Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Go to this site: Cinebingers.ca for the unedited versions of all our content.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/T9X3YRagX3 👈 for the full reaction where you do not need your own copy.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/nOurpsoCD0 👈for the full reaction where you need your own copy.

If you are on a phone/tablet, hold down the link above and press "open in browser", or go straight to Cinebingers.ca on your browser app.

Files

Comments

Joel

Happy Star Trek Day!!!

ChiefKC

Star Trek Day!

Robert Cooper

I need dilithium crystals to control my big D energy.

Captain Kermit

I'm casting Daisy Ridley to play Simone.

Cc Decc

an Uwe Boll reference!

Matt O'Keefe

Simone's eyes during the Relics episode...

Cc Decc

Also, I vote for Steven Segal to play George.

Cc Decc

The Fog (1980) -- John Carpenter horror starring Jamie Lee Curtis. Should definitely poll/watch at some point.

Matrim

::the monkey’s paw curls a finger as George speaks::

Dirge Girl

"There's-something-in-The-Fog!"

ChiefKC

it wasn't old footage of the Enterprise. They rebuilt that original bridge for this episode.

Jamie

Oh shush :P

Jamie

I think the first shot is, and the rest is partially built

Paul T Hewes

-6x03: "hey, lets mentally molest Troi again!

Joel

Also known on the TNG set as "Tuesday"

Blackbaldrik

First episode: What if angry, horny, jealous, and impatient is all the emotion he was offloading on people? We don't know, maybe that guy was just plagued 24/7 with constant jealous rage-boners the likes of which the galaxy had never seen 😂

REDR58

Man of the People George: “Tai Chi with Worf”… we have seen Worf teach martial arts (in this case “Mok'bara”) classes before in the episode Clues which you have seen. Stephanie Erb who plays Alkar’s assistant Liva was in Starship Troopers and The Ring, here with Naomi Watts: https://youtu.be/igEO_oyUs6U?is=uztbvqste2_wvOyg

Shaka, When the Walls Fell

Besides the obvious episode, Relics is also one of my favorites. Seeing Scotty was such a nostalgia run and a punch in the feels.

dudewheresmycar

I normally watch these reactions the whole way through. I skipped 603 the moment I realised which episode it was.

Der heilige Stuhl

How did Kirk die? Oh..you will find out soon..believe you me...

Nabikon

instantly knew who he was referring to as soon as he said German

Life in the cave of Garanoga

I had a similar gaming experience with "Against the Storm". I love builder games of all sorts. For example when people ask me what class I roll with in Terraria my first answer is Builder, then Summoner. Against the Storm takes a basic building/town builder and adds the roguelite aspect of constantly starting over and collecting prebuild resources and options over time. It's amazing. Like one review said, "The part of most builder games that is most fun is usually the beginning. So why not just do that part over and over?" Instead of grinding out all the checkmarks you get to enjoy the game and do all the things it has to offer in a satisfying way.

Lessiarty

OMG, brainstorm! We _must_ campaign for George and Simone to watch "Sita Sings the Blues"! For those who don't know, it's an animated telling of the Hindu myth of Rama and Sita. That may sound esoteric but it isn't, it's just really uncategorizable. There's three completely different styles of animation: Balinese shadow puppets as the narrators of the story, a wryly Disneyfied version of "Ramayana" (think "Aladdin" meets "South Park"), and the director's seemingly unrelated telling of her own love relationship. -- Oh, and interspersed with 1920s jazz songs by Annette Hansaw. Bizarre and trippy and funny and touching and more trippy. That's all!

REDR58

And for comparison, since George mentioned the Death Star, the given figures of the Dyson Sphere here are: Thickness, about 2,400 meters Diameter, 200,000,000,000 meters The Death Star in A New Hope has a diameter of about 120,000 to 160,000 meters.

Thomas88

Its not about star Trek, but i recommend the video of James Doohan (Scotty) talking about the time, he saed a fans life. If you like him and not know the story, wou will love him after that. Because he talks about his proudest moment, and that was a man, who was a war-hero, who inspired milions of people who made their master or engeneering degree

Patrick - Excelsior

603 is Space version of The Portrait of Dorian Grey, but in this case Diana is the Portrait. Interesting side note: In this episode you can see something James Doohan tried to hide all his years on Star Trek (although there are episodes of TOS and movie where you can see it). James doesn't have a middle finger on his right right. It was amputated while fighting in WW2 on the beaches of Normandy. You can see it when he pours a drink for Picard on the hollowdeck as he hands him a glass.

Joe Concepts

An episode I hate followed by one I love.

Vinnero

Agreed! and please do not watch the remake, My attitude is "Remake everything if done right" in this case for sure NO!

Monica Alarcon

I highly recommend the Relics Novel. It expands upon the Dyson sphere and it has an extended introduction where we see how Scotty was traveling and how they crashed and he and Franklin set up the transporter to hold their buffers. And the holodeck scene also includes recreations of young Kirk, Spock, and the rest. Scotty shows up in several novels and comics set after "Relics". I recommend "Crossover" it has Scotty, old McCoy and Ambassador Spock and it also serves as a sequel to "Unification"

David N

I was a little dissapointed by the show brushing past the moral implications of the first episode. Ambassador Alkar believes that one persons life (even taken unwillingly) is worth sacrificing if it means that thousands would be saved. Picards response is that what he's doing is immoral and selfish but all of that is undercut by Alkar finishing the negotiations before they cut his link to Diana. I think it would have been more satisfying if there were some sort of consequences such as the peace talks breaking down and the implication of continued war. The way it is written they get to have the moral high ground, save Dianas life, punish Alkar and save everyone on the planet; which to me dosent seem like much of a moral quandary on who was correct.

photos_by_geoff

George!! Please stop asking Simone about Star Trek memories of episodes or possible scenarios! You might find that you regret asking if thats what she remembers or get unintended spoilers that Simone will then be blamed for unrightfully. You have good ideas but Simone is very innocent in her wanting to enjoy Star Trek with you and all of us. Just pose your questions or scenarios but remember that most anything you ask Simone will be a potential spoiler for you my man!

Alex Macdougall

I think I figured out the perfect bad actor for George. Its Steven Segal cause im pretty sure Segal genuinely thinks hes an Asian man. And of course is an abysmal actor.

Jomero

Another "And Troi gets violated" episode. Thanks, Rick Berman. Although, to play devil's advocate in response to the horny-ness, it has been established already (in an episode with Lwaxana) that Betazed women do gain a massive sex drive when they get older. And Deanna did age pretty fast. Even so, that also feels like it was concocted by some horny male writer. Of which, TNG's "boy's club" had many at the top level. I have always liked "Relics." I never got into TOS, but even so I understood the importance of Scotty's character and was glad they wrote him in a way that showed off his brilliance as well as his can-do attitude.

Captain Kermit

Why? Why? Why can't we just say, "The last time we saw Kirk was Star Trek VI. That's all we know."? Why say anything else? I truly don't understand. Please erase your comment or heavily modify it. Please.

akaTheBAY-AY-RON

When it comes to the fact that Spock is still alive, would you say..... Scotty doesn't know?..... *Runs away in shame* *Regrets all life decisions* *Wishes I was never born*

Captain Kermit

I literally just bought a giant collection of Star Trek novels at a yard sale on Saturday. According to the seller, it has every TOS, TNG, DS9, Voy, and New Frontier book up to when he stopped collecting. It was 10 boxes, so I believe him so far.

Captain Kermit

It doesn't matter. Someone in the comments is always going to spoil it, because they don't care about other people.

Captain Kermit

It doesn't matter. Someone in the comments is always going to spoil it, because they don't care about other people.

Monica Alarcon

That is awesome! I have all the novels in digital format. New frontier is my favorite novel series. Enjoy!

Alex Macdougall

Yea! George wanted a terrible disaster class movie. Someone out of ethnicity, out of age range and filmed almost exclusively sitting down sounds perfectly suited

Michael Kemmet

Agreed about New Frontier. Peter David did some real fun things with those characters.

Michael Kemmet

To be pedantic guy, Relics is not equivalent to a Model T mechanic jumping to today. 75 years ago is 1951, which was over 40 years after the Model T was introduced. A more accurate comparison would be the car that Doc Hudson from Cars was based on. All that being said, it would be quite difficult for a 1950s mechanic to work on a 2020s car; especially given next to no notice. Some things are still unchanged(basic principles and the like), but the use of diagnostic computers for most everything would be a big hurdle. Though not an insurmountable one. My father learned how to be a mechanic in the 50s and continued teaching student mechanics well into the 2000s; including using computers for diagnostics. So it's doable.

Runes N Raccoons

It's a combination of Dorian Grey and Jekyll & Hyde. Dorian Grey only looks good, but he becomes well known as an evil man.

Patrick - Excelsior

In Dorian Grey all the evil he does goes into the portrait while he stays looking angelic. BUt when he is forced to look at the Portrait, the spell is broken and the Protrait return to a beautiful looking young man and Dorian changes to an ancient, repusive, deseased man.

Cc Decc

2005 The Fog was an utter embarrassment that ruined absolutely everything about the original. The director, writers, and no doubt idiot studio hacks who meddled should have been forced to write a public apology and been sentenced to public service.

Peter K

Simone, you know it is about time to watch Generations, not a great ST movie, but George is ready for it. And once that is out of the way, the next is First Contact, best TNG movie, as good as Khan IMHO.

Holy Squire

creepy ripple of rapiness. The writer was feeling up her mind.

Hoop

Spock may still be alive, but as far as we know, he's on Romulus. I don't think it would be practical for Scotty to travel to Romulus. Look how much trouble it took Kirk and Data to go there to see Spock.

John Miller

The thing that bothered me the most about the Scotty episode was Geordi was a complete dick to him. And that makes no sense. Scotty would literally have chapters written about him, in any engineering textbook. Geordi should have been fanboying over him, the entire time.

funky weapon

I get what you mean but I don't think the writers wanted to imply that it's okay to rape people and take their life force if you do it in the name of the Greater Good. What Alkar does is evil, straight up. That he also does good with peace talks doesn't excuse the evil he does.

funky weapon

All I know is that I want my life narrated by Werner Herzog.

Vinnero

Spock was the First Officer (Number One) and the Science Officer

Craig Motbey

“Relics” was supposedly inspired by the car of an old friend of mine. He was a revhead as well as a Trekkie. At the time, he drove an HSV Senator (AKA a fancy Australian muscle car). He had 1701D custom registration plates, and on top of the engine block was a small plate with James Doohan's signature engraved on it. He was involved in organising one of the Australian Trek cons, and was responsible for ferrying Rick Berman around. Which, of course, also involved showing him his car. Apparently when Berman saw the car, he objected that it was inappropriate to have Scotty's signature inside the engine bay of the 1701D. But then he thought about it some more, and the script for “Relics” was born…

Stephen Morris

there is a scene that was cut between Troi and Scotty, She asks if he wants to look up what happened to his family and friends, in response scotty says he couldnt bear knowing yet.

John Miller

George needs to learn to stop asking questions that he doesn't want the answers to. He really puts Simone on the spot sometimes.

Cinebinge

hi John, George here. Please understand that when i ask questions, i am not expecting to always get answers, i trust Simone is capable in deciding what to tell or not tell me. I ask those questions because the point is for me to convey thoughts in my head, including whatever questions come to mind, not so i can get answers but so the viewers know whats going through my mind. As such i have no intention to stop asking questions, but it also doenst mean i am disappointed or unhappy if no answers are given.

John Miller

I was being a little sarcastic. I love it. It's just a little funny watching Simone squirm sometimes.

Michael Daw

I love Riker. As much as he loves to fuck, he loves being a Starfleet officer way more. Always the consumate professional. Still, I'd hate to be that one ensign.

Joel

It's more like something a highly secretive society would build to try to hide their home star

MacGuffinStuff

Just finished Man of the People, my theory is this episode is a not just a twist on a vampire movie, but also maybe a little homage to that Buck Rogers space vampire episode that introduced a lot of sci Fi kids to Erin Gray being aroused to go steal some LIFEFORCE ( haha 1985 cult classic) with Space Nosferatu. I was curious if maybe this was some kind of Halloween episode, and it actually did first air in October, '92. Plus the ambassador's name Alkar just reminded my of Alucard, a little joke in MONSTER SQUAD. Speaking of Halloween, think Bram Stoker's Dracula is in the Alucards? That was my best attempt at a George pun. I'm really sorry. It's not that easy. Edit: just saw that Francis Ford Coppola's BRAM STOKER'S DRACULA, was released about a month after this episode aired. Anyway I love that movie, just wanted to mention again.

punterjoe

I always felt Relics was also a gentle message to the fan base: "let it go. move on. don't petrify - embrace change". Doohan was brilliant as always. I loved the subtle touches - like the old TOS films transporter sfx of the Jenolan's 75 year old transporter. I read that there were scenes cut for time, including Scotty working through things with Troi that Paramount really should offer as extras. All in all a very good episode that balanced "fan service" with constructive messages. By the end, Scotty didn't feel old and I'm the way... just ready to start the next chapter of his journey. BTW - I also loved the "It's .....green..." TOS callback. I hope you guys stick with Trek because by the time you get to Lower Decks or Strange New Worlds, (years from now) you're going to have SO much fun! 🖖

Simon Pegged Me

Perfect casting! It makes me wish I knew George better so I can imagine Steven Segal as George in the key moments of his life. As it is, I can only imagine Steven Segal doing Cinebinge with Simone—"I would not run from a Balrog. Balrogs would run from me."—and I'm going to need a moment.

Captain Kermit

I know. People strangely get very protective and defensive of their spoiler comments, when someone else points out that it's a spoiler, but you knew this was a spoiler when you typed it. You just, I guess, believe you have a right to spoil something that you know George is going to see eventually, and something Simone worked hard not to spoil.

Der heilige Stuhl

Yes and today I have thrown perfecly good croissants in the trash as well..btw I am also the Lindbergh baby

funky weapon

to add onto your comment, if anyone is curious what Marina Sirtis thinks about the trope of Deanna always getting assaulted, she's talked at length about it at various conventions but most notably the Edmonton Comic Con and on the Inside of You podcast hosted by the worst Lex Luthor.

gfixler

Sulu's counterpart is Picard. We've seen both of them fence. Actually, maybe it's Guinan. She was the one fencing with Picard in the first-season episode "We'll Always Have Paris."

gfixler

Scottie: Now lad, I thought you were going to buy me a drink at Ten Forward. La Forge: I have a better idea. This shuttlecraft is all yours. Now, get off my ship.

Lintrinsic

No, Guinan was fencing with Picard in "I Borg" Picard was fencing with some random bloke in "We'll Always Have Paris" Whoopi Goldberg hadn't joined the show at that point.

gfixler

Touché. Foiled again.

Eversharpe

Simone's giggle was just Scooby Doo.

Darth Fatass

Simone and George bio pic Sydney Sweeney as Simone and Ke Huy Quan as George directed by Quentin Tarantino

Simone's Coconut Squire

The Cinebinge Biopic: Quirky day-in-the-life film starring Randall Park and Amanda Seyfried, directed by Richard Linklater.

Robert Carter

How dare you! Michael Rosenbaum is a treasure and a great Lex that suits the Smallville world

Robert Carter

I thought Generations is after Season 7

Data Cable

Simone is already fluent in BuffySpeak, so SMG is an obvious casting choice for her.

Athenor

I dunno if you ever decided to watch star trek enterprise or not but it has a few episodes in this vein that , well they wouldn't be callbacks more like call forwards

Keith Jones

I prefer biopics that are explicitly true to life. I want them to be as accurate as possible. My favorite is Weird: The Al Yankovic Story. The research is top notch and the lead is almost as handsome as the subject.

Ian

Gravity

Daniel Lanctot

Re: Telling Scotty Spock is alive. While they could tell him, he would NOT be able to visit him because Spock, as far as we know, stayed on Romulus and that would be too dangerous for him to just visit. If Bones is still alive, after the 6 years since we saw him in the pilot episode (Which was the true “passing of the baton”), that would be more feasible; but there is no guarantee he still is. … Ultimately, I love this episode for the nostalgia of Scotty being there and how, despite it being the third character from the original series to appear on TNG, they found plausible and different ways for each of them to be on the show (Spock being long lived as a Vulcan, Bones being a really old man who just happened to have benefited from good healthcare advancement and a good life, and Scotty having found a novel technological way to skip over the years and appear in the future; each being appropriate for their character) Fun fact: The “It is GREEN” line is a reference to a TOS episode, in a scene where a drunken Scotty presents a bottle of liquor he found and, when asked what it is, he answers: “It’s GREEN!” (I guess canonically, he was too drunk to remember he said the same thing Data said to him!) 😅

Daniel Lanctot

Well the very concept of the Dyson sphere has long been one that didn’t really take into account the enormity of how much materials (metals, dirt, water, air, etc.)l, man power, financial backing, construction/travel/extraction time, etc. it would take to execute such an endeavour; that is precisely why it was originally envisioned as a full sphere (as we saw it in this episode) but later got down graded as just a few rings around a star, but even that requires ridiculous amounts of time/materials and now, when someone talks of “Dyson spheres” they have brought it down to only a few satellite-like panels around planets and no longer constitute anything close to “a sphere” and is nowhere near the amount of potential than the original design would have delivered, had it been feasible.

WayneC

It was.

This Justin

I always felt that Deanna's character was naturally a sexual being, almost as if sexuality is a Betazoid's default state. I mean, being a telepath would probably be an incredibly sensual experience. So I'm not sure it's just a case of the writers looking for ways to make Deanna a victim. It could be that sexuality is simply one of the most basic aspects of her species' emotional nature.

Angela D. Mitchell

Seeing Scotty was surprisingly moving, and it was a great episode -- loved the Dyson sphere setup. But I was somewhat jarred by how blase people were toward Scotty overall, especially Geordi. These people would be in awe of Scotty and know his historical significance! He's actually written some of the textbooks Geordi is quoting, yet Geordi can barely be civil to him, or patient with him as he adjusts to the loss of 75 years? That really felt unnecessary and cruel. I get the point they were trying to make, and I loved the rest of the episode. but the first quarter with Geordi being just plain rude to Scotty felt out of character to me, and I also felt like they hammered the "feeling old and useless" aspect a bit too hard. But oh, man, when Scotty used the Holodeck to go sit in the original Enterprise, that really hit me so hard. It was such an emotional wallop, seeing old Scotty sitting there, realizing it was all in the past, and all over, and now here he was. Just quietly devastating.

Angzarr

If one made ice cubes in the shape of Ice Cube, they'd be best used in a Ice-T shaped glass of iced tea.