a few things.

Jeff K.

The rule of thumb with the Cumberbatch Sherlock is basically: 1 great episode, 1 decent episode, 1 meh episode in each season. And I love the show, to be clear. But it's also diminishing returns the further you get into the show.

James O'Sullivan

It's because "nut" is a British slang for the head. So called because the head is a round, hard object. It's why we'd called someone crazy/daft a "nutter", "nuts" or even a "nut job"

Jeff K.

Well, I hope Simone doesn't read these comments since George stopped himself short of revealing who played Moriarty in the sequel and Simone thanked him for doing so to avoid spoiling it.

Jeff K.

"It's like setting LOTR to death metal." Oh, so you're familiar with Christopher Lee's music career, then!

Farbod

Yes, please do BBC's Sherlock and also Guy Ritchie's King Arthur: Legend of the Sword

PG Modehouse

In the novels, Inspector Lestrade is at first quite a bit at odds with Holmes. They butt heads a lot. He's conventional with his conclusions as a detective, and doubts Holmes's methods, while on the other hand, Holmes doesn't have patience for it. But over the years, with each novel he appears in, they begin to slowly warm up to each other, Lestrade makes his way up the ladder at CID through bulldog tenacity, Holmes starts to consider him a friend whom he respects, and by his thirteenth and final appearance in the novels, he's one of the most trusted detectives employed at Scotland Yard.

John

I think a really nice place to stop is after the series 2 finale, that gives you 6 total episodes 12 hours of quality television.

John

I really enjoyed the first season

FranciscoGios

I want Justice for Gladstone; poor dog was stone almost every scene. I just found out the third installment for this series has been delayed multiple times.

Robert Cooper

Damn it. I thought this was going to be the Dinosaur one.

BoredLittleLady

Yes Simone, that actress is from Yellowstone. Although, I recognize her from Pride and Prejudice (2005).

SnabbKassa

the initials on British police helmets, crests etc. are the Royal Cypher, always with Latin for King or Queen. VR -- Victoria Regina (1837 – 1901) E II R -- Elizabeth II Regina (1952 – 2022) C III R -- Charles III Rex

Richard Z Herrera

I'm going to drop a crazy suggestion, after watching A Game of Shadows, but before the BBC series, watch the Enola Holmes movies. I really liked them, and Cavil does a decent job

Darren Harrison

Anyone who has been to London knows that Tower Bridge is nowhere near the Houses of Parliament, even George remarked on it. Also, the deerstalker cap was introduced in the Basil Rathbone films. There's no mention of it in the novels.

Jayson Phillips

Holmes was also a drug addict, they explore that in the Sherlock Holmes series with Ben Cumberbatch

Matthew Maxon

He crashed through the coal bin & not the outhouse

Marty McGee

The second one is also very good. I was a little worried in the beginning that you guys wouldn't like this one as George mentioned he didn't see Sherlock Holmes as an action story. Granted this had plenty of action, but I think it had enough mystery and crime solving elements to balance it out.

Tatiana Ferreira

Watch the second one. It's just as good or even better than this one. 👌🏻

Richard Church

Glad you both enjoyed this one! Definitely watch the second, its just as good. Sorry to George that the piece of trivia spoiled the actor for you! Now that you've been introduced to Sherlock Holmes, you should check out of the best Sherlock movies - Disney's The Great Mouse Detective!

Hercule Pyro

As others have said, really hope you watch the sequel, shame you got spoiled but it was already quite obvious Moriarty was being built up in this one.

Happy Hanukkah

"Rex is for king" Who's a good king? You are! Yes you are! :-P

Happy Hanukkah

If you want an authentic Sherlock Holmes that's true to the books, you need to watch Without a Clue (1988)! :-P

Happy Hanukkah

Eagerly anticipating the Guy Ritchie action version of Hercule Poirot. :-P

Happy Hanukkah

34:31-34:37 Hey, give me a break! I was just under a lot of stress! This has never happened before!

gfixler

The show "House" was a modern take on Sherlock Holmes, but in a medical setting. He spends every show noticing a bunch of things no one else could, being belligerently better than everyone else, while also having a drug addiction, and being a very good musician. His best buddy's name is Dr. Wilson, and his own name, House, is like homes/Holmes. It's also shown at one point on the show that his home address is 221 Baker Street, Apartment B, Princeton, New Jersey, on a shot of a letter from immigration, about his request for citizenship. His first ever patient on the show's last name is Adler. He also has a run-in with a Jack Moriarty in season 2. There are probably many other Easter eggs in there, too.

Seth's Coffee Cup Ambush

This one and the sequel are great fun. Probably one of my favorite movie soundtracks and I think RDJ was surprisingly good in the role. For anyone who wants lots of really good, book-accurate Sherlock Holmes content check out the Grenada TV series from the 80s. Jeremy Brett is brilliant as Holmes with a really intense take on the character and the series avoids a lot of the campy tropes that came from the earlier Basil Rathbone or Peter Cushing takes ("Elementary my dear Watson" and the deerstalker for example).

gfixler

Came to plug that show, too. I really enjoyed it.

Stefan Daniw

Please do the sequel. It’s even better than the first there’s even a famous slow motion sequence where Gavin Free from the famous YouTube Channel The Slow Mo Guys worked on.

Maniacalmouse

I wasn’t voting for Sherlock Holmes vs Dinosaurs, but now I kinda need to see that lol. More seriously, the series “Sherlock” is amazing and you should definitely check out Disney’s version of Sherlock Holmes in “The Great Mouse Detective” which features peak villainous acting by the always entertaining Vincent Price.

Tom Hess

Hi guys. I don't know how popular it would be, but I think you would enjoy Young Sherlock Holmes (1985). - Directed by Barry Levinson (Good Morning Vietnam / Rain Man). - Written by Chris Columbus (Harry Potter). - Produced by Spielberg. - Music by Bruce Broughton (Tombstone). - Special effects by ILM. I remember the film having an excellent atmosphere. Part Indiana Jones, part Goonies, part Harry Potter. Just an overall good film from the 80s.

Philipp Roensch

These are a fun run, Guy Ritchie really brings energy and brilliant ideas to make Holmes very entertaining. I would say, the whole myth vs science thing has always been a cool undertone for Holmes stories, and this one nails it. The trivia fact about this taking place while Holmes pretends to be dead is also accounted for, you have seen he hides his face from the press and stays inside for months. It makes even more sense with the next movie. I bet as fans of good Sir Ian McKellen, you would also appreciate Mr. Holmes from 2015, shows a wholly different side of the character.

Maniacalmouse

I used to watch that one a lot when I was a kid, though it freaked me out a bit lol. Definitely worth a watch.

schnoobs

The BBC Sherlock with Benedict Cumberbatch is a really good modern take on Sherlock Holmes, also one of the best shows out there in general . Hope it shows up in a poll soon

Logan Kerlee

I didn't particularly enjoy this movie. There were parts though that were VERY cool and fun. My favorite bit was the end scene, actually. You both must watch the show Sherlock! Holy crap - it's excellent. Now that you've begun this, I only feel it's natural to continue onto that. I'm very glad that there seems to be support here in getting you both to watch that. :) Batman is 100% Sherlock Holmes. Well, he's more Watson+Holmes because he;s solo during his nights. One could argue that Alfred is his Watson but I have trouble saying that because he's never out in the field with Batman.

Bill Campbell

In the BOOKS there was no relationship between Irene and Sherlock, she was a small character who found out Sherlock was looking for her, so she fled. End of Story

MasterElodin

I really hope you get around to do the show at some point. It's so so good :)

Metalhead Reacts

The VR on the police hat stands for Victoria Royal. Just like how it has been ER for the past several decades for Elizabeth Royal. The Irene Adler thing is a reference to an actual Holmes Story "Scandal in Bohemia" where Irene managed to get the best of him, the photograph he lays flat in this film is actually from that story, it was the one thing he requested to keep from to case. When Irene mentions that her name is never mentioned in any of the stories or case notes is also a callback, since Holmes only ever refers to her as "The woman".

Mark Ryan Cabico

Oooo since you have watched this movie,have you seen the show Psych. It is Sherlock Holmes adjacent and one of my favorite shows.

Tom Dabrowski Music

I noticed something about the audio mix that might help improve the reactions. When Simone gets loud or screams, the volume spikes quite a lot. When watching the version without needing a copy of the movie, I had to turn the volume down several times. Maybe you could add a compressor (and optionally a limiter) to her microphone track. A compressor would even out the dynamics so the loud parts aren’t way louder than the normal talking volume. It would make the reactions more comfortable to watch without changing her energy. Just a suggestion because I really enjoy your reactions. :)

Kaushik Sethunath

Simone!! You're thinking of 'Velocipastor', I think? A raptor vs a pastor hahaha! The poster is iconic!

ExtraBigAssTaco

"What of the warts?... Are they EXTENSIVE!?"

Angela D. Mitchell

I thought this was fun, but for me the coincidences needed for the villain to succeed are too silly, and it tries a little too hard to physicalize Holmes. Although there are some great details -- like the cocaine, the violin, and yes, Holmes boxes in the books and uses disguises. I also like that both men are young, since the books/stories start when they are in their early 20s and I get so tired of them portrayed as old. I hope you'll react to the sequel, which for me is better, and Moriarty is superbly (and -- refreshingly -- quietly!) played by one of the best actors working today. I do get distracted by some of the modern tech thrown in, and by (on a shallow note) the incredibly heavy almost goth modern makeup on Irene (why??). I also think while Robert Downey does his usual charismatic turn (sometimes I do wish he'd turn it down a notch), the best performance for me in the film is Jude Law's quiet, humorous, steadfast Watson. I always feel that Law is a character actor at heart, and he really seems like he enjoyed playing this role. (Colin Farrell was originally in talks to play Holmes, and I would have loved to have seen his version.) Meanwhile, to echo others, George, I'd argue that Batman is not really a great detective but a great crime fighter who uses his gadgets and wealth to gather information, versus his own brilliance (although he's by no means stupid). Holmes isn't a gadgets guy in the books at all, and his relationship with Irene is much tamer, although I do enjoy his admiration for her. Selena/Batman is definitely unique to their story in terms of origin (if anything, this borrows from that). Also, if you want to watch a unique modern take on Sherlock Holmes that is absolutely wonderful, y'all should check out ZERO EFFECT, which is a little gem from the 90s and one of my favorite sleepers to recommend to people who missed it. Wonderful Jake Kasdan movie with Bill Pullman, Ben Stiller, and Kim Dickens. Last but not least, I really hope you don't react to the "Sherlock" TV series. It has little to do with the literary characters at all, it's smug and misogynistic (and its "Irene" is just awful), and the stories get progressively worse and worse. The two main actors Cumberbatch and Freeman are fantastic but even they couldn't save the show at a certain point.

Angela D. Mitchell

But she is the one woman Holmes respects and admires above all others, referring to her as "the" woman, so it's no wonder that many saw a romantic element there. Irene is also referenced afterward as well.

Angela D. Mitchell

I can't stand the BBC series -- it's so over the top and has so little to do with the actual characters. Great actors, awful stories, and so smug and misogynistic. I started out finding it mildly fun and ended up hating and completely abandoning it by the time the "fanfic" episode rolled around.

Matthew Blackwood

Zero Effect rules! Like a non-sci fi Dirk Gently, love it.

MeetMountain

Velocipastor is amazing. A real work of art. But one I like even more is Clownado.