Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Go to this site: Cinebingers.ca for the unedited versions of all our content.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/rErGlyMTR5 👈 for the full reaction where you do not need your own copy. (Subbed - The version we recorded in)

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/gZtELnSQK1 👈 for the full reaction where you do not need your own copy.(Dubbed Version)

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/hEJvOLqnx9 👈for the full reaction where you need your own copy.

If you are on a phone/tablet, hold down the link above and press "open in browser", or go straight to Cinebingers.ca on your browser app.

Episode 9 YT Edit: https://youtu.be/2MnNuUZqjLU

Episode 10 YT Edit: https://youtu.be/7EqQiKwKOnw

Episode 11 YT Edit: https://youtu.be/atV3MezlM84

Files

Comments

Yari

Rewatching the scene with Eren trying to control Rod's Titan is so funny. Eren is so close yet so far to succeeding. Also the reason there was this weird shot at the end of the scene is because there's a running gag about the height of Levi. So Eren realized shouting "tiny old man" might have struck a nerve. Regarding Reiss' transformation, what he licked is assumed to be just Titan spinal fluid, the kind of which turns people into titans. The reason he's so big is never really explained, but considering the fact that he wasn't chosen as a Founding Titan inheritor (it went to his brother then his daughter), and the fact that he said that he "mustn't become a Titan" might imply that he and his family know what kind of Titan he would turn into (the one we see right now) and thus it would be particularily dangerous for him to turn into a Titan, which is needed for the inheritance ritual. (They need to first turn into a mindless Titan, which then eats the Founding Titan holder, getting its power and reverting back to human). It's also possible that the act of licking instead of injecting has something to do with it, otherwise the royal family would likely just gulp that spinal fluid down instead of injecting it.

Adam Vialpando

I always assumed it was the latter. I imagine some trial and error was involved.

David

next 2 week will be crazy!!

Jose Robles

not sure if is a spoiler and dont remember if is going to be talk about it later, but the main reason to the Reisse family not be on the throne was just tactics, they put a fake king while they ruled over the shadows.

eZTarg8

I kept going back and forth on Erwin's dad possibly being the beast titan lmao, and kept coming back to him not recognising odm gear, then thinking maybe memory loss or something explained it. There's a few times the show seems to deliberately muddy things that way with character designs lol. Cheers for the reaction

Yari

Possible but SPOILERS We know eventually that there's other ways of turning people into titans, one of which involving actually gulping down spinal fluid mixed with another liquid. So it makes me think that there's something wrong with Rod Reiss himself. That still doesn't explain why the Royal family inject themselves for the ritual instead of using other methods, though.

OddThomas

How many times per episode does someone shout "Eren!"? Over the whole series it's probably 1000

Reed James

In the first episode, you muted the sound during Rod Reiss POV befor the opening started. Sub version no sync.

Saifu

It's probably too late but someone needs to let them know to not skip the credits in an upcoming episode...

Yari

Personally my reasoning was Simone's. When the Reiss lost the Founding Titan, they also lost their way of safekeeping their position, and they eventually got replaced, probably with some sort of deal (to avoid an internal power struggle/war) since they seem to have retained some influence in the council in charge. Remember that the night they lost the power (or a couple of nights after), the Interior Police went to get rid of Historia and her mother, while Rod was trying to save them. If he was the one truly in charge, that wouldn't have happened.

Filip Telążka

I gotta finish reading Stormlight Archive, cause one day Simone's going to spoil it for me :D

K

They mentioned it during this so I think they’ll be watching it.

Reed James

The Reiss family was never overthrown, they are just controlling things from the shadows.

Yari

That's not true. The Interior Police went to get rid of Historia and her mother while Rod was trying to keep them safe. Why would that happen if Rod was the one in charge ? There was no reason for the Assembly of nobles to stay loyal to the Royal family if they lost the Founding Titan power. Remember that most of those nobles are absolutely selfish and only care about their own power and interests. The loss of the Founding Titan created a power vacuum that was filled by the nobles who covertly transformed the monarchy into an oligarchy, and installed a false King as a puppet. Also according to the manga (allegedly, I haven't read it), Rod tried to hide the death of his family to the Assembly of nobles (which makes a lot of sense as I've discussed above) and tried to flee with Historia and her mother. But the nobles had already sent the Interior Police to kill them, that's when Rod managed to convince the Interior Police to let Historia go, as she's just a clueless child that could just be exiled under a new name. Of course Rod saw this as a future opportunity to get the power of the Founding Titan back through Historia and restore his family on the throne. And he eventually revealed the truth to the Assembly (after the battle of Trost apparently), hence why he still retained some influence in the Assembly, because he had the one key that would allow the Wall Kingdom to fight back against the invaders, which is why the Assembly of nobles agreed to his plan of capturing Eren and feeding him to Historia, otherwise they would not have any means of defeating the invaders themselves and would eventually lose everything.

Charlie G

Crazy how Bystander could easily be the most popular episode this season if it weren’t for the absolute even more craziness of like 5 other episodes

Degenerick

sometimes i just wish they would focus more on the reading than on the commentating. show: the only ones worked up are the new recruits simone: yeah where were you guys at? (talking about floch and marlo literally recruits)

parker469a

I was under the impression they haven't sat on the throne in forever if they ever did in the first place. Why attract unnecessary attention to a family that has to do pretty much all of their functions in secret? Why bother sitting on a throne, that somebody needs to be on, just to keep the people who don't know anything's attention. The throne isn't power, it's just a prop.

Carlos

I understand why people like it as a teaser, but it always seems so pointless considering reactors aren't waiting months to watch the second half of the season.

Carlos

Did Will and Jacob get to them too? Lol

Clément

Simone : "I love when things are on purpose"... Then you're in for a treat.

parker469a

For some reason he only syncs it to the Japanese dub which it does match up with perfectly.

Hannah

I always thought that it was because of Historia throwing Rod and breaking his back + not injecting the spinal fluid correctly that he turned out the way he did. That's my head cannon anyways lol

simo

"Eren's titan should have a weapon" Yeah i'm sure he'll need one 😶‍🌫️

Clément

Imagine a titan with, like, a huge hammer or something like that, that would be insane.

Clément

We can't change them now, I just hope they don't miss anything too important during the rest of the story.

Clément

To me, that’s a really "crazy theory" (even though I understand why they might believe it), because it’s made pretty clear to us that he was "silenced" by the Military Police. Sannes clearly implied as much when he was talking to Hange about the various acts of torture he had to commit. But I guess they didn't connect the dots.

Adam Vialpando

@Yari They only lost the founding Titan when the wall broke. And the council members still refer to Rod as the King

Adam Vialpando

But you just pointed it out. The council didn't know about the death of his family until after Trost, so they wouldn't try to overthrow him. They sent Kenny to kill the two because she was a stain. Sure Rod could have ordered them spared, but that would lead to the question of why. Which would lead to them finding out his family died

Jaaahn

no thanks. i dont want to watch 2 people sitting there silently reading. i rather they miss some stuff here and there and keep commentating, thats what i paid for. i dont care if they dont understand everything fully. especially when its something as trivial as what you pointed out.

Jose Robles

I also think so, but before that happened, they did not want to be on public.

Danovan D. Doyle

I would call Red Swan many things, but hopeful it's not

Yari

No, what Rod revealed was the whole thing about the Founding Titan inheritance ritual, and why Historia and Eren had to be captured. The nobles knew about the death of the Royal family by then, it had been 5 whole years between the fall of wall Maria and the battle of Trost, go try to explain where the whole family went since then and why they can't show up anymore. Also why would Rod have to give a reason if he was the true king ? He would simply order to spare them, and that'd be the end of it. They were a stain on the Royal family's honor in the eyes of the Assembly though yes, and they always wanted them dead. But now that they didn't have to follow the Royal family (because they were dead), then they had the perfect opportunity to do it.

Xeco

Since you are about to start season four, you will meet a character name falco which is voiced by Tanjiro's voice actor. Which is a fitting fun fact.

Cinebinge

sorry sorry sorry!! I'll try not to :S

Adam Vialpando

I literally said that. The nobles found out about the death of the royal family 5 years after the fact because of what happened in Trost. And like I said, Rod could have easily ordered his mistress and Historia spared and Kenny would have obeyed. But he would have to reveal that it was because he needed Historia as his heir. So he instead pretended it wasn't of any importance and acted cold. Sure the nobles might have SUSPECTED he was lying and were pushing boundaries, but if someone has godlike power on their side you'll likely wait for actual proof before deposing him. And once they found the Founding Titan again it didn't matter because they needed it and only a Reiss could control it, so it made no sense to overthrow him.

Adam Vialpando

Plus another thing that doesn't work is the part about them looking alike. For most anime I would agree. But Isayama, for all his strengths, is terrible at making distinct looking people. Armin and Historia are practically twins, Eren and Jean have switched multiple times already, pretty sure without her glasses people eould mix up Hange and Sasha. If you go back over the show you'll see tons of characters who look similar enough to others that you could mistake them easily. So them looking similar means nothing to me.

dansoddity

really hoping they avert their eyes to the upcoming op, pretty spoilery

Rainy Days

There absolutely could have been something between Shadis and Carla... but he's, well... a bystander. So he didn't ever make any real move.

Sailingcats420

You guys are very confused on why did the fake king take the throne. The fake king never took the throne, for some reason you guys dont understand that the fake king was installed by the Reiss family, they wanted to rule from the shadows. Rod reiss was still the real king in charge, as we've seen over the seasons, so idk why you got it in your head that the fake king was anything of a real power, the fake king was put there by the reiss family. They never lost control, they've always been the royal family. They wanted to hide their identities. Yall getting hung up on the wrong stuff lol

Yari

No I meant that they found out before. You don't wait 5 years before realizing something is amiss when your royal figure and their relatives hasn't shown up for so long, it doesn't make sense. Also why would Rod need to reveal anything to Kenny at the time ? All Rod had to tell him was to stand down no questions asked, if he truly was in charge that is. Even if a reason was needed, everyone knew that Historia was his daughter and Alma his concubine, so there wasn't a need to give any additional reason. Obviously he wouldn't want them dead because he cares about them. The fact that he let Kenny do it is because Rod didn't have any authority over the Interior Police anymore (and he wanted to keep hiding the death of his family as much as possible of course). In fact, I'm not sure Rod had any real authority to begin with. He was part of the Royal family but he never was the King, he never got the Founding Titan power. Frieda was supposed to be the Queen at the time. Now the question (and where I might have had it wrong) is whether the nobles already knew about the death of the Royal family when they sent the Interior Police to kill Alma and Historia, or if it was just one heck of a coincidence. I find it weird for them to go that route if they didn't know though, they could have faced repercussions from the Royal family for covertly assassinating their relatives, hence why I jumped to the conclusion that they might have known somehow. There's also the possibility that Rod managed to convince the nobles that he inherited the Founding Titan power somehow and so he could remain the de facto King between 845 and 850, before revealing everything (about the death of his family and the inheritance ritual) after the battle of Trost as a plan to safeguard the Wall kingdom. But that's pure conjecture and I honestly have a hard time believing it. Would the nobles really be so easy to fool ? Especially with Kenny on their side, who knows a bit more about the inner workings of the Royal family than they do. He probably knew very well that Rod didn't have the power, the same way he knew Frieda had it just by looking at her eyes.

Gray Matters

Obligatory message to make sure to watch the end credits for the next episode with sound on! (49) (3-12)

Gray Matters

Y'all keep mentioning Erwin's dad, Armin's mom, I think you need to re-watch the Sannes torture scene that Levi and Hange performed in S3 Ep 2

Rory Borcherding

It’s because Rod Riess is not the king, the Founding Titan is.

NthDgree

::SPOILER:: The original name of the royal family is Fritz, not Reiss. The royal family took the name Reiss years and years back as a way to protect the bloodline and rule from the shadows and only the other leaders of the noble families are aware of it. The false kings were put on the throne as Fritzes to keep up the ruse that they were the real rulers. Therefore, the Reiss family was never overthrown, it was a purposely enacted ploy that they pretended they were just another noble family.