Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi folks, we feel that this on-going issue now warrants something more official from us.

We're pretty sure some of you have noticed these kinds of comments occasionally popping up either here in our community or elsewhere in other bigger social media sites. Comments and posts where a user claims to be unjustly blocked, most of the time accusing us of doing so, among other more out there theories.

Here's the thing, while we get an email for every comment made across our platform, we very seldom go in and manually remove anyone. We're sure most of you whos been here long enough have seen our occasional replies of "Please keep things civil, lets end this now and just walk away." etc, etc. And 90% of the time, the conflict resolves there and then. Only a handful of times in the entire history of the channel had we have to directly remove someone, and again, those of you whos been here long enough will likely remember the exact incidents.

With that being said, Patreon DOES have its own automated systems which we have chosen to keep active. One aspect of this automated system is that it marks a blocked users payment methods, so that it lets us know when a previously blocked user (by us or by the platform) tries to come back in with a fresh account pretending to be someone else. As you can see in the following screenshots, it allows the user to post comments just incase the user was falsely flagged in the first place, giving them a chance to reach out to us. But it does mark them as "blocked".

As you can see from the screenshots, it also tells us when that user joined Patreon, and in this instance, both users who are pretending to talk to eachother, were both created at the same time. Additionally, when a new user joins we also get an email letting us know. Which you can see below shows both users joined on the same day, about an hour apart.

One additional thing. When a user chooses to delete their own comment which contains replies, it will appear as "This comment has been removed". If a user has been manually blocked by us, the entire comment chain will disappear instead, including all replies.

Now, normally we would just report and then remove these spammers, even refunding them. But we feel that perhaps its better for us to be transparent about this and just show you guys what we actually see, and what kind of information we get so that in the future we're all on the same page together.

Of course, this particular instance we've highlighted has been reported to Patreon as usual and will be dealt with accordingly, and we'll keep the comments up while they investigate.

Since the creation of this post, the blocked user has created a 3rd account to join back in to keep arguing as some of you saw. This third account was manually banned, and as a result the entire conversation chain they started disappears, rather than just the initial comment. Their email and user name has been forwarded to Patreon staff as well.

Files

Comments

Jef Etters

Oh my God, what a bunch of nonsense you have to deal with.

Armchair Rizzard

I trust you guys. You have demonstrated yourselves to be the most reasonable and transparent Patreon account I’ve ever followed. And I follow several of the Patreon film reaction crowd. It’s the reason I’ve been a long-term fan of yours for a few years now.

Robert Cooper

I dunno. Maybe showing what you see isn't the best plan. Just makes it easier for the next time someone wants to try to game the system.

Dave van der Kuyp

Well. In the timeless words of the great Saitama: “Here’s a guy with free time.”

Carlos H

How do these people have the time and energy for this nonsense?.

Dazzler & Em

how do these people have the time for this. Definetlu sorry that you have to put up with this hassle. Must make you think if it is worth it sometimes. thanks for the transparancy, its appreciated.

Insane Rabbit Daddy

The vibe I get from your subscribers' posts here on Patreon and from watching your videos tells me that you are not unreasonable people, and that you wouldn't just block somebody for no reason. It doesn't even make sense. Why would you block someone for no reason when they're giving you money? No, I'm pretty sure there's a reason if you block someone.

blerbaberpaterb

im.. not a mod.. wouldnt mod accounts be labelled...? lol. like comments from S&G are labelled as "author"

Dustin Duvall

that's what a fed would say. lol jk

Dustin Duvall

This is kinda sad, hope life gets easier for that person

Psyclopath

We do have some passionate animu fans.

Cinebinge

We kind of treat this like a real physical store. Any and all customers are welcomed as long as they dont bother others, if they do we kindly ask them to stop. And only if that customer becomes extremely problematic then we do excise the right of a private business, which is to no longer serve that customer. But that's genuinely happened maybe a handful of times.

Thall

Interesting to know! I always wonder what systems creators have to handle their channels and traffic. Thanks :)

Todd

I love you guys. You seem to care so much. It’s always really heartening.

Collinson

Damn some people need to find a hobby. Well done for being open about this.

Farbod

Some people really have too much free time on their hands...

Dioskur

The short, thick first digit of my hand, set lower and apart from the other four and opposable to them, raises towards the sky.

TheLeftPecOfTheLord

It’s like when people on twitter get caught using their alt accounts to gas themselves up Guy - “I love/hate (insert thing here)” Guy incognito - “I love/hate that thing too suspiciously handsome stranger” And they both turn out to be Elon musk

Senec

I just... Why do they think you wouldnt be able to see that information? And what was their endgame on this? This seems like a weird thing to make a second account over.

Will Sofer

Unfortunately, they haven’t seen anything yet. While most anime fans are nice, ‘normal people’ (whatever that means), there is definitely a lunatic fringe that’s pretty unique to the genre. Hyper-obsessed “otaku” are definitely a thing.

Jimmy Olofsson

Most of the people here seem very chill and friendly thankfully and there's only been the occasional rude person who loses it over the movie selection or decides to spoil something out of spite (i guess?) but from what I've seen those have usually been dealt with smoothly. Haven't encountered anything where I thought someone was punished out of the blue.

Life in the cave of Garanoga

You two do great work and are more than fair. Some people are just miserable and don't think they are ever at fault. It's near impossible to moderate a channel with as many fans and supporters as you have. Keep up the good work.

Justus Brazelton

Holy cow, I just choked on my morning tea reading your username. lol

Matt Dellarosa

(Me thinking everything is about me...I'm sorry, I didn't mean anything by it. Please dont block me. I really need you to like me!!!) Lol, in all seriousness yall are awesome. Love the channel. Sorry you have to deal with that kind of stuff but I guess it comes with the channel. No explanation was necessary from my standpoint, i dont even pay attention to that kind of stuff. Like you said, I just come here to watch movie reactions and have fun. I hope you both have an amazing day.

BigM

I remember when I joined another reactors channel mainly to watch one reaction, only to realize it was in watch along format. I commented either in the reactions post or in their chat wondering if they had considered doing the full reaction since some reactors were doing that atm. The next day I was blocked, 2 days into my subscription, no refund. Let's just say I don't ever watch those guys anymore not even on YouTube.

Jason R Carpenter

I am flabbergasted at the lengths some people can go when they are angry enough.

Jason Pratt

Dang, then my off again on again subscriptions must be annoying! Sorry about that.

Potsi

Wild

guyincognito

To the esteemed Peck, I do not even know you. Why would you attack me so and compare me to that x loving entire box of tools?

ren

I've noticed a lot of entitlement coming from patreon users lately, idk if it's just that state of the world at the moment but regardless I'm sorry that it's gotten so bad that people will pay to create a false narrative where they're a victim. I'm certain that parasocial hate/love/obsession is a symptom of some kind of deeper psychological issue and while I'd like to give those people compassion, when they take things this far I think more online creators should have the right to ban IP addresses/bank accounts/etc to the extent that a site like reddit does when they permaban users. I know it's a potential loss of money but these people are usually very unwell and need that push that hopefully leads them to wake up and get help. but also some people are just malignant assholes who love online anonymity and believe it gives them permission to act a fool and throw tantrums that they never would irl. I say ban them too lol

Laura Dawson

Wow, that sounds exhausting!

Brady Renfro

Reminds me of the people who try to evade twitch bans. Sorry you both have to go through this and people cant just act like adults T_T

Jay Perry

Thanks. I had no idea about this.

Bambi

Thank you for sharing this with us. Its very nice to see things like that from your perspective and to see whats going on on the other side. Very cool of you to do so and not just being quiet about it and deal with it. <3

Steve Mercier

I feel like I want to complain about something...like...like I DON'T HAVE ANYTHING TO COMPLAIN ABOUT!!! WHAT THE ACTUAL %&$!!!?? WHOSE IDEA WAS IT TO PROVIDE ME WITH ABSOLUTELY NOTHING TO COMPLAIN ABOUT!!?? I'M VERY %&#ING ANGRY ABOUT THAT!!! I...I...oh...I feel better now. I think a bubble popped in my skull.

fargoboyle .

I don't usually bother with comments so know nothing of what's gone on. Its no surprise its not all sweetness and light, any discussion, forum, social media platform is the same. Reminds me of what Stephen Fry said about Twitter, likening it to a swimming hole or beautiful river that over time becomes more and more polluted with turds, broken glass, rusty shopping carts and the like. I've no answer because for every person that says the sky is blue, there's someone else that will tell you its green. Maybe zero tolerance is the only way.

Logan Nelson

The dead internet theory makes more and more sense everyday...

Milosz Skowronski

Lol it must be incredibly funny watching those spammers think they have executed some masterful astroturfing campaign to get back at you by creating smurf accounts while you're just sitting there looking at all this info plain as day and shaking your head in disbelief :D

Scott CineRam

I'm very glad that you have access to this kind of information.

Tamalan

Glad to see your transparency on this. I had a post blocked once and no idea why. It’s good to understand the process.

Gryff

Time was we used to talk folks like this out behind a shed and beat them with a hose till they learned their lesson. Now you've got your damned unions!

Forsythe

Hate to see a fellow "Jon" behaving badly. Thanks for the transparency on this issue, Simone & George!

Ari Ramirez

Must be the crazed shipper who was posting Stranger Things spoilers if I had to guess

FranciscoGios

The first red flag I see from this person is that instead of talking to George or Simone in a civilized manner about the matter from their two recent New Accounts; he/she comes with "No! I'm still Mad! Now Hear me Out!! YOU are wrong & I'm Still RIGHT!!" type of behaving manner.

Tall Paul

I think George is wrong

Tall Paul

No, I think George is right!

Tall Paul

You are wrong I hate you!

Tall Paul

I hate you more!

Tall Paul

/alt account logon script

Jay Johnson

I don't plan to ever have multiple accounts just to have conversations with myself in the comments. But if I do, my usernames will be Gollum and Smeagol.

Aye Jaye

Well, they might not be a Jon since they also have an account named Chris, their main account that got banned might have been a different name

Faidra Galaxy

Wow...I mean, I'm not that shocked it's happened, but the fact they went as far as to try evading the ban by pretending to be a different person is just sad and pathetic. Sorry you've had to deal with this.

Jon Nelson

Making Jon’s look bad

p0sthum4n

Damn they spent $23 to shitpost with themselves

Shibby

Thanks for the transparency. I appreciate everything you guys do to make a welcoming community it can't be easy. I hope the person making these accounts gets the help they need.

Matt Blanchette

That's way more work than someone ought to do online just for them to make three accounts on one Patreon channel talking to themselves.

Chris Foster

Will I get in trouble if I create an account for my dog? ;)

Maniacalmouse

Thanks for the peek behind the curtain! One of the many reasons I became a patron is because you seem like genuinely good and levelheaded people. This is aimed at my fellow patrons as well. It’s a really cool community you have here and I am happy to be part of it. Keep up the great work! The trolls can go be unhappy somewhere else lol.

Marylou inProgress

Wild. Sorry you guys are having to deal with this nonsense.

Happy Hanukkah

>>> When a user chooses to delete their own comment which contains replies, it will appear as "This comment has been removed". If a user has been manually blocked by us, the entire comment chain will disappear instead, including all replies. <<< "If a user has been manually blocked..." Am I correct in my understanding that the same happens if you remove an individual comment?

dys

It just doesn't make sense to me how toxic the comments can get here when George and Simone seem like the nicest people. I enjoy their reactions because they're actual adults who have intelligent takes on the things they watch.

gfixler

Ha! I was reading it on my phone, and I'm old, and my eyes aren't what they once were, but I thought "it can't be THAT guy still being a nuisance," and then I zoomed in and saw the name. Oh, Jon. He's a lost soul. I remember him just thrashing in every direction in here, getting a couple of warnings, and then getting banned. Then I randomly saw a post by him on Reddit, railing against what happened, making it all Cinebinge's fault. I can't believe he's still going. That was quite a while ago.

Logan Kerlee

I'd of LAUGHED so hard if the alternate you was instead named Short Paul! xD

Thomas Larsen

> Since the creation of this post, the blocked user has created a 3rd account to join back in to keep arguing I feel a bit bad for him, idk why he would do something like that but what ever the reason is it cant be a pleasant one.

DonkyDave

For those who keep asking for a CineBinge Discord, this is EXACTLY why we don't have one. Massive amounts of drama and moderation nightmare, it's just not worth it.

Ginger_Legacy07

It's sad to see people taking such efforts to keep arguing and all. But I am glad that you guys are transparent about it. I really enjoy your reactions and opinions and it's alright when someone might disagree with you, as long as they are respectful about it.

Scoobay

Fister Miyagi is a great username

Logan Kerlee

hahahaha, wow. Reading your post here made me smile big! Thank you for that! :)

WalrusWallace

Haha okay that was good thanks for that!

Katie I

Love to see the receipts from George and Simone! Thank you for informing us what’s happening, the process and what it looks like from your end. It’s helpful as Patreons but also for any of us considering starting a creator account at some point. That guy really needs to get a life, creating multiple accounts just to talk to himself like he has “backup” 🤦🏼‍♀️

Katie I

Understandable. Just a shame because this is probably the ONE community I’d like to engage with properly via something like Discord. The a-holes ruin it for everyone 🤦🏼‍♀️

Katie I

It’s so common though. It’s the same way across all social media. People create multiples just so they can have “backup” in an argument. It’s just sad

HanBrolo

I just don’t understand what the point even is? Are they just attention hungry? Willing to pay multiple subscriptions to create drama? Doesn’t seem worth it but I guess I don’t share the same mindset as this clown. Love your videos keep up the great work!