Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Go to this site: Cinebingers.ca for the unedited versions of all our content.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/ZzN9eiTaO9 👈 for the full reaction where you do not need your own copy.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/jESZeYVBD2 👈for the full reaction where you need your own copy.

If you are on a phone/tablet, hold down the link above and press "open in browser", or go straight to Cinebingers.ca on your browser app.

Files

Comments

Brandon

Episode 5: Sorry, George and Simone, but I'm going to go ahead and side against the government on this one. Which is not exactly atypical of me... Johnny Sack is incarcerated, but as yet he hasn't been convicted of a crime. They turned a wedding between two un-mobbed up kids into airport security post 9/11, based on who the father of one of them is. Security should be expected, with eyes on him at all times in the event that he may flee. However, despite the presence of genuine mobsters at the wedding, how many mob weddings turn into shootings and drug deals? Johnny should have been able to attend his daughter's wedding with more freedom. In the same way that Junior was allowed to attend so many funerals while he was awaiting his own trial. It's the US government making a spectacle of their power while making sure that Johnny is publicly stripped of his. Making him pay for the extra and unnecessary security was the icing on the cake for them.

Jaaahn

you think drug deals and shootings are the only things that could possibly happen at a gathering of italian mob bosses lol? or you think thats what the government thinks?

Brandon

Like I said, security should be expected. I think they overreached and made a point of showing it. Tony even says the people around him are like jackals when it comes to weakness and the FBI would know that.

Matt Okeefe

Yes George, the famous Stonewall club was a mob-owned place.

Ben Stevens

Acrimonious is an adjective that means angry, bitter, or filled with deep resentment, especially regarding language, behavior, or a dispute. Sanctimonious is an adjective that describes someone who acts as if they are morally superior, more ethical, or more devoutly religious than other people, often in a hypocritical or smug way.

Jedi Lounger

During his appointment with Dr. Melfi in the second episode Tony was talking about Rick Santorum, a infamous racist and antagonist to the LGBTQ+ population. He was elected to the senate in the 2000 election when George W. Bush won, but got blown out in the Blue Wave of 2006 so he only lasted one term. He ran for president a few times since but has very little ability in terms of connecting to people and lacks the "rizz" that most successful presidents have. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rick_Santorum

Potsi

AIDS!?

TJ

Tony wasn't looking at his new driver's anger problem as a weakness and why would he when Tony also has an anger problem? I feel like George reads into things a little too much sometimes lol

Anonymous Andy

That Vito! Always with the practical jokes!

fforw

03:43 Is it just me or is Johnny Sack being framed as if he is a boxer going into his most important fight? The boxers etc, the lone shot of the boxer before the fight trope..

Anonymous Andy

It’s true we don’t know what Vito’s backstory is in the sense of understanding when exactly he might have realized he was gay, and at what point he might’ve been too deep in the mob. But for me, the more interesting question I always had was “why would Vito go to a gay club in a place where there was even the slightest remote chance he might run into somebody who is connected to the Mob?”. You would think that somebody in his position would have the sense to maybe go three or four states away first before going to a gay club, not saying that would be easy for him to balance in his life, but it would certainly make it less likely he would run into anyone who knows him.

The Old Blazer

I wonder if George ever heard of Santorum in his days in the porn industry? For those that don't know, the LGBTQ+ community began using Santorum as the name for the byproduct of anal sex. lol

Thall

I had issues with "gayness" in my past lemme tell you. Thankfully I grew out of it, the root cause being taught it's not okay while also being **very** ok with it if you know what I mean. I can tell you this: The thought pattern was 'Being gay is being feminine, being feminine is being weak because masculinity is strong, so that guy is weak.". The shit gay people are going through doesn't factor in, because "they brought this on themselves". That's where the thinking kinda ends, because otherwise you'd have to ask yourself complex questions. Most of the time I think it's insecurity, like with any bully. Put someone down that can't defend themselves, that is in a vast minority. Makes you think you're better than them, makes you feel better about yourself, like you belong, like you're "normal". It was for me anyway. Made me feel.. not defective. It's absolutely possible to get out of that shithead mindset though, but as with any change in thinking, it takes time and is not easy. But doable.

Kansas City Shuffler (edited)

Comment edits

2026-11-18 12:00 First of all George, it’s in fact good to ask questions about things you do not know. The fact is that many (I hesitate to say most) queer men, and women, have tried to pass at some point in their lives—including in their sex lives. The degree to which they were aroused by the women they would have been intimate with is subjective and varies from person to person. Is it that a man who can’t be with a person that he loves is just really pent up? Possibly. Is it that a man who is not attracted to a woman would fantasize about a man instead? Possibly. In the end, the sexual experiences of LGBT+ persons, and straight people, are deeply personal. I noticed Brokeback Mountain found its way onto your guys poll recently, but there are hundreds of other LGBT films that I would also endorse for your channel—for instance, But I’m a Cheerleader, Happy Together, and the documentary Paris is Burning.
2026-11-17 17:44 First of all George, it’s in fact good to ask questions about things you do not know. The fact is that many (I hesitate to say most) queer men, and women, have tried to pass at some point in their lives—including in their sex lives. The degree to which they were aroused by the women they would have been intimate with is subjective and varies from person to person. Is it that a man who can’t be with a person that he loves is just really pent up? Possibly. Is it that a man who is not attracted to a woman would fantasize about a man instead? Possibly. In the end, the sexual experiences of LGBT+ persons, and straight people, are deeply personal. I noticed Brokeback Mountain found its way onto your guys poll recently, but there are hundreds of other LGBT films that I would also endorse for your channel—for instance, But I’m a Cheerleader, Happy Together, and the documentary Paris is Burning (and My So-Called Life, the TV series).

First of all George, it’s in fact good to ask questions about things you do not know. The fact is that many (I hesitate to say most) queer men, and women, have tried to pass at some point in their lives—including in their sex lives. The degree to which they were aroused by the women they would have been intimate with is subjective and varies from person to person. Is it that a man who can’t be with a person that he loves is just really pent up? Possibly. Is it that a man who is not attracted to a woman would fantasize about a man instead? Possibly. In the end, the sexual experiences of LGBT+ persons, and straight people, are deeply personal. I noticed Brokeback Mountain found its way onto your guys poll recently, but there are hundreds of other LGBT films that I would also endorse for your channel—for instance, But I’m a Cheerleader, Happy Together, and the documentary Paris is Burning (and My So-Called Life, the TV series).

JHaze (edited)

Comment edits

2026-11-18 12:00 The protagonist bias/double standard goes crazy
2026-11-17 18:19 The protagonist bias and the whole double standards with Vito goes crazy

The protagonist bias and the whole double standards with Vito goes crazy

Leverage

Carmela and Tony being better parents than Livia and Johnny doesn’t mean they are good parents it just means they’re not as severely emotionally and mentally abusive 😂

Ben G

The mentioned "powder": This and an earlier reference to "spores" in s4 AND the tonal shift between s3 and s4 is due to Sep 11 2001 which occurred between seasons. Spore and powder are references to anthrax attacks around 9/11 where powdered anthrax was sent to government and media outlets. The general pessimism and references to the bad economy are also a 9/11 reaction.

Kansas City Shuffler

I will say that your point regarding the court’s prerogative is actually a fair question that is still a topic of Fifth Amendment litigation. Though now that I’m older and more cynical, I honestly believe that the rules of US criminal procedure are all just theater, justifying what a person in power would have done regardless.

Philipp Roensch

Episode 05: Considering different relationships with health and weight, this episode hits on a lot of themt. All that talk about mental and physical wellness, but the gang is all about percieved strenght above all. Putting the mask up is equally dangerous though, weird that Melfie suggest that. Tony immediatly breaks and well Vito had too keep that mask on too long. Well done that contrast, got me good. Episode 06: Really thought you would catch New Hampshire, with the state motto fitting for people on the run, like Walter White. I even feared Vito might have gone suicidal there, terrible how he is ousted. I put all of that homophobia on the church, they are not only see it as weak but as against god. (Which has ever been the greatest bull as we know religious history and institutional abuse) You go off Meadow, I'm happy to weigh in on that^^.

lily7

Fr if it’s was Tony in Johnny’s place they will be throwing a pity party for him like for most of the time

lily7

I know that respecting your parents is important, and Georgie often says he could never talk to his parents like that. But his parents aren’t Tony and Carmela, so it’s not fair to expect their kids to respect them just because they’re their parents. Honestly, I don’t even think the kids respect them as people, let alone as parents. Like in episode three, when Carmela went to see Melfi after saying those awful things to AJ. She made the choice to be with Tony, but their children never had that choice. Throughout the entire series, Tony and Carmela never once have an honest, meaningful conversation with their kids about what their father actually does. Meanwhile, Meadow and AJ constantly have to deal with the fact that everyone around them knows, and that people even treat them differently because of it. Whenever they ask questions or confront their parents, Tony and Carmela treat them like idiots and gaslight them, without ever considering what it must be like for their children to navigate the outside world.Carmela gets angry at AJ for talking to the paparazzi, but has anyone ever actually sat down and had a proper conversation with him about any of this? Or is he just supposed to magically know the rules because he was born a Soprano? Don’t do anything that could hurt the family, no questions asked? And considering that Tony and Carmela are both terrible parents, being a good parent means more than just not physically abusing your children, providing for them, and occasionally, I don’t know, taking them fishing. It also means actually raising them, teaching them about the world, helping them develop their own values and worldview, and at least trying to be honest with them. What kind of upbringing can Tony Soprano possibly provide? He’s a piece of shit, a psychopath, a murderer, and a mob boss who literally ruins other people’s lives by exploiting them. He’s incapable of being honest, constantly cheats, lies, and has violent outbursts. And then there’s Carmela, who puts up with all of it because she enjoys the comfortable, luxurious lifestyle, and couldn’t even bring herself to leave a man like that for the sake of her children.Meadow and AJ are spoiled, sure, but they’re still better people than their parents. And they don’t owe Tony and Carmela respect just because they provided them with basic material necessities.

JHaze

That and Uncle Jun, he deserves no sympathy when he is locked up with dementia but Vito the greedy cousin killer does? Interesting to see how people react to each character, but still an odd double standard imo

lily7

Yes I think people forgive everything just because he suffers from homophobia but he is peace of shit who chose this word that is extremely homophobic in the first place and people still can’t forgive uncle Jun because he went against our beloved protagonist Tony twice and tried to kill him

Alexander Sawasdee

And also Johnny Sack who’s done basically the same level of crimes as Tony. You’d think he was a Ralphie or a Richie by the way they reacted to his plights in this episode it’s so strange lmao.

Jaaahn

what i think is weird is you lot seems to have trouble accepting other people having different interpretations than you, that anything differnet than how you feel is = double standard/wierd/wrong. people are capable of feeling more than one thing at a time, its not that odd for people to both feel bad for someone AND disagree with their life choices.

JHaze

I thought the odd part was lack of grace given to the certain characters that was given to others, despite them all being pretty much equally awful, so you obviously didn’t understand what I meant I wasn’t insulting anyone, like I said, it’s interesting to see how different people react to each character. Not sure why you are getting so worked up/defensive over it

Jaaahn

who says im worked up or defensive? and who says i was talking to only you? but calling it double standard and wierd is you stating anything different than your interpretation is incorrect. which IS weird.

Alexander Sawasdee

Woah why are you so heated? All I’m saying is if they’re gonna give Johnny Sack that “lack of empathy” energy then they’d better do the same to Tony as that’s what Chase intends anyways with him gradually deterring the viewers from supporting these characters throughout the series.

Jaaahn

why do they have to "better do the same"? why is it that people like you insist reactors must react the way you did? and again, just cuase i dont agree with you, it doenst mean im 'heated'. youre posting in a public comment, people CAN disagree with you. your opinion, despite what you might think, isnt infallible.

Jaaahn

on the other hand, just like with expanse, just like with stranger things, when fans of a show that lacks the capability of understanding other people see things differently tells reactors theyre reacting wrong or have double standards for having differing opinions, youre now messing with shit i and others paid for, which is their honest opinion. i dont need them to hold back their thoughts out of fear of what the loud minority of unimaginatives might say to them. i didnt pay to hear them echo your thoughts to appease you, i paid to hear their thoughts.

Alexander Sawasdee

Well perhaps my wording could be better but I don’t think this is worth arguing over do we agree? I really don’t have the energy for this and at the end of the day I was also posting a public comment expressing my opinion on the subject matter lol dude come on now.

SbE

Live free or die is the motto of New Hampshire. You guys probably remember it from season 5 of Breaking Bad

Stan the Man

Ok. I have to know. I think I’ve asked before but How old are these two? They are Canadian. I am Canadian. They look 30+ maybe 35ish. I’m surprised they’ve never heard of “Don’t Leave Home Without it”? The credit card commercial for American Express. I know it’s not a major card here in Canada but we still are exposed to American commercials and media. For example, It’s referenced in Batman ‘89 at the beginning with the two street punks. “hey! American Express card, alright, hey! Don’t leave home without it” This is actually an important little point in the show. Chris was warned by FBI about middle easterners 2 episodes ago. Now we see he’s doing business with these guys and Chris makes a reference and given that they don’t understand the reference it tells us they have not been in America very long. Our spidey sense should be tingling about these guys. Keep in mind. This season came out circa 2006 so the War on Terror was in full swing. They show is playing on audiences paranoia and complicit racism.

Brad Lowry

As far as Homosexuality and Gangsters... look up the Kray Twins [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kray_twins] and brother Ronnie in particular. He was so powerful and viscious and feared that, back in the day, nobody dared to take issue with his boyfriends. Stephen Fry told this story on QI, I think...

JHaze

Again I didn’t say anything other than my interpretation is weird, I didn’t say that it’s odd for someone to disagree with life choices and feel bad for someone. If you wanna be a pretend comment section moderator go ahead but I don’t think their interpretations of the shows are wrong and I like their reactions which is why I have watched and enjoyed the whole series. At the end of the day we are all paying for this and we are allowed to comment/discuss the content we are paying for, George and Simone aren’t going to stop being honest because of a few comments. Not sure why you are telling people what they can and can’t comment, we are all fans here

Jaaahn

JHaze show me the exact place where i said you arent allowed to comment/discuss? i disagree with your PUBLIC comment. or do you think anyone that disagrees with you is 'censoring' you? on the other hand, they absolutely have been hammered and bullied by toxic fans who insist they must react a cerintain way or its wrong, until they either give up on a show like expanse, or stop talking for a while to avoid backlash like with stranger things. so yeah, what you say has an effect on the things everyone else also paid for. and thats what im jumping in on; to tell you just because you dont agree with their interpretation, it doenst make their interpretation wrong or double standard or bad. i aint stopping you from posting non sense, i dont have that power nor do i want to. but just like you have the right to say whatever you want, i have the right to say whatever i want back to you. your not infallible.

Jaaahn

ive been around here long enough to see this pattern with fans of shows like you. when S&G interprets scenes or internalizes things differently than what you anticipated, you tell them theyre wrong, or have double standards, or should've seen it some other way instead. and its never in a "heres how i saw it", instead its always in a "no youre just wrong for seeing it that way" or "its weird why would you think that", its always talking down at S&G for thinking differently. but when someone then chimes in and goes "no i disagree with your disagreement" in your PUBLIC comment, you immediately hide behind the "well im allowed to say what i want" as if a disagreement with you is in anyway equal to preventing you from speaking. as if people can only agree with you or theyre trying to silent you. its real boomer behavior.

Cally

To "take a powder" is to leave. I thought he meant Vito keeps disappearing off somewhere.

JHaze

You saying shit like “you are messing with shit I pay for” Is what I’m talking about And for the last time I don’t think their interpretations are wrong, I didn’t say that Look I barely ever comment on their videos and then when I do you are lumping me in with bully’s and toxic fans, while saying I think I’m infallible, just because I shared an observation/opinion. I don’t think I’m infallible just think you are being a dick, see ya

LSTER

Johnny Sack literally orders a hit via Tony during the wedding. Even with all the security it wasn't enough

LSTER

The Sacrimoni matrimony

REDR58

And there are any number of people who have had children with a member of the opposite sex and who later discover they are gay. Vito may not have even considered that early on, when he was first married. Or perhaps he is bi, perhaps he actually loves his wife and that's enough to be aroused by her, as evidenced by his 2 relatively young children.

REDR58

Yeah that seems like an extraordinary dangerous thing for him to do being in the position he is, as you say. Perhaps he did go far away initially, but then got more comfortable risking being closer to home.

Mark Barger

G&S, remember that Johnny Sac hasn’t been convicted of anything. He’s innocent until proven guilty under the US legal system. He’s just been accused and awaiting trial.

REDR58

Episode 5, Mr. & Mrs. John Sacrimoni Request... “First runner up, Mr. Teenage Bloomfield.” Nice flex, there, Perry. Blockbuster shut down the last of its stores in the US by 2014. One independent Blockbuster remains in Bend, Oregon: bendblockbuster.com/about/ I always take off my shoes when I come in and usually just wear socks or a pair of indoor only shoes. Allegra is indeed a real medicine used as an antihistamine: https://www.allegra.com/en-us AJ's date at the wedding, Gillian, who’s smoking and worried about toxins in fish is played by Katie Quinn Lowes who was in Wreck it Ralph, Big Hero 6 and Zootopia. “Say hi to Don Ho” at the wedding right before John is taken away is a reference to the late Hawaiian singer Don Ho (Donald Tai Loy Ho) famous for the song “Tiny Bubbles”: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mlCiDEXuxxA and many others.

Brandon

@LSTER Exactly. It's a wedding and you can't legally stop people from meeting and gathering together at an event like that. All the added security, metal detectors etc. are just a show of strength over Johnny. It's the FBI's way of "sending a message".

Anonymous Andy

That’s maybe the one reason I could think he would do it, that he kind of gets off on the danger of it, or otherwise he’s just gotten so complacent and reckless

funky weapon

I really liked how this show explained the dynamic of the sack family without saying a word. You've got three happy portly people and one anorexic miserable person. Between that and food being an unhealthy focus in all of their lives, you can see in one frame who they are and how they got to this point. Just a really cool piece of storytelling.

Ari Ramirez

Now now, let's not forget that Vito pulled the trigger on Jackie Jr. and had been conspiring behind Tony's back

dys

Letting Johnny Sack out of prison for his daughter's wedding was a kindness they didn't have to do, and wouldn't have for most cases, and G&S are right that they should have had the marshals monitoring Johnny's conversations. Pulling up the fed Suburban to cutoff his daughter's "just married" car and putting her dad in handcuffs so that is both Johnny's and his daughter's last memory of the wedding is quite petty though.

dys

Growing up in Massachusetts, the state directly south of New Hampshire, what that meant in practice was we could go just over the state line for legal fireworks and no sales tax and cheaper alcohol.

dys

It is pretty surprising that George has spent some time working in the porn industry and is still surprised that a gay (or possibly bi) man has had children with a woman.

dys

also when Simone was wondering how far Vito walked before he got to the B&B, I was thinking about how New Hampshire is mostly not very densely populated and it can be quite far between small towns... except when you put that in Canadian perspective New Hampshire is *10 times* as densely populated as BC. It's just that New Hampshire is small and doesn't have any big cities like Vancouver, but Vito could never have been remotely as far from a town in NH as you could be in BC.

dys

I wondered about that. I'm a 40 year old American, I'm guessing from past context they're both over 35 as well, and that commercial was memetic in the US before "meme" was even a word. I assumed those commercials must not have aired (as much) in Canada but from what you're saying it was equally ubiquitous in Canada at the same time.

Stephen as Moviebuff3000

I would love to see them do happy together. Well when I say I want reactors to do more Hong Kong Films I mean Martial Arts ones it would be great to see some Wong Kar Wai movies on the channel.

Raven Blackrose

Pretty much...everything you said. AJ being like he is is ENTIRELY Tony and Carmelas fault. People learn by qatching, and what they see in their parents are horrible corrupt philandering gossiping murderous thieving bullies, one who makes the money by being such a piece of shit it makes national news and talk shows, the other by just depending on it, both are horribly neurotic and stunted, neither ever wants to just be honest with their kids except when they want to win a screaming match... The idea that parents deserve respect no matter what is frankly ridiculous, even if T&C weren't fucking terrible parents.

Doug's Night Terrors

I had an intestinal issue and lost a lot of weight in a short amount of time. can confirm, you lose a lot more muscle than fat. and I wasn't stuck in a bed not moving at all, so it has to be worse for a coma.

MacGuffinStuff

The basic unwritten rule about homosexuality and gang/Mafia life, because prison happens, is that being a Top is okay as long as it's only in prison and you don't talk about it, HOWEVER being a Bottom is unacceptable. It's crazy loglc. And what's funny is I just watched Training Day, Cassie was watching it, and I had to comment how those Mexican gangsters, were not written realistically because they were joking about having been r*ped in jail but no one would ever joke about that. The Mexican Mafia literally murdered people over American Me because they implied that the leader of the gang had been assaulted in Juvie. That's how ironically homophobic gangs are.

PastaDon

I got to say, it is absolutely ridiculous that this country and our neighboring country above have turned a person being gay into a political issue.. because it's not, it's a personal choice.. and because of a smaller minority that has caused such a problem for gay people.. now everyone has an issue and needs to talk and put out a fire when their is no major fire.. Because the majority of people that are heterosexual do not give a shit at all if a person is gay or straight.. And the real reason why it's taught in schools that everyone does have a problem with gay people and that it is an issue, is all about making sure gay people vote Democratic that's the truth.. And this is the exact reason why I stay in the middle and don't choose sides because both sides are fucked

REDR58

Live Free or Die Christopher’s comment about the Muslims and dogs and George’s wondering about why don’t terrorists have dogs thing…dogs are seen as unclean or “impure” in some Muslim communities and are not generally kept as pets in such places. In such cases, having dogs as specifically working animals is sometimes permitted. I promise you, Simone, many of us Americans say please and thank you at coffee stores. And speaking of Tim Hortons they’ve opened up a few around here in my area, including 2 in Philadelphia: https://6abc.com/amp/post/2-tim-hortons-locations-coming-center-city-philadelphia/19972417/ The “lesbian thing” with Jennifer Beals, is reference to the show “The L Word” (a show about lesbians) which she starred in. Beals is probably more famous to people of a certain age as she starred in the critically panned but highly popular and successful movie “Flashdance” (1983, see poster above), which you should watch as it’s a definite 1980s classic that I expect you would both enjoy.

Simon Pegged Me

Given the homophobia amongst his peers, going to a club nearby was as safe as going to one three or four states away. The likelihood of running in to someone in the family would be about the same—minimal. As it turns out, the one-in-a-million shot came in. Vito got I.D.ed by guys who had business in there. They didn't say what the business was, but it seems unlikely that they frequent gay bars for business. Unfortunately, Vito was unlucky, but he could have been as unlucky in any gay bar. (He's got the luck of the guy in witness protection Tony spotted when he was taking Meadow on her tour of colleges.) He does seem to like taking risk—fellating a security guard in a car in the parking lot where you and other mobsters work, for instance—but I don't think going to a gay bar was that risky.

Ben G

"over the state line for legal fireworks and no sales tax and cheaper alcohol." New Hampshire: the Mexico of New England?

Raven Blackrose

It's not a choice or opinion, the current Executive Branch is attempting to dismantle queer rights as part of Project 2025, regularly ignoring court orders and discrimination lawsuits, and enabling discrimination based on religious beliefs. Fence sitting is immorally harmful ignorance.

Raven Blackrose

Once they take care us scary trans people gay men are next becuase they say the bible says they're icky. Give an inch they take a mile.

PastaDon

I'm talking about normal everyday people.. Not the psychos that work in politics.. Call it fence sitting if you want.. I think it's more ignorant to try and change something you cannot and do not control..

Zoran24

It's not wrong to feel empathy for a sick person, no matter what they did tbh. just my opinion though

Brandon

@dys, I just think it's important to remember that Sack hasn't been convicted of anything yet. They didn't have to let an incarcerated man go to a wedding, true. My issue is how far the government oversteps, and I think that was the writer's point. I'm not sure if they could legally monitor all of his private conversations at the wedding, but I'm not a lawyer. Not to mention every single guest is subject to their airport style security, not just Johnny Sack. I think Johnny could have had his lawyer fight back on all of the FBI's conditions for attending the wedding and came to a compromise, but time wasn't on his side. It's like the FBI was saying, "Oh you think you're a big mob boss? Well, now we're YOUR boss."

Patrick - Excelsior

"Taking a powder" is an old expression for leaving abbruptly. So when Sil described his "unexplained powders" he just meant Vito's unexplained absences.