Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Go to this site: Cinebingers.ca for the unedited versions of all our content.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/MF1SSHarj2 👈 for the full reaction where you do not need your own copy.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/UULvHmer04 👈for the full reaction where you need your own copy.

If you are on a phone/tablet, hold down the link above and press "open in browser", or go straight to Cinebingers.ca on your browser app.

Files

Comments

Captain Kermit

Welcome to one of the BEST Star Trek days!

Mastervodo

Two banger episodes!

James Kelly

I'm very glad that you're doing DS9. But there will be some spoilers, if you don't do them in release order. Just FYI!

TalynOne

They're minor spoilers, DS9 doesn't really pick up the serialized story line until after TNG is done. The more important thing is to watch the movies during the right timeline during DS9's run.

Jaaahn

you only know they are minor spoilers because youve seen it James Kelly. to someone like George whos never seen DS9 it would mean nothing to him, he wont even recognize it as such when it shows up as long as no one tells him. and by the time they do get to DS9 it will be months from now and he will likely have forgotten.

Captain Kermit

Look, I'm going to need to see some changes to the Cinebinge YouTube channel. From now on you're on a 5 movie weekly rotation, and you will integrate a new TV show into the weekly rotation. Check with me for your next title. Get it done!

Gizmo_Mogwai_

Have they said if they'll do voyager also?

dc

I was hoping they would watch S1 of DS9 before S7 of TNG. This would largely mitigate any spoilers and allow them to experience one of the few instances in the franchise where there are plotlines that span shows. DS9/VOY have very little crossover so I think those shows could be done separately.

Jaaahn

simone has seen DS9 so it wont even be a spoiler for her, and without someone telling george some things are and arent spoilers, why would he know. it would have no meaning to him without any context.

Captain Kermit

There aren't even any spoilers. There are storylines that cross over, but no TNG storyline spoils any DS9 episode.

Joel

Simmer down, your assignment is temporary

ChiefKC

Star Trek Day!

Fedora The Explorar

I quite disagree that what they tried to do is make Jellico seem unlikeable and unreasonable. I think the point was to establish how Picard runs a very relaxed and Ronald D Moore, the writer, wanted to make Star Trek more miliatristic. So at the end I think George just agrees with the episode that Jellico is a reasonable Captain who does well in preparing for a war scenario but think its a criticism of the episode.

Joel

My beard now reaches to my chest and I love it :)

Fedora The Explorar

I would honestly say it has been established throughout the series that this crew has been run very loose and very priviledged and not as militaristic as it should be so this episode makes complete sense to me

Robert Cooper

Peanut Butter Hamper! Best but of trivia about Chain of Command 1: a lot of the changes Jelloco makes -- losing the fish, making Troi wear a uniform -- were all things the cast wanted and had been asking for forever.

Jamie

He's also in Star Trek 5!

Blackbaldrik

For the episode one question about what Borg would do with fully technological lifeforms: I think they'd capture them, and then disassemble them to figure out how they work, and therefore the Borg would, "add their technological distinctiveness to their own." It would essentially be the same as what they already do, minus the biological distinctiveness part. Also, on why the Borg don't create sentient robots of their own; the Borg haven't really been shown to innovate. They consume. It's possible they simply haven't encountered fully robotic life yet. And even if they have, I'm not sure they'd even use it. They're not exactly short on manpower, integrating emergent intelligence into the Collective might be seen as an unnecessary risk, and further, the parameters of their base goal to assimilate all intelligent beings to, "improve quality of life," may simply not include sentient AIs.

TalynOne

There's a lot of Jellico did nothing wrong opinion among the fandom. I'm closer to Riker's opinion that you can be effective without being a hard-ass. Riker himself has been a hard ass the few times he doesn't get results, especially to junior officers. I also think that it depends on the crew. The Enterprise is the flag ship, made of the best of the best in Starfleet. People who want to excel in their work and are good at it. They don't need to be brow beaten to do a good job.

Cc Decc

Ah yes, we've entered the latter days of STNG where flag officers start getting removed from the ship and sent hither and there on secret missions. because obviously you risk your high ranking officers who know all the Federation's secrets rather than sending random expendable redshirts who might have some training for the job.

Matrim

Jellico has a pretty standard command style for a ship’s captain, and Jellico didn’t really get hardassed until Riker failed to carry out an order he was given.

Mike W

I always thought that Troi didn't wear a standard uniform because as a counsellor it made her more approachable, it allows the crew to forget rank and just talk. That being said the uniform really does suit her.

Runes N Raccoons

As Simone said, she watched TNG multiple times before she watched DS9, as did many other Trekkies. The two shows don't overlap THAT often. I'd say the level of overlap between TNG and DS9 is less than between Buffy and Angel.

TalynOne (edited)

Comment edits

2026-10-07 22:00 Typical maybe for American military, not for Starfleet, It's pretty clear of the Captains we've seen in Trek such as Janeway, Picard, Kirk, Sisko, etc... they are much more personable with their crews. I think that's why so many people give Jellico a pass, because he seems closer to what they've known in real life, but again Starfleet captains are humans with hundreds of years of social evolution.
2026-10-07 14:16 Typical maybe for American military, not for Starfleet, It's pretty clear of the Captains we've seen in Trek such as Janeway, Picard, Kirk, Sisko, etc... they are much more personable with their crews. I think that's why so many people give Jellico a pass, because he seems closer to what they've known in real life, but again Starfleet captains are humans with hundreds of years of social evolution. They listen to those bellow them in rank and don't treat them like garbage that's in their way.

Typical maybe for American military, not for Starfleet, It's pretty clear of the Captains we've seen in Trek such as Janeway, Picard, Kirk, Sisko, etc... they are much more personable with their crews. I think that's why so many people give Jellico a pass, because he seems closer to what they've known in real life, but again Starfleet captains are humans with hundreds of years of social evolution. They listen to those bellow them in rank and don't treat them like garbage that's in their way.

Brandon

I feel like "Riker vs. Jellico" is just the 90's version of "Poe vs. Holdo" and I'm more on the Jellico/Holdo side of the argument. I've been in Riker's situation many times, as I'm sure a lot of us have. You go to work every day and you have a team of coworkers that you trust and get along with. Management is pretty cool. Then one day corporate randomly decides to transfer a manager to another location, a new person takes their place and suddenly the vibe of every shift is very different. There's nothing wrong with the new person (usually), but being forced into a period of adjustment when you weren't expecting it can be a real pain.

Jaaahn

and thats in an office setting where most of whats done doenst actually matter. imagine if that new manager corporate transferred in is there to prevent a war and has like a few days to do it.

Brandon

They will not be lost or confused or spoiled at all if they finish TNG before moving on to DS9.

Alan Pownall

When presented with two options of how to communicate Jellico almost always chooses the most abrasive one, is it any wonder the crew don't like the guy? Having a three minute conversation with Riker about the change in shift rotation so that he has heard any concerns doesn't seem a big ask, even if he doesn't change his mind it would at least give the impression he has considered the input of the people actually doing the job. He wanted Riker to execute his order no matter what, which seems a recipe for disaster if any of the people beneath you might know something pertinent that you don't. Does expressing dissatisfaction with Riker to Picard serve any real benefit? particularly when he has zero interest in Picard's insight because he more or less tells him to shut up when he offers it. It doesn't really matter if his crew are bunch of pampered infants, he has to work with what he is given and wilfully ignoring who his crew are because he doesn't want to deal with it means he increases the risk of failing at his job. Given he is such a good negotiator his people management skills seem to be nonexistent.

Blackbaldrik

"For a species that looks like that, why would they find those features attractive?" George, my guy, have you SEEN the kinds of things humans are into? 😂 It's really not very difficult to believe that a majority of an alien species might find members of another alien species unbelievably attractive despite looking very different. Ferengi probably just have a very, very widespread kink for smooth, tall, and what we consider feminine.

Lessiarty

I know that this will sound terribly sexist, but I just don't like beards on women. I've lived past my time.

Curaitis

Totally get the decision, its still sad because it will take more time until George learns to appreciate Ferengis more.

Ciarra Jade

and appreciate the Magnificent Ferengi!

TalynOne

In the real world when a new manager who has his own way of doing things is brought in they end up costing the company an enormous amount of money because the person doesn't understand why things work well currently and are too rigid and arrogant to learn.

TalynOne

I think so, especially since Simone has said she liked Voyager more than DS9.

Gizmo_Mogwai_

Nice! Looking forward to it. Also liked it better than DS9.

Jeffrey Mitchell

Looks like we've reached the "is Jellico a good captain or bad captain" part of our program. Personally, I agree with George. Jellies had a job to do and not a lot of time to do it. Starfleet is a military organization and when you're given an order you carry it out. It isn't unreasonable to offer concerns or present the difficulties of carrying out the order, but at the end of the day you carry out an order. And honestly, after Riker delayed the shift rotation change for several hours, I get why Jellico needed to remind him to follow orders. You don't need your first officer questioning your decisions in the middle of combat. I'm not sure they were necessarily trying to make Jellico unlikable. I think it was more about shaking up the status quo for the crew and seeing how they react to change. But I agree that it makes them seem whiny. Mostly Riker. Geordi a bit, but mostly Riker. Even Troi took everything in stride, even though she looked a little nonplussed when she was put in charge of dealing with the morale issue she brought up rather than Jellico taking her advice to take time making adjustments. But Jellico said exactly what the audience needed to understand. He doesn't have time for a honeymoon either the crew. I also think it's interesting how they took this opportunity to make changes the cast wanted. Like changing Troi to a standard uniform and getting rid of the fish Picard was keeping captive in his ready room.

R. Chang (edited)

Comment edits

2026-10-08 10:00 The best thing Jellico did was get Diana to start wearing a uniform. She looks great. I believe it was at the request of the actress, too. Yep. Looking it up, she had been asking for years to wear a standard uniform. As a kid I hated Captain Jellico. As an adult, I agree with George - the crew is so whiny about it and Jellico is a little harsh, but reasonable.
2026-10-07 15:52 The best thing Jellico did was get Deanna to start wearing a uniform. She looks great. I believe it was at the request of the actress, too. Yep. Looking it up, she had been asking for years to wear a standard uniform. As a kid I hated Captain Jellico. As an adult, I agree with George - the crew is so whiny about it and Jellico is a little harsh, but reasonable.

The best thing Jellico did was get Deanna to start wearing a uniform. She looks great. I believe it was at the request of the actress, too. Yep. Looking it up, she had been asking for years to wear a standard uniform. As a kid I hated Captain Jellico. As an adult, I agree with George - the crew is so whiny about it and Jellico is a little harsh, but reasonable.

dc

During TNG’s production, Marina Sirtis had been lobbying for a standard uniform for her character for a while—Jellico’s arrival was an opportunity for the writers to switch her over to one.

Thall

Callico is what Saul Tigh was to Adama. Hardass, militaristic, but with flaws.

gfixler

I kind of gave up on questions like when did Data become alive. It's the tadpole problem. Every time I've tried too hard to define something, the fabric of reality starts to unravel around me. I tried to define a function (in programming), and point-by-point threw out all of my assertions with counter-examples. I was in a room with OO programmers, and one asked how people defined OOP, and everyone had a different version, and most didn't have a strong sense of even their own idea. The same thing happened in another state in a room full of functional programmers, who couldn't define FP well. I have other examples. I've just made peace with the fact that I'm dumb, and the world is way more complex than I'll ever understand.

Jomero

it was all the way back in Season 2, so it's very easily forgotten. But the crew did encounter "borg babies" the first time they explored a borg cube.

DanTurismo

Just know that once you hit the TNG episode "Birthright" (616-617), you will spoil a bunch of DS9 stuff: The DS9 sets, some of the principal cast, etc. are featured heavily in that episode. There's also big spoilers for the plot of the DS9 opening episodes, and the overall premise of that show. It's assumed that anyone watching that episode has seen the opening to DS9.

gfixler

That door that went out to a really sharp exit... Riker and Data were in the Observation Lounge, where the senior staff has most of its meetings, and which is directly behind the bridge. I didn't learn where it was for decades after I watched the whole show as I kid, and rewatched it as an adult, then read things online 😆 You can see it, as a bunch of Windows, on top of the saucer, facing backwards, in exterior shots. When you're on the bridge, looking toward the back, there's the bank of computer consoles on the back wall, behind Worf. To their left is a door. You'll often see them head back there and through that door. It's a hallway that dead ends with a door on its right into the lounge. So they were exiting and turning hard left to go down the hall back onto the bridge. There isn't another exit from the Observation Lounge, which I always found odd. The other side at the back of the bridge is where the turbolift is.

DanTurismo

Unfortunately there's a significant thing with Data that's introduced in that episode, that's referenced again in future episodes, so that could be confusing if you skip it.

John Miller

Thank you George. It's amazing how many Star Trek fans hate Jelico. Or, at the very least, defend the crew. The simple fact of the matter is that Jelico, as a captain, did exactly what he was supposed to do. The crew were a bunch of cry babies. On a side note. This episode gave the show a chance to fix some things that Patrick Stewart and Marina Sirtis had wanted changed for a long time. Marina Sirtis hated not wearing a uniform like everyone else. And Patrick Stewart didn't think someone as enlightened as Captain Picard would keep animals (Fish) captive in a tank, simply as a decoration.

Scott Orr

I can never watch this episode without thinking of all the trouble Mr. Cox’s character caused SG1, lol. And I know it’s a different show, different character.

gfixler

Here's one example plan of where the lounge sits in relation to the bridge. There are many such plans, and they're all a little bit different, but this is basically it: https://forgottentrek.com/the-next-generation/designing-the-next-generation-bridge/images/Enterprise-D-bridge-floor-plan-1.jpg You can also see the head (the bridge's bathroom). There's also a spare turbolift parked behind the main one, at the back of the bridge, so there's less waiting for a lift if someone else needs to leave shortly after the first one leaves. Also, there's the square turbolift that only goes to the battle bridge, which was seen in the first episode, and a few other times.

Opti_Frog

Troi should have gotten into that uniform long ago. It's such a better fit for her.

gfixler

Speaking of exocomps, let's add Batteries Not Included to the to-watch list, for no reason. Don't look it up. Let's just watch it and enjoy.

REDR58

That is absolutely the sort of awkwardly-arranged passageway you might find on a real ship, incidentally. You can only have so many options, or no options, when space is at a premium.

REDR58

Callico is THE best typo!

REDR58

Quality of life Thank goodness that Crusher did not lose glorious red hair. Ugh, forehead aliens. Blah. Note once again, the glowing and pulsing red “most important device in the universe” in the background of the opening scene on the space station, most recently seen in The Last Starfighter George, Ellen Bry who played the scientist Farallon that you recognized was “Stofsky” in Deep Impact and she was also in Mission: Impossible III as the mother of Lindsey (Keri Russell) who gets her brain exploded in the helicopter. I can’t find a picture of her in the Deep Impact movie so she probably didn’t have a big part there. Likewise for Mission: Impossible III. She was also Margot Kidder’s stunt double in Superman the Movie (1978) and Superman II (1980). Bry has no other credits on any of the Star Trek series or movie. Beverly talks about crystals growing yet they are not considered alive. Does she not remember the enormous Crystalline Entity and then small sentient crystals in “DataLore” and “Home Soil” in the first season?

REDR58

The Borg do indeed have babies. Remember in “Q Who” in the second season?

REDR58

Excellent choice.

gfixler

Super interesting to watch the LordAtrocities videos on how they designed the Enterprise-D in Minecraft, on the MineTrek server. They ran into constant issues, including that the 3 different plans of the ship didn't agree at all, and all were missing a ton of detail. They don't even agree in deck number, so they had years of meetings while designing, and came up with cool solutions, and did the best they could. I can't recall now who (maybe Ed Whitefire?), but at least one of the original plan makers said they were always pulling things out of their butts all over the place, and they thought the MineTrek team did a phenomenal job cleaning up the mess, and actually mapping out literally the entire ship. It was a joy for me to walk around it for hours (okay, weeks/months 😆).

Simone's Coconut Squire

The fish in the Ready Room was also addressing Patrick Stewart’s long standing complaint that having captive wildlife in his office was kind of antithetical to Picard’s character.

Jomero

Captain Jellico is pretty polarizing to a lot of Trek fans. As character on a show with main characters that an audience loves and follows, he comes across as adversarial and "the bad guy." But as a military officer who has had actual successful negotiations with Cardassians and is essentially the only starfleet "Expert" on them, he knows the chances for a potential armed conflict. And as a military officer who sees the Enterprise and its crew is NOT ready for such a potential confrontation, he does his best to make the ship and the crew as ready as he possibly can in the time allotted. His sole responsibility and goal is to safeguard the entire 1400 crewmembers of the Enterprise. In the actual real-world military, he's very realistic. And him not being charming, friendly, or chummy is also realistic especially under the looming threat and deadlines he has. But as audience members, it's easy to dislike him because he's not being charming, friendly, or chummy or that he's brusk with some of the characters we like... even when they have not even done what they were asked by Jellico to do.

Lintrinsic

That was an assumption by Riker.

gfixler

Omg, I sighed when Picard was relieved of command, thinking back, let's see, 14 years ago, to when I switched from using SVN to using git for versioning my code. It also happened to be my 1000th commit in that Python repo, and here are the commit details. That commit message.... Such a colossal nerd. commit cfe62ad88e16ea1995daedd9f25c3f0af3928a4e (tag: GITSWITCH) Author: gfixler Date: Wed Sep 26 10:04:51 2012 +0000 added several git links to links/git in preparation for the move - and now, Attention to Orders... To Subversion, committing officer of the Centralized Version Control fleet aboard this repo, on this, your 1000th commit, you are hereby requested and required to relinquish command of your repository to git, of the Distributed Version Control Systems, as of this date, 2 years, 1 month, 28 days, 790 days in total since you began your long mission on July the 29th, 2010. Computer, transfer all command codes to git. Git, you relieve SVN. SVN, you stand relieved. So long, and thanks for all the commits.

Thall

Deep Space Nine thankfully has the powe to sway Georges thinking about the irritating races! I can't wait to see if it manages that magic trick once again or nah

TalynOne

I usually agree with Moore, but I think he's wrong on this. Starfleet is only military when necessary, not by design. His views work well for grimdark humanity like in Battlestar Galactica and portraying Klingons, but not the evolved humans portrayed in Trek.

Thall

Oh come on George! You have never seen a Ferengie female, so maybe bodyshape is enough for Ferengi. Not like they seem picky anyway, the little trolls

REDR58

I’m going by current information where we are in the story at this point.

REDR58

Riker states: “…from the looks of it the Borg are born as biological lifeform. Almost immediately after birth they begin getting artificial implants. They have apparently developed the technology to link artificial intelligence directly into a humanoid brain.”

REDR58

I will have to look that up! I haven’t run Minecraft in a long time. This of course, reminds me of the internal layout of the Millennium Falcon, which, as it appears in the Star Wars movies, cannot fit properly given the ship’s exterior set dimensions. This is probably true of many science fiction vessels.

Alex Macdougall

My favourite double header of the whole series. Even over BoBW. Probably Stewart's most impressive acting of the whole series.

Thall

I was of course talking about my cat, which is a callico. I don't even know what Star Trekwars is!

REDR58

Speaking of Picard’s fish, It was named Livingston by the production crew and is a red lionfish (Pterois volitans) that was later replaced with a radial firefish (Pterois radiata).

TalynOne

Gene Rodenberry the creator of Star Trek insisted that Starfleet was not a military organization. This is stated multiple times across multiple franchise shows. He viewed it as a post-military, humanitarian, scientific research, and diplomatic body. it would be interesting to see a season of Jellico. Jellico: Ro take off those earings! Worf take off that Sash! Geordi take off that visor, it's not Starfleet issue. Geordi: But I need it to see. Jellico: I don't care, get it done!

akaTheBAY-AY-RON

"so we'll establish the Exocomps have developed sentience and the audience will connect with, and care for them." "Are you sure? they're still just round metal robots, I don't think they're going to care." "Then lets give them cute little feet, that'll do it." "Brilliant!" Yeah, they knew what they were doing with that design... those BASTARDS lol

Jeffrey Mitchell

We have ranks, and orders, and courts Marshall, and ships with massive armaments that are regularly called into battle and even engage in warfare when necessary. Regardless of Gene Roddenberry's intention or what is said in the show, it clearly is structured like a military. If we need to we can call it military-like, but it doesn't change the fact that orders are orders and if people don't follow orders, people die.

Jaaahn

what gene rodenberry wanted was also terrible for a lot of things and its a good thing the show writers didnt follow it after 2 seasons. after season 2 the show has taken on its own identity past what roddenberry insisted, or else the show would still be making sexist and racist plots like in TOS and even S1-2 of TNG. so no, you dont get to pick and choose when to decide what rodenberry wanted is good and when its bad. in the case of the military structure, if everything is ranked as such, named as such, and behaves as such so it is military.

fforw

You guys missed the Star Trek Geordie Good/Bad meme source at 3:10 and 4:28.

Lintrinsic

"from the looks of it"

Paul Peavler

Ugh, I love the Chain of Command two parter, but I hate watching reactions of it. I feel the full weight of modern corporate and grindset culture breaking everyone’s brains when it comes to assessing Jellico as a leader. The first and most important job of a leader is to rally and inspire their team, and Jellico not only doesn’t do that, he actively pisses everyone off and acts like it’s good leadership. He’s not interested in inspiring confidence, he’s only interested in commanding with an iron fist and bending people to his will. Questions aren’t an opportunity to educate and negotiate, they’re an indicator of insubordination and disloyalty. I don’t think he’s acting this way because he’s “rushed,” evidenced by the fact that he never bothers to tell the crew that he knows these changes are tough but things are critical, or even getting their feedback on how to get the changes he needs in a more efficient way. He’s the opposite of every good Starfleet captain prototype, and just because his broken clock is right twice a day people think it means he’s successful. It’s just like how every modern billionaire freak turned a silver spoon into a single successful venture flip and then built a cult of sycophants to keep siphoning venture capital and buying all their competitors. This makes me so viscerally angry because I’ve been living it the last few years. I’ve been a corporate engineer for 16 years, and for the first 10, even though I was meh on the work, I enjoyed the people and the culture. Leaders were engaging and responsive and built a culture where input was valued and people worked together and stayed together to build experienced teams because we all mostly liked and trusted each other. And then in 2019 we got a new CEO and everything changed. The entire leadership structure started getting flooded with insecure yappers like Jellico, so in love with their own reputation and so obsessed with pleasing their own bosses that everyone became yes men; don’t question leadership or it shows up in your performance evaluation as being “difficult to work with;” stop complaining about lack of resources or unrealistic expectations and just push your team to work more overtime; you must return to the office despite working remotely fine during the pandemic because we need to make sure you’re not slacking off, etc. The result has been a disaster. We’ve had four corporate reorgs in the last 6 years. Turnover has been abysmal, especially during COVID, and an insane amount go institutional knowledge is just gone. Most people I know either already left or, like me, are stuck because of either health insurance or immigration reasons. I had four managers in the first 10 years, three of which I liked, and I’m now on my fourth manager in the last three years, and that includes the 9 months I was off of work on short term disability. So when I see leaders like Jellico, I just start seeing red. His kind of totalitarian rule and complete disinterest in showing the modicum of respect to his crew should be disqualifying as a Starfleet captain IMO. Even if Starfleet was a purely military organization, which it isn’t, he would still be a bad leader, and his style of leadership and people’s acceptance or even endorsement of it is, for me, kind of the core of the rot of modern work culture. Every other Trek captain shows a model of good, compassionate, and strong leadership, and Jellico just comes in and does the opposite and people wanna be like “idk he has a point, maybe the crew is being too whiny” and it makes me want to scream.

Gryff

Sitting in a bar and Picard walks in and I *jizz in my pants*

Pokes

I think there's another layer to the crew's "whining" when Geordie says, "I don't mind changes, and I don't mind hard work, but the man's not giving me the time to do the work." I think on top of everything else about the situation, the crew also knows that things can go South in a hurry on this mission. And if that happens, maybe having a bridge crew who's off of their normal body clocks and a scaled down Engineering team who's still in the middle of trying to rewire half the ship isn't exactly setting them up for success. There's probably some level of apprehension on the crew's part that all of the changes in such a short amount of time will keep them from being at their best, when/if the time comes.

Andrew

At the beginning of the first episode I was thinking the music sounded like DS9 music and then Simone said the same thing. Very weird. 🤯

funky weapon

Jellico is exactly the man you want in charge of a mission like this. He knows what his job is and he knows what needs to happen to get it done. I think the disconnect with the whiny crew is that the Enterprise is NOT a military vessel but one designed for exploration and diplomacy. the Enterprise's charter or standing orders as it were is to meet new life. the crew is mainly scientists and diplomats, not military personnel. I mean, that's why there are families on board. I always found it odd that they picked the Enterprise for Jellico to command for that reason. everyone knows it's not a military ship and Picard is a diplomat first and foremost. picking his ship, his crew, AND giving Jellico a mere handful of days to get both ready for possible war is not exactly setting Jellico up for success.

s0rd3z

Great couple episodes. Ronny Cox is just such a good antagonist. He's knows the role well, from straight up villain to a hard ass with good intentions. He really makes you dislike him in this even though he as said has good intentions.

REDR58

I understand completely, where you’re going, but I’m just commenting on what we have at the moment.

StonyD

THANK YOU! Senator Kinsey was the WORST! lol

REDR58

Chain of Command Part 1 Admiral Alynna Nechayev is played by Natalija Nogulich who you saw in National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation as Mrs. Shirley who was concerned about a beastly, bulging man: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4xL8_Yo5-_E

droodly

Can't believe George is siding with the evil asshole from Robocop. Shame George. Shame.

REDR58

Holy Flashback, Batman, I had that toy!

REDR58

May the Prophets be with you.

REDR58

Yeah, I don't see how Roddenberry could have said that with a straight face, particularly as we see the TOS ships and characters are clearly militaristic.

REDR58

It was absolutely absurd for Riker to be essentially disobeying commands like that and talking back to Jellico. He's not asking for Riker's advice and especially not having a conversation about it.

REDR58

And Tron!

REDR58

Remember who’s Number 2 around here!

REDR58

Jellico should have decorated his office more like his ancestor Vilos Cohaagen did back on Mars.

TechJJ

I just realized that in S6E09 Data is advocating for Exocomps as they are unable to advocate for themselves. Data in this case, is the prime example of being a Woke person (Woke Warrior?) - someone who's advocating for the unable/underprivileged/suppressed. This is very much consistent for the franchise.

James W.

Good call on finishing TNG before jumping into DS9. I don't remember there being any real overlap of stories between the two except maybe one ep with a cameo which spoils nothing. Also, DS9 first 2 seasons are more of the serialized, adventure of the week vibe, before it really settles into the stronger, overarching narrative. At least that is my memory of it, I think the tonal differences between early DS9 and late seasons of TNG would almost be jarring.

Captain Kermit

And, most importantly, TMNT 2, if we're naming everything

Ron

E09: The Quality of Life: Actually, LLMs already make and use tools. We provide them with tools (via MCP Servers) as well as program them on-the-fly. (They can also run the self-written tools given specific and proper permissions.) Some have demonstrated the ability for self-replication as well. But, I still wouldn't consider this a lifeform. E10: Love Jellico. The 1701D was getting too comfortable. I think they needed a Jellico to whip them back into shape. Plus, I like that Troi is now "forced" to wear a uniform like everyone else. I say, "forced", because Marina was thrilled to switch to the standard uniform because "it covered her cleavage and made her character feel intelligent and capable again." She said that it felt like she got her "brains" back and could be more of an active participant in the stories/missions going forward.

Jeremiah

Ironically, you’ll actually be messing things up by not watching DS9 along with TNG in air date order. I can’t explain further without spoilers. But it’s your trek through Trek. 🖖

Thall

And with you, child. (may I just say i am sorry and I don't know why I defaulted to Wynn)

erosennin

yeah, I think changing the shift times of a 1200 people strong team within a couple of hours on route to a risky mission isn't just unreasonable, it's fucking insane. It would be a logistical nightmare to organize alone. Especially with absolutely no explanation or comprehensible reasoning.

gfixler

I, um... I had the hots for Rosie, from A Bug's Life.

gfixler

I'm sure he'll end up finding their women sexy, the way we all do.

fforw

Personally, I'm not a big fan of Star Trek's military organization. They got rid of money, they should be socially more developed than we are and they're barely ahead and then there's the military organization and falling into some fascist trope a dozen times or more.

Craig Brennan

It's fine to finish this series first but there is some overlap in the timeline. The bigger overlap is DSN and Voyager and TNG movies. So at very least gonin release order after TNG is finished. I personally think you guys should be doing everything in release order from DSN starting. After I went and watched DSN I wish I would of watched everything in release order because it overlaps Voyager more.

Holy Squire

I've only seen a few minute of this week's first star trek episode but my immediate thoughts are a Frankenstein's monster parable

TanyoScatto

Oof, should definitely do DS9 and TNG at the same time, at least one concurrent storyline will be affected

Matrim

In addition to other stuff mentioned like some of Jellico’s changes being cast requests, this episode was also originally supposed to be a tie in to DS9. Originally it was Quark they were dealing with to book passage. DS9’s first episode was delayed, however, so they changed it to some random base and a random Ferengi.

parker469a

The woman in the first episode plays a very aggravating character in Voyager.

Matrim

Also, I think George is a little off base (ironically by feeling what the episode was trying to do). I don’t think the episode was trying to make Jellico the bad guy, I think they were trying for exactly what they achieved with his opinion.

Robert Carter

They will be totally fine. I watched all of TNG, then all of Voyager and then all of DS9. I had no issues at all

Eric Wilson

The two things you had issue with, the fish and the uniform, were things requested by the actors. I think it was Stewart who thought there wouldn't be fish in captivity on a starship in the future and the woman who plays troy didnt want to keep wearing the leotards.

Eric Wilson

More rec time more sleep better ready. 8 hour workday into a 6 hour workday.

Data Cable

She did, in "Future Imperfect."

Bruce Woodcock

You guys are absolutely make the WRONG DECISION by not watching TNG and DS9 concurrently. TNG will ruin several DS9 episodes for you, and then in the future other Star Trek shows that crossover will be even worse. I don't see how you could be worried about making mistakes when there are literally lists you can follow. As I offered before, you can do the order in which they aired, or if you want one with minimal back-and-forth swapping, I have another list you can follow. You're like those reactors who start watching Buffy the Vampire Slayer and then say they won't watch Angel. They absolutely end up regretting it.

TalynOne

You have to understand TNG is way more evolved than we are, that's why many can't understand it fully. It's not like our world where everyone follows orders without question leading to severe depression and war crimes. There's many times when the crew is tested and disobeys orders when the captain or admiral is acting badly. This happens many times across all shows. Badmiral exists as a term for a reason. This would never happen in our time as we're all programmed to be dumb immoral sheep to never disobey, so it's hard for us to understand. Our military morality is basically a horror show in the TNG era.

Opti_Frog

Perhaps so, but if i remember correctly she kept wearing it from this point onwards.

Kieran Hawk

To be honest, Troy looks better in uniform... And Edward Jellico is the best captain to ever command any starship named Enterprise.

Elvenwitch

Spoilers Peanut Hamper! You PSYCHO

Dirge Girl

Ra's al Ghul in Batman TAS, In the Mouth of Madness, Cast a Deadly Spell...

Craig Motbey

The self-replicating space locust that George was suggesting after the first episode is a Von Neumann machine. Out of control Von Neumann probes feature in several SF series; they're definitely in Lexx, and I think they show up in Farscape as well.

Lex Kuzma

George, did you forget that Troi is an empath? When she says Jellico's not sure of himself, she's not speculating.

Robert Mendoza

I get the feeling the writers weren't really writing Jellico as a slightly harsher commanding officer more as a bad boss in the private sector so the crew reacts like disgruntled employees instead of experienced officers. With that in mind when Jellico told Deanna to deal with the morale problem I'm surprised he didn't tell her to throw the crew a pizza party.

Bruce Woodcock

Why was my comment removed? As I said before, you are making a mistake not watching DS9 and TNG at the same time. You can either watch it in air date order or I can give you a watch list that minimizes switching between series if that is your concern. And this problem will continue for future Star Trek shows as well. You really need to heed our warnings. You can't unring the bell once you spoil yourselves.

megamoo chilli

Yeah I've seen a clip of Marina Sirtis saying that she was so happy to get to wear a proper uniform because she'd been in so many cheap horror movies where they just wanted her as a topless victim.

MidlineShift

I don't quite remember the Chain of Command episodes completely so I'm rewatching them now with CB, but did I miss where it was explained why Starfleet Command decided to send senior officers in their 40's/50's into a high-risk spec ops mission? That would be like asking the captain of an aircraft carrier to sneak into a....I dunno, a uranium enrichment facility in a mountain. Take one of the doctors on board too so they can use their extensive medical knowledge for.... infiltration?

Runes N Raccoons

The cast actually used Jellico as an excuse to make changes that they've been asking for for years. Stewart wanted the fish gone because he thought in the future, they wouldn't use animals as decoration, and Sirtis had been DYING to wear a standard uniform.

Chrissonator

In fact, the fish thing even Sir Patrick Stewart was for, he asked why a 24th century human would have a lionfish captive in a bowl. As for Deanna, her casual uniforms were due to her job as a counselor, to make people feel more at ease because she wasn't in a formal uniform. I wouldn't go so far as to say that it's military. Starfleet isn't a military organization. They adopt a hierarchy with ranks, but it's not militarized.

Chrissonator

All of the male uniform have built-in shoulder pads. lol

Thomas88

A fun fact to know, about this episode and the next. David Warner was contacted, to play the cardassian, 3 days before filming started. He was a last minute replacement. So he had no time to lern his text. He is doing both episodes, by reading cue cards next to the camera ..... now imagine this performance, with him, having time to prepare

Mike MacColin

George hates Ferengi and Cardassians? Oh dear, chances that he'd be going into DS9 are not that good, are they?

Angela D. Mitchell

David Warner was such a superb actor, and he was in BOTH Star Trek 5 AND Star Trek 6! My favorite roles for him were Jack the Ripper in "Time After Time" and as the perfect Bob Cratchit in the George C. Scott "A Christmas Carol" (for me the end-all, be-all, perfect version). I also loved him as Evil in "Time Bandits," where he was surprisingly and incredibly funny.

Angela D. Mitchell

I really liked this episode (#10) and it was perfectly cast. George, I know some of the crew reactions bothered you, but while I would agree that this is a military vessel (and I say this as a Navy brat), it's obvious that the disciplines of the exploratory starships of the future are slightly more relaxed than the wartime versions. So it worked for me. I always love seeing David Warner, one of my favorite character actors of all time, and so especially good in "Time After Time" (as Jack the Ripper), "Time Bandits" (as Evil), among many other things (also love his Bob Cratchit in "A Christmas Carol" with George C. Scott). He was also in both Star Trek 5 AND Star Trek 6, and is most famous probably these days as the evil henchman in "Titanic."

Marcus Hicks

Also voiced Jon Irenicus in Baldur's Gate 2 (and the Beamdog developed Baldur's Gate expansion" Siege of Dragonspear").

Marcus Hicks

....but he was also the awesome Lieutenant in Beverly Hills Cop.

Marcus Hicks

I hated him back during the original airing of the show but, over subsequent re-watches, I have come to love him.

Marcus Hicks

I am one of the people that wanted them to keep watching in release order, but even I don't think that the level of "spoilers" will be harmful to their enjoyment of the show.