Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Go to this site: Cinebingers.ca for the unedited versions of all our content.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/BBho7SKMn9 👈 for the full reaction where you do not need your own copy.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/y4L2KkxWB1 👈for the full reaction where you need your own copy.

If you are on a phone/tablet, hold down the link above and press "open in browser", or go straight to Cinebingers.ca on your browser app.

Files

Comments

Robert Cooper

Jack London wrote Call of the Wild and White Fang and a bunch of other books that kids used to read on the regular. It is a thing I wonder about sometimes. Kids books used to be evergreen. Kids read a lot of the same books for nearly a century, then it stopped.

Mike FromOz

Best time period: 90's. I was still young, music was amazing, and the radio stations I had to listen to played all the quirky off-the-wall stuff, which soon became mainstream. I felt hopeful for the future, as the Berlin wall had come down earlier, and the winds of change seemed to be sweeping everywhere. Worst time period: The 90's. One of the best people I ever went to school with died of Leukemia. He was one of the cool kids, but was genuinely good to everyone. We worked together as security on a massive rock event, and the next year he was dead. It was also the time of the Yugoslavian War, which decimated my ancestral homeland, and lead to many of my extended family having to flee or die. I was just coming into my late teens and adulthood, and it felt like a whole part of myself was stripped away. I was once Yugoslavian, and we had such a great community here in Australia. But the war fractured and broke all of that, and groups that were once so close separated along ethnic and cultural lines, and it never came back together again. I thought I'd have some kind of information about my roots and background to lean on, since I felt so out of place compared to the rest of the Australian population, but it all collapsed. And as such, I've felt adrift as to my identity ever since.

Mike FromOz

Agreed. I read both books in the 80's, and it seemed like there was just a certain group of books everybody just read. I could talk to adults about them, and they knew exactly what I was speaking of.

ChiefKC

Star Trek Day!

Lintrinsic

Happy Star Trek Day, and Happy Belated 60th Star Trek Day for yesterday. 🎉

Thall

Can't have that, have to be consumers that get new books. How else is a corpo supposed to make money?

Matt O'Keefe

Simone and George, Reg's full name should be Wretch Barfly.

Thall

Jack London is a well known writer. His books are fun reads!

Thall

I will never not have "MR PICKERD" stuck in my head. It's so fun to say.

Joel

I love Call of the Wild, I still re-read it occasionally

Neil

The teacake question was from Red Dwarf.

Shaka, When the Walls Fell

The concept of the Time's Arrow was good. The concept of Mark Twain in it, was not so good. can't wait for Episodes 4 and 5 "Relics" and "Schisms". "Relics" especially.

Jamie

Retchinald Barfley

Stephen Morris

Remember after Chain of Command part 2 the first episode on DS9 starts.

Captain Kermit

I don't understand George's frustration with Mark Twain. Yes, he's supposed to be a foil to Data, but he's not wrong. Data does constantly lie to him, Data is from the future, and there is a species trying to destroy 20th century Earth.

John Miller

I loved Mark Twain. And I'm sure him being so prominent was pure fan service to Mark Twain fans, which I am. From every indication, this was a pretty accurate portrayal of the man. He was flamboyant and outspoken. What they didn't show is that "Mark Twain" was Samual Clemens pen name, as well as character he played in public. Basically, he put on a show. I would have actually loved to see more of that.

Matt O'Keefe

The actor(Jerry Hardin) does a good Twain impression(from what I understand) compared to others who have done one including his costar in The Firm (Hal Holbrook).

fforw

I'm really surprised George uses peanut butter for sauces. In addition to all the palm oil not being good for the environment, it also does not taste that good in a dish. Here we can get just ground peanut with a bit of salt. I prefer chunky even for sauces, because I think it keeps the peanut taste better.

John Miller

The casting of Barclay was perfect. Prior to this, Dwight Schultz played Mad Murdock on the A Team. He does such a great job at the neurotic/ crazy person. And his list of video game voices is enormous.

Venusian

George likes TNG more than I thought, but less than I hoped.

Monica Alarcon

Relics is next week!!! It's the one I've been looking forward to the most.... Although Simone probably remembers the surprise in it...

Monica Alarcon

Oh damn. I forgot episode 16 crossovers with Deep Space Nine... So... There goes the continuity...

Venusian

I love Barclay. Don't be mean to him.

Blackbaldrik

"Boy were they optimistic back then." I'm not 100% positive if you were referring to the writers of Star Trek and people back then, or people from Twain's time. But in the case of Star Trek, considering it canonically takes place multiple hundreds of years from now, following a prolonged period of multiple massive wars that ends in an apocalyptic global nuclear race-war that irradiated the planet and killed a massive percentage of the world's population in terrifying hellfire; I'd say their idea of how the future would go has been fairly bang-on so far.

Lessiarty

Hey, remember way back when _that_ was the biggest thing people had to be upset about? When _he_ was the biggest asshole we had to deal with? Magical times.

Joel

Broccoli!!! :-D

DesolationEntertained

In-kind minor spoiler with Simone's Lower Decks comment, *canonically* people react differently to Mark Twain. He is insufferable, pompous, egotistical, and self-indulgent. One is welcome to find him unpleasant. I think the only opinion the man himself would find insulting, would be to call him uninteresting.

Nabikon

I did SoftWave for a tailbone injury and it seems to have helped. Would have liked to have had more sessions, but it's 'spensive

Monica Alarcon

A macroscopic waterbear in Star Trek??? Nah, that's too silly...

The Real Andrew Kim

Being a Bay Area native, Jack London is a local legend. The main commercial waterfront area of Oakland is named Jack London Square after him.

REDR58

Jerry Hardin toured as Mark Twain in a one-man show for many years. I commented on this last week.

The Real Andrew Kim

FYI, the whole earthquake bit is a reference/joke about how this was just a few years before The Great 1906 San Francisco earthquake which was a 7.9 on the richter scale and was one of the most devastating earthquakes (and the resulting fires) to hit a major metropolitan city in modern times.

REDR58

I love Hardin’s Twain here. He was the best part of the episodes as far as I’m concerned.

REDR58

The comment Clemens made about if the Enterprise had encountered Halley’s Comet is a reference to a quote of his: Mark Twain was born on November 30, 1835—two weeks after the perihelion of Halley’s Comet. “I came in with Halley’s Comet,” Mark Twain commented in 1909. “It is coming again next year. The Almighty has said, no doubt, ‘Now there are these two unaccountable freaks; they came in together, they must go out together.’” He died on April 21, 1910—one day after the comet had once again reached its perihelion. https://www.laphamsquarterly.org/future/miscellany/mark-twain-again-follows-halleys-comet

Rob Thompson

Is that the 2nd toaster from Red Dwarf question we've had now? xD

Matt O'Keefe

I wonder if there are any audio recordings of Twain.

Opti_Frog

Oh no. Perhaps i wasn't as original as i thought? 😄

Gryff

Why doesnt this starship have grapplers? I love the grapplers!

Rob Thompson

I just thought it was a beautifully coded way of getting Red Dwarf on the watch list :)

Monica Alarcon

Maybe they can watch at least the pilot before. To avoid spoiling it...

Brandon

A werewolf!

Mikebdrx

You think next weeks episode will end up in Georges favorite TNG moments. lol

Life in the cave of Garanoga

Barclay has aged so well. Looking back it was kind of a big deal they used his character for serious plot lines. It was still the era of the nerdy, allergic, panicky character tropes, and were almost always for comedy to be the butt of jokes. They usually had a big positive part in the story but not like how TNG handles Barclay. As you two mentioned, they take him seriously for the most part. Sure, the comedy is there, but it isn't so much him being the butt of the joke as it is just his awkwardness, so well performed. He's also a great fantasy fulfillment character, all those people out there who know they'd be terrified in these situations but want to believe they could still do it. Barclay gives everyone hope that you can overcome anything if you keep working on yourself and trust yourself.

Andrew

I don’t blame Twain for being skeptical about the perfect society that exists in the 23rd century. More than 100 years after his time and nothing has changed really. Men still achieve power and wealth by standing on the backs of the poor. Where prejudice and intolerance and commonplace and power is an end unto itself.

Jaaahn

you seem to be confusing "being right" with "being enjoyable". those are not the same things. George is clearly talking about him finding the character not enjoyable, regardless of right or wrong.

REDR58

Take your like!

REDR58

I found the Triolic Aliens the least interesting aspect of the Times Arrow episodes and was much interested in Clemens as I am admirer of his work. Once again, though, time travel here only opens up nothing but problems if you analyze it too deeply. As George asked, why didn’t the aliens go even further to the past, before any sort of sophisticated society could possibly cause issues with the Aliens’ plan?

Opti_Frog

I would absolutely love for S&G to get into some classic British sitcoms.

Dan

6x02 is a nice inversion of the usual trope where someone experiences weird stuff and - despite encountering ample weird stuff in the past - everyone else assumes they're crazy. This time Barclay himself assumes he's crazy.

Kevin S

The lack of reaction on the "Jack London" hurt my heart! 😢 but I love you both and know you are always learning. Thanks to you both!

The One True Chris

I'm sure it's not intentional, but when watching Star Trek, George very often has this expression on his face like he can't understand why anyone would like the show.

REDR58

Realm of Fear The USS Yosemite is an Oberth-class vessel, like the vessel see in Star Trek The Search for Spock and various episodes of TNG that have already been watched here. It bothers me greatly that the tricorder holsters look so poorly attached, flopping around like that. Why do they let Barclay just walk away from the first transporter incident when he refuses to go? How does he have a choice in this? Remember McCoy and Dr. Pulaski didn’t like transporters either! There was an entire episode, devoted to how Pulaski had not taken a transporter in a very long time (“Unnatural Selection”). When Barclay arrives on the Yosemite and after he speaks to Geordi, he walks over to a computer console and in some of the darkened panels can be seen reflections of ordinary incandescent lightbulbs inside the light fixtures. How does Troi order him to take a leave of absence but not send him to sickbay immediately? Why do they do experiments with plasma streams inside of engineering with just a force field? Do they not have dedicated science bays for this, well away from engineering? Maybe a cargo or shuttle bay that can be vented to space?

John

There's a meme about this very episode, but I can't paste it here. 😭😭😭

Stephen Morris

t would have been cool if it was Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. You could have had Data having to outwit the author of Sherlock Holmes.

D Gyre

Ooof we don't know of Jack London!!!

MacGuffinStuff

First episode part 2 of Arrow Of Time, it's probably been said about the previous episode but I didn't realize, or possibly just forgot, that this two-parter has to be at least a little inspired by The Voyage Home. They go back to San Francisco, again, timeline shenanigans and near catastrophes ensue, there's humor albeit Voyage Home leaned so well into the comedy, it's still my favorite, just so fun and kind of self aware. Except instead of taking the likeable Jillian the Whale Expert along in the future, they drop off an very annoying portrayal by an otherwise pretty good character actor of Samuel Clemens/Mark Twain (which is a play on words btw, Clemens was a wizard of wordplay and PUNS, and otherwise a pretty smart folksy guy). You guys never ever heard of Jack London? Aw, my heart, not even White Fang? To Build A Fire? Now you're gonna tell me you never read John Steinbeck I bet. I'm just teasing, you read a lot more than I do sad to say. No but "A Connecticut Yankee In King Arthur's Court" had already been published because the reporter at the beginning of this episode was trying to ask him questions while Clemens was sounding senile talking about actual time travellers. Good bit.

Dan

The whole pyjamas-with-no-pockets aesthetic does get in the way of practicality and it always looks odd when the equipment for an away mission is just two things on a belt. But what I noticed was that after sending over the first person via their bridging-two-transporters trick they didn't check in with them to make sure they arrived ok before sending more! To be fair, fairly loose discipline is the usual standard (except when it's occasionally ridiculously strict/harsh as in the court-room episodes). And Troi ordering Barclay to take a leave of absence is a much softer approach (personally and with respect to his service record etc) than relieving him of duty - and sickbay seems to be more for physical ailments than "welfare" issues. TBH if you start to think about how you *would* do things on Enterprise D without the constraints of a limited number of major characters, a limited number of sets, and the requirements for regular tension and peril, a lot of the plots kinda fall apart. A whole detachable/launchable quarantine/science unit/mini-ship would make a lot more sense than a detachable saucer section (or the "Captain's Yacht"). Have away-team personnel who visit not-known-friendly locations live and work in internal quarantine zones for a time afterwards. Have the computer actually report immediately when someone disappears from the ship without leaving via an authorised method rather than waiting until someone asks to tell them that they're not on-board. Have the Battle Bridge be permanently manned (it's not like the Enterprise doesn't have enough people on board). In fact, probably make that the "real" Bridge and have the "official" Bridge be the one dignitaries can visit with fewer security risks. Actually have a couple of escort ships flying in very loose formation so there's some level of help nearby and a ship that can go ahead to investigate something without putting the civilians (including children) on board the Enterprise at the sharp end (and those ships can be much more spartan and have the crews rotate through the Enterprise). And so on.

Dan

I don't know about Canada but in the UK you can get peanut butter that is 100% peanuts with no palm oil or anything else.

Joshua Bloom

I just started the episode and I love that Simone, a Canadian, admits that she gets her news from John Oliver, a British man, who's show is shot in America and talks about world issues!

Patrick - Excelsior

When examining the transporter Obrien mentions checking Heisenberg compensators. This component was introduced here due to a conversation between Gene Roddenberry and Michael Okuda. Micheal is the technical advisor on the show. He mentioned to Roddenberry that the transposrter is physically impossible due to the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle, which states that you cannot simultaneously know both the exact position and momentum of a subatomic particle. He noted that a matter transporter would theoretically need this exact data for every single particle in a human body to beam them safely, making the device seemingly impossible. Michael Okuda invented the fictional Heisenberg compensator to let the audience know future engineers had simply "solved" it.

Guy Gordon

Yeah, I read at least a couple Jack London books in high school.

Will Sofer

Silly and plagiarized.

Will Sofer

Where do you live, out of curiosity? Palm oil isn’t used to make peanut butter in North America. Like, at all. We use natural or hydrogenated vegetable oils, primarily soybean, cottonseed, and rapeseed (though the original 19th century Canadian and American versions didn’t include oil for half a century). The British introduced palm oil in the 1920s since they didn’t grow any of those oil crops in decent quantities, but they could obtain palm oil from the subjugated Asian nations that the British Empire controlled. The European mainland market started following suit in the 1960s, and there’s been strong culturally-ingrained resistance to the idea of using a substitute ever since.

Will Sofer

@Matt O’Keefe. There were. Clemens made multiple audio recordings on wax cylinders with Edison, but none of them survive to the present day. However, contemporary people knew from these recordings and his public appearances what he sounded like; Mark Twain impressions were relatively common. How we really know what he sounded like today though is primarily from a 1934 recording of an impression done by his neighbor, who grew up next to Clemens, and was an accomplished actor (Clemens actually financed his initial career). It’s not a perfect impression, but contemporaries said that it was “very good”. The audio is distorted and hard to hear, but you can make it out. If you’re wondering, this actor (Jerry Hardin) doesn’t actually sound like Clemens. He has the cadence more or less correct, but Twain had a much deeper voice, and it wasn’t grating or discordant in tone like this performance was. The real Samuel Clemens actually sounded more akin to Foghorn Leghorn. The only recording of Clemens that survives today is a short film clip with no audio.

Will Sofer

Well said, and you’re right. It wasn’t just literary classics like London either. Even with children’s books, there was a core corpus that everyone seemed to know, per all age groups. I can probably still bring up The Boxcar Children to other Gen X or Y adults, and most of them would know exactly what I’m talking about.

Trevor S Bright

I'm still on Season 1 and slowly catching up. I kinda hope they alternate between TNG and DS9. Maybe that way things won't get stale like when they took a break from TNG a while back. Coz I do kinda like the characters in DS9 a bit better (I am pretty Quark biased).

Adam Morgan

The descriptions of transporters and how they work are not consistent across Star Trek. They will often do whatever magical nonsense today's writer needs them to do for the plot to happen. However, this and other episodes do suggest that they don't actually disassemble you completely when you transport. People are still conscious, sometimes keep moving or talking, and are actually aware of their surroundings. Instead of disassembly, they might just make you a bit 'looser' but still more or less connected and in one piece.

fforw

Germany, I don't know. All the brands seem to have and most of them are American, but maybe they just use another formula. Anyway it's awful. Mushed peanuts FTW

Simon Pegged Me

I think Simone would like London's most popular novels: Call of the Wild and White Fang. Both are written from the point of view of the animal protagonists, wolf dogs. Don't worry. The novels are better than that sounds. They are a part of the American canon. Reg should have received a medal for his actions. Despite being terrified, Reg let Miles and Geordi suspend him in the beam and even though he knew any big movements could cause them to lose his signal, he reached out to pull a suspended crew member into the beam with him. His actions saved the lives of four crew members. Everyone was ho-hum about it, but he was the finest in StarFleet for a moment. Go Reg! And I'm with Simone and my hero, Dr. "Bones" McCoy. If taking a shuttle is an option, I'm taking the shuttle. Transporters are for inanimate objects and humans and aliens with death wishes, not me. If I wanted to join that group, I'd take up smoking. #FuckThatTransporter

REDR58

Yep, we saw Saavik speaking to Kirk as they transported back to the Enterprise in TWOK.

REDR58

Morn man, myself.

REDR58

"To be fair, fairly loose discipline is the usual standard (except when it's occasionally ridiculously strict/harsh as in the court-room episodes). " That's the thing with TNG, it sometimes plays fast and loose with its rules in comparison to how a real navy and its naval ships (or perhaps a "coast guard" equivalent) operate. I've watched this series perhaps a half-dozen times or more all the way through and love it, but I still enjoy nitpicking. What really drives me nuts (speaking of away missions) is that they don't even wear boots or the minimal of protective gear. They don't seem to carry first aid kits unless a medical tech/Beverly is with them. All your observations are spot on and I really like that idea with the computer immediately reporting someone no longer aboard ship. Heck, even my smart home system knows when my cellphone is outside of its geofenced boundary and my phone lets me know when I leave my earbuds behind (this worked out great recently when I accidentally dropped the charging case outside after parking my car and I was able to track the case down right away.

punterjoe

I think Simone might enjoy some Mark Twain. Maybe his "mega hits" like Tom Sawyer and Huck Finn would be more digestible as audiobooks. I'd also suggest "Innocents Abroad" a rather scathing social satire on the white western (self-described "civilized") world's hoi polloi interacting with the cultures they meet (collide with?) on a voyage across the world.

Michael Daw

I did not know this. What a guy.

Michael Daw

Picard’s upgraded lamps probably saved many lives.

Runes N Raccoons

And if you (George and Simone) don't have time to read one of his longer-form books, he wrote plenty of short stories as well. "To Build a Fire" is a common short story assigned to kids (at least in the US) to demonstrate a "Man vs Nature" narrative.

Runes N Raccoons

And even though Twain is projecting about the Enterprise being conquerors (he jumps right into the accusations without asking clarifying questions first), he's not wrong to be suspicious. In fact, Twain interrogating Troi over the mission of the Enterprise should be appreciated, not scorned. Twain was alive during the concept of "Manifest Destiny", and the fact that he did not approve of that, especially during his time, is a great display of the quality of his character. I'm surprised that George didn't see that, considering that he frequently brings up colonialism (as he is absolutely right to do!)

Runes N Raccoons

And it's even worse now than during his time. The wealth inequality in 2026 USA is greater than it was during the Guilded Age and before the New Deal. Twain would be outraged over what is happening.

Runes N Raccoons

There likely has been a recording of Twain's voice, but if there were, there are no surviving records.

Marcus Hicks

Oh, so you're a waffle man 😆

Spectre Mando

I think the name Simone was looking for at the start of Ep 2 was Retch Barffley 🤮

Spectre Mando

It is a funny coincidence that episode 2 delt with Barclay's medical fears just as Simone talked about her shoulder. Not the same thing, just thought the timing was funny

Jamie

I think it helps that he's batshit in real life

Robert Carter

It will be a country thing. Jack London may be popular across the USA but not necessarily in other countries such as Canada in George and Simone’s case. I’m from the UK and have never heard of him or any of his works. This isn’t to say that London’s reach isn’t international but it would be more concentrated in English Literary studies I would have thought

Robert Carter

As ever with these things, well known where? If it is just the USA then he may not have been widely popular outside the USA, even as close as Canada.

John Smith

"Kids read a lot of the same books for nearly a century." I don't think this is true; sure there were a few books that carried over generation to generation, but I know there were books that very popular in the 50s and/or 60s, that basically nobody who was a kid in the 80s/90s or later has ever heard of. For example, remember the Disney movie "The Black Cauldron"? Well, apparently, it was based on the second book from a fantasy series of books that was very popular back in the 60s. I've never read them, I never saw them around when I was a kid, I don't think I ever even met anyone who read them. Also, (the other way around) I know that F. Scott Fitzgerald was not a popular author when he was alive; yet "The Great Gatsby" was required reading when I was in school and has been adapted as a movie twice.

Ian Tellam

I'm from the UK and I remember reading White Fang when I was 12 or 13 - although it was just on the book shelf in my form room and I picked it up, it wasn't like something we read for an English class.

Robert Cooper

I'm not saying things didn't get added, or there weren't changes. But White Fang, Tom Sawyer, Caddie Woodlawn, Black Beauty, these were persistent. I'm Gen X. Where the Red Fern Grows, A Wrinkle in Time and Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy were our things, but we still read old books. Alphas, if they read, don't read anything pre-Potter that isn't on a syllabus.

This Justin

There’s more than just a pun with “Beaming with Barkley” while transporting. I bet you could write an entire script about people on a futuristic starship where all their technical dialogue is just stuff you hear livestreamers say, and it would work perfectly. TACTICAL: Captain, we’ve gained six followers. CAPTAIN: Excellent. Welcome them aboard. TACTICAL: Sir, they’re Klingon battlecruisers. CAPTAIN: …Mods? SECURITY: Already banning them.

Alan Kobb

Unlike the the other season ending cliff-hangers, this one neither had me waiting all summer for it's resolution, nor did I really care about the resolution. As for Samuel Clemens, I agree that the voice and manners were grating. I think the actor thought of this as a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity and just left any thoughts of subtilty behind. Too bad, because if you excuse the rest of the episode he is actually quite wonderful on the ship. Leave it to Troy to save the day and get him on the team! Historically speaking it was all wrong. There are pictures of Clemens in 1893 just starting to go gray, not completely so. Also, he spent nearly the entire year in Europe, and probably never met Jack London. That being said, I think it was probably originally intended as a single episode that was artificially stretched to two parts just so they could have another season-ending cliffhanger by adding things like Data's head. Things like Clemens and the landlady and Jack London were probably added just to fill time. It would have been better as a single episode.

Lem Bach

Imagine if Twain had been likeable.

Angela D. Mitchell

Jack London wrote wonderful books -- my personal favorite is The Sea Wolf (Wolf Larsen is a fantastic character), although I loved White Fang and The Call of the Wild too, as a kid. I will always have a soft spot for Barclay, like Simone. Anxiety is my superpower! AND -- the thing Deanna is having Barclay do is a REAL behavioral (somatic) therapy! It and similar tapping actions at different pulse points and body points are very effective with PTSD and used in behavioral therapy, and tapping behind your ear can also help with tinnitis. George, what I love about Princess Donut is that she is an incredibly loving, loyal, kind, and fiercely protective pet parent to Mongo. It's very poignant when you think about it. As a pet herself, she understands what it means to be a pet parent. (And was there ever a more quietly brutal moment than when Carl casually comments early on that people don't sacrifice themselves for their pets? You could actually hear Donut's little heart crack a tiny bit.)

Angzarr

Actor William Boyett, who made a career of playing cops (47 episodes of Highway Patrol, 127 of Adam-12, and countless others) and who previously was a police lieutenant in S1E11 "The Big Goodbye" (the holodeck film noir episode), appears in S6E1 as, yes you guessed it, the policeman.