Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Go to this site: Cinebingers.ca for the unedited versions of all our content.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/ODhByziMT7 👈 for the full reaction where you do not need your own copy.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/vrnjKUUJc1 👈for the full reaction where you need your own copy.

If you are on a phone/tablet, hold down the link above and press "open in browser", or go straight to Cinebingers.ca on your browser app.

Files

Comments

ChiefKC

Happy Star Trek Day. May your Inner Light shine bright!

Robert Cooper

Aah, the end of the best season. Also, I think the old robot thing actually started with Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy. Marvin was 2.5 times the total lifespan of the universe at the end of those IIRC. Also, the San Francisco 49ers are a football team. The name is what people called people who moved to Northern California for the gold rush of 1849.

djKENTO

Hey George and Simone, the first season of Star Trek Deep Space 9 runs side by side with TNG starting on Episode 11 of season 6.. Some stations would air them together one after the other, others split them across two nights, but they aired together. So when you get to season 6, episode 11 and it ends, that's when you start up DS9 Season 1 episode 1. During TNG season 7, they staggered their premieres by one week. So it's TNG 7-1 then TNG 7-2 and then DS9 2-1 and then TNG 7-3 and DS9 2-2 BUT I think we'd all be fine if you didn't stagger then and just did 7-1 and 2-1. There's no reason at that point to really stagger them that way other than to not double up on premieres and get bumps in viewers 2 weeks in a row...

JakeyShakeyBakeyBoy

So “The Inner Light” at long last… No surprise it’s a cast fave as it’s one of the finest stories of television ever. On top of what Picard’s been through, having to carry the pain of losing a lifetime of memories as a family man that he’d never imagined for himself, only able to keep it alive through a beautiful melody hits like a truck. How Mr Stewart clutches that flute without a word is a very powerful to show it! When you compare this to how hymns and chants from 1000 years ago are kept alive now in our culture, having music as sometimes the only window into the distant past is a consolation and true gift. Um… back on topic lol: it’s very thought-provoking, superbly written and it’s the main episode of TNG that personally has gotten better every year since seeing it as a teen (next to Measure of a Man that is). Happy that George has been able to experience it with Simone… and the rest of us ol’ patrons too eventually haha 😎🤙🏻 Also that flute melody is a killer Key of D Major learning exercise 🪈🎉

Captain Kermit

Next Star Trek day we need to arrange a specific time where we all run into a business and start yelling frantically, "Computer end program! COMPUTER END PROGRAM!"

Will Sofer

George, the actor who plays Batai is Richard Riehle, who you’ve actually seen multiple times before. A notable example is as the “Jump to Conclusions” guy, Tom, in Office Space.

dudewheresmycar

In addition to the above, and because I've yet to see it mentioned, I think everyone should be made aware that there is no remaster of DS9. Paramount lost money on the TNG remaster so didn't continue with a DS9 remaster. So if George and Simone do react to DS9 both they and everyone else should be aware that visually it's going to look a little rough compared to TNG.

Michael Daw

Pretty excellent episode, that Inner Light. Never really tire of it. I'm a pretty big fan of Time's Arrow too. Good end to the season.

Nick Marten

How much soma did you take? 😵‍💫

Pearl Jam

Young Batai in The Inner Light is played by Patrick Stewart’s actual son, Daniel Stewart! Definitely a fan favorite episode!!!

Mike W

The Inner Light is so good. I love all the big, action episodes, but the quiet, thoughtful nature of this one has stuck with me since seeing it all those years ago.

Matt O'Keefe

I do not notice it being that bad myself.

Mike W

Goodbye season 5 hello season 6. Season 6 has got some really good episodes.

Tinfoilnation

Also more trivia: Batai's namesake, Kamin's son... is Daniel Stewart, Patrick Stewart's son.

Tinfoilnation

George the reason Batai was so familiar to you is you saw him in Glory just a couple-three weeks ago. He was the quartermaster that wouldn't give with the shoes and uniforms.

Darcy Smith

I swear I get more and more emotional every time I watch The Inner Light. What a perfect science fiction story. A nice little what-if idea encapsulated in wonderful characters.

Mastervodo

I really think you should celebrate this momentous milestone by releasing Songs of Cinebinge IV: The Undiscovered Country.

Mastervodo

Not including the remaining ST:TNG Episodes left to watch (which will still take about 6 months) and not including the Star Trek movies, If y'all watch DS9, Voyager, Enterprise, Lower Decks, Strange New Worlds, Discovery, and Picard, that's a total of 685 episodes, which would take right about 342 weeks, or about 6.5 years.

Opti_Frog

A bit of trivia regarding The Inner Light: Picard's Ressikan flute (which is a prop and can't actually be played) was sold in a Propstore auction in 2021 alongside its custom storage box and an episode script for $237,000. The episode also won a Hugo Award for Best Dramatic Presentation.

Mike W

I'd forgotten about the TNG movies, really like the first 2. Wonder if the new movies will get watched, not a huge fan of those personally.

Brandon

1848 was when the California Gold Rush began. The peak year for gold miners and prospectors traveling there in search of fortune was 1849, though. So the thousands that traveled there were nicknamed 49ers.

Jeffrey Mitchell

First, regarding The Inner Light, I may not be able to watch that one any more. I was nearly sobbing by the mid point. Gets worse every time I watch it. Well done keeping it together Simone! Now, about Time's Arrow. George, why would Picard or the others remember what happens in the past before they time travel? The events may have already happened, but not from their perspective. When Picard was talking to Guinan, she knew what happened because it was both in the past and in her past. But for Picard it was in "the past", but not his past. He didn't travel back in time until the end of the episode, so whatever happened in "the past" is still in his future. Great reactions as always! Looking forward to several more years of Star Trek Day!

Gryff

I would have loved to see Inner Light with a humanized Data as the lead in the alternate life.

Mastervodo

I want a cat that sits on my lap and does purrs and lovey head rubs on my microphone. I would need to get a microphone. And a cat.

Bruce Woodcock (edited)

Comment edits

2026-10-29 20:00 George and Simone, unfortunately TNG and DS9 do overlap, and DS9 and Voyager also overlap a little, so watching an entire show before switching to the other is not advisable. You have two options: 1. Watch every episode in air date order. This means that for many weeks, you'll be switching back and forth -- one TNG and one DS9. Other times, though, you'll have multiple of one show or another in a row. This is probably the best way to watch Trek, but it's a lot of back and forth. 2. If you want to minimize switching between shows as much as possible, I DO have a watch order I prepared for my friend that only switches between shows when needed. In other words, watch all of one show until there's a crossover point, then catch up on the other show to the crossover point. Let me know if you're interested in that. You need to decide after S6E11 of TNG if you're going to start switching between them or not.
2026-09-02 15:00

Robert Gendron

I was wondering if either would think Picard's son in The Inner Light looked familiar or if Simone would recognize Frederick La Rouque. The first being Patrick Stewart's actual son, and the second being more usually covered in Cardassian makeup as Dukat.

s0rd3z

Inner Light ❤️

Thall

There is a LOT of Star Trek. The list diminishes heavily if you factor in quality. I'd not even include Strange new Worlds into that list then, but yea. A lot of shows that are Star-Trek-like, not a lot of Star Trek. Edit: Also I'd say there are only two people in all the Star Trek whose heads has been fucked with more than Picards, lol. One we know already, but I'll leave out any hint who.

Joel

The Inner Light - Quite possibly the best pure character episode in all of Star Trek

Alan Pownall

Even if Data doesn't have an emotional reaction to his death it isn't weird that the people who love him do. Riker is just venting about something that he finds very upsetting.

Life in the cave of Garanoga

The actor you recognized is from The Man From earth. He was the psych professor. I'm telling you George, you guys should do The Man From Earth on the channel so Simone can see it. Plus like half the cast are Star Trek alums lol. I have heard that movie is rough for copyrights though so maybe you just can't anyways. But God I love that damn movie.

Mike FromOz

He was also an officer in "Glory" who was dismissive of the 54th, but not the guy who was holding back the goods specifically.

REDR58

Quartermaster. See above.

Curaitis

Inner Light is up there with others like "The Visitor", "In the pale Moonlight" (both DS9) or "The Measure of a Man". Sadly newer Star Trek was lightyears behind to everything the old shows achieved.

James III

The premise of "The Inner Light" is strongly reminiscent of a series of books written by Stephen R Donaldson "The Chronicles of Thomas Covenant the Unbeliever". It is about a man in the "real world" who happens to be a leper and suddenly finds himself in an alternate world of great beauty in a struggle with ultimate evil. Decades pass in that world while only hours or days pass in his native world. The first in the series, "Lord Foul's Bane" was published in 1977.

Cartoons ReAct

49ers are named after the prospectors who went for the Gold Rush in 1849

REDR58

The Inner Light Simone, I have to say I really enjoyed watching the recognition that flashed over your face when the episode started with the probe zapping Picard! It was all a dream! One of the most famous in US TV history was probably the series “Dallas” when the entire 9th season was revealed to be a dream...

Jeff Jake

Episode 25 is one of the best of TNG!

Naj

He was also the 'Jump To Conclusions' mat guy in Office Space.

Life in the cave of Garanoga

I wanna to say the next Film needs to be watched at the right time also, but I can't remember if there was anything important that makes any difference. Other than the obvious.

TechJJ

Just starting to watch this reaction, and already loved Simone's reaction the minute she remembers this episode!! Well, she said she can't wait/look forward to rewatch DS9 and Voyager, and then (at least) Lower Deck and SNW. I therefore assume ST:Discovery since that spawned ST:SNW, and of source ST:Picard (after Voyager). Of course I hope they watch ST:Enterprise (my top favorites along with Voyager). Now I will budget 7-10 years worth of membership!

Mike FromOz

Dangit, I didn't reload the page and missed your answer 😅

Michael Duncan

Have to try to boost this. Love you guys and your Trek reactions, I joined Patreon just for that, and while I understand that there are no direct connections that require viewing concurrently, I believe that you miss a certain flavor if you do not watch them as they were intended to be watched at the time. Plus, I think having 1 episode of TNG and one episode of DS9 every week will stretch out the remaining TNG episodes while also keeping things a little more fresh for you. Fingers crossed.

The Real Andrew Kim

Being a Bay Area native we get taught alot about the California Gold Rush with 1849 being its peak where thousands of people flocked to California trying to make it big, thus these migrants were called Forty-Niners(49ers) and San Francisco was the "Golden Gate" and first stopping point for migrants to the gold rush. And yes our NFL Football team is the Five time championship winning 49ers as reference to our historic past.

Michael Duncan

Well they're not technically in canon with these series so I don't think it would be necessary.

Life in the cave of Garanoga

Oh the end conversation reminds me of a movie reccomendation. "The History of Time Travel" (2014) It's a Docu-Fiction Sci-Fi movie. It's low budget but is a wild ride that was really well done. In my opinion it and "Predestination" are two of the best time travel movies in the last 10-20 years. Both great time rides.

Captain Kermit

HOLY SH!T I've rewatched Times Arrow atleast 100 t8mes, and, I believe, this is my first time realizing that the main poker guy is Marc Alaimo! I've recognized him easily in his other guest roles. I just never recognized him in this one.

Mike FromOz

Agreed, I would like for them to follow this method as well. It will help bridge the gap between TNG and DS9. Eases us into it pretty much.

REDR58

We are going to see him again real soon.

Captain Kermit

I know and remember that guest role.

punterjoe

I think, like Ellison's "City on the edge of forever" the story is not inherently a Trek story and would work just as effectively in a non-trek framing. Still, being a TNG episodes in no way hampers the story, and it does benefit by being seen by TNG's vast audience and having Sir Patrick Stewart in the lead. He has the chops to make a good story downright unforgettable. I've been counting down to this episode for weeks. 😁

punterjoe

I don't want to spoil - or even telegraph anything, but we learn more about Guinan in future episodes - and even when they get to the TNG movies. I don't know if the writers had Guinan figured out from the start, or if her character evolved over time, but there are more Guinan revelations to come - even if some have been hinted at as far back as "Q who" and "Yesterday's Enterprise" years ago. Whoopi landed one of the most intriguing roles in the Trek universe.

Gareth Hackney

If Data lived forever, "Making friends and watching them die then making more." would he eventually see biologicals as we see cats and dogs?

David N

With some people the universe just seems to give with both hands.

James W.

Guinan as a timelord is funny but she went through time in a linear fashion as opposed to Dr. Who being able to jump around in the Tardis; like she has no real powers. However, I do like the parallels between Guinan and the Doctor. One of the few remaining of their species, which was nearly eradicated by space-faring, living robots, spending time among shorter lived species, hoping to get some new experiences or impart some wisdom. That would make Picard her companion.

Runes N Raccoons

I can't help but cry every time I watch the final scene with Picard playing the flute. Without saying a word, you feel the loss of a previous life.

Runes N Raccoons

HE'S the "jump to conclusions" guy?! The wonders of costuming and makeup!

Brandon

IMO the 2-3 times DS9 and TNG cross over aren't that big of a deal. They aren't major event storylines like the Arrow-verse, for example, where you had to watch an episode of The Flash, then Arrow, then Legends of Tomorrow in order to see the whole story unfold. When DS9 characters appear on TNG, it's more like very minor connective tissue between the two shows. They basically functions as standard guest star/supporting characters in a one-off capacity. Ultimately, I'm fine with however they choose to watch.

gfixler

You skipped a big part of it. it was first put up at a Christie's Paramount Archive sale in 2006, estimated to fetch $300. I remember the hoopla around it back then, and being amazed when it actually went for $40,000. When it went back up in 2021, a lot of us were wondering if the market was still there, and if it would fetch as much this time around, and then it went for that staggering number, nearly 6x the original sale price. Patrick Stewart has a funny clip online somewhere where they asked him what he thought after the first auction, and he said "It doesn't even play!" it was just a prop. It inspired me last year to buy the same style of flute actually used to record the music, and learn to play the song, though pretty crappily.

gfixler

Inner Light is pretty widely regarded as the best, or one of the top episodes of TNG, so it's probably all downhill from here 😆 In 1993, it won the prestigious Hugo Award for Best Dramatic Presentation, a rare feat for a television episode at the time. Patrick Stewart has stated it's his favorite episode.

p0sthum4n

Funny little nitpick that I've always had about The Inner Light is that the planet is named Kataan in the Federation star charts even though the civilization that named it that went extinct centuries before the Federation existed.

Guts

Season 6 is the best season imo, followed closely by season 4.

gfixler

I didn't notice it until this viewing, but when Picard plays the flute at the end, the camera circles him, and stays on him playing toward the couch and table, with little spotlights on each, making their emptiness stand out in the darkness. As a kid, I was sad about the loss of the people, and that whole world, but as an adult, it really stands out to me that he just lost his whole family.

gfixler

I'm here for this.

gfixler

The inner Light Suite is such a beautiful piece of music. Here it is, played by the Czech National Symphony Orchestra: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PciJcCXczUw That's Jay Chattaway's YouTube channel. He composed The Inner Light Suite, as well as other music for TNG, DS9, Voyager, and Enterprise.

REDR58

No problem, I do it all the time myself!

Revann117

Cant wait to get to the TNG movies

Angela's invisible airfryer (corey)

Yo I just looked ahead to some season 6 episodes, and there are some direct main characters (actual characters, not just the actors) from DS9. Maybe doing season 1 of DS9 between seasons 5 and 6 of TNG is the way to go after all.

REDR58

Time's Arrow Part 1 The watch inscription says: "To S.L.C. With Love 30 November 1889." Notice there is no name of the person who had it inscribed... Jerry Hardin, who plays Samuel Clemens / Mark Twain should be *very* familiar to fans of the X-Files series, but I will not name his character here in case S&G ever watch the show. Hardin went to play Mark Twain in his own one man show, "Mark Twain: On Man and His World" for many years. We previously saw Hardin as "Radue" in the Season 1, episode 17 of TNG, "When the Bough Breaks": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KeAGj-y0V9k The 49er was played by Jack Murdock who you saw as the lawyer reading the will in "Rain Man": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dODfA5kyeyM $1 US in 1893 is worth about $37 today or about $51 Canadian. An "oyster pirate" is just an oyster thief/poacher.

Guts

The actor playing Picard's son is actually Stewart's son. And don't worry George, "Inner Light" is just a part 1 to an even better episode, at least to me it is, although according to IMDB, people disagree with me on this. I said the same thing about "Best of Both Worlds" being a setup for the great episode that is "Family".

Lessiarty

George, a "49er" is someone who went to San Francisco -- or ended up there -- because of the Gold Rush of 1849. That's when SF suddenly went from a half-mule little town to the beginning of what it is today. "49er" distinguishes a "real" San Franciscan from all the Johnny-come-latelies. I happen to live near Fire Station No. 5, and in some ways the neighborhood hasn't changed at all.

Lessiarty

The millennial equivalent of "Beam me up, Scotty."

Guts

Regarding this two-parter, it is one of the weaker ones imo, although I like part 1. Also Picard did not remember because he literally hadn't traveled to the past yet. Guinan met future Picard.

Daniel Lanctot

Fun Fact: While we have no recordings of Samuel Clemens (Mark Twain)’s voice and speech pattern, a contemporary of his did, years after his death, make voice impersonations of him which were recorded and while the performance of Jerry Hardin (the actor playing Twain here) may seem strangely idiosyncratic, it is actually based on the recording of that impersonation and therefore is most likely very close to what the true Mark Twain sounded like in real life!

parker469a

The saddest thing is Picard can never go home ever again now. He can never see any of the people he loved most in his life.

SnabbKassa

George recognized Mark Twain, but didn't know that Twain was just his pen name, not his real name.

Ken

The Measure of a Man is an absolutely wonderful episode, and The Inner Light clocks in 100 times better. My favorite episode for sure, with Measure of a Man as my 2nd. My close 3rd fav has yet to come but I will refrain from spoilers.

Monica Alarcon

Guinan a TimeLord??? We'll have to ask Pelia...

Drew Acheson

No one asked, but Inner Light is my favorite episode of this show.

REDR58

Yes, I saw that. Incidentally, for those who don't know, the name "Mark Twain" has its origins in measurement: * * * * * Why is Samuel Langhorne Clemens known as Mark Twain? He adopted the pen name in early 1863 when he was a newspaperman in Nevada. It referred to his steamboating days, when the measure of the depth of the water was expressed with a crewman’s cry “mark twain!,” meaning two fathoms, or 12 feet. https://marktwainhouse.org/about/mark-twain/frequently-asked-questions/#1 * * * * * The specific reason Clemens used the name has at least 2 stories behind it, however: * * * * * Clemens had become widely known in Virginia City — if not necessarily widely liked — by the time the pseudonym Mark Twain first appeared in the Enterprise on February 3, 1863. A decade later, Clemens claimed he’d appropriated his by-then-famous nom de plume from a staid Mississippi riverboat captain. However, according to more convincing Virginia City legend, Clemens acquired the nickname before it appeared in print, derived from his habit of striding into the Old Corner Saloon and calling out to the barkeep to “Mark Twain!” a phrase Mississippi river boatmen sang out with their craft in two fathoms of water, but that in Virginia City meant bring two blasts of whisky to Sam Clemens and make two chalk marks against his account on the back wall of the saloon. https://time.com/5313628/mark-twain-real-name/

REDR58

There are, however, a few brief film clips of Clemens standing and walking alone and then sitting with two women thought to be his daughters, Clara and Jean that were taken in 1909 at his home: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mqaSOw1WhjI There is an excellent documentary about Clemens called "Mark Twain" by Ken Burns from 2002.

xeve

Along the lines of optimal viewing, if possible arrange 2 parters so they're in the same sitting. I know with DS9 they have some arcs which are more than 2 episodes, so it's not possible.

xeve

@punterjoe beyond the built in audience , there is the developed character of Picard, who is career focused with an aversion of children living a second life as a husband, father, and grandfather and loving his family and the experience of having one. It would lose impact,imo, if it were a Twilight Zone episode of the week.

MacGuffinStuff

Dude that lamp story was a creepy pasta? I heard that story from Mr. Ballen, and if I remember correctly he said he'd gotten in contact with the guy who originally posted the story (I don't remember where, maybe Reddit), and the guy claimed it was true and said he was in therapy because the trauma was that severe. I was already wondering about some of the stories I've heard Mr. Ballen tell, he doesn't always go into the sources. Hmm. Now I'm wondering about that story about the Mexican pilot and the alien voice.

xeve

The song "Oh My Darling Clementine" has an introduction which is pretty sad about one such miner. Iirc, the old cartoons leave that part out.

Michael Kemmet

Some famous "It's all a dream" moments. (there will be spoilers, but most of these are 30-40 years old, so...) Dallas - Season 9. Dallas was a huge primetime(evening) soap opera of the '70s-'80s. In the season 8 finale, one of the major characters was unexpectedly killed. In the season 9 finale, the wife of that character wakes up and her husband is calmly taking a shower. It turns out the entire season was her dream and never happened. The real reason for it all was that the actor decided to leave the show for greener pastures that turned out to be not so green. The show was also in decline after almost a decade on the air, so they tried to retcon themselves back to their former glory. The show limped along for a few more seasons, but it never became what it once was. St. Elsewhere A well-regarded medical drama in the '80s, St. Elsewhere's final scene revealed that the entire show had been occuring in the imagination of an autistic boy. The scene is famous for its use of a snowglobe with the show's hospital being inside of it. Newhart Newhart was a sitcom in the 80s(notice a pattern here?) starring comedian/actor Bob Newhart. In it, Bob plays an author that owns a rustic inn in rural Vermont. In the series finale, everything goes crazy with a Japanese businessman showing up out of nowhere, buying up the town, and turning it into a giant golf course. Things get stranger and stranger until Bob is knocked out. He then wakes up in bed next to his wife, who is now the wife from Bob Newhart's previous sitcom, The Bob Newhart Show. This now means the entire Newhart series was actually a dream from one night of The Bob Newhart Show. Since both shows were comedies that would often get silly, this is actually regarded as one of the best series finales of all time.

Christopher Johnson

Been waiting for this episode for so long! One that sticks with me forever. I want to believe it introduced the VR game ROY in rick and morty. It's a concept that I think about often.

MacGuffinStuff

The '49ers, are an NFL Foozball team from San Francisco, their mascot is a '49er gold miner from the 1849 California Gold Rush. In 1848, California officially became part of the US after being sold very cheaply by the recently independent, newly formed Mexican government to the US after being invaded and a lie of a war started in Texas (Abraham Lincoln, a new representative, was the only NO vote on the clearly illegal war, but...?). A year later they found a bunch of gold in Northern California rivers and people from all over the country and the world came to California in a hurry. Including the Chinese immigrants who built China town and later the railroads. And California is still called the Golden State. Some people think it's the Sunshine State, that's Florida, which is Bizarro California, as weird as California is, Florida always out weirds us.

Simone's Coconut Squire

If I remember correctly, this role actually led to the actor doing an entire one-man-show as Mark Twain that ended up being very successfull.

MacGuffinStuff

I always assume Egg, from Big Trouble In Little China, that he came to California in that 1849 Gold Rush. I mean he had infrastructure, tunnel access, bus routes, I bet he invented or engineered the Trolley cars in San Francisco.

The Real Andrew Kim

I really hope they stagger the seasons, I can think of at least 1 very iconic future episode which would have more meaning if we knew more about the cardassians....how many lights are there again? 😜

TalynOne

I think George will end up liking DS9 a little more than Simone did, it's more his style.

The Real Andrew Kim

One of my favorite line readings is when Data is explaining the difference between him and Lore is that Lore is a Type-L while Data is a Type-R and Picard responds, "TYPE-R!!!" with such enthusiasim. Being a car guy, this confirms 2 things, Data is the racing Type-R model while Lore is the douchy "Luxury" or "Limited" Type-L model which I find so fitting 😂

Nabikon

One of the recent seasons of Futurama has one of my favorite episodes, All the Way Down

That’s Not Acting

Picard wasn't aware that he and Guinen had met in the past because he had not yet gone to the past. He would not have remembered them meeting in the past when he hadn't yet traveled there. Guinin remembered because it IS her past. She met Picard 500 years in the past on Earth. My assumption about her saying they'd never meet if he didn't go, is that if he had not gone and she had not met him all those years ago then whenever she had occasion to come across him in the future, when HE remembers meeting her for the first time, she may have simply passed him by. But because she remembered him from all those years ago, upon seeing his face or hearing his name she would have gone out of her way to put herself in his path or introduce herself.

Carlos

In my opinion, The Inner Light is the single best episode of Star Trek TNG. It's also the best episode of any Trek. And it may well be among the best episodes of any television series, ever. I love the story. It rips my guts out every time I watch it: when he tells his daughter to "Seize the time, Maribor. Live now! Make now always the most precious time. Now will never come again!". When his wife passes. When the truth about the probe is revealed. And when he clutches the flute.

Z Simons

Inner Light is one of my favorite episodes of TV ever. I've also been counting down.

Simon Pegged Me

"The Inner Light" is my second favorite Next Gen episode because of moments like the one in the final scene where Picard takes the flute in both hands so tenderly, so lovingly that you know immediately how precious it is to him. You can tell he knows every millimeter of it by touch even though he has never picked it up before now. And when he puts it to his lips, we know immediately the song he's going to play: "Woke up this morning/ "Bought yourself a gun..." And it's probably because I just watched "Banshees of Inisherin," but when Picard/Kamen first meets Batai and asks him, his best friend, "Who are you?" I died a little. The actor playing Batai, his reaction to the question broke my heart. (I realized that he played the despicable quartermaster in "Glory" who ignores Col. Shaw's request for shoes for black regiment shortly after that.)

The One True Chris

@11:03 George says "This actor looks familiar." Well George, you shouldn't...jump to...any...conclusions. ;)

Cc Decc

Yeah, so like for many people Inner Light is my favorite SNG episode. Its emotional gut punch was only approached a few other times in the series, and those episodes are mostly favorites too (including an upcoming episode going back to that flute theme). So being science nerdish about it is a little misplaced -- the episode succeeds on a human level, as the best and most enduring Trek moments (The needs of the many...) always do. Nonetheless, years ago my astronomy interest led me to look up the physics of novas, and: The star of the Kataan system that went nova 1000 years ago would have had to have been part of a binary system -- all novas are. But the nova itself is a short, intense explosion lasting only a few hours or a day. It wouldn't cause the slow deterioration of the climate on Kataan. Instead the process of the white dwarf acquiring all of the nova material from its fellow star would cause that deterioration, and it takes tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands of years for that to occur, and it's that time period which is completely deadly to any planets in the system as swirling stellar gases strip their atmospheres and boil them long before the final explosion. So at a bare minimum the Kataan people haven't been dead 1000 years, but literally tens of thousands of years. But to make matters more grim, white dwarves that go nova are normally stealing their gases from a red giant companion, meaning that the original star system has already seen their stars turn into red giants -- because for that white dwarf to be a white dwarf it has to have gone through its entire life cycle including its own red giant phase . And so Kataan would likely have been eaten up by one or both red giants. And even if the white dwarf is stealing from a main sequence star, the white dwarf itself still went red giant long ago, and swallowed up its planets and its fellow star, eventually resulting in an explosion that created a nebulae. All of which makes the survival of Kataan extraordinarily difficult and could perhaps have pushed that probe's origin back billions of years. Well engineered little thing for a race no more advanced than modern humans.

Lintrinsic

The 49ers are a football team. But they're named after the many prospecters that headed to California in the 1849 gold rush.

Superpotroast

Inner Light is a top 5 episode for me..

Eric Wilson

So Samuel Clemens is Mark Twain. I just typed that and you caught it. Lol. Oh well, the bus boy is Jack London.

Peter K

Adding to the suggestion to stagger TNG and DS9, I would take it a step further. When TNG is over, start staggering Voyager with DS9.

Robert Mendoza

The Inner Light: That probe gave Captain a gift and trauma all in one. The gift of a family which he doesn't have in his real life but now he has to mourn that entire family. Besides grieving their loss he has no one to share memories of them. One of the comforts when grieving a loved one is talking to other people who remember them as well. No one else remembers Captain Picards probe family. He can tell people about them but it's not the same. I used to really dislike Time's Arrow but now I don't think it's as bad as I used to think. It really suffers from coming after The Inner Light. What a tough act to follow. The actor who played Mark Twain, Jerry Hardin was in a first season TNG episode. He looks very different without the Mark Twain makeup and hair.

Matthew Corya

Not only one of the best episodes of TNG, one of the best episodes of any TV show!

Michael Kemmet

George: Your instincts about the bellhop are spot on. He's supposed to be another real-life historical figure. In the 1990s, there was a better than even chance the audience would have recognized him in this episode or the next, but I really doubt you or Simone will recognize the name because of your ages and respective backgrounds. In short, he's a late-19th/early 20th Century American adventure writer. His stories were/are often used in middle school English classes as they were/are considered more "approachable" for younger readers. Straightforward language and enough action/adventure to keep middle school boys interested. Several of his stories are set in Alaska and the Yukon, so I suppose it's possible Canadian schools also use his works. I'll leave his full name for the reveal next episode, but his most famous stories include "The Call of the Wild", "White Fang", and "The Sea-Wolf".

dys

The Inner Light is one of my favorite Star Trek episodes, but it did inspire so many copy-cat episodes in scifi shows that came after. I also wonder if we weren't meant to recognize Frère Jacques as the tune Picard was playing, because even as an American I was very familiar with that as a very young child.

Alan Kobb

In case nobody told you, in 1848, deposits of gold were discovered in Northern California. The original finders tried to hide this, but by the next year the secret was out and this drew a huge influx of people who came to try to get lucky digging or "panning" for gold. These people were collectively called 49ers. This also brought a lot of other people and a lot of other businesses to serve all of these people, and causing the area to quickly become populated and many towns spung up overnight. Unfortunately a lot of the gold was quickly gone, and many of the latecomers ended up like thate poor man. 97 years later, a new professional football team was formed in San Francisco and named after those historical 49ers.

Jay

ok. Im not sure why the decision on how to watch TNG and DS9 is being overly complicated. Watch them as they aired. so yes for a bit We would get 1 episode of TNG and 1 episode of DS9 per week.. That's how it SHOULD be done. You guys wanted to experience it like we did in release order. That's how you do it.

Tall Paul

George has brought shame on his ancestors by not responding to Simone's question about the earliest use of the "it was only a dream" trope with "Once, Zhuang Zhou dreamed he was a butterfly". Like many others have said The Inner Light is my absolute favourite Star Trek episode. Reminiscing about the first time I saw it decades ago give it depth.

This Justin

A show that would also take forever, but I’d love to see you two react to, is MASH*. It’s still one of the greatest sitcoms ever on TV, yet it also had some incredibly serious moments because it takes place during the Korean War.

This Justin

The last season of Roseanne ended up being all a dream.

This Justin

The Guinan and Picard meeting is basically the same as *Back to the Future*. Picard remembers the first time he met Guinan, but this two-part episode shows us the first time Guinan meets Picard. Just like *Back to the Future*, where we see the first time Doc meets Marty, but not the first time Marty meets Doc.

Angela D. Mitchell

I enjoyed this. It didn't knock me out, but it had some nice moments, and I always love seeing Guinan and learning more about her. Whoopi Goldberg plays her with such a lovely, understated knowing calmness. Every time she's onscreen, I find myself smiling or relaxing, because Guinan just feels like such a kind, safe, and benevolent presence. Seeing Data in the past was a lot of fun, especially since the writers wisely let him fit in quickly, so we didn't spend the whole episode with people noticing, "Hey, that guy looks slightly metallic!" I'd much rather get to the real story, and we did. I also really liked the bellboy, who reminded me of a similar character in "Andor" season 2, just a bit. Without any season 6 knowledge or memory, I already worry of course that he's doomed! Riker is very consistently written -- he always reacts to sad situations or those that deal with the potential deaths of his friends with anger. He's done it several times now. It's frustrating sometimes in terms of his character, where I just want him to take a deep breath and listen -- but it also feels very realistic to me, and I love that.

Angzarr

Seeing as Data "comes from France", this reminds me that the "Coneheads" movie would be a fun one to react to.