Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Go to this site: Cinebingers.ca for the unedited versions of all our content.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/6NV4YC3ID0 👈 for the full reaction where you do not need your own copy.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/Ai0yJrdwx3 👈for the full reaction where you need your own copy.

If you are on a phone/tablet, hold down the link above and press "open in browser", or go straight to Cinebingers.ca on your browser app.

Files

Zero Dark Thirty | Canadian First Time Watching | Movie Reaction | Movie Review | Movie Commentary

Full length/Unedited: https://www.patreon.com/Cinebinge https://www.instagram.com/cinebingechannel/ Merch: https://www.cinebinge.ca BlueSky: https://bsky.app/profile/cinebinge.bsky.social Simone & George are reacting to Zero Dark Thirty for the first time! Canadians React! Subscribe | Like | Share | Comment Early Access & Full Reaction available on Patreon! #moviereaction #moviereview #zerodarkthirty Instagram: @cinebingechannel

Comments

djKENTO

Oh fuck yeah. Great way to start my day at 5am. Let’s rip!!!

Jedi Lounger

You guys should absolutely watch some MST3K. Several movies are bad enough where that version is the only watchable one. Just off the top of my head. I will look for more. Manos: The Hands of Fate Space Mutiny Pod People Edit: Also yes, watch The Hurt Locker (2008).

Cc Decc

MST3000 guys was a show from the...90s? 2000s? Long running. And in some ways a more sophisticated version (sorry) of what you were probably doing on Cinecringe? Anyway, the gimmick was that would take old bad movies (the best kind IMO) from the 1950s-70s mostly, and put them on screen with the silouettes of the MST3000 characters (1 human and several robots) overlaid in front of them like they were in a movie theater and you were sitting behind them, and then they would wisecrack throughout the movie at all the dumbness. There were also little skits during the intros and intermissions. It wasn't like reactikon channels -- these were professional comedians who had seen the movie before and written the jokes. Some were great, others just amusing.

Mike FromOz

Homer's mum didn't die in that episode, she went on the lam again and left town with her old hippy burnouts, leaving Homer by the roadside where he sat on his car and looked at the stars. She dies in season 19, because the later seasons suck and we can't have nice things.

Patrick Waldeck

Even though this is a very good film on a technical level, I can't stand it because it portrays the idea that torture yielded key intelligence in the operation for Bin Laden, which it absolutely did not.

Lokior

Such a great movie!!! Just love it! It may be just the pacing is on beat

JakeyShakeyBakeyBoy

Kathryn Bigelow’s an amazing filmmaker for sure! Plus, as wonderful as Ms Chastain is in this film I’m gonna be that guy and single out the fabulous turns from fellow Aussies Jason Clarke and Joel Edgerton. The latter especially gives a sterling performance in “Train Dreams” which came out not too long ago, among many others. Hope to the see “The Hurt Locker” appear down the line anyways

gfixler

MST3K mentioned! I fell in love in college in the mid-90s. I hadn't heard of it before then. I ended up copying a bunch of them onto VHS tapes from friend's copies, which was a thing; the show itself told people to keep circulating the tapes way back in the day. The internet was very new, and you couldn't download or watch shows yet. It was art school. I ended up making a black mat board cut-out of the 3 guys and the seats that fit across the front of my desk, which faced the door, so when people came in, it looked like I was the movie they were watching.

gfixler

You guys should watch some MST3K, but you probably couldn't react to it, because it would be you reacting to reactors reacting to movies. It would be too much reacting 😆

gfixler

Are you guys saying Huge Ackman?

gfixler

First episode of MST3K was 1988!

gfixler

MST3K came back years ago, after decades away. I was part of the Kickstarter. Felicia Day was one of the new actors on it, and she was there on stage at the premiere, which was at the theater right next to the Cineramadome in LA. Wil Wheaton and his wife, Anne, also walked past me as I waited in line, and went in through a famous person entrance.

Mike FromOz

The short "Last Clear Chance" never fails to crack me up, despite the heavy subject matter. "I could say goodbye from here..." MST3K: GOODBYE! Ooop...

DonkyDave

At least they didn't show the forced rectal feeding

Paulo Souza

Yes, the ex-CIA agent now working for a russian state sponsored media said so.

David Martin

Zero Dark Thirty means 30 minutes past midnight. And the helicopters have been outfitted with something called "blade mufflers", which I assume kills some of the sharpness of their noise noise created by the propellers. Probably also regular mufflers on the engines. Plus they are going in, dropping the soldiers off, then disappearing in the middle of the night. Not much time to react.

Michael T. (edited)

Comment edits

2026-10-25 03:00 I think George is misundestanding what it means when they say an aircraft is stealth. A stealth aircrarft is hidden from radar not from visual contact. The helicpoters were meant to be able to slip into Pakistani airspace unnoticed by the Pakistani military, not that they're invisible to the human eye. Sure they were quieter than a normal helicopter but anyone looking out the window can still see them and hear them, that's not what makes them stealth.
2026-09-19 14:18

Jenny Harvey

James Gandolfini is great in, 'In The Loop' directed by Armando Iannuci, specially when squaring off against Peter Capaldi' Malcolm Tucker

throg of thunder

Everybody make sure to use the bathroom before we get on the helicopter

Keith Jones

I basically always watch the no sync versions. I like to watch my casting to my TV in the living room and just don't want to setup a tablet or something to sync with. It's pure laziness on my part. Of course, I rarely watch a reaction to something I haven't already seen at least once; so having the video being smaller doesn't really matter.

Jay Johnson

another Gandolfini movie that I've always liked is "The Last Castle" with Robert Redford. also, I'm amused that this (zero dark) is a movie with James Gandolfini that also mentions Gandalf

L77045

Haha, wasn't expecting my question to start things off. MST3K might be a great entertainment option for you guys! There's no way they'd watch something that you would ever react to on your channel, unless you chose to react to them at some point. Personal favorite episode, and what got me started on the show way back when. Especially good if you're a little...under the weather or under the influence. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LNq_zBuBBhE And the idea of you guys as puppets intro is awesome.

REDR58

As much as I like Felicia Day, I could not get into that version of MST3K. For me, it’s all about Joel and Mike in particular.

Der heilige Stuhl

Yes...Maya is actually a real person..and the raid you watched at the end is VERY close to what actually happened

Twiska Brand

Actually, Jenny probably didn't give Forrest HIV. She probably didn't have enough of a viral load to be transmissible back then, and in general, sexual woman-to-man transmission is a lot less common than man-to-woman or man-to-man. Woman-to-woman sexual transmission is the least common. HIV is seen as mainly a sexual threat due to the impact it had on the gay community, but most transmissions are straight blood-to-blood via sharing needles.

Cc Decc

I have to admit to being a little concerned that when asked whether she had 6 fingers on their right hand, Simone IMMEDIATELY hid her right hand under her blanket.

Ben G

I DEMAND to see Simone and George Muppets!!! 🤣🤣

Brandon

For more Kathryn Bigelow, 'Strange Days' from 1995 is extremely underrated and underseen. It has great Cyberpunk vibes. The plot even revolves around something very similar to Brain Dances from the games.

REDR58

Stealth technology, involves not only the absorption of radar by the aircraft, it can also mean not using radio emissions (so an aircraft or ship cannot be detected in that way) Here’s Simon Whistler on how stealth works: https://youtu.be/lKfozw5kDyQ?is=sKCWaxQGskXAxi_m

Jamie

concerned?

DonkyDave

You guys should watch Captain Philips which has another brilliantly tense sequence

Twiska Brand

This film is CIA propaganda. Straight up. The CIA even gave the filmmakers classified information in exchange for a few things. Mainly, the idea that torture works, and that is the reason they got Bin Laden. In reality, the torture set them back, as it just doesn't get you reliable information, and it completely wrecks any trust or rapport with the prisoner. The FBI were doing well with their regular interrogation techniques until the president ordered in the CIA. 9/11 happened on US soil, so for a while it was treated as under FBI jurisdiction. The CIA paid millions for "enhanced interrogation" research to psychologists and doctors before 9/11, and they used the rage after 9/11 to test them out. In the end, it was regular interrogation techniques and good signals intelligence and analysis that got Bin Laden, and if it wasn't for the CIA torturing all the good leads to madness they US would have gotten him much sooner.

Reed James

They're talking about the ex-CIA agent that blew the whistle on the detainee program who now works for a media organization that's partially funded by Russians. I don't remember his name, but he has opinions on this movie. Calls it CIA propganda to make the torture stuff seem not as bad and that the CIA violated top secret laws to share things with the filmmakers. Gave them tours around parts of the CIA they shouldn't have. Things like that.

Maiki

Of course Jessica Chastain stands out, but what a great cast overall. I always enjoy seeing Mark Strong and Kyle Chandler. Both incredible (supporting) actors.

Reed James

Zero dark thirty is military slang for 12:30 AM which in military time is 00:30 or Zero thirty hours. Then soldiers drop the dark in as a joke and it stuck.

Jeff K.

Other MST3K suggestions: The Final Sacrifice (for its pure Canadian goodness) Time Chasers (for its pure Vermont goodness, which is basically Canadian goodness) The Mole People Eegah! I went and saw the new MST3K: The Rifftrax Experiments episode last weekend in the theater, and Sting of Death will absolutely be in the conversation once it's readily available, too. It felt like Eegah! meets Manos meets Boggy Creek II (which is another one they should watch, now that I mention it). OOH! Riding With Death is another fantastic one. It's easy to find on YouTube, as well. Not nearly as elusive as Robert Denby.

Sporty Taco

Odd that you say that since all of the actions in the movie were completely disavowed by the Obama Administration. Of course, it was VP Biden that casually leaked that Seal Team 6 was the unit involved. Then most of the team members were killed a few years later in an op dubbed Extortion 17. One could also argue extracting the names of viable targets through enhanced interrogation was more helpful in the long run than using drones to kill random people at weddings and funerals. Or to execute US citizens and their children without due process.

Jeff K.

MST3K is one of the foundational pillars for my sense of humor (along with Monty Pyton, Kids in the Hall, and The Simpsons; those four are pretty much entirely responsible for shaping my humor, so blame them).

Jeff K.

It's back again now, too. They've got four new episodes that are rolling out in movie theaters before being released digitally. I just saw the first of the batch at the theater last weekend, it was fantastic. Mike and the bots back on the SOL almost made me emotional, given how important that show is to me.

Jeff K.

I was trying to guess which episode that was a link to... I did not get there. My immediate guess is always gonna be Manos or Final Sacrifice or Space Mutiny.

Ben G

George: "I didn't know there was a CIA site in Poland" There isn't, and there never was...

REDR58

Manos….. …

SnabbKassa

the reaction to Plan 9 was very much in the vein of MST3K

SnabbKassa

it would be fun for people to find some after-reaction quotes from you guys and then put them on fake movie posters of the movie. I'm sure you have both said some funny things. "Dan Aykroyd proves he has healthy knees"

REDR58

For a “good” US propaganda movie that George in particular may enjoy, check out “Thirty Seconds Over Tokyo”: https://youtu.be/9V9ik07qvMM?is=EPC7bTsPqVXBJOXE I’m curious to know if the Mandarin spoken in the film is correct. From what I know about the movie, it is, but of course i could be wrong. The move just had a really nice HD Blu-ray Disc release in June 2026.

Raven Blackrose

Hobgoblins is up there in MST3K for me. "It's the 80's, dooo a lotta coke, and vote for Ronald Reagan!"

Steve Arnold

Now Simone and George should watch „The Report“ with Adam Driver. It puts „Zero Dark Thirty“ into a whole different perspective.

Gizmo Swr

Longest manhunt I believe was for Ted Kaczynski, the Unibomber ... 17 years and change

funky weapon

Movie should've ended with the rock sending out that tweet. Maybe throw an American flag behind him as he stares off whistfully in the distance knowing that he just healed one of America's deepest wounds. The movie is well made and Simone is right, when they started making this movie it was supposed to be an examination of how the USA did a bunch of heinous shit and it got them nowhere. You know, like a Vietnam movie. Then Obummer went on TV and dabbed on bin Laden's grave. and that completely destroyed the original ending to the movie. I still giggle at the fact that they had to completely rewrite the final act and it wound up being propaganda for torture. It's Kafkaesque.

Ben G

Camp Chapman bombing: I remember when this happened and no one could figure out how this happened in the middle of an army base. Of course the US government wasn't giving details at the time.

Karl Ries

Exactly. Being heard or seen by the locals wouldn't be a primary concern as they really wouldn't know what they are hearing or seeing. And even if they figure out that it's a foreign incursion, it wouldn't trigger an immediate response like being caught on radar would. That being said George was right when talking about those inside the house being alerted and the risks involved, but the team is going in anticipating those potential threats.

Jeff K.

Sting of Death was definitely a really solid return to the show. It took a little bit to get going (I think some of the jokes also didn't land in my theater because, as always, Mike, Kevin, and and Bill made some very old, very niche references that most of the younger crowd didn't get; they made one Natalie Wood joke that caught me totally off guard and had my jaw on the floor for a second before I started dying laughing, but I'm not sure how many people in the theater are familiar enough with Natalie Wood, as an example).

Twiska Brand

I'm talking about the Bush administration, which was actually in charge during the events of this movie, which beings in 2003. The US world would have gotten him before Obama was elected if they hadn't been torturing them and had let the FBI keep doing what it was doing.

Thall

Imma go out on a limb without having ever seen the movie: The film also doesn't talk at any point about how Osama Bin Laden was a key ally of the US for many years int he fight against the Russians, or how the US brought a hundred thousand mercenaries over to fight, which is why the entire region is still fucked to this day

Ben G

2:00:07 One George level plot hole in an otherwise excellent movie was the deduction that there had to be a third male to account for the third female. But Muslims can have multiple wives.

Jeff K.

The first time I remember ever seeing Galdolfini was in Get Shorty, which would be a great film for them to react to some day.

Joel

I vote yes on Cinebinge: MST3K edition I'm warming my popcorn up as we speak

Carlos H

If you want more James Gandolfini you should check out Killing Them Softly (2012) it stars Brad pitt, Gandolfini, Ben medelson and ray liotta. Great movie.

Patrick Waldeck

Bin Laden was never actually a key US ally. We funneled money to a ton of different militias and freedom fighters through Pakistan, most with different goals and designs for Afghanistan. We threw weapons to anyone willing to kill Soviets. Bin Laden immediately became hostile to the US as soon as the Soviets left due to American military bases on Saudi Arabia. Either way, none of that is important to how torture was not actually used to catch him. Khalid Sheikh Mohammed actually repeatedly gave false info after while being waterboarded over 180 times.

Lana Gorgeous

The movie was done so fast and was more accurate than most movies of this type because the Obama Administration gave them unprecedented access. Director Kathryn Bigelow and screenwriter Mark Boal were given extensive and controversial access to top-tier CIA officials and operational details while researching Zero Dark Thirty. The filmmakers met with top figures including CIA Deputy Director Mike Morell and Under Secretary of Defense for Intelligence Michael Vickers. They gained entry to CIA vaults, a classified facility, and even a replica of the compound in Abbottabad, Pakistan, used by Navy SEAL Team Six. They were allowed to consult with active intelligence and military operatives involved in the real-life hunt for Osama bin Laden.

Ben G

The helo crash: Apparently they trained on a mockup of the compound but used chain link fence to represent the walls. When they hovered in the compound the solid walls disrupted the rotor airflow and caused the crash. As for stealth. It's mostly to evade Pakistan air radar search. The people on the ground heard something but by that time they were already assaulting the compound.

OddThomas

Not my favourite Chastain movie tbh. Take Shelter, Tree of Life, Molly's Game and Dark Phoenix are better (Yes Dark Phoenix. Sit down, trolls).

OddThomas

Very ahead of its time

Cc Decc

What if she does?! 😨

Stephen Morris

Trivia Cuts off after George says “in real life”

PDP1472

This is a debunked conspiracy theory. Biden did no such thing; and there was no connection to Extortion 17. Even the name Seal Team 6 is an obfuscation. It's was a made up title to hide the true numbers of SpecOps personnel we had.

Denis Yugov

All your information about whether torture worked or not comes from John Krikaou, ex-CIA traitor who now works for the Russian propaganda machine, known for it's effective disinformation techniques. So, not sure how much I would trust the source. But as someone who has been to places in the movie, I KNOW(not think) it does help a lot.

PDP1472

The goggles aren't really disorienting. It doesn't expand vison, so much as reduce the 'porthole' vision normal(and older) NVGs give you.

Maiki

She's amazing in Molly's Game. As is the movie. More Sorkin, please :) Also wanna add Miss Sloane (2016). Mark Strong is in it too.

Stanley Etienne

This is a propaganda film to justify the torture that was happening at the time.

zona999

Those recordings at the beginning of the film are, of course, real. The Betty mentioned in them is Betty Ong, a flight attendant on the first plane. She was amazing. She was the first to alert authorities that something was wrong and she remained calm as she gave information for as long as she could. We just had the 25th anniversary of the attacks and it brings it back my experience that day.

zona999

That's false. Key info was gathered through those methods, whether we like it or not.

Patrick Waldeck

Nope. Sorry but no matter how much you absolutely love torturing people, it doesn't work, and it didn't work to catch Bin Laden. Zero Dark Thirty is a no more that Bush apologism that perpetuates the myth that Torture is actually effective. The Senate Intelligence Committee wrote a few thousand pages going to into great detail about how useless the torture programs actually were for the entirely of the "war on terror." Hassan Ghul gave accurate information on the identity of Bin Laden's courier to the CIA when in custody, THEN was tortured, and after the torture gave absolutely nothing of substance.

OddThomas

Yes Miss Sloane is another good one. And for more Mark Strong: Stardust (2007)

OddThomas

Enough Said is a very underrated Gandolfini/Julia-Louis Dreyfus romance

Stan the Man

What are you talking about? Did you watch this movie? How was the key name revealed? Torture? No. Subterfuge. They lied and used their wits. Showing that torture occurred, which it did, is not a lie or an approval. If you think Kathryn fuckin Bigelow is going to make a pro torture movie, you’ve got another thing coming. This movie had inside info, probably thru Leon Panetta. But if you don’t think torture has never revealed any true info I’ve got news for you. But it’s also revealed just as much false info. Which this movie clearly shows. The truth is uncomfortable. Torture sometimes works. Torture also is awful and against the law and shouldn’t be done. We know people will say anything to make it stop. But this movie shows that all the torture in the world won’t work. Dogged investigation, running down leads, mass surveillance. That’s what did it. Also? Money. Did you see the part where they gain info from buying a dude a brand new luxury car? So the movie shows the many different methods used to gain intelligence. You are free to not like the movie. But don’t dislike it for wrong reasons. Because if you walk away from this movie thinking torture helped, I just don’t know what movie you watched. Look at how Maya is eaten away, her eyes become dark and almost dead. So again, the show quite clearly shows all the methods used to gain information. It shows torture resulting in misinformation. It shows how dehumanizing it is. It DOES NOT show torture “working”.

Music

I was friends with the last caller who said she was going to die, Melissa Doi. Another friend warned me that Melissa’s call was in this movie so I was prepared. Even being prepared, it’s still heartbreaking.

Stan the Man

What is with all these weird comments that say the movie shows “torture works”. This is NOT TRUE. All the main info is revealed thru subterfuge. Or buying intel. I don’t know what fairy tale you want to be told but showing torture happening does not mean the movie shows it working. This movie was released during the Obama administration. They were absolutely against torture and were not trying to do “propaganda”. I mean come on. The movie shows key intel obtained by withholding information, corruption, surveillance. The main piece was revealed not thru torture but subterfuge. Now when the movie shows torture what does it show us? How dehumanizing it is. The toll it takes. That a person will say anything to make it stop. Does that sound like propaganda to you? I’m serious. Does that sound like propaganda? If you think it does then you are NOT coming at this from a place of reason & truth. You think the purpose of showing torture was to what? The audience is suppose to walk away thinking what? “GO AMERICA!” No. No. No. It’s clearly shown that this is wrong, it’s ugly, it’s brutal, it’s immoral, dehumanizing. But the movie is not going to lie to us either. Which is why it’s great. Torture happened. We know this. Not just by America but countries where torture isn’t against law. Has any useful info ever come about from torture? If you think the answer is no, you need to wake up. But the movie isn’t saying “this is what worked” the movie is saying “look at how the best intel came about”. That wasn’t torture. This “Zero Dark Thirty is cia propaganda and is pro torture” is an argument I’ve seen and it makes me wonder where it comes from. Why are people lying about the intentions of a movie? Who benefits from that? I don’t know. But it’s weird. And wrong.

REDR58

I had no personal connection with anyone lost that day but even now 25 years later, I cannot watch footage from that day. I saw it all live on TV. Never again.

REDR58

Gonna respectfully disagree with you about Dark Phoenix, which I feel is just a bad movie, no fault of Chastain or anyone else, but I like her a lot in everything else of hers I’ve seen.

John

For another James Gandolfini movie I would suggest Crimson Tide also starring Gene Hackman and Denzel Washington, for Kathryn Bigelow consider House of Dynamite, and for a larger historical context Charlie Wilson's War starring Tom Hanks and Julie Roberts

Twiska Brand

The courier led them to the compound. They got him from regular intelligence. This movie says that it was based on old information taken from people under duress.

Joel

Reactception ROFL

Kyle Fleming

Hey George, how about Jack the Ripper? Longest and most infamous manhunt in recorded history, surpassing Bin Laden.

E G

Kinda odd to lay out torture or indiscriminate drone striking as the only viable options when there are many options between those two extremes.

Lycowolf

There are 2 great movies that have James Gandolfini in them, one is 'In the Loop' a political satire, and 'Killing them Softly' a drama thriller. If you want to see more movies with him.

beefjerkywizard

Shout out to Bob's Burgers! It truly is the best and would make a great addition to the channel. You could do one episode here and there

Jay Johnson

what about DB Cooper? (or perhaps the active manhunt wasn't that long before they gave up, I dunno)

Jay Johnson

Crimson Tide also had Aragorn (I mean Viggo Mortensen)

Jay Johnson

not familiar with that movie, but I'm guessing just from the title that it is about the Doolittle raid

Jay Johnson

so sad. have had a bit of a crush on Ms. Vayntrub ever since happening across the "Live Prude Girls" web series back in the day

Logan Nelson

This movie is pure propaganda....

Stan the Man

No it isn’t. You are spewing other people’s propaganda and can’t tell the difference.

Jay Johnson

the author of the Gump novel has stated that Jenny died from Hep C picked up through her drug use days, but that doesn't mean that's what was portrayed in the movie (although I think they kept it rather ambiguous). and if I'm not mistaken, hep C is more of a bloodborne transmission than a sexually transmitted one, as well

Stan the Man

You want a great Gandolfini movie? “The Mexican”. He steals the movie. True Romance is another movie is almost steals. You can tell he’s a great actor with just his small amount of screen time

Craig Motbey

On the theme of MST3K: the 1993 Australian cult movie Hercules Returns. A sword-and-sandal classic given a comedy redubbing due to underdog independent cinema opening night hijinks. Features Bruce Spence, AKA the Gyro Captain from Mad Max.

Jay Johnson

might bring back memories of what George saw being filmed in his old career.... (kidding. I hope)

Anthony.Smith

George is right, torture doesnt work because human beings will literally say anything to make the torture stop. There is no forethought to the idea of "well if I give them false information they will just come back and torture me again so best give them the correct information right off the bat." If this was true, then torture would never happen in the first place because everyone would give whatever information they had immediately before even being tortured. We know that torture doesnt work, not from some ex CIA agent that people keep mentioning in the comments, but because thousands and thousands of internal documents were leaked to the press entitled The Afghan Papers, where, among other things, official documents and memos from intelligence officers, agents, and higher military personnel personally lend credence to the fact that torture wasnt working and they werent getting any closer to answers doing it. The war on terror was the worst failing in the history of the United States. Not only did it not end terrorism, it literally caused the creation of ISIS. Colin Powell stood on stage while giving a speech and called out by name some seemingly random militant, a man named Abu Musab al-Zarqawi as being responsible for the terror attacks. This gave Abu global notoriety in the Taliban, which garnered him access to resources and funding, and because of this new access to resources, funding, and heightened notoriety, he went on to be one of the main individuals responsible for the founding of ISIS. Also released in the Afghan Papers was internal documents from a lot of the higher military personnel where they constantly spoke about not knowing what they were doing on the ground, not having any plans before boots even made it on the ground, and having no course of action MONTHS after the invasion commenced, meaning soldiers stationed in Afghanistan and Iraq for months without having any idea of what they were supposed to be doing. The Papers also revealed, definitively, that the US government lied to us when they said there were weapons of mass destruction in the middle east. They knew well beforehand this wasnt true. They slaughtered men, women, and children alike overseas, literally mowed down hundreds of civilians in Fallujah. US soldiers raped women AND children. One other thing that this film fails to portray correctly is that most interriogators had absolutely no qualms about performing torture. They were happy to do it, not only because many thought they were fighting a just cause, but because, and we need to be frank here, a lot of US service members, especially men, are just racist garbage. Whistleblowers reported interrogators laughing and enjoying themselves while torturing people. They joined up not only to fight terrorism, but also and this is going to be rather crass, because they wanted to shoot brown people and blow them up. I believe you have a dedicated area for movie suggestions, but considering it is directly related, you two should watch Vice. It is about Vice President Dick Cheney and how he mastermind the invasion into the middle east, manipulated George w. Bush (who was an absolute moron) and knowingly used incorrect and unverified intelligence to justify actions and spin narratives to the public about why the invasion was a good idea. Christian Bale plays the titular character, unrecognizable in his make-up and he does a remarkable job. I know this is a long comment, but it would be cool if you could read this as a precursor to watching Vice if you guys decide to watch it. If it's too long and youd rather not, that's totally fine.

CouchCheese

AmeriProp film but you can't expect better from a Hollywood film from this era depicting such a heady subject. And even then, integral details (like torture resulting in valid outcomes) is just fantasy or revisionist history. I won't say much more about America's complicity in the tragic event that lead to the events laid out in this film, but I will say one thing: Look up and read up on the CIA-coined concept of "blowback" . Whether or not you agree, it's very important to know all you can, because even now, in 2026 as important elections are happening for Senate and Congress all across the United States, 9/11 is a topic that is relitigated and wielded as a cudgel simply because a political candidate(s) has a certain racial or religious background. In a lot of ways, we never truly learn.

REDR58

Correct.

REDR58

Ditto!

Stan the Man

Did you really just say most US service members are racist pieces of garbage? What is wrong with you? Be a better person.

REDR58

Kathryn Bigelow on torture: * * * * * Bigelow says she is a lifelong pacifist and against torture. However, she felt it necessary to depict the actions onscreen in order to fully tell the story and calls on the First Amendment to protect her right to do so. “This is an important principle to stand up for, and it bears repeating,” Bigelow continues in her essay. “For confusing depiction with endorsement is the first step toward chilling any American artist’s ability and right to shine a light on dark deeds, especially when those deeds are cloaked in layers of secrecy and government obfuscation.” https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/general-news/kathryn-bigelow-rejects-torture-addresses-412935/

Joshua Davidson

I haven't seen Zero Dark Thirty since it first came out 14 years ago, and I remember being slightly disappointed by it at the time. I watched it on Netflix a few days ago in preparation for this reaction, and the full reaction video this morning. Not only is it WAY better than I remember, it's probably one of my top 20 or 30 movies ever now. I love it's attention to detail and how it doesn't hold the audience's hand. In some ways, it reminds me a lot of David Fincher's Zodiac.

Stanley Etienne

The CIA has been in bed with Hollywood for decades. How do you think they got all the declassified stuff to film. Just like the movie the Hurt Locker or even Argo. Funny how those two films ended up winning best picture. It's a known fact man, don't be mad at me

REDR58

Kathryn Bigelow also directed "Point Break." Jennifer Ehle who played Jessica, who was killed in the base bombing, played Myrtle Logue in "The King's Speech." The "Wolf" was played by Fredric Lehne who was also in "The Dark Knight Rises." Australian actor Joel Edgerton, one of the SEAL team members, Patrick Grayston, played the young Lars Owen in Star Wars Episode II and III. George, "Sikorsky" (sick-or-ski) is the manufacturer of the UH-60 Black Hawk helicopters that were modified for use in the raid. Sikorsky Aircraft Corporation was founded by Russian aviation designer Igor Sikorsky in 1923 after he emigrated to the US in 1919. My sister worked for Sikorsky some years ago and would sometimes get rides on their various helicopters. The reason the one SEAL team member's foot broke through the panel on the fuselage of the downed UH-60 Black Hawk (as he was setting the demolition charges) was because the external stealth panels/cladding can be easy to damage.

MacGuffinStuff

When I first heard the Zero Dark Thirty, I was a private in my first unit, they called it my first Permanent Party unit, it was not that. But I heard it as "O Dark 30", meaning earlier than the Butt Crack of Dawn, more like Buttfuck Early, and we used it more like whatever was happening that we had to show up at O Dark 30 was usually something stupid. "Usually" being the operative word, this time they got Bin Laden Anyway that's my theory about the title.

Richard Z Herrera

Its wild to think that people in the field of movie/show reactions don't know anything at all about MST3K...that feels like a crime, and I know they aren't the only ones guilty.

Stan the Man

I love it lol. Ok. Where do I even begin? Ok. Yes the CIA has been involved in Hollywood productions. But because you maybe aren’t 100% familiar with how the film industry works you automatically equate it to “propaganda”. There are numerous government agencies that have been involved in film. NASA for example. Is Apollo 13 NASA propaganda? Lol. No. But the film benefited from the access of NASA workers, research, technicians etc. Now most government involvement in film isn’t “Hey Hollywood do what we say” it’s usually technical info. It’s similar to when movies get the involvement of say the NYPD. So a movie like Ghostbusters had involvement with NYPD. Was it NYPD propaganda? No. Of course not. If you look at “Zero Dark 30” and think it’s propaganda…I don’t think you know what propaganda is. If the CIA was using this as propaganda they wouldn’t be showing ANY TORTURE AT ALL. Because it makes them look bad. Nor would they show CIA officers making mistakes. They wouldn’t show how a CIA officer got multiple people killed. They wouldn’t show the CIA failing at all. Now I am not going to sit here and say the CIA or DOD doesn’t use filmmakers like Michael Bay to produce propaganda. They do and they have. Those movies are designed to make you go “America rah rah rah!”. Propaganda looks like “13 Hours Secrets of Benghazi” or “American Sniper”. Those are movies that use American military assets and if you don’t do what they say? You don’t get to play with their toys. Zero Dark 30 was not such a movie. If Zero Dark 30 was propaganda it would’ve made the assault on the compound of Bin Laden an exciting action set piece. It would’ve been alot like a Rambo movie. Instead what did we see? A methodical, by the numbers raid with no fetishization. If the CIA wanted to make this propaganda Michael Bay, Clint Eastwood or Zack Snyder would’ve directed it. What Kathryn Bigelow did was show the ugliness of counter terrorism work. It wasn’t sanitized, it wasn’t made to be sexy, there was no flag saluting crap. It was about the job. The journey of the people who investigated, found and helped kill one of the men behind 9/11. That’s not propaganda. That’s storytelling.

Simon Pegged Me

I love The Mexican (2001). It's one of my favorite Brad Pitt movies.

dys

Obama's announcement of bin Laden's death was also the first time the entire world first heard about the *existence* of stealth helicopters, they were that secret.

Daniel Bjork

On George’s question about finding porn - it is very common to find that terrorists have large amounts of porn, to the point where the CIA believes that they use pornographic images as a way of communicating. What looks like just a whole bunch of porn is actually hiding a coded message.

dys

It doesn't get much focus in the movie, but besides all the torture, Guantanamo Bay, etc., the fake vaccination campaign is so upsetting to me. It set back the fight to eradicate polio by decades if not forever because now Pakistanis are quite rightly skeptical of vaccination workers. Like the announcement that they got bin Laden was a huge national pride moment for me as an American. After the Iraq war which I'd marched in protest against as a highschool student and all the torture shit that stained the soul of our country, SEAL Team 6 killing bin Laden was the most unironic "America, fuck yeah" moment I think I've ever experienced. George said he watched that Obama speech, but I can't imagine it hits the same for a Canadian as it did for me. I remember where I was when it happened, in the computer science lounge of my university, just as I remember being in highschool health class when 9/11 happened (I took a few years off before finishing college for my computer science degree). I don't even agree with the death penalty but bin Laden getting shot, I was like fuck yeah. So to learn years later that to kill this one guy they set back the effort to eradicate this disease that has plagued humanity since time immemorial was so upsetting. I couldn't help but recognize this time viewing how much this movie is glazing Obama. He's the one who stops the torture, Stannis Baratheon (btw is he even *trying* to do an American accent here?) makes a point of saying he's a "thoughtful, analytical guy". And I mean that's all true, and I very much prefer that to what we have now, it was nice to have a president who was intellectually curious... but he was still drone striking wedding parties.

Carlos

Would love if y'all watch Warfare some day.

Ray Ward

Pretty sure that Simone didn’t speak…or blink…during the raid sequence.

dys

Or just recently in Attack on Titan.

dys

I dunno, REDR58, I usually agree with your takes but there is absolutely no implication in this movie that the torture was not helpful. As far as I know in reality it was not, but this movie takes no time to show that the torture was bad and something else led them to get bin Laden.

Korpse

For more Gandalfini I highly recommend The Last Castle 💪😁

Snuggelbum

as with most things in actual real life, things aren't just black and white like ideologues on the internet likes to paint things. torture, as horrid and objectionable as it might be for just about everyone, does indeed work as *one of several methods to extract information. the key here is that the US used many many different approaches to get information. if torture didn't work, they wouldn't be using it. why would the general public or hobby-psychologist know more about this than actual intelligence services? yes, of course it can lead to false confessions and false information, but don't you think the CIA and every other intelligence service out there would be well aware of this by now? after all, humans have been doing torture for a very very long time. by now, you can be pretty sure that they gotten this fact part of their equation. it's just one tool of many, again, as horrid or objectionable as it might be(if i didn't already make that clear).

Snuggelbum

@Twiska Brand chicken chicken, ideologue dinner

James W.

Jennifer Ehle (friend who got exploded) played Elizabeth Bennett in what many Jane Austen fans consider the best version of Pride and Prejudice. I saw the Joe Wright film first so I really like that take but the 90s BBC one she did with Colin Firth in on my list to watch eventually. I know the Star Wars stuff are the most common credits for Joel Edgerton but I like to call out his roles in Animal Kingdom (2010 film not the American remake) and Warrior (2011), a film expected to be "fine" and ended up being a really solid film. Last year he got nominated for an Oscar for Train Dreams, so he has come a long way since a face in the prequels and a cameo in the sadly disappointing Obi-Wan show from Disney+. I was kind of surprised to see that Simone and George hadn't seen True Romance, that is the first thing I saw Gandolfini in. When I saw him in Sopranos I recognized him from his small but memorable role in True Romance.

Christian Da Silva

You are going to want to watch Jessica Chastain in The Help after this.

OddThomas

LOVED Train Dreams. I think about it often.

gfixler

Re: stealth helicopters... I have planes and choppers fly over all the time, and often I have Blackhawks fly right over me. They're really loud, so I do hear them coming from further away. They're not trying to evade me, though, so they're not going full speed. I like to see them, so I'll often go over to the window, yet I often miss them. By the time I hear them, and get up and go over to the window a lot of times they're already directly over the house, and I can't look up high enough, and then they're just gone seconds later. If I wanted to hit one, and I wasn't already manning something to do that with, and they were flying fast, to avoid such things, I'd basically get no chance, especially at night, no lights, where I can't see them. Also, all those panels are really for radar, so if the enemy had something like that, it would be ineffective, or much less so. It's not about fully hiding in this case; it's about greatly lowering the things the enemy needs to hit them, and greatly upping the chances they make it.

Philipp Roensch

Has a bit of a clean slate vibe for sure. Would not call it pro-torture or pro-Obama either, but it goes from torture giving one crucial information to slowing down without much context. The hunt was done by multiple people and a single pov, though played well, is not enough. I like the style and matter of fact violence not being too dramatized, it's fine. The Hurt Locker (2008) deserves to be on the next war movie poll again. I also love The Report (2019) also could be on a docu-thriller poll, if you can stomach a bit more of that era.

By Grapthar's Hammer, what a member!

One of the few movies James Cameron worked on that he didnt direct. He was producer and wrote the story and was co-writer of the screenplay. Thought this was a great movie but it kinda disappeared after Y2K. Just it recently again on streaming

DuplicitousDuck

By like aircraft standards, even non-stealth Blackhawks are actually surprisingly "quiet". Like, you'll obviously hear them if they fly over, but the sound fades surprisingly quickly. It's honestly kinda crazy; One moment the loudest helicopter you've ever heard is screaming overhead and a few moments later it's gone.

Dan

Also in general military "stealth"/camouflage/etc is often not about being "invisible" so much as just not visible from so far away and/or being harder to locate, identify, determine the range of, etc. In this movie (and I'm guessing the real op) I suspect a lot of the concern re sound was more about avoiding the attention of the military academy a mile-ish away than not alerting people in the compound itself.

Dan

In the UK (I was in cadets rather than proper military, but plenty of time around real military/bases/etc) I always heard it as "zero dark thirty" with the same meaning. Not necessarily turning up for something stupid but often due to the military practice of scheduling something early, and insisting on being early for it, and it being something you have to travel to.

Maxi_Rad

Against Human Nature to maim, murder, and massively dismiss the existence of another person? I love an Optimist George, but have we been following the same Human Nature through History?!

Maxi_Rad

The point of Music Overtimulation torture is to pick music that you knowingly hate, in this case specifically culturally offensive music, that's why metal was a big pic because some of it's already fairly offensive to our own culture...and the Torturers usually liked it.

Maxi_Rad

**New Question** What Music would they have to play for Either of you for it to become Torture?

Scurvyville

Strange Days is also really relevant given the current social and technological climate.

Maxi_Rad

While tailing a vehicle for intelligence or Interdiction, you'd idealling have multiple Cars with 3-4 Personnel inside covering different angles. Following behind, Parralling a street over, sometimes even coming straight towards. So that they can avoid the issue of; "Haven't those three dicks been tailgating me for miles now?", you'd rotate out teams in different positions and while moving those teams to those different positions they may even switch vehicles{or maybe 'Disguises' if in foot}. Serverilence is sometimes more Scintillating that a Stake Out.

Maxi_Rad

Stealth Technology can even sometimes be Cloaking the Sound Signiture to Sound like another Aircraft, maybe one that isn't instantly heard as hostile.

Maxi_Rad

Watched BB2 before this and it's funny the streak of Surprise Sopranos and Faux Sopranos. Ahhah

Maxi_Rad

Another Surprise Soprano was seeing that Gandolfini and Robert Redford did a movie together, The Last Castle{2001}

Maxi_Rad

Can Not speak from experience, but apparently hungover was some of those guys existence on "The Teams", decompressing from some of that shit is tough and they do have alternates like a play or show for emergencies.

Maxi_Rad

Quad Tube Night Revision Devices provide a composite image of all 4 to give the wearer better periferals and depth perception. In addition to being able to View different spectrums at the same times.

Gizmo Swr

Great point. I was corrected by my lady, she said it was Josef Mengele so I looked it up. She is correct. 40 plus years. I also looked up why DB isn't on the list and you nailed it. The fact that he hasn't been heard from and his status as unknown, they closed that case. Same with the Alcatraz convicts, no supporting evidence of survival.

Big.Bad.Mr.Mustard

All I'll say is this. For anyone who wants to know the real story, look up interviews and/or articles by Seymour Hersh regarding Bin Laden's capture.

JarHead0351

Now watch "12 Strong", America's 1st response to 9-11 attacks..

Tinderbox

That wasn't the same squadron that killed bin Laden

L77045

Yeah, there's definitely ones that are more referenced, but Prince of Space is my go-to. If you haven't seen it before, make sure to watch Invasion of the Neptune Men with it. Sort of sequel. Think both movies were originally a longer TV show.

Angela D. Mitchell

It's a very slick, well-done movie that is honestly a superb US CIA propaganda piece. The opening with the 9/11 victims is cynically placed -- it's meant to justify everything that follows. The movie wants us thinking of all that tragedy as the torture immediately follows so we feel he "deserves" it. I have issues with this film that are similar to those you were having as we watch so much extended torture -- and the idea that it is justified -- and that it was actually productive. That's total propaganda BS for the most part. Also, I know it's gonna sound nitpicky as hell, but Jessica Chastain's hair bothered me so much. It's so carefully coiffed for so much of the movie -- to the point that it took me out of what I was watching. Would she really spend THAT much time on her perfect waves in that situation? Meanwhile, I liked that the ending was just her reaction, but honestly I wish there had been more of a release of tension there. I just felt like I was watching Jessica Chastain shrug it off -- I didn't feel some big sense of completion at all from her.

JarHead0351

Now react to "12 Strong" America reaction to 9-11 attack... A good unknown by many movie

BangDroid

@Denis Yugov Worst self-report I've ever seen on Patreon

Ste Rawlings

You guys should check out Enough Said. It was James Gandolfini's final film and really shows what a tremendously versatile actor he was

Anamondaris

I can’t wait for the comments when this hits YouTube. George is gonna get lit up for his stealth understanding😂

Sean Hennessy

Great Kathryn Bigelow joke from the Golden Globes that Amy Poehler made around this movie was "When it comes to torture, I trust the lady who spent three years married to James Cameron." They were married for a few years in the late 80's early 90's.

Andrew

Some random thoughts. I did find this movie hard to watch at times, but I pushed through, mostly just because I was on a Jessica Chastain kick and was watching everything I could find with her in it. I give it a 7/10, but it's not one I'm eager to rewatch. If you want more of Jessica Chastain, I highly recommend Molly's Game and Miss Sloane. Also, George's comment about the drone strike cake conversation made me think of the song Death from Above by Thrice, which I think is a fantastic song and kind of relates. The lyrics sort of touch on the desensitization of it being on screen instead of in person. Haunting.

Andrew

Also, James Gandolfini was an absolute treasure.

REDR58

I'd Recommend Pride and Prejudice be watched here. Not just for its high quality, but also because it was such a cultural success at the time.