Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Couple of things, first we read your comments about Star Trek movie 6 taking place between season 4 and 5 AFTER recording this video. So we'll delay the movie till then.

Second thing is that for those who joined after Wednesday became Star Trek day, this slot each week use to be empty and we decided to add a show of our own choosing, which was Star Trek. At the moment though both of us are dying to watch season 2 of Fallout so for the next 4 weeks, Wednesday will be Fallout S2. Once we finish those 8 episodes, we'll resume TNG.

Go to this site: Cinebingers.ca for the unedited versions of all our content.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/ZMXaAvIgT4 👈 for the full reaction where you do not need your own copy.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/qRw6T1uFp4 👈for the full reaction where you need your own copy.

If you are on a phone/tablet, hold down the link above and press "open in browser", or go straight to Cinebingers.ca on your browser app.

Transfiguration, Best of Both Worlds Part 1

Files

Comments

Tinfoilnation

*refresh* *refresh* *refresh* *squeeeeeeeeeee!*

Mastervodo

STAR TREK DAAAAY! Also - kinda awesome that they are giving themselves a one-month break RIGHT AFTER this cliffhanger!

Data Cable

Well, at least George will experience 1/3 of the agony/anticipation some of us endured in the summer of '91.

otto

If you take any more breaks from Star Trek may I suggest Rome.

dudewheresmycar

Nice. You get the same agonising delay we all did back in the day between Season 3 and 4 of TNG. Smart move. 😁

Ramen Nudels

Giving George the real life treatment of waiting for season 4. I love it lol.

Fritz

George having talked about Actors being from Rome in every movie ever, he might have already seen it. A few times.

William

Heh. I watched this and went off to boot camp the next day. It would be several years before I managed to see anything after this. 🤦🏼‍♂️🤣

Tinfoilnation

George for sure has already watched all of that - multiple times unless I miss my guess. Every damn time one of the actors from Rome appears in a reaction "Oh! He/She was in Rome!"

Matrim

Well, we had to wait 3 months when it first aired, so at least you’re being authentic.

TheLeftPecOfTheLord

Man Sopranos season 2 and Fallout season 2 back to back for the next month is awesome!

Life in the cave of Garanoga

I like this format. Wednesday is your day to watch what you want. And Star Trek is arguably the largest undertaking there is lol. Taking a break will make that experience much better in the long run.

funky weapon

on the one hand, boo, no Star Trek. on the other hand, yay, Fallout. *insert Larry David gif*

adv97

I’d rather them start Fargo Instead

dc

I'm going to miss Star Trek day during its brief hiatus, but the Sopranos will be back (yay) and taking a brief break is true to the original cliffhanger. Plus I wouldn't want you to get burned out on Star Trek—there's still so much great Trek episodes awaiting you, especially if you do DS9.

Krong

/s? Please tell me this isn't even in the same Galaxy as the worst news you could get today.

Levi Curry

Noooooooo! It's the summer of 1990 all over again. Lol

Mike FromOz

God, I'd love for them to do Fargo. The first 2 seasons at least. It drops off after that.

Nick Marten

How dare you take a reasonable one-month break between season that, at the time, had a 3+ month break (6-18-90 to 9-24-90) and somewhat recreate the cliffhanger feeling those of us who watched this in 1990 felt! /s

s0rd3z

I never understand the weird idea that a reactor has to experience the same wait we did when this stuff first aired. It's just weird. Also glad they are not waiting for Fallout, I am a huge TNG geek but I am here for S&G reactions in general. The show that is reacted to is kind of secondary for me personally so I like all the variety. And we are literally getting something every day of the week now which was not always the case ( as well as the full cinebingers website ) Best value for my money I have gotten in a very long time to be honest.

adv97

Season 1 and 2 are goated, 3 and 5 are decent as well

Matrim

“Maybe he likes his chair? Some people don’t want to climb forever.” This might be something that civilians don’t have a lot of insight on, but in the military if an officer passes up a promotion it’s seen as a failure of character. At best it’s interpreted as them being comfortable or lazy; at worst it betrays indecision and a lack of confidence, and timidity is unacceptable in an officer.

blerbaberpaterb

i envy your easy life if this is the worst news you could get

blerbaberpaterb

Rome is to George what Buffy is to Simone i think. they both point out every actor thats every appeared on either shows. so clearly theyve each watched those shows to death already.

Michal Novotny

Don’t mind taking a short break from Trek, looking forward to the Fallout reactions!!

Marcus Hicks

Oh no, a whole month without TNG?!?! I think I might lose my sanity!!!!

djKENTO

George, your question about how they communicate at warp is all answered by Star Trek magic called Subspace Communication. It's an electromagnetic field that exists outside our own space. You can use it to send communication faster than the speed of light. in Season 6 there is an episode where they try to explain it even more, but really all you need to know is that it's a field that lets us communicate over infinite space at once.

Cory Garron

Oh Numfar, of the Death Deathwok clan!

Robert Carter

Just to say, it is not an unreasonable thing to have a day where you watch what YOU guys want to watch. You are catering to others across 6 other days so having at least one day that is your choice is totally cool 😆. (Personally I would have a more even split, 5/2 or even 4/3 but I don’t run a channel that relies on viewer preferences for my income 😜)

Thall

WEEKS?! No problem, can't wait for you to get back to it! Have fun with Fallout!

Stephen Morris

Can’t wait to watch this reaction. Fire. to be continued…

michael denny

we waited 3 months back in 1990 we can wait 4 weeks in 2026

WayneC

Star Trek VI was filmed between seasons 4 and 5 of TNG, and was released between episodes 9 and 10 of TNG. It doesn't "take place" between season 4 and 5, and it is a standalone movie. Start Trek VI is more related to world events at the time than TNG, IMO.

michael denny

subspace communication is explained as signals are sent into a compressed dimension known as sub space which shortens the distance of communication to near 0 making communication times significantly faster. I do believe that signals degrade with distance somehow though.

michael denny

referring to the collapse of the Soviet Union? Interesting.

michael denny

it's surely not "puppet cancer".

Guts

I am saddened by these news

Thall

PErsonally I feel the Borg are at their most effective as a narrative device when used sparingly and being barely explained. Them being unknowable and weird is what makes them so scary!

Jomero

Feeling like you're forced to do something, or feeling like you're stuck, is never great. And it would lessen your reactions. Do what you need to do for your own sanity and enjoyment.

R. Chang

I subbed for Star Trek, but even if you weren't switching to something I was already interested in, it's fine to take breaks. A month is nothing. And even if it was an long show that I wasn't interested in, I can always pause my sub and come back later. You shouldn't be worried about watching stuff you want to watch. The people that pitch hissy fits about it aren't worth your time. All that said, maybe you could stick Pluribus in between seasons 4 and 5? I really think you'd dig it.

Joe Concepts

I think it's best for the first time viewer to get that real cliffhanger affect, anyway. As I'm sure many of my fellows patrons are saying alongside me.

otto

I know George has seen Rome. But I think he might like to share a show he really likes with his friend Simone. It is their day after all.

Greg Johanson

Another reason I think George will jive with ds9 is it becomes a lot more serialized unlike tng that only has handful of “special” episodes

Mikebdrx

I have been purposely waiting to watch Fallout with you. This is the first time I’ve actively avoided spoilers for a show for this reason. It’s a lot more difficult than I thought.

Mike W

Yes, agree with this. Although this is your job it shouldn't feel like a chore. Do what you need to do to keep going

Lintrinsic

This cliff-hanger was were the show became "water cooler TV" and gained mainstream popularity, arguably the only Star Trek show to accomplish that. It was also known at the time that Patrick Stewart's contract was up for renewal, so his future was uncertain. It's often cited that in the UK there was only a week between the episodes when first broadcast, but for those of us watching the earlier release on VHS at 2 episodes a time weeks apart it was very much a long wait.

Phosphorus

Activate the Omega 13... (dun dun dun)...

ChiefKC

If you really want to stick to release order then after Season 4 you would need to add Deep Space Nine. So it could be one episode of TNG and one episode of DS9. And Star Trek 6 should be watch during Season 5 during the 2 part episode "Unification"

gfixler

Me: [light panic over change to/end of ST:TNG schedule] George: we're going to take a short break for Fallout, season 2. Me: Yay! Phew, that was a scary one. I love this choice.

Brandon

DS9 didn't debut until partway through season 6 of TNG. It was one of those shows that started its first season in January. I don't know if they're going to switch back and forth between TNG and DS9 every week when the time comes, but I'm not sure I want to see it that way. I don't know why they would watch Star Trek VI in between a two-part episode of TNG that has nothing to do with the plot of the movie. If we're watching in "perfect" release order then ST6 came out after that two-parter.

gfixler

So Riker and Data have a new podcast (Dropping Names with Brent and Jonny), and I watched a livestream with them yesterday. Apparently, Brent Spiner, while reading his script, had been saying it like DAH-tuh ("a" like in "apple"). At the first table read, Patrick Stewart read a line with his name in it, and pronounced it DAY-tuh, and Spiner interrupted to ask how his name was supposed to be pronounced. Roddenberry said "New rule: the first person to say a name decides how it'll be pronounced." Brent and Jonny said that's how it was for the rest of the show. He was almost DAH-tuh.

closetoyou28

nooooooooooooooooooooooooooo :-( i love my Wednesday NTG. but is oki i love you 2 more ha ha ha keep up the good work

Mike W

I hope this channel and Star Trek day keeps going for years as I would love to see DS9 and Voyager reactions.

Jeffrey Mitchell

Not likely. I was 8 years old in the summer of '91. 3 months might as well have been forever.

Pokes

I don't ever want Star Trek to become a chore that has to be powered through to complete the work day. Like with any job, I realize that will sometimes be the reality. But the occasional hiatus to break up the weekly monotony, and keep things feeling fresh, will make for a much better viewing experience for all parties involved.

REDR58

Yay Star Trek Day! Yay Fallout! I cannot wait to see what George thinks of this season-ender!

Joel

Picard has been assimilated!!! Resistance is FUTILE!!!

Florian

Great choise, I'm happy to watch Fallout :)

Life in the cave of Garanoga

As someone else said this was about setting up "outs" and replacements in case Stewart didn't return to the show but it also highlights one of my favorite parts of the Star Trek universe, things change and live evolves. People get promoted, demoted, switch sides, and the progression of individual character's lives don't just stay in one place for the sake of the stories. The stories shift around their changing lives. Stargate does this expertly by the way lol. On a side, the next OG movie isn't really relevant to the TNG season so there isn't any real need to time it exact. I would definitely wait until it's within the same release year but it doesn't have to be right in the middle if that's not how you want to plan it. But the next movie "Generations" should be watched in the correct order.

ChiefKC

I am Locutus of Borg! Resistance is Futile!

Kat

I think you answered your own question as to why the Borg have been used so sparingly. They are too OP and in episodic TV you kinda want to have a nice resolution at the end of each episode (or two-parter). And you can only defeat/escape/outwit the Borg so many times before they become less threatening.

Thomas Yanez

I'm curious why George suddenly is questioning Subspace Communication now, three full seasons into TNG, when we've had it since TOS. Obviously, it's a magic method to allow them to communicate faster than the ship can fly, while still sometimes delayed depending on if the story needs it. I'm just wondering why it suddenly vexes him?

Cinebinge

Did... it come across as vexing? It's just a thought I had and a question to I wanted to ask... I wanted to know if there was in universe explanation, because I'm interested in the show and the universe it created. Does me asking questions sound like I'm expressing dislike? If so, I will stop asking.

Kelley Leary

Best of Both Worlds answers Kirk’s question to “God” in Star Trek V. “God” needed a starship to fight the Borg. The late actor George Murdock played both “God” and Admiral J.P. Hanson.

REDR58

Do not stop asking questions!

Thomas Yanez

LOL, hey there, George. I actually spent a significant amount of time trying to decide if "vexing" sounded too strong, knowing how easily some people jump to a reactor's defense at the slightest implied critique. I should have dug out a thesaurus for a better alternative. No, I read no dislike in your question, just curiosity on the topic. And my curiosity was just wondering what triggered it now, after so many other episodes where Subspace Communication is used regularly.

Cinebinge

just hadnt thought about it until now.

Thomas Yanez

Works for me! Keep up the good work, both of you. Looking forward to the "Fallout" season 2 coverage.

REDR58

Wow, that’s interesting! Did you find it was worth the wait when you finally did see it?

Robert Gendron

Back in 1990, people weren't on the TNG subreddit getting news of which actors have renewe their contracts or seeing set photos like a lot of fans are today. So most wouldn't know if Patrick Steward had renewed his contract or not. If you had some knowledge of the tv industry, you'd know the three year standard tv contract before the actors can leave or have more negotiating power for salary. So there was a very good change that TNG would be Captain Riker with Shelby joining the crew. Fans had to wait three months from when this aired to when BoBW Part 2 aired. A season of Fallout in between is a good substitute for that summer break between seasons.

Colin Reid

When STAR TREK DAY! Is eventually finished (sad Star Trek day) you should watch Being Human. And if you ever take another break from STAR TREK DAY! again the Canadian mini series Darknet is a good watch, only 6 episodes.

REDR58

I’m fairly certain everyone, including myself, who is saying George should have to wait the three months is just doing so tongue in cheek.

REDR58

Especially, I imagine, for someone who’s supposed to be a *career-minded* officer. I don’t know what the situation is, with say, someone who joins Starfleet for the education route, if they’re just planning to doing a tour for a few years or whatever and are not interested in officer ranks. I find it hard to believe that every single member of Starfleet is there to make a full career out of it, but I suppose it’s possible.

s0rd3z

Oh for sure. And I didn't mean it as a critique. It does come up often though among reaction communities.

John

"so for the next 4 weeks, Wednesday will be Fallout S2. Once we finish those 8 episodes, we'll resume TNG." Wow... so the month of February will be cold, dark, AND cheerless for me. 😭😭😭

Tangerra

I think that’s why Shelby didn’t really get into trouble. She did the right things, just ignoring protocol. Which is 100% not anything to be punished over, just abrasive and a little disrespectful toward Riker specifically. That’s why Riker, even after initially being a little pissed, told Troi that he saw what she was doing as something he might have done in the same place at her career stage. We always get a little annoyed when we see people who are like us, especially when they show traits we used to have and like but have since outgrown.

Tangerra

The funny thing about the zarconian zentai bodysuit is that if you were watching it on an old-school analog tv set, the picture quality actually would have made the edges fuzzier and it would look pretty cool. But HD kinda fucks that up. The same way 2-d sprites from the snes looked better because of the crt lines.

Danny Bryant

Would that be the UK Being Human or the US Being Human? or Both?

Danny Bryant

Um Peter, there are four more seasons and a movie between Best of both worlds and First Contact. A for effort thought. :)

Danny Bryant

Or, you'll learn that you love Fallout. eh, maybe? :)

Joe Concepts

And it's far from established just how it works. Because some episode of both TOS and TNG, they make a point of saying it will take a long time for messages to get somewhere, and other times they just act like they're a phone call. Very writer-dependent.

Danny Bryant

Preface for George: Don't change, this is my hangup and not really your problem. So, I am really not sure how I feel about this. He is questioning physics in a science fiction series. It feels like questioning magic in DnD.

Ryan Ware

I’m sad I won’t get your ST:TNG reactions for the next 4 weeks. Honestly one of the highlights of my week.

Joe Concepts

I think I have a reaction-watching problem. This is likely the 4th reaction channel that I have watched react to this episode. Not to mention, watching along to the entire series.

Joe Concepts

I usually think of these Patreon subscriptions as not only a monthly subscription but also basically a donation to keep the channel going. Taking some breaks here and there is okay to me.

Joe Concepts

So, I always thought the point of this ending is that Riker proves he can make the hard choices. Even at the end Shelby herself gets emotional and wants to save Picard. But I have seen some people think he makes the easy decision because it's the right one? I think the point is that Shelby, Crusher and even more may want to rescue Picard, and Riker knows they can't take that chance. A "risky" choice to not destroy the Borg hoping you can save the captain would be the selfish choice. I never saw that as "playing it safe."

Ian Tellam

Yeah but fantasy worlds often still have a magic 'system' - even if it's fantastical there is often an internal logic behind it. E.g. Mass Effect uses quantum entanglement to communicate faster than light, Warhammer 40k uses psychic messages through the warp. It's fair to ask what the internal logic behind Star Trek subspace communication is, as things like warp travel and the transporters have their own pseudoscientific explanations. Even if it's 'magic' at the end of the day, it's all part of the worldbuilding.

Gerald Walker

I was 19 when this initially aired- We had to wait a year for resolution, and we had no idea if Picard would be back or not

REDR58

The bodysuit they give the actor to wear is really unfortunate.

Dan

That was an unfortunate gimp suit. That George probably already has somewhere haha.

Danny Bryant

If Simone has seen Rome that would be a great switch show after Fallout.

Paul T Hewes

I watched it as it aired. It was a LONG summer....

Joe Concepts

Always liked how Troi stepped in to tell Riker to not join the away team. It's like, she knew she may be the only one who would've said something to him about it. Though honestly, Worf or Data would have been perfectly within their jobs to say something.

Ian Tellam

I do enjoy the little Riker/Shelby arc in these episodes. It's a nice bit of character development.

REDR58

Transfigurations You guys seem to not have recognized her, but Julie Warner who played “Christy Henshaw” here played the same character in this season’s episode 6, “Booby Trap” (where the Enterprise encounters an ancient derelict spacecraft in an asteroid field). In that episode, Christy and Geordi went on a few dates but eventually she said she wasn’t interested in him romantically, and things between them seemed to end. Then suddenly in this episode, it seems like Geordi has somehow barely spoken to her before and is all nervous around her when she inexplicably seems interested in him again? And then the alien influence makes him all confident everything and whatever. Riker even notes that Geordi had little previous success with Christy, so is he speaking of the events of “Booby Trap”? So something is a little strange/inconsistent with the writing for the Christy character. Or she had a massive change of heart. I *really* don’t like the ending of this episode. Too much magic. I really hate the idea of an individual “evolving” in what is ostensibly a “sci-fi” (and not magical) universe and somehow radically changing from a matter to energy being. Individuals *do not physically evolve.* These aren’t even freaking caterpillars changing form and turning into butterflies (and that’s not evolution). *Massive eye-roll* from me. Tedious. Very tedious. I did like how the other guest star, Patti Tippo as Nurse Temple who was working with Crusher got an actual speaking role and didn’t have to stand around mutely. Once again, why are the shuttle bays so poorly secured??? Any rando that comes across the room can takeoff in a shuttle. We have seen this number of times in the show already. Charles Dennis as Sunad gave a laughably hammy performance. Sorry, Chuck. The late Mark La Mura as John Doe does a nice job here, though.

Ian Tellam

Yeah the gimp suit in the last scene of Transfigurations does kind of undercut the 'majesty' of the situation that it's trying to convey, lol. With that said it does raise a wider issue that's worth mentioning. The show was originally designed, and the special effects composited, to look good on a standard definition, CRT screen. The now fairly obvious details like the folds in the costume that are easily seen on a modern HD display would have much less apparent, and the bloom effect more pronounced on the different screen technology. This is often the case with props and sets as well on the show, where they would have generally looked much more convincing when viewed on their original intended medium, it's not just a factor of the literal age of the show. With the way that the show was remastered from the original film, I don't think they made allowances for this. That's not to say I feel this show needs a TOS-remaster style glow-up, I think for the most part it still looks pretty good, but it's worth bearing in mind.

REDR58

And notice how La Mura’s voice is muffled when he’s wearing that full body suit that the glow was applied to. They didn’t even bother to ADR his lines there.

DonkyDave

You have to respect the absolute madness of seeing the season finale then choosing to wait weeks to watch the next one :D :D

REDR58

You can also see screw heads holding the panels on the consoles and other things on the set.

REDR58

You know, additionally, it seems to me that the visual effects team doing the remastering work could’ve more or less easily just made a little bit more of a diffuse brighter glow to take out the edges of that bodysuit the guy was wearing.

Maerandir Eldar

Mad respect for spacing out the two-parter. That was the longest summer of my life... to this day, I rate significant moments of anticipation on a scale of 1 to "mister Worf, fire!"

Eddie lecornu

Well I did only join as I'm a huge tng fan and thought be great to watch again for the millionth time just to see someone else's reaction. It's a shame but may take a break and possibly pop back in a couple of months....

mpd

Why does Locutus have abs?

REDR58

That’s for sure!

Happy Hanukkah

No, *I* am Locutus! And so is my wife!

Happy Hanukkah

Tangerra, it is amusing watching people react to Top Gun: Maverick.

BzzBzzBzzBzzBzz

As much as I enjoy Star Trek day, I am okay with this. I really want to see you two react to Fallout season 2. Star Trek isn't going anywhere, unless it gets banned in the US as leftist propaganda.

Angzarr

Everybody, sing along with the theme! You woke up this morning Got yourself a phaser. Your previous command was the USS Stargazer. You carry the rank and the burden, Every call rests on you, Out here the right thing ain’t easy, But it’s what captains do. ...

Carlos

Bummed.

REDR58

Because he’s jacked! ?

Nick Marten

A few Notes: - While Stewart signed a 6-year contract, seasons 4-6 were options for Stewart, so he could leave at the end of season 3. When Best of Both Worlds Part I aired, fans had no idea if Stewart would return (just like you George). - This was only the 2nd two-part episode in Star Trek history (after TOS: The Menagerie, Parts I and II (Encounter at Far Point originally aired as a single extended episode that was later cut into two parts for rebroadcast) and Star Trek’s first cliffhanger. - Best of Both Worlds Part I won two Emmys ("Outstanding Art Direction for a Series" and "Outstanding Sound Editing for a Series"). - Parts I and II (combined) were ranked as #50 in TV Guide’s 1996 list of most memorable TV moments of all time and #70 on its 2001 list of Greatest TV episodes of all time.

Stuart_Design

Any chance you could watch Movie 6 during the break (just as one of your regular weekly movies)? That way it won't feel quite as looong between seasons for us Trek fans. There are no plot points that cross over at all, so it would be totally fine to do movie 6 between S3 and S4 of TNG instead of S4 and S5.

Angzarr

Is it just me, or is the Zalkonian ship seem a bit... um... reminiscent of the Ace & Gary car? (46:35)

DanManMtn

The writer of Best of Both Worlds, Michael Pillar, was leaving the show after this episode. He had no idea how to get out of the cliffhanger, but didn’t care because it would be someone else’s problem. Between seasons, they offered him a raise if he’d come back and he agreed. His first assignment was to write part 2. Oops!

Mastervodo

Yes. They know. Recommendations get put on a list. They've got it. Stop repeating it. It's annoying.

makaveliaton

Im loving the reactions.. are you two doing ds9 as well? After season 2 its peak startrek imo. Regardless im here for anything. Thanks for all the hard work and fun you guys bring. Take care

David N

I love the borg episode but i've always hated how Patrick Stewart shines that laser pointer right into the camera. It gives me some kind of wierd headache and it's the clip that everyone uses online when they talk about this episode.

REDR58

I think it looked a lot cooler at the time than it does now. What does he even need it for? It’s not like he has the Predator shoulder cannon!

Angzarr

Plus we'd experienced Tasha's death, so main cast getting killed off seemed much more plausible than on a typical show of the time.

dlpheonix

Someone correct me if im wrong, but i believe this was the first ever season finale cliff hanger for an on air syndicated show. Of course this immediately became very standard after the fact but this finale was considered responsible for saving TNG from getting potentially canceled after s3 if i remember right.

Angzarr

That rule could have gone so badly with a mischievous actor... "Yes, I know it's spelled L-O-C-U-T-U-S, but I'm pronouncing it Throatwobbler Mangrove and there's nothing you can do about it!" Sir Stewart: "I am... [big sigh and eye roll] Throatwobbler Mangrove of Borg..."

REDR58

The obvious thumbnail for the season three best-of video is the Borg-ify both of yourselves.

Angzarr

Isn't there something about signal strength in subspace not following the inverse square law and dropping off more slowly, or am I remembering that from some other SciFi? (Bobiverse, maybe?)

Angzarr

Or Locutus of.... Georg? Borge?

gfixler

I had something very "private" I needed diagnosed back in my college days (turned out to be nothing and temporary), and I was hoping it would be a grizzled old man who'd seen everything, but when I opened the door to the examination room, it was a gorgeous young redhead girl doctor, and I was like 👁️ 👄 👁️ ❌. I almost immediately thanked her for her time, spun in place, put my hat back on, and grandpa Simpson'd my way back out of the clinic.

REDR58

Best of Both Worlds Part 1 So the Enterprise has sensors/imagers that can see across a solar system, but they are surprised to see that the buildings are *extremely* missing from the colony site on surface of the planet when they arrive? They know there’s a problem with the loss of communications, but they don’t bother to do at least a visual scan when they arrive in orbit? It’s not like they have never observed the ground from orbit before…we saw this several times in “The Survivors” when they were able to see the last remaining house on the otherwise ravaged landscape. I can go to the International Space Station’s website and get a nearly-live view of the earth right now! https://eol.jsc.nasa.gov/esrs/hdev/ It looks like the Federation is still using rebar for building construction for its colonies. That’s interesting! But how big was the infrastructure of this colony of ~900 that Borg evidently excavated a massive crater to remove it?? Shelby is played by Elizabeth Dennehy, daughter of Brian Dennehy who you saw in Rambo as the jerky sheriff who tried to run Rambo out of town. Elizabeth was also in Gattaca, Red Dragon and the Charmed series. The “old man’s fantasies” was a very creepy line! And Wesley was never invited to play poker again… The hand phaser holsters are very floppy. It’s difficult to talk about the Borg now because of what we may see in the future, but I find they are a lot more interesting when they are infrequently seen. The Paulson Nebula uses modified visual effects of the Mutara Nebula seen in The Wrath of Khan. When Picard walks into Engineering before going on to Ten Forward, you can see a technician working inside an overheard access point and there is what looks like a 1980s computer motherboard up in there. Why does Picard order only forward torpedo bays loaded before leaving the nebula when the Enterprise is going to be in front of the Borg cube? He should have ordered aft torpedo launchers loaded as well. George, “Porg” is something from another universe, but the less said about that the better…

Happy Hanukkah

Before anybody jumps in (like I was about to): please note "syndicated." (I accept responsibility for shooting Sly Lovegren.)

dlpheonix

I should have scrolled more. This guy knows the history better then me.

Ron

Surprisingly, Michael Pillar (writer and showrunner) said that when he broke the story he didn't know how to resolve the cliffhanger. He actually told the staff, "We're going to figure it out next season." This was partly prompted by the uncertainty of Patrick Stewart's on-going contract negotiation. Also, the B-plot of whether Riker would leave or stay on the Enterprise was partly prompted by Pillar's own desire to because he himself was torn between staying or leaving to run his own show. 3 Months: Part 1 aired on 6/18/1990 and Part 2 aired on 9/24/1990 -- almost exactly 3 months. Today, that is a pretty quick turn around compared to some shows which have literally years between season. (I think the Twin Peaks gap between S2 and S3 is probably the winner. I'll abstain from saying the exact length for now.) Fallout: I haven't seen Fallout but have wanted to see it. So, for me, this will be a nice change of pace and mirrors the real-life break we had during the first-run broadcasts. Looks like I have some catching-up to do. Remembrances: I taped all the episodes on VHS and manually edited the commercials out live during broadcast so that I could easily rewatch them. I must have rewatched this 3 or 4 times that day. I remember saving up and and buying a better VCR (SVHS with a flying erase head) to help with this.

TalynOne

Hey George, you asked if the Borg will always be a season finale thing. It wasn't even a season finale for their first/previous appearance. "Q Who" was Season 2 Episode 16, a good 6 episodes before the season finale.

John Wiese

Quick correction: it was Ronald D Moore who was the writer who thought he was leaving and wrote this cliff hanger. Ron Moore later went on to create the Battlestar Galactica reboot

John Wiese

Quick correction: it was Ronald D Moore who was the writer who thought he was leaving and wrote this cliff hanger. Ron Moore later went on to create the Battlestar Galactica reboot

Ron

Thanks!

Kevin Knadle

For the thumbnail, we need to see "Simonus of Borg".

Angzarr

Further nitpicking: O'Brien also says he beamed them to the city center, but they arrive on the edge of the crater and it's just wilderness on the other side of them from the crater.

Simon Pegged Me

Because the Borg assimilated Crunch Chair technology years ago.

Kevin Knadle

In the summer of 1990, Patrick Stewart had not signed on for season 4. The writers didn't even know if he was coming back.

DanManMtn

It was Pillar. Heard it years ago and it’s in his Memory Alpha entry. He is also listed in the credits as the writer for the 2 episodes.

Angzarr

They didn't react to S1 though, right, or did I overlook it?

Steven Linden

My dad has always tried to say "Space" at the exact moment Patrick Stewart does too. Not quite as good at it as Simone, though.

Holy Squire

The season 3 finale is the most theatrically literate Star trek ever. Including Star Trek OS and next gen thru season three it's my favorite episode after City on the Edge.

Edina Lewis

That’s my favourite shot in the whole episode!!!

Gryff

We should get both of them as borg then copy/pasted into a collective

Gryff

I AM VISIBLY ANGRY ABOUT THIS!

Ray Ward

George: We’re going to take a break before Season 4. [Watches BOBW Pt 1] George: D’OH!

Pendergasted

Let's just hope your patreon can survive the fallout from this decision. Hoping to make George proud with that one ;)

Marcus Hicks

Oh, I face-palmed so hard at your joke that I nearly had a concussion 🤪

Marcus Hicks

To George's question, I had to get shoulder surgery after a traffic collision, and my doctor was a stunning brunette woman with an Olive complexion, who could easily have been a model if she hadn't become a doctor.

Mikebdrx

They did. That season I had watched them before and then again with S&G but this time I want to experience it with them.

REDR58

Yeah that was strange!

Mister Forbez

I remember watching this "in real time" back when I was a wee lad. TNG was the first "grown up" show that I was not only allowed to watch, but *wanted* to watch. A lot of it was hard to follow, but I still enjoyed it. This episode was the first time I experienced a real 'cliff hanger' (cartoons always resolved their plot twists after the commercial breaks), and I distinctly remember yelling "NO!!!" at my TV when "to be continued..." came up on screen. I barely knew what that meant, but then I remembered it was the last episode of the season, and for all I knew the show would never be on again. Three months is nothing compared to show breaks now, but it seemed like forever to a kid with a whole summer to wait.

MacGuffinStuff

I don't remember having a very attractive doctor, but my orthodontist's assistants were like he recruited from the Charlie's Angels Orthodontic Assistants School. And, it was a different location, but I had my wisdom teeth pulled when I was 18 and I came out of anesthesia basically drunk, and a nurse said "ok follow me," and I said, "I'll follow you anywhere pretty lady." She laughed a little I remember, then put me in the little recovery room and I don't remember exactly how long it took but I started to sober up, I was fuckin mortified, could not believe I said that out loud. Could not look her in the eyes when she came back to hand me off to my mom. Hey at least it's not as bad as some of the things I've heard people say on anaesthesia that their loved ones ruthlessly shared on social media lol

John Smith

There's no way that TNG was in danger of being canceled after season 3. They were routinely pulling in 10 to 11 million viewers per episode throughout the season. The lowest recorded viewership for a season 3 episode was Menage a Troi at 9.1 million.

John Smith

Because the Borg are trying to convince humanity to willingly become "Borg-ified". Can't really be convincing if the end result isn't sexy.

MacGuffinStuff

What a great finale to leave on, see you guys in four weeks. No just kidding, I've been hoping you'd watch Fallout, been holding back. But yeah, what a great episode to end on, giving me that anticipation you're talking about, so I know my next mortgage payment coincides with TNG's return!

John Smith

It was only three months (June 18th - Sept. 24th).

BellaBlue

TV Series Request for your consideration: - Silo (Apple TV) 2 Seasons so far (planned for 4) I previously read the book series which was amazing. Just got around to the show and they have done a great job with it. Highly recommended

John Smith

The Fallout world isn't exactly warm and fuzzy.

Robert Cooper

You should have to walk away from this for a year like I did. Also, Patrick Stewart's contract was up here. There was a legitimate question as to whether or not he would return. "Slaughter this whole village and she will love you. " (George has been watching DS9) Speaking of which... O'Brien getting hurt... The beginning of a tradition. It's just a guy in a suit with a bloom light! -- Yeah, but for early 90s TV, it was a great effect. Also, GOD DAMN IT, YOU MUTATE THE SHIELD MODULATION, NOT MODULATE MUTATION.

John Smith

There were a couple of season five TNG episodes that were (very loosely) connected to The Undiscovered Country. It's not necessary to watch them together or anything, but they might pick up on a detail or two if they watch them on consecutive weeks.

Chris Kelley

I was really looking forward to season 4. How dare they watch what they want on their own channel? Crazy Bingers! Side question: does anyone know how the fallout show holds up if you haven’t played the games?

Alex Macdougall

Thats a good breather. Let George stew in the mystery!

James W.

Yeah, same of the effect of the dude in a suit. On a tube TV you didn't see the bunches in the suit and the bloom from the lighting broke up the silhouette such that it didn't look quiye as silly as it does higher res on modern displays.

E G

Sweet fallout S2 next!

Alan Kobb

No biggie. Back when i first saw thiis I had to wait 3 months to see part 2..

Chris Kelley

For the record Simone was right. Part one aired June 18, 1990– part two aired September 24, 1990. It was a three month wait not a year. Having said that I was there and it did feel like a year.

FranciscoGios

Now that I know Simonous of Borg is getting a little popular, her mind will be extra busy; because you know she’s one mind into many thoughts 😅.

The Real Andrew Kim

You do not need to play the games to enjoy the Fallout universe and the story is very compelling. If you have played the games, you will see all the references, easter eggs and feel the goosebumps from certain music cues

Michael Kemmet

I suspect the faults George found with Transfiguration had a lot to do with budgets, shooting time, and VFX time being diverted to the season finale. That's probably the reason for the 'tell don't show'.

Ben Schwartz

Boooo! j/k I'll be back when you resume TNG!

Michael Kemmet

Yeah. I don't remember being able to see the creases and other flaws back then. I remember the glow overpowering all the details back in analog NTSC on a CRT.

REDR58

The problems with the VFX are the least of its problems. It’s a silly premise and I can’t take it any more seriously than I do the goofy body suit (pre- and post-transfiguration).

REDR58

Spoilers!

REDR58

They were saying “Nutation” with an “N.” Nutation is a real thing having to do with swaying in symmetrical objects: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nutation Of course for this episode, it seems like it’s just a borrowed concept for the shield.

Michael Kemmet

How hailing works: The most honest answer is something called subspace. It's one of Star Trek's handwavy things to deal with writing yourself into a corner. Subspace is usually used when dealing with FTL things. Other stuff too. It's one of the core technobabbles in ST. The easiest way to deal with it is don't look too closely and just let it go. :) Seasoned: Riker is saying that 'seasoned' is a euphemism for being called old. And considering Riker's personality(and the context of the conversation with Deanna - partially about Shelby), you can see why Riker jokingly considered it an insult. Shield "N"utation: Huh, for almost 40 years I always thought they were saying "M"utation. Guess I should have had the closed captioning on. lol. But this might explain that idiotic line in 2012 from a week or so ago. They said the neutrinos were mutating. I wonder if someone was thinking nutation and it got fudged up between concept and performance(the line doesn't seem to be from the screenplay). Or maybe I'm giving the Emmerich team way too much credit. Yeah . . . probably giving too much credit. :) Borg appearances: One of the problems with the Borg from a meta perspective is that familiarity breeds contempt. The Borg are a great villain if you keep them mysterious and use them very, very sparingly. The more you use them, the less formidable they become. Because you HAVE to beat them each time(because of the episodic format of the show), and by beating them again and again, they lose their mystique. It's the same problem Doctor Who has with the Daleks. It's extremely hard to keep an enemy terrifying when the heroes beat them time and time again.

Robert Mendoza

I am one of those people on your Patreon specifically for TNG but of course y'all have to do what works for you. I started watching TNG right after the series was complete so I never had to wait to see what would happen next. The music when they first confront the Borg cube makes me think of boss music in a a JRPG. It's so dramatic and I love it

FromDarknessComesLight

Heck of a cliffhanger to leave on. 😜 Just like on tv! lmao Riker: "Fire!" Everyone: 😱😱😱😱 Paramount: "See you in 3 months!"

Craig Brennan

I'm sure paramount looking back after The Best of Both Worlds episodes that they wish this would of been a movie released over the summer between both seasons as the first TNG movie. You can actually buy a theatrical release edit of it.

Simon Pegged Me

Fallout is irrelevant. Stranger Things is irrelevant. ST:TNG Season 4 will be assimilated in four weeks time because I, Pegolas of CineBorg, am flexible and do not want to be an ass about it. You have four weeks (more or less). The CineBorg will be having our ab suits let out to accommodate holiday weight gain.

Michal Novotny

Did Brent Spiner play one of the Borgs that appeared on the bridge and then got shot by Shelby on the cube? Or am I just seeing things? :-D

Brandon

Can we just stop and appreciate that George never learned about Locutus, not even through cultural osmosis? I was watching the combined version of the two-parter and had to immediately hit stop after Riker says, "Fire!" because the scene just keeps going. 😆

FranciscoGios

Im just assuming she plans ahead of her foes.

Jean-Dominic Lapointe

I can’t wait for you to get to my favorite TNG movie (not generations, the other one, I don’t want to say the title), but it’s SOOOO far away in the release order 😭 I wanted to start Fallout Season 2 but now I’ll wait next Wednesday to watch it with you

SnabbKassa

the Borg gave Picard a nice black corset with a Batman sixpack

Chris Kelley

Thank you. I appreciate your reply. I’ll give the show a shot.

Donna Castellano

Watch some of Mike on RedLetterMedia's ramblings on the upscale releases of TNG as opposed to the old. He's got frames and frames of stuff. Marks on the floor for actors, black tape covering reflective surfaces, boom mikes visible in frames, etc.

Logan Kerlee

I'm STOKED for Fallout but at the same time - STAR TREK IS SO DAMN COOL and I'm LOVING your guys' reactions to the show!! Ugh!! xD I'm not wanting to wait however long for a return to TNG. :P

Logan Kerlee

hahahahaha, I love your comment! xD

Logan Kerlee

Love your take on the Borg. I'm totally alright with them being a season finale villain sort of thing for that reason. If they were encountered as often as any other race then yeah, they'd become a trivial opponent but if they're used so sparingly they'll keep their mysterious feature intact while being incredibly interesting/terrifying. :)

Logan Kerlee

I was considering beginning that show. :) It's cool that you're a fan of it. Is it something that I should watch beforehand and rewatch with them (as I do with most everything else) or would it be better to go in blind with them (if they happen to watch it?)

Logan Kerlee

hahahahaha, I love your story! xD I've never had anything like that happen with anesthesia before and I'm thankful! lol - I've had numerous major surgeries in my life but for everything after my surgery when I was a preteen I have told them to just knock me out immediately. lol, I don't want to wind up saying anything that I'd regret saying. :P

Logan Kerlee

I'm over here hoping that they one day make it to Voyager! I loved that series so much. :)

Logan Kerlee

lol, yeah - I was subscribed to three different Patreons when the MCU was in full swing with all of their shows. Those days were so much fun! :)

Logan Kerlee

Ohhhhh, man! I'm REALLY looking forward to reactions for Voyager! That was the first Star Trek series that I watched every episode of and I'm totally down to do so again. :)

JoeNotCharles

Her ultimate decisions were right, but she was still wrong to go over Riker's head. She should have told him about the storm and recommended they go early. If he'd said no, THEN he'd be wrong. But he might have assigned more security or techs to go with her, or shuffled his schedule around so he could go early too, and she didn't give him that chance. And when she went over his head to Picard, it's not like he delayed excessively - he only got there a few minutes after her, and he's got other duties before reporting in. He'd only be wrong if he lied to her and wasn't actually planning on bringing the option to the Captain.

JoeNotCharles

I think you should take breaks between seasons of everything, to make it more like it was originally broadcast.

Logan Kerlee

Love the Galaxy Quest reference! :D

Logan Kerlee

I think that's the reason why DS9 didn't super vibe with me. I super enjoy how TNG goes about it all, including episodes like this for special occasions when you know it's an important moment.

JoeNotCharles

There's a big debate over whether Starfleet is a "military" or just a government agency with ranks and guns. Different episodes (and especially movies) have different emphasis. I try not to think about it too hard. But regardless, "up or out" might not apply here. Still it's easy to see from this episode why Riker's bosses wouldn't be happy with him staying on the Enterprise, regardless of how he feels: as he gets more experienced, it's a waste to have him and Picard on the same ship. Some ship out there has a captain who's not as good at his job as Riker would be, and Picard could be mentoring another young officer. Moving Riker would ultimately be good for both ships.

Logan Kerlee

How many episodes is Pluribus? If it's more than 12 I don't know if I'll be in support of this.

Matrim

Yeah, but I think the debate is settled by the fact they have “court martial” and they are an armed force that prosecutes wars. Whatever you want to call them, they’re by definition a military.

Thomas Yanez

The biggest problem, IMO, was that the effect was created before remastering and the ubiquity of digital TVs. The effect sells much better on an old raster TV, as did many of the original effects. Edit : just realized you are talking about in general, not the specific visual George pointed out as looking so bad (love the wrinkles in the bodysuit :) )

Thomas Yanez

Yeah, that doesn't help me, either. *puppy head tilt*

Thomas Yanez

I resubscribed to Jen Murray when I saw she was starting an MCU run. I love watching her do franchises. Her Bond run was fantastic.

Logan Kerlee

I'm looking forward to Voyager! :D

Gerald Walker

I should have said "I had to wait a year" I was 19 and had a bunch of stuff happen that curtailed my tv viewing

erosennin

at least Sopranos is back. If Sopranos AND TNG were off that would be a tragedy.

gfixler

@Logan: I saw it, and it's been a while, but I feel like you could see it first. There's a lot that happens, so you'd probably end up needing to pause and rewind a fair amount to listen to them, and then listen to what the show said. I've also wanted them to watch this show.

gfixler

I've always wondered how anesthesia is handled with, say, spies, or government officials full of state secrets. You wake up, and end up spilling war plans, or the names and locations of embedded agents.

BellaBlue

I def prefer to watch first and only do reactions on a rewatch..I think you would enjoy either way though. If you are a reader you could always read the series first also! Wonderful series of books and very happy w how they adapted for the show

BellaBlue

glad someone else is a fan. Did you happen to read the book series as well?

John Smith

If they had done that, it would've meant padding it out another 30 minutes in order to match the two hour run time of the other Star Trek movies. That might've hurt the overall quality.

John Smith

For those that don't recognize the term (I assume most people), "nutation" is a real term from the physics of 3D motion. It refers to a kind of "rocking" motion in the axis of an already rotating body. That implies the Enterprise's shields are "rotating" in some manner.

John Smith

As someone who's never played a Fallout game (but I've watched others play) - I think season 1 was okay, but not amazing. In particular, I felt like the plot should've made more sense.

John Smith

Ah... yes, I had similar problems when it came to most of season 7 (including the finale).

John Smith

How it would really go: Patrick Stewart: "You are a very silly person, and I'm not going work with you." other actor: "Aha! Anti-thespianism!" Stewart: "Not at all, that's not even a real script!" other actor: "Give me my notes back!" Stewart: "You can collect them at reception, now go away."

John Smith

"I’m fairly certain everyone, including myself, who is saying George should have to wait the three months is just doing so tongue in cheek." Speak for yourself - I want everyone else to suffer as I did. Three months is forever to a nine year old, especially a nine year old who had no idea that cliffhangers were a thing until he saw the words "To Be Continued..." flash onscreen.

John Miller

When this originally aired, we honestly didn't know if Picard would come back. TNG hadn't quite hit its stride yet. And you could easily see Riker takin command. In fact, some people wanted that, because Riker was more like Kirk.

Logan Kerlee

Thank you both! I'll go ahead and begin the show tonight (even though it's 4:45am.. xD lol, anybody have advice for an insomniac?

Logan Kerlee

I've had similar things happen with other shows in the past, it's always mega disappointing when you miss big/dramatic episodes (like most finale episodes tend to be).

Superpotroast

As someone who enjoyed the original 2 Fallout games and New Vegas, and yet increasingly annoyed by Bathesda's handling of the IP..I can't stand the Fallout show which is, imo, an even more dumbed down and retconned version of the lore..So, glad other people can enjoy it but it's a complete dumpster fire of a show (much like most major modern adaptations nowadays).. Will be glad when Star Trek is back..

Logan Kerlee

Perhaps not, but it's a good bit of fun. :)

Logan Kerlee

9 is nothing! I'm totally cool with a break for that. :)

Logan Kerlee

Agreed! Though - the film First Contact does focus on them and nothing is taken away and they remain my favorite scary bad guy/race in the show/universe of Star Trek.

makaveliaton

Agreed Voyager was awesome as well . Janeway was a great captain

Plaid Hills

Can Simone share a link for the Etsy shop? I've tried to find it but have been unsuccessful.

Robert Durant

I still remember the day this cliffhanger episode came on and having the episode end with that “to be continued” with Riker giving the command to fire was a real gut punch to me and a lot of fans. Then to wait all summer for the show to come back in September, that was the longest summer of my life.

Andrew Hogan

Is anybody else having an issue with not being able to play these vids on Patreon anymore. Just wondering if it’s an issue on my end because I don’t see it mentioned anywhere else.

Cinebinge

hi Andrew, we have stopped posting the unedited videos on Patreon due to Patreon lacking any support in protecting our content from being data scraped by 3rd party sites. All of our videos are now on our site Cinebingers.ca which you can access once you verify with your patreon account.

Andrew Hogan

Okay, appreciate the response.

Richard S

What kind of season ending was that? It was too good to end there. ::waaahhh::

Neil

Originally, Patrick Stewart wasn’t eager to sign on to Star Trek TNG. His agent reportedly told him the show would likely be cancelled after a season or two, so he saw it as short-term work rather than a long commitment. By the end of Season 3, Stewart’s original contract was expiring, and it was uncertain if he would return for Season 4. Because of that, the writers crafted the Season 3 finale, so that Captain Picard was assimilated by the Borg — leaving the door open in case Stewart chose not to come back. If he hadn’t returned, the character could potentially have been written out and/or killed off.

Angela D. Mitchell

I was there for this when it aired -- in college, and my roomie was a massive SNG fan, so it was a blast to watch the show with her. She even had a life-size Picard cutout in the hallway. (Yes, it was hot, but it also scared the crap out of me in the middle of the night.) So yeah, we were here for the actual airing -- and it was AMAZING! We were gobsmacked. She may have screamed. And everyone was talking about it the next day. (In real life! Not on the Internet!) I will never forget the awful thrill I felt when Picard stood before them and announced that he was "Locutus of Borg" and that "resistance is futile." I loved that it was Shelby who could not bear to take the hard road. That it was Riker being strong and ending on, "Fire!" Because we already knew that Riker will absolutely go to the edge if he has to. It was such a satisfying character moment. So awesome. Good times! I can't wait for your reactions to s4 premiere. (It will be fun to revisit since it's been, oh my God, so many decades...) The actress who played LCDR Shelby is Elizabeth Dennehy, actor Brian Dennehy's daughter. I always like seeing her and thought she did a good job here with a difficult character. PS -- Simone, someone with a shop called "Locutest" is the best Etsy store name I've ever heard.