Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Go to this site: Cinebingers.ca for the unedited versions of all our content.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/wY5Exjae01 👈 for the full reaction where you do not need your own copy.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/ErJXWmBd17 👈for the full reaction where you need your own copy.

If you are on a phone/tablet, hold down the link above and press "open in browser", or go straight to Cinebingers.ca on your browser app.

Files

Comments

Joel

Happy Star Trek Day

Joel

Here we go... at least episodes like this are rare these days

dudewheresmycar

Rascals is quite possibly the stupidest TNG episode. At least the following episode is kinda fun.

djKENTO

Ro's hair here reminds me that the writers intended her to be one of the main characters on DS9... but instead we got Kira Nerys who I'm sure George will learn to love. George... any word on how you're doing DS9? We're only 2 weeks away from where they'd line up in broadcast order.

D Gyre

I might not play exactly as I did as a kid, I absolutely would find joy in some things doing them again as a child and getting to indulge myself. I would definitely be guinan in this scenario. I'm in my 40s for context Going back to the Academy is like going back to graduate school for a different field than graduated with. The academy isn't just a training location, its a university with many different programs. Troi mentions "get another degree" so think of it as going back for a second masters or PhD.

TalynOne

So we're just ignoring that they just invented the fountain of youth/virtual immortality?

JakeyShakeyBakeyBoy

For “Fistful of Datas” it’s a wonderful display of Brent Spiner’s range of comedic abilities that were originally shown off as Bob Wheeler in “Night Court.” He used the twang accent to amazing effect for laughs on that show. Fun fact is that he took the pilot of TNG over becoming a regular on NC, and as great as he was it’s hard to imagine anyone else as Data when all is said and done 😎

Matrim

I have a degenerative joint condition that leaves me in near constant pain in my feet and knees. If I were suddenly 12 years old again I would be running and jumping and skipping everywhere and would be goddamned delighted to do it.

Gizmo_Mogwai_

Not George getting "space" right on at his first attempt 🤣🤣🤣

djKENTO

The girl who plays young Guinan in this episode also played young Whoopi in the opening of Sister Act. And yes she's dubbed over. They didn't feel her voice matched so they retired in the booth to make it seem more like older Guinan.

Robert Cooper

Ok, I f*cking LOVE "Rascals". Especially in light of... recent events... it is the existence proof that you can do a gimmick episode that is also just a really good episode. **Stephan Voice** it's got everything. Reflections on existence. A little action. Addresses the questions you immediately ask. More story than you'd think you could cram into 42 minutes. Some legitimate funny (something that TNG doesn't do reliably).

Captain Kermit

I guess George wants 12 year old Captain Picard to square off against Romulans and negotiate peace treaties. "I want peace NOW! NOW! NOW! NOW! NOW! NOW!"

Jaaahn

its almost like hes saying being a captain is about the intellect and personality not physical size.

Lintrinsic (edited)

Comment edits

2026-10-01 09:00 Here the case for sticking with release order and filtering in DS9. While if you watch as separate shows it will all make sense in the end, watching that way throws off continuity. Characters disappear without mention because their farewell is on another show, cameos and crossovers happen, and some in your audience won't be able to contain themselves from announcing "That's x from y!" and spoilers will abound. There are themes introduced that ripple through to other shows etc. Seasons are long, and it can change the pace and make it feel less of a marathon to complete each show. Then there's the movies. It's probably more of an issue with them than it is for the individual shows. They're made with the assumption the audience has seen what happens in the shows that were still ongoing. There are major spoilers for First Contact in Enterprise, spoilers for DS9 in First Contact, and a hefty spoiler for Voyager in Nemesis just off the top of my head. You'll still need to follow https://startreklist.blogspot.com/2011/04/list-of-all-star-trek-episodes-sorted_05.html?m=1 for the movies anyway, so it'll still be complicated, if not moreso than just following the list for everything. Then there's the fact all the DS9 fans (and by extension Voyager fans) who've been expecting you to follow release order as that's what you've been saying you plan to do, and getting excited for the start of DS9 and now it's potentially shoved back by months, even longer for Voyager to start. Release order is a selling point. I've spoken to people who go out of their way to support channels that commit to release order because it's a big commitment. I feel the same. Ultimately, it's up to you how you watch. But I do think it matters, if only because you've been saying until recently you're going by release order.
2026-09-30 13:00 Here's the case for sticking with release order and filtering in DS9. While if you watch as separate shows it will all make sense in the end, watching that way throws off continuity. Characters disappear without mention because their farewell is on another show, cameos and crossovers happen, and some in your audience won't be able to contain themselves from announcing "That's x from y!" and spoilers will abound. There are themes introduced that ripple through to other shows etc. Seasons are long, and it can change the pace and make it feel less of a marathon to complete each show. Then there's the movies. It's probably more of an issue with them than it is for the individual shows. They're made with the assumption the audience has seen what happens in the shows that were still ongoing. There are major spoilers for First Contact in Enterprise, spoilers for DS9 in First Contact, and a hefty spoiler for Voyager in Nemesis just off the top of my head. You'll still need to follow https://startreklist.blogspot.com/2011/04/list-of-all-star-trek-episodes-sorted_05.html?m=1 for the movies anyway, so it'll still be complicated, if not moreso than just following the list for everything. Then there's the fact all the DS9 fans (and by extension Voyager fans) who've been expecting you to follow release order as that's what you've been saying you plan to do, and getting excited for the start of DS9 and now it's potentially shoved back by months, even longer for Voyager to start. Release order is a selling point. I've spoken to people who go out of their way to support channels that commit to release order because it's a big commitment. I feel the same. Ultimately, it's up to you how you watch. But I do think it matters, if only because you've been saying until recently you're going by release order.

Here's the case for sticking with release order and filtering in DS9. While if you watch as separate shows it will all make sense in the end, watching that way throws off continuity. Characters disappear without mention because their farewell is on another show, cameos and crossovers happen, and some in your audience won't be able to contain themselves from announcing "That's x from y!" and spoilers will abound. There are themes introduced that ripple through to other shows etc. Seasons are long, and it can change the pace and make it feel less of a marathon to complete each show. Then there's the movies. It's probably more of an issue with them than it is for the individual shows. They're made with the assumption the audience has seen what happens in the shows that were still ongoing. There are major spoilers for First Contact in Enterprise, spoilers for DS9 in First Contact, and a hefty spoiler for Voyager in Nemesis just off the top of my head. You'll still need to follow https://startreklist.blogspot.com/2011/04/list-of-all-star-trek-episodes-sorted_05.html?m=1 for the movies anyway, so it'll still be complicated, if not moreso than just following the list for everything. Then there's the fact all the DS9 fans (and by extension Voyager fans) who've been expecting you to follow release order as that's what you've been saying you plan to do, and getting excited for the start of DS9 and now it's potentially shoved back by months, even longer for Voyager to start. Release order is a selling point. I've spoken to people who go out of their way to support channels that commit to release order because it's a big commitment. I feel the same. Ultimately, it's up to you how you watch. But I do think it matters, if only because you've been saying until recently you're going by release order.

Joe Concepts

Aw, come on, six seasons in and you're still saying Data has no emotions?

Mike W

From my experience of some managers in the 90s they thought it was definitely more important that you were a middle aged white man than being competent

Captain Kermit

Don't make me give you the side eye...

Captain Kermit

And I have the exact opposite opinion. I HATE A Fistful of Datas, but I have fun with Rascals. Also, you must not know anything about SNW episodes.

Captain Kermit

But, as he stated, there are real logistical issues that will arise. Are you going into every alien encounter and explaining to them why a 12 year old is in command of the Enterprise, and George brushed off how dangerous it would be for him to ever go on away missions. Yes, Picard doesn't go on as many as Kirk, but he still has to put himself in danger on occasions and he's going to be a liability to himself and the away team. It's something Starfleet would have to consider for every mission they want to send the Enterprise on.

Joel

Lol, give me whatever you want, I usually skip these 2, rare mid eps in these last 2 seasons

Matrim

Picard’s flute isn’t a recorder, it’s a tin whistle. It’s the same instrument that you hear in the Lord of the Rings soundtrack and in My Heart Will Go On from Titanic.

Joe Concepts

They're just being realistic with Picard's career because logic aside, people are still going to have trouble seeing him as an authority figure. It's expecting a lot for people to accept that.

Brian Smith

the clothes didn't change size you can see on ro eariler it was too big on the transporter they gave them new clothes

Gryff

Naw dawg. I used to skip and jump and hop and bounce off shit and climb everything when I was a kid, I did all that because I was little and agile and full of energy without body pain. I would 100% do it again, but having my elder knowledge I wouldnt do it as much.

Joe Concepts

Star Trek episodes are full of all kinds of discoveries that would change human civilization forever, but are never brought up again.

Joe Concepts

If I had to wait around as a kid for a week or two, I think I'd go down in the basement and break out my old Transformers.

supwizy

I think george's view on Picard being accepted as in a younger body is a human view. I doubt a Romulan or a other hostile species would accept it so fast. And for picard stepping down so fast is mostly because they didnt know if it would get worse and how would you measure/notice when picards mental state has degraded. He is charge of thousand of people, it would be too reckless to wait for the moment you start noticing that his decisions were being influenced.

Lessiarty

"Ancient" means to me the time of the Roman and Greek empires. But we also refer to "ancient Egypt," even though the Egyptian empire was as old to the Greeks and Romans as they are to us.

Jim Madden

Just wondering how many people know the significance of the ship name "Biko" in the second episode. One of the great things about Star Trek was how it acknowledged significant historical figures by naming ships and space stations after them.

Jaaahn

i mean its a made up species, the assumption they would find youth as unacceptable is also just projecting human views.

Runes N Raccoons

To me, ancient either implies a civilization that hasn't existed for at least a few hundred years or a time that is at least 1000 years in the past. Ancient Greece is a different society than Modern Greece, and I wouldn't consider 1500s Greece as "ancient".

Joel

Somehow the knowledge of how to make a virtual machine sandbox disappeared

Bill

That time when the Enterprise crew discovered human immortality via transporter, and quickly reversed it and never again looked into it. (Phew!)

Polecat21

my take on skipping is that its a natural form of movement for children but as they get bigger its not as convenient. I think we stop doing it is because as we get bigger you have to actually think about doing it.

Captain Kermit

I'll buy them from you, if they're just sitting in a basement.

Captain Kermit

Six seasons in, Data still says he has no emotions.

Runes N Raccoons

Do you REALLY think a Romulan or Cardassian would accept a 12 year old captain?

Jaaahn

i REALLY think they would accept whatever the writers decided they will accept, and since there is no such scenario and its all made up, it can just be whatever each person want it to be

Joe Concepts

True, but lots of evidence over the years suggests otherwise.

D Gyre

size and weight matter even if your joints aren't old, agreed!

TalynOne

And Spock says Vulkans never lie, we all know both are bullshitting.

Jaaahn

why would he need to Let. It. Go. ? its his thoughts and opinions?

TalynOne

Lets say Simone was turned to 5 year old, do you think George would still do a reaction to Sausage Party with her even though intellectually he knows she's an adult?

Jaaahn

you know there are people in real life with genetic diseases that makes them look 12 when theyre 30 right? do you think those people only befriends other 12 year olds even though theyre 30? because by that argument Talyn, it implies you think visual appearance matters more than actual age. and if i were to reverse that and ask you do you think its then acceptable to give a 15 year old that looks 19 alcohol and drugs? because your argument conveniently leaves out the point hes making which is that mentally, internally the person inside didnt de-age. picard didn tutrn into a literal 12 year old with the mindset of a 12 year old.

Captain Kermit

I can't use specific references, but 1 of next week's episodes would be my Exhibit A as to why, even though they retain their adult mental capacity, there's HUGE arguments as to why it's not a good idea.

DesolationEntertained

I felt there was a good point to be made that hormones differ quite a bit between children and adults, which would have an effect on behavior that can't be quickly dismissed.

Jomero

Hooray! Fistful Of Datas is, I think, one of only two Alexander episodes that doesn't make me cringe.

Jomero

I personally would be fine if they just started DS9 after finishing TNG. There is hardly any overlap between the two series. And what little there is, is pretty inconsequential.

ChiefKC

Star Trek Day!

Jamie

I was going to say that. Interesting that they gave Picard the same pips etc but it sort of makes sense. Easy to replicate what they were all wearing and normalise it

Jamie

But we know about these races? We know how they deal with younger people? Also nature has a tendency towards certain behaviours deal with younger animals.

Life in the cave of Garanoga

As a 48 year old man who is fairly healthy, but now starting to feel the effects of all the sports and partying, if I was de-aged...... I am doing ALL the physical stuff including skipping and jump rope lmao. God what I wouldn't give to launch into a full sprint again without paying for it almost immediately haha.

Jamie

I'm not sure you understand the way people think. You're blinded by logic, like a Vulcan. :P

Jamie

You're on a rampage

Geoff Richards

Patrick Stewart's accent is something he trained himself to do, for stage acting. IIRC he grew up in Barnsley (Yorkshire, northern England), so would have sounded quite different as a kid.

REDR58

He’s also said he cannot use contractions.

REDR58

I reconsidered my position of this and have come around to your (and others) way of thinking.

John M.

This is up there with Trouble with Tribbles of just yelling at the screen, "George! It's just supposed to be fun!"

Monica Alarcon

Episode 17 will be a spoiler for DS9 if they don't watch the pilot at least....

halfAbee

I enjoyed your different reactions. As another George who is now in my mid 60s, my advice is that "growing-up" is overrated, and to embrace play and joy in the moment as much as we can. Skipping is enjoyable, and need not be set aside because of thought control societal norms of dignity. I'd prefer state leaders who can laugh, show empathy for all humans, and skip when they can.

Monica Alarcon

I absolutely agree... Also they insisted on release order and now they don't want to follow it "for convenience"... But at the end of the day it's their channel and we have to respect their decision even if we don't agree.

Ron K

First, their clothes didn't change. You can see that when they first beam back. Ro's sleeves are hanging down past her hands. Second, come on George. I'm in my 50's, make me a kid again due to a faulty transporter and put me in a room full of transformers and G.I. Joe figures and let me play. Guinan skipping and wanting to play is completely in line with her character.

Monica Alarcon

The first thing that came to mind is the Peter Gabriel song which I guess is about the same subject...

DesolationEntertained

I only just noticed at the end, the Enterprise flies off into the sunset :)

The Real Andrew Kim

It's less of a question of biology and physiology, it has more to do with what is socially acceptable behavior and how your behavior and appearance affects those around them. Picard had to step down because as Captain, it is more than just about competence but his role as a leader and diplomat relies on those who he interacts with take him seriously and to treat with a some respect and to some extent intimidation, which is not possible when your suddenly a child. For Ro and Guinan, if you skipped around or acted like a child, no one would put up with that shit as an adult and it would affect your reputation, but as a kid no one would blame you. And do I need to even need mention Keiko and O'brien.....?

Monica Alarcon

Rascals is total nonsense. Not the "turning into children" plot. Star Trek Strange New Worlds has done like 5 equally ridiculous episodes this last season ALONE and they make them work. But a bunch of ferengi taking over a Constitution class ship with hundreds of starfleet officers I just can't accept. And security is nowhere to be seen. That's just stupid.

REDR58

Don’t make me tap the sign!

Dan

Late 19th century guns weren't (generally) "wildly inaccurate" and certainly not over those sort of ranges. A quality late-C19 firearm would probably be similar in accuracy to a normal modern (non-precision) firearm. In fact, I'd say they'd be practically more accurate than the TNG hand-phasers when aiming since the TNG hand-phasers don't have sights! Troi keeps racking her lever-action rifle over and over again without having shot, as was typical for TV of that era. I think that's becoming more endearing than annoying now, for me.

Lintrinsic

Respect their decision yes, stick around and pay a subscription every month, that's optional.

REDR58

If Picard were stuck as a child who had re-grow up again, he may as well go back home to his brother and his identical nephew (also played by David Tristan Birkin) René Picard.

Pokes

The Enterprise riding off into the sunset at the end is such a great touch.

REDR58

Incidentally, Troi’s rifle is a Winchester Model 1873 and she has a Colt Single Action Army “Artillery” revolver in her holster. The “Frank Hollander” Data also has a Colt Single Action Army. Worf uses a Colt Single Action Army “Calvary” model. https://www.imfdb.org/wiki/Star_Trek:_The_Next_Generation

REDR58

I can accept many things in Star Trek and will tolerate excessive technobabble but I cannot deal with the utter absurdity that is the premise of this episode. Well, I’ll watch it for the reaction, but *never* again. The child actors are all fine and do what they can with it, but. No.

REDR58

And YES the total lack of any security responding is just silly.

Thall

The writers making O'Brians wife a child is exactly why Star Trek was so good back then, and why almost none of the new Trek can catch that magic. It is awkward, it's difficult to talk or write about, and it requires thinking about it. I am not saying they always stick the landing, far from it, but you gotta have the balls to do it. New Trek is comedy writers trying to create SciFi, which simply doesn't work. Not because of skill, but because subject matter. Scifi is completely different and you need dedicated writers to make it. Otherwise you end up with mutating neutrinos. Or Neutrinos that are deadly (like in strange new worlds).

Thall

Especially with the Captain of the flagship. What if Romulans show up and diplomacy is needed? Kid-Picard might have the skill, but they would certainly not take him seriously.

The Real Andrew Kim

or black holes and white holes just being portals you can just fly into with no regards to gravity....

Thall

I dunno how.. I wouldn't take a kid in a police uniform telling me to the vacate the premises serious tbh. So if I don't know that's one the most decorated officers or whatever... If I knew, different story. But even then, it would take a lot of effort to take orders from a kid.

REDR58

Evidently there was some consideration to have Ro stay as a child: * * * * * As Ro was not seen returning to an adult in this episode, the writing staff considered having her choose to remain a child. Jeri Taylor commented, "Where else but on Star Trek could you do something like that? But it seemed too drastic for us, and we were sort of squelched on that." (Star Trek: The Next Generation Companion, 2nd ed., p. 223) https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Rascals_(episode) Tracey Walter who played the Ferengi “Berik” is probably most famous for playing the Joker’s right-hand man in Batman (1989): https://youtu.be/U70p8VHxWZM?is=LlQvLFpgbH1u6WPt

Thall

This. Don't need to split it. I think it's more fun, you don't have to keep to shows in mind all the time, and as you said, the overlap is mostly cosmetic.

Jaaahn

but all examples of nature any of us can point to come from the same planet, it doesnt mean it will be universal in the literal sense- and again, these are made up aliens and could be anything writers want. secondly, nature and cultural attitudes is not the same thing. look at the way elders are viewed and treated among different cultures on just earth alone much less species, and thats just within 1 planet. my point is that the argument of "hes just projecting human view onto aliens" works both ways.

Joe Concepts

I always found the phrase "Ancient West" to be kind of dumb. Sure, I get it, and maybe they think they're being clever. But Old West is a nickname, not an official title based on age. It's a specific era and place. Changing the term would just confuse people. Just feels like silly sci-fi over-thinking.

Kansas City Shuffler

So, there’s a point in Crusher’s favor, which is that hormonal changes can have a significant effect on personal psychology. For instance, someone I know who had stomach staple surgery was warned by his doctor that the psychological effect of resulting dramatic weight loss might include significant increase in libido. It turned out to be true. That is itself reason enough to keep the change. Imagine reliving your hormonal peak but after the trauma of your earliest romantic misadventures.

Will Sofer

@REDR58 The contractions bit is a prime example of something stupid that Gene Roddenberry insisted on, even though it makes absolutely no sense, and it stymied the writing a bit.

Joe Concepts

Yes, the only programming you would need is, "In casual settings, use contractions."

Will Sofer

I have to admit, these two episodes are near the bottom of the barrel for me as far as TNG is concerned. I guess they’re okay in a “mindless fun” kind of way on first viewing, but I would never actually choose to re-watch them.

REDR58

A Fistful of Datas “DataS” is correct as it is a plural proper noun and would be like saying “A fistful of Toms” But yes, “data” is both used for singular and plural otherwise. Troi is damn fine-looking in that outfit she’s got on. She really has to learn better firearm discipline, though, as she was pointing that rifle right at Worf several times when standing near him. Why is Beverly in her service uniform while she’s doing the play rehearsal, supposedly on her own free time? Riker and the other people are in civilian clothing.

REDR58

I like AFOD way more than Rascals and normally skip Rascals when doing my own rewatch. It's just a bit too silly to take seriously despite some nice character moments. And I am not a huge fan of Ro (the character specifically, not the actor).

REDR58

As did Enterprise A at the end of TUC: www.youtube.com/watch?v=G-ie3ttNLaE

gfixler

I don't fully agree with the no-skipping stance. I got crazy into shape before college, and it felt SO good to use it. If you suddenly lost 30 years of body aging, I think you'd struggle not to skip, because you would just have so much energy, like a kid. After college, I gained a ton of weight, and then I tried the Atkins diet, and at least that first time (never again, sigh), it worked amazingly well. I did no exercise, just avoided all carbs and ate whatever I wanted on the diet, and lost 70 lbs. in 3 months. There was a day when I got up from my desk at my office, and almost fell, because I leaped out of the chair. I was so used to being 70 lbs. heavier so recently that I had forgotten how much lighter I was, and I have strong legs. I literally jumped in the air, unexpectedly, and fell back, knocking the chair back and almost falling over. I ended up bent over, grabbing onto the desk to regain balance, and laughing, but also thinking "wtf?!" It was like someone had changed gravity (Q!). During that time, I was almost skipping everywhere, because it felt like I was on the moon. It felt so good to use my body more. I started lightly jogging to everything, like from a store to my car, because I had all this extra body energy I had to bleed off. It didn't last very long, but was really fun while it did 😆 I think it's personal, though. There are kids who plod around, never skipping. Maybe they wouldn't.

DemNikoArt

My take on Picard going back to Starfleet Academy: This world's main driver is growth and advancement. For society and personal benefit. Picard saw this as an opportunity to gain knowledge and opportunities he never had before. It's not about him learning all the stuff again he already knows. It's his opportunity to gain further growth and explore different paths. These things are some of the most important drivers for humans in that time. Also yes, Starfleet people would maybe get used to his new appearance, but enemies like Romulans would definitely not take him seriously.

John Miller

First, it makes total sense that Picard stepped down. Remember, aside from the crew, other people have to interact with him. Do you really expect a Romulan commander to take 12 year old Picard seriously? And as far as acting like a child. It's an interesting idea. Why, exactly did you stop doing childish things? When did playing with cars or dolls stop being fun? And there are things that are just easier to do, as a small child. Running around, jumping, these are easier as a small child. Me personally, I didn't stop using swings, because they're not fun. They're just not made for adults.

s0rd3z

I like both of these episodes. Nothing ground breaking but they are fun I think. The actor that plays young Picard is the same actor that played his nephew in family, which I always appreciated. On the subject of WoW I am really considering giving WoW Forever a go as it's been so long. Was late on applying for the beta but the previews look good to me. Neck deep in witcher III remaster at the moment as I have not played that for like half a decade or more.

StonyD

I think both of these episodes deserve to be in S1, since they are absolute clownshoes. True low points for TNG, imo.

StonyD

Until they get to the movies. Then by First Contact, they would have to be up to at least S4 of DS9 to avoid spoilers for that series.

D Gyre

George needs to get in touch with his inner child more! (Joking)

D Gyre

Guys, it's a 90s episodic tv show, we've had how many ridiculously over contrived plots at this point and this is the one that breaks you? It's a problem through the entire show. I feel like you just have to accept the contrivance and enjoy the rest or not bother. Just me though. This is, for me, why TNG is always really good but never truly great outside 2 or 3 episodes.

Adam Morgan

Coincidently, I listened to a podcast before watching this that touched on the word "ancient". It apparently just means generally old, before now, or old-fashioned. It's an abstract and personal definition of generically 'long ago'. So, "Ancient West" seems reasonable, even if it isn't in the official Ancient Era (i.e. pre-c. 500 AD).

Mike FromOz

One of the reasons why I think Picard chose to get turned back to his previous age is because he's essentially Horatio Hornblower in the Star Trek universe. He does whatever is best for his crew, the Enterprise, and the Federation. Yes he could have gone and learnt a whole bunch of new things and studied different areas, but that would remove him from what he felt his duty was to do. Also, yeah it does make it hard for the TV series to have the main lead actor suddenly leave for the want of a contrived throw-away episode. But if we're looking at this as an actual event that happened, then yeah Picard would have chosen to be reverted back to old age. As for myself, de-age me to age 12, please. I want to skip and jump again.

Peter K

Since a Fistful of Datas was set in Deadwood, SD, I thought it would be a good time to lobby for the HBO series. Put it on the next series poll please.

Michael Daw

Like George said: "This can be good if the child actors are good". As far as I'm concerned, they all did fantastic. I love the episode.

Ron K

Sometimes it seems like you're not considering the reality of the situation. It's a science fiction show from the late 80's to mid 90's where the writers were trying to crank out 26 episodes a season. You're going to get episodes that aren't great. There are going to be plot holes. There are going to be story lines that just don't go anywhere.

funky weapon

I work with kids. Some of the younger ones like to walk on their knees and it horrifies me every single time. I wish I could still do that.

Michael Daw

Oh, Alexander is just fine.

ColdPizzaChris

This was the biggest element that I think was overlooked in the discussion. The majority of what Picard does is diplomacy and he’d be putting the whole crew and mission at risk. It would have been interesting if there actually had been Klingons in the episode to show how they’d react to a child captain even if they knew it was still Picard.

MacGuffinStuff

If I got to be 12 again, are you kidding? I'm absolutely going to have fun, call me an idiot but I'm going to take all of my adult expertise and organize the best game of Ditchem ever, onboard the Enterprise, and that's how we'd retake the ship and win the episode. And I meant to just have fun because Ditchem would be the Squid Game I'd organize if I was an evil billionaire, and I'd play, it was so fun. But it's also a tag and capture game so we could actually retake the ship and have a great time at the same time.

gfixler

I always wanted to find few-second shots of O'Brien at the transporter controls, not doing anything, and then find an episode where he beams in or out some dignitaries near the end, and then just cut those shots all through the episode, like he's just waiting all day to have anything to do. I also need a shot where he looks surprised, like people coming in startled him after hours of nothing.

Robert Mendoza

hese are probably two of my least favorite episodes. The actor who plays young Picard previously played Picards nephew in the episode Family. Crusher is such a menace trying to get everyone to act in her plays. If I was on the ship and saw her walking toward me in the corridor I would probably run the other way. That one scene between Troi and Worf really has the energy of a roleplayer and a non-roleplayer interacting in an mmo.

Ian Tellam

Besides, it's essentially a video game - they probably have aim assist.

Ian Tellam

Data could be programmed to use contractions because Lore can - the point is that Noonien Soong deliberately made Data more 'robotic'. So it's more likely he's explicitly programmed not to use contractions which is why he is unable to.

Ian Tellam

I can't think of a reason not to do it in release order - it's not really any more work or effort. Unless I'm missing something. I mean, if they want to do two episodes of the same show a week, instead of one of each, then at the very least doing them in season release order makes sense. They did the TOS movies (broadly) in release order with TNG seasons already, so I presumed the movie/show order would be upheld.

Simon Pegged Me

I'm with you. I'd love to be able to play a pickup game of tackle football or play tennis with my friends for hours like use to do in the summers. Or just go for a run—lace up my shoes, do the minimum of stretching, and just go. If they told me I'd be restricted from duties, I'd say, "So long suckers! If you need me, I'll be snowboarding in Holodeck 4! No, wait. Make that Holodeck 3. "(HD 4 is the one Ricker uses when he's frustrated.)

Simon Pegged Me

Dr. Crusher didn't go through medical school and a residency just so she could wear civilian clothing. 😉

Guts

Second life? This is Picard's third life, at least.

Guts (edited)

Comment edits

2026-10-01 23:00 Well maybe the transformations affects their minds and they are just unaware.
2026-10-01 10:38 Well, maybe the transformation to children also affects their minds, and they are just unaware.

Well, maybe the transformation to children also affects their minds, and they are just unaware.

Guts

Academy isn't one linear set of courses. It's more like a university. Picard could choose any courses that he didn't choose last time to widen his horizon.

Simon Pegged Me

Yeah, it's the Enterprise losing a battle to two Klingon Birds of Prey that gets me. In Klingon hands, that would be quite an accomplishment, but in Ferengi hands...?! The Galaxy Class Enterprise outguns those two ships, and Riker only manages to fire one shot, spending most of the battle asking Data and Worf for reports. To quote the lovable rogue Tuco Benedicto Pacifico Juan Maria Ramirez, "When you have to shoot, shoot! Don't talk." Come on, Riker. You're better than that. You, too, Worf. You had the first shot at the Ferengi boarding the bridge, and you missed. A Klingon?! And the Ferengi took you out with his first shot. You're lucky the Ferengi had his weapon on stun, because today was a good day to die. Finally, the Ferengi took over the Enterprise with a boarding party of less than 20 because apparently Red Alert for security is smoking and joking time. Once the shields were down, you'd think they'd be ready to repel boarders. You'd be wrong. I know this needed to happen for the plot, but still.

gfixler

George's humor is rubbing off on me. At the end of the episode: George: "That's just my preference, the big... big, um, what do you call it...?" me: "dick energy?" George: "...big theoretical SCIENCE fiction." me: "oh, right, that."

Guts

I assume that was a joke, right, regarding estimating Picard's age as in his 40s? :P He is 64 here.

TalynOne

I object sir. The Enterprise D is Galaxy Class, not Constitution.

Monica Alarcon

Oops. I done goofed. You are correct. But I object on you calling me "sir"

Vinnero

George, with all love and respect... Wrong! both of these where fun episodes and most seem to love them. But hey we still like you anyways. LOL

Eversharpe

It makes perfect sense to relieve them children from active duty. While yes they retain all the knowledge of their adult selves, they now have the brain chemistry of a pre-teen.

Guts

The second episode next week is part 1 of a two-parter. Will we get 3 episodes?

KnittingHaven

I'm also a big fan of release order, especially for the TNG-DS9-VOY era of trek. it is easy to find release order lists for these series. The arguments for watching the movies as they did are the same, they will get to see the stories and characters and technology evolve same as we did when they first aired.

Cromulentius

Picard called Riker daddy. So he and Troi have that in common at least.

dc (edited)

Comment edits

2026-10-02 16:00 Have they said what they’re doing? Maybe I missed it? Surely they aren’t doing TNG S7 before going to DS9?
2026-10-02 11:08 Have they said what they’re doing? Maybe I missed it? Surely they aren’t doing TNG S7 before going to DS9? I'd much prefer sticking to broadcast order. A compromise position would be doing TNG S6, DS9 S1, TNG S7, DS9 S2, VOY S1, etc, which would probably be fine too.

Have they said what they’re doing? Maybe I missed it? Surely they aren’t doing TNG S7 before going to DS9? I'd much prefer sticking to broadcast order. A compromise position would be doing TNG S6, DS9 S1, TNG S7, DS9 S2, VOY S1, etc, which would probably be fine too.

Matt Blanchette

Makes sense that they would hire Spock's son to direct the episode where everyone gets turned into children.

Matt Blanchette

Captain Jellico! :-o Wouldn't you make everybody change their uniforms?

Matt Blanchette

"human immortality via transporter" Wasn't that "Relics"?

Lintrinsic

They discussed it a few weeks ago. George seemed to think it would be easier to finish TNG first. Simone said it probably didn't matter and they haven't mentioned it since.

Bill

Nah - that was indefinite hypersleep. You're still only living one lifetime. But this? Just reset to a pre-teen every 80 years? Sign me up!

funky weapon

the little rascals episode was cute and fun, but fucking woof. the Fistful of Datas. I couldn't even get to the gimmick of the episode. Worf and Alexander are good, I think, when they're doing Klingon stuff, or navigating between Klingon and Human cultures. when it's just the two of them doing random shenanigans I just can't.

Elvenwitch

Seriously, I have been in pain for so long. If I could run around and jump, I would do it as long as I could. Especially if I could do zero-g and use a holodeck.

ColdPizzaChris

I think A Fistful of Datas is fun. I love George and by this point I know that he enjoys things in different ways than I do.. this is a prime example. I think an episode like this was probably fun for the cast and it’s also meant to just be fun for the audience. From what I’ve seen, most people like it for that reason.

Data Cable

Going by stardates, Molly was born 1 year and 28 days before "Rascals," where she is played by 4-year-old Hana Hatae. (So much for aging more realistically than Alexander.)

Robert Carter

I think most people (myself included) won’t mind either way. However, I think viewers such as yourself put the argument forward for release order so passionately that this is probably the way to go!

dc

I think it would be a big mistake to finish TNG before starting DS9. I think interspersing the seasons would be OK; they’d minimize spoiling the other season that way. But no way TNG S7 should be done before DS9 S1 on a Star Trek watchthrough.

Hammond of Texas

Does anyone else here watch/listen to the great podcast "Dropping Names with Brent and Jonnie"?

Marcus Hicks

Whilst I will happily watch them, however they choose to proceed, I really hope they stick with release order. I know that Jen Murray managed to make that format work during the DS9/TNG overlap.

Lintrinsic

They've already decided not.

Crow T. German Robot

Just come skipping with the rest of us you grumpy old fart. ;)

Marcus Hicks

Rascals is definitely my least favourite episode of Season 6.....and is yet another example of the Enterprise Crew discovering a form of immortality, and just forgetting about it by the next episode 😉.