Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Go to this site: Cinebingers.ca for the unedited versions of all our content.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/vhEXaUq5o0 👈 for the full reaction where you do not need your own copy.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/Fom3TqRBY9 👈for the full reaction where you need your own copy.

If you are on a phone/tablet, hold down the link above and press "open in browser", or go straight to Cinebingers.ca on your browser app.

Captain's Holiday, Tin Man

Files

Comments

Mastervodo

The next month is going to be banger after banger until the Finale! Tin Man is one of my personal top 10. It's like TNG's Moya, with teeth.

Mike FromOz

Today sucked, so I am here with a bowl of thawing prawns, ready to watch what I hope is going to be some great episodes of TNG with you! Cheers!

Joel

Vash, baby :D

dudewheresmycar

Not sure what your watch cadence is, but can I request you not watch the end of Season 3 episode and the start of Season 4 episode right after each other on the same day? You need at least several days between both episodes to at least experience it like viewers did back in the day.

Mike FromOz

Quickly jumping back in - There is such a thing as a Sci-Fi/Fantasy Romance, it's a movie called "Krull" and I love it so very much, I don't care what anyone says! 😁

Stephen Morris

Two of the weaker episodes of this season imo.

Be Human

Natural Born Killers Lucky Number Sleven The Royal Tenenbaums Layer Cake

Michael

Why do you keep referring to the Star Trek episode shore leave as the Alice in wonderland episode when only ONE SCENE was Alice

dudewheresmycar

Krull features some of James Horner's best work so don't be afraid to love it! Also, Krull has a coincidental Star Trek connection. Because of time constrains in-between scoring both Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan and Star Trek III: The Search for Spock, Horner reused many of his musical themes from Wrath of Khan in Krull. You can hear it most in his Quest For The Glaive and Ride of the Fire mares themes. Also the the lead actor in Krull later had a recurring role in DS9 appearing in at least 9 episodes.

blerbaberpaterb

i mean thats how short hand references work.. you reference the thing that stood out the most. like do you expect them to describe the whole damn plot every time they talk about Shore Leave? "that episode of the office with the pot of chilli" "that futurama episode with the dog outside the pizza place". you pick the most notable thing. you dont pick a different part of the episode each time you bring it up, thats an insane way to have a conversation. hell, that episode was so mediocre Alice in Wonderland might be the only thing they remember from it.

Lintrinsic

And yet you knew exactly which episode they meant....

Thall

George on fire today with the puns! Love it! 🔥

Michael

I know because he always refers to shore leave as Alice in wonderland episode

fforw

Sci-Fi/Fantasy Romance could be "Outlander" with the time traveling nurse and her Scottish hunk. There's certainly Fantasy, it might be sci-fi, but there is also sciency stuff, so...

blerbaberpaterb

What an insane thing to complains about.

Thall

I don't know about deeper lore, but I know we do meet a lawyer klingon and a few scientist and priest klingons throughout the Star Trek shows. IIRC Deep Space 9 has the lawyer. Edit: Ah about the "meters and what do they call themselves", I think the idea is that the universal translator translates different units and names and stuff, so the listener knows whats going on. MNight just be my headcanon though, i would certainly want a magic translation device to do it

Robert Gendron

Not going to say why, but this reaction demands a reaction to the movie "UHF"

Mastervodo

Space Sci-Fi Romance! Like Simone wants!

Mike W

Because I sit at a desk all day for work I need to be doing things if I'm away. History is my passion, I've explored places like Athens, Rome, Rhodes and Istanbul

Robert Cooper

Just as a thing: not a lot of Vulcans on TNG, but they come back in later shows. Enterprise is arguably about the Vulcans. Also, "Best of Both Worlds"... Coming into the sweet spot of the show.

Lintrinsic

The books are canon, and they also aren't. What appears on movies or shows is Alpha canon, licensed media like books, comics, games etc is Beta canon. Beta canon is messy, often superceded by Alpha canon, and conflicts with itself (TBF so does Alpha to some extent in places). Alpha canon is recorded on the fan site https://memory-alpha.fandom.com (and there's probably spoilers) https://memory-beta.fandom.com for licensed media.

dlpheonix

Someone make george watch Babylon 5 if he hasnt seen that show already for living ships. If its the same for simone definitely make that a series you react too.

Mike FromOz

Timestamp 40:42 [Birds calling] *Simone's cat enters the room* I love coincidences like this 😁

dlpheonix

TThe tin man episode imo shows just how powerful romulan ships are. They spend less than 3 seconds strafing the enterprise with no real intent to destroy it and nearly collapse the shields completely.

Mike FromOz

You can definitely hear it in the soundtrack. It enthralled me as a kid. The movie didn't do well at the box office, as people found it too weird to have both fantasy and sci-fi in the same film together. I think its delightful and I don't put too much thought into the where's and why's, I just enjoy it for what it is. And I especially love the way the disparate characters join together, and it is less about individual action, and more about collective effort. Its definitely influenced by "The Lord of the Rings" in that way, especially for the fantasy elements. It's one of my favourite childhood movies and I can put it on anytime today and still enjoy the hell out of it.

Greg Johanson

I perked up at the d29 mention. It’s my favorite trek media and I hope you guys go through it. Based on some conversation I think George will like it a lot as some of his earlier concerns with tng are changed on d29. Also it is one of those shows that gets better as it goes along season 1 has some incredible highs and the lows are not very low.

hackbyte

About universes with more non-human aliens..... I can't and won't spoiler anything.. But at times, you should take a look at Farscape. ;) Srsly. ;)

R. Chang

Oh, shit. Until Simone reacted to it, I had no idea that Tam Elbrun was also The Mayor.

GAB

Living ships in Farscape and LEXX as well.

Scott CineRam

It took me a moment to recognize the kid in this episode, but then I remembered that he was in RoboCop 2. He also played Mel Gibson's son in an excellent drama called Tequila Sunrise. Sorry Simone...not Paul Walker. Simone might recognize this line: Was it sudden? "No...and yes. It's always sudden."

Data Cable

B5 also features pharmaceutical methods to inhibit telepathic abilities... though in a far less therapeutic usage than George is suggesting here.

Jon

For Star Trek books, they're all "canon" but they don't always line up. They're not like the Star Wars Legends that all followed one specific timeline with everything in it's place. The Star Trek Left Hand of Destiny is one of my favorite duologies, has to do with Worf and the Klingons almost exclusively. Also, Star Trek: Klingon is a great book too.

Ian Tellam

I hope you do Best of Both Worlds Parts 1 and 2 together. They're better watched as one movie-length episode in my opinion.

CT

Sci-Fi romances: Starman (1984) The Shape of Water (2017) Avatar and its sequels The Matrix sequels

Theo Bracco

I've been saying that they should alternate DS9 and Babylon 5 seasons to compare. Also, Farscape whenever. Probably after Voy, to be release accurate.

Data Cable

Trek telepaths do transmit thoughts as well as read them. Lwaxana holds telepathic conversations with Deanna, even though the latter is only a half-Human empath. The genetically-engineered "child" in "Unnatural Selection" telepathically spoke to Pulaski. Though in this case, it may have been Gomtuu's ability to read Tam's thoughts at a great distance more than Tam sending them. Re: R-rated Trek, the more recent streaming series, not being subject to broadcast standards and practices, do drop the occasional F-bomb. Lower Decks isn't one of them. While it does contain swearing (at times, outrageously gratuitous,) all of it is very deliberately bleeped.

Mastervodo

Claudia Black and Ben Browder have excellent chemistry. Good frell.

Mastervodo

And speaking of R-Rated Sci-Fi.... Lexx definitely qualifies.

Spacedone

I think that George would enjoy Babylon 5 a lot. It does a lot of the things he's wished that TNG did more of like having storylines and events that have continuing impacts on future episodes. It also goes into some darker territory than Star Trek... I live in hope but it's almost as big a commitment to their time as watching Star Trek is so I doubt it'd happen any time soon.

PIG

lol I can go either way on this one and be happy :)

pippi l

Yes! Love Farscape

PIG

It's painful. Fucking painful.

Spacedone

I kinda want them to watch it just so I can see them losing their minds when they spot who is in the cast. Also, from a decade of cheap fantasy movies that were mostly bad, Krull is one of the highlights even if it's not perfect.

JFC

I've always thought "Captain's Holiday" is the point where the TNG Enterprise crew shows that they've become more close-knit than friends and are starting to become a family - the casual joking and familiarity with each other, understanding better how to get "dad" to take a vacation, and Riker's prank with the horgon. You see flashes of it throughout season 3, but episode 3x19 is the turning point where it's the new standard, and from this point forward the Enterprise D crew is a family.

Mike FromOz

"Is that?!?!?! ********** looks so young!" I am not expecting them to know who plays all of them, but there were some damn fine actors in the film. I think a lot of its poor performance might be due to it's name. I can see people going to the cinema saying "What the hell is a Krull?". It's not as catchy as Star Wars/Trek. But also hard to describe for a movie title. Naming it after the two romantic characters wouldn't help much either. Space Fantasy? Ehhh...

Jomero

If you believed the chemistry between Picard and Vash felt real, you would be right. Stewart, who met Hetrick in this episode, had an affair with her and it was the impetus for his divorce. Still, a good episode. And one that introduced the One True Sex Planet in the series.

Mike FromOz

Best Multi-Class Klingon: Warrior-Pet Groomer

Ian Tellam

lol, well I first watched it as a re-run in the late 90s so I only had to wait 1 day. I’m also looking at it from the perspective of a Cinebinge viewer and I’d rather see the whole reaction to both the episodes at once than waiting a week myself.

dudewheresmycar

Hard disagree. A time jump is needed so they have to wait just as we all did when they were broadcast.

Stephen Morris

It broke up a real life marriage. Patrick Stewart left his wife for the actress who played Vash.

Danny Bryant

I agree that for the best of both worlds part 1 and 2 there should be a gap in watching these 2 episodes. Please do not watch back to back. The experience of the cliff hanger is CURCIAL

Danny Bryant

For George: Warrior Therapist / Psychologist Gynecologist / OBGYN Dentist Pre k teacher Nurse Waste Management Technician Building Maintenance Actuary

David N

To me the first psychic bio ships were the tyranids and I can't say which came first but tin man bears a striking resemblance to the narvhal from 40k. I do know that the tyranids were the basis for the zerg though and the other starcraft races have direct warhammer counterparts as well.

Ian Tellam

Think he probably clicked on the wrong episode to comment. I’ve done that a bunch of times.

Holy Squire

The coquette thing is a bit overdone in 319.

Scott CineRam

People dying in TV series is occasionally sudden.

Scott CineRam

The kid who lost his mother during the away mission. The actor's name is Gabriel Damon. Sorry, left this comment on the wrong post as I am playing catch-up.

Scott CineRam

You're right, I forgot to comment on the relevant post instead of this one. Playing catch-up right now.

James W.

Klingon Warrior/Sanitation worker would 100% be that warrior in a garden mentality. Doing endless battle against the accumulation of detritus. War for cleanliness and hygienic standards. But if the homeworl dwas attacked he would be the most skilled at and knowledgeable defender using all of their knowledge to out flank and out think the aggressor.

R_Van_S

Oh, just the mention of Best of Both Worlds sent a shiver down my spine. I absolutely can't wait.

Will Sofer

“Star Trek: Enterprise” could have easily been subtitled “Star Trek: Humans and Vulcans”.

s0rd3z

I am also about halfway through Oathbringer as of this posting.

ImpishMisconception

Captain's Holiday is not one of my favourite episodes, but I put it on in the background when I do any cleaning. I don’t think Jennifer Hetrick is a good actress at all; I find her acting unappealing. I just find her acting to be very one-dimensional; there just isn’t any substance, at least in my opinion. Tin Man, I like this episode better; it’s in my top ten favourite episodes. I really love the idea of the alien ship that’s alive. I think that is very cool. However, I think Tin Man looks like a poop, am I the only one who thinks this? I have often wondered about Betazoids and how they would handle hearing and sensing others’ thoughts and emotions. It does seem, though, that Deanna can turn off her empathic abilities; maybe it’s because she is half human. Like in the first episode, when Deanna sensed pain from the being on the planet, she was able to disconnect herself from it, and I recall something about Picard asking her what she sensed about the other alien, and she said she didn’t want to open herself up to it. So, it would seem that Betazoids can turn off their empathic abilities, or maybe it’s simply because Deanna is half human; I really don’t know. Does anyone have any theories on this? It is a shame that Vulcans aren’t around a lot on TNG, though I do admit a bias, as I absolutely love the Vulcans. The Vulcans are my favourite alien species in Star Trek (though I haven’t seen the other Star Trek shows beyond TNG, I plan on watching the other Star Trek shows along with Simone and George as they watch them). What are everyone else's favourite alien species so far? I am curious to know. Simone and George, what are your favourite alien species so far? As for George’s question about what is my ideal vacation is, I am going with the Vulcans on this and say that for me to rest is to do exactly that: rest. I sit and meditate, not joking, to me it makes sense to do nothing and rest when I need rest. I agree with Spock when he said that it doesn’t make sense for humans to give themselves activities when they seek rest. I am not knocking anyone’s activities, do what you want for a vacation, I just don’t understand why do activities when one needs rest. Also, I love George’s puns. I love a good pun, and the jokes were great. I often make puns myself, which are for some reason called, dad jokes, which I don’t know why that is. I often make dad jokes even though I’m not a dad, I guess that makes me a faux-pa…

Polecat21

Good job George. You came close to breaking the rules about respecting others opinions when Simone said she likes Emily in Paris but you held back just enough.....

PIG

I still remember that day when I was 12. It was in a foreign country and the only good thing ever week was TNG booted off a British network. I jumped out of the couch and yelled nooooooo! My parents laughing at my obvious dismay.

Glenner7

This story (319) is a bit like The Maltese Falcon.

Tinfoilnation

Don't worry George - there are episodes ahead (and for the life of me I can't remember what season) where we actually get to meet some Klingon scientists. Oh and Tin Man is always a good watch - it's a bit predictable and the Romulans are wholly one-dimensional but the sentimentality gets me in the feels every time.

Matt Blanchette

"The Maltese Falcon", incidentally, is now in the public domain! (I refer to the novel, here.)

Stephen Morris

After a rewatch, I think my mind has changed… these are actually good episodes.

dasgrove

George really needs to see Farscape.

p0sthum4n

George, you seek...jamaharon?

Liquor & Swords

Just in case you forgot, you still have DS9, Voyager and Enterprise. Right? You have yet to watch those. Right? Yes. OK, just checking! :)

MacGuffinStuff

I really liked both episodes, Captain's Holiday was a lot of fun, reminded me of "Romancing the Stone" that's a fun movie btw. But Tin Man was really good, really loved the writing. Reminded me of Star Trek 4, but a lone whale, that looked like a seed, to me it looked like a really huge seed or pit lol. And it reminded me of a few other movies but especially one, 80s kids know it, and I don't think this is a spoiler, just spoils the poster maybe, "Flight of the Navigator", kind of similar, loved that movie when I was a kid, but it's been so long I don't remember how it even ended. Also couldn't help it when early in Tin Man, just his outfit and learning more about where the episode was going, I said it on accident but made me chuckle: Peter Pan in pleated pants had a plan to meet Tin Man, now say it three times fast.

Skyruff Creative

George and his fascination with non-human aliens ... hum hum hum .... but yet Star Trek like .... he reallly needs to see "The Orville" (2017).

TheGrimOne

The I.K.S. Gorkon novels take place on a Klingon ship. There are other Klingon based novels as well.

p0sthum4n

George, your point about other cultures in Trek calling themselves and their home the same thing that outsiders call them is something that comes up a lot. There's one example where a thousand-year-dead civilization called their world the same thing the Federation calls it in the present, even though the Federation was entirely unaware of their civilization prior to the episode. Always bugged me.

Angzarr

I don't see any reason to assume that "Betazed" is an externally-imposed name. I assumed it's a Betazoid word meaning "dirt" or "the land" or "the planet" or something, or at least derives from such a word. Or perhaps the other way around, and "Betaz" is a root word that means "the people" or similar, and Betazed is "the place of the people". "Betazoid" does feel like an anglicization though.

Angzarr

"TODAY IS A GOOD DAY TO DIE... statistically speaking" -- a Klingon actuary

Angzarr

They also need to watch Farscape before Stargate SG-1.... for reasons.

Angzarr

Lexx is fever dream "WTF is this and who in their right mind let them make it" bonkers, in the kind of way where I can't decide if it's great or awful. Maybe trending more toward the latter over time. I'd be up for reactions though. Each season is also like a completely different unrelated show, except not, and each ups the insanity ante.

Angzarr

I wonder how Tam would feel being around Pakleds. It's probably like being forced to watch a video on 0.25x.

Angzarr

Nobody mentioned the Ferengi vacationwear in this one. I think the costume department did a great job at answering the question "what is the Ferengi equivalent of a Hawaiian shirt and board shorts"

parker469a

So George wants to watch Farscape is what I get from this video?

parker469a

For those wondering "a lot" in this case means well over 800 official novels.

parker469a

Can we get a show like "Control"? That game's world is a lot of fun.

MacGuffinStuff

Klingon warrior/retail sales associate at a big box hardware store. Klingons I assume occasionally have to repair a hole they punched in a wall, maybe you need a new electrified enclosure, or even a targie door, for your TARG, obviously, you come to the hardware store where a grizzly Klingon Army vet like me explains wire gauges and amps, and how spackle isn't enough dude, you're gonna need a piece of drywall for that, cut precisely, and we gotta color match it if you want it to look right. Sorry I get goofy on Star Trek Day because it's the best, and Simone, we thank you for your service. No but that's a legitimate gripe, she can't watch her stories because we're slow. No but seriously I'm like Simone, I saw some of DS9, I don't remember specifics but I do remember I was intrigued, very; so I am hoping you guys go full in. 🤘

Drew Acheson

I'm sure someone has said this already but George if you like the idea of a biological ship you guys should watch Farscape. After Star Trek obviously.

MacGuffinStuff

Klingon warrior/influencer, that has to the be the WORST, right? Just a really annoying Klingon that intentionally bumps into people and hides behind his really huge security guy, and he has a podcast.

The Real Andrew Kim

Warrior Wedding Planner or Warrior TV reacts youtuber :P

Simon Pegged Me

My ideal vacation varies. It depends entirely on what part of me has been damaged the most by my life and needs repair. If I feel alienated from my friends and their love, then my favorite spot is a beach house on a sparsely populated island where I can reconnect with them over board games, puzzles, body surfing, home-cooked meals, and fruit juices, tonics, and anything that makes cheap rum taste good. If I'm feeling ground down, I need to travel to a foreign city with great museums, great restaurants, and great places to read and rest. If I just need to kill some vacation time to get HR off my back, I just go to a setting from one of my favorite novels and reread it from there. It always makes me love the novel more. Admittedly, I choose those options because I can't get to Risa, and don't own a Horga'hn (which I'm guessing is Risan for "butt plug"). It's been years since I've had a friend as comically horny as Riker. Back then, I could pour my heart out to this guy over a few beers, tell him everything that was troubling me, and his response was always the same: "Dude, you just need to get laid." So I sympathize with Picard when his ideas of a good time are pooh-poohed by Riker in favor of more venereal suggestions. I've always thought of the Klingon's warrior culture the way I think of the US Marine Corp and its Rifleman's Creed—every marine is a rifleman, meaning regardless of what your role in the Marines is, you are a rifleman first. As a Klingon, I imagine that for the first 18 years or so of your life, you are trained to be a warrior, in martial arts, hand-to-hand, small weapons, and basic military tactics. Then, after you've proved yourself proficient enough to defend the Empire and your family's honor, you can move on to be a Klingon florist, dermatologist, or poet. (Hey, that love poetry they're reading when they're not hurling chairs at each other ain't gonna' write itself.) The most lethal of the lot will naturally go on to join the Klingon military, but everyone can fight and will accept a challenge if their honor is challenged. Simone, you mock the warrior librarian?! What did Giles ever do to hurt you?

dc

Both were better episodes than I originally remember them being, particularly Tin Man. I remember Tin Man as being a boring episode when I was a kid, but I think I was just a little too young to appreciate what it had to say. While I wouldn't pick it as one of my all-time favorite TNG episodes, it's a really good representation of a Star Trek story.

Tangerra

You know George is into something when he doesn’t speak or blink.

Stephen Morris

The older books are not canon. They have a specific controversial ending. The newer books however are canon, but they mostly focus on Discover, Strange New Worlds and Picard.

Gizmo_Mogwai_

Think they'd like Battlestar Galactica. Hope they check out one day.

Cory Garron

Hehe, I saw a rerun of this episode when Buffy was still on, so I've known for a long while. I was waiting for Simone to recognize him, and it didn't take long.

Brian Moore

I got a good laugh seeing where Simone’s eyes were going while Picard was in those shorts. 🤣 I heard those shorts actually went for a lot of money in an auction several years ago.

p0sthum4n

I specifically do not think George would be happy with BSG.

Carlisle Richards

When I was young, I always had dreams of creating a Klingon TV show and what it would be like. But I always believed it'd be too niche. But, after watching sometimes brutal shows like Game of Thrones, it could work today. But to answer some of your Klingon questions think of it like this: - Klingon Librarian = Klingon historian. Someone has to tell the tales of all the Klingon battles and successes. This is needed to pass on history and maintain the warrior spirit. This is an honorable endeavor. - Klingon doctor = Klingon healer. Someone has to take on the noble practice of healing wounds and repairing warriors. - Klingon janitor = This would be prob be considered work that isn't honorable imo. Something for disgraced families, maybe? I don't know if Klingons have other societal systems like indentured slavery, etc. - Klingon engineer/repaiman = the honorable man of fixing or making weapons. Like a blacksmith. - Klingon programmer = Again, this could be a noble position as technology is needed for ships, defenses, weaponry, etc. Ultimately, look at Klingons as the military looks at these positions. I'm sure some programmers aren't treated well by "real" warriors just like would happen in the army.

Joe Concepts

Lower Decks does have a little swearing, while Discovery and even Picard are not above dropping an occasional F-bomb.

Joe Stacey

Don't look at episode lists! Also, wishing the romulans would be destroyed by the borg... That's horrible.

Weirdo

These were the first two episodes of TNG I ever watched, catching it in syndication as a teenager. I still have a lot of love for both of them, as they made me fall in love with both Picard and Data. Tam from Tin Man is one of my favorite minor Star Trek characters, I always found him fascinating and it's a great performance.

John

Re: the pronunciation of "Vash" Well... it varies. Sometimes they say it so it rhymes with "posh," and sometimes they say it so it rhymes with "cash." It's even inconsistent with the same actor (Patrick Stewart says it both ways).

John Miller

Sci Fi, Fantasy, Romance movies usually fall into the B-movie category.

Sven Ketelhut

Nearly all Star Trek novels are non-canon. There are a view that are considerd kind-of-canon like the novilization of the movies or some episodes as they are based of the script an basicly directors-cuts of those. But in gerenal: only what is shown on a TV or Movie-screen is canon, no novels, no technical manual, no RPG sourcebooks (there are a bunch and I think the current by Modiphius is the best), no computer games and so on. If you want to know more about Klingon culture, go on watching TNG, DS9 and Voyager, it's a very interesting culture and one of the two non-human cultures that get the deepest dive in (the other on is the Ferengi culture)

Gwydify

possibly, but it may be too weird for them both to watch all the seasons.

Nabikon

Not as weird as Lexx, which I like more tbh

Elisa H.

Have they already seen doctor who ?