Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Go to this site: Cinebingers.ca for the unedited versions of all our content.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/Ga6pmnuT77 👈 for the full reaction where you do not need your own copy.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/5bij2z2cn0 👈for the full reaction where you need your own copy.

If you are on a phone/tablet, hold down the link above and press "open in browser", or go straight to Cinebingers.ca on your browser app.

sarek, a menage troi

Files

Comments

dc

Howdy George, I’m not able to play the no-sync copy—the play button just doesn’t do anything. The sync-your-own version works fine.

TomGas2025

Damn...video can't be found? That hurts...problems again? 😅

TheLeftPecOfTheLord

The No-Sync copy is stuck on the play button, watch along is all good

John_rd

Same. Not working. Poor George always has problems.

Cinebinge

should be fixed now, sry bout that.

Cinebinge

should be fixed now, sry bout that.

Cinebinge

should be fixed now, sry bout that.

Cinebinge

should be fixed now, sry bout that.

Cinebinge

should be fixed now, sry bout that.

Cinebinge

should be fixed now, sry bout that.

Rhinehold

We love you George, just let us know when it is fixed. Don't feel rushed, excited to watch but can definitely wait patiently. :)

Cinebinge

should be fixed now, sry bout that.

Cinebinge

should be fixed now, sry bout that.

TomGas2025

Sh** happens...right?

Rhinehold

Thank you, no worries! You guys rock.

Michael Bauer

George saying he misses the TOS cast made me smile. 😊❤️ They're great, aren't they?

Data Cable

The title of "I Am Not Spock" has been misconstrued as Nimoy wishing to distance himself from the character. I haven't read it, but as I recall him once explaining in an interview, that was also the title of a chapter, in which he explained that the character was not his sole creation, but a collaboration between Spock's creator (Roddenberry), the numerous writers, the makeup artists, wardrobe, etc. Perhaps the phrase "I, alone, am not Spock" would be more descriptive.

Fedora The Explorar

Thankfully Patrick Stewart gets a lot more to do as an actor Season 3 onwards. They saw that they were wasting him in the early seasons.

Joe Concepts

Good thing George isn't watching Simone's face when he makes certain comments... I hope she doesn't play poker.

Fedora The Explorar

Also does anyone here also kind of hate Wesley Crusher and the subplot in Menage a Troi? Literally all about how his little nepo baby is getting handed opportunities he doesnt deserve to screw other other ensigns who deserve it more.

Guts

I forgot it is Star Trek day 😲

Mike W

A love the Sarek episode, some great acting and such a sad story for Sarek. Looking forward to Star Trek 6. One of my favourites, didn't think it was this early though I was expecting it to be months yet.

Joe Concepts

Yeah, I'm not sure why ST6 would come soon. In release order, it came out in the middle of Season 5. EDIT: They must be talking about ST5!

Joe Concepts

It's also buried in a weird episode.

Joel

Yes, Simone, it is Neelix

Joe Concepts

I forgot how well directed that concert scene is. It's all told without one bit of dialogue.

Guts

As a certified WebMD: There is the possibility of reactive hypoglycemia due to insulin resistance (which one could call pre-pre-diabetes). Simple carbs spike blood sugar -> pancreas overeacts as cells do not listen to current insulin levels and too much glucose is still floating around in your blood -> sharp blood sugar drop leads to the symptoms.

dc

Star Trek VI premiered between S5E9 and S5E10, so we've got a few months before it's time to watch it. DS9 begins during Season 6 of TNG. If Simone & George go in true airdate order, they'll have to interleave TNG and DS9 episodes (which I actually think would be wonderful, since there are plotlines that weave through both series, but I totally get if it would be too much of a hassle) This website shows the broadcast order: https://startreklist.blogspot.com/2011/04/list-of-all-star-trek-episodes-sorted_05.html

Mastervodo

Shall I compare thee to a summer's day? No, a summer's day is not a .... Betazoid.

PIG

I don’t even remember which ones these are and I’m giving it a heart. So glad to have these once a week from Du Binge.

Jasbro

Only 1 week to go till the best season ending episode ever!

WayneC

They've already done ST5.

Mike W

Yeah, the new one is Starfleet Academy. Seen the first 2 episodes and quite like it. It seems to be quite controversial though

Michael Bauer

Stewart's performance here is one of my absolute favorites - and I totally get that George was focused on how much more he got to chew the scene here than usual. Might be worth a re-watch after a while for a second viewing to let yourself be immersed in the emotion of the story. The older I get (and the more loved ones I've seen grow old and die), the harder this episode hits. Seeing a person that was so quiet, put together and integral to their community be consumed in such a way, and portrayed so well ... man, what a ride. I do think Shatner's acting is somewhat under-appreciated - he's really good in "Judgement at Nuremberg", Spock's funeral at the end of Star Trek II, or some of the quieter moments between the trio in the series and movies. (I still think Stewart is the better actor overall, though)

Mike Jenson

Are you formular with Starship Simulator? It's as close to Star Trek as you can get. There is a demo available and a few days a week you can watch it's development

Mike W

Yeah, I actually really liked that reaction. Seeing it through their eyes made me appreciate it more than I did when I first saw it.

s0rd3z

I concur, the way the schedule is I am hoping maybe they can finnagle a three episode Trek day, that might cover the overlap. Which would only be for a month or so. Lot harder to accommodate now though with the anime schedule included. So they might have to do one of each and just mix n match depending on airing order. Edit: Thinking about it combining them in one vid might not logistically work if they want DS9 to exist as it's own playlist without having to cut and edit them on here after the fact.

Matrim

That Ferengi is, in fact, played by Ethan Phillips. So, yes, it is Neelix.

Alec Zrike

Episodes like Menage a Troi remind me just how much more interesting the Ferengi got in DS9.

REDR58

I don’t like the character at this stage because I find it absolutely absurd that they have a literal *child* running any aspect of ship operations.

REDR58

Oh, I almost wish you two hadn’t discussed the “Sarek” episode title at the start!

Gryff

I second this course of actions. It is logical, and wise.

Stephen Morris

I’m hoping the thumbnails on paramount plus don’t spoil anything.

Thall

in my headcanon, the Ferengy we meet in TNG are spacetravelling, like... nomad Ferengi. There are different Ferengi, but not all of them are total idiots. I think its a function of TNG not knowing what to do with them. DS9 does a way better job

Gryff

Sarek: Picard sends Data to back Sakkath (assistant helping contain emotions) into a corner with logic. Vulcans *cannot* lie. They can ignore you as much as possible, not answer, ask a question in retort or find some other way to logically avoid answering you, but once you pin them down with straight forward questioning and typically the needs of the many versus the needs of the few, or the individual they will fold.

R. Chang

The whole reason Wesley was put in the show initially was to appeal to young nerds and give them a character to identify with. That's why in those early episodes he's always saving the day and singled out as super special. But what the creators didn't anticipate was that, while young fans *did* identify with Wesley, they didn't *want* to. They didn't want to be reminded that they were an annoying know-it-all nerd. They wanted to escape the real world and imagine that they were Riker or Picard or Geordi. But as long as Wesley was on screen it was hard not to think of themselves as Wesley. Young fans didn't like Wes because of the things they didn't like about themselves. As an adult, I can appreciate his character. As a kid, I just couldn't get past that. Wesley's worst episodes are behind him. At this point in the show, I think the writers understand how the fans felt about the character and do a better job with him. If you like him now, I think that will likely continue.

ChiefKC

Star Trek 6 indirectly ties into TNG with episode S5 9 & 10, hence one of the reasons it should be seen at that time. Although I also do like the fact that after next weeks finale, they should take a short break before season 4, just so he gets to experience some of the same wait we all had to endure after it aired.

R. Chang

As far as why some people think you should not watch the Season 4 premier right after the end of season 3 is that it's just kind of a fun way to sort of simulate the original viewing experience of having to sit with a cliffhanger all summer.

Steven Linden

They say it's a Mozart concert, and they clearly show only a quartet playing, but the music during the scene where Sarek cries is a Brahms string sextet. Hope somebody got fired for that blunder!

R_Van_S

"I'm really excited to finish this season"... oh, me too

Jomero

I like that that they got Mark Lenard to reprise his role as Sarek. He did great, and he unfortunately passed away just 4 years later. I'm excited for you guys to get to the next and final TOS movie too. Personally, I think it's the best of the TOS movies. Yes, I personally like it more than Wrath of Khan. Either way, I am sure you two will enjoy it too.

bullettbot

Simone has earned one true star trek fan credit back for the Neelix catch

Dan

I love the nerdy point of comedy that Picard ordered warp 9 for returning Lwaxanna, but only warp 8 for the last emergency to retrieve Data from a dangerous kidnapper haha

blerbaberpaterb

notice how you (probably unintentionally) dismisses the 'younger' generations opinions as "offended, silly bit, not serious", but give yourself the benefit of getting to hate characters. like for them, its generational and they just dont get it, but for you, its legit and reasonable.

blerbaberpaterb

bro you really dont need to spam this in every post... they get 1 email for every comment. they 100% have already seen it and is added to their catalogue.

Pearl Jam

I love how they brought back the same actor that played Sarek in TOS, TAS and the Movies! He was also the Romulan Commander in TOS S01E14 ‘Balance of Terror’ episode and one of the Klingon Captains in The Motion Picture. Poor Wesley. He probably gets so much flack because his character is a prodigy and everything seems to come so easily for him, particularly with all the help and opportunities he’s given onboard the flagship of the Federation. When viewers see this, while having to seemingly work so much harder than this character and not getting similar results and/or recognition, it may be causing resentment against the character… just my thoughts though, I can’t speak to others actual reasons for disliking the character.

Robert Gendron

Yeah, but she lost one for not spotting Rom in Captain's Holiday

Mike W

Thanks for this. Never heard of it before but it looks good.

David N

Patrick Stewart could lift a building with his acting muscle.

Dan

@REDR58 It should be noted that 8 year olds in TNG are also taking advanced calculus classes, which is more than most adults have accomplished in the last 2,000 years. I used to be bored with his character when I was a kid, but it's easier to take it with a grain of salt when I see the other details they place in the show about what humans of their time are called to do.

Robert Gendron

That's Kale! At the time, the largest purchaser of Kale was Pizza Hut. They didn't serve it, just used it to line their salad bars. It was not a food most people watching the episode would recognize.

bullettbot

oh she is still in the negative, plus I think Simone has admitted that DS9 is a weak spot

R. Chang

Oh, now I'm curious. Can I get a hint as to what ep it is?

REDR58

Younger generation… children should be seen and not heard! (Kidding!) (Mostly…)

REDR58

I suppose, but I’m also looking at this from the aspect of what’s a “realistic” portrayal of what is essentially a naval vessel and its highly-trailed crew and I seriously doubt a child under 18 would be allowed to do anything that Wesley does, no matter how precocious he or she is. At this point, he has not even attended the academy.

Superpotroast

Should we try to find appropriately aged commercials for them to watch as well..

Superpotroast

He was way too much a Gary Stu in the first seasons..I do think he gets a much better written character as the series continues, especially after his promotion in this episode..

REDR58

Sarek: It may not be immediately obvious but Sarek’s chief of staff, Ki Mendrossen (played by William Denis) is a human, not Vulcan. Interesting how we never see the Legaran people. I’m so glad they didn’t show us what they look like and some things remain mysterious. The fluid tank hints at what they may be like and I’m just glad it wasn’t some sort of silly hybrid fish-race that walks around like the Antedians in season 2. The illness Sarek suffers from really hits home for me and I suppose for anyone who has seen a relative endure a debilitating condition like Alzheimer’s. Top tier work from Leonard and Stewart.

Superpotroast

Stewart is one of the older actors who did Shakespearean plays, like Ian McKellen..(Also that's why they're so good together in the X-Men movies).. So while, Stewart is a very classically trained and seasoned actor, Shatner just kinda does his own thing, especially for Kirk..But he is a good actor as well..They are just on different levels.. Perhaps this last episode makes this song appropriately timely: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bl5TUw7sUBs

p0sthum4n

I'm having an annoying damn day and I'm in a bad mood, so let me tell you that the few moments of internal decompression I felt when I realized it was Star Trek day were very welcome.

Matt O'Keefe

George, I figure The Ferengi maybe paid somebody somehow at some point for space flight and warp tech.

Will Sofer

It’s only controversial amongst a hyper-online segment of right-wingers, most of whom have literally never even seen Star Trek. If creepy ghouls like Elon Musk, Stephen Miller, and “catturd” are leading the charge, it’s almost certainly just manufactured and performative outrage.

R. Chang

How about a Blockbuster ad and the "This is your brain on drugs" PSA?

Katrine Myra

Yeah, I had zero memory of the TNG Ferrengi (having possibly supressed them), and going from DS9 to this was... jarring, to say the least.

Katrine Myra

Sarek is such a great episode (and character). I'm so annoyed and frustrated when people - even Trek itself, sometimes - try to frame it like Vulcans are cold and emotionless, and need to "learn" how to feel, when this episode so, so clearly shows that the problem is they feel _too much_. Yes, certainly, there is an interesting conversation to be had on where to draw the line and what you lose and gain by such strict mental control, but IMO Trek so rarely has that conversation. Instead, we get "I can teach you how to love, cold space person" angles. On Lwaxana, I find I like her more now that I'm closer to her age than Deanna's. Make of that what you will! Regardless, I agree that one of the best things about this episode is that we get to see the competent, selfless and strong side of her for the first time. It takes, uh, lobes to do what she did...!

akaTheBAY-AY-RON

Hearing Picard say the whole "it's better to have loved and lost" thing WITHOUT it being set to music doesn't seem right to me XD

REDR58

They should frankly have to wait as long as we did back in the day to get the full experience!

Cally

Deanna says that she's heard similar stories to Beverly's from ten different people in the last couple of days. All those people queueing up to slap poor Wesley.

ChiefKC

There are some later TNG episodes and a DS9 episode featuring Lwaxana Troi the really expand upon her character.

ImpishMisconception

Sarek I have commented this before in the Star Trek Original Series, and I will comment it again, Sarek is a VILF, Vulcan I’d Like To Fuck. This is one of my top favourite Star Trek TNG episodes. I love that Sarek made an appearance on this show, and I’m so glad it was Mark Leonard portraying him again. Such great acting from both Mark Leonard and Sir Patrick Stewart in this episode. It is heartbreaking, though, to see Sarek struggle with what I understand is basically Vulcan dementia. Cool to see a mind meld though, I love watching mind meld scenes. I find the bar fight scene funny. I don’t know what it is, as I know it’s an all-out bar brawl, but somehow it looks silly to me. When Picard and Riker are walking to the transporter room, I noticed the little detail of them mentioning the admission of Corridon, which was a debated thing in The Original Series. I love that this little detail was mentioned. … Menage A Troi This is just silly, and I actually don’t mind it. I enjoy the occasional silly episode. I love Lawaxana’s outfits, so flashy and very pretty. I have a love-hate thing for Lawaxana. have a hate-love thing for Lawaxanna. First, what I love... I love her outfits; those huge dresses are just amazing. Some of her lines I do find funny, like in season two, Manhunt, Lawaxana looks at the delegates that look like fish (I forget what they are called) and she says, "I still say they look better in sauce." She has other lines in the series that I love, but I think mentioning them would spoil the episodes, so I won’t mention the lines or episodes, but yeah, I think she has so very funny lines. Now for I hate... I can't stand her sexual innuendos towards Picard when he is clearly uncomfortable. Makes me uncomfortable watching it. During scenes where Lawaxana is making a sexual innuendo comment towards Picard, I always wonder, "If Lawaxana were a male and if Picard were a female, would this be seen as okay?" Imagine if a guy made that many sexual innuendos towards a woman who was as uncomfortable with it as Picard clearly was. I don't think it would be received very well. Another thing I don't like is that Lawaxana seems to be very inexperienced with technology; there seems to be a running joke that Lawaxana and technology don't get along well. I think this is stupid, as in the time of TNG, all the technology we see is supposed to have been around a very long time, so it's assumed that everyone is at least familiar with it, unlike Lawaxana. I think this supposed joke just makes her look stupid, and I got bored with this very quickly. Lawaxanna really was a terrible mother, always demeaning Deanna, even after the episode Menage A Troi, where Troi finally tells off her mother and says to stop demeaning her and address her as an adult. Lawaxana doesn't seem to learn this lesson, as she keeps demeaning Deanna after this episode. I hope commenting that doesn’t spoil much. … As for the Wesley Crusher hate, I don’t hate the character myself, but I do find him just a tad annoying. For one, because he is a know-it-all, just seems to know everything. I know there are young adults out there with high IQ’s, but even they don’t know everything. With the whole crew of the Enterprise, it seems that Wesley seems to be the only one who can figure things out. Such as with the Menage A Troi episode, the only one able to pick up the popping sounds. I think it makes the rest of the crew look stupid, just my opinion. Also, two, Wesley is a goody two-shoes. Gets along all too well with his mother. What adolescent gets along that well with their parents/guardians? Even the most well-behaved adolescents rebel against their parents/guardians; I don’t care how smart they are, it’s a natural thing. It just doesn’t seem natural for Wesley to get along with his mother so well and not rebel. He never breaks the rules or anything like that; it’s not natural. Adolescents break the rules; it’s part of growing up. So, those are the reasons I find him a tad annoying, but I don’t hate him.

Jomero

My personal theory for all the Wesley hate: A lot of fans would like to believe that if they, somehow, were to magically appear in the Star Trek universe that they would act like Riker. But the reality is that they would more likely act like Wesley. And the truth mirror doth sting. Wesley never bothered me. There's only two characters I actively groan and dislike, one is Lwaxana. The other is one you haven't seen yet. Neither of them are the actors' fault.

James W.

I get why people hate him in season 1/2, he is a bit annoying and he isn't given much to do but the people who are sincerely in the "Shut Up Wesley!" camp and not just memeing, are asshats. If we're lucky, we are Boimler from the Lower Decks, probably never a Wesley. Unless you saw Star Trek as a kid and then became a scientist-soldier-poet-astronaut, in real life, then maybe you would be "better" than Wesley but most of us and less capable than Mr. Crusher. Haters just jealous. I feel like most of the crew of a s Federation star ship are pretty dope. Wesley included. He has a lot of growth throughout the show and after like season 2 he typically has a good utility in the story of the episodes he is included in.

REDR58

Ménage à Troi Ceremonial rhythms… the Ferengi is right, it is noise! It always makes me laugh when they try to invent future music on sci-fi shows. It almost always sounds bland. Typically, in TNG, we only hear classical music and sometimes jazz. I think Majel Barrett does an excellent job in this episode. I love the little gesture she makes towards DaiMon Tog at the end. It’s so nice to see more on-location shooting (in this case for Betazed) as opposed to the usual sets. That dress Troi is wearing seems a bit ill-fitting. It keeps falling down on the side! Frank Corsentino who played DaiMon Tog did a nice job. He played the Ferengi “Bok” in the first season episode “The Battle” when he used the device to attack Picard’s mind in revenge for the death of his son during the Battle of Maxia in which Picard destroyed a Ferengi ship. I didn’t mind the Ferengi stuff at but this episode does suffer in comparison to “Sarek.” I enjoy it enough for what it is, a bit of a lark. It was worth it to see Picard go all out at the end with his love poetry.

Marcus Hicks

Vulcan emotions were so strong-pre Surak-that they almost wiped themselves out with full-scale war.

Marcus Hicks

Its referred to in Deep Space Nine.

Matt O'Keefe

I wonder if they looked like Antedians or maybe were more amphibian.

Michael

Leonard Nimoy wrote his autobiography “I am not Spock” published in 1975 people assumed he hated Spock but it was literally I am not Spock I’m Leonard Nimoy a Russian Jew born in New York and his struggles 20 years later he wrote I Am Spock , that covered his Star Trek career and directing ST3 and ST4 ,the year before he died he recorded the audio book version of I Am Spock . On a side note you should check Leonard Nimoy singing The Ballad of Bilbo Baggins ,you can find it on YouTube

Michael Kemmet

As fantastic as Stewart's performance is in this episode(Sarek), I think most fans would agree that we're going to see even better to come. It's an absolute pleasure when the writers give him some real steak to work with.

DanTurismo

You should 100% watch the season finale in one go.

Angzarr

A classic! I knew what it was going to be before I even clicked the link.

Kevin Knadle

Yes. I hope they wait to watch Star Trek 6.

Angzarr

Nobody has mentioned the fact that this child is also dating an adult Ensign? Who, as an officer, has presumably attended the academy, making her probably around 22...

Angzarr

As someone who has is dealing with parents with dementia, the scene of Picard confronting Sarek about it really hits close to home. I've been there. On a happier note, is it just me or is William Denis (Ki Mendrossen) a dead ringer for Bruce McGill?

Kevin Knadle

I'm excited for the movie too but I wish they would wait until after the season 5 episodes it was released after in 1991.

Lex Kuzma

Seeing George wishing he could see more opportunities for Stewart to flex is chops, all I can say is I've got some good news for you.

Holy Squire

Patrick Stewart and the full panoply of his Shakespearean training.

TechJJ

Nah... If we had to wait entire summer, George can wait a week!

djKENTO

Hey George, The reason we're saying to wait between seasons is just to build tension. You're gonna wanna jump right into the next episode to see what's gonna happen next, but we had to wait MONTHS So to get a small sample of that tension that WE all felt watching it for the first time, we're suggesting just spacing it out. Give you a bit of that authentic syndicated week to week experience. That's another thing I'm not sure you know... This show had NO HOME NETWORK. This show was fully syndicated. That means stations paid out of budget to license the show. Say you're an NBC, ABC or CBS affiliate and you bought Star Trek TNG to show on your station's airewaves. Your evening programming is already set. You've gotta show what the network planned from 8pm to like 1am. So Star Trek aired at like 6-7pm on MOST of the stations it was syndicated to. This also meant no network control or censorship. They just made the show they wanted to make.

Darth Fatass

At least Wesley never swallowed his combadge!

MacGuffinStuff

When you guys did the "TNG" sound during the intro I flicked my almost empty Stanley cup and it made a little "ting" sound that I found way too funny, and then it was that thing where I was laughing at myself for being so easily entertained 🤣 reminded me of yesterday, I was on break sitting in my car and I know Tesla trucks have been around a while but for some reason one pulled up near me and I started laughing, they look so stupid, it's literally a car shape I designed with crayons when I was 5 and that thought, and how expensive they are, I was crying laughing for at least 20 minutes and then again when I was telling my coworker and they started laughing too, and the lady thought she looked cool and then she came back out and couldn't find it and I'm like "how do you not see it? It's the ugliest thing in the entire lot! It looks like it's made out of Legos," and I started laughing again. I was just like, "WHYYYY???" Seriously hadn't laughed that hard in a while, holy shit, literally couldn't breathe, I guess I just really needed to laugh or something. I gotta stop thinking about it, already starting to laugh again.

Jonathan

Is there a reason you are watching Star Trek 6 so much earlier than release order?

E G

George is really overestimating how much people like loxanna. She's somewhere between ok and slightly annoying and I don't think any of her episodes are really standout greats.

MacGuffinStuff

Not offended George said Shatner isn't as good of an actor as Stewart, one is a 1960's American TV actor, the other is a Shakespearean trained English stage actor, literally trained by William Shakespearean.

Nick Marten

Really enjoying your guys watch through. Very surprised you’re going to watch Star Trek VI so soon. It was released in theaters between episodes 9 and 10 of season 5. You’re watching it nearly a season and a half early. Even if you’re only going to watch movies between seasons (instead of actual release order), it would be better to watch it between seasons 4 and 5, not 3 and 4. No worries if you’re just excited to watch it now though, it’s not a big deal. Please tell me you’re not going to watch all of TNG before starting DS9. TNG seasons 6 and 7 and DS9 seasons 1 and 2 overlapped and are best watched in actual release order. Someone’s already done the work of ordering the episodes: https://startreklist.blogspot.com/2011/04/list-of-all-star-trek-episodes-sorted_05.html?m=1

MacGuffinStuff

I did not care for that Menage A Trois, was not was I was expecting lol, no I'm kidding but seriously, didn't like it until the very end, but I did like it for several reasons, one was I realized Betazoid women are Latina coded. They made the joke, see I'm Chicano, most of the women I've dated have been Latina, just works out that way geographically etc, but when you date a Latina you need to be prepared to fight someone for her, it somehow just always happens, to defend her honor or whatever, or in the case of my big ex, she would start shit and I'd have to finish it. Sucked actually. But I actually like Lwaxana, because she makes Picard feel uncomfortable and he has to do ridiculous shit for her, I can relate.

MacGuffinStuff

Also, I also do not understand the hate for Wesley, never did, he's I think a few years older then me, Wil Wheaton, I follow him and his coffee mug on Instagram and I love the guy, but I remember watching this as a kid, and I loved the character, also Beverly Crusher was the original MILF, before the term existed, what am I lying? Don't pull back, it's true. No but I did hate his onesie, it's like a onesie with a turtleneck, horrendous, and the zipper is in the back, why? So the highlight is Wesley doesn't have to wear that stupid onesie turtleneck anymore. Do all the uniforms have zippers in the back? I mean asthetically, camera wise, that's great, but that's so dumb speaking as an Army veteran and imagining having to get zipped up every morning 🤣

The Real Andrew Kim

Yup Simone, that's Ethan Phillips, and you would know him as Neelix

The Real Andrew Kim

Just in case people don't know, Majel Barrett was Gene Roddenberry's wife.

John Miller

I think the hatred for Wesley came, not from the young viewer, but from the TOS fans who were mad about pretty much everything TNG, in the beginning. Add that to the fact that the first couple of seasons were hard to watch at times. People wanted to like TNG, and they wanted it to continue, but they needed an outlet for their dislike of the series. And the target of that dislike was Wesley. It's actually sad that, by the time TNG got its footing, Wesley was already out the door.

Simon Pegged Me

I never liked Wesley. At first, I saw him as necessary as an audience surrogate, someone, an outsider, who asks the questions the audience members are asking or who the other characters provide with exposition about culture, Starfleet, whatever. But the show quickly stopped using him for that, using him instead as just another character. Except he wasn't another character: he was a Mary Sue, which I found uninteresting. Instead of giving him Ensign duties, I would have preferred an actual Ensign or Lieutenant j.g. character with a better backstory and history. When I see him on the bridge, I think of all the characters who must resent him below decks. Geordie points out in the episode that only 91% of graduates are posted to Galaxy-class vessels. The percentage of graduates who make it to the flagship has to be even lower. Wesley doing it without a Starfleet education belittles Starfleet Academy and the accomplishments of those that busted their asses to make it to the Enterprise. Four years of training and coursework in diplomacy, military history and strategy, command and control of a Starfleet vessel and crew, all seems like a waste of time. I don't hate Wesley, but I assume the other junior officers do. All the doting on him is bridge time and mission experience they're not getting. Not to mention he now outranks Chief O'Brien. And I wouldn't have to listen to a teen mock an adult for masturbating on the holodeck. That moment in "Sarek" was just creepy. Wesley to me began as a plot device and never became a fully rounded character no matter how much they tried to make him one as the seasons went on. I wished they'd created a character that earned the right to helm the Enterprise. I refuse to believe that character would not have been more interesting.

WayneC

Shouldn't that be Season 5 episodes 7 & 8? These episodes aired before Star Trek VI was released.

Robert Cooper

Comparing actors: It's a think I have thought about for years... Patrick Stewart is a fairly normal guy who shows his skill by playing these Shakespearean characters. Avery Brooks is a Shakespearean character who shows his still by playing normal guys.

StonyD

Back in the day, fans "hated" Wesley because he was Patient Zero for "they're not taking my science fiction show seriously". Nerds and Trekkies weren't culturally embraced, so Wes exemplified this feeling with a child being on the main bridge. No kids on the bridge in TOS. It was all "serious adults". And Wesley wasn't "cool", he was a geek, even in that world. This made some insecure fans think the producers were making fun of their own fanbase. By the late 90's into the 2000's, it simply became a meme. "Shut up Wesley" was clipped and memed and became a known cultural touchstone, even if you never watched TNG. Then Wil Wheaton himself got involved in the world through the internet and social media, admitting his own "hatred" of the character. Then, by late 2010's into the teens, Wheaton became more politically outspoken and this also turned a sect against him, and thus his character. So "Wesley Hate" is multifaceted and has layers. Watching it all in a cultural bubble like this, it's easy to misunderstand the whole thing.

ChiefKC

Not a spoiler. It's obvious that she is a reoccurring character and that you will learn more of her backstory over the course of the series and her appearance in DS9.

Ian Tellam

Part of the dislike of Wesley was older 'serious' fans not wanting Star Trek to be a 'kids show'. Part of it was the 'Wesley as super child' trope Roddenberry pushed for in the first Season was a bit tiresome and in a season that was overall considered fairly rough it was something to focus on. Another aspect was the fact that, given the nerdy demographic fanbase, TNG was one of the first major shows to be discussed extensively on the early internet before usage had become widespread - and you know how internet hate-train's can be, and the way that popular opinion can coalesce in online spaces in toxic and extreme ways. As far as Lwaxana goes, I think most of the enjoyment is less her character and is what you mention - it leads to some fun and memorable Picard moments, which does help humanize a usually stoic character. So regardless of how good or bad the episodes are in themselves, I think they do contribute to the overall character-building of Picard. Just to excuse the logic of that episode a little bit, I don't think that the Enterprise would just 'start blasting' and risk a war, there would have been a bunch of negotiation first in any case. Once the Starfleet officers were returned, Lwaxana had technically agreed to stay on board the Ferengi ship (and they're big on contracts) and Star Fleet itself had no legal reason to threaten the Ferengi - so I think the idea was not to demand her back but to get Daimon whatever to voluntarily back out of the contract, or something. Given the way network TV worked, and the fact this was a primetime show I think there was some pressure to do 'lighter' episodes, and seeing as this episode is among a cluster of heavier episodes it was probably put there for that reason. Although it does feel like tonal whiplash after 'Sarek'. I think the Wesley field promotion bit was stuck in this episode to at least make it slightly worthwhile for fans.

John Smith

Also, for those who don't know - they were in a very "open" relationship; or at least Gene was, not sure about Majel.

John Smith

I remember hearing (back in the day) that Gene didn't think clothing in the future would have zippers; and so he tried to hide them wherever possible.

The Real Andrew Kim

I only bring it up cuz I wasn't sure if the Simone and George were aware that relationship with Trek as well as her being pretty much the estate holder until her passing.

djKENTO

Just decided to watch the Pulp Fiction reaction and Simone likes Holly Hunter... She is going to fucking LOVE Starfleet Academy. Chancellor Ake is the most Simone coded Star Trek character of all fucking time. It's gonna take years to get there, but Simone is gonna loser her fuckin mind.

Crow T. German Robot

Aaaaaand the algolian ceremonial rhythms are back in my head for the next week, great.

Alan Kobb

I think the reason for the Wesley hatred was something of a fear that Star Trek would be "dumbed down" and turned into "kids fare". I remember comparisons to the Ewoks of Return of the Jedi for being seen as just an excuse to excite little kids and sell plush toys. This seems to be a common complaint any time a "youth-oriented" aspect character is added to a Sci-Fi or fantasy movie, and those who make the complaint never cease their complainng even when their fears don't come true.

John Smith

Yeah... I was hoping we could get some clarification on that issue. Perhaps George simply misread the season schedule? Watching The Undiscovered Country in early season five works a bit better because there is a slight tie-in to a couple of TNG episodes that came out around the same time. It's not a true crossover or anything, just some mildly related plots.

Angzarr

I dunno, I think that's one of the many problems with the show. Simone has many wonderful qualities, but would be a catastrophically bad Starfleet captain.

djKENTO

I love Chancellor Ake so far. I think she's a great choice for a character that runs a school. I don't need or want all my Trek captains to be the same. I like how free and loose she is and she's a pretty good educator so far.

Paul

There's one episode with her that I find truly remarkable. Half of something.